Juan Cole: Iranian Elections More Democratic
Charles Johnson
Mon Jan 31, 2005 at 11:49 am PST • Views: 277
Can you spot the rather large “but” in this post by Arabist professor Juan Cole?
I’m just appalled by the cheerleading tone of US news coverage of the so-called elections in Iraq on Sunday. I said on television last week that this event is a “political earthquake” and “a historical first step” for Iraq. It is an event of the utmost importance, for Iraq, the Middle East, and the world. All the boosterism has a kernel of truth to it, of course. Iraqis hadn’t been able to choose their leaders at all in recent decades, even by some strange process where they chose unknown leaders. BUT this process is not a model for anything, and would not willingly be imitated by anyone else in the region. The 1997 elections in Iran were much more democratic, as were the 2002 elections in Bahrain and Pakistan.
Cole predicted a 30% turnout in the Iraq election, by the way. He was a bit off.
Frank says: