LGF

more options

  

Advertisement

Buchanan Blames Israel and AIPAC for High Gas Prices

Tue, Jul 15, 2008 at 10:10:41 am PDT

Townhall.com should be ashamed of themselves for giving this creep a podium to spew his antisemitism: Patrick J. Buchanan :: Townhall.com :: A Phony Crisis — and a Real One.

These ugly articles by Buchanan are why I’ve removed Townhall.com from our news sources.

UPDATE at 7/15/08 10:49:51 am:

If you'd like to tell Townhall.com what you think about this, here's their contact form.

Also see:
Pat Buchanan Appears on Neo-Nazi Radio Show

Advertisement

372 comments

  • Comments are open and unmoderated, and do not necessarily reflect the views of Little Green Footballs.
  • Obscene, abusive, silly, or annoying remarks may be deleted, but the fact that particular comments remain on the site in no way constitutes an endorsement of their views by Little Green Footballs.
  • Posts that contain phone numbers, street addresses, email addresses or other personal information will also be deleted, as will posts that consist only of a variation on the word, "First!"
  • Comments that advocate violence will be cause for immediate banning with no appeal.
  • Disagreement and debate are welcome, but insults and abuse are not, and may cause your account to be blocked.
  • REMEMBER: posting comments at LGF is a privilege, not a right. Abuse that privilege, and your account will be blocked.

Hide comments | Jump to bottom

1 Maximu§  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:11:51am

FU Buchanan!

2 The Other Les  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:12:06am

Oh, yeah! The JOOOOOOOOOOS are charging us through the wazoo for all of their oil!

/sarcasm

3 Macker  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:12:10am

And I'm about ready to ditch Human Events for the same reason.

4 kynna  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:12:48am

What in the world is with Townhall?! This is just bizarre hate-spewing. Way to marginalize your product, guys.

5 Kaitian868  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:13:01am

I don't understand why people appeal to Buchanan.

6 Silhouette  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:13:12am

I always thought Sunoco and Amoco sounded more like Italian names than Jewish.

/air head

7 bosforus  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:13:18am

Who hasn't been blamed for oil prices? It's the 'in' thing right now.

8 The Other Les  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:13:43am

I go to Capitalism Magazine for my Sowell and Williams editorials instead.

[Link: www.capmag.com...]

9 The Other Les  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:14:21am

re: #7 bosforus

Who hasn't been blamed for oil prices? It's the 'in' thing right now.

Democrats.

10 Opinionated  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:14:41am

When I saw that Onion parody of seeking a candidate with an evil soul, I thought of Buchanan's run for President.

11 transient  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:15:16am

Rationally, I know that Buchanan gets this attention because he has buddies in the media, and maybe 'cause they think he's quaint and all.

Viscerally, I simply do not understand why people are willing to let him voice his patently foolish racist garbage.

12 bosforus  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:15:21am

re: #9 The Other Les

Except by the right wing.

13 Charles  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:16:26am

re: #3 Macker

And I'm about ready to ditch Human Events for the same reason.

I have ditched Human Events, for their support of Buchanan and their connections to the Discovery Institute.

14 gop_patriot  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:17:27am

Wow, he starts off sounding almost rational, the 'mullahs' this and 'Iran' that...

Then in the last three sentences, he just lets his anti-Israel/Jewish/semitic venom rip.

Disgusting. He doesn't even try and hide it any more.

15 noshariaincanada  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:17:49am

Buchanan should travel to Gaza. And stay there.

16 nikis-knight  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:18:14am

So what do the comments for his articles lately look like? I don't usually bother checking out comments for articles elsewhere.

17 Crusader Rabbit  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:18:24am

He's sounding more like Ron Paul every day.

18 Ringo the Gringo  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:18:25am

Last week I sent Townhall an email informing them that I would stop reading anything at Townhall until they stopped publishing the Nazi sympathizer Patrick Buchanan.

I would suggest that others do the same.

19 Uncle Joe  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:18:46am

Hannity & Colmes have him on constantly. Fox News adores the SOB.

20 Silhouette  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:20:26am

re: #7 bosforus

Who hasn't been blamed for oil prices? It's the 'in' thing right now.

I blame rock-n-roll. These kids today, with their gyrating hips and loud music.

21 Kragar (Proud to be Kafir)  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:20:56am

Link is going to default page

22 Honorary Yooper  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:21:07am

Oh William F. Buckley, where art thou to curse out this demon we have in Pitchfork Pat Buchanan?

/sigh.

23 ORD neighbor  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:21:13am

Blaming Jews for any problem that exists... Surefire approach with certain audiences. What those audiences are is left as an exercise to the reader. The worthiness and decency of such groups are left as an exercise in plumbing stinky depths.

24 FurryOldGuyJeans  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:21:14am

re: #19 Uncle Joe

Hannity & Colmes have him on constantly. Fox News adores the SOB.

Yet another reason why FNC has been circling the bowl. Time to give them a flush and let them join the ranks of the MSM.

25 Sharku  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:21:19am

Fox is down to Brit Hume and Cavuto.... after that I watch nick toons, at least my IQ value is raised then.

26 Ringo the Gringo  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:21:21am

I have a freind who's father is a dead ringer for Pat Buchanan...He's a nice fellow too, each time I see him I feel bad for wanting to punch him in the nose.

27 MandyManners  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:21:26am

Israel is a fifth column?

28 Lizard by the Bay  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:21:27am

re: #14 gop_patriot

Disgusting. He doesn't even try and hide it any more.

Did he ever?

29 Sponge  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:21:35am

re: #20 Silhouette

HA! That's funny.

Darn Elvis. Just ruined the entire planet.

30 harrylook  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:22:08am

re: #11 transient

Rationally, I know that Buchanan gets this attention because he has buddies in the media, and maybe 'cause they think he's quaint and all.

Viscerally, I simply do not understand why people are willing to let him voice his patently foolish racist garbage.

I think they're giving him all this attention b/c he's a "conservative" who sounds like a raving mad leftist half the time. It's a way for the MSM to claim they gave "equal time."

31 Honorary Yooper  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:22:13am

re: #25 Sharku

Fox is down to Brit Hume and Cavuto.... after that I watch nick toons, at least my IQ value is raised then.

Agreed. Shep jumped the shark during Katrina, and Geraldo is as unwatchable as MSNBC.

32 jcm  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:22:23am

Back the bus up, we didn't get 'em on the first pass.

33 bosforus  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:22:31am

re: #20 Silhouette

I blame rock-n-roll. These kids today, with their gyrating hips and loud music.

I don't care what the people say - rock 'n roll is here to stay!

34 maddogg  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:23:12am

Pat Buchanan, please, shut the fuck up!

35 Charles  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:23:34am

re: #21 Kragar (Proud to be Kafir)

Link is going to default page

Fixed now.

36 bosforus  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:23:43am

re: #33 bosforus

I don't care what the people say - rock 'n roll is here to stay!

37 Slumbering Behemoth  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:23:59am

Any outlet that gives this man a platform to air his nonsense instantly loses credibility with me.

There are greater political minds out there, why bother with this buffoon?

38 Iron Fist  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:24:33am

It's interesting, because high gas prices are, to one degree or another, the fault of the Democrats/Enviro lobby. Rather than lay the blame where it belongs, Buchannan wants to blame the Jews.

Typical of a true anti-Semite. This is no mistake, or misunderstanding. Pat Buchannan is a true and unashamed anti-Semite. He should be shunned by all Conservatives and Republicans, everywhere.

39 nikis-knight  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:25:01am

re: #30 harrylook

I think they're giving him all this attention b/c he's a "conservative" who sounds like a raving mad leftist half the time. It's a way for the MSM to claim they gave "equal time."

Yeah, but that doesn't excuse townhall. Either they copied Obama and fired their editor, or someone over there has some screws loose regarding conservative ideas.

40 Dustyvet  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:25:26am

Patrick J. Buchanan, The man's off his meds!

41 gop_patriot  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:25:33am

re: #28 Lizard by the Bay

Did he ever?

Maybe not, I don't know! I remember hearing him when I was younger, back in the Reagan days... he sounded rational to me, but then, it was mostly sound bites, etc. I was in high school, maybe a Fresh. in college- and I wasn't exactly doing any in-depth political research.

Did he talk like this when he was a Reagan adviser?

42 lawhawk  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:25:40am

Typical of Puchanan to ignore facts. Like that the US has all but strangled domestic production for the last 30+ years. No new refineries or offshore drilling bans that limit production. NIMBY that prevents building new refineries, that is if they can run the gauntlet of bureaucracy and red tape. And forget about nuclear or other energy sources, since NIMBY and eco-nuts have made it increasingly difficult to build power plants around the country of any kind.

The high prices do factor in instability in the ME, but the region has always been unstable. Iran's current machinations for nuclear weapons has a wee bit to do with the price, as do the oil barons in the ME who want to keep the price artificially high.

Democrats and Leftists also want the high prices to use against the GOP and Bush (memo - he's not running again), to increase their chances of winning elections - all to secure more power for them, and to further restrict the rights of citizens. After all, this too goes hand in hand with the global warming crowd, who wants zero growth and to tax the heck out of those who produce stuff for a living so that it can be transferred to those who seek hand outs.

43 Kragar (Proud to be Kafir)  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:26:09am

Buchanan is a scumball.

44 Honorary Yooper  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:26:09am

I have a job for Pat, if he dares to take it. He should be Barack Obama's running mate. It's a damn near perfect fit of anti-semitism, anti-Americanism, and sheer lunacy.

45 transient  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:27:17am

re: #30 harrylook

I think they're giving him all this attention b/c he's a "conservative" who sounds like a raving mad leftist half the time. It's a way for the MSM to claim they gave "equal time."

I guess that would be similar to the way that NPR, when they are forced to include an Israeli opinion for "fairness," uses people so far to the left they might as well be Palestinian.

46 jcm  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:27:19am

PJB, get a clue.

A State of War has existed between the United States of America and Iran since Nov. 4. 1979.

Only one side seems to know this.

AND IT AIN'T US!

47 alegrias  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:27:33am

Bay Buchanan his sister ought to take her brother aside and tell him to shut up and stay away from the microphones for the love of their country & humanity.

Take a vow of silence Pat. Get thee to a monastery. Wash thine mouth out with soap.

48 FurryOldGuyJeans  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:27:37am

re: #44 Honorary Yooper

I have a job for Pat, if he dares to take it. He should be Barack Obama's running mate. It's a damn near perfect fit of anti-semitism, anti-Americanism, and sheer lunacy.

Too perfect. He should never be that close to being POTUS, ever, even on a losing ticket.

49 Macker  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:27:50am

re: #13 Charles

DONE. Thank you!

50 jemima  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:28:26am

What's the contact email for Townhall--where my opinion counts and I damn well want to give it to them--?

51 BeerDrinking_VictoryMonkey  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:29:04am

It was a shame to lose Bill Buckley for many reasons, not the least of which is that he kept this jerk marginalized.

52 A.W.  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:29:14am

Well, here's the dirty unsaid secret in all this. Probably alot of the hatred toward america in the middle east stems from the fact we don't let them just have another holocaust. And that hatred probably does cause the price of oil to go up at least a little.

But what's the alternative. Now it is true that there have been several genocides since we said never again at the end of WWII, but we are right to say, "no you are not completing hitler's work."

And if that decison makes the diffference betwee $3.00 and $4.00 gas... then i can live with that.

As for Town Hall, geez, i don't know. they seem to be doing us a service by giving the man repeated chances to beclown himself. I guess i am too much of a believer in open conversation to be mad at them.

53 Kenneth  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:30:06am
Israel tested new Russian radar bought by Iran

During last month's exercise in which some 100 Israeli fighter jets flew 900 miles over the Mediterranean, Israel tested its ability to evade the new Russian S-300 radar that is being purchased by Iran. It was able to do so with the cooperation of the Greek government, in whose airspace it flew, and which owns the same radar the Iranians are buying.

It pays to have friends.

54 Trent_Boyett  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:30:08am

I really feel betrayed by this hateful clown. I'm really glad we're strong enough as conservatives to police ourselves and not make excuses for this creep unlike the libs.

55 Opinionated  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:30:16am

re: #27 MandyManners

Israel is a fifth column?

Not implied. Not inferred. Unapologetic. As clear as day.

Classic anti Semitism in every "respectable" outlet that carries this Nazi.

56 Macker  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:30:32am

re: #26 Ringo the Gringo

I have a freind who's father is a dead ringer for Pat Buchanan...He's a nice fellow too, each time I see him I feel bad for wanting to punch him in the nose.

Your friend doesn't know this, does he?

57 harrylook  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:30:33am

re: #45 transient

Exactly. Or when Ineedadinnerjacket (who gets credit for coining this awesome nickname, btw?) says his conference isn't anti-semitic because the Neturei Karta attended.

58 Plain ol' Curt  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:30:41am

30 seconds ago, I unsubscribed to Human Events for giving Buchanan a platform to spew his jew-hating bile.

The cheese slid off of his cracker a long time ago.

59 alegrias  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:30:52am

re: #37 Slumbering Behemoth

Any outlet that gives this man a platform to air his nonsense instantly loses credibility with me.

There are greater political minds out there, why bother with this buffoon?

* * *
Like equally repugnant democrat strategist Bob Beckel, Buchanan once worked for candidates & presidents, and also ran for office, so presumably was once considered up & coming.

We've seen how the once & future become yesterday's jokes.

60 Fat Jolly Penguin  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:31:34am

What the hell is Buchanan's problem?

Slightly unimportant, he didn't even credit you, Charles:

Saturday's New York Times reported that that photo of the four Iranian missiles fired in salvo had been doctored.

61 Ringo the Gringo  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:31:43am

re: #50 jemima

What's the contact email for Townhall--where my opinion counts and I damn well want to give it to them--?

Here.

62 alegrias  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:31:52am

re: #41 gop_patriot

Maybe not, I don't know! I remember hearing him when I was younger, back in the Reagan days... he sounded rational to me, but then, it was mostly sound bites, etc. I was in high school, maybe a Fresh. in college- and I wasn't exactly doing any in-depth political research.

Did he talk like this when he was a Reagan adviser?

* * *
Nixon speechwriter.

63 Kragar (Proud to be Kafir)  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:31:52am

OT

Youtube protects viewer confidentiality

Plaintiffs Viacom and a class-action group led by the Football Association of England agreed to accept a watered-down version of YouTube's viewer logs. That version will not include the IP addresses nor the YouTube usernames of the viewers.

64 Ringo the Gringo  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:32:47am

re: #56 Macker

Your friend doesn't know this, does he?

We've joked about it.

65 Tazzerman  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:32:58am

Buchanan's arguments and so-called 'proof' are specious at best. His use of the now MUCH discredited intelligence briefing (discredited by our OWN intelligence community BTW) speaks volumes in regards to Buchanan's willingness to use any means necessary in order to move his 'agenda' forward.

Who does he think he's fooling?

And what IS that agenda? I don't really know but I DO know this, as time goes by, Mr Buchanan reveals more and more of himself and the more we see the more proof we have that the man is an anti-Semitic bigot who's living in a total dream world..

I think he needs to get back on his meds...

66 MandyManners  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:33:11am

re: #50 jemima

What's the contact email for Townhall--where my opinion counts and I damn well want to give it to them--?

[Link: www.townhall.com...]

67 Ward Cleaver  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:33:39am

re: #4 kynna

What in the world is with Townhall?! This is just bizarre hate-spewing. Way to marginalize your product, guys.

And they want people to subscribe to their magazine? No WAY!

68 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:33:46am
69 runrabbitrun  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:34:02am

re: #26 Ringo the Gringo

I have a freind who's father is a dead ringer for Pat Buchanan...He's a nice fellow too, each time I see him I feel bad for wanting to punch him in the nose.

re: #23 ORD neighbor

Blaming Jews for any problem that exists... Surefire approach with certain audiences....

I too am shocked at how many times I discuss politics with (what I imagine to be) nice, sensible, sane, logical, well-educated Republican friends and neighbors, I discover that, when it comes down to it, they eventually confide that they blame almost every ill on the planet on our Middle East policy and support for Israel.

70 nikis-knight  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:35:04am

re: #60 Fat Jolly Penguin

What the hell is Buchanan's problem?

Slightly unimportant, he didn't even credit you, Charles:

Yeah, somehow I just don't see that happening.

71 DistantThunder  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:35:13am

Can we blame Obama on the Jews? I wouldn't mind blaming anything and everything on the Jews if it ever made any difference at all to improve even one problem - but it never has and never will, because the Jews aren't living in the world to create problems, they're trying to alleviate human suffering.

If the Jews were all powerful wouldn't they be living in a wholly Jewish middle east?

Buchanan has jumped the shark, the great white shark and the megaladon shark.

72 Tazzerman  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:36:41am

re: #68 buzzsawmonkey

WOW! Well said, well said. I think you've nailed this totally! Well done! -tm

73 Fat Jolly Penguin  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:36:49am

*slight pause as everyone dashes to Townhall.com to write e-mails*

74 jemima  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:37:42am

#61

Thanks! I feel much better now!

75 mj  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:39:05am

Why send traffic their way? Treat them as if they are a Neo-Nazi site, which they are as long as they publish this Nazi sympathizer.

76 Tazzerman  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:39:30am

re: #71 DistantThunder

I'm Jewish and I'm STILL waiting for my 'World Dominance' check damit! Is there someplace, maybe in NYc, that I have to register or something?

77 Ward Cleaver  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:40:08am

One of the posters there has a link to Lew Rockwell's site in his comment. Idiot.

78 transient  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:40:38am

re: #76 Tazzerman

I'm Jewish and I'm STILL waiting for my 'World Dominance' check damit! Is there someplace, maybe in NYc, that I have to register or something?

Email me and I will send you the secret password.

;)

79 brainwizard73  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:41:05am

Had to read this carefully to get it, but it's there.

The greatest problem for Patty is that he assumes that the Israelis are just a bunch of blood-thirsty goons bent on destroying Iran. There is nothing in history to suggest that. If Israel didn't think Iran was a threat, they would be more focused on Syria, or the West Bank, Gaza, or some other issue. It isn't like they don't have other issues.

Sure, tension in the Middle East impacts oil prices. But the cause of the tension isn't going to be Israel just for tension-sake...it is because there is a genuine threat to Israel, on some level, and Patty can't see that.

I guess he thinks Israel has to wait until Tel Aviv has a 3 million degree wake up call?

Then Patty will write a book about how Iran really never wanted to nuke Israel.

80 Opinionated  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:41:54am

re: #68 buzzsawmonkey

Think me naive, but once I had the opinion that anti Semitism was the result of ignorance and conditioned behavior.

Almost excusable in a strange way.

I have for some time now become convinced that you are absolutely correct and it is a form of delusions and mental illness.

81 formercorpsman  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:41:54am

re: #51 BeerDrinking_VictoryMonkey

I just signed on, and you read my mind.

Why does it seem, no sooner than Buckley's passing, these clowns have come to know a resurgence?

82 lawhawk  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:42:10am

re: #79 brainwizard73

No, he'll write that Israel had it coming.

83 Ward Cleaver  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:42:14am

I've already written Hugh Hewitt about one of Buchanan's earlier columns, and received no reply. Screw Townhall.

84 realwest  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:42:24am

I just don't understand Townhall. They HAVE to have known ahead of time what a mofo Anti-Semite Buchanan is, and they go ahead and publish him as if he were actually respected by anyone with any intelligence.
WTF's wrong with them?

85 nyc redneck  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:43:12am

aren't the people around him getting sick of his smelly bullshit?
this is how these haters grow their agenda. no one speaks up against them.
sean hannity should stop back slapping and guff hawing w/ this nazi.
buchanan should not be given public forums to ply his anti semitism.

86 calcajun  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:43:35am

Oh God. Here we go again. The world-wide Jewish/Zionist conspiracy. Goodness, this is a people that can't even decide among themselves what to do with the Palestinians , or where to eat dinner. How in the name of the Wide World of Sports can anyone think they could formulate such a massive conspiracy.

Unless, of course, someone wants to engage in a little blame-shifting.

87 itellu3times  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:43:36am

re: #47 alegrias

Bay Buchanan his sister ought to take her brother aside and tell him to shut up and stay away from the microphones for the love of their country & humanity.

As I recall, sister is worse.

88 gop_patriot  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:44:12am

re: #62 alegrias

* * *
Nixon speechwriter.

Yes, and he worked with Ford, too. And of course, Reagan. I don't recall that they were anti-semitic..?!?

Are you saying that Buchanan spoke in this manner during the time that he wrote speeches for Nixon? Seriously, I was asking if those who were old enough at the time to remember, actually remember him being anti-semitic out loud and in public back then..? It just seems to me that he hid it for a long time, and now is unashamedly and blatantly out front about it.

89 Silas Blex  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:44:13am

I think you're on to something. If I convert will I get a discount world dominance check? :-)

Buchanan has always made me uncomfortable. A few years ago I put him on my "just ignore him" list...but of course the danger is while we try to ignore him he's off doing real damage.

90 Charles  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:44:34am

Please note that the same "news sources" that promote creationism and "intelligent design" (Townhall and Human Events) are also publishing Pat Buchanan's garbage.

91 brainwizard73  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:44:37am

re: #82 lawhawk

Or he will blame America for supporting Israel, which gave Israel "false confidence" and started nuclear horrors of unspeakable destruction.

Too bad George Bush will be out of office...or he could blame Bush, too.

92 snowcrash  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:44:38am

Pat is a Paleocon and is expressing views that are common to many Paleocons. That is why he is kept on at Townhall. I totally disagree with that brand of conservatism but it does exist.

93 alegrias  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:45:20am

John & Cindy McCain hosted AIPAC at their Arizona ranch.

McCain is a strong defender of Israel, as you may recall he & Joe Lieberman stand strong by our ally in that unfriendly neighborhood.

Let's just say OPEC is not McCain's friend, but AIPAC is.

94 FurryOldGuyJeans  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:45:47am

re: #84 realwest

I just don't understand Townhall. They HAVE to have known ahead of time what a mofo Anti-Semite Buchanan is, and they go ahead and publish him as if he were actually respected by anyone with any intelligence.
WTF's wrong with them?

Either they are in agreement with the man or they don't care about his positions. Looks like they want to kill off the Republican party so the Dems are the only survivor.

95 wolfie  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:45:48am

re: #16 nikis-knight

So what do the comments for his articles lately look like? I don't usually bother checking out comments for articles elsewhere.

I read through the comments. Except for the higher degree of literacy and the absence of vulgar language, I dare say you will find about half of them to be indistinguishable from the comments at DU or Kos.

A major meme is "Bush lied, people died" because of hysteria over WMD programs in Iraq and that history is repeating itself.

There are the usual calls for a draft (w/ no college deferments) as justified by Charles Rangel, i.e. as a way to discourage military action.

Condoleeza Rice is portrayed as a war-monger blindly supporting defense of an "ally" (at least most do use that term) at the expense of US interests (which kinda contradicts the "ally" thing!)

Then there are the usual protests that being against Israeli policy is not being anti-semitic. No attempt to draw a line or examine this (a la Buckley) though.

96 Dianna  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:46:10am

re: #27 MandyManners

So far as Buchanan is concerned, Israel has a fifth column.

Disgusting.

97 Killgore Trout  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:46:23am

Very few outlets are willing to print Buchanan's antisemitic trash. Townhall, Conservative Voice, the the White Nationalist site VDare

98 Dar ul Harb  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:46:28am
99 WriterMom  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:46:45am

LIZARDS!

Can I make a suggestion? Instead of just complaining, why don't we try to get the ball started on a grass roots e-mail campaign, questioning TownHall's judgement in giving this POS Jew-hater a platform on an otherwise respectable, Conservative news source?

THE CONTACT FORM IS HERE:

Please be polite, and explain why you have a problem with Buchanan's continued presence on the site and briefly describe your concerns.

100 formercorpsman  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:46:49am

re: #90 Charles

Parlays into my OT question yesterday about the foreign investment in American companies.

Triangulation.

Catchy names like Holy Land Foundation.

101 Ward Cleaver  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:47:12am
Israel and its Fifth Column in this city seek to stampede us into war with Iran. Bush should rebuff them, and the American people should tell their congressmen: You vote for 362, we don't vote for you.

That statement makes me want to puke.

102 scottishbuzzsaw  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:47:18am

re: #90 Charles

It feels like we've entered the Twilight zone this election cycle. Terrible things coming out of the woodwork.

103 GGMac  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:47:19am

re: #61 Ringo the Gringo

Here.


Done.

Thanks, Ringo -

104 Opinionated  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:47:35am

re: #92 snowcrash

Pat is a Paleocon and is expressing views that are common to many Paleocons. That is why he is kept on at Townhall. I totally disagree with that brand of conservatism but it does exist.

Give Fascism a new name and it becomes a respectable movement?

105 Honorary Yooper  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:47:38am

re: #92 snowcrash

Pat is a Paleocon and is expressing views that are common to many Paleocons. That is why he is kept on at Townhall. I totally disagree with that brand of conservatism but it does exist.

I think I agree more with Jonah Goldberg and consider Buchanan to be a populist. He makes appeals to the people, and his writings (scribble?) and TV appearances are a part of that. I find it most interesting that Goldberg devotes an entire chapter of Liberal Fascism to Buchanan.

106 RightOnTheLeftCoast  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:47:47am

I'd always considered townhall.com a decent source of conservative opinion, but always cringed when a new Buchanan column went up. That asshat does nothing but hurt the reputation and credibility of all conservatives with his lunatic ranting.

While I firmly believe in freedom of speech (including unpopular, offensive speech), I also believe in the right and freedom of a publisher to cease carrying a contributor because his views are anathema to their overall philosophy.

I hope the feedback from lizardoids and other conservative voices can convince townhall that keeping Buchanan around is destructive to their own credibility and to the conservative movement as a whole.

107 WriterMom  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:47:53am

Heh.

RINGO you bastoid! Ya beat me to it.

108 FurryOldGuyJeans  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:48:08am

re: #90 Charles

Please note that the same "news sources" that promote creationism and "intelligent design" (Townhall and Human Events) are also publishing Pat Buchanan's garbage.

Starting to think HE should change the name to Aryan Events and Townhall to Stalag.

109 scottishbuzzsaw  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:48:50am

re: #99 WriterMom

Already done.

110 Dianna  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:49:00am

re: #52 A.W.

You need to rewrite that - I can't figure out what you're saying, and I read it three times.

111 quickjustice  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:49:05am

BuchananThink: Arabs pump oil. Arabs hate Jooos. Therefore Arabs are raising oil prices to get even with Jooos. High oil prices all are fault of Jooos. QED.

112 calcajun  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:49:24am

re: #80 Opinionated

Can't agree totally. Antisemitism is like any form of bigotry; its roots are in fear of the strange and ignorance/suspicion of another group--especially when that group does not want to assimilate.

What Paddy is talking about is akin to mental illness. Some people have to look for someone to blame when events are so huge and important that they could not have simply resulted from a series of random acts and coincidences. Look at everyone who are absolutely convinced that there was a conspiracy to kill JFK (sorry-one guy, three shots, game over) or the FDR deliberately sacrificed the Pacific Fleet. The delusion is that something so monstrous had to be the result of deliberate planning, despite all evidence to the contrary.

113 dhg4  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:49:27am

re: #41 gop_patriot

re: #41 gop_patriot

Did he talk like this when he was a Reagan adviser?

Not about Israel. I don't remember where, but sometime after his famous "Israel's Amen corner" comment in the lead up to the first Gulf War, he admitted that back then he was a big supporter of Menachem Begin. I can't say I remember everything from those days, but I'm pretty certain that he even wrote an op-ed during the Lebanon War that was very supportive of Israel. (I just checked archives and can't find said op-ed; so maybe I confused him with someone else.)

Even before the Gulf War he showed an unhealthy attachment to Nazis, defending the likes of Dejmanjuk.

And Buchanan did serve in both the Nixon and Reagan White Houses, so one would assume he was a little more balanced then.

114 Honorary Yooper  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:49:28am

re: #104 Opinionated

Give Fascism a new name and it becomes a respectable movement?

See my #105. Goldberg even devotes an entire chapter of Liberal Fascism to Buchanan.

115 Ward Cleaver  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:49:37am

re: #98 Dar ul Harb

OT,

AFP photo editors strike again!

Heh.

The trees look too green and non-tropical, and the soldiers don't appear to be wearing desert camo.

116 Eowyn2  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:49:58am

before I read all comments.

what is the WASP word for "putz"

117 Racer X  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:50:01am

This is why Jews drift over to the left.

118 alegrias  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:50:23am

President Nixon supported Israel against her enemies in 1973, when we helped Israel defeat her neighbors arrayed against her.

Presumably in 1973 Buchanan was rooting for our side and our allies back in the day, while he worked in the White House.

119 itellu3times  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:50:24am

re: #88 gop_patriot

Yes, and he worked with Ford, too. And of course, Reagan. I don't recall that they were anti-semitic..?!?

Are you saying that Buchanan spoke in this manner during the time that he wrote speeches for Nixon? Seriously, I was asking if those who were old enough at the time to remember, actually remember him being anti-semitic out loud and in public back then..? It just seems to me that he hid it for a long time, and now is unashamedly and blatantly out front about it.

I don't recall the details, but it's been no secret for a long time, when buchanan ran for pres in 2000 the "surprise" was that he had it in for blacks, too. I believe Hunter S. Thompson wrote even in 1972 (?), in Fear and Loathing on the Campaign Trail, about the kink in a blood vessel in buchanan's brain that sets off these attacks. Or else, I borrowed the metaphor from HST twenty years ago to apply to buchanan myself.

He just seems out front about it now.

In fact, John McLaughlin is only barely better about it now, in regards to Iraq and the Palestinians. I would not be surprised if Buchanan had discussed this with Mclauglin, before spewing it. I do think Mclaughlin is still sane enough, to attempt to hide it.

120 yma o hyd  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:51:07am

I'm beginning to think that this sort of creeping anti-semitism is now slowly getting more visible/audible, more acceptable, if you will, not because slobs like PB are getting tehir stuff printed but because people who have kept their mouths shut before are now thinking it is ok to do like PB, and speak out.

I have the feeling this might be because they think that in a World of raging islam its better to be seen to be on their, the jihadists', side - a bit like Germany after WWII in reverse: then, nobody was a Nazi or, God forbid, and anti-semite, and nobody knew anything about anything.
Now they side with what they think is the 'winning' side, the muslims, and now they are anti-semites, jsut like them, and have always been like that, ok, yah, please don't kill us ...

Thats how it starts to look like, to me. Its not just happening in the USA, its happening in Europe as well.
I cannot believe that it took only 60 years after the birth of Israel, and 65 after the holocaust, to rear its ugly head again.

121 FurryOldGuyJeans  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:51:09am

re: #116 Eowyn2

before I read all comments.

what is the WASP word for "putz"

schmuck, loser, turd, asshat, etc.

122 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:51:24am
123 calcajun  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:51:50am

re: #116 Eowyn2

The affectionate form of the name "Richard"

124 SpartanWoman  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:51:52am

re: #105 Honorary Yooper

I think I agree more with Jonah Goldberg and consider Buchanan to be a populist. He makes appeals to the people, and his writings (scribble?) and TV appearances are a part of that. I find it most interesting that Goldberg devotes an entire chapter of Liberal Fascism to Buchanan.

Populist. I shudder to think what would happen if Buchanan's ideas were truly popular. If the US made decisions based on what was good for Israel, Israel would extend to Damascus.

125 Ward Cleaver  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:52:01am

re: #116 Eowyn2

before I read all comments.

what is the WASP word for "putz"

Idiot?

126 Kragar (Proud to be Kafir)  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:52:44am

re: #98 Dar ul Harb

OT,

AFP photo editors strike again!

Heh.

Actually, the red attachment is a BFA, blank fire adapter, allowing a blank to generate enough gas pressure to cycle thru the firing process and has nothing to do with MILES gear. It can be used at any time. The little black device and some of the other gear attached to the rifle and worn by the soldier is part of miles gear though.

127 GGMac  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:53:03am

re: #68 buzzsawmonkey

Pat Buchanan hates Jews, and hates the fact that Israel exists.

He will do what he can to erode American relations with Israel, and he is working very, very hard to delegitimize World War II and the Allied defeat of Hitler.

In this, he is working for the Left and the Islamists and doing his best to ensure that Israel will be destroyed--a goal that the putatively right-wing Buchanan shares with the Left and the Islamists.

The Left still reflexively celebrates WWII, but that war has always been a major obstacle to the Left's endorsement of pacifism and disarmament. Celebrating the defeat of the fascist regimes of Hitler and Mussolini has also supported resistance to the Islamic fascism currently threatening America and the West from within and without.

Buchanan, with his revisionist "history" of WWII, does the Left and the Islamofascists the service of delegitimizing the Allied effort in that war. Falsely claiming that Hitler did not want war, but was forced into it by the Allies, Buchanan turns blame back on the West and the US, where the Left and the Islamists long to place it. Lying about the Final Solution, and claiming that it was "only a late response" to the war that had been forced on Germany, Buchanan achieves the feat of indirectly engaging in Holocaust denial, in a manner that is more difficult than usual to call him on.

Buchanan thus serves the Left which would like to see this nation passive and disarmed, and convinced that armed force is never justified. Despite his ties to European neo-fascists, Buchanan serves the Islamists who those neo-fascists allegedly oppose.

Why would Buchanan do these things? Hasn't he, in prior decades, shown that he is at least a patriot? The answer lies in Buchanan's hatred of Jews and of the existence of Israel. Just as Hitler, whom Buchanan now seeks to whitewash, undermined his own war effort in the interest of killing more Jews, Buchanan would bring down the United States and hand it over to the Left or the Islamists rather than see the US relationship with Israel (and Israel itself) survive.

Buchanan appears to be a living proof that antisemitism is a progressive mental disease whose progression resembles the descent into dementia common in syphilis victims prior to the advent of antibiotics.

And once again we bow to the wisdom of our very own, very articulate, and incomparable, buzzsawmonkey.

)))))))/bowing

128 gop_patriot  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:53:09am

re: #119 itellu3times

Thank you. :) I'm learning...

129 calcajun  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:53:22am

re: #118 alegrias

You know, it could be he (like a few old USN guys I know) bear a grudge over the sinking of the USS Liberty by the Israeli Air Force.

130 WriterMom  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:53:34am

Holy shitzky.

A MENTALLY DERANGED colleague just came into my office practically sobbing about the Omar Khadr tapes, and how BAD they are, and how SAD it is...I felt like saying UHHHH HELLLLO, do you know who you are talking to, you idjit?

131 jcm  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:53:38am

PBJ,

Quick question, since I'm too dense to understand your finely nuanced points.

What did Israel have to do with:
The Embassy Invasion of Nov. 4, '79.
The Marine Barracks and Embassy bombings in Lebanon '83.
The Kuwait Embassy Bombing in '83.
The Lebanon kidnappings.
Bombing of U.S. Embassy annex northeast of Beirut in '84.
Hijacking of TWA Flight 847 in '85.
............

132 lawhawk  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:53:41am

re: #83 Ward Cleaver

Ditto. The last time Buchanan spewed his venom, I wrote to Hewitt, FoxNews, and Hannity to no avail. They are blatantly ignoring the problem with Buchanan.

Stay classy.

133 mean Gene  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:54:07am

Does Pat simply not worry about Islamofascism or does he merely hope that the crocodile will really eat the appeasers last?

134 So?  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:54:09am

Boochanan!

135 MandyManners  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:54:29am

re: #116 Eowyn2

before I read all comments.

what is the WASP word for "putz"

Dick.

136 Opinionated  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:54:49am

re: #112 calcajun

Can't agree totally. Antisemitism is like any form of bigotry; its roots are in fear of the strange and ignorance/suspicion of another group--especially when that group does not want to assimilate.

That's the thing. And why I have changed my mind. What you wrote is no longer valid.

In the information age nothing is strange. The cliches are obviously not true to anyone who sees.

Go and read some of the virulent anti Semitic sites and you will see that the hatred of Jews, supported by manufactured facts, are not about ignorance or suspicion. They are the deliberate works of people with an obsession that would easily be classified as mental illness.

137 WriterMom  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:55:15am

re: #132 lawhawk

Hannity and him are best buddies.

That dude has some questionable friends (Hannity that is). I also have been reading how much stuff he rips off from Debbie Schleussel-and that is just tacky.

138 Eowyn2  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:55:44am

re: #30 harrylook

I think they're giving him all this attention b/c he's a "conservative" who sounds like a raving mad leftist half the time. It's a way for the MSM to claim they gave "equal time."


you have a point. they wouldnt want to give a rational point of view because conservatives cant be rational.

Reminds me of all the interviews that people have done on the abortion/anti abortion issue. Pro-Choice is always a dignified female of indeterminate years and preferrable, non-white. Pro-Life is always a white male age 30-50.

139 formercorpsman  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:55:46am

re: #130 WriterMom


I suspect this is the Gitmo stuff on Drudge?

140 wolfie  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:55:49am

re: #88 gop_patriot

The chief unifying issue on the right in those days was the fight against Communism and the USSR. Buchanan was a staunch Cold Warrior.
Israel was allied w/ the US and the Palis were allied w/ the USSR. As long as that situation remained, Buchanan navigated w/in the outlines of mainstream conservative thought.
His derailment came after the Cold War, when his antipathy toward Israel and latent anti-semitism were no longer checked by Cold War interests.

(The fact that we are still in a fight against totalitarianism and Israel is still our ally in that fight seems to have escaped him.)

141 Racer X  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:55:50am

re: #131 jcm

What did Israel have to do with:
The Embassy Invasion of Nov. 4, '79.
The Marine Barracks and Embassy bombings in Lebanon '83.
The Kuwait Embassy Bombing in '83.
The Lebanon kidnappings.
Bombing of U.S. Embassy annex northeast of Beirut in '84.
Hijacking of TWA Flight 847 in '85.

They exist.

142 So?  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:55:56am

I blame Boochanan for dementia.

143 MandyManners  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:56:03am

re: #130 WriterMom

Holy shitzky.

A MENTALLY DERANGED colleague just came into my office practically sobbing about the Omar Khadr tapes, and how BAD they are, and how SAD it is...I felt like saying UHHHH HELLLLO, do you know who you are talking to, you idjit?

Why didn't you say it?

144 Tazzerman  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:56:07am

re: #89 Silas Blex

I'm not sure about converts. Of course, first we'd have to circumcise ya, THEN we can start talking paychecks. :)-tm

145 Iron Fist  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:56:25am

re: #117 Racer X,

When were the Jews ever right? Besides, anti-Semitism is very much a part of Leftist belief. This is more of an example of Buchanan drifting Left, inasmuch as he now agrees with Queers for Palestine more than he does me.

146 jcm  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:56:39am

re: #115 Ward Cleaver

The trees look too green and non-tropical, and the soldiers don't appear to be wearing desert camo.

The one on the hood has a MILES vest on also.

147 wolfie  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:57:00am

re: #91 brainwizard73

Or he will blame America for supporting Israel, which gave Israel "false confidence" and started nuclear horrors of unspeakable destruction.

Too bad George Bush will be out of office...or he could blame Bush, too.

He has. Repeatedly.

148 WriterMom  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:57:04am

re: #112 calcajun

Anti-semitism is a unique form of hatred that poisons minds and souls. It has nothing to do with Jews wanting to assimilate-that's preposterous. It has nothing to do with the Jews either, it has to do with a deep seated hatred and jealousy of the Jewish people which can be propelled by religious, philosophical, economic or political fuel.

149 gop_patriot  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:57:12am

re: #140 wolfie

That was very clear, thank you. :)

150 runrabbitrun  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:57:13am

re: #132 lawhawk

Ditto. The last time Buchanan spewed his venom, I wrote to Hewitt, FoxNews, and Hannity to no avail. They are blatantly ignoring the problem with Buchanan.

Stay classy.

I fear they are exploiting the problem with Buchanan. Despite the shtick, they'll sell their souls for ratings - i.e., their jobs.

151 jcm  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:57:20am

re: #141 Racer X

They exist.

Ahh, thanks for clearing that up....
//

152 mean Gene  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:57:22am

re: #98 Dar ul Harb

OT,

AFP photo editors strike again!

Heh.

I thought AFP reporters at least hung out in hotel bars drinking while their stringers got their stories for them.
This photo indicates they just mail it all in.

153 Land Shark  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:57:31am

The way some conservative news outlets like Human Events and Townhall let this Nazi apologist Buchanan pollute their forums is positively nauseating. They give him a level of credibility he doesn't deserve as they damage their own, plus he gets a platform to spew his ignorant BS. Don't they realize the damage they do to the conservative cause by giving him a platform?

Sean Hannity, Townhall and Human Events, useful idiots for Pat The Nazi Apologist. Disgusting.

154 debutaunt  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:58:03am

re: #118 alegrias

President Nixon supported Israel against her enemies in 1973, when we helped Israel defeat her neighbors arrayed against her.

Presumably in 1973 Buchanan was rooting for our side and our allies back in the day, while he worked in the White House.

It's odd that Buchanan and Carter ended up at the same vile place.

155 WriterMom  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:58:06am

re: #143 MandyManners

I had to just think it unfortunately. Work and politics don't usually agree.

156 MJ  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:58:23am

re: #136 Opinionated

That's the thing. And why I have changed my mind. What you wrote is no longer valid.

In the information age nothing is strange. The cliches are obviously not true to anyone who sees.

Go and read some of the virulent anti Semitic sites and you will see that the hatred of Jews, supported by manufactured facts, are not about ignorance or suspicion. They are the deliberate works of people with an obsession that would easily be classified as mental illness.

Antisemitism is not a mental illness.

157 Kragar (Proud to be Kafir)  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:58:38am

re: #146 jcm

The one on the hood has a MILES vest on also.

Here is a BFA which is whats on the end of their weapons. You try and shoot live round with that on and you get a nice explosion in your face.

158 WriterMom  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:58:39am

re: #139 formercorpsman

Yes, the Gitmo interrogations ("you don't care about meeeeeeee")

159 calcajun  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:58:41am

re: #136 Opinionated

I agree there are differences. But, there are still people I know who are, to put it charitably, "old south", who just don't like 'em, but would never advocate mass deportations, boxcars, and Zyklon B, like the people who run the sites you describe.

I think our difference is that you see it all as one group, while I see a difference. That's all.

160 Ward Cleaver  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:58:45am

re: #132 lawhawk

Ditto. The last time Buchanan spewed his venom, I wrote to Hewitt, FoxNews, and Hannity to no avail. They are blatantly ignoring the problem with Buchanan.

Stay classy.

Maybe they think they're trying to be the "big tent", but this is wrong.

161 Iron Fist  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:58:49am

re: #129 calcajun,

The Liberty didn't sink.

162 Dianna  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:59:13am

re: #136 Opinionated

One really minor quibble - I've run into a lot of ignorant young people who will, to my face, repeat the old canard about, "Well, the Jews have all the money."

The ignorance out there is astonishing.

163 alegrias  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:59:14am

re: #129 calcajun

You know, it could be he (like a few old USN guys I know) bear a grudge over the sinking of the USS Liberty by the Israeli Air Force.

* * *
Possible. However, in my book,

There is no excuse for siding with the people who used civilian planes to "sink" the US PENTAGON, both World Trade Center Towers, and a field in Shanksville, Pennsylvania.

There is no excuse for siding with expansionist totalitarians who declared war on us since oh, 1979 or Munich 1972.

There's no excuse for siding with people who've been killing Americans for years with impunity.

I don't know the details of the USS Liberty accident whenever that happened, but certainly we and our allies have had plenty of "friendly fire" accidents during the current war. It is a tragedy when we accidentally kill fellow allies.

164 kansas  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 10:59:45am
This is why Jews drift over to the left.


I always wondered why they voted against their best interests.

165 calcajun  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:00:05am

re: #143 MandyManners

Grab that putz by the neck and bring up the Al Queda beheadings on You Tube and ask him how she/he feels then.

166 Tazzerman  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:00:35am

re: #154 debutaunt

It's a well know fact that Nixon hated the Jews. Any support he gave to Israel was purely pragmatic and caused more by his hatred of the Soviet Union than any love/friendship with Israel or Jews..

167 formercorpsman  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:00:44am

re: #158 WriterMom

I would love to comment on my opinion about your reaction, but you can read my mind.

168 RightOnTheLeftCoast  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:00:45am

re: #8 The Other Les

I go to Capitalism Magazine for my Sowell and Williams editorials instead.

[Link: www.capmag.com...]

Thanks for that link... I always enjoy Sowell and Williams (two of the reasons I started reading Townhall...). Finding a more reputable source for their writings makes my day.

169 So?  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:00:46am

re: #162 Dianna

One really minor quibble - I've run into a lot of ignorant young people who will, to my face, repeat the old canard about, "Well, the Jews have all the money."

The ignorance out there is astonishing.

And don't forget this one..."Jews are good in business."

170 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:00:46am
171 ointmentfly  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:01:22am

If the Israelis are really leading us around by the nose, they aren't going anywhere fast with the Saudis pulling us in the opposite direction by the balls.....

172 WriterMom  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:01:42am

re: #165 calcajun

I think that was directed toward my comment.

The colleague is a Muslim and very highly placed. An outburst like that would cost me my job.

173 itellu3times  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:02:10am

re: #131 jcm

PBJ,

Quick question, since I'm too dense to understand your finely nuanced points.

What did Israel have to do with:
The Embassy Invasion of Nov. 4, '79.
The Marine Barracks and Embassy bombings in Lebanon '83.
The Kuwait Embassy Bombing in '83.
The Lebanon kidnappings.
Bombing of U.S. Embassy annex northeast of Beirut in '84.
Hijacking of TWA Flight 847 in '85.
............

Ya mean PJB?

Look, Israel is responsible for the Pali's tossing kazzam missiles at them everyday, and every day they show dar al-Islam that the west are a bunch of Christian crusader monkeys and dogs, and the Saudis spend billions a year making sure every good Moslem knows this, so what's your question again?

174 BeerDrinking_VictoryMonkey  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:02:14am

re: #146 jcm

The one on the hood has a MILES vest on also.

Yep, thems MILES gear, alright. Damn things never worked right when I was in basic.

175 Silas Blex  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:02:15am

FYI: The Liberty didn't sink. What happened was bad enough without that exaggeration.

176 calcajun  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:03:12am

re: #161 Iron Fist

My mistake. 34 dead and a couple of massive holes.

177 Kragar (Proud to be Kafir)  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:03:12am

re: #174 BeerDrinking_VictoryMonkey

Yep, thems MILES gear, alright. Damn things never worked right when I was in basic.

8 and a halfs years in the Marines and never used them

178 Dianna  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:03:28am

re: #169 So?

Yes, I've heard that one, too.

179 Iron Fist  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:03:29am

re: #172 WriterMom,

I suppose explaining to him that I think we should have nuked the Mohammedans until they surrendered is out of the question?

[Sigh]

180 alegrias  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:04:05am

re: #154 debutaunt

It's odd that Buchanan and Carter ended up at the same vile place.

* * *
It's a choice.
Despicable.
Anti-American.
Just Wrong.

181 BeerDrinking_VictoryMonkey  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:04:29am

re: #169 So?

And don't forget this one..."Jews are good in business."

Heh. I recall a Chris Rock (I think) routine about "positive stereotypes" & he said, "Boo-hoo! I wish someone would say 'I got me a n*gger accountant & business has been great!'"

182 Slumbering Behemoth  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:04:42am

re: #5 Kaitian868

I don't understand why people appeal to Buchanan.

He finds them tasty?

183 kansas  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:04:58am

re: #130 WriterMom

Holy shitzky.

A MENTALLY DERANGED colleague just came into my office practically sobbing about the Omar Khadr tapes, and how BAD they are, and how SAD it is...I felt like saying UHHHH HELLLLO, do you know who you are talking to, you idjit?

They are bad, bad acting, and sad, sad they didn't shoot this little miscreant.

184 Charles  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:05:24am

The bombing of the USS Liberty, by the way, was proven to be an accident:

[Link: littlegreenfootballs.com...]

And the ship did not sink.

185 Xango Annie  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:05:41am

sent my comment. told them I had been considering becoming a charter subscription member of their new mag..but now will not..get rid of PB and I may reconsider.

186 runrabbitrun  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:05:42am

re: #164 kansas

I always wondered why they voted against their best interests.

That, and also because a large number of them truly believe in their heart of hearts, that if they are 'nice' to everybody - even those who tell them outright that they would exterminate them - their enemies will have a change of heart, and grow to love and know the Jews and Israel.

(this is the dynamic of my relatives =( academics and elites.)

187 WriterMom  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:05:51am

re: #178 Dianna

Don't you know the joke about two Jews sitting on a bus just before the Second World War, in Europe? One of the older men is reading the newspaper-a Nazi party newspaper. The other man says 'why are you reading a Nazi newspaper-they hate us', and the first one says 'when I read our newspapers, I get depressed-when I read their newspapers I see how all powerful the Jews are'.

188 kansas  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:06:25am

re: #186 runrabbitrun

That, and also because a large number of them truly believe in their heart of hearts, that if they are 'nice' to everybody - even those who tell them outright that they would exterminate them - their enemies will have a change of heart, and grow to love and know the Jews and Israel.

(this is the dynamic of my relatives =( academics and elites.)

Might ask how that's been working for them.

189 formercorpsman  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:06:27am

re: #172 WriterMom

Oh boy.

As well as lamenting the treatment of this captured shithead.

I must shut up.

190 WriterMom  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:06:34am

re: #186 runrabbitrun

Are we related?

ROFL.

191 Kragar (Proud to be Kafir)  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:06:36am

Fascists in Denver seek to oppress the masses

Denver police propose law to take pipes, chains out of protesters' hands

A draft law proposed by the Denver Police Department would ban the possession by protesters of materials such as weighted pipes and chains and items that can make urine and feces bombs.

Police say that such materials are potentially dangerous. The City Council Safety Committee will review the proposal July 23.

An earlier version also would have made it unlawful to possess bulletproof vests and gas masks.

192 calcajun  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:06:51am

re: #172 WriterMom

Then, if at all possible, tactfully engage him in what his faith allows and what it would take to dissuade the men and women of his faith from engaging in terror operations. If at all possible, mention that if his fellow Muslims had locked horns with the old USSR, or the Third Reich, they would have never received the comparatively good treatment that the present captives have received.

193 lawhawk  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:06:52am

Meanwhile, Obama goes on thinking that the Iraq war distorts the US foreign policy.

Ignoring the war against the US by the Islamists for 30 years was a distortion. Fighting the war back and eliminating a threat to US national security, whose intentions for the region included the regular and repeated use of WMD, and whose leader Saddam Hussein engaged in ethnic cleansing and genocide on a wide scale, is not a distortion.

194 Opinionated  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:07:13am

re: #159 calcajun

I agree there are differences. But, there are still people I know who are, to put it charitably, "old south", who just don't like 'em, but would never advocate mass deportations, boxcars, and Zyklon B, like the people who run the sites you describe.

I think our difference is that you see it all as one group, while I see a difference. That's all.

No. I think our difference are who we characterize as anti Semitic.

I'm not concerned with people- especially older people- who have a residual dislike of Jews for one reason or another. Even who given a choice would choose not to associate with Jews. People have intrinsic prejudices for all sorts of reasons and against all sorts of other people and we are all guilty in one form or another.

I am referring to the active anti Semites. The ones who see it as a calling to do harm to Jews. That calling- which Buchanan sees to answer regularly- is from a form mental illness. Buchanan is a hybrid. He is old enough to have been indoctrinated in the hatred but he is experienced and educated enough that if it were not for his illness he should have long ago been unindoctrinated.

195 MJ  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:07:14am

Pat's antisemitism is not rooted in a specific even such as the Liberty incident. It's much more primal than that.

Dress it up anyway you like...but Pat's antisemitism is of the deicide/blood libel origin.

196 yma o hyd  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:07:39am

re: #148 WriterMom

Anti-semitism is a unique form of hatred that poisons minds and souls. It has nothing to do with Jews wanting to assimilate-that's preposterous. It has nothing to do with the Jews either, it has to do with a deep seated hatred and jealousy of the Jewish people which can be propelled by religious, philosophical, economic or political fuel.

And we need to add to this that it is an easy way out for people who cannot bear to analyse their own faults, mistakes, and errors, because blaming someone else is always easier.
We also need to add that people all over the world have had a couple of thousand years or so practice in blaming the Jews.

Now that Israel is trying to accomodate leftist 'world' opinion in what they do vis-a-vis the islamists encircling them, it is obvious to the anti-semites that the Jews can again be blamed for eveything.
And lets not forget that the Qur'an is so full of anti-semitism that it should be put on any index, in any civilised nation who is making laws against 'hate-speech' ...

197 WriterMom  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:08:02am

re: #192 calcajun

Nice idea in theory, but I honestly believe that these people are all in cahoots with Allah et al, so there is no point in 'going there'. Plus, I don't think I would be able to shut my pie hole once I got started.

198 Iron Fist  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:08:03am

re: #191 Kragar (Proud to be Kafir),

Recreate '68 Denver '08

Even if Hillary doesn't fight it to the floor, the Democratic Convention has all kinds of possibility for fun! I'm bringing popcorn!

199 Spiny Norman  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:08:10am

re: #118 alegrias

President Nixon supported Israel against her enemies in 1973, when we helped Israel defeat her neighbors arrayed against her.

Presumably in 1973 Buchanan was rooting for our side and our allies back in the day, while he worked in the White House.

I would bet my last dollar that Pat opposed that move absolutely, and likely wasn't the only one. Nixon only sent aid after a direct personal appeal from Golda Meir, and he paid a political price for it, too. I remember that many, many people blamed him personally for the Arab Oil Embargo that followed.

200 Kenneth  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:08:23am

re: #130 WriterMom

Oh cripes! I don't give a shite foe that whiney little turd wipe! Does the CBC have a tape showing the Khadr family celebrating at the Kandahar Al Qaeda compound on Sept 11th?

WTF is wrong with these leftist ijits!?!

201 BLBfootballs  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:08:31am

As disgusting as Buchanan's antisemitism is his fast-and-loose relationship with inconvenient facts. His reliance on demagoguery is the first indicator that his ideology is false.

202 Tazzerman  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:09:09am

re: #184 Charles

True but the entire incident continues to be used by some in order to turn Americans away from Israel. There are those who still believe it was NOT an accident. (I'm not one of those mind you)

203 looking closely  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:09:50am

Buchanan sez:

Israel and its Fifth Column in this city seek to stampede us into war with Iran. Bush should rebuff them, and the American people should tell their congressmen: You vote for 362, we don't vote for you.


Nobody voted for YOU, Buchanan, or have you forgotten that?

Buchanan also seems painfully deluded about the threat of a nuclear armed Iran (or a non-nuclear one).

He is ignoring Khomeinist "Death to America" Iran's global sponsorship of terrorism through Hizb'Allah including the '83 Beirut attack and its arming soliders against the USA in Iraq.

Of course Israel is an obvious Iranian target, but its clearly not the only one. This is a GLOBAL concern, most definitely one of the USA, and not just Israel.

For example, the Saudis are also scared of the Iranians (and should be), and if they have a bomb, the Iranians could project power throughout the entire middle east, including all the oil supplies.

204 johnnyreb  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:10:41am

Is it just me or is that one very disjointed article? He is all over the place in it.

205 calcajun  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:10:58am

re: #184 Charles

I don't doubt it, but there are a few old navy hands I know who--no matter how hard you try to convince them--just won't accept the version that the IDF aircraft and PT boats mistook it for a "an unknown destroyer" or the Egyptian cargo ship "El Quseir". Honestly, the ship's silhouette looked nothing like a destroyer--no deck guns at all.

206 Silhouette  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:11:00am

re: #158 WriterMom

Yes, the Gitmo interrogations ("you don't care about meeeeeeee")

Show them a couple of the jihadi snuff films and ask them if it was them, would they rather be sobbing, while dressed, fed, and medically cared for, OR have their heads cut off. Would they rather be a jihadi in the hands of Americans or an American in the hands of jihadis? And no excuses that start with, "Well, can you blame them for...." or "But we should have a higher standard..."

Show them the jihadi training manual that directs the terrorists to act as if they are being tortured no matter what.

/probably wasted information, like seeds sown on the rocky ground, but it might make YOU feel better

207 WriterMom  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:11:06am

re: #196 yma o hyd

In Hebrew, there is a unique term for self-destructive, terror-loving Jews: Yefe Nefesh ('delightful or lovely souls'). Isn't that perfect. They are so nice and caring about our enemies and couldn't give a rat's ass about their own people. They donate clothes and food to them, take up their cases pro bono in Israel, go to their houses for dinner, stand at IDF barriers on their behalf.

Yefe Nefesh. Remember it-they are today's Kapos.

208 madisonsfriend  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:11:47am

I am a Jew and I own oil. I currently have 1 bottle of extra virgin olive oil and a bottle of canola. I will sell them for $100 each. Pat Buchanan is just another media whore- albeit one who hates me and mine.

209 Pullus Iulius  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:12:05am

re: #130 WriterMom

From what I saw, the interrogation was about as strenuous as the questioning that comes after a DWI arrest. I'm just so sorry that the widdle emo terrorist is sad.

210 Golem Akbar  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:12:06am

Mohammed (PBUH --Pat Buchanan Upon Him) would be proud.

211 WriterMom  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:12:19am

re: #206 Silhouette

Listen-I've already determined that this guy is a raging Jooooooo hater, and a very committed Muslim, so we don't have that much common ground-you know what I'm sayin?

212 alegrias  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:12:26am

re: #199 Spiny Norman

I would bet my last dollar that Pat opposed that move absolutely, and likely wasn't the only one. Nixon only sent aid after a direct personal appeal from Golda Meir, and he paid a political price for it, too. I remember that many, many people blamed him personally for the Arab Oil Embargo that followed.

* * *
Gee, do you think Kerry & Fonda came to Israel's assistance before Nixon did? I think not.

With the unpopular Vietnam War still on his watch, 60,000 dead and POWS just back from 9 years in Hanoi, Americans probably were not clamoring to go to enter another conflict.

But then isolationists always Blame America First, though OPEC withheld petroleum from its buyers.

213 Spiny Norman  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:12:38am

re: #184 Charles

The bombing of the USS Liberty, by the way, was proven to be an accident:

[Link: littlegreenfootballs.com...]

And the ship did not sink.

Anti-semitic paleocons seem to think that's their "trump card", even though their version of events has been debunked by everyone who has examined it. They are little different from the 9/11 Troofers.

214 WriterMom  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:12:49am

re: #210 Golem Akbar

Golem! PBUH indeed.

215 jcm  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:13:10am

re: #184 Charles

The bombing of the USS Liberty, by the way, was proven to be an accident:

[Link: littlegreenfootballs.com...]

And the ship did not sink.

Shit happens in a shooting war. USS Liberty was one of those. IIRC it's been investigated by 5 different commissions etc... All came to the same basic conclusion.

A Charlie Fox in the fog of war.

216 jorline  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:13:50am

re: #191 Kragar (Proud to be Kafir)

Fascists in Denver seek to oppress the masses

A draft law proposed by the Denver Police Department would ban the possession by protesters of materials such as weighted pipes and chains and items that can make urine and feces bombs.

Now I know what a dirty bomb is.

217 calcajun  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:15:21am

re: #194 Opinionated

I think we are arguing the same thing. There are "bigots"--(typical white people--I couldn't resist) and then there are the people who Jonah Goldhagen described as being infected with a virulent antisemitism which allows them to call for, and be willing to participate in, the murder of those people. Yes--I agree that the latter could be called a mental illness.

218 looking closely  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:15:32am

A little OT, but worth a gander:

Israel plays small role in Columbian FARC rescue:

Former Colombian presidential candidate Ingrid Betancourt, who was released after six years in captivity on Wednesday, compared her "impeccable" rescue operation to Israeli commando operations.

Perhaps she did not know it, but Israel indeed contributed to the elaborately-planned, daring rescue mission.

Betancourt, who was kidnapped in 2002 by Marxist rebels in Colombia (FARC), was rescued without a shot being fired. Colombian military agents, who had penetrated FARC's leadership, instructed her guards to transfer her to another rebel group.

Her captors put her on a helicopter that arrived as scheduled, little knowing that their comrades-in-arms were undercover Colombian soldiers. Betancourt and 14 other hostages who had been held in the jungle, including three Americans, were freed.

Since word of the dramatic rescue spread, speculation in the world media has attributed the success to people trained by Israeli intelligence. But an Israeli figure familiar with the military aid to Colombia said there was "no need to exaggerate" Israel's involvement in the operation.

219 runrabbitrun  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:15:54am

re: #190 WriterMom

Are we related?

ROFL.

Of course! We are on the 'smart side' of the family. (Unfortunately, I am also on the 'poor side'.)

=)

Really, as Peggy Noonan once pointed out (she was referring to Marxism), there is no beautifully expressed theory so absurd that an intellectual elite won't believe it

220 Spiny Norman  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:16:10am

re: #212 alegrias

* * *
Gee, do you think Kerry & Fonda came to Israel's assistance before Nixon did? I think not.

With the unpopular Vietnam War still on his watch, 60,000 dead and POWS just back from 9 years in Hanoi, Americans probably were not clamoring to go to enter another conflict.

But then isolationists always Blame America First, though OPEC withheld petroleum from its buyers.

Sending military aid is hardly the same as sending the Marines, so directly "entering a new conflict" likely wasn't what was on their minds. Pissing off OPEC and the Soviets surely was.

221 Golem Akbar  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:16:16am

Right now Dennis Prager on radio is discussing Jew-Hatred in his Ultimate Issues show.

222 experiencedtraveller  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:16:18am

re: #130 WriterMom

Holy shitzky.

A MENTALLY DERANGED colleague just came into my office practically sobbing about the Omar Khadr tapes, and how BAD they are, and how SAD it is...I felt like saying UHHHH HELLLLO, do you know who you are talking to, you idjit?

Its OK WriterMom. Omar Khadr is going to be "religiously rehabilitated".

/

223 Eowyn2  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:16:25am

re: #131 jcm

PBJ,

Quick question, since I'm too dense to understand your finely nuanced points.

What did Israel have to do with:
The Embassy Invasion of Nov. 4, '79.
The Marine Barracks and Embassy bombings in Lebanon '83.
The Kuwait Embassy Bombing in '83.
The Lebanon kidnappings.
Bombing of U.S. Embassy annex northeast of Beirut in '84.
Hijacking of TWA Flight 847 in '85.
............


the Munich olympics?
The Achilie laural (sp) hijacking
The bombing of the pentagon
the bombing of wtc1
the bombing of wtc2
the bombing of a field in PA

(I consider them bombings, not plane crashes)
the list of a thousand

224 TalkinKamel  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:16:40am

re: #213 Spiny Norman

And, for whatever twisted reason, they often seem to regard it as an atrocity equivalent to 9/11, or Arafat's murder of American diplomats (actually, they rarely touch on the last one.)

225 Kragar (Proud to be Kafir)  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:16:55am

re: #216 jorline

Now I know what a dirty bomb is.

A catapult which chucks hippies.

226 calcajun  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:16:59am

re: #207 WriterMom

And the kapos were the last to go into the "showers"--or they were shot as the SS abandoned the camps.

227 yma o hyd  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:17:15am

re: #207 WriterMom

In Hebrew, there is a unique term for self-destructive, terror-loving Jews: Yefe Nefesh ('delightful or lovely souls'). Isn't that perfect. They are so nice and caring about our enemies and couldn't give a rat's ass about their own people. They donate clothes and food to them, take up their cases pro bono in Israel, go to their houses for dinner, stand at IDF barriers on their behalf.

Yefe Nefesh. Remember it-they are today's Kapos.

Excellent expression - I will indeed remember that.

228 TalkinKamel  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:18:10am

re: #207 WriterMom

"Yefe nefesh"---"Lovely Souls"; you know, I like that!

"Lovely" indeed! It certainly sums such people up!

229 Dianna  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:18:11am

re: #187 WriterMom

I learned that as two Russian Jews, but yeah, I know that joke.

230 Iron Fist  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:18:21am

re: #225 Kragar (Proud to be Kafir),

No, that's entertainment :-)

231 Kenneth  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:18:28am

re: #211 WriterMom

At least this raging Joooo hater and committed Muslim isn't "lacking in empathy" (for poor little Khadr anyway, if not for Joos or infidels) because as Obama pointed out that could lead to desperation & terrorism.

232 MandyManners  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:19:03am

re: #207 WriterMom

In Hebrew, there is a unique term for self-destructive, terror-loving Jews: Yefe Nefesh ('delightful or lovely souls'). Isn't that perfect. They are so nice and caring about our enemies and couldn't give a rat's ass about their own people. They donate clothes and food to them, take up their cases pro bono in Israel, go to their houses for dinner, stand at IDF barriers on their behalf.

Yefe Nefesh. Remember it-they are today's Kapos.

How is that pronounced?

233 Golem Akbar  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:19:28am

re: #187 WriterMom

Don't you know the joke about two Jews sitting on a bus just before the Second World War, in Europe? One of the older men is reading the newspaper-a Nazi party newspaper. The other man says 'why are you reading a Nazi newspaper-they hate us', and the first one says 'when I read our newspapers, I get depressed-when I read their newspapers I see how all powerful the Jews are'.

Old joke, and still very true, very apt, today. Thanks, WM.

234 calcajun  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:19:51am

re: #197 WriterMom

Well, they respect force. If there is a little push back, then they might back off in some areas. Here's hoping.

235 TalkinKamel  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:19:53am

re: #205 calcajun

If they won't accept it, that's kinda sad. Doesn't make them right, Old Navy hands or not.

236 TalkinKamel  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:20:30am

If I ever write a book about such misquided people, I'll call it "Lovely Souls'!

237 itellu3times  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:20:34am

re: #205 calcajun

I don't doubt it, but there are a few old navy hands I know who--no matter how hard you try to convince them--just won't accept the version that the IDF aircraft and PT boats mistook it for a "an unknown destroyer" or the Egyptian cargo ship "El Quseir". Honestly, the ship's silhouette looked nothing like a destroyer--no deck guns at all.

If you read down the entire thread on the link Charles posted, I think you get a pretty good discussion on both sides.

238 Kenneth  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:21:59am

re: #236 TalkinKamel

If I ever write a book about such misquided people, I'll call it "Lovely Souls'!

because Dead Souls has already been taken.

239 runrabbitrun  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:22:03am

re: #188 kansas

Might ask how that's been working for them.

I believe that my elite/academic relatives would be sadly willing to keep their faces down, speak in low halting voices, and try to stay quiet and out of sight of the barbarians, just to survive as Jewish.

240 Dirk Diggler  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:22:24am

TalkinKamel,

"Yefe nefesh"---"Lovely Souls"; you know, I like that!

I prefer the English equivalent, "assh*les". Less flowery but far more economical.

241 jcm  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:22:32am

re: #223 Eowyn2

the Munich olympics?
The Achilie laural (sp) hijacking
The bombing of the pentagon
the bombing of wtc1
the bombing of wtc2
the bombing of a field in PA

(I consider them bombings, not plane crashes)
the list of a thousand

Yep, Like I said up thread.
A state of war has existed since Nov. 4, '79.
But we (collectively) have figured it out yet.

242 hazzyday  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:22:38am

That is standard isolationism for Pat Buchanan. IMO he has aged into a state where he no longer cares to hide his opinion about Israel. What we see is the true Pat coming out. Iran could launch missiles right at Israel and if they fell 3 feet short, Pat would pronounce this as no credible threat by the Iranians.

I am fine if he has a voice in the country, but it should be more like on the David Duke radio show. They are more in step with Pat then Fox News or Laura Ingram. I suppose he is pulling strings. Fox does have ultra left and right positions at times. Pat is basically an irrelevant person today.

I have met several smart people in the past year who are obsessed with AIPAC as the root cause for a lot of problems in America. They generally seem to be brittle twisted people to me. Inflexible.

243 calcajun  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:22:53am

re: #235 TalkinKamel

It's the same sort of mentality where a family refuses to believe a cop acted properly when a family member is killed in an officer-involved shooting. They cannot accept that systems sometimes fail and bad things happen through no one's fault.

244 Dar ul Harb  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:22:58am

re: #219 runrabbitrun

As Peggy Noonan once pointed out (she was referring to Marxism), there is no beautifully expressed theory so absurd that an intellectual elite won't believe it

Sort of a paraphrase of the remark attributed to George Orwell that there are some ideas so foolish that only an intellectual could believe in them.

245 gymnast  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:23:06am

Pat Buchanan seems to think that he has achieved credibility do to his ability to repeatedly jump the shark. His actual status is shark bait in a clown suit and any entertainment value that he once exhibited has been replaced by his twisted psychopathology. Buchanan's "popcycle" has melted and there is nothing left but shit on a stick.

246 BeerDrinking_VictoryMonkey  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:23:28am

re: #238 Kenneth

because Dead Souls has already been taken.


Gogol it.
/

247 Kragar (Proud to be Kafir)  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:23:35am

re: #230 Iron Fist

,

No, that's entertainment :-)

Depends on if you're in the impact area.

Of course, the idea of lauching hippies bring to mind Mel Brooks.

"Sire, the peasants are revolting!"
"You said it. They stink on ice."

248 wolfie  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:24:07am

re: #194 Opinionated

My reservation about calling ideological anti-semitism a mental illness is that the very word "illness," for me, absolves one of responsibility.

Allowing me poetic license here, we may call anti-semitism a form of demonic possession. In medieval thought, there was a distinction drawn between those who were possessed through no fault of their own and those who (usually through a gradual process) surrendered right reason to absurd imaginings and egotism.
The French philosopher Alain Besancon makes the point in A Century of Horrors that to begin to understand the uniqueness of the Shoah even an atheist has to think theologically.

I wonder if anti-semitism, the kind that goes beyond simple xenophobia, is not more properly described as a spiritual perversion.
The mental dysfunction may be a result, not a cause.

249 madisonsfriend  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:24:22am

re: #237 itellu3times

If you read down the entire thread on the link Charles posted, I think you get a pretty good discussion on both sides.

Whatever - the point is that I think we mostly see the Liberty being used as an anti-semitic tool. And people in the military can be anti-semitic too- not just among older people.

250 TalkinKamel  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:24:35am

re: #202 Tazzerman

Well, unless and until we invent time travel (and I hope we never do), I really don't see what Israel's supposed to do about it this incident to reassure everybody---especially as it has been judged an accident.

Some people believe the earth is flat. Some people believe all we have to do to make Islamist terrorists like us is be nice to them. Some people (like Pat Buchanan) believe the Jews are responsible for all the evils of the world; some people believe 9/11 was caused by George Bush, with smoke and mirrors, and some people really believe they'll get lotsa money if they just help out that nice widow who emailed them from Nigeria.

Some people will believe the damndest things, and that's all there is to it.

251 WriterMom  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:24:59am

ACK

I can't catch up...Work, once again getting in the way of LGF....I'll try to respond in the next few minutes to the comments.

252 Kosh's Shadow  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:25:18am

re: #239 runrabbitrun

I believe that my elite/academic relatives would be sadly willing to keep their faces down, speak in low halting voices, and try to stay quiet and out of sight of the barbarians, just to survive as Jewish.

Ask them how well that worked for assimilated Jews in Germany.

253 MJ  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:25:39am

Nixon and the 73 War:

It's useful to remember that Nixon at first resisted sending weapons to Israel. Both he and Kissinger thought it was a good idea to let Israel bleed in order to put leverage on Israel. However, after the the massive Soviet air-lift of weapons to the Arabs was well under way, both Nixon and Kissinger came to the consludion that they could not let the Soviets win. Only then did the air-lift begin in earnest.

Nixon and Kissinger wanted to show the Arabs they could never defeat Israel with the backing of the Soviets. Neither Nixon or Kissinger would allow the Soviet-backed Arabs to win a victory over a U.S. ally. By sending arms to Israel, the United States could insure an Israeli victory, hand the Soviets a defeat, and provide Washington with the leverage to influence a postwar settlement.

254 Golem Akbar  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:25:47am

re: #242 hazzyday

That is standard isolationism for Pat Buchanan. IMO he has aged into a state where he no longer cares to hide his opinion about Israel. What we see is the true Pat coming out. Iran could launch missiles right at Israel and if they fell 3 feet short, Pat would pronounce this as no credible threat by the Iranians.

I am fine if he has a voice in the country, but it should be more like on the David Duke radio show. They are more in step with Pat then Fox News or Laura Ingram. I suppose he is pulling strings. Fox does have ultra left and right positions at times. Pat is basically an irrelevant person today.

I have met several smart people in the past year who are obsessed with AIPAC as the root cause for a lot of problems in America. They generally seem to be brittle twisted people to me. Inflexible.


Just remember that the Germans who later became Nazis were the most intelligent, cultured, and advanced in the world, at that time. Intelligence (or sh#t for brains) has little to do with having any kind of moral center. Alas.

255 yma o hyd  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:26:00am

re: #248 wolfie

That is a very interesting explanation - and I'd go along with that.

256 Kenneth  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:26:31am

Buchanan explained:

It's not about the USS Liberty
It's not about US foreign policy
It's not about the Israeli Lobby

It's about hate. Period.

257 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:26:37am
258 WriterMom  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:26:43am

re: #222 experiencedtraveller

Feh.

259 Canadastani  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:27:31am

As someone who loves Townhall and agrees with Charles, I sent them the following:

Let me begin by explaining that I love Townhall. I read a couple articles daily, and listen to the entire Dennis Prager show each day using your podcasts (I also listen to the others, such as Hugh Hewitt's Mark Steyn interviews). I am disappointed in you publishing the garbage that Pat Buchanan writes. Today's "Two Different Crises" feature is typical of his drivel. If I need someone to blame the Jews and exonerate terror regimes like Iran, I can read the New York Times or watch Keith Olberman. I read Townhall features because even those that I disagree with start from a realistic conservative perspective. Pat Buchanan has long abandoned conservatism for the fever swamps of conspiracies, anti-semitism, and xenophobia. His most recent book, if reviews are accurate, is a revisionist fantasy blaming Churchill for WWII while conveniently exonerating the role of a certain German anti-semite. Please clean it up and let Buchanan publish his diatribes elsewhere.

260 Golem Akbar  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:27:36am

re: #251 WriterMom

ACK

I can't catch up...Work, once again getting in the way of LGF....I'll try to respond in the next few minutes to the comments.


I keep having to come back...leave...come back....[speaking of hampster wheels...]

261 Amy  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:28:07am

re: #27 MandyManners

Israel is a fifth column?

It isn't Israel that's the Fifth Column; it's worse than that. After all, Israel is a sovereign country which can be expected to act according to its national interests.

According to Buchanan and his ilk, it's American Jews (via AIPAC) who are the Fifth Column, because we supposedly place our loyalty to Israel above our loyalty to the US. Therefore, these creeps argue, the Jews and AIPAC wants to push the US into wars which are not in the US's interest but which will benefit Israel.

No question but that this is unadulterated antisemitism, but it's nothing new; it's a reprise of Hitler's "The Jews stabbed us in the back" excuse for everything that had gone wrong in Germany since World War I.

262 Kenneth  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:28:50am

re: #248 wolfie

Brilliant post! Really.

My reservation about calling ideological anti-semitism a mental illness is that the very word "illness," for me, absolves one of responsibility.

Exactly!

263 alegrias  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:28:52am

OT
Whoa, Y'all! Another democrat throws Obama under the bus...

O'Hanlon on Obama

The Washington Post reports:

Michael E. O'Hanlon, a Democratic defense analyst at the Brookings Institution who has been an outspoken supporter of the war in Iraq, said he could not believe that Obama would put such a definitive timeline into print before a trip to Iraq, where he is to consult with Iraqi leaders and U.S. commanders.

"To say you're going to get out on a certain schedule -- regardless of what the Iraqis do, regardless of what our enemies do, regardless of what is happening on the ground -- is the height of absurdity," said O'Hanlon, who described himself as "livid." "I'm not going to go to the next level of invective and say he shouldn't be president. I'll leave that to someone else."

Posted by John McCormack at 12:02 PM
2008
[Link: www.weeklystandard.com...]

264 Silhouette  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:29:16am

re: #248 wolfie

Allowing me poetic license here, we may call anti-semitism a form of demonic possession.

History seems consistent with examples of anti-semitism but the reasons seem to vary with each culture, which leads me to believe that, yes, it is the work of a greater evil, which works in opposition to the Children of God.

265 MandyManners  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:29:23am

re: #259 Canadastani

As someone who loves Townhall and agrees with Charles, I sent them the following:

Let me begin by explaining that I love Townhall. I read a couple articles daily, and listen to the entire Dennis Prager show each day using your podcasts (I also listen to the others, such as Hugh Hewitt's Mark Steyn interviews). I am disappointed in you publishing the garbage that Pat Buchanan writes. Today's "Two Different Crises" feature is typical of his drivel. If I need someone to blame the Jews and exonerate terror regimes like Iran, I can read the New York Times or watch Keith Olberman. I read Townhall features because even those that I disagree with start from a realistic conservative perspective. Pat Buchanan has long abandoned conservatism for the fever swamps of conspiracies, anti-semitism, and xenophobia. His most recent book, if reviews are accurate, is a revisionist fantasy blaming Churchill for WWII while conveniently exonerating the role of a certain German anti-semite. Please clean it up and let Buchanan publish his diatribes elsewhere.

Well said.

266 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:29:45am
267 wolfie  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:30:08am

re: #207 WriterMom

Yefe Nefesh.
Americans, both Gentiles and Jews, need a term like that!
It's so much more concise than "groveling, self-blaming, kumbaya-singing, surrender-monkeys!

268 WriterMom  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:30:19am

Hmmm OK

#219 Yes, something so stupid only an academic would believe it...so true.

#232 Mandy Manners

Yeh-Fay Neh-Fesh

That's singular, a lovely soul....

269 Sunlight  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:30:33am

I wish Dennis Prager would say something on his show about these increasingly hostile articles on the site he is associated with. I know he defended Hagee, but Hagee apologized for his far out comments. Even if Dennis took a "freedom of speech" approach, he could think about switching to the site where Tammy Bruce is for he distribution (I get it on iTunes and listen on my iPod)...

270 jorline  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:30:38am

re: #225 Kragar (Proud to be Kafir)

A catapult which chucks hippies.

Sounds like they're preparing for a big party in Denver.

271 MandyManners  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:30:51am

re: #261 Amy

It isn't Israel that's the Fifth Column; it's worse than that. After all, Israel is a sovereign country which can be expected to act according to its national interests.

According to Buchanan and his ilk, it's American Jews (via AIPAC) who are the Fifth Column, because we supposedly place our loyalty to Israel above our loyalty to the US. Therefore, these creeps argue, the Jews and AIPAC wants to push the US into wars which are not in the US's interest but which will benefit Israel.

No question but that this is unadulterated antisemitism, but it's nothing new; it's a reprise of Hitler's "The Jews stabbed us in the back" excuse for everything that had gone wrong in Germany since World War I.

Oops. I was seeing red so badly by the time I finished the article that I mis-read.

272 TalkinKamel  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:30:52am

re: #243 calcajun

Yes, I know---same sort of thinking.

And when people bring this up, and say things like, "Well, some people still say. . . " and, "Though it may have been an accident, it still creates bad feelings. . . " all I can say is that Yassir Arafat, and his PLO goons, murdered American diplomats. They murdered American citizen Leon Klinghoffer, and were responsible, over the decades, for countless murders, bombings, airplane hijackings and other jolliness and nobody, but nobody, holds it against them. Instead, American taxpayers send them money and are enjoined to support something laughably called, "The Peace Process". (Cue in the laff track here.)

(And all of these crimes were deliberate, none of them were accidents; no one ever even pretended that they were at the time. This is just your typical double-standard at work, here.)

Face it---people will believe---or talk themselves into believing---some stupid things.

273 Kosh's Shadow  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:31:07am

I think Pat Buchanan being on web sites and TV is a symptom of a rising anti-Semitism. Right now, he's considered somewhat loony but still allowed to rant on semi-respectable forums.
This makes what he is saying more acceptable than it was before. Gradually, what he's saying will become mainstream, and it will be the frothing Nazis that are the fringe on these forums. After that, we've seen it before.

This is why Pat should be left with nothing more than the modern-day equivalent of the soapbox on the corner. He should have to get his own web site, and his own late-night local access cable TV program; no one should be letting him use theirs, especially no one who is considered respectable.

274 yma o hyd  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:31:12am

re: #257 buzzsawmonkey

Good point!
The last 'friendly' happened a few days ago in Afghanistan, involving the British 2nd Battalion Paras and British helicopter gunships (6 wounded). And thats with all the brilliant modern technology.
So why can't people accept that this was the case with the USS 'Liberty'?
Perhaps because at that time 'friendly fire' was not talked about in the media - and because afterwards too many vested interests wante to believe what they wanted to believe, but not the evidence.

275 looking closely  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:32:15am

re: #261 Amy

Of course all that you say is correct.

Even apart from the Jew-hating angle, Buchanan's premise is false on its face.

Assuming Iran got its fantasy, and Israel were actually to "disappear from the map" tomorrow morning, it would *STILL* be in the interest of the USA to ensure that "Death to America" Iran doesn't get the Bomb.

Maybe Buchanan thinks the evil fifth column American South Korean lobby is pressing the US to exert pressure on North Korea to drop *ITS* covert nuclear program also.

276 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:32:17am
277 MandyManners  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:32:41am

re: #248 wolfie

People choose to hate.

278 Silhouette  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:32:52am

re: #225 Kragar (Proud to be Kafir)

A catapult which chucks hippies.

Can you see a bunch of hippies trying to figure out the complex mechanics of a catapult?

A bong is almost at the end of their abilities.

279 Maine's Michael  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:33:31am

Since Buckley died, Buchanan has danced out of the closet.

280 brainwizard73  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:33:35am

re: #261 Amy

I think the greatest insult is the insinuation that Israel has nothing better to do that start something with Iran...as if they don't have enough problems.

If Iran is building a bomb, or is close to getting the elements for a bomb, I think both the U.S. and Israel would have a common interest in seeing that wiped out. No need for a sinister lobby here.

After all, the fact that Iran is arming terrorists to kill American troops in Sadr City, Mosul and other places in Iraq is, in my opinion, a causus belli. That is all we should need if we wanted to use it as a legitimate reason for an attack.

281 runrabbitrun  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:33:36am

re: #244 Dar ul Harb

Sort of a paraphrase of the remark attributed to George Orwell that there are some ideas so foolish that only an intellectual could believe in them.

Aha, so she stole it! (okay, she 'researched' it.) I don't remember any attribution....

I'm getting tired of Peggy anyhow. She so hates and resents the Bush administration for not begging her to sign on and help out, and so overvalues her own (admittedly considerable) talents as a speech writer, that every time in the last couple years I've read her WSJ columns, I've been near poisoned by the venom drippings.

282 looking closely  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:34:07am

re: #263 alegrias

OT
Whoa, Y'all! Another democrat throws Obama under the bus...

O'Hanlon on Obama

The Washington Post reports:

Michael E. O'Hanlon. . ."I'm not going to go to the next level of invective and say he shouldn't be president. I'll leave that to someone else."
Very well. . . .

Obama shouldn't be President.

He's simply a foreign policy idiot. His very words are damaging to American interests and INCREASE (not decrease) the likelihood of war.

283 Kragar (Proud to be Kafir)  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:34:07am

re: #278 Silhouette

Can you see a bunch of hippies trying to figure out the complex mechanics of a catapult?

A bong is almost at the end of their abilities.

I wouldn't trust them to operate it, just serve as the ammo.

284 Iron Fist  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:34:21am

re: #257 buzzsawmonkey,

There were incidents of friendly fire in the First Gulf War:


[edit] Friendly fire
While the death toll among Coalition forces engaging Iraqi combatants was very low, a substantial number of deaths were caused by accidental attacks from other allied units. Of the 148 American troops who died in battle, 24% were killed by friendly fire, a total of 35 service personnel. A further 11 died in detonations of allied munitions. Nine British service personnel were also killed in a friendly fire incident when a USAF A-10A Thunderbolt-II attacked a group of two Warrior IFVs.


The Gulf War was as close to a "by the book" war as you could possibly hope to get, but there were friendly fire accidents. These things happen. They are regrettable, and the dead are just as dead, but they are called "accidents" for a reason.

285 Maine's Michael  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:34:26am

re: #76 Tazzerman

I'm Jewish and I'm STILL waiting for my 'World Dominance' check damit! Is there someplace, maybe in NYc, that I have to register or something?

I'll send you your registration forms.

You're likely eligible for millions in arrears.

286 alegrias  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:34:49am

Isolationists and neo-isolationists and paleo-isolationists are not looking out for us.

Whether Pat B or Markos M, isolationists, appeasers & navel-gazers are not interested in defending our founding principles of life, liberty and pursuit of happiness.

We should not elect isolationists nor appeasers to be our Commander in Chief if we care about life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.

287 Colonel Panik  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:35:04am

As I said before on the last Buchanan thread, we need to send him to Gitmo and waterboard him until he tells us where Martin Bormann and Josef Mengele are hiding.

288 ploome hineni[deleted]  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:35:49am
289 Silhouette  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:35:53am

re: #284 Iron Fist

Weren't there more killed by friendly fire than by the enemy?

290 orbital  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:36:25am

Charles, I applaud your efforts at trying to marginalize this man. Good call on taking them out of the news sources.

Any ideas on how many hits Townhall gets through this web page from your links to PB? Or how many hits from other links which have linked from you?

I suppose in the long run, these things have to be exposed. But I am betting their hit count goes WAY up off of Buchanan's anti-Jew pieces.

291 WriterMom  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:36:49am

re: #287 Colonel Panik

I don't agree with your comment. While Buchanan is surely an antisemite-he is not a Nazi. I believe those kind of comparisons actually demean the evil that was actually done by the real Nazis.

292 Iron Fist  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:37:15am

re: #280 brainwizard73,

we have pleanty of reasons to go to war with Iran that have nothing to do with Israel. I can think of 444 that don't even have anything to do with Hizb'allah.

293 yma o hyd  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:37:19am

re: #287 Colonel Panik

As I said before on the last Buchanan thread, we need to send him to Gitmo and waterboard him until he tells us where Martin Bormann and Josef Mengele are hiding.

They're hiding in the deepest Hell of Hells by now, I think.

294 wolfie  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:37:37am

re: #259 Canadastani

That's a great letter ! Perfect in tone, too.

295 Golem Akbar  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:38:02am

re: #280 brainwizard73

I think the greatest insult is the insinuation that Israel has nothing better to do that start something with Iran...as if they don't have enough problems.

If Iran is building a bomb, or is close to getting the elements for a bomb, I think both the U.S. and Israel would have a common interest in seeing that wiped out. No need for a sinister lobby here.

After all, the fact that Iran is arming terrorists to kill American troops in Sadr City, Mosul and other places in Iraq is, in my opinion, a causus belli. That is all we should need if we wanted to use it as a legitimate reason for an attack.

I think Pat Buchanan is really saying something else. He is attributing Israel's existence as the reason for the anti-western attitude of the Islamic world, today. He is blaming Israel's existence for 9/11. Etc. Or: If Israel would stop existing, oil prices would go down, and the world would be in complete Kumbayah, m' lord.

296 Sunlight  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:38:32am

re: #257 buzzsawmonkey

Ask them whether they believe the not-unknown occurrences of friendly fire incidents within our own armed forces are accidents or plots of some kind, such as the work of hostile enemy agents embedded in the military.

If our own forces on occasion cannot tell that they are shooting at our own men--something which has, regrettably, occurred in every armed conflict--why is it so difficult to believe that the forces of an ally could make a similar error?

It is only impossible to believe if one ascribes magical, unfailing omniscience to the ally. And magical, unfailing omniscience of that sort is exactly the same thing that antisemites who talk about "Jewish control of the banks" or other such stereotypes engage in.

Also, I read that the Liberty was doing electronic something and had moved into the battle zone without telling Israel. Some of these people who hold onto the Liberty incident think the U.S. should be able to do anything anytime anywhere and not have to coordinate... I also know people who don't support anything about Israel because they saw films of miserable Palis separated from their fields by the fence. Israel left Lebanon? check! makes no difference (as a matter of fact, they say this was "inelegant"). Israel left Gaza? check! makes no difference. This is why I know people (surprises me who) are anti-semitic. Nothing Israel does makes a difference and if something actually happens to Israel, they will tsk tsk (just as they say about the holocaust) or say "oops, I guess the stories were right" and go on. Too unpleasant to think of and they must have had it coming, just like in Europe and Russia. Bah!

297 jcm  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:38:47am

re: #274 yma o hyd

Good point!
The last 'friendly' happened a few days ago in Afghanistan, involving the British 2nd Battalion Paras and British helicopter gunships (6 wounded). And thats with all the brilliant modern technology.
So why can't people accept that this was the case with the USS 'Liberty'?
Perhaps because at that time 'friendly fire' was not talked about in the media - and because afterwards too many vested interests wante to believe what they wanted to believe, but not the evidence.

Noteable Blue on Blue incidents....

1863 - Lt. Gen. T. J. “Stonewall” Jackson, famous Confederate Civil War general accidentally mortally wounded by his own troops at Chancellorsville, VA.

10 September British submarine HMS Triton sank another British submarine, HMS Oxley, mistaking it for a German U-boat and having received no responses to challenges. Oxley was the first Royal Navy vessel to be sunk and also the first vessel to be sunk by a British vessel in the war.

RAF fighter ace Wing Commander Douglas Bader shot down in what recent research suggests was a friendly fire incident.

Operation Husky (Allied Invasion of Sicily): 144 C-47 transport planes passed over Allied lines shortly after a German air raid, and were mistakenly fired upon by ground and naval forces, 33 planes were shot down and 37 damaged, resulting in 318 casualties.

Viet Nam War: USCGC Point Welcome was attacked by USAF aircraft, with two deaths resulting.

USS Boston, USS Edson, USCGC Point Dume, HMAS Hobart and two U.S. Swift Boats, PCF-12 and PCF-19 are attacked by US aircraft on June 17 in the Vietnam War.[11] Several sailors were killed and PCF-19 was sunk.

U.S. Helicopters attack U.S. 3/187th Infantry Battalion CP during the Battle of Hamburger Hill, killing two and wounding thirty-five, including Lt. Col. Weldon Honeycutt.

American AH-1 Apache attack helicopter fires on US Army Bradley Fighting Vehicles during night operations during Operation Desert Storm killing several US Army soldiers. (Note: My BIL was in this one)

American A-10 during Operation Desert Storm attacks British armoured personnel carriers killing nine British soldiers (the same number as were killed by enemy fire in the whole war).

Pat Tillman, famous American football player and friendly fire victim in Afghanistan.

298 Spiny Norman  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:38:56am

re: #250 TalkinKamel

Well, unless and until we invent time travel (and I hope we never do), I really don't see what Israel's supposed to do about it this incident to reassure everybody---especially as it has been judged an accident.

Some people believe the earth is flat. Some people believe all we have to do to make Islamist terrorists like us is be nice to them. Some people (like Pat Buchanan) believe the Jews are responsible for all the evils of the world; some people believe 9/11 was caused by George Bush, with smoke and mirrors, and some people really believe they'll get lotsa money if they just help out that nice widow who emailed them from Nigeria.

Some people will believe the damndest things, and that's all there is to it.

It's called the "Elvis Factor" - polls have shown over the years that a consistant 8% of the population believes Elvis Presley is still alive. Irreducible looniness...

Kinda puts Congress' 9% approval rating into perspective, doesn't it?

299 Eowyn2  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:39:27am

re: #208 madisonsfriend

I am a Jew and I own oil. I currently have 1 bottle of extra virgin olive oil and a bottle of canola. I will sell them for $100 each. Pat Buchanan is just another media whore- albeit one who hates me and mine.

is it 72 extra virgins olive oil?

300 Golem Akbar  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:39:35am

re: #280 brainwizard73

I think the greatest insult is the insinuation that Israel has nothing better to do that start something with Iran...as if they don't have enough problems.

If Iran is building a bomb, or is close to getting the elements for a bomb, I think both the U.S. and Israel would have a common interest in seeing that wiped out. No need for a sinister lobby here.

After all, the fact that Iran is arming terrorists to kill American troops in Sadr City, Mosul and other places in Iraq is, in my opinion, a causus belli. That is all we should need if we wanted to use it as a legitimate reason for an attack.


It's not just Israel. If Jews would stop being, existing, living, etc., the world's troubles would just disappear, in Pat Buchanan's world view.

301 Opinionated  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:40:08am

re: #248 wolfie

Mental illness does not in and of itself absolve of responsibility.

To be so absolved the perpetrator is supposed to be in a state where the illness prevents him from knowing right from wrong.

Buchanan knows that his repulsive attack Jews was unacceptable wrong even to a colleague such as William Buckley, but the compulsion- the illness- is so great that he continues deliberately with mens rea.

302 ploome hineni[deleted]  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:41:14am
303 Iron Fist  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:41:23am

re: #289 Silhouette,

No, we did actually sustain some losses. According to Wiki, U.S. forces suffered 148 battle-related deaths. Still war is, by its very nature, a dangerous business. Accidents will happen and people will die.

304 Silhouette  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:42:13am

re: #280 brainwizard73

I think the greatest insult is the insinuation that Israel has nothing better to do that start something with Iran.

And if Israel bombed them flat tomorrow, they no more "started" it than the Allies did by invading Normandy.

305 dhg4  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:43:10am

re: #184 Charles

The bombing of the USS Liberty, by the way, was pr oven to be an accident:

[Link: littlegreenfootballs.com...]

And the ship did not sink.

Alas there are organizations out there every bit as malign as Buchanan (when it comes to Israel) whose central issue if the attack on the Liberty and yet the media treats them as mainstream.

There was the recent incident with that "reporter" from WRMEA whose complaints of mistreatment by the Israelis were taken at face value. Given the organization he works for, he never should have been trusted.

There's something about being anti-Israel (usually a front for being antisemitic) that makes it "not so bad" in many precincts. It's a shame that sites like Townhall haven't risen above that in respect to Buchanan. (Doesn't WND also feature Buchanan?)

306 wolfie  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:44:23am

re: #273 Kosh's Shadow

This is what concerns me. It is not that individuals jump up on a soapbox and spout bile and inanities. It is what is acceptable discourse in the mainstream.
I do not like the direction we're heading.

307 alegrias  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:44:27am

I am eternally grateful to and thank Israel for whacking Saddam's nuke facility, and for whacking Bashir al Assad's nuke facility, and for spooking Ahmedinejad until we we're decided to act.

La Chaim!

308 Kenneth  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:44:28am

re: #291 WriterMom

Buchanan is not a Nazi, but he is a Nazi apologist.

309 Vergeltung  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:44:29am

re: #287 Colonel Panik

As I said before on the last Buchanan thread, we need to send him to Gitmo and waterboard him until he tells us where Martin Bormann and Josef Mengele are hiding.

I think they died as old men in Brazil a long time ago.....

310 Iron Fist  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:45:09am

re: #300 Golem Akbar

It's not just Israel. If Jews would stop being, existing, living, etc., the world's troubles would just disappear, in Pat Buchanan's world view.


Actually, if Mohammedans stop being, existing, living, etc., the world's troubles would just disappear. Well, almost. To a large degree.

Something like that :-)

311 Pyrocles  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:45:27am

Thanks for the link, Charles. I worked with a guy who was a very Conservative, intelligent, and respectable guy, and a Swifty to boot. He loved the many forwards I sent him from LGF, but NOT the ones about Israel. He was always hung up on the Liberty incident... I knew it had to be an accident; but he just wouldn't accept that explanation...

re: #184 Charles

The bombing of the USS Liberty, by the way, was proven to be an accident:

[Link: littlegreenfootballs.com...]

And the ship did not sink.

312 alegrias  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:45:55am

re: #306 wolfie

This is what concerns me. It is not that individuals jump up on a soapbox and spout bile and inanities. It is what is acceptable discourse in the mainstream.
I do not like the direction we're heading.

* * *
Someone close to Pat B. needs to say "Porque No Te Callas?" like King Juan Carlos told Hugo Chavez to close his mouth.

313 Eowyn2  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:46:12am

re: #295 Golem Akbar

I think Pat Buchanan is really saying something else. He is attributing Israel's existence as the reason for the anti-western attitude of the Islamic world, today. He is blaming Israel's existence for 9/11. Etc. Or: If Israel would stop existing, oil prices would go down, and the world would be in complete Kumbayah, m' lord.

He is not a big fan of history.

His history starts in 1948 and is tainted.

314 wolfie  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:46:33am

re: #291 WriterMom

I don't agree with your comment. While Buchanan is surely an antisemite-he is not a Nazi. I believe those kind of comparisons actually demean the evil that was actually done by the real Nazis.

Amen.

315 Spiny Norman  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:46:41am

re: #297 jcm

Noteable Blue on Blue incidents....

1863 - Lt. Gen. T. J. “Stonewall” Jackson, famous Confederate Civil War general accidentally mortally wounded by his own troops at Chancellorsville, VA.

10 September British submarine HMS Triton sank another British submarine, HMS Oxley, mistaking it for a German U-boat and having received no responses to challenges. Oxley was the first Royal Navy vessel to be sunk and also the first vessel to be sunk by a British vessel in the war.

RAF fighter ace Wing Commander Douglas Bader shot down in what recent research suggests was a friendly fire incident.

Operation Husky (Allied Invasion of Sicily): 144 C-47 transport planes passed over Allied lines shortly after a German air raid, and were mistakenly fired upon by ground and naval forces, 33 planes were shot down and 37 damaged, resulting in 318 casualties.

Viet Nam War: USCGC Point Welcome was attacked by USAF aircraft, with two deaths resulting.

USS Boston, USS Edson, USCGC Point Dume, HMAS Hobart and two U.S. Swift Boats, PCF-12 and PCF-19 are attacked by US aircraft on June 17 in the Vietnam War.[11] Several sailors were killed and PCF-19 was sunk.

U.S. Helicopters attack U.S. 3/187th Infantry Battalion CP during the Battle of Hamburger Hill, killing two and wounding thirty-five, including Lt. Col. Weldon Honeycutt.

American AH-1 Apache attack helicopter fires on US Army Bradley Fighting Vehicles during night operations during Operation Desert Storm killing several US Army soldiers. (Note: My BIL was in this one)

American A-10 during Operation Desert Storm attacks British armoured personnel carriers killing nine British soldiers (the same number as were killed by enemy fire in the whole war).

Pat Tillman, famous American football player and friendly fire victim in Afghanistan.

Another one to add: WWII American fighter ace George Preddy was shot down and killed by a US anti-aircraft crew on Christmas Day, 1944, during the height of the Battle of the Bulge. Two others with him were also shot down by the same US AAA batteries, but managed to bail out.

316 DistantThunder  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:47:33am

Letter sent to Townhall.

317 big L  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:48:42am

Maybe that is part of the reason that Mary Katherine Ham left KarinHall, I mean Town Hall

318 Opinionated  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:50:04am

re: #311 Pyrocles

No one who believes the incident was deliberate can ever give a rational answer- from the real facts of the time- to the most crucial question as to why would Israel- while at war needing American goodwill- attack an American ship.

319 Canadastani  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:51:18am

re: #294 wolfie
and
#265 MandyManners

Thank you both. I am a big fan of Townhall and think the world of many of their people. Unfortunately, many conservatives are still under the illusion that Buchanan is a conservative because he was the designated "conservative" on Crossfire and acts as the "conservative" guest on many shows. Townhall, being conservative, probably thinks "well, we don't like him, but he is a prominent conservative but we're not about to censor a guy just because we disagree with him." I say they probably don't like him (I extend the benefit of the doubt) because if Townhall is the sum of its parts, it is fair to say that Dennis Prager, Michael Medved, Hugh Hewitt, Bill Bennett, etc are not Buchananites and they are the collective face of Townhall. The thing is, Pat long since left conservatives. Pat Buchanan is anti-free trade, generally isolationist, clearly anti-Israel (I believe he is anti-Jew, but anti-Israel is easier to prove), and very willing to support the premise that America is the problem. The fact that he is also pro-life does not make him a conservative.

320 experiencedtraveller  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:51:58am

re: #297 jcm

Operation Husky (Allied Invasion of Sicily): 144 C-47 transport planes passed over Allied lines shortly after a German air raid, and were mistakenly fired upon by ground and naval forces, 33 planes were shot down and 37 damaged, resulting in 318 casualties.

That was a particulaly terrible event. Atkinson writes well about it.

321 ploome hineni[deleted]  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:52:03am
322 WriterMom  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:52:54am

re: #308 Kenneth

I'm OK with that terminology.

323 Opinionated  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:54:45am

re: #308 Kenneth

Buchanan is not a Nazi, but he is a Nazi apologist.

The difference is only in the wardrobe and the marching.

324 wolfie  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:57:36am

re: #308 Kenneth

Buchanan is not a Nazi, but he is a Nazi apologist.

Considering his last book, I would have to agree with you.

325 quickjustice  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 11:58:15am

re: #321 ploome hineni

I actually know Jay Cristol, the retired U.S. Bankruptcy Judge in Miami who researched the Israeli attack on the U.S.S. Liberty for decades. Cristol also served in the U.S. Naval Reserves, which gave him an incentive to find out why Israel might have attacked a U.S. Navy vessel. There was a great deal of speculation about whether the attack was a deliberate Israeli effort to blind U.S. intelligence-gathering efforts at the time.

Once the critical documents were declassified, largely through Cristol's efforts, it became clear that the attack on the Liberty was an accident.

326 Slumbering Behemoth  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 12:00:57pm

Buchanan has his own magazine, and continues to write books. No one would be "censoring" him by denying him air time/blog space.

327 brainwizard73  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 12:01:07pm

re: #295 Golem Akbar

I can see that.

However, it seems to me that Patty is alleging that Israel is "trumping-up" the Iran nuclear threat and that this "puffery" is leading America to a conflict with Iran. The hate here is couched in the notion that Israel is simply looking for trouble with no legitimate right to be concerned about a rouge nation that may be arming with nuclear weapons and has indicated time and again that destroying Israel is a primary objective.

If any other nation, other than Israel, took this position, it would be seen as totally legit.

Make sense to anyone but me?

328 quickjustice  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 12:01:10pm

Although I believe that Buchanan is anti-semitic, I also think that his motives are economic. He wants to sell his book. What better way than to drum up some controversy about the Joos?

329 Pyrocles  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 12:02:35pm

Nope, not really. He hinted that the Israelis attacked because the Liberty was spying on them. Or the Israelis were doing something sneaky and illegal; didn't want the US to see them. *shrug*

I liked the guy, and miss him a lot. He was Vietnam vet, and a Swiftboat Veteran who HATED Kerry. The guy was great! I never understood his distrust of Israel though. He grudgingly sided with them over the Pallies though.

re: #321 ploome hineni

did he say why he believed Israel attacked the Liberty deliberately?

330 calcajun  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 12:02:47pm

re: #274 yma o hyd

I've studied enough history to know that friendly fire happens in every conflict. It's an occupational hazard. Look at Stonewall Jackson. The mentality with which we're dealing is one where the USN personnel have a communication system in which they place their faith so that "regrettable events" do not happen. When that system is followed (and I do not know if it was with the Liberty) and such an event takes place, the inclination is not to blame the system, but to blame others.

That's the point I was making originally with Paddy's antisemitism having the USS Liberty as a possible root. He, presumably, could not blame the USN--which as I understand it, still thinks it was a deliberate and unprovoked attack. So, as that thinking goes, the fault must lie with the IDF, which (again following that line of thought) if it followed the proper protocols, would not have attacked. Therefore, the reason for the attack must be darker and more sinister.

This is similar to something I wrote earlier, where people cannot simply accept that s**t happens and that when it does, it must be as a result of some dark conspiracy. Look at JFK's assassination, Hurricane Katrina, etc. --some people will not accept that people make imperfect systems and sometimes those systems fail.

331 TalkinKamel  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 12:06:55pm

re: #269 Sunlight

Yes, I know, I wish he would too.

332 Maine's Michael  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 12:07:27pm

Buchana's subtext:

"Jews are not legitimate, therefore Israel is not legitimate, therefore ISraeli self defense measures are not legitimate. 15 billion muslims, and WW2 era Germans, can't be wrong."

333 TalkinKamel  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 12:09:32pm

re: #298 Spiny Norman

heh, heh, heh. . .. (Hey, Elvis is alive, and he lives in my walk-in closet!)

334 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 12:12:15pm
335 alegrias  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 12:18:52pm

Meanwhile, among the Lucid:

John Bolton Rocks!

Israel, Iran and the Bomb
By JOHN R. BOLTON
July 15, 2008

[Link: online.wsj.com...]

336 calcajun  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 12:31:01pm

re: #315 Spiny Norman

You might want to add Glenn Miller to that mix. The theory now is that Miller's plane flew into a "dumping area" for the RAF and 8th USAAF bombers which had to abort and dump their loads over the Channel. Miller's plane was at a lower altitude and struck by bombs which had been jettisoned from above. Another foul up.

337 BeerDrinking_VictoryMonkey  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 12:36:46pm

re: #332 Maine's Michael

Buchana's subtext:


"Jews are not legitimate, therefore Israel is not legitimate,
therefore ISraeli self defense measures are not legitimate. 15 billion
muslims, and WW2 era Germans, can't be wrong."


15 billion muslims? I know that their reproduction rates are higher than the West's, but not that high!

338 ploome hineni[deleted]  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 12:42:49pm
339 Amy  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 12:43:55pm

re: #275 looking closely

Assuming Iran got its fantasy, and Israel were actually to "disappear from the map" tomorrow morning, it would *STILL* be in the interest of the USA to ensure that "Death to America" Iran doesn't get the Bomb.

Agreed. It's also interesting how the anti-Israel lobby, on both the left and right, argues simultaneously that Bush is in the pocket of the oil producers and that our government is held hostage to Israeli (meaning Jewish) interests. It is simply absurd to believe that Bush is doing what he knows isn't in the US's national interest simply to please a postage-stamp-sized country without any natural resources. Right.

re: #280 brainwizard73

After all, the fact that Iran is arming terrorists to kill American troops in Sadr City, Mosul and other places in Iraq is, in my opinion, a causus belli. That is all we should need if we wanted to use it as a legitimate reason for an attack.

Absolutely true. I wish we would make more noise about the killed and captured Iranians in Iraq; I have a feeling we don't because it would cause problems for Maliki's Shi'ite-dominated government.

re: #295 Golem Akbar

I think Pat Buchanan is really saying something else. He is attributing Israel's existence as the reason for the anti-western attitude of the Islamic world, today.

Bingo! Buchanan's in the "Israel's creation was a mistake" camp.

340 ploome hineni[deleted]  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 12:47:01pm
341 dreaboi  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 12:47:35pm

Don't blame this on Buchanan being a Paleo; there are a whole halfdozen of them, with good hearts, who don't hate Jews. We disagree on quite a bit of policy (and, indeed, on everything that philosophically got us to that place), but let's not forget about the things we all see eye-to-eye on. Buchanan is a rabid Jew-hater--and, increasingly, he's become unable to just contain it in that box. The rise of Neoconservatism and the War on Terror really unhinged him to the point that now he sees dastardly Jews everywhere (following the 'pagan' god of Strauss). Not sure if you all noticed his mention of "Pagan morality" in a previous column re: Hitchens-- it's a subtle dig at Leo Strauss.

342 abolitionist  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 12:52:49pm

From the article,

Under Secretary of State Nick Burns then splashed cold water on Iran's alleged crash program to acquire nuclear weapons.
[snip]
Iran, says Burns, has not yet mastered the technology of converting uranium gas into fuel for use in power plants, let alone the stuff of bombs. And even if Iran is one day able to enrich to weapons grade, she would still have to build and test a nuclear device, then weaponize it to fit atop a missile and deploy a missile force. All in all, says Burns, Iran's progress with uranium enrichment has been "modest."

There is thus no imminent crisis to justify war on Iran.

The Uranium Enrichment drumbeat seems to be working. IMHO, some issues are being confused and others ignored.

The very first fission bomb based on Uranium (LIttle Boy) was field test over Hiroshima, August 6 1945. By its simple design, it was sure to work. Whether the plane delivering it would get off the ground was not so certain.

Plutonium does not occur in nature but is produced only within nuclear reactors. For Plutonium-based bombs, the simplest practical design is far more complex than for Uranium, but has the advantage of a lighter payload.

In general, missiles with heavy payloads can't go as far as those with lighter payloads.

Missiles are not the only option for delivery.

343 calcajun  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 12:57:50pm

re: #342 abolitionist

How big a nuke can they get in the back of an '87 Toyota pick-up?

344 tgibson1962  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 12:59:31pm

re: #332 Maine's Michael

Buchana's subtext:

"Jews are not legitimate, therefore Israel is not legitimate, therefore ISraeli self defense measures are not legitimate. 15 billion muslims, and WW2 era Germans, can't be wrong."

Reading the subtext is a pretext, especially when the text is bad enough on its own.

345 ak47pundit  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 1:07:58pm

I think we just need more sympathy for poor Pat Buchanan, he gone clear round the bend.

After all, don't you know his father died at Auschwitz?

He fell out of a guard tower.

346 Maine's Michael  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 1:08:44pm

re: #337 BeerDrinking_VictoryMonkey

15 billion muslims? I know that their reproduction rates are higher than the West's, but not that high!

It's true.

I read it in the NYTIMES.

347 yochanan  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 1:08:58pm

re: #92 snowcrash

another name for neo fascist.

348 Vikingstar  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 1:10:57pm

Bless me, Lizards, for I have sinned.

I voted for Buchanan in 1992 in my state's primary.

You have to understand, there was a time when Buchanan seemed to make sense, and his vitriol towards Israel was minimal. It seems to me that he slid into his present viciousness after losing in 2000.
Not to say it wasn't present before, but it wasn't so much front and center in his writings and interviews.
In 1992, he was running against George H.W. Bush, who had done much to make conservatives sour on him. It was a protest vote on my part. At least I can say I didn't vote for Clinton...
While I'm doing true confessions, I voted for Carter in 1976. I was 18 and barely sentient. It took a couple of years to realize what I had helped do, and I ran to vote for Reagan in '80.

I'm sorry. I didn't mean to. I won't do it again.

349 sparrowlake  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 1:13:13pm

re: #291 WriterMom

I don't agree with your comment. While Buchanan is surely an antisemite-he is not a Nazi. I believe those kind of comparisons actually demean the evil that was actually done by the real Nazis.

But he uses Nazi propoganda tactics.
This stinking little piece of populist excrement started with the "fifth column" bullcrap before his presidential political aspirations were soundly rejected by the vast majority in 1992. Instead of graciously accepting the democratic will of the people, this ugly little xenophobic antisemite unsuccessfully ran again and again in 1996 and 2000. Buchanan, using a tried-and-true Nazi tactic, continues to attempt to scapegoat the US Jewish lobby/Israel's "amen corner"/AIPAC for everything from high oil prices to Arab terrorism and perhaps his own political failures.

350 yochanan  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 1:13:57pm

Partisan differences are more significant on the question of what the U.S. should do if Iran attacks Israel. By a 70% to 12% margin, Republicans say the U.S. should respond militarily if Israel is attacked. Forty-five percent (45%) of Democrats oppose a military response while 30% support it. Unaffiliated voters are evenly divided.

anti semitism seems to be a bi partisan activity.

351 scottishbuzzsaw  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 1:18:29pm

The comments posted at TH for this article are depressing.

352 quickjustice  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 1:18:41pm

re: #338 ploome hineni

Correction. The Israeli attack on the U.S.S. Liberty was deliberate, but the Israelis believed that the ship was Egyptian. So it's incorrect to call it an "accident". It's more accurate to call it a deliberate attack based upon a case of mistaken identity.

"After the Liberty was bombed by both the Israel Air Force and the Israel Navy, the two helicopter pilots were summoned from their base to assess the damage and evaluate the possibility of rescuing the surviving crew members. An American spy plane, which had been sent to the area as soon as the NSA learned of the attack, recorded their conversations, which took place between 2:30 and 3:37 P.M. on June 8, the third day of the war.

The spy plane also recorded the orders radioed to the pilots by their supervisor at Hatzor Base, which instructed them to search for Egyptian survivors from the "Egyptian warship" that had just been bombed - thus supporting Israel's claim that it had believed the ship was Egyptian when it ordered it attacked. "Pay attention. The ship is now identified as Egyptian," the pilots were told.

Nine minutes later, Hatzor informed the pilots that it was not an Egyptian warship, but an Egyptian cargo ship. Only at 3:07 were the pilots first informed that the ship might not have been Egyptian at all: Hatzor told them that if they found Arabic-speaking survivors, they should be taken to El-Arish, but if they found English-speaking survivors, they should be taken to Lod. "Clarify by the first man that you bring up, what nationality he is, and report to me immediately," the supervisor instructed, according to the transcript. "It's important to know."

Then, at 3:12, one of the pilots informed Hatzor that he saw an American flag flying over the wounded ship. He was asked to investigate and determine whether it was really an American ship."

Contemporaneous NSA intercepts confirmed this.

353 sparrowlake  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 1:23:27pm

re: #352 quickjustice

Correction. The Israeli attack on the U.S.S. Liberty was deliberate, but the Israelis believed that the ship was Egyptian. So it's incorrect to call it an "accident". It's more accurate to call it a deliberate attack based upon a case of mistaken identity.

It was an accident. Why split hairs?

354 sparrowlake  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 1:32:45pm

re: #350 yochanan

Partisan differences are more significant on the question of what the U.S. should do if Iran attacks Israel. By a 70% to 12% margin, Republicans say the U.S. should respond militarily if Israel is attacked. Forty-five percent (45%) of Democrats oppose a military response while 30% support it. Unaffiliated voters are evenly divided.

anti semitism seems to be a bi partisan activity.

I'll take 70% to 12% anytime.
And remember, within the 12% and the 45% there is presumably a substantial percentage of isolationists and cowards who are not necessarily anti-Semitic.

355 yochanan  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 1:43:58pm

re: #353 sparrowlake

the ship was a spy ship in a war zone if you want to blame someone blame the people who sent it there. esp after they said there were no american ships in the war zone. A egyptian war ship was sunk the day before in the same general area.

America was not a allie of Israel back in 1967.

356 A.W.  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 1:47:25pm

quickjustice

Actually, if you want to split hairs, it was an accident. the accident was the mistake of identity, not the act of firing itself, but the overall--firing on an american vessel--was an accident.

I just wonder why so many people harp on this so much, out of proportion? if you haven't missed it, we shoot our own soldiers a goodly amount of the time--why is it even worth remarking that the isrealis hit us by accident, when our ship was where it wasn't supposed to be, without propert indentification? If you want to blame someone, talk to the captain and everyone up and down the line, who didn't at least say, "hey isreal, we are here to observe and we are americans. don't shoot."

Isreal at that stage was like a cornered rat. they were facing down many times their own number, facing an enemy that planned to wipe out every man, woman and child in isreal. they got jumpy. if i was them, i would be jumpy too.

The conspiracy theories just the latest example of a modern left that is no longer in touch with reality. Here's a hint guys. Oswold killed kennedy. oliver stone flat out lied to you to sell movie tickets--don't pretend you are shocked by that. we landed on the moon. how do i know? because even over a decade later, when they shot superman II, they couldn't make the moon scene look even half-assed. Oh, and the holocaust happened. you can't get millions of people to keep a secret. and 9-11 was carried out by crazy muslims, led by osama bin laden, with no prior knowledge by our government. how do i know this? because our government is too incompetant to pull off your fantasies. There are no aliens visiting us. how do i know this? because the stories told by these nuts are scientifically impossible, and because space travel is too difficult to justify aliens coming here just to do silly experiments on us. and finally, the isrealis hit us by accident, which is what we get when we stick our ships where they are not expected, without properly announcing and identifying ourselves.

God, I am so sick and tired of these conspiracy nuts.

357 yochanan  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 1:56:39pm

re: #356 A.W.

THIS WHOLE ISSUE IS BEING USED BY ANTI SEMITES HAS BEEN FOR A LONG TIME.

358 ploome hineni[deleted]  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 2:00:09pm
359 yochanan  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 2:02:08pm

re: #358 ploome hineni

NO!

360 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 2:15:22pm
361 yochanan  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 2:22:13pm

re: #358 ploome hineni

are you Muman?

THANKS A LOT I AM YOCHANAN BEEN A LIZARD FOR A LONG TIME.

362 yochanan  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 2:23:00pm

re: #360 buzzsawmonkey

JESSIE will not be able to find them to cut them off OBAMA DOESN'T HAVE ANY. no spine eather

363 A.W.  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 2:34:43pm

yochanan:

I know. I know. my real first name is "jewish" (meaning from the old testament) and despite the fact i am a scottish christian, just because of my "jewish" first name, i have seen anti-semitism up close for a long, long time.

buzz

lol.

But on jackson, seriously, what was up with that? i guess part of the seething hate the left has these days.

The only time i think i'd like to see someone castrated is when they are like a child rapist or something, especially after the kennedy decision, and that is generally as an alternative to just killing the bastard. and i think i would snip the frank and not just the beans, if it were up to me for those rapists.

364 ploome hineni[deleted]  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 3:27:13pm
365 A.W.  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 3:42:10pm

ploome

i prefer to remain mysterious on the name, but where? All over the place but online most of all. and yes, most often from muslims. they have a real cultural problem there.

366 Maine's Michael  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 5:31:29pm

re: #356 A.W.

Excellent. Just, excellent.

367 grahamski  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 6:08:42pm

I am not much for name calling, but Pat is a big fat wind bag.

368 Jeff MacMillan  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 6:17:25pm

Gave Townhall my 2 cents. Never ceases to amaze me that this character still gets his face everywhere.

America would be better off if a monkey was given the air time instead of Pat Buchannon.

369 Sloppy  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 6:56:50pm

In the mid-Sixties, when he became a syndicated columnist after a stint writing editorials for the St. Louis Globe-Democrat, I edited PB's columns for the paper I was working for. As I recall, he was a mainstream conservative. What happened to him, I couldn't imagine.

370 GMRoper  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 7:01:14pm

re: #367 grahamski

I am not much for name calling, but Pat is a big fat wind bag.

Why are you being so kind?

371 Quilly Mammoth  Tue, Jul 15, 2008 8:58:30pm

GM,

I wonder if there could be a blogburst organized? Mr. Buchanan has long been on the edge and it has been clear for the last two years that he has gone off it. He's simply changing history to make the last century's wars and today's problems the fault of the Jews. Blaming Israel for the Iranian arms escaltion is just crazy. Has no one confronted this fool on Ahmonajihad's 12th Imam desire?

372 Joel  Thu, Jul 17, 2008 2:52:31pm

What a neo Nazi piece of excrement he is!


This entry has been archived.
Comments are closed.

^ back to top ^

log in
Name:
Pass:

Register Forgot Your Password? My Account Re-send Confirmation (To log in, cookies must be enabled in your browser!)

► LGF Headlines

► Top 10 Comments

► Bottom Comments

► Recent Comments

► Tools/Info

► LGF Hits

► Slideshows

► Resources

► Never Forget

► Statistics

► Tag Cloud

► Contact

You must have Javascript enabled to use the contact form.
Your email:

Subject:

Message:


Messages may be published in our weblog, unless you request otherwise.
Tech Note:
Using the Contact Form

► News/Opinion

Learn to Read with Hooked on Phonics
More Partners

Compare Electricity Prices in your area. Texas Electricity is deregulated; you have the right to choose Texas Electric Rates from among many Texas Electric Companies.

Now, nobody dance!


Finish Line- $10 off $60- 160 x 600
Barnes & Noble Deal of the Day