An Open Letter to AP, AFP, and Reuters About the Qana Photos
Charles Johnson
Wed Aug 2, 2006 at 6:28 pm PDT • Views: 334
Jihad Watch reader S. has posted an open letter to AP, AFP, and Reuters about the Qana photos, that deserves to be reprinted in full, so that the news wires have a chance to respond if they choose:
To Whom It May Concern,
Many powerful photographs were taken following the recent tragedy at Qana. Legitimate questions have arisen regarding the actual times certain photos were taken.
News agencies have begun responding to some of the questions raised. Here is AP’s response.
The AP had three different photographers there who weren’t always aware of what the others were doing, and filed their images to editors separately, said Santiago Lyon, director of photography.The Associated Press, Reuters and Agence France-Presse all distributed photos of which questions have been asked relative to the time shot. What Lyon of AP does not address, is that the exact time of digital capture is recorded along with the image. This EXIF information cannot be altered, and would give accurate timings as to the sequence of all photos released.There are also several reasons not to draw conclusions from time stamps, Lyon said. Following a news event like this, the AP does not distribute pictures sequentially; photos are moved based on news value and how quickly they are available for an editor to transmit.
We urge AFP, AP, and Reuters to make available to this website a small JPEG file, with all EXIF data attached, of each of the photos analyzed on the various websites that have raised this issue. A list will be provided if they are not already known. Sensitive IPTC data may be removed, if any responding agency wishes. The EXIF is the only important data.
The actual capture times, between photos of all agencies, would then be made a public record — chips falling where they may.
It is the responsibility of a free press to ferret out information that those in power wish to withhold. It is the responsibility of an informed citizenry to openly request information from press sources when there is the appearance that they are withholding information critical to their mission of maintaining the public trust.
We await response from AP, AFP and Reuters that could lay to rest this one important issue.
Frank says: