LGF

more options

  

Advertisement

Russia Bombs Civilians in Georgia

Sat, Aug 9, 2008 at 8:33:49 am PDT

The provincial capital of South Ossetia, Tskhinvali, lies in ruins as Russia sends hundreds of tanks into Georgia: Russian troops raid Georgian town; scores dead.

GORI, Georgia (AP) - Russia sent hundreds of tanks and troops into the separatist province of South Ossetia and bombed Georgian towns Saturday in a major escalation of the conflict that has left scores of civilians dead and wounded.

Georgia, a staunch U.S. ally, launched a major offensive Friday to retake control of breakaway South Ossetia. Russia, which has close ties to the province and posts peacekeepers there, responded by sending in armed convoys and military combat aircraft.

Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov told reporters in Moscow that some 1,500 people have been killed, with the death toll rising Saturday.

Advertisement

853 comments

  • Comments are open and unmoderated, and do not necessarily reflect the views of Little Green Footballs.
  • Obscene, abusive, silly, or annoying remarks may be deleted, but the fact that particular comments remain on the site in no way constitutes an endorsement of their views by Little Green Footballs.
  • Posts that contain phone numbers, street addresses, email addresses or other personal information will also be deleted, as will posts that consist only of a variation on the word, "First!"
  • Comments that advocate violence will be cause for immediate banning with no appeal.
  • Disagreement and debate are welcome, but insults and abuse are not, and may cause your account to be blocked.
  • REMEMBER: posting comments at LGF is a privilege, not a right. Abuse that privilege, and your account will be blocked.

Hide comments | Jump to bottom

1 FrogMarch  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:34:39am

Putin's Russia must be stopped.

2 opnion  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:35:17am

Putin is a Stalinist to the core!

3 FrogMarch  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:35:46am
Russia, which has close ties to the province and posts peacekeepers there, responded by sending in armed convoys and military combat aircraft.


There's the spin.

4 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:36:05am

Links to the latest news from Georgia.

[Link: www.aboutgeorgia.net...]

5 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:36:32am

re: #3 FrogMarch

There's the spin.

They also helped Azerbaijan complete a railway.

6 HoosierHoops  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:36:36am

just in time for the olympics..
how nice of putin..

7 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:37:08am

When was BHO's trip to Hawaii scheduled?

8 ROP?LOL  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:37:32am

Apartment buildings bombed. Women and children killed. Where is the world press? Where is the outrage?

9 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:37:39am

Has Soviet Russian television shown images of happy workers, peasants, and children showering the Soviet Russian with flowers yet?

10 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:37:40am

Sky news coverage.

[Link: news.sky.com...]

11 rawmuse  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:37:42am

Sounds like the old military adage "Kill them all and let God sort it out".

12 willowone  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:37:56am
13 ibmkeyboard  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:38:01am

Sister Rice.

"We call on Russia to cease attacks on Georgia by aircraft and missiles, respect Georgia's territorial integrity and withdraw its ground combat forces from Georgian soil."


America would never attack the territorial integrity of another small country?!?

/sorry boys and girls but the cat is out of the frigging bag.

14 AW  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:38:09am
The Russian military has laid waste to the provincial capital of South Ossetia, Tskhinvali

It's actually the Georgians who attacked Tskinvali. The population there is sympathetic to the Russians.

The Russians are attacking Gori and other towns inside Georgie, and they sent troops in to Tskhinvali to drive the Georgians out and help the Ossetian rebels.

15 nigella  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:38:14am

I really believe we will be meeting up with Russia one day, and I don't mean socially. I expect a military show down. What scares me most is who will be at the "helm" here as POTUS? If it's the Messiah, we might want to start learning that second language he has told us to do. Not Spanish of course, but Russian!

16 HoosierHoops  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:38:37am

re: #7 MandyManners

When was BHO's trip to Hawaii scheduled?

I thought he was having a rally today in Hawaii mandy..
I'll check..

17 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:38:37am

This looks really bad and it could get a lot worse.

18 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:38:40am

Russia blames us.

19 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:38:41am

Georgia has 2000 troops in Iraq. Are we gonna help them?

20 itellu3times  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:38:50am

I doubt they sent hundreds of tanks. Hundreds of vehicles, couple dozen tanks, the rest miscellaneous armor and transport. How many tanks does Georgia have, likely zero?

21 jaunte  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:39:07am

" Russia, which has granted citizenship to most of the region's residents, appeared to lay much of the responsibility for ending the fighting on Washington."
This is outright blackmail on Putin's part. He's telling the U.S. and NATO to get out of his back yard or he'll keep bombing.

22 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:39:10am

re: #8 ROP?LOL

Apartment buildings bombed. Women and children killed. Where is the world press? Where is the outrage?

The Spirit of Munich prevails.

23 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:39:28am

re: #16 HoosierHoops

I thought he was having a rally today in Hawaii mandy..
I'll check..

But, when was it scheduled?

24 Quilly Mammoth  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:39:37am

I'm revising my opinion on this. Russia means to reabsorb Georgia and there's nothing anyone can do about it.

25 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:40:09am

re: #13 ibmkeyboard
Ah, so we should've left the Taliban and Saddam alone?!

26 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:40:22am

re: #20 itellu3times

I doubt they sent hundreds of tanks. Hundreds of vehicles, couple dozen tanks, the rest miscellaneous armor and transport. How many tanks does Georgia have, likely zero?

Russia's the one that sent in the tanks.

27 itellu3times  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:40:36am

re: #19 pingjockey

Georgia has 2000 troops in Iraq. Are we gonna help them?

Georgia has called the troops home, and the US has offered them transport.

With an extra baggage allowance, if you get my meaning, if you catch my drift.

28 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:40:40am

re: #24 Quilly Mammoth

I'm revising my opinion on this. Russia means to reabsorb Georgia and there's nothing anyone can do about it.

It's all about Russian colonialism and oil.

29 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:40:55am

re: #18 MandyManners

Russia blames us.

[Link: www.liveleak.com...]

The Soviet Russian state can do the Monica on me.

30 willowone  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:41:09am

Russia's foreign minister said that Georgia brought the airstrikes upon itself by bombing civilians and Russian peacekeepers, and warned that the small Caucasus country should expect more attacks.

"Whatever side is used to bomb civilians and the positions of peacekeepers, this side is not safe and they should know this," Lavrov said
from article, yet Israel isn't allowed same defense as they claim.

31 republic  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:41:27am

Fuck Russia!

32 jaunte  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:41:33am

re: #20 itellu3times

Georgia has more than 100 tanks, but Russia has more than 20,000.
The exact figures are at the Telegraph (UK) somewhere in a related story.

33 willowone  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:41:38am

re: #15 nigella
agree, cannot imagine Obama defending us.

34 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:42:09am

re: #28 MandyManners
I think Putin has visions of reassembling the Russian Empire, with himself as Czar. No communists, just a good old fashioned dictatorship.

35 dmandman  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:42:56am

I wonder if we will start finding "revenge" diaries on captured Russian soldiers soon? If so we are in for a terrible ride.

36 DoubleU  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:43:01am

It was done on behalf of the common good!

37 willowone  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:43:08am

post 30 (mine) was irrelevant to this discussion, sorry bout that.

38 itellu3times  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:43:15am

re: #26 MandyManners

I understand that, but there's really nothing for that many Russian tanks to *do*, and they are big, heavy, nasty, expensive things to lug around.

Unless they're going to send an armored column 100 miles to the Georgian capital Tbilisi, like Hungary 1956, lite.

39 ibmkeyboard  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:43:30am

re: #25 pingjockey

Ah, so we should've left the Taliban and Saddam alone?!

NO
but how the hell are you supposed to tell another country not to attack someone else when you did the same thing?

Eh

40 HoosierHoops  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:43:36am

re: #23 MandyManners

But, when was it scheduled?

looks like yesterday..todays paper reported it..
HONOLULU - Hawaii-born presumptive Democratic presidential nominee Barack Obama hailed the aloha spirit and diversity of his native state, telling several thousand cheering supporters the nation as a whole is hungry for it.

Obama, who was born and raised in Honolulu, said yesterday at a rally that the aloha spirit meant helping those in need, taking care of one’s elders and treating people with respect. He said it also meant working with people of different backgrounds, whether they are black, white, Japanese-American, Filipino-American or any ethnicity.

41 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:43:36am

Looking more and more like the Cold War is on again.

All the more reason to keep BHO from the WH.

42 FrogMarch  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:43:36am

re: #5 MandyManners

They also helped Azerbaijan complete a railway.

Before they bombed it?

43 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:43:42am

From my No. 4, a look at the headlines.

Georgia Says Destroyed 40 Russian Tanks
Civil Georgia, Georgia - 32 minutes ago
The Georgian forces have destroyed 40 Russian tanks as they tried to attack the South Ossetian capital Tskhinvali from the north, the Georgian Interior ...
Upper Kodori Attacked
Civil Georgia, Georgia - 44 minutes ago
Abkhaz armed forces launched an operation to drive Georgian forces out of the upper Kodori Gorge, Reuters reported quoting Sergey Shamba, ...
Russia Confirms its Two Jets Downed
Civil Georgia, Georgia - 5 hours ago
Russian Ministry of Defense said that two of its warplanes – SU-25 and TU-22 – were downed over the South Ossetian conflict zone, the Russian media sources ...
Scores of Civilians Dead in Gori Bombing - Reports
Civil Georgia, Georgia - 5 hours ago
Scores of civilians are reported to be killed after the Russian warplanes bombed town of Gori close to breakaway South Ossetia this morning. ...
Georgia Controls Tskhinvali - Saakashvili Claims
Civil Georgia, Georgia - 5 hours ago
Up to 30 Georgians, mainly servicemen were killed, as a result of heavy fights and air strikes carried out by the Russia warplanes on August 8, ...
Strategic Targets Bombed Across Georgia
Civil Georgia, Georgia - 12 hours ago
Russian aircraft dropped bombs in number of strategic places across Georgia late on August 8, including military base in Senaki and port of Poti, ...
Russian Troops Intervened in S.Ossetia - Russia Official
Civil Georgia, Georgia - 12 hours ago
Units of the Russian 58th Army were deployed in outskirts of Tskhinvali “to suppress” the Georgian forces’ firing positions, an aide to commander of the ...
Medvedev: Russia will Protect its Citizens in S.Ossetia
Daily Georgian Times, Georgia - 21 hours ago
Russia will protect its citizens wherever they are and punish the perpetrators, President Medvedev said on August 8, while commenting on the situation in

[Link: www.aboutgeorgia.net...]

44 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:43:43am

re: #19 pingjockey

Georgia has 2000 troops in Iraq. Are we gonna help them?

The fact that the Russian state retains and has worked to replace components of the old nuclear arsenal of the Soviet Union severely limits the options of any nation that wants to intervene on behalf of the Georgians. Some of those missiles still work.

45 Wyatt Earp  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:43:44am

And Putin said Bush was evil for invading Iraq. Medvedev is being portrayed as a hero for invading Georgia. Interesting.

46 nigella  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:43:50am

Mandy, if I'm not wrong, didn't he pretty set himself up as ruler for life? Has a puppet leader to cover for him?

47 Occasional Reader  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:44:00am

Abkhazia also taking advantage to open a second front.

48 talkradiobug  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:44:15am

The MSM has not exactly been overboard about this story.

Last night on TV every "news" program was dwelling in the Edwards affair. Even the Olympics have been overshadowed by the Edwards story.

49 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:44:16am

re: #34 pingjockey

I think Putin has visions of reassembling the Russian Empire, with himself as Czar. No communists, just a good old fashioned dictatorship.

You can take the boy out of the KGB but, you can't take the KGB out of the boy.

50 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:44:31am

re: #47 Occasional Reader

Abkhazia also taking advantage to open a second front.

Yep.

51 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:44:31am

re: #20 itellu3times

I doubt they sent hundreds of tanks. Hundreds of vehicles, couple dozen tanks, the rest miscellaneous armor and transport. How many tanks does Georgia have, likely zero?

200 according to Wikipedia. I looked it up last night.

52 akak  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:44:33am

Can we talk about this?

53 E.T.  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:44:57am

Does anyone know if Georgia has any of the left-over nukes from the USSR days ?

54 HoosierHoops  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:45:49am

re: #53 E.T.

Does anyone know if Georgia has any of the left-over nukes from the USSR days ?

don't go there...

55 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:45:53am

re: #28 MandyManners

It's all about Russian colonialism and oil.

And where are the moonbat protesters?

56 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:45:58am

re: #39 ibmkeyboard
I see. I didn't know Georgia was putting people into shredders, flying planes into buildings and invading its neighbors. Glad you cleared that up.

57 ibmkeyboard  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:45:58am

re: #53 E.T.

Does anyone know if Georgia has any of the left-over nukes from the USSR days ?

Welcome to a whole new ball game if they do.

58 nigella  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:46:00am

PIMF pretty much.

59 dmandman  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:46:09am

Does anyone know what the Black Sea fleet is doing?

60 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:46:15am

re: #38 itellu3times

I understand that, but there's really nothing for that many Russian tanks to *do*, and they are big, heavy, nasty, expensive things to lug around.

Unless they're going to send an armored column 100 miles to the Georgian capital Tbilisi, like Hungary 1956, lite.

It is a hilly country, with the Caucasus Mountains to the north.

61 ibmkeyboard  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:47:00am

re: #56 pingjockey

I see. I didn't know Georgia was putting people into shredders, flying planes into buildings and invading its neighbors. Glad you cleared that up.

Stalin killed 50 million Russians

When did we invade Russia

smart ass.

62 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:47:03am

re: #42 FrogMarch

Before they bombed it?

I don't see where Russia has bombed the Azerbaijan rail system.

63 republic  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:47:23am

re: #45 Wyatt Earp

And Putin said Bush was evil for invading Iraq. Medvedev is being portrayed as a hero for invading Georgia. Interesting.

The only reason, factual reason, that Putin was upset with GWB about Iraq, is that it interfered greatly in the billions that Putin was scamming from the "Oil For Food" scam.

64 Occasional Reader  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:47:25am

re: #53 E.T.

Does anyone know if Georgia has any of the left-over nukes from the USSR days ?

I believe all the ex USSR nuke were consolidated in Russia.

65 willowone  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:47:30am

re: #52 akak some tea, arugula and some hope might change this.

66 jaunte  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:47:36am

From the Telegraph:
Georgia v Russia: By numbers
(Georgia is the smaller number in each category)

Population
4.6 million
140 million
Army
18,000
400,000
Tanks
128
23,000
Fighter jets
9
1,736

[Link: www.telegraph.co.uk...]

67 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:47:50am

re: #61 ibmkeyboard
Why, thank you.

68 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:48:17am

re: #18 MandyManners

I think that one describes the situation pretty damn well.

69 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:48:20am

re: #64 Occasional Reader

I believe all the ex USSR nuke were consolidated in Russia.

That's my recollections, when the Russians pulled out they took the nucs with them.

70 kansas  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:48:22am

Well, you all are going to hate this, but some years ago in this country some of it tried to form into a separate country. I'm pretty sure the Great Emancipator kicked the living shit out of them.

71 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:48:25am

re: #59 dmandman
Rusting at the pier.

72 DoubleU  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:49:13am

re: #41 jcm

Looking more and more like the Cold War is on again.

It never stopped.

We were just fooled into a false sense of security. Khrushchev might have been correct with his "We will crush you" quote. The communist just needed to try a better tactic.
"Communism is enslavement by force.
Socialism is enslavement by vote."

73 dmandman  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:49:36am

re: #71 pingjockey

Just afraid they were deployed and approaching the straights.

74 kansas  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:49:44am

re: #72 DoubleU

It never stopped.

We were just fooled into a false sense of security. Khrushchev might have been correct with his "We will crush you" quote. The communist just needed to try a better tactic.
"Communism is enslavement by force.
Socialism is enslavement by vote."

Democracy is enslavement by taxation.

75 _RememberTonyC  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:49:45am

Ralph Peters has a good piece about this situation in the NY Post today. He said the Russians may not realize how difficult this war against the Georgians might be.

76 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:49:57am

re: #53 E.T.

Does anyone know if Georgia has any of the left-over nukes from the USSR days ?

No. All former Soviet nukes were returned to the Russian state.

77 ibmkeyboard  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:50:47am

re: #67 pingjockey

Why, thank you.

50 million people died under Stalins rule

3 American presidents and
America did jack shit.

don't teach me history lessons.


/its a whole new ball game now.

78 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:50:49am

re: #70 kansas
But the US was not an empire held together by fear. It also doesn't cover half a continent and 12 time zones and 100 languages.

79 Eric Cartman's Conscience  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:50:49am

I don't pretend to know the dynamics of the situation in this part of "Asia". But don't the Ossetians prefer Russia to Georgia. Or if nothing else desire an independent state? I thought the Ossetia region was at war with Georgia for many years before breaking away in '91/'92 to form their own state and identity. Most of them hold Russian citizenship. Obviously, if Texans decided to break away from the USA, we might convince them through various means (how's that for doublespeak), not to secede. But I don't think this is as cut and dry as we might think. Russia is again the rising, if doddering, bear. But this seems more complex than us vs. them.

80 willowone  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:50:53am

did we ever put defense, or patriots into Georgia? i know it was under argument

81 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:50:57am

Azerbaijan? I meant Abkhazia.

[Link: news.yahoo.com...]

82 DoubleU  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:51:28am

re: #74 kansas

Democracy is when man takes advantage of man, with communism it is the other way around.

83 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:51:37am

re: #59 dmandman

Does anyone know what the Black Sea fleet is doing?

How much of it is left?

84 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:51:46am

re: #74 kansas

Democracy is enslavement by taxation.

Which is why we need to restore the Representative Republic.

85 kansas  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:52:14am

re: #78 pingjockey

But the US was not an empire held together by fear. It also doesn't cover half a continent and 12 time zones and 100 languages.

Obviously it was held to together by force. I'm pretty sure while Sherman was looting and pillaging there was a little fear.

86 lori lane  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:52:49am

re: #40 HoosierHoops

"taking care of one’s elders and treating people with respect."

...except your typical white grannie under the bus.

87 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:52:57am

re: #59 dmandman

Does anyone know what the Black Sea fleet is doing?

Good question.

If it wasn't rusting away at the dock it would be parked off the Georgian coast blocking all maritime traffic. They would presumably have orders to prosecute to kill any Georgian naval unit that came out to challenge them.

88 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:53:00am

re: #77 ibmkeyboard
We also didn't inade China, Cuba, finish off N. Korea, or E. Germany, or Libya, Nicauragua.

89 FrogMarch  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:53:23am

The left's response: But.. but.. but.. - The US invaded Iraq. (because they are the most predictably boring historically blind)
in
3...2...1

90 David IV of Georgia  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:53:34am

As for the MSM news repeatedly calling Georgia a "former Soviet republic", I would ask them to look a little deeper in the history books: It was a "former independent monarchy" for over a thousand years before the the Soviets ruled diddly squat. It existed as a Christian monarchy hundreds of years before there was a Moscow or a Kievian Rus. It existed when France wasn't French and the British weren't Angles. It used to be an ally of the Roman Empire.

91 Glackinspeil  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:54:01am

This is payback for Kosovo.
Georgias's president can't survive.
Putin will install a supporter

92 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:54:13am

re: #61 ibmkeyboard

Stalin killed 50 million Russians

When did we invade Russia

smart ass.

And Stalin did it the old fashioned way, he shot them, starved them, and worked them to death.

93 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:54:17am

re: #75 _RememberTonyC

Ralph Peters has a good piece about this situation in the NY Post today. He said the Russians may not realize how difficult this war against the Georgians might be.

I dated a Georgian paratrooper in Denver for a while. Tougher than nails.

94 HoosierHoops  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:54:29am

re: #86 lori lane

...except your typical white grannie under the bus.

LOL
so true Lori..how are you today?

95 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:55:28am

re: #79 Eric Cartman's Conscience

I don't pretend to know the dynamics of the situation in this part of "Asia". But don't the Ossetians prefer Russia to Georgia. Or if nothing else desire an independent state? I thought the Ossetia region was at war with Georgia for many years before breaking away in '91/'92 to form their own state and identity. Most of them hold Russian citizenship. Obviously, if Texans decided to break away from the USA, we might convince them through various means (how's that for doublespeak), not to secede. But I don't think this is as cut and dry as we might think. Russia is again the rising, if doddering, bear. But this seems more complex than us vs. them.

That may be true. If so, why doesn't Russia let Chechnya establish its own nation?

96 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:55:35am

re: #87 The Other Les
I don't really know how good Russias' Black Sea fleet is. After the Sovs went down the crapper their whole military just rusted in place. That said I doubt Georgia has much of a navy at all.

97 _RememberTonyC  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:55:45am

re #75 (from the Ralph peters article I mentioned):

This is a fight between a very small David and a very large Goliath. That said, the Russians may be surprised at how fiercely the Georgians defend their homeland. At least two, and possibly four, Russian jets have been shot down while attacking Georgian bases close to the capital city, Tbilisi.

As of last night, the Georgians had retaken Tskhinvali, South Ossetia's capital. I'd bet American veterans helped Georgia with contingency planning for just such a situation (it worked in Bosnia).

Meanwhile, hundreds of civilians and dozens of militiamen, Kremlin-funded mercenaries and Russian "peacekeepers" have been killed, along with tens of Georgian troops. This fighting is serious. And, unless Moscow pulls out all the stops, its forces just might take a surprise beating.

98 willowone  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:56:12am

re: #86 lori lane
and his campaign tossing out "mccain is to old and infirm to be Potus/

99 wiffersnapper  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:56:19am

I really hope they don't try to send in the UN to sort this out.

100 Nevergiveup  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:56:25am

re: #91 Glackinspeil

This is payback for Kosovo.
Georgias's president can't survive.
Putin will install a supporter

Georgia will stay more or less independent but without those break away minority republics that want to secede and also much more deferential to Moscow.

101 republic  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:56:30am

re: #86 lori lane

...except your typical white grannie under the bus.


Or the 500 and some unit "low income housing" project that Obama singlehandidly created near Chicago using Federal and State tax dollars, which is now, basicly, uninhabitable.

Trashed beyond repair.

Leftists can only be judged by their "intentions", never their actions, or outcomes.

Obama is the true defenition of, empty suit.

102 kynna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:56:38am

This conflict gives me chills. The utter lack of discretion in the fighting seems so bizarre but it goes to show once again that only the US and a handful of Western allies give a rats behind about honor.

And no, I'm not talking about the egregious rules of engagement our troops suffer under. I'm talking about our military's basic humanity and care for others.

Perhaps congress should be forced to watch the atrocities that occur when Russia puts on a war. Maybe they'd let up a little on our heroes.

Nah. I don't really think that would happen.

103 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:57:38am

The Prez of Gergia on CNN now!

104 wiffersnapper  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:57:43am

re: #101 republic

As the South Park quote says: "The ends justify the means" (My Future Self 'n' me)

105 itellu3times  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:57:48am

Tanks are too vulnerable now to truck, copter, even shoulder-launced missiles. Thought I saw a video of Russian tank, looked to be drapped with reactive armor, but even so. Well, if all reports keep saying tanks, maybe they're tanks.

106 republic  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:57:55am

re: #93 MandyManners

I dated a Georgian paratrooper in Denver for a while. Tougher than nails.


I dated a farm girl from Wisconsin years go. Tougher than nails.

:)

107 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:59:00am

re: #90 David IV of Georgia

As for the MSM news repeatedly calling Georgia a "former Soviet republic", I would ask them to look a little deeper in the history books: It was a "former independent monarchy" for over a thousand years before the the Soviets ruled diddly squat. It existed as a Christian monarchy hundreds of years before there was a Moscow or a Kievian Rus. It existed when France wasn't French and the British weren't Angles. It used to be an ally of the Roman Empire.

More on their history.

[Link: www.aboutgeorgia.net...]

108 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:59:07am

Asshole on cnn interrupting the prez with soviet talking points.

109 lori lane  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:59:14am

re: #94 HoosierHoops

hi {HH}. doing great. watched most of the Womens' Volleyball. but stepped away from the tv and have no idea of the final outcome. do you know? how are things going poolside?

110 Nevergiveup  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:59:20am

I am now watching womens weight lifting. For some reason it just doesn't appeal to me as much as women's gymnastics. I guess that makes me a sexist bastard?

111 republic  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:59:24am

re: #102 kynna

This conflict gives me chills. The utter lack of discretion in the fighting seems so bizarre but it goes to show once again that only the US and a handful of Western allies give a rats behind about honor.

And no, I'm not talking about the egregious rules of engagement our troops suffer under. I'm talking about our military's basic humanity and care for others.

Perhaps congress should be forced to watch the atrocities that occur when Russia puts on a war. Maybe they'd let up a little on our heroes.

Nah. I don't really think that would happen.

Russia/communism are the "heroes" of much of Congress.

112 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 8:59:53am

re: #90 David IV of Georgia

As for the MSM news repeatedly calling Georgia a "former Soviet republic", I would ask them to look a little deeper in the history books: It was a "former independent monarchy" for over a thousand years before the the Soviets ruled diddly squat. It existed as a Christian monarchy hundreds of years before there was a Moscow or a Kievian Rus. It existed when France wasn't French and the British weren't Angles. It used to be an ally of the Roman Empire.

Asking the MSM to look a little deeper is like asking for a pig to fly.

113 Quilly Mammoth  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:00:00am

re: #38 itellu3times

I understand that, but there's really nothing for that many Russian tanks to *do*, and they are big, heavy, nasty, expensive things to lug around.

Unless they're going to send an armored column 100 miles to the Georgian capital Tbilisi, like Hungary 1956, lite.

The pictures shown on the bbc last night were actually self propelled howitzers and scout vehicles. SO probably an infantry regiment. I didn't see a single T72 or T90. IIRC Russia only has 1200 T90 in inventory. Georgia isn;t reall good tank terrain and it _very good_ anti-tank terrain. Which leads to an invasion from Abhakzi. Which I beleeive will happen shortly since it appears that they are acting up today.

114 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:00:07am

re: #103 pingjockey

The Prez of Gergia on CNN now!

115 BlueCanuck  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:00:12am

re: #105 itellu3times

The liveleak video I saw said tanks, but they looked more like troop carriers and mobile artillery than tanks to me.

116 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:00:23am

re: #108 pingjockey

Asshole on cnn interrupting the prez with soviet talking points.

Asshole on CNN....
redundant phraseology.

117 Glackinspeil  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:00:27am

re: #100 Nevergiveup

Agreed, but I don't think GA's pres. can survive national humiliation.

118 willowone  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:00:35am

sheesh they are blam8ing the georgians

119 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:00:38am

re: #108 pingjockey

Asshole on cnn interrupting the prez with soviet talking points.

Good grief. I'm watching this shit. Unfuckingbelievable.

120 wiffersnapper  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:01:08am

fuck cnn

121 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:01:21am

re: #116 jcm
Well, if the fhoe shits!

122 opinionated  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:01:26am

If the Israeli Government had any sense at all, it would take the opportunity to enter Gaza and match the Russians in the number of dead Hamas.

123 republic  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:01:27am

re: #115 BlueCanuck

The liveleak video I saw said tanks, but they looked more like troop carriers and mobile artillery than tanks to me.


The msm doesn't know the difference between a tank and a H3 Hummer.

124 tradewind  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:01:31am

WTF?
Someone please tell me what is going on..... is Russia pulling a Czech thing, or is the Georgian president lying?
Sounds a lot like what we used to read in history classes started a world war.

125 Nevergiveup  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:01:44am

re: #114 MandyManners

The asshole on CNN just accused the Georgia President of shooting down Soviet planes as if that is wrong when they are bombing your country?

126 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:01:44am

Saakashvili seems to be standing up pretty well to Putin's mouth on CNN.

127 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:02:05am

Who is that fuckhead on CNN?

128 Eric Cartman's Conscience  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:02:24am

#95 et al;

I'm no sympathizer for Russia. But Georgia and Russia have been running smack back and forth for a few years now. I just hope Georgia can back up her smack. Unfortunately, if a few Russian jets can indiscriminately bomb three of your air bases perhaps one should temper ones smack. News reports claim Georgia moved on Ossetia first. If true, they should have expected and been prepared for a Russian response. The head of Georgia made a campaign promise to reclaim Ossetia and seemed to choose the Olympic games, with Putin out of town, for his opening gambit. But, man, Russians dominate at chess. This seems a folly brought on by the Georgians at a time we need no folly.


As for the left's response - they are so f*cked up in the head that not only with they immediately utter "Iraq", but they'll now "question the timing" of Georgia's move. They'll somehow insist, Georgia, as our ally, made this move to destabilize a region and help McCain. They'll probably go so far as to think Putin was in on it.

129 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:02:25am

re: #125 Nevergiveup

The asshole on CNN just accused the Georgia President of shooting down Soviet planes as if that is wrong when they are bombing your country?

YOU SUCK, CNN.

130 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:02:26am

re: #115 BlueCanuck

The liveleak video I saw said tanks, but they looked more like troop carriers and mobile artillery than tanks to me.

Russian doctrine is artillery heavy, bludgeon your opponent.

131 tradewind  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:02:30am

Dammit, the prez should let Fox get an interview on the air.....

132 ibmkeyboard  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:02:37am

re: #88 pingjockey

We also didn't invade China, Cuba, finish off N. Korea, or E. Germany, or Libya, Nicaragua.

I agree.

but we cant tell another nation they cant attack if they feel threatened.

I don't like the damn Russians. their weapons killed friends of mine.

but they invaded Afghan territory,
let them get their asses kicked again.

133 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:02:44am

re: #127 MandyManners
He's got Putins talking points down pat.

134 jaunte  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:02:47am

Bush saw this coming. When Georgia was denied NATO membership at the last summit, there was an obvious window opened for Russian action.
[Link: findarticles.com...]

135 Nevergiveup  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:02:53am

re: #127 MandyManners

Who is that fuckhead on CNN?

Obvioulsy an Obama think a like!

136 willowone  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:02:56am

re: #127 MandyManners

it's maddening!

137 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:03:03am

re: #121 pingjockey

Well, if the fhoe shits!

LOL!

How's things on the dry side.
Bit damp on this side.

138 republic  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:03:11am

re: #125 Nevergiveup

The asshole on CNN just accused the Georgia President of shooting down Soviet planes as if that is wrong when they are bombing your country?


The left loves communism, which is why 99% of the msm is already leftist state run media.

139 dmandman  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:03:23am

re: #102 kynna

That's why I made the comment about "revenge" diaries earlier. Look up how Stalin got his troops revved up during WWII against the Germans. A political officer monitored those (mandatory) entries to insure the troops were sufficiently motivated for revenge. If an entry was deemed too mild it was noted and commented upon (implication of better use in Penal Battalion perhaps?). The troops knew they had to deliver on the "Revenge" also which contributed to the rape statistics that were later compiled against the German women.

140 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:03:32am

re: #124 tradewind

See #18, i think that explains it all.

141 HoosierHoops  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:03:33am

re: #109 lori lane

hi {HH}. doing great. watched most of the Womens' Volleyball. but stepped away from the tv and have no idea of the final outcome. do you know? how are things going poolside?

that's great lori!
the kids have taken over the big screen playing some crazy new video game..I'm heading out to the backyard and going to work on my tan
in about 30 minutes..
did you watch the olympic opening last night?
I was very impressed..somebody on ESPN said today the brits are nervous now.. how do you top that?

142 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:03:51am

re: #119 MandyManners

Good grief. I'm watching this shit. Unfuckingbelievable.

CNN has always been pro-Soviet. It should be no surprise that they are supporting the heirs of Stalin.

143 Eric Cartman's Conscience  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:03:57am

#110 nevergiveup

no, that makes you a pedophile! :) Just kidding! A joke...a joke...

144 David IV of Georgia  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:03:58am

re: #112 jcm

Asking the MSM to look a little deeper is like asking for a pig to fly.

I beg to differ. I expect there is a far greater likelihood of my seeing a pig fly. I guess Fluff Journalism 101 class didn't teach them to consider anything they haven't seen on ABC, CBS or NBC (preferably on sitcoms).

145 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:04:19am

re: #132 ibmkeyboard
Ok. Now I see where you're coming from. Guess I misread/obtuse.
Putin thinks he's gonna be the next Czar.

146 republic  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:04:19am

re: #130 jcm

Russian doctrine is artillery heavy, bludgeon your opponent.

Russian doctrine is,

"if you come back this way you will be shot and killed."

147 medaura18586  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:04:26am

There are plenty of folks on our side who are cheering for the Russians on this one.

148 FrogMarch  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:04:43am

re: #127 MandyManners

Who is that fuckhead on CNN?

eee. he is a fuckhead.

149 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:04:59am

re: #137 jcm
Us too. Luckily we got some rain to go with the lightening.

150 Nevergiveup  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:05:20am

re: #147 medaura18586

There are plenty of folks on our side who are cheering for the Russians on this one.

Who?

151 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:05:24am

re: #128 Eric Cartman's Conscience

#95 et al;

I'm no sympathizer for Russia. But Georgia and Russia have been running smack back and forth for a few years now. I just hope Georgia can back up her smack. Unfortunately, if a few Russian jets can indiscriminately bomb three of your air bases perhaps one should temper ones smack. News reports claim Georgia moved on Ossetia first. If true, they should have expected and been prepared for a Russian response. The head of Georgia made a campaign promise to reclaim Ossetia and seemed to choose the Olympic games, with Putin out of town, for his opening gambit. But, man, Russians dominate at chess. This seems a folly brought on by the Georgians at a time we need no folly.


As for the left's response - they are so f*cked up in the head that not only with they immediately utter "Iraq", but they'll now "question the timing" of Georgia's move. They'll somehow insist, Georgia, as our ally, made this move to destabilize a region and help McCain. They'll probably go so far as to think Putin was in on it.

Abkhazia Claims Shootdown of 2 Georgian Spy Drones
By VOA News
04 May 2008

Pro-Russian separatists in Georgia's Abkhazia region say they have shot down two Georgian spy drones over the breakaway region Sunday. However, Georgia has denied launching any flights in the area.

The claim and denial come two weeks after a Georgian drone was downed in the same area, heightening already-strained relations between Russia and Georgia.

SNIP

152 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:06:10am

re: #133 pingjockey

He's got Putins talking points down pat.

Saakashvili is talking right over him.

153 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:06:36am

re: #144 David IV of Georgia

I beg to differ. I expect there is a far greater likelihood of my seeing a pig fly. I guess Fluff Journalism 101 class didn't teach them to consider anything they haven't seen on ABC, CBS or NBC (preferably on sitcoms).

LOL! I stand corrected!
Journos are too lazy do basic fact and history checks.

154 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:06:37am

re: #150 Nevergiveup
The msm springs to mind.

155 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:06:53am

re: #147 medaura18586

There are plenty of folks on our side who are cheering for the Russians on this one.

Put up or shut up.

156 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:07:21am

re: #154 pingjockey

The msm springs to mind.


Those aren't our people.

157 bill-tb  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:07:32am

Democrat friendlies have nothing to worry about ... bomb away.

Isn't bombing civilians a war crime, or do they have to have panties on their heads first for it to be an official war crime?

Anyone know where Amnesty international is? Probably working on the Bush Democrat's impeachment team. Reality has a way of intruding on liberal fantasies.

158 ibmkeyboard  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:07:34am

re: #92 The Other Les

And Stalin did it the old fashioned way, he shot them, starved them, and worked them to death.

agree

159 lori lane  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:07:41am

re: #141 HoosierHoops


did you watch the olympic opening last night?

yes, i watched it...until i fell asleep. :) i'll watch the rest of it this weekend, hopefully. :)

somebody on ESPN said today the brits are nervous now.. how do you top that?

this morning i bought the friday edition of USA TODAY to get more familiarized with everything. what are they nervous about? :)

160 Quilly Mammoth  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:07:49am

re: #115 BlueCanuck

The liveleak video I saw said tanks, but they looked more like troop carriers and mobile artillery than tanks to me.

Exactly right. The question is how much training have the Georgians done with AT weapons, and when will Russia get T90's there. Infantry deployed AT hunter teams will have a field day until the T90s get there if they have any sort of decent training.

161 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:07:50am

re: #156 MandyManners
That is true. My bad.

162 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:07:54am

re: #125 Nevergiveup

The asshole on CNN just accused the Georgia President of shooting down Soviet planes as if that is wrong when they are bombing your country?

Our Mainstream Communist press is taking advantage of the fact that we are traditionally adverse to forcible censorship in the American Republic. If those idiots keep it up we're may see that aversion disappear amougst many of our citizens.

163 FrogMarch  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:07:58am

CNN fuckhead says: ... (I paraphrase) 'We don'd care about your people - what about he Americans who are there? - what about your troops in Iraq?"

seriously - he is a fuckhead.

164 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:08:55am

From the VOA link I posted above.

Moscow also contends the April 20 Georgian drone flight violated a 1994 international ceasefire agreement for Abkhazia. That pact permitted Russian peacekeepers in both Abkhazia and South Ossetia.

Moscow has drawn international criticism for bolstering its military presence in the two Georgian regions. Moscow calls its move a response to a Georgian troop buildup near the breakaway regions.

Abkhazia and South Ossetia declared independence from Georgia in the early 1990s, sparking fighting and the dispatch of Russian peacekeepers. Many residents in the regions hold Russian passports. Georgia says the peacekeepers side with the separatists, and has pledged to bring both regions back under central government control.

165 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:09:19am

Putin is down there somewhere. Maybe a stray bomb will scare his ass.

166 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:09:25am

Sakki's a cutie.

167 David IV of Georgia  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:09:30am

re: #153 jcm

LOL! I stand corrected!
Journos are too lazy do basic fact and history checks.

It would be nice if they would just check Wikipedia, the unimpeachable source of all truth [citation needed].

168 CyanSnowHawk  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:09:33am

re: #48 talkradiobug

The MSM has not exactly been overboard about this story.

Last night on TV every "news" program was dwelling in the Edwards affair. Even the Olympics have been overshadowed by the Edwards story.

The Olympics? Don't you mean the spotlight on China's human rights record/abuses that the coverage has turned into? I haven't heard word one about an Olympic competition yet. Not likely too either, I'm not watching it this time, except maybe some TaeKwonDo since my Son might be interested.

169 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:09:48am

re: #128 Eric Cartman's Conscience

The Russian state needs to be put down. The problem is that it would require nukes and that they can respond in kind.

170 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:09:54am

re: #165 pingjockey

Putin is down there somewhere. Maybe a stray bomb will scare his ass.

Why?! Is he trying to show the world that he has a big, swinging dick?

171 Glackinspeil  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:09:59am

Just announced on cnn......
Georgia parliament has declared WAR.
Putin is in border area

172 HoosierHoops  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:10:05am

re: #159 lori lane

this morning i bought the friday edition of USA TODAY to get more familiarized with everything. what are they nervous about? :)

Well in 4 years the olympics are in London.. It will really be hard to top last nights show...
Costas last night said it was stunning..twice..it was really cool..

173 akak  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:10:12am

re: #151 MandyManners

Abkhazia Claims Shootdown of 2 Georgian Spy Drones
By VOA News
04 May 2008

Pro-Russian separatists in Georgia's Abkhazia region say they have shot down two Georgian spy drones over the breakaway region Sunday. However, Georgia has denied launching any flights in the area.

The claim and denial come two weeks after a Georgian drone was downed in the same area, heightening already-strained relations between Russia and Georgia.

SNIP

[Link: www.strategypage.com...]

174 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:10:23am

Gaaah! FNC leads off with silky pony BS.

175 tradewind  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:10:32am

Fox is on Edwards..... yech, enough already.

Send Silky to bed without supper and ignore him with an extended timeout.

176 ASU86PE  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:10:54am

Russia is following their natural sense of justice; kill and blame the West.

177 lori lane  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:11:17am

re: #175 tradewind


Send Silky to bed without supper and ignore him with an extended timeout.

*spanks Johnny* bad bad boy!

178 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:11:38am

re: #139 dmandman

That's why I made the comment about "revenge" diaries earlier. Look up how Stalin got his troops revved up during WWII against the Germans. A political officer monitored those (mandatory) entries to insure the troops were sufficiently motivated for revenge. If an entry was deemed too mild it was noted and commented upon (implication of better use in Penal Battalion perhaps?). The troops knew they had to deliver on the "Revenge" also which contributed to the rape statistics that were later compiled against the German women.

I never read about that. But gosh that's not a surprise.

179 tradewind  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:11:40am

re: #159 lori lane

The Brits scould start by not building the World's Largest Mosque in the same area as their Olympic stadium.......

180 medaura18586  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:11:43am

re: #150 Nevergiveup

Who?

One of my favorites, Rusty:
"Russia Invades Georgia: When 2 Natural Allies go to War"
[Link: mypetjawa.mu.nu...]

No, he definitely isn't "cheering" for Russia -- but he admits he is torn on this one. I'm sure there are more similar sentiments out there.

I'd like to see what Robert Spencer and James Jatras have to say about this. Nothing about it on Jihad Watch at this time.

181 republic  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:11:46am

I am so very thankful that I don't ever watch, CNN, NBC, ABC, CBS, MSLSD, etc.

My life is much more full and enjoyable, by never, ever watching that crap.

182 itellu3times  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:12:05am

re: #147 medaura18586

There are plenty of folks on our side who are cheering for the Russians on this one.

What you mean "our side", kimosabe?

183 HoosierHoops  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:12:06am

re: #171 Glackinspeil

Just announced on cnn......
Georgia parliament has declared WAR.
Putin is in border area

He was in China yesterday..those dictators sure know how to get around

184 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:12:20am
185 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:13:06am

Haven't heard a peep from the euroweenies.

186 Nevergiveup  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:13:17am

re: #163 FrogMarch

CNN fuckhead says: ... (I paraphrase) 'We don'd care about your people - what about he Americans who are there? - what about your troops in Iraq?"

seriously - he is a fuckhead.

Right. Instead of thanking him for his countries past support for our efforts in Iraq and showing any concern for the massacre of his citizens, the asshat feigned concern for American citizens. As if he really gives a shit about America or Americans. After all the MSM is not suppose to show any favoritism towards the good old US of A!

187 itellu3times  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:13:33am

US sweeps women's sabre

Just as soon as they pick up their team medals, send them to Georgia, I think they can clean up this little mess!

/I wish

Congrats to them in any case!

188 tradewind  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:13:49am

re: #184 MandyManners

Damn. I wonder what Dubya sees now when he looks into those eyes?

189 Nevergiveup  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:13:53am

re: #165 pingjockey

Putin is down there somewhere. Maybe a stray bomb will scare his ass.

I thought he is in Peking?

190 HoosierHoops  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:14:03am

re: #184 MandyManners

Putin.

I can't look into his eyes and see his soul..
/damn sunglasses

191 Eric Cartman's Conscience  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:14:05am

About the CNN correspondent - he's a rising star at CNN and just celebrated his 30th birthday a few months back - on air. They love this guy. The point is, he's 30. So, you can imagine the indoctrination, as a young black man in America, this man went through over the past twenty-five years. He never had a chance but to think like an automaton.

192 Occasional Reader  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:14:05am

re: #170 MandyManners

Why?! Is he trying to show the world that he has a big, swinging dick?

He likes to watch.

193 Glackinspeil  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:14:06am

re: #184 MandyManners

Putin.

Looks like Damien's father from one of the Omen movies.

194 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:14:11am
195 lori lane  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:14:13am

re: #172 HoosierHoops

oh oh. i can't believe i didn't know that. we were watching the beginning of it at Nick's last night. the beginning looked amazing with all of those drums. can't wait to actually hear it. :)

i was telling my daughter yesterday that long long ago in a faraway time, both the summer & winter Olympics were held in the same year, but I can't remember when that changed. i'll google it unless someone has the answer now. :)

196 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:14:28am

re: #170 MandyManners

Why?! Is he trying to show the world that he has a big, swinging dick?

I think that's a big part of his political career, that and knocking off opponents.

197 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:14:39am

re: #189 Nevergiveup
CNN said he was down by the border now.

198 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:15:18am

re: #188 tradewind

Damn. I wonder what Dubya sees now when he looks into those eyes?

From the Dead Thread. What Sen. McCain saw when he looked into Putin's eyes.

199 ibmkeyboard  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:15:38am

re: #145 pingjockey

Ok. Now I see where you're coming from. Guess I misread/obtuse.
Putin thinks he's gonna be the next Czar.

The terrorists will be on his ass like flies on honey.

and unless he forgets,
he is closer to these fanatics than we are.

remember the 300 school children?

200 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:15:46am

re: #190 HoosierHoops

I can't look into his eyes and see his soul..
/damn sunglasses

I can see it just fine. He's looking over them.

201 FrogMarch  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:15:56am

re: #186 Nevergiveup

Right. Instead of thanking him for his countries past support for our efforts in Iraq and showing any concern for the massacre of his citizens, the asshat feigned concern for American citizens. As if he really gives a shit about America or Americans. After all the MSM is not suppose to show any favoritism towards the good old US of A!

I suspect that any country willing to commit troops to Iraq is also on CNN's shit list.

202 nigella  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:16:10am

Pingjockey, Probably haven't heard from the euroweenies because they are shitting their pants about now. This stuff is a little too close to home for them,

203 itellu3times  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:16:14am

re: #115 BlueCanuck

The liveleak video I saw said tanks, but they looked more like troop carriers and mobile artillery than tanks to me.

That's what I'd expect.

204 Nevergiveup  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:16:21am

re: #191 Eric Cartman's Conscience

About the CNN correspondent - he's a rising star at CNN and just celebrated his 30th birthday a few months back - on air. They love this guy. The point is, he's 30. So, you can imagine the indoctrination, as a young black man in America, this man went through over the past twenty-five years. He never had a chance but to think like an automaton.

Who are you talking about, Obama?

205 lori lane  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:16:25am

re: #199 ibmkeyboard


remember the 300 school children?

yes. horrified by it. never want to see anything like that again.

206 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:16:36am

re: #184 MandyManners

Putin.

Someone should do an animated .GIF of his eyes turning to a glowing red color.

207 FrogMarch  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:17:04am

re: #198 MandyManners

From the Dead Thread. What Sen. McCain saw when he looked into Putin's eyes.

[Link: www.youtube.com...]

Makes me remember why I liked McCain so much back in 1999-2000.

208 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:17:11am

re: #199 ibmkeyboard
Is Beslan in that area?

209 JHW  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:17:17am

I don't know how reliable this source is, it's a leftist publication, ( Wiki says formed in part by friends of Noam Chomsky) but it claims there is a lot of Slavic vs. non-Slavic feeling in Russia and it claims that it has been exploited by Putin particularly against Georgia, with examples of actions taken against non-Slavs in Russia:

Meanwhile, the escalating campaign against Georgians is driving internal Russian politics down dark and uncharted avenues. “The Kremlin is appealing to Russian society’s nationalistic moods, and that’s very dangerous,” says Fyodor Lukyanov, editor of the foreign policy journal Russia in Global Affairs. “This kind of device is easy to use, but very hard to control.”


Ethnic Cleansing in Russia

210 Glackinspeil  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:17:44am

CNN ..... from video of Putin getting off plane at border.....to Bernie Mac coverage

211 Steffan  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:17:55am

re: #51 The Other Les

200 according to Wikipedia. I looked it up last night.

Strategypage has a few items of information also.

Most of what both sides have was inherited from the Soviet breakup. How it was maintained is open to question.

Putin had to be planning this to get any Russian troops there that quickly -- the Russian Army simply doesn't have the equipment or training to bring a reserve unit up to speed that quickly.

OTOH, the Georgians have had American training for the past few years. I'd think they could hold their own against mildly superior Russian forces. If the Russians get creative on the number of troops sent in, the outcome would be more debatable, but if the Russians are as cheap as I think Putin might be, they're about to have their heads handed to them.

Incidentally, the Russians have been hanging out in the two breakaway provinces, and have been giving the locals Russian passports. This is not a new thing. (Scroll down to the bottom on the link).

212 stevieray  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:18:14am

re: #180 medaura18586

I don't see much of a jihad connection to this. None of the three nations are Islamic, and I don't think the separatists are looking to become part of any caliphate. This isn't a Muslim vs. Other conflict.

213 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:18:25am

Putin.

[Link: www.iht.com...]

214 HoosierHoops  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:18:44am

re: #195 lori lane

oh oh. i can't believe i didn't know that. we were watching the beginning of it at Nick's last night. the beginning looked amazing with all of those drums. can't wait to actually hear it. :)

i was telling my daughter yesterday that long long ago in a faraway time, both the summer & winter Olympics were held in the same year, but I can't remember when that changed. i'll google it unless someone has the answer now. :)

The IOC votes to change the schedule of the Olympics. Starting in 1984, the Summer Games and Winter Games will take place two years apart from one another, rather than in the same year.

215 ibmkeyboard  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:19:03am

re: #182 itellu3times

What you mean "our side", kimosabe?

lol

216 tradewind  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:19:45am

Scary territory.... Turkey underneath them, all the 'zans to the right, between the Black Sea and Russia's Caspian......
no wonder they're worried....
[Link: www.worldatlas.com...]

217 Nevergiveup  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:20:28am

When Putin flew to the war zone, did he bring his puppy dog, I mean the President of Russia with him?

218 lori lane  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:21:02am

re: #214 HoosierHoops

thx HH. i think i liked it better when they were in the same year.

it's cloudy down here. do you have sunshine?

219 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:21:33am

re: #217 Nevergiveup

When Putin flew to the war zone, did he bring his puppy dog, I mean the President of Russia with him?

Why?

Is there a shortage of camp followers?

220 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:21:41am

re: #208 pingjockey

Is Beslan in that area?

It's in North Ossetia.

221 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:21:59am

re: #217 Nevergiveup
The prez of russia is being watched by some big beefy KGB types to make sure he says his lines right. Wouldn't want him to have an accident.

222 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:22:28am

re: #220 MandyManners
Dayum. BBIAW.

223 HoosierHoops  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:23:01am

re: #218 lori lane

thx HH. i think i liked it better when they were in the same year.

it's cloudy down here. do you have sunshine?

sort of overcast with the sun peeking out every so often...
bummer..i think it will clear up..hoping like heck

224 Eric Cartman's Conscience  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:23:27am

#204 Nevergiveup

You got it! Exactly!

225 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:23:38am

Home video of Russian equipment moving into Georgia.

APC's, tracked artillery, bridging units, trucks.

226 Tigger2005  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:23:50am

re: #39 ibmkeyboard

NO
but how the hell are you supposed to tell another country not to attack someone else when you did the same thing?

Eh

So the reasons don't matter?

Afghanistan harbored Bin Laden and the terror camps where 9/11 was planned. And this after we helped them defeat Soviet aggression. They refused to give Bin Laden up, which would have spared them an invasion.

Saddam Hussein attacked his neighbors, slaughtered (with poison gas among other things) and tortured his own people by the tens of thousands, was developing WMDs in defiance of numerous United Nations resolutions, and likely had ties to al-Qaeda. He was involved in an assassination attempt on a former American President.

What has Georgia done that establishes it as a threat to Russia proper or to its neighbors in general? It was dealing forcefully with an internal threat. Russia acts like Georgia itself is an "internal threat." It's only an internal threat if it's not a sovereign nation but part of the Russian Empire.

227 tradewind  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:24:04am

re: #182 itellu3times
The real Khemosabi.....remove your hat when you say that name...
[Link: www.exposureplus.com...]

228 Quilly Mammoth  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:24:13am

re: #211 Steffan

Putin had to be planning this to get any Russian troops there that quickly -- the Russian Army simply doesn't have the equipment or training to bring a reserve unit up to speed that quickly.

OTOH, the Georgians have had American training for the past few years. I'd think they could hold their own against mildly superior Russian forces. If the Russians get creative on the number of troops sent in, the outcome would be more debatable, but if the Russians are as cheap as I think Putin might be, they're about to have their heads handed to them.


I'll fully believe that when I see video of T90 tanks. Why the T90? Because in the terrain the fighting is currently in the Georgian anti-tank teams have standoff against everything in the Russian Inventory except the T90. That being said India, the largest producer of the T90, is slated to start a whole new tanks because fear that light AT missiles are progressing faster than they can up-armor the T90.

229 debutaunt  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:24:29am

re: #40 HoosierHoops

looks like yesterday..todays paper reported it..
HONOLULU - Hawaii-born presumptive Democratic presidential nominee Barack Obama hailed the aloha spirit and diversity of his native state, telling several thousand cheering supporters the nation as a whole is hungry for it.

Obama, who was born and raised in Honolulu, said yesterday at a rally that the aloha spirit meant helping those in need, taking care of one’s elders and treating people with respect. He said it also meant working with people of different backgrounds, whether they are black, white, Japanese-American, Filipino-American or any ethnicity.

HAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAA

230 Serge GoFan  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:24:32am

I'm watching enormous activity of Russian sleepers (and KGB-FSB officers?) throughout major western i-forums. Never seen anything like this since death of Litvinenko.
Charles, what are ISPs?

231 Nevergiveup  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:24:57am

re: #221 pingjockey

The prez of russia is being watched by some big beefy KGB types to make sure he says his lines right. Wouldn't want him to have an accident.

He's got one hella of a job, ha? I wonder how comfortable his office in the Lubyanka is?

232 tradewind  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:26:45am

re: #229 debutaunt

BOH is gonna go ballistic if they try to get him to eat a typical Island diet.... way too many fat grams for him. I hope someone forces him to a pig roast.

233 Steffan  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:27:05am

re: #59 dmandman

Does anyone know what the Black Sea fleet is doing?

Not a lot at the moment, but Putin is apparently trying to take the Crimea back from Ukraine.

Also:

Russia is also annoyed with joint military training exercises being held in the Black Sea, involving forces from Ukraine, NATO, America, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Georgia, Turkey, Macedonia and Latvia. The exercises cover, ground, naval and air operations. Russia has, for centuries, considered the Black Sea to be "Russian territory," and this "invasion" by "foreigners" has roused lots of nationalistic anger back in Russia.
234 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:27:19am

Georgian forum. [Link: www.georgia.lv...]

I cannot get the English version to load.

235 mpax  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:27:57am

Does anyone know of a blog or news site with up to the minute coverage of events?

236 bubbasbbq  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:28:01am

I think it is time to fast track Georgia into NATO ASAP if nothing else just to piss off that Puke Putin. il figlio di mille padri, tutti i maiali amano appena è translate that you Russian sow!

237 Marvo76  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:28:09am

re: #53 E.T.

Does anyone know if Georgia has any of the left-over nukes from the USSR days ?

I believe they were removed a few years back along with some (not all) from the Ukraine as part of the Nunn-Lugar effort to "protect" them from proliferation...

238 Nevergiveup  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:28:13am

re: #235 mpax

Does anyone know of a blog or news site with up to the minute coverage of events?

Your on it

239 Mars Needs Neocons  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:28:26am

Welcome the new Russia, same as the old Russia

I expect Marxist Obambi to become really good friends with Putin. This is another reason we can't allow this clown to become president.

240 Nemesis6  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:28:35am

I think you got this backwards... I have no doubt the Russians have been shelling, but the capital of South Ossetia, tzhinvali, was bombed by Georgian artillery. That's what I've heard.

241 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:29:32am

re: #225 jcm

Home video of Russian equipment moving into Georgia.

APC's, tracked artillery, bridging units, trucks.

A bunch of 152mm self propelled guns, some MLTB personnel carriers, and some tracked vehicles which may be antiaircraft missile launchers. (Can't tell with all that canvas covering it up.)

242 tradewind  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:29:36am

Deja Vu at pravda... it's all our fault....

[Link: english.pravda.ru...]

243 medaura18586  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:29:38am

re: #212 stevieray

I don't see much of a jihad connection to this. None of the three nations are Islamic, and I don't think the separatists are looking to become part of any caliphate. This isn't a Muslim vs. Other conflict.

Not that I think that, of course! Here is some basic background: [Link: www.cia.gov...]

Disputes - international:

Russia and Georgia agree on delimiting 80% of their common border, leaving certain small, strategic segments and the maritime boundary unresolved; OSCE observers monitor volatile areas such as the Pankisi Gorge in the Akhmeti region and the Argun Gorge in Abkhazia; UN Observer Mission in Georgia has maintained a peacekeeping force in Georgia since 1993; Meshkheti Turks scattered throughout the former Soviet Union seek to return to Georgia; boundary with Armenia remains undemarcated; ethnic Armenian groups in Javakheti region of Georgia seek greater autonomy from the Georgian government; Azerbaijan and Georgia continue to discuss the alignment of their boundary at certain crossing areas

There is barely a Russian minority in George (around 1.5% according to the CIA) so Russia has no credible excuse.

It looks to be all about oil, and Russia blew up their major pipeline: that was their first target. It's also about an affront to the USA... it's about Bush's political weakness now at the end of his last term, his inability to respond, and Putin affronting him directly at the Olympics (the timing of the attack is telling).

That of course, does not stop some people from calling Russia "our natural ally" against Islamism. The MSM is carrying the salt for Putin right now because his advances are bad for American power...

244 Nevergiveup  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:29:43am

Qassam rocket lands in western Negev, no injuries

[Link: www.ynetnews.com...]

Maybe Israel should pull a Putin!

245 stevieray  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:29:47am

Russia really rolled the dice on this one. They need to win this quickly, cleanly, and decisively to maintain any military credibility. If this turns into another miserable slog-fest like Afghanistan or Chechnya, the Russian military and arms industry will take a huge hit.

Georgia is tiny, the Russians know the terrain well, and it sits on their border... no excuses for the Red Army if things don't go smoothly.

246 David IV of Georgia  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:29:49am

re: #234 MandyManners

Georgian forum. [Link: www.georgia.lv...]

I cannot get the English version to load.

Georgian news servers have probably gotten more visits in the last 24 hours than they have for the rest of the year combined.

247 Eric Cartman's Conscience  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:29:59am

Someone mentioned earlier that the CNN guy said "we don't care about your people, what about Americans there". Was this (almost/mostly) verbatim? Or was there some embellishing going on with that post?

I ask because I did notice they seemed to usher the correspondent off the air after the interview. Did he really say that? If so a transcript is crucial. THAT could be a huge story. An American anchor saying "we don't care" or making any such subjective value judgement.

248 CyanSnowHawk  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:30:15am

re: #167 David IV of Georgia

It would be nice if they would just check Wikipedia, the unimpeachable source of all truth [citation needed].

Coke on the keyboard. Thanks David.

249 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:30:20am

re: #228 Quilly Mammoth

Putin had to be planning this to get any Russian troops there that quickly -- the Russian Army simply doesn't have the equipment or training to bring a reserve unit up to speed that quickly.

OTOH, the Georgians have had American training for the past few years. I'd think they could hold their own against mildly superior Russian forces. If the Russians get creative on the number of troops sent in, the outcome would be more debatable, but if the Russians are as cheap as I think Putin might be, they're about to have their heads handed to them.

I'll fully believe that when I see video of T90 tanks. Why the T90? Because in the terrain the fighting is currently in the Georgian anti-tank teams have standoff against everything in the Russian Inventory except the T90. That being said India, the largest producer of the T90, is slated to start a whole new tanks because fear that light AT missiles are progressing faster than they can up-armor the T90.

Russian soldiers were in Abkhazia until a week ago. How much you wanna' bet they've not really left?

SUKHUMI, Georgia (Reuters) - The last of 400 Russian soldiers sent by Moscow to repair a railway in Georgia's rebel region of Abkhazia began to pull out on Wednesday, ending a deployment which angered Tbilisi and its Western allies.

Loudspeakers played music from a brass band and children handed out flowers and Abkhazian flags to Russian soldiers at the opening ceremony of the 54 km (33 mile) railway line.

"It's certain that all the personnel and all the equipment will be sent away from here," the Russian commander, Lieutenant-General Sergei Klimets, told reporters after handing out medals to the soldiers

SNIP

250 Charles  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:30:20am

re: #240 Nemesis6

I was trying to do two things at once, sorry. It's corrected now.

251 mpax  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:30:23am

I think this makes it less likely for Georgia to enter NATO. No one wants to go to war with Russia

252 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:30:47am

re: #241 The Other Les

A bunch of 152mm self propelled guns, some MLTB personnel carriers, and some tracked vehicles which may be antiaircraft missile launchers. (Can't tell with all that canvas covering it up.)

One of those the back part was uncovered looked like a bridging unit.

253 JammieWearingFool  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:30:51am

re: #214 HoosierHoops

The IOC votes to change the schedule of the Olympics. Starting in 1984, the Summer Games and Winter Games will take place two years apart from one another, rather than in the same year.

Actually, the Winter and Summer Games took place the same year through 1988. In 1990, the Winter Games were held on their own, with the Summer Games following in 1992.

254 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:30:59am

re: #230 Serge GoFan

I'm watching enormous activity of Russian sleepers (and KGB-FSB officers?) throughout major western i-forums. Never seen anything like this since death of Litvinenko.
Charles, what are ISPs?

What?

255 nigella  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:31:01am

#232 tradewind, Do you think they sell arugula there?Barry can just work off the fat by going to the gym. As a totally frivolous post, am I they only one who thinks Obama looks like Urkel from that old sit-com?Just put glasses on him and a pair of "floods" and there you go! Separated at birth?

256 Nevergiveup  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:31:31am

re: #251 mpax

I think this makes it less likely for Georgia to enter NATO. No one wants to go to war with Russia

Patton?

257 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:31:36am

re: #233 Steffan

His ego must be smarting.

258 mfarmer1  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:31:36am

Admittedly I don't know much about the details of that region. However, hasn't the US been pushing for Georgia to be admitted into NATO?

NATO is a joke to begin with, but even so, trying to get Georgia on board would have been like the USSR pushing for Mexico to be a Warsaw Pact member.

Remember what happened when the Baltic states joined? Russia was powerless then to really do anything about it. Not so anymore. We have our hands full as it is. Sorry, but these former Soviet Republics need to deal with this on their own or with help from the EU. I'm sick of our involvement all over the globe getting us nowhere. In fact, we should say nothing, do nothing, and let the Euros scream and demand action on our part...and then tell them to politely take care of their own backyard.

259 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:31:37am

re: #241 The Other Les

A bunch of 152mm self propelled guns, some MLTB personnel carriers, and some tracked vehicles which may be antiaircraft missile launchers. (Can't tell with all that canvas covering it up.)

Sorry, that's MT-LB tracked personnel carriers. Usually issued to support units.

260 Glackinspeil  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:31:56am

re: #232 tradewind

BOH is gonna go ballistic if they try to get him to eat a typical Island diet.... way too many fat grams for him. I hope someone forces him to a pig roast.

Wouldn't some people be offended by that?
Just let him eat his waffles!

261 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:32:14am

re: #235 mpax

Does anyone know of a blog or news site with up to the minute coverage of events?

This is as good as I can find.

[Link: www.aboutgeorgia.net...]

262 HoosierHoops  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:32:17am

re: #232 tradewind

BOH is gonna go ballistic if they try to get him to eat a typical Island diet.... way too many fat grams for him. I hope someone forces him to a pig roast.

LoL typical Island Diet? I live in Hawaii for 3 years..
I'm not sure what you mean by a typical diet..but i ate really healthy
there..lots of fruits and great steaks and meats..Yes the occational roasted pig on the beach...oh and do NOT visit Hawaii without eating the corn soup..yummy yummy..

263 kevinmumaw  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:32:23am

Ralph Peters has a decent column in today's NY Post where he makes an excellent claim to evidence that Russia planned this entire thing. The armored brigade from the 58th, which was stationed in N Ossetia would not have been in a state of readiness to simply roll into Georgia at a moment's notice. It took some prior planning to ensure they were ready, and had competent crews. Russia planned this.

How do I know that the Russians set a trap? Simple: Given the wretched state of Russian military readiness, that brigade could never have shot out of its motor pool on short notice. The Russians obviously "task-organized" the force in advance to make sure it would have working tanks with competent crews.

264 vagabond trader  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:32:29am

Not knowledgeable about this part of the world, just wondering if Russia is doing this to test the US.We haven't exactly been best friends as of late and I wouldn't put it past the thugocracy.

265 Eric Cartman's Conscience  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:32:35am

#163 Frogmarch - did he really say exactly that?

266 Steffan  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:33:00am

re: #139 dmandman

That's why I made the comment about "revenge" diaries earlier. Look up how Stalin got his troops revved up during WWII against the Germans. A political officer monitored those (mandatory) entries to insure the troops were sufficiently motivated for revenge. If an entry was deemed too mild it was noted and commented upon (implication of better use in Penal Battalion perhaps?). The troops knew they had to deliver on the "Revenge" also which contributed to the rape statistics that were later compiled against the German women.

For the defense of Moscow and Leningrad, Stalin invoked the old Russian saints and Rodina, the Motherland. Since his own, personal, survival was involved, I don't think he was being all that cynical.

Saints and the Motherland beat the crap out of the Fatherland.

267 tradewind  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:33:01am

The Russians have been messing with Georgia for a long time....
[Link: www.physicsforums.com...]

268 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:33:17am

re: #243 medaura18586

Where did you get that Russia blew up the pipeline? The Kurds did that the other day.

269 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:33:51am

re: #246 David IV of Georgia

Georgian news servers have probably gotten more visits in the last 24 hours than they have for the rest of the year combined.

Poor Georgian hamsters.

270 mpax  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:33:53am

re: #256 Nevergiveup

Patton?

We will not see his like again.

271 ibmkeyboard  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:33:55am
What has Georgia done that establishes it as a threat to Russia proper or to its neighbors in general? It was dealing forcefully with an internal threat. Russia acts like Georgia itself is an "internal threat." It's only an internal threat if it's not a sovereign nation but part of the Russian Empire.

re: #226 Tigger2005

I don't know,
but Russia has attacked because it wanted to.

We attacked because we wanted to.
that was my point.

Are we going to threaten Russia and make them withdraw?
No.
I don't think World Opinion or territorial rights means shit anymore.

272 Nevergiveup  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:33:56am

re: #265 Eric Cartman's Conscience

#163 Frogmarch - did he really say exactly that?

I don't think it was verbatim, but it was rather obvious, he had no use for the President of Georgia and was just trying to lecture him.

273 Marvo76  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:34:14am

re: #243 medaura18586

There is barely a Russian minority in George (around 1.5% according to the CIA) so Russia has no credible excuse.

It looks to be all about oil, and Russia blew up their major pipeline: that was their first target. It's also about an affront to the USA... it's about Bush's political weakness now at the end of his last term, his inability to respond, and Putin affronting him directly at the Olympics (the timing of the attack is telling).

That of course, does not stop some people from calling Russia "our natural ally" against Islamism. The MSM is carrying the salt for Putin right now because his advances are bad for American power...

The same MSM that publicized the chat "NO BLOOD FOR OIL"?

274 Occasional Reader  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:34:26am

re: #264 vagabond trader

Not knowledgeable about this part of the world, just wondering if Russia is doing this to test the US.We haven't exactly been best friends as of late and I wouldn't put it past the thugocracy.

I heard a piece on the radio a few months ago about how the Putin regime is pushing anti-Western propaganda (specifically anti-US) HARD, and has been doing so for some time, for its domestic audience; all while the West is mostly blissfully unaware.

275 CyanSnowHawk  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:34:44am

re: #185 pingjockey

Haven't heard a peep from the euroweenies.

They've got their eyes on the Folda gap.

276 Shay4l  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:34:48am

We should help Georgia close that tunnel that is the only conduit for Russian supplies into the war zone.

277 HoosierHoops  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:35:15am

re: #253 JammieWearingFool

Actually, the Winter and Summer Games took place the same year through 1988. In 1990, the Winter Games were held on their own, with the Summer Games following in 1992.

so your saying google is wrong? oh the humanity!
That was a cut and paste job from some IOC website..
thanks for the update

278 Dustyvet  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:35:19am

re: #99 wiffersnapper

I really hope they don't try to send in the UN to sort this out.


The UN can't orginize a piss up in a brewey!

279 debutaunt  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:35:25am

re: #99 wiffersnapper

I really hope they don't try to send in the UN to sort this out.

Why? It will be added to the long list of stunning UN successes.

280 David IV of Georgia  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:35:30am

re: #245 stevieray

Russia really rolled the dice on this one. They need to win this quickly, cleanly, and decisively to maintain any military credibility. If this turns into another miserable slog-fest like Afghanistan or Chechnya, the Russian military and arms industry will take a huge hit.

Georgia is tiny, the Russians know the terrain well, and it sits on their border... no excuses for the Red Army if things don't go smoothly.

Georgia hasn't been a tiny nation for 2000 years when all her neighbors have come and gone (or converted to Islam) by being a pushover. Expect that the Georgians expect to win.

Are the Georgians still fighting Armenia?

281 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:35:36am

re: #259 The Other Les

Sorry, that's MT-LB tracked personnel carriers. Usually issued to support units.

Not sure on the canvas covered stuff, one look like bridge. Too small for SCUD, no fins hanging off the back like a FROG.

282 ciaospirit  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:35:51am

re: #229 debutaunt

Obama, who was born and raised in Honolulu, said yesterday at a rally that the aloha spirit meant helping those in need, taking care of one’s elders and treating people with respect.

He is such a liar. If that's what he believes, why did his grandmother have to take care of his dying mother? And Obama didn't even bother going to Hawaii to be with her when she died. Anyone who has had a loved one die of cancer knows that there is plenty of notice when the end is near. He's disgusting. Then out of this "respect" he talks about, he went on to use his dead mother's cancer in a Oho TV commercial trying to score political points.

283 tradewind  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:36:06am

re: #255 nigella

Don't know, but he angers the locals whenever he won't eat/drink their stuff....
Politics 101: Thou Shalt Eat the Donut.

284 willowone  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:36:57am

re: #274 Occasional Reader the MSM AND Putin regime is pushing anti-Western propaganda (specifically anti-US) HARD, and has been doing so for some time, for its domestic audience; all while the West is mostly blissfully unaware
repair job.

285 JHW  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:36:58am

re: #280 David IV of Georgia

i don't think they fought Armenia, that was Azerbaijan IIRC, over Nagorno-Karabeck.

286 Dustyvet  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:37:18am

re: #283 tradewind

Don't know, but he angers the locals whenever he won't eat/drink their stuff....
Politics 101: Thou Shalt Eat the Donut.


Can I just eat my waffle?

287 Nevergiveup  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:37:50am

re: #274 Occasional Reader

I heard a piece on the radio a few months ago about how the Putin regime is pushing anti-Western propaganda (specifically anti-US) HARD, and has been doing so for some time, for its domestic audience; all while the West is mostly blissfully unaware.

I think most Bear watchers are very aware, but when your options are limited for a variety of reason, it is easier to ignore the facts.

288 tradewind  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:38:14am

re: #262 HoosierHoops

I thought about that later... it's true, the ' old ' Island diet is totally healthy, but in the cities, Hawaii eats an inordinate amount of fried baked goods and condensed milk candy/sweet type stuff.... and obesity is fairly high among Islanders because of this.

289 Eric Cartman's Conscience  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:38:17am

#267 tradewind

That's the rub, though. Who moved first on Ossetia.

If Georgia moved first, Russia will think is a casus belli and use it an an excuse to crush Georgia. If Russia manufactured the conflict, the world will learn the truth. All I know is the president of Georgia was on CNN basically begging for an immediate cease-fire. So, if Georgia did go after Ossetia, they deserve the harsh Russian rebuke for the presumptuous move. They weren't prepared to reclaim nor defend a newly captured Ossetia. If Russia created the conflict they should be condemned on all fronts with B-2s landing in Georgia TODAY.

290 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:38:39am

ISTANBUL, Turkey (AP) - Kurdish separatist rebels claimed responsibility Thursday for sabotaging a critical Turkish pipeline, helping push global oil prices back above $120 per barrel.

The Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan pipeline, which brings Azeri oil from the Caspian Sea to the Mediterranean for westbound shipments, caught fire Tuesday night and Turkey's state-run Anatolia news agency said it could remain shut down for up to 15 days. The pipeline can pump slightly more than 1 million barrels of crude oil per day or more than 1 percent of the world's daily crude output

SNIP

291 JammieWearingFool  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:38:57am

re: #277 HoosierHoops

so your saying google is wrong? oh the humanity!
That was a cut and paste job from some IOC website..
thanks for the update

I didn't read the site. Perhaps they voted in 1984 to do that. Anyway, I recall them both occurring in 1988, and I think the Winter Olympics were in Albertville in 1990

292 mpax  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:39:08am

re: #282 ciaospirit

He is such a liar. If that's what he believes, why did his grandmother have to take care of his dying mother? And Obama didn't even bother going to Hawaii to be with her when she died. Anyone who has had a loved one die of cancer knows that there is plenty of notice when the end is near. He's disgusting. Then out of this "respect" he talks about, he went on to use his dead mother's cancer in a Oho TV commercial trying to score political points.

In addition, he acts as if the aloha spirit is so unique. Care and respect are basics in many communities in the U.S.Maybe Obama should visit my Manhattan apartment building to see care and respect at work. We don't need Hawaiians to teach us.

293 Eric Cartman's Conscience  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:39:15am

#272 NGU

Thanks, Never. I'll find a transcript if the cowards at CNN ever release one.

294 Glackinspeil  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:39:37am

re: #261 MandyManners

This is as good as I can find.

[Link: www.aboutgeorgia.net...]

Good collection of links:

Global Voices online

295 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:39:46am

re: #268 MandyManners

Where did you get that Russia blew up the pipeline? The Kurds did that the other day.

I was talking about the Turkish pipeline.

296 Nevergiveup  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:40:36am

re: #289 Eric Cartman's Conscience

#267 tradewind

That's the rub, though. Who moved first on Ossetia.

If Georgia moved first, Russia will think is a casus belli and use it an an excuse to crush Georgia. If Russia manufactured the conflict, the world will learn the truth. All I know is the president of Georgia was on CNN basically begging for an immediate cease-fire. So, if Georgia did go after Ossetia, they deserve the harsh Russian rebuke for the presumptuous move. They weren't prepared to reclaim nor defend a newly captured Ossetia. If Russia created the conflict they should be condemned on all fronts with B-2s landing in Georgia TODAY.

I doubt the military would be so hot on landing B-2's or any other expensive hardware on airfields that apparently are wide open to attack.

297 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:41:23am

re: #295 MandyManners

I was talking about the Turkish pipeline.

Which runs through Georgia.

298 vagabond trader  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:41:58am

re: #274 Occasional Reader

Heh, I believe it. Even when the detestable Soviet Union dissolved have never trusted them.A lady I know visited recently and told me that outside the garish new wealth in the cities, the roadways are lined with the destitute living in shacks.

299 MadJadBad  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:42:17am

Ironic or coincidental? Joseph Stalin was born in Gori, Georgia.

300 Summer  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:42:31am

My guess is that people are still too busy protesting the "Genocide" against the Palestinians to protest this action by Russia.

No Jews involved, you see...so not all that worth protesting I suppose...

301 tradewind  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:43:11am

re: #292 mpax

He explained he didn't realize ' the end was so near'.
She had ovarian cancer.... back then, there wasn't much doubt about what was happening to her. No excuse.
Of course, she did leave him as a tot to chase another Muslim husband around SE Asia, so maybe he still had abandonment issues.

302 akak  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:43:15am
304 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:44:26am

bbl

305 David IV of Georgia  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:44:30am

re: #300 Summer

My guess is that people are still too busy protesting the "Genocide" against the Palestinians to protest this action by Russia.

No Jews involved, you see...so not all that worth protesting I suppose...

I thought the "Elders of Zion" ran everything. That's what my secret societ club handbook says.

306 debutaunt  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:44:37am

re: #167 David IV of Georgia

It would be nice if they would just check Wikipedia, the unimpeachable source of all truth [citation needed].

To be extra sure, they can Snopes it.

307 HoosierHoops  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:44:56am

OK Lizards.. time to sign out..
bless you and keep up the good work..

308 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:45:12am

re: #300 Summer

My guess is that people are still too busy protesting the "Genocide" against the Palestinians to protest this action by Russia.

No Jews involved, you see...so not all that worth protesting I suppose...

But I'm sure the nutroots are right now tying USA interests in this, and therefore, because we all know US interests are controlled by Jews the anti-zionists protests will start shortly

309 psyop  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:45:32am

This situation could easily be the start of something much larger.

We could see the dominos start to fall with Russia de facto ally, Iran, getting getting more aggressive.

I truly hope this doesn't lead to a World War.

310 psyop  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:46:13am

re: #300 Summer

My guess is that people are still too busy protesting the "Genocide" against the Palestinians to protest this action by Russia.

No Jews involved, you see...so not all that worth protesting I suppose...

Excellent point....

311 Nevergiveup  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:46:17am

re: #309 psyop

This situation could easily be the start of something much larger.

We could see the dominos start to fall with Russia de facto ally, Iran, getting getting more aggressive.

I truly hope this doesn't lead to a World War.

You say that like it's a bad thing?
//

312 Steffan  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:46:35am

re: #228 Quilly Mammoth


I'll fully believe that when I see video of T90 tanks. Why the T90? Because in the terrain the fighting is currently in the Georgian anti-tank teams have standoff against everything in the Russian Inventory except the T90. That being said India, the largest producer of the T90, is slated to start a whole new tanks because fear that light AT missiles are progressing faster than they can up-armor the T90.

I honestly don't know either way, Quilly. Russian tank manufacturing of late has been kind of iffy -- most of the major factories turned out to be not in Russia, and part of the breakup deal was that the individual countries took title to any factories or equipment in their areas at the time of the breakup.

OTOH, I saw an interesting pic of a Georgian tank on the NYP website last night -- looks like they glued chunks of metal to the glacis plate, the fenders above the road wheels, and the sides of the turret.

I don't think it's chunks of Semtex -- any kind of reactive armor when you have friendly infantry nearby is a major no-no. Maybe Tom Kratman would have a better idea if we asked him.

313 sifty  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:47:03am

I think with in-flight refueling and an in-flight movie the B-2's could do their magic on some neo-Sov idiots and never have to land.

There is no way that this wasn't planned by the Russians. The bomber flights resuming, the talk of basing bombers in Cuba again, the buzzing of our carriers...

This is all related. It looks like Pooty is another short shit with empire dreams.

Sneaky fuckin' Russians. -- Cousin Avi

314 Josephine  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:47:37am

That poor injured woman in the photo. How long before someone came to help her? And the person crushed under the debris with just his/her lower legs sticking out: was this a friend or loved one?

How many times over was this scene repeated? It's horrifying.

315 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:47:52am

Wasn't Russia Putinstan last seen threatening to use force and instill unrest in Kosovo on behalf of their Serb buddies? You bet!

Russia could use force in Kosovo

Czech Nato troops went to prevent further Serb violence

Russia's ambassador to Nato, Dmitry Rogozin, has warned that Russia could use military force if the Kosovo independence dispute escalates.

"If the EU develops a unified position or if Nato exceeds its mandate set by the UN, then these organisations will be in conflict with the UN," he said.

In that case Russia would "proceed on the basis that in order to be respected we need to use brute force", he said.

Many EU members have recognised Kosovo, but several oppose recognition.

Russia, a permanent member of the UN Security Council, backs Serbia, which has condemned the independence declaration issued by the Kosovo parliament on 17 February.

On Tuesday members of the Serb minority in Kosovo attacked two border posts staffed by UN personnel and Kosovo police.

The violence led the Nato troops in Kosovo - known as K-For - to reinforce the border with Serbia.

Kosovo's majority ethnic Albanians are following a plan drawn up by UN special envoy Martti Ahtisaari for "supervised independence", which was rejected by Serbia.

Russian media outcry

The EU will soon deploy 2,000 officials to strengthen law and order in Kosovo, which has a population of about two million. Russia argues that the mission has no legal basis.

There has been a furious reaction in some Russian media to Kosovo's declaration of independence.

A commentary in the Vesti Plus analytical programme, on state-run television, called the assassinated former Serbian Prime Minister, Zoran Djindjic, a Western puppet who had "received a well-deserved bullet".

It said Djindjic had sold national heroes to the International War Crimes Tribunal in The Hague.

The programme concluded that Serbia - and not only Serbia - must now decide whether to acquiesce in what has happened, or resist.

Russian imperialistic aggression. Coming to a Sudetenland near you soon!

Putin warns Kosovo will 'come back to knock' the West, as NATO envoy lashes out

MOSCOW: President Vladimir Putin on Friday issued a sharp warning to the West about the consequences of recognizing Kosovo's independence, saying the decision would "come back to knock them on the head."

The comments, made during an informal meeting of leaders from ex-Soviet republics, were the strongest by the Russian leader since Sunday when Kosovo made its declaration of independence from Serbia.

They followed statements made earlier Friday by Russia's envoy to NATO, who warned the alliance against overstepping its mandate in Kosovo and said Moscow might be forced to use "brute military force" to maintain respect on the world scene.

Putin used the meeting of presidents from the Commonwealth of Independent States — a loose, Russian dominated organization of former Soviet states — to harshly lambast Western nations that have recognized Kosovo's independence. Among them are the United States, Britain, Germany and France.

"The Kosovo precedent is a terrifying precedent. It in essence is breaking open the entire system of international relations that have prevailed not just for decades but for centuries. And it without a doubt will bring on itself an entire chain of unforeseen consequences," he said in televised comments.

Those who have recognized Kosovo "are miscalculating what they are doing. In the end, this is a stick with two ends and that other end will come back to knock them on the head someday," he said.

Let's see how many of those people who complained about the NATO bombing of the Chinese embassy by mistake will now blame the Putinstanis for carpet bombing entire cities and towns with civilians in them.

316 Quilly Mammoth  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:47:54am

re: #263 kevinmumaw

Ralph Peters has a decent column in today's NY Post where he makes an excellent claim to evidence that Russia planned this entire thing. The armored brigade from the 58th, which was stationed in N Ossetia would not have been in a state of readiness to simply roll into Georgia at a moment's notice. It took some prior planning to ensure they were ready, and had competent crews. Russia planned this.

I don't fully buy it was planned in advance. I don't mean to harp on this but unless Russia breaks out south east of Ostia without the T90 they are dog meat. Only the T90 has a 3km sight and the Shtora ATGM jammer. Remember what happened to them in Grozny?

If they really planned this far in advance they would have transfered in a unit from the 5th Guards Tank Division in Siberia.

317 Dustyvet  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:47:55am

Almighty Supremebeing Allah Arrested


[Link: fox61.trb.com...]

318 sifty  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:48:42am

re: #312 Steffan

Chobham armor I think.

319 David IV of Georgia  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:48:46am

re: #309 psyop

This situation could easily be the start of something much larger.

We could see the dominos start to fall with Russia de facto ally, Iran, getting getting more aggressive.

I truly hope this doesn't lead to a World War.

It'd take our minds off of gas prices and inflation eating our paychecks.
//

320 Eric Cartman's Conscience  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:49:17am

#303 OJOE

ELECTERKEL.COM


I'm ashamed to admit it but what I took most from that article is that Obama should from here on out be labeled "Erkel"! LOL!

It seems so obvious but never really occured to me.

If the left can call Bush Hitler, surely we can aloofly refer to this idiot as Erkel!

Perhaps, today, a movement has begun.

I'm registering "electerkel.com" as we speak! LOL

321 Nevergiveup  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:49:23am

re: #313 sifty

I think with in-flight refueling and an in-flight movie the B-2's could do their magic on some neo-Sov idiots and never have to land.

There is no way that this wasn't planned by the Russians. The bomber flights resuming, the talk of basing bombers in Cuba again, the buzzing of our carriers...

This is all related. It looks like Pooty is another short shit with empire dreams.

Sneaky fuckin' Russians. -- Cousin Avi

This Cuba stuff is really starting to bug me. It is really time to throw the commies out of Cuba and install a real good major league baseball team there!

322 Glackinspeil  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:50:13am

re: #305 David IV of Georgia

I thought the "Elders of Zion" ran everything. That's what my secret societ club handbook says.

According to Debka, Israeli "military advisors" are on ground in Georgia.

Also....strangely enough, as I was checking out the Ossetia blogs this morning, there seems to be a fairly large pseudo hippie movement there and they were calling for non-violent protests against both sides. I did not save the link but I will see if I can find it again.

323 vagabond trader  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:50:23am

re: #317 Dustyvet

We have some real beauties in CT, the supposedly wealthiest state in the USA. lmao!

324 tradewind  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:50:34am

re: #316 Quilly Mammoth

They have been harassing Georgians for at least the past two years, though....

325 Quilly Mammoth  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:51:10am

re: #312 Steffan

I honestly don't know either way, Quilly. Russian tank manufacturing of late has been kind of iffy -- most of the major factories turned out to be not in Russia, and part of the breakup deal was that the individual countries took title to any factories or equipment in their areas at the time of the breakup.

OTOH, I saw an interesting pic of a Georgian tank on the NYP website last night -- looks like they glued chunks of metal to the glacis plate, the fenders above the road wheels, and the sides of the turret.

I don't think it's chunks of Semtex -- any kind of reactive armor when you have friendly infantry nearby is a major no-no. Maybe Tom Kratman would have a better idea if we asked him.

I'll have to buzz Col Tom. The sighting system on the T90 works best in very cold conditions. In the desert it fries. I wonder if anyone told the Saudis? I spent a _lot_ of years in AT and there are some serious questions here.

326 debutaunt  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:51:33am

re: #232 tradewind

BOH is gonna go ballistic if they try to get him to eat a typical Island diet.... way too many fat grams for him. I hope someone forces him to a pig roast.

Spam is a big favorite there.

327 Dustyvet  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:52:36am

re: #326 debutaunt

Spam is a big favorite there.

Can I just eat my poi?

328 Serge GoFan  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:53:20am

Some date and figures MSM prefers to omit:

South Ossetia is part of Georgia;

they are Muslims (Georgians are Christians);

population of S.Ossetia - 75 000;

19th regiment of 58th Army (operating in Georgia) - estimate 10 000 troops.

329 Eric Cartman's Conscience  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:53:25am

#321 NGU

That's a great idea, actually.

The entire spring training for MLB takes place throughout the country, increasing revenues, love of baseball and america everywhere.

Sure, the cactus and grapefruit league regions and other leagues would suffer in the spring, but imagine the influence AND THE CUBAN TALENT, we could tap into. I love this idea.

330 Nevergiveup  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:53:29am

Serious question. I don't know why the USA doesn't send high tech cameras into the war zone and televise those images LIVE all over the world?

331 jester6  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:55:02am

I think everyone is focusing on the tactical military nature of this foray and missing the big picture. This is not about terriroty, colonialism, Russian citizens or any other garbage.

This is about oil and natural gas.

Putin figured this out a few years ago. That is why he:

- Nationalized the Russian energy sector.
- Started looking for oil in the arctic.
- Flexes his muscle by reducing natural gas shipments to Europe in recent winters.
- Has built alliances with as many oil rich countries as possible - regardless of ideology
- Left his role in government and now heads (is the chairman I believe) of Gazprom.

This is from 2006 and sums it up well:

The Great Multi-dimensional Chess Game of Democracy versus Energy is in full sway, and the EU and the United States are in danger of being check-mated before they even fully realize they are in the game, let alone understand its rules. The view from the other side - led by Russia but joined by Iran, Venezuela, Nigeria and, increasingly, Algeria and even Norway (to name just a few), must be laughable as they watch the major free economies of the world flail about as if they were playing blindfolded.

Part of the problem may be that US leadership, in the persons of President Bush and Vice President Cheney, have spent real time in the private sector of the U.S. energy industry. They believe they know this game. It could be a case of a little knowledge being a dangerous thing, however. They have seen the problem as mainly one of supply of oil. Their answer, as became evident in the now infamous speech that Cheney delivered in Vilnius, Lithuania, is to chastise Putin for backing away from democratic freedoms, and to cozy up to leaders such as Kazakhstan's Nursultan Nazarbayev or Azerbaijan's Ilham Aliev, neither of whom has professed to run democracies in the first place, but who also control much of the world's supply of fossil fuels. Cheney understandably wants to head off a situation whereby Russia controls all of the fossil fuels heading west out of Central Asia; the question is, at what price to the freedom of millions of Central Asians?

The article is here: Putin's Energy Strategy

Do you realize Putin could just shut off gas to most of Europe and freeze thousands of Europeans next winter? That is a weapon much more powerful and selective then the Strategic Rocket Forces ever were.

It is not Axis vs Allie, East vs West, or even Civilization vs Islam. Its Energy Producers vs. Energy Consumers. Putin has made himself head of the Producer alliance. If we pull our forces out of Iraq it will make Jimmy Carters transfer of the Canal to Panama look like chump change.

Google - putin energy strategy - all the dots are there very easy to connect.

332 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:55:22am

re: #318 sifty

Chobham armor I think.

T-90 has a composite but it's not Chobham specifically. Chohbam has some special tricks which pretty tightly guarded.

333 Eric Cartman's Conscience  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:55:45am

#330

Unfortunately, perception and not reality is everything. Iraq really does compromise our moral high-ground, indignation, and assistance to anyone anywhere. It's total and complete marxist propagandistic bullshit that this is the case. But it is the case.

334 debutaunt  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:55:50am

re: #262 HoosierHoops

LoL typical Island Diet? I live in Hawaii for 3 years..
I'm not sure what you mean by a typical diet..but i ate really healthy
there..lots of fruits and great steaks and meats..Yes the occational roasted pig on the beach...oh and do NOT visit Hawaii without eating the corn soup..yummy yummy..

I loved the Hula Pie!

335 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:56:37am

re: #332 jcm
Correct. Only the Brits and the US have Chobham armor. It is classified above Top Secret.

336 gymnast  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:56:42am

Between the war in Georgia, and the Olympics in China, this will indeed be remembered as "The Week of War and Circus" Which channel is the UN tuned in on? Obviously the pack of UN clowns prefers to devote it's energies to the circus.

337 Eric Cartman's Conscience  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:57:28am

I've had enough of my own naysaying for the day.

Sorry for the many ill-informed rants and comments.

Hang in there. Keep the fight. Much love. See ya'll another day.

338 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:57:36am

re: #330 Nevergiveup

Serious question. I don't know why the USA doesn't send high tech cameras into the war zone and televise those images LIVE all over the world?

1st, delivery. A USA drone (or however it would be delivered) would be entering sovreign territory.
2nd extraction. how to get the images "out"

3rd , durability... things usually go BOOM in war zones,, unattended cameras would have no way of avoiding it

339 jaunte  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:57:39am

"BBCs not so neutral reporting:
Almost immediately following the analysis of Russia's supposed interests in the BTC pipeline came a report from a woman living in Moscow whose sister was trapped in South Ossetia. Despite telling us her sister had not left the basement for 2 days, she had still managed to get enough mobile reception to call her sister and tell her that Georgian planes were bombing them (perhaps they are, but how can you tell from a basement which planes are Russian or Georgian?). After that she proceeded to repeatedly claim that the Georgians were carrying out genocide against the South Ossetians with no comment from the interviewer that this might be a little strong at this stage. While I would expect the BBC to present both sides of the picture, the overwhelming picture building up is of a distinctly anti-Georgian bias."
[Link: kosmyryk.typepad.com...]

340 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:57:48am

re: #331 jester6

Excellent post.

All the more reason to shove the (D)s and greens in damn closet and start using our resources. They scream "no war for oil" but then make sure we're dependent on iffy sources.

341 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:58:28am

re: #316 Quilly Mammoth

I'm not so sure of that. I think - from my reading over the last couple months - that the thought is that they would strike, and then count on international condemnation to allow them to hold onto their gains.

I'm hoping for a 1938/39 Winter War scenario.

Russian logistics stink.

342 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:58:54am

The writing on the wall...

INTERVIEW WITH RUSSIA'S AMBASSADOR TO NATO

'The Attempt to Push Georgia into NATO Is a Provocation'

Russian Ambassador to NATO Dmitry Rogozin, 44, spoke with SPIEGEL about Moscow's opposition to membership for Ukraine and Georgia in the Western alliance, the threat of an arms race and potential cooperation between Moscow and the West to help stabilize Afghanistan.

SPIEGEL: Ukraine and Georgia are pushing to become membership candidates at the upcoming NATO summit in Bucharest in early April. Last week this led to a heated debate among NATO foreign ministers -- many of whom are afraid of Russia’s reaction. Should they be worried?

Dmitry Rogozin: Ukraine and Georgia’s NATO membership bid is backed by the most radical forces in the United States administration, the neoconservatives. In Georgia, however, President Mikhail Saakashvili has established a tyrannical system: There is massive suppression of the opposition and the media.

SPIEGEL: The Georgians don’t think Russia can lecture them on democracy.

Rogozin: If people in Brussels and Washington think that Georgia is a democracy, they’re deluding themselves. Should Georgia become, under pressure from the US, a NATO member, it would cease to be a sovereign state because two of its provinces, Abkhazia and South Ossetia, won’t join the Western Alliance.

SPIEGEL: Both regions are effectively Russian protectorates. Moscow has stationed peacekeeping troops there, the majority of the population has Russian passports ...

Rogozin: ... which we haven’t forced on them. It is not we who intend to take possession of foreign territories -- rather it is Abkhazia and South Ossetia that want to belong to Russia. If Georgia joins NATO, it will permanently lose these regions.

SPIEGEL: Because Moscow will intervene?

Rogozin: We cannot stand by idly. Abkhazia and South Ossetia share close ties with the Caucasian peoples in Russian territory. The attempt to push Georgia into NATO is a provocation that could lead to bloodshed.

"The attempt to push Georgia into NATO is a provocation that could lead to bloodshed."

This shouldn't come as a surprise to anyone... If Serbs are anti-American and Putinstanis are pro-Serb, then it follows that Putinstanis are, well, basically anti-American too. Not necessarily the average Joe, to be sure, but the henchmen who dictate the foreign policy of Putinstan.

Hence their staunch opposition to an independent Kosovo, a sovereign Georgia and a westernized Ukraine. These are luxuries Putin and his cronies can't afford.

343 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:59:34am

re: #338 sattv4u2

1st, delivery. A USA drone (or however it would be delivered) would be entering sovreign territory.
2nd extraction. how to get the images "out"

3rd , durability... things usually go BOOM in war zones,, unattended cameras would have no way of avoiding it

Our drones are real time, the drone drivers in Afghanistan and Iraq are in FL and CA.

344 David IV of Georgia  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 9:59:52am

re: #313 sifty

I think with in-flight refueling and an in-flight movie the B-2's could do their magic on some neo-Sov idiots and never have to land.

There is no way that this wasn't planned by the Russians. The bomber flights resuming, the talk of basing bombers in Cuba again, the buzzing of our carriers...

This is all related. It looks like Pooty is another short shit with empire dreams.

Sneaky fuckin' Russians. -- Cousin Avi

Thankfully I know a few hundred Russians and the Russian people do love their children. The Russian government and Puta Putin may want to lash out and showoff for the ladies, but they sure don't want to start a world war. I think they are trying to create some breathing room so that they can resume their domination and pillaging of their neighbors.

345 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:00:04am

re: #322 Glackinspeil

According to Debka, Israeli "military advisors" are on ground in Georgia.

Also....strangely enough, as I was checking out the Ossetia blogs this morning, there seems to be a fairly large pseudo hippie movement there and they were calling for non-violent protests against both sides. I did not save the link but I will see if I can find it again.

Please do - I hadn't seen those.

346 Nevergiveup  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:00:24am

re: #338 sattv4u2

1st, delivery. A USA drone (or however it would be delivered) would be entering sovreign territory.
2nd extraction. how to get the images "out"

3rd , durability... things usually go BOOM in war zones,, unattended cameras would have no way of avoiding it

Georgia would be happy to assist in getting the pics out. Set up the satellite ground stations in southern Georgia. Surround them with surface to air protection.

347 CyanSnowHawk  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:00:26am

re: #338 sattv4u2

1st, delivery. A USA drone (or however it would be delivered) would be entering sovreign territory.
2nd extraction. how to get the images "out"

3rd , durability... things usually go BOOM in war zones,, unattended cameras would have no way of avoiding it

4th, if you have the capability, you don't necessarily want to show it off to potential enemies.

348 DeafDog  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:01:40am

re: #292 mpax

In addition, he acts as if the aloha spirit is so unique. Care and respect are basics in many communities in the U.S.Maybe Obama should visit my Manhattan apartment building to see care and respect at work. We don't need Hawaiians to teach us.

Ya know, the "aloha spirit" is a face that the locals put on for the toursists. The undercurrent when one lives in Hawaii (or anywhere in the Pacific) is less multicultural....

Kill Haole day

349 medaura18586  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:01:41am

re: #268 MandyManners

Where did you get that Russia blew up the pipeline? The Kurds did that the other day.

Mis-typed. I meant the main trade port (not pipeline) -- was thinking about oil..

350 JHW  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:01:56am

Remember a few years back, the Dems could not wait to spend the so-called "peace dividend" to buy more votes. Go to sleep with unicorn and kitten dreams and it is very easy to pretend that the world has always been a dangerous place for the unwary and naive.

351 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:01:57am

re: #343 jcm

Our drones are real time, the drone drivers in Afghanistan and Iraq are in FL and CA.

I'm aware of that. Our drones are 'invited" guests in Afghanastan and Iraq. A deal with Gerogia would have to be worked out

352 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:02:00am

re: #330 Nevergiveup

Serious question. I don't know why the USA doesn't send high tech cameras into the war zone and televise those images LIVE all over the world?

Everyone got caught flat-footed with the Olympics?

353 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:02:35am

re: #347 CyanSnowHawk

4th, if you have the capability, you don't necessarily want to show it off to potential enemies.

That always a tough balance. You want the deterrence effect of what you can do to be known. But also what a few tricks up your sleeve.

354 Nevergiveup  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:03:06am

re: #351 sattv4u2

I'm aware of that. Our drones are 'invited" guests in Afghanastan and Iraq. A deal with Gerogia would have to be worked out

And our drones in Pakistan are on the the "don't ask don't tell" plan?

355 Tigger2005  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:04:06am

re: #271 ibmkeyboard

I don't know,
but Russia has attacked because it wanted to.

We attacked because we wanted to.
that was my point.

No, we attacked because we HAD to.

Nobody is threatening Russia itself. Nobody is threatening Russia's energy supplies. Georgia wasn't harboring terrorists planning operations inside Russia. Georgia isn't a dictatorship with a history of violence and aggression intent on developing WMDs.

And by the way, Russia didn't go to the U.N. and get a series of resolutions passed against Georgia, which Georgia proceeded to violate with impunity.

Russia attacked because...well, because its Russia. This is what Russia has done for a long, long time.

356 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:04:14am

Charles,

Several minutes ago, a few seconds after I opened LGF, Norton Anti-Virus popped up an "Intrusion attempt has been blocked" message box. The only other place I'd been at this morning was Yahoo webmail (came here from there). It's possible that the attack came via there. However, I think you might like to know about this, just in case.

Risk name: HTTP Adobe SWF Remote Code Exec
Attacking computer: spe.atdmt.com (206.132.122.64, 80)
Event time was: 08-09-08, 11:50:50 AM CDT

357 Shay4l  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:04:16am

I wonder if the stories of 2 additional carriers heading over to the reagion were the result of observing Russian armor moving south.

358 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:04:28am

re: #351 sattv4u2

I'm aware of that. Our drones are 'invited" guests in Afghanastan and Iraq. A deal with Gerogia would have to be worked out

True.
The KH-12's, are undoubtedly giving us plenty of good stuff.

359 Nevergiveup  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:05:57am

File this under: Great work if you can get it!

[Link: apnews.myway.com...]

Where is laura?

360 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:06:34am

re: #342 A. van Hilten

This is all very traditional Great Russian strategy.

361 free  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:06:39am

First, I am not defending Russia. When i read an AP story on anything i have to think about how they report on the conflicts we [USA] have had and are having. So keep that in mind as you read the media reports on this conflict.

362 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:07:19am

re: #354 Nevergiveup

And our drones in Pakistan are on the the "don't ask don't tell" plan?

sshhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

363 debutaunt  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:07:28am

re: #282 ciaospirit

He is such a liar. If that's what he believes, why did his grandmother have to take care of his dying mother? And Obama didn't even bother going to Hawaii to be with her when she died. Anyone who has had a loved one die of cancer knows that there is plenty of notice when the end is near. He's disgusting. Then out of this "respect" he talks about, he went on to use his dead mother's cancer in a Oho TV commercial trying to score political points.

Beneath contempt.

364 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:08:05am

re: #350 JHW

Remember a few years back, the Dems could not wait to spend the so-called "peace dividend" to buy more votes. Go to sleep with unicorn and kitten dreams and it is very easy to pretend that the world has always been a dangerous place for the unwary and naive.

Just to make sure people have seen it. This is very much the predictable outcome of the "peace dividend."

365 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:08:54am

re: #351 sattv4u2

I'm aware of that. Our drones are 'invited" guests in Afghanastan and Iraq. A deal with Gerogia would have to be worked out

Somehow, I think the engraved invitation is probably being hand-delivered as we speak, don't you?

366 Quilly Mammoth  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:09:33am

re: #345 Dianna

Please do - I hadn't seen those.

Front page of LiveLeak has peaceniks forming a Peace Chain.

367 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:10:29am

re: #357 Shay4l

Now that is an excellent observation.

368 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:11:26am

re: #366 Quilly Mammoth

I saw. I spent several minutes laughing, then began thinking about how really stupid that is when the Russians are rolling armor and had a very hard time not throwing up.

369 Ayatollah Ghilmeini  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:12:06am

Georgia is very limited in what they can do here.

The best they can hope for is a military standstill.

Russia has strategic strike weapons that Georgia cannot defend against- cruise missiles and strategic bombers among other things.

The Russian army still has poor morale, awful officers and flawed equipment. Supplied with stingers and some anti tank rockets, assuming the Georgians are reasonably well trained and well led, they might just be able to stymie the Russians and get the conflict to the negotiating table.

The problem is Putin may decide to make an object lesson of Georgia and go all the way to reoccupation. Putin is a ruthless SOB, the only limitation on his behavior is he dare not provoke the US too much. Short of that though, expect at least several days of this and maybe even more.

Georgia wins by surviving and remaining independent. The US is not going to war for Georgia, however the Georgians may find that, with US supplied satellite real-time intel and some precision weapons that they can severely hurt the Russian Army.

And then their is the other imperial power in the region, Turkey. The opportunity to expand into Georgia may be too tempting for the Islamist government to pass up.

All in all, a excellent Caucasus clucsterf*** in the last year of lame duck deeply distracted by other wars presidency. The silver lining: Russia will have little to say when we paste Iran.

370 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:12:44am

Am I alone, here?

371 JHW  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:13:03am

re: #364 Dianna

Exactly right, and I also should have used the word "forget" instead of pretend, but I guess it's fairly clear what I meant. They too many times take wishes for reality.

372 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:13:39am

re: #366 Quilly Mammoth

Front page of LiveLeak has peaceniks forming a Peace Chain.

re: #366 Quilly Mammoth

Front page of LiveLeak has peaceniks forming a Peace Chain.

Stack of pancakes!

373 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:13:39am

re: #370 Dianna

Am I alone, here?

I guess so

(who th' heck said that?! .. not me)

374 Russkilitlover  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:13:41am

Georgia has opened its arms to American influence for several years now. The other Caspian region nations would rather have American influence than Russian. Their ethnic tensions in each of these countries, however, weakens them. Not to mention, an outgoing President, pretty popular in former Soviet bloc countries and in this Caspian region, is about to be replaced by a moron when it comes to American strength and how to wield it.

If, by some looooong shot, McCain makes it into the White House, things may change. But clearly the Russians know who they will be dealing with and they will take full advantage of our weakness. Here comes the Iron Curtain again.

Welcome to the Bloc! ~ channeling Sean Connery

375 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:14:07am

re: #370 Dianna

Am I alone, here?

You are very alone.........
/

HI!

376 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:14:08am

re: #370 Dianna

Am I alone, here?

about what?

377 Marvo76  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:15:14am

re: #357 Shay4l

I wonder if the stories of 2 additional carriers heading over to the reagion were the result of observing Russian armor moving south.

I will post a blog I posted last night, it has a rather lengthy explination...

378 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:15:16am

re: #370 Dianna

Am I alone, here?

Do mean alone as in the room, because there is always someone around so we're never really alone......

379 David IV of Georgia  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:15:25am

People have asked here why we don't give Georgia air protection, real time reconnaissance, or other military aid. Georgia is a sovereign nation. Even though we are their ally, we don't go without being asked. Except for some indirect aid, we will likely not be asked. Why? Well would you want two major powers fighting it out in your country? Any aid we give them will most likely be benign or untraceable.

If Russia tries to relive their glory days in Hungary, this assessment may rapidly change.

380 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:15:25am

re: #375 jcm

You are very alone.........
/

HI!

Hi there!

I'm hanging out for the moment, in case Charles comes back re my #356.

381 debutaunt  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:16:08am

re: #313 sifty

I think with in-flight refueling and an in-flight movie the B-2's could do their magic on some neo-Sov idiots and never have to land.

There is no way that this wasn't planned by the Russians. The bomber flights resuming, the talk of basing bombers in Cuba again, the buzzing of our carriers...

This is all related. It looks like Pooty is another short shit with empire dreams.

Sneaky fuckin' Russians. -- Cousin Avi

An axis of shitheads.

382 Steffan  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:16:09am

re: #338 sattv4u2

1st, delivery. A USA drone (or however it would be delivered) would be entering sovreign territory.
2nd extraction. how to get the images "out"

3rd , durability... things usually go BOOM in war zones,, unattended cameras would have no way of avoiding it

Some drones can operate above 70,000 ft. and can be controlled via satellite link -- most of the larger UAVs in Iraq are controlled from the States.

There isn't a lot in the inventory that can fly that high, and those things are fairly stealthy.

All they need is a secure place to land (I'm sure a small civil airport outside Tbilisi with no obvious military activity around it could work very well).

383 Russkilitlover  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:16:11am

re: #331 jester6

Sounds pretty spot on to me. Whoever controls energy production and access will absolutely control the world. And it certainly won't be the US, because our Democratic party is determined to make us wholly dependent, and thus subservient, to the energy producers.

384 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:16:59am

re: #370 Dianna

Am I alone, here?

Of course you are.

No man is an island, but women, of course, are another matter.

*DUCK*

385 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:17:03am

re: #369 Ayatollah Ghilmeini

The problem is Putin may decide to make an object lesson of Georgia and go all the way to reoccupation. Putin is a ruthless SOB, the only limitation on his behavior is he dare not provoke the US too much. Short of that though, expect at least several days of this and maybe even more.

A very good observation - this paragraph is particularly cogent. I have thought for some time that Putin is thinking very seriously about reconstituting the old Russian Empire, starting - as did the Tsars - with consolidating control of the Caucasus (let's leave Ukraine and Belarus out of the discussion for the moment). So it might be a good idea to think of Russia as being expansionist totalitarians again (considering their current agricultural policies and the neutering of the Duma, it's not all that different from the Soviet model).

Which means that we should support the Georgians with materiel, and maybe some air support and hope they can kick Russian butt.

386 Quilly Mammoth  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:17:14am

re: #370 Dianna

Am I alone, here?

I'm seeing what's happening at The Bar.

387 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:17:30am

re: #366 Quilly Mammoth

Front page of LiveLeak has peaceniks forming a Peace Chain.

re: #372 jcm

I'd be impressed if they formed it in front of the Georgian parliament building, like the "human shield" people did in Baghdad just before the war.

(huh ? ,,, wha ?,, what do you mean the human shield people only said they were going to do that, and fled before the bombs dropped?)

388 Marvo76  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:17:30am

[Link: europebusines.blogspot.com...]

I posted this on the overnight thread

389 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:18:27am

re: #374 Russkilitlover

They chose this week, with everyone at the Olympics, deliberately.

I'm annoyed.

390 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:19:05am

Hi medaura18586,

You have put together an awesome exposé of the ties of Jatras and Spencer to the American (sic) Council for Kosovo at your site. Highly recommended. That's an actual piece of investigative journalism—and not some comedienne's tales and distortions about organ trafficking, but I digress. Putin seems to be willing to go to war against Georgia, so will he deliver on his promises and teach those "dirty Albanians" a lesson too? I bet some would still praise him for fighting a "Jihadist state"... Thing is: if Puttin dares to actually harm ze French peacekeepers the nukes wil be rainin' on Moscow in no time flat.

BTW, Josephine was acussing me of being your sock puppet a few threads back (the Antichrist one).

391 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:19:08am

re: #383 Russkilitlover

Sounds pretty spot on to me. Whoever controls energy production and access will absolutely control the world. And it certainly won't be the US, because our Democratic party is determined to make us wholly dependent, and thus subservient, to the energy producers.

If we get into an energy war I hope Pelousy and Reid are the first things dropped on the enemy.

392 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:19:42am

re: #376 sattv4u2

I just noticed that I'd replied to 3 people, and all my replies were one after the other. I wondered if everyone else had popped off to another thread.

It's good to see you haven't!

393 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:21:02am

re: #392 Dianna

I just noticed that I'd replied to 3 people, and all my replies were one after the other. I wondered if everyone else had popped off to another thread.

It's good to see you haven't!

We're suckers for a beautiful lady.

394 David IV of Georgia  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:21:05am

re: #391 jcm

If we get into an energy war I hope Pelousy and Reid are the first things dropped on the enemy.

Give them to the enemy. They destroy all they touch.

395 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:21:16am

re: #379 David IV of Georgia

I have a bad feeling we're going to be seeing atrocities. Glory days of Hungary, indeed!

396 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:21:40am

re: #393 pre-Boomer Marine brat

You're just saying that because you're scared of Salvatore Squirrel!

397 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:21:58am

re: #147 medaura18586

There are plenty of folks on our side who are cheering for the Russians on this one.

Yes, the same who routinely make excuses for the Chetniks who tried to burn to the ground the embassy at Belgrade.

398 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:22:13am

re: #386 Quilly Mammoth

Ah!

Any particularly good linkage?

399 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:22:58am

re: #396 Dianna

You're just saying that because you're scared of Salvatore Squirrel!

(quivering, hiding under the computer desk)

400 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:24:57am

re: #391 jcm

We'll just send them to negotiate. Putin may laugh so hard he can't give orders, or something.

401 So?  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:25:21am

/UN Security meeting has been called

/ UN denounces Russia


/ Human Rights groups are outraged

402 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:25:40am

re: #400 Dianna
He could die of a laughing fit.

403 Westward Ho  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:25:54am

re: #369 Ayatollah Ghilmeini

"The silver lining: Russia will have little to say when we paste Iran."

And when will that be? Will it be just aerial bombardment or a regime change?

404 Nemesis6  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:26:14am

re: #300 Summer

"In the 1910s, its censused population was 5,033 with 42.3% Jews, 33% Georgians, 13.4% Armenians and 11% Ossetians."
[Link: en.wikipedia.org...]

405 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:26:59am

re: #392 Dianna

I just noticed that I'd replied to 3 people, and all my replies were one after the other. I wondered if everyone else had popped off to another thread.

It's good to see you haven't!

I'm still here, for what good that does anyone!@!

406 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:28:12am

re: #242 tradewind

Deja Vu at pravda... it's all our fault....

[Link: english.pravda.ru...]

Well, apparently some folks seem to think Pravda is a very credible source. At least, as far as unsubstantiated rumors of organ trafficking are concerned.

407 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:28:56am

re: #402 pingjockey

I don't think his cardio-vascular system is in that poor shape.

408 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:28:59am

re: #401 So?

/UN Security meeting has been called

/ UN denounces Russia


/ Human Rights groups are outraged

I'll wager most of the mucky mucks from the UN are in China right now (paid for by the UN, therfore paid for by the US) living large at the Olympics. (what ,,,, after living large in NYC you expect them to downgrade in China ?)

409 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:29:04am

re: #331 jester6

I think everyone is focusing on the tactical military nature of this foray and missing the big picture. This is not about terriroty, colonialism, Russian citizens or any other garbage.

This is about oil and natural gas.

Putin figured this out a few years ago. That is why he:

- Nationalized the Russian energy sector.
- Started looking for oil in the arctic.
- Flexes his muscle by reducing natural gas shipments to Europe in recent winters.
- Has built alliances with as many oil rich countries as possible - regardless of ideology
- Left his role in government and now heads (is the chairman I believe) of Gazprom.

This is from 2006 and sums it up well:


The article is here: Putin's Energy Strategy

Do you realize Putin could just shut off gas to most of Europe and freeze thousands of Europeans next winter? That is a weapon much more powerful and selective then the Strategic Rocket Forces ever were.

It is not Axis vs Allie, East vs West, or even Civilization vs Islam. Its Energy Producers vs. Energy Consumers. Putin has made himself head of the Producer alliance. If we pull our forces out of Iraq it will make Jimmy Carters transfer of the Canal to Panama look like chump change.

Google - putin energy strategy - all the dots are there very easy to connect.

Spot on.

410 Macker  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:29:15am

re: #61 ibmkeyboard

Stalin killed 50 million Russians

When did we invade Russia

smart ass.

Actually, the Allies in WWI intervened in Russia's Civil War back in 1918, when we took the side of those opposed to the DFCs which just took power. IIRC, US troops were in Murmansk.

411 JHW  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:29:19am

I was searching for a book by an Eastern European journalist, Czech I believe, on the Russian Army's performance in Chechnya. It was miserable by Western military standards, I think a whole tank unit was wiped out in Grozny ala Custer's Last Stand. Unbelievable corruption, soldiers and commanders selling weapons to the Chechens, finally just flatten everything in sight, the sledgehammer tactic. Can't find the book but I did find this one, highly recommended by the likes of Strobe Talbott and Jim Woolsey, ex-CIA Director. Very sobering, I'll have to order a copy.
Darkness at Dawn: Rise of the Russian Criminal State

412 Westward Ho  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:29:45am

re: #385 Dianna


"Which means that we should support the Georgians with materiel, and maybe some air support"

Would you like to go to war with Russia over some remote caucasian shithole?

413 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:30:23am

re: #407 Dianna
Awww. Too bad. Cause as silly as Pelousi and Reid are, they could be a comedy team.

414 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:30:29am

re: #408 sattv4u2

Which is why I am sure the Russians (I almost typed Soviets again) planned to do this now.

Grrr.

415 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:30:40am

re: #389 Dianna

They chose this week, with everyone at the Olympics, deliberately.

I'm annoyed.

BHO went on vacation. When was it first scheduled?

Edwards released his confession.

416 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:31:47am

re: #412 Westward Ho

I'd like to see Russia's pretensions depressed.

Of course, all bets are off if Russia decides that if they can't win, neither can anyone else. They've never shown signs of thinking that way in the past, but I am not willing to guarantee they won't go that way this time.

417 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:32:07am

Reuters is messing up. [1] They were showing a video of a Soviet Russian Mig-29 shooting down a Georgian UAV.

[Link: www.strategypage.com...]


1. I would have expected them to favor the Soviet Russian side.

418 So?  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:32:35am

Here's the plan. Keep Iran off the front page burner, so Russia can continue to assist them in obtaining a nuclear weapon.

419 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:33:07am

re: #410 Macker

Actually, the Allies in WWI intervened in Russia's Civil War back in 1918, when we took the side of those opposed to the DFCs which just took power. IIRC, US troops were in Murmansk.

Archangelsk, too.

420 Desert Dog  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:33:46am

re: #303 Ojoe

Blackfive has some very perceptive comments on Putin's Russia regarding all this, it is short and worth a read.

And here's the San Gabriel Mountains (towercam)

Are you telling me Putin would not fall under Obama's "spell" and get a tinglely sensation running up his leg when he meets him for the first time?

421 David IV of Georgia  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:34:06am

re: #406 A. van Hilten

Well, apparently some folks seem to think Pravda is a very credible source. At least, as far as unsubstantiated rumors of organ trafficking are concerned.

There was an old Soviet joke about trusting a newspaper called "Truth" (Pravda).

422 George guy  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:34:09am

This is weirdly similar to the plot of Ghost Recon.

423 Tigger2005  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:34:16am

Scary as hell. They have a strategy. We have nothing at all. NOTHING. No plan, not even the ghost of a plan.

By the time we realize we have to do something, it could well be too late to do anything. If they have controlling stakes in our companies they will block every effort we make to achieve energy independence and keep us dependent and subservient.

re: #331 jester6

I think everyone is focusing on the tactical military nature of this foray and missing the big picture. This is not about terriroty, colonialism, Russian citizens or any other garbage.

This is about oil and natural gas.

Putin figured this out a few years ago. That is why he:

- Nationalized the Russian energy sector.
- Started looking for oil in the arctic.
- Flexes his muscle by reducing natural gas shipments to Europe in recent winters.
- Has built alliances with as many oil rich countries as possible - regardless of ideology
- Left his role in government and now heads (is the chairman I believe) of Gazprom.

This is from 2006 and sums it up well:

The article is here: Putin's Energy Strategy

Do you realize Putin could just shut off gas to most of Europe and freeze thousands of Europeans next winter? That is a weapon much more powerful and selective then the Strategic Rocket Forces ever were.

It is not Axis vs Allie, East vs West, or even Civilization vs Islam. Its Energy Producers vs. Energy Consumers. Putin has made himself head of the Producer alliance. If we pull our forces out of Iraq it will make Jimmy Carters transfer of the Canal to Panama look like chump change.

Google - putin energy strategy - all the dots are there very easy to connect.

424 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:34:42am

re: #415 MandyManners

No clues on BHO and Edwards - I think Edwards couldn't hide any longer, though.

With the Russians, always remember that they always have a plan.

With the Dems...not so much.

425 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:35:26am

re: #417 The Other Les

I saw that last night, and wondered.

426 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:36:13am

re: #420 Desert Dog

Are you telling me Putin would not fall under Obama's "spell" and get a tinglely sensation running up his leg when he meets him for the first time?

I think it would be hard for Putin to contain his contempt.

427 Syrah  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:36:28am

Russia has a declining population.

Russia's population peaked in the early 1990s (at the time of the end of the Soviet Union) with about 148 million people in the country. Today, Russia's population is approximately 143 million. The United States Census Bureau estimates that Russia's population will decline from the current 143 million to a mere 111 million by 2050, a loss of more than 30 million people and a decrease of more than 20%.

If they were to win this war and take territory from Georgia, could they keep it?

And how popular can a war of this type be in Russia? If it is dragged out with a lot of casualties, they would likly fail in keeping their gains. Nations with declining populations are much more adverse to losses on the battlefield then nations with expanding populations.

428 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:36:40am

"Your avearge Rooskie don't take a dump without a plan".
Fred Thompson, in "the Hunt for Red October".

429 medaura18586  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:36:48am

re: #349 medaura18586

Mis-typed. I meant the main trade port (not pipeline) -- was thinking about oil..

Well -- look at the top headline on Instapundit right now:
[Link: www.pajamasmedia.com...]

PERHAPS IT IS ALL ABOUT PIPELINES: "Russian fighter jets targeted the the major Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan (BTC) oil pipeline which carries oil to the West from Asia but missed, Georgia's Economic Development Minister Ekaterina Sharashidze said on Saturday."

UPDATE: More here. And a more pro-Russian take here. (But what's the Discovery Institute connection?)

430 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:37:09am

re: #412 Westward Ho

"Which means that we should support the Georgians with materiel, and maybe some air support"

Would you like to go to war with Russia over some remote caucasian shithole?

We will eventually go to war with the Russian state. The question isn't if, the question is when?

432 Serge GoFan  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:37:54am

Looks like www.civil.ge and www.aboutgeorgia.net are out.

433 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:37:55am

re: #428 pingjockey

A marvellously accurate observation on Tom Clancy's part.

434 Tigger2005  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:37:55am

re: #423 Tigger2005

Scary as hell. They have a strategy. We have nothing at all. NOTHING. No plan, not even the ghost of a plan.

By the time we realize we have to do something, it could well be too late to do anything. If they have controlling stakes in our companies they will block every effort we make to achieve energy independence and keep us dependent and subservient.

And, by the way, they can do this for a long, long, long time, keeping us on subsistence rations. Slash Western energy use by half or more and the oil will probably last another three hundred, four hundred years.

435 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:38:17am

re: #424 Dianna

No clues on BHO and Edwards - I think Edwards couldn't hide any longer, though.

With the Russians, always remember that they always have a plan.

With the Dems...not so much.

the dems not only always have a plan, they also have back-up plans

PLAN 1 ,,,,, blame Bush
PLAN 2 ,,,,, blame Bush again
PLAN 3 ,,,,, cry racist
PLAN 4 ,,,,, blame Bush
PLAN 5 ,,,,,, blame any republican or conservative within blaming distance
PLAN 6 ,,, blame Bush

436 Westward Ho  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:38:21am

re: #416 Dianna


Dianna,
There is a good case for staying out of ethnic blood feuds in a seriously badass region. For better or worse it is their backyard and the Mob boss putin is slapping some respect into this Mikhail come lately punk.

437 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:38:26am

re: #429 medaura18586
Huh? DI connection, WTF?

438 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:39:03am

re: #432 Serge GoFan

I haven't been able to get to either one since about 2 pm yesterday.

439 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:40:00am

re: #432 Serge GoFan
I would bet some of the first airstrikes took out communication nodes.

440 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:40:16am

re: #436 Westward Ho

Dianna,
There is a good case for staying out of ethnic blood feuds in a seriously badass region. For better or worse it is their backyard and the Mob boss putin is slapping some respect into this Mikhail come lately punk.

Someone should invite Comrade Putin in dinner at Spark's Steak House.

441 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:41:47am

re: #436 Westward Ho

I must disagree.

The Georgians have fulfilled their obligations as allies very well, especially considering their precarious economic and political state.

If you think brushing off an ally and surrendering their territory to a newly expansionist and totalitarian Russia is a good idea, you're not taking a very long view. The consequences will not be good.

442 anotherindyfilmguy  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:41:51am

re: #316 Quilly Mammoth

Or they did their own calculations of how much force they would need and sent it. Worked great for them in Afghanistan...

443 Syrah  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:42:22am

I am sure some one has already asked, but are their any "Human Rights" activist having riots outside out Russian Embassies, or holding protest marches against Russian "War Crimes" in Georgia?

/

444 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:42:44am

re: #442 anotherindyfilmguy

Or they did their own calculations of how much force they would need and sent it. Worked great for them in Afghanistan...

"Well, that didn't work...let's do it some more!"

445 godfrey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:43:02am

Let's have W and Putin meet again, and ask W what he sees this time.

446 Syrah  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:43:23am

. . . and isn't Russia supposed to be Rice's area of Expertise?

447 MandyManners  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:43:51am

re: #432 Serge GoFan

Looks like www.civil.ge and www.aboutgeorgia.net are out.

[Link: www.aboutgeorgia.net...] is good to go for me.

448 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:44:03am

re: #443 Syrah

I am sure some one has already asked, but are their any "Human Rights" activist having riots outside out Russian Embassies, or holding protest marches against Russian "War Crimes" in Georgia?

/

As soon as they can find either a Zionist or USA connection to the russian embassy, they will

449 Colonel Panik  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:44:07am

I'm looking at the upside to this. I think Russia's actions in Georgia have just increased the chances that John Sidney McCain will be our next President.

450 godfrey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:44:34am

Does the cease-fire gives the US a pass on transporting 2k Georgian troops back to Georgia from Iraq?

451 Westward Ho  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:44:43am

re: #430 The Other Les

"We will eventually go to war with the Russian state. The question isn't if, the question is when?"

What would the war be fought over? Communism is dead

452 JHW  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:44:51am

re: #441 Dianna

Yes, you are right and Ukraine has to be very, very nervous indeed right about now. It was bad enough there when a presidential candidate was "mysteriously" poisoned.

453 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:45:08am

re: #441 Dianna

Appeasing the bad guys makes them stronger.

454 godfrey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:45:36am

Can you imagine Obama vs. Putin?

lol

455 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:45:56am

re: #446 Syrah

It is.

I'm curious if she'll trend towards her later positions, of confrontation, blocking and depression of pretensions or revert to her earliest "detente" views.

It will depend on what Bush decides, of course.

456 medaura18586  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:46:26am

re: #390 A. van Hilten

Hi medaura18586,

You have put together an awesome exposé of the ties of Jatras and Spencer to the American (sic) Council for Kosovo at your site. Highly recommended. That's an actual piece of investigative journalism—and not some comedienne's tales and distortions about organ trafficking, but I digress. Putin seems to be willing to go to war against Georgia, so will he deliver on his promises and teach those "dirty Albanians" a lesson too? I bet some would still praise him for fighting a "Jihadist state"... Thing is: if Puttin dares to actually harm ze French peacekeepers the nukes wil be rainin' on Moscow in no time flat.

BTW, Josephine was acussing me of being your sock puppet a few threads back (the Antichrist one).

Thank you van Hilten for the kind words. I am updating that post with what I think is a very important and globally relevant point.

As to Josephine's allegations of sock puppetry, I am very flattered to be confused with you, even in the minds of the demented.

457 Syrah  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:46:48am

re: #454 godfrey

Can you imagine Obama vs. Putin?

lol

AAAAAAARRRRRGGGGGGGHHHH!

(must find hard liquor in quantity now.)

458 Russkilitlover  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:47:30am

re: #454 godfrey

Can you imagine Obama vs. Putin?

No. No I can't.

459 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:47:38am

re: #447 MandyManners

Thanks. I hadn't tried that one - it's always been very slow, and usually far behind the news in the past.

But if it's all we've got, I'll take it.

460 stevieray  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:47:53am

re: #427 Syrah

Russia has a declining population.

If they were to win this war and take territory from Georgia, could they keep it?

And how popular can a war of this type be in Russia? If it is dragged out with a lot of casualties, they would likly fail in keeping their gains. Nations with declining populations are much more adverse to losses on the battlefield then nations with expanding populations.

Long term... no. They can barely hold onto the far eastern parts of Russia proper. And that explains why this is happening now. If China wasn't pinned down with the Olympics right now, they might be tempted to make a move up into Russia and grab a bunch of land while the Russian army is distracted in the Caucuses. Ethnic Chinese have been moving into Russian land for a while now... the civilian stalking horse for a Chinese land-grab down the road.

461 medaura18586  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:47:54am

re: #431 Colonel Panik

Good article. Here is another interesting article from Blackfive.

LOL @

Do I even have to write this piece after putting those two pictures side by side. W looked into Putin's eyes and saw his own weakness, Obama would look in those eyes and wet himself.

So true.

462 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:48:02am

re: #453 The Other Les

I thought I said that, but not as pithily.

463 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:49:04am

re: #449 Colonel Panik

I'm looking at the upside to this. I think Russia's actions in Georgia have just increased the chances that John Sidney McCain will be our next President.

hmmmm,,,,, I wonder how we can tie Barrys recent Excellent Asian/ European Adventure to this.

"Just weeks after Senator Obama returned from the region, all hell broke loose"

464 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:49:28am

re: #451 Westward Ho

Resources, expansion and influence.

465 medaura18586  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:50:11am

re: #437 pingjockey

Huh? DI connection, WTF?

I think Instapundit is referring to a trackback from discovery.org at the bottom of that Russia Blog propaganda piece.

See for yourself: [Link: www.russiablog.org...]

TrackBack URL for this entry: [Link: www.discovery.org...]

466 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:51:41am

re: #452 JHW

I'm not going to harp on this, but there's been solid evidence that Russia's back in Imperial mode for at least the last three years. I thought so from the moment Putin took the presidency and started systematically gutting every rival institution.

Ukraine is watching its neighbor closely.

467 Charles  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:51:44am

The Discovery Institute runs that Russia Blog site.

How interesting that they are on the side of Russia.

468 ploome hineni[deleted]  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:51:46am
469 medaura18586  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:52:19am

re: #397 A. van Hilten

Yes, the same who routinely make excuses for the Chetniks who tried to burn to the ground the embassy at Belgrade.

That is what I was trying to get at. In those positions, people tend to be remarkably consistent, whether they realize it or not.

470 anotherindyfilmguy  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:52:48am

re: #412 Westward Ho

Yes. Tomorrow/next week/next month/next year it will be another of the "breakaways" being re-subjugated or possibly something worse... Hitler could have been stopped dead in his tracks if the powers that were had moved to defend the first of his aggressions into "historically German" areas etc.

471 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:53:20am

re: #451 Westward Ho
Umm..No, communism is not dead. China, Cuba, N. Korea, possibly Venezuela. How about defending freely elected democracies who finally threw off their Soviet overlords after 60+ years of opression? Or should we just say to them, well it is too bad but we can't help. Shal we tell the Poles, Lithuanians and other folks they are on their own against renewed Russian agression?

472 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:53:51am

re: #419 Dianna

Archangelsk, too.

We lost about 400 troops supporting the White Russians IIRC.

473 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:53:58am

re: #465 medaura18586
Ahh. Thanks.

474 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:53:59am

re: #451 Westward Ho

"We will eventually go to war with the Russian state. The question isn't if, the question is when?"

What would the war be fought over? Communism is dead

The old Russian paranoia and will to conquer is still there. Communism was just a convenient excuse. The rulers of Russian have traditionally seen their nation as the legitimate heirs of the Roman Empire and thus the sole legitimate political authority on the planet. Thus war is ultimately unavoidable.

Under the such circumstances the plan of Obama and the Donks to shut down the BMD program and dismantle the nuclear arsenal are nothing less than treason to the American Republic and a betrayal of Humanity in General.

475 Colonel Panik  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:54:16am

re: #457 Syrah

AAAAAAARRRRRGGGGGGGHHHH!

(must find hard liquor in quantity now.)

May I suggest a nice vodka? Polish, not Russian!

476 Serge GoFan  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:54:23am

re: #447 MandyManners

It's good only for frontpage.

477 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:54:32am

re: #454 godfrey

Can you imagine Obama vs. Putin?

lol

Actually, it wouldn't be funny.

478 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:54:59am

re: #451 Westward Ho

"We will eventually go to war with the Russian state. The question isn't if, the question is when?"

What would the war be fought over? Communism is dead

Putin is a Communist and would like to restore the Soviet Union.

479 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:55:20am

re: #477 The Other Les

Actually, it wouldn't be funny.

He'd give Alaska back.

480 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:55:52am

re: #477 The Other Les
Puppy vs pitbull. No contest.

481 Tigger2005  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:56:12am

You know, this stuff about energy producers asserting control over the planet reminds me of Orwell's "1984" (of course, a lot of things remind me of Orwell's "1984" these past few years).

At one point, the Party chief tells Winston Smith that while the German Nazis and the Russian Communists used Party methods, their weakness was that they were bound too much by ideology. The Germans stuck to Nazism even though it cost them their best Jewish minds...the Russians stuck to Communism even though it was plainly a failure. The difference, Winston is told, is that ALL the Party cares about is power. Power IS its ideology, it doesn't even try to pretend otherwise. "We are the priests of power," the Party chief tells Winston.

The thought of a world governed by people who care about nothing but power is terrifying indeed.

"Imagine a boot stomping on a human face...forever."

482 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:56:28am

re: #458 Russkilitlover

No. No I can't.

I can. All I can do is indulge in gallows humor.

483 Glackinspeil  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:56:31am

Dianna:
I looked but could not find that Ossetian Hippie blog. Maybe the inernet cafe they run it out of got run over by a tank.

484 JHW  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:56:31am

re: #466 Dianna

I agree whole-heartedly with you on this, the last year in particular there have been so many disquieting signs coming out of the Kremlin, that it has reminded me too much of the old Cold War days. I'm wary of radical Islam, but a resurgent belligerent Russia is just as, if not more, dangerous than jihadis. Too often in the past they have made common cause also, as I understand it Arafat was practically a creation of the KGB.

485 akak  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:56:50am

re: #474 The Other Les

The old Russian paranoia and will to conquer is still there. Communism was just a convenient excuse. The rulers of Russian have traditionally seen their nation as the legitimate heirs of the Roman Empire and thus the sole legitimate political authority on the planet. Thus war is ultimately unavoidable.

Under the such circumstances the plan of Obama and the Donks to shut down the BMD program and dismantle the nuclear arsenal are nothing less than treason to the American Republic and a betrayal of Humanity in General.

They don't need tanks if Gazprom moves from 3rd to 1st in their race, and no reason to think they won't.

486 anotherindyfilmguy  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:57:03am

re: #451 Westward Ho

re: #451 Westward Ho

Power. Enslavement by dictator versus freedom for the rest of the world...

487 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:58:32am

re: #480 pingjockey

Puppy vs pitbull. No contest.

I'm thinking fetal poodle versus full size doberman.

488 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:58:49am

re: #472 jcm

That sounds about right. I could pull my Blackwell's and check, if you like.

489 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:59:33am

re: #483 Glackinspeil

Thanks for the effort, anyway.

I wouldn't be surprised if the communications nodes are down, and likely to stay that way for a while.

490 realwest  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:59:41am

re: #478 jcm
Hey jcm! Putin was, iirc, head of the KGB at the time that the Soviet Union fell apart - and I think he either can't get over his habit of creating mischief and mayhem for the U.S. But I also agree that he longs for the "good old days" when the Soviet Union was in fact a first rate world power- especially in a non-nuclear confrontational world.
Sadly for Putin and his successor, Russia is now a second rate power (in terms of conventional, non-nuclear weapons military) and doesn't seem to be able to "catch up".

491 Dr. Shalit  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 10:59:45am

re: #184 MandyManners

Putin.

"MM" -

As an Illya Kuriakin lookalike? -S-

492 Ojoe  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:00:14am

re: #431 Colonel Panik

Thanks for the heads-up.

Will read it at lunch.

BBL

493 Syrah  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:00:27am

re: #460 stevieray

Long term... no. They can barely hold onto the far eastern parts of Russia proper. And that explains why this is happening now. If China wasn't pinned down with the Olympics right now, they might be tempted to make a move up into Russia and grab a bunch of land while the Russian army is distracted in the Caucuses. Ethnic Chinese have been moving into Russian land for a while now... the civilian stalking horse for a Chinese land-grab down the road.

The terms of Victory for the Georgians are different then they are for the Russian.

The Russians have to take and hold territory, while the Georgians have to make it so expensive that the Russians fail.

Russia's declining population makes losses on the battlefield VERY expensive to them.

If Georgia can kill and maim enough Russians, even over a period of time, Russia will begin to suffer draft riots and other protest that will make it difficult if not impossible for them to hold the territory.

Georgia must not give up easy.

Russia now has two hostile territories that that are costing them soldiers, Chechnya, and now Georgia.

494 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:01:01am

re: #488 Dianna

That sounds about right. I could pull my Blackwell's and check, if you like.

I could do it online too. ;-)
Cleaning up the kitchen, kids are watching 101 Dalmatians (the old animated one) for the 101, 010th time.

495 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:01:07am

re: #478 jcm

Putin is a Communist and would like to restore the Soviet Union.

Um...no. He sees himself as the new Tsar; he won't require the title, but he wants to be Tsar.

496 godfrey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:01:39am

re: #477 The Other Les

What's the emoticon for "dry, sarcastic laughter"?

497 Basho  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:01:56am

re: #430 The Other Les

We will eventually go to war with the Russian state. The question isn't if, the question is when?

I don't think so. Mark this day on your calendars. This is the start of America becoming a paper tiger. Today we don't help Georgia, tomorrow we don't help Taiwan. America is becoming a flake. God help us all.

498 medaura18586  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:02:05am

re: #467 Charles

The Discovery Institute runs that Russia Blog site.

How interesting that they are on the side of Russia.

That Russia Blog is also pumping up James Jatras' (Robert Spencer's "friend") anti-western, pro-serbia/russian propaganda. I linked to one such post in my Spencer/Jatras report: [Link: kejda.net...]

Here is the direct link to the Russia Blog post:
[Link: www.russiablog.org...]

499 realwest  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:02:11am

re: #493 Syrah I agree with what you said, but what is your take on Russia/Ukraine relations?

500 David IV of Georgia  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:02:13am

re: #454 godfrey

Can you imagine Obama vs. Putin?

lol

Да. Я могу.

501 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:02:33am

re: #493 Syrah
Don't forget the Ukraine. Putin would love to have Russias' breadbasket back under his thumb.

502 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:02:42am

re: #490 realwest

and doesn't seem to be able to "catch up".

I don't think he aspires to 'catch up' he knows that train left the station a long time ago. I do think what he would settle for is to be a strong #2, and regionally THE dominant power (China's wealth not withstanding)

503 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:03:06am

re: #490 realwest

Hey jcm! Putin was, iirc, head of the KGB at the time that the Soviet Union fell apart - and I think he either can't get over his habit of creating mischief and mayhem for the U.S. But I also agree that he longs for the "good old days" when the Soviet Union was in fact a first rate world power- especially in a non-nuclear confrontational world.
Sadly for Putin and his successor, Russia is now a second rate power (in terms of conventional, non-nuclear weapons military) and doesn't seem to be able to "catch up".

Putin was KGB, I don't remember how high up the top echelon. Their military never recovered from the Reagan build up and subsequent collapse. I would bet the Bear flights are pushing their resources.

504 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:03:27am

re: #494 jcm

I could do it online too. ;-)
Cleaning up the kitchen, kids are watching 101 Dalmatians (the old animated one) for the 101, 010th time.

But I trust my Blackwell!

505 Syrah  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:04:03am

re: #499 realwest

I agree with what you said, but what is your take on Russia/Ukraine relations?

They are held hostage by a pipeline.

If the Ukraine ever figures out that the pipeline is a gun that can be turned back on the Russians, they could make Putin's life very uncomfortable.

506 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:04:13am

re: #495 Dianna

Um...no. He sees himself as the new Tsar; he won't require the title, but he wants to be Tsar.

Rabbi, Rabbi, is there a proper blessing for the Tsar.
mmmmm
Yes, there is. May the Lord bless and keep the Tsar,.... far away from us.

507 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:04:22am

re: #497 Basho

We haven't abandoned our ally yet.

I'm not saying we won't. But we haven't done it yet.

So please hold off with the razor blade, all right?

508 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:04:28am

re: #467 Charles

The Discovery Institute runs that Russia Blog site.

How interesting that they are on the side of Russia.

Is there any radical/foreign interest group they're not in bed with?

509 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:05:25am

re: #508 A. van Hilten

Is there any radical/foreign interest group they're not in bed with?

Martians

510 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:05:56am

re: #499 realwest

Ukraine is nervous.

However, their agriculture is in better shape than Russia's, and they can use food as a weapon if they absolutely have to.

511 Syrah  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:06:24am

re: #501 pingjockey

Don't forget the Ukraine. Putin would love to have Russias' breadbasket back under his thumb.

I hope that the Ukraine is paying enough attention to what is happening in Georgia to be worried.

512 AuntAcid  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:06:25am

Human shields needed here.
(Sean Penn, you're up!)

513 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:06:28am

re: #503 jcm
Those Bear flights are at the limit of their capabilities. When I retired in '97 seeing a Russian ship/sub was a big deal. Back in the '80s we saw them everywhere. I can't think their AF and navy have improved and I shudder to think what sort of state their liquid fueled ICBMs are in. Those type of missles are extremely manpower intensive for maintenance.

514 realwest  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:06:34am

re: #502 sattv4u2 Well you certainly could be right about that, but those Russian Bear flights over US Naval Carrier Battle Groups happened on his watch - he may not aspire to catch up, but he sure hasn't acted the way I'd expect someone who would settle for #2 would (and yes, I know Putin isn't officially in charge in Russia now, but I'd bet no significant decision gets made without his approval).

515 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:06:41am

re: #500 David IV of Georgia

Да. Я могу.

Now that was succinct!

516 yma o hyd  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:07:13am

re: #297 MandyManners

Which runs through Georgia.

And thats the point!
Russia has indeed been rpeparing this attack - on several fronts. The pipleline means that Russia won't have the monopoly over gas and oil exports in that region. It wants that monopoly.
30% of the pipeline consortium is/was owned by BP
Scroll to the bottom few paragraphs here ..., and another indicator is that Russia has made huge difficulties for BP, and mroe or less banned the director of the Russian BP operations from that country ...
The report about thsi harrassment dates from July 22nd 08 ...

/But of course its only America that goes to war for oil ...

517 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:07:34am

re: #509 The Other Les

Martians

Ray Walston was a radical?

[Link: www.imdb.com...]

518 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:08:08am

re: #511 Syrah

Ukraine's been worried sick for the last 3 years.

519 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:08:19am

re: #517 sattv4u2
Yep. He was part of the Mars for the Martians movement.

520 realwest  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:09:59am

re: #513 pingjockey I remember reading - oh, maybe three, four years after the break up of the USSR, that Russia was having trouble paying it's troops, feeding it's troops and maintaining some otherwise excellent war machines (and desperate to find pilots for the latest fighters). Do you remember that and do you think that's still a problem - morale in the Russian military ranks?

521 JHW  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:10:09am

Photo essay by a young Ukrainian woman on the "Orange Revolution" and the attempted stealing of the presidential election. Notice the before and after photos of the pro-democracy presidential candidate. Several pages in this essay, very interesting.
Orange Revolution in Ukraine, photo essay

522 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:11:12am

re: #513 pingjockey

Those Bear flights are at the limit of their capabilities. When I retired in '97 seeing a Russian ship/sub was a big deal. Back in the '80s we saw them everywhere. I can't think their AF and navy have improved and I shudder to think what sort of state their liquid fueled ICBMs are in. Those type of missles are extremely manpower intensive for maintenance.

When I was AF, they pulled me out of classes in basic for a special interview. Seems I did well enough on the apptitude tests they wanted be to volunteer for the NEST team. This is when we still had Titans in the silos and they fairly regular blew up and tossed the warhead someplace. I would be the one with the geiger counter looking for the damn thing. I told 'em I wasn't crazy, I wanted to go to PJ school.

523 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:11:28am

re: #517 sattv4u2

Ray Walston was a radical?

[Link: www.imdb.com...]

Okay. Maybe the Venusians.

The Soviets were landing a lot of probes there.

524 Serge GoFan  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:11:42am

re: #478 jcm

Putin is a Communist and would like to restore the Soviet Union.

Russian communism is dead since late 20th. After that it became Russian Fascism. Now it is Russian cripto-fascism.
Big difference...

525 Colonel Panik  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:13:20am

re: #490 realwest

Putin's highest rank in the KGB was Colonel, IIRC. At the time of the breakup of the Soviet Union he was working in the office of the Mayor of Leningrad/St. Petersburg, Anatoly Sobchak , in an economic position that dealt with international business.

This is where he first came to the attention of Boris Yeltsin.

526 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:13:22am

re: #520 realwest
I don't know if conditions have improved. I do know in 1997 and E-5 in our military was making more a month than Russian Colonels!

527 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:13:49am

re: #498 medaura18586

That Russia Blog is also pumping up James Jatras' (Robert Spencer's "friend") anti-western, pro-serbia/russian propaganda. I linked to one such post in my Spencer/Jatras report: [Link: kejda.net...]

Here is the direct link to the Russia Blog post:
[Link: www.russiablog.org...]

There seems to be an underlying connection between white supremacist, hardocre creationist, pro-Chetnik propagandist groups that vindicates LGF's position on this issues.

528 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:14:40am

re: #520 realwest

I remember reading - oh, maybe three, four years after the break up of the USSR, that Russia was having trouble paying it's troops, feeding it's troops and maintaining some otherwise excellent war machines (and desperate to find pilots for the latest fighters). Do you remember that and do you think that's still a problem - morale in the Russian military ranks?

Morale is always a problem with the Soviet Russian military. That's why they usually have "barrage battalions", lots of KGB FSB guys with lots of machine guns and anti-tank missiles, behind the front line army units.

529 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:14:59am

re: #522 jcm
I remember back in the late/mid 70s that Titan that blew up in Arkansas, IIRC. Immense hole in the ground. NEST team, no thanks. Crikey! Here take this counter and go look for plutonium.

530 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:16:21am

re: #523 The Other Les

Okay. Maybe the Venusians.

The Soviets were landing a lot of probes there.

That's because they're interested in making love, not war.

/need I?

531 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:17:26am

Will we fly the Georgian troops home? If we do and the Russians shoot down our transport plane what will GW do? I know the midnight oil is burning in the Pentagon now!

532 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:17:52am

re: #524 Serge GoFan

Russian communism is dead since late 20th. After that it became Russian Fascism. Now it is Russian cripto-fascism.
Big difference...

Had to do it.

533 realwest  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:18:59am

re: #525 Colonel Panik
Ah! Thank you for that information - but I still think he has a hard-on for the US!

534 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:19:11am

Has this already been posted and discussed?

Georgia claims to have destroyed 40 Russian tanks.

535 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:20:29am

re: #534 Dianna
Discount all claims of destroyed hardware by both sides by half, at least.

536 Mars Needs Neocons  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:21:23am

re: #313 sifty

I think with in-flight refueling and an in-flight movie the B-2's could do their magic on some neo-Sov idiots and never have to land.

There is no way that this wasn't planned by the Russians. The bomber flights resuming, the talk of basing bombers in Cuba again, the buzzing of our carriers...

This is all related. It looks like Pooty is another short shit with empire dreams.

Sneaky fuckin' Russians. -- Cousin Avi

And this all ties in to the things the last couple years. Crackdowns on press, "disappearances" of spies, hostile rhetoric. I said here over a year ago that the soviet union was alive and well.

537 Syrah  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:21:27am

From the Orange Revolution. Разом нас багато

538 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:21:34am

re: #533 realwest

He doesn't like us much, that's for sure.

539 godfrey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:21:46am

Question: why doesn't Putin start building a direct pipeline from Samara to St. Petersburg? Direct access to Baltic, Germany, etc. No pesky wars.

540 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:21:56am

re: #535 pingjockey

That's my usual rule of thumb, yes.

541 Mars Needs Neocons  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:22:02am

re: #519 pingjockey

Yep. He was part of the Mars for the Martians movement.

Hey, enough on the martians, we don't have a dog in this fight.

542 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:22:22am

re: #539 godfrey

Because they can't pay for the work.

543 godfrey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:22:42am
544 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:22:55am

re: #534 Dianna

Has this already been posted and discussed?

Georgia claims to have destroyed 40 Russian tanks.

That was supposed to be a link. I wonder what I did wrong this time?

545 David IV of Georgia  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:22:57am

re: #535 pingjockey

Discount all claims of destroyed hardware by both sides by half, at least.

Until there is some substantiation at least. War makes for inflated claims.

546 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:23:14am

re: #535 pingjockey

Discount all claims of destroyed hardware by both sides by half, at least.

The guys at NSA watching KH-12 images probably have the best count.

For the rest of us take the number claimed killed, divide my the number admitted lost. Multiple by a factor based on media perception of how it's going for that side divide again by two and you'll be pretty close.

547 realwest  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:23:51am

re: #528 The Other Les
WHOA! That's the first time I ever heard of "barrage battalions"! Good grief, the Russians better keep those FSB guys paid and well fed!
I don't mean this disrespectfully, but are you sure about those "barrage battalions"? I'd hate to have to be in one of them, just in case the Army they were "behind" decided to say fuck it and go after THEM!

548 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:24:19am

re: #498 medaura18586

I finally got around to checking out Spencer's criticism of Glenn Reynolds. In fact Mr. Reynolds is 100% correct and it's happening right now to PZ Meyers who called a communion wafer a "cracker". He received death threats from Christians and the Catholic League has started a campaign to get him fired. They also tried to align with CAIR after PZ Meyers desecrated a Quran and a communion wafer. They don't belief free speech covers blasphemy and hurting feelings.

549 Mars Needs Neocons  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:24:38am

re: #529 pingjockey

I remember back in the late/mid 70s that Titan that blew up in Arkansas, IIRC. Immense hole in the ground. NEST team, no thanks. Crikey! Here take this counter and go look for plutonium.

You think that's bad. I was posted on an "incident" in Germany. Sitting there inside the cordon wearing my normal uniform watching people pass in and out in full hazmat gear. I wondered if I should be worried, my bosses all said no, no, don't worry about it.

550 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:24:55am

re: #541 Mars Needs Neocons
You might. Pooty might have eyes on the Red Planet.

551 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:25:15am

re: #545 David IV of Georgia

And Georgia needs to claim successes to keep from being abandoned. What a world!

552 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:26:08am

re: #549 Mars Needs Neocons
Always liked when they did that. NOT!

553 David IV of Georgia  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:26:21am

re: #536 Mars Needs Neocons

And this all ties in to the things the last couple years. Crackdowns on press, "disappearances" of spies, hostile rhetoric. I said here over a year ago that the soviet union was alive and well.

A Soviet Union without the constraints or stress of trying to make everyone atheist or follow some wacky form of Marxism. As long as money and power are centralized, do as you like.

554 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:26:38am

re: #547 realwest

It's solid.

They were openly employed in WWII; much less so after that, but yes, they exist.

555 pingjockey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:26:48am

Later folks. The boss(8 yr old) wants to play. BBIAW.

556 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:27:21am

re: #547 realwest

WHOA! That's the first time I ever heard of "barrage battalions"! Good grief, the Russians better keep those FSB guys paid and well fed!
I don't mean this disrespectfully, but are you sure about those "barrage battalions"? I'd hate to have to be in one of them, just in case the Army they were "behind" decided to say fuck it and go after THEM!

They did during WW2 and Victor Suvorov in INSIDE THE SOVIET ARMY said they still had them in the Soviet Era. I would not be the least bit surprised that the KGB FSB is doing something to keep the Soviet Russian army units focused on their mission.

557 Syrah  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:27:45am

re: #549 Mars Needs Neocons

You think that's bad. I was posted on an "incident" in Germany. Sitting there inside the cordon wearing my normal uniform watching people pass in and out in full hazmat gear. I wondered if I should be worried, my bosses all said no, no, don't worry about it.

If your are still alive 30+ years after the incident, . . .

You probably have nothing to worry about.

If you had been exposed to "something," it would have most likely made itself known by now.

558 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:28:01am

re: #553 David IV of Georgia

A Soviet Union without the constraints or stress of trying to make everyone atheist or follow some wacky form of Marxism. As long as money and power are centralized, do as you like.

Reverting to the historical model. The Russian Empire rises again, without the Romanovs.

559 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:28:41am

re: #549 Mars Needs Neocons

You think that's bad. I was posted on an "incident" in Germany. Sitting there inside the cordon wearing my normal uniform watching people pass in and out in full hazmat gear. I wondered if I should be worried, my bosses all said no, no, don't worry about it.

I had a first shirt who was involved in cleaning up that B-52 that went down at Thule with 4 nucs.

560 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:28:50am

re: #548 Killgore Trout

Exercising my free speech and at the risk of hurting your feelings, I think it's time you got a new dead horse. The one you're beating on is all worn out,
IMHO

561 Mars Needs Neocons  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:29:10am

re: #553 David IV of Georgia

A Soviet Union without the constraints or stress of trying to make everyone atheist or follow some wacky form of Marxism. As long as money and power are centralized, do as you like.

I think that makes them more dangerous.

re: #552 pingjockey

Always liked when they did that. NOT!

Here's the weird part. It was a leftover incident from when the Fwench had the base just after WW2, we were just doing cleanup after it was discovered. I was there to protect the scene from ...Greenpeace. The lunatics made a threat to break into the base and make a big stink about something over 40 years old that the US wasn't even involved with. Luckily I had shooting orders.

562 realwest  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:29:23am

re: #535 pingjockey
Ordinarily I'd agree with you, but my former niece-in-law (?) lived for two years in what was then Soviet Georgia and always marveled at the independent spirit of the Georgians - and given the apparently ready availability of shape-charged mines (the kind Hezbollah used on Israeli tanks and armored vehicles with such success) numbers of armored vehicles destroyed could be true; but, as is always the case, I think the issue is who controls the skies.
And on that point I have NO IDEA whatsoever!

563 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:29:47am

re: #559 jcm

I had a first shirt who was involved in cleaning up that B-52 that went down at Thule with 4 nucs.

"first shirt" ?

564 Mars Needs Neocons  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:30:17am

re: #557 Syrah

If your are still alive 30+ years after the incident, . . .

You probably have nothing to worry about.

If you had been exposed to "something," it would have most likely made itself known by now.

That's what I figure. I also had to walk inside a lot of "may cause sterilization" areas and have two kids, so things must have worked out there too.

565 JHW  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:30:23am

re: #547 realwest

It gets even worse if you are or were a Russian G.I.
Penal Battalions

The Shtrafbat Archipelago

566 Mars Needs Neocons  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:30:43am

re: #563 sattv4u2

"first shirt" ?

First Sgt, First Shirt, Fur shirt, all the same.

567 Mars Needs Neocons  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:31:43am

re: #559 jcm

I had a first shirt who was involved in cleaning up that B-52 that went down at Thule with 4 nucs.

I knew some people that were on that detail too.

568 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:31:51am

re: #563 sattv4u2

"first shirt" ?

First Shirt, first Sgt.

569 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:31:52am

re: #566 Mars Needs Neocons

First Sgt, First Shirt, Fur shirt, all the same.

K ,, thanks

570 David IV of Georgia  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:32:00am

re: #544 Dianna

That was supposed to be a link. I wonder what I did wrong this time?

re: #556 The Other Les

They did during WW2 and Victor Suvorov in INSIDE THE SOVIET ARMY said they still had them in the Soviet Era. I would not be the least bit surprised that the KGB FSB is doing something to keep the Soviet Russian army units focused on their mission.

My grandfather fought against battalions of German boys and old men. In each group there was at least one SS officer assigned to make sure everyone fought. My grandfather, who was a crack shot, and a couple of other marksmen would always look for the twenty-ish man standing straight and gun him down first. Once the SS officer was dead, the rest usually surrendered.

571 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:32:01am

re: #563 sattv4u2

"first shirt" ?

First Sergeant. An E-8 NCO.

572 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:32:25am

re: #560 sattv4u2

No it isn't. It's very true that some Christians are using Islamist tactics to suppress free speech and even seeking alliances with Islamist groups to achieve that goal. It's very true and very real.

573 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:33:44am

re: #567 Mars Needs Neocons

I knew some people that were on that detail too.

Four ruptured bombs, in adequate protect gear. Tons of ice shipped to the US for processing. Class A Charlie Fox.

574 realwest  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:34:37am

re: #554 Dianna Thanks Dianna and all I can say is "wow" - what kinda effin army could they possibly have? Assault, surrender or retreat and die - doesn't necessarily amount to a really "motivated" regular army, ya know?

575 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:35:01am

re: #572 Killgore Trout

No it isn't. It's very true that some Christians are using Islamist tactics to suppress free speech and even seeking alliances with Islamist groups to achieve that goal. It's very true and very real.

there are many things in this life that are very true and very real. They also get very tedious, especially to people that have no involvement in it nor axe to grind about it. Here at LGF, I have yet to see a Christain using Islamist tactics to suppress free speech and even seeking alliances with Islamist groups.

Right Time,, ,Right Place

576 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:35:08am

re: #562 realwest

It looks like the Russians currently have air superiority (someone told me - firmly, I might add - that the Russians did not have air dominance (I leave these definitions to those with much more expertise in the matter than I have)), but that could change if we decided to weigh in, even a little bit.

577 David IV of Georgia  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:35:29am

re: #558 Dianna

Reverting to the historical model. The Russian Empire rises again, without the Romanovs.

The Romanovs at least had to pretend to be Orthodox Christians and had the self imposed constraint of imitating Paris' and Vienna's social class.

578 Colonel Panik  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:35:38am

re: #533 realwest

Ah! Thank you for that information - but I still think he has a hard-on for the US!

No doubt about that. Unfortunately I think the way the Clinton administration dealt with Russia and Slavic countries in general contributed to his rise and popularity in Russia.

579 godfrey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:35:48am

By the way, I don't think the ethnic questions here are trivial. This sounds like a fair description and history. I see the US interest here, and Russia's power play, but Ossetian nationalism isn't based on fiction. Question is, why didn't they see that siding with Georgia was in their best long-term interest?

580 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:36:17am

re: #575 sattv4u2

I'm sorry you find free speech a tedious topic. Nobody is forcing you to discuss it.

581 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:36:53am

re: #565 JHW

It gets even worse if you are or were a Russian G.I.
Penal Battalions

The Shtrafbat Archipelago

Rokossovsky commanded the 16th Army while under a suspended death sentence.

582 JHW  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:38:18am

re: #581 The Other Les

Yes, that's true. Wasn't he Polish by nationality?( Too lazy to look it up.)

583 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:38:31am

re: #548 Killgore Trout

I finally got around to checking out Spencer's criticism of Glenn Reynolds. In fact Mr. Reynolds is 100% correct and it's happening right now to PZ Meyers who called a communion wafer a "cracker". He received death threats from Christians and the Catholic League has started a campaign to get him fired. They also tried to align with CAIR after PZ Meyers desecrated a Quran and a communion wafer. They don't belief free speech covers blasphemy and hurting feelings.

He received death threats from Christians? Well, I'm pretty sure they must have been Christians in name only. No true Christian would ever do that.

/sarc, but not really.

584 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:39:58am

re: #574 realwest

Remember when the Kursk sank? Putin wouldn't accept help from us or the British. Their own rescue equipment was unusable, due to poor maintenance and the theft of parts, but they still wouldn't let us help.

The Kursk was in 400 feet of water. We could have saved the trapped survivors, but Putin wouldn't let us.

What do you think that did for morale?

Things are not that much better, now, and I don't think the Russian army has much faith in their political leadership - nor should they have!

I will not start ranting. I will not start ranting. I will not start ranting....

585 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:40:15am

Captured Russian pilot being interrogated by Georgia

I really think Georgia is going to get the short end of the stick.

586 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:40:58am

re: #577 David IV of Georgia

I think you and I are feeling equally gloomy, here.

587 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:41:14am

re: #580 Killgore Trout

I'm sorry you find free speech a tedious topic. Nobody is forcing you to discuss it.

Please show me where I posted that free speech is a tedious subject. I clearly stated that I was exercising my free speech right from the start. What I did object to, if you had read the post accurately, was you beating the subject to death. My second reply factually stated that no Christian here at LGF is doing what you report (that "some Christians" are doing). I suggest you take it up with "them". I also added IMHO, because after all, that is all I can speak for.

588 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:42:06am

re: #583 A. van Hilten

Yup death threats against him and even his children. Last I checked he didn't even get any hate mail from Muslims even after he soiled a Quran.

589 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:42:22am

re: #578 Colonel Panik

One wonders, sometimes, if things could get worse. Then I remember Zhirinovsky, and shake my head.

Poor Russia.

590 realwest  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:42:28am

re: #565 JHW
Holy shit. I never heard of that stuff before (which simply means I'm ignorant, not a question of whether or not the stuff you linked to was true!).
Having been a combat infantryman it's inconceivable to me that the regular fighting units of the Army would have tolerated that crap.
Course, we are talking American vs. Soviet so....!
I think the key phrase in your first link was this one:
" NKVD was given enormous power to deal with those suspected of disloyalty and their families, including that of execution without trial." [emphasis added, realwest].
Thank you for those links.

591 David IV of Georgia  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:42:40am

re: #583 A. van Hilten

He received death threats from Christians? Well, I'm pretty sure they must have been Christians in name only. No true Christian would ever do that.

/sarc, but not really.

Any Christian might say the wrong thing if provoked enough, but any true Christian would soon feel remorse afterwards. It is funny (odd, not ha-ha) that some people call themselves Christian, take umbrage if you question their faith or commitment, yet feel perfectly within their rights to say and do things condemned by Christ and his Apostles.

592 JHW  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:42:56am

re: #584 Dianna

To this day, if you visit many Russian websites discussing this, there are numerous people, the Russian version of "troofers", swearing up and down that the USA did this and murdered those sailors. Motive does not occur to them.

593 Colonel Panik  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:43:18am
594 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:43:33am

re: #584 Dianna

my guess is they wouldn't let us get near the Kursk so we wouldn;t be able to see how advanced or not their equipment was at the time

595 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:43:44am

re: #587 sattv4u2

What I did object to, if you had read the post accurately, was you beating the subject to death.


I don't care if you like it or not. Scroll on past, I don't mind.

596 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:44:18am

re: #593 Colonel Panik

Not the comfy chair!

597 DaChew  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:44:53am

The Russians bombed civilians? Wow. International ANSWER is going to be all over those guys. /sarc

598 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:45:21am

re: #595 Killgore Trout

I don't care if you like it or not. Scroll on past, I don't mind.

and by the same token, I don't mind if you care for the critique or not. i'm sure you also have scroll capabilities

599 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:45:38am

re: #574 realwest

Thanks Dianna and all I can say is "wow" - what kinda effin army could they possibly have? Assault, surrender or retreat and die - doesn't necessarily amount to a really "motivated" regular army, ya know?

You should pick up or borrow a copy of THE LIBERATORS and INSIDE THE SOVIET ARMY by Victor Suvorov. He eventually joined Soviet Military Intelligence (GRU) (third book INSIDE THE AQUARIUM) and defected to the U.K.

When Suvorov join the GRU they showed him a film of a traitor being cremated alive pour encourager autres,

600 godfrey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:45:43am

re: #548 Killgore Trout

PZ Myers, former Lutheran and now professed atheist, took a consecrated host from a Catholic Mass, did not consume it, and kept it at his home for a week. This isn't about "free speech," Killgore. This is the action of a low-class cad, nothing more. How can he, or anyone, possibly expect respect when he effectively lies about himself, takes something as sacred that he doesn't believe is sacred, mocks its believers, and then sets himself up as some kind of martyr when they protest?

He can mock and say whatever he wants, but don't expect him to be given a free pass for his mendacity.

601 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:46:23am

NATO warns Russia over Georgia move

Over recent weeks Russia appears to have been significantly turning up the pressure in Abkhazia and South Ossetia, the BBC's diplomatic correspondent Jonathan Marcus says.

He says that many Western diplomats see these moves as part of a more assertive Russian policy in the wake of Western recognition of the independence of Kosovo in February.

The row over Moscow's support for separatist enclaves in Georgia now threatens to provoke a more serious strain between Russia and the West, our correspondent adds.

Ya think?

602 yma o hyd  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:46:33am

re: #588 Killgore Trout

Yup death threats against him and even his children. Last I checked he didn't even get any hate mail from Muslims even after he soiled a Quran.

Just a very humble question - how do we know he isn't suppressing the Muslim hate mail?
Are we really meant to belive that not one single Muslim hothead has e-mailed him?

603 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:46:38am

re: #592 JHW

I've seen those. It makes me so very angry.

604 medaura18586  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:46:58am

re: #527 A. van Hilten

There seems to be an underlying connection between white supremacist, hardocre creationist, pro-Chetnik propagandist groups that vindicates LGF's position on this issues.

These supremacist positions are psychologically consistent. People who fall prey to one of them, tend to gravitate towards the others, for the same emotional reasons which made them embrace the first node on this loose chain.

605 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:47:40am

re: #594 sattv4u2

That was part of it. But "national pride" had more to do with it. Plus a very Russian attitude toward personnel.

606 Colonel Panik  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:47:42am

re: #596 Killgore Trout

Not the comfy chair!

DIABOLICAL LAUGHTER

607 JHW  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:47:48am

re: #590 realwest

Yes that part stuck out at me, too. Just like the Nazi concept of Sippenhaft. Rommel's family were very fortunate they weren't executed. Sippenhaft

608 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:48:38am

re: #584 Dianna

Remember when the Kursk sank? Putin wouldn't accept help from us or the British. Their own rescue equipment was unusable, due to poor maintenance and the theft of parts, but they still wouldn't let us help.

The Kursk was in 400 feet of water. We could have saved the trapped survivors, but Putin wouldn't let us.

What do you think that did for morale?

Things are not that much better, now, and I don't think the Russian army has much faith in their political leadership - nor should they have!

I will not start ranting. I will not start ranting. I will not start ranting....

The Pentagon knew before Moscow the Kursk had gone done. We had an LA Class 688 sub in the area observing the exercise. The Pentagon put the Mystic or Avalon on alert, the DSRV rescue sub, I don't remember which one is on the East Coast, and lined up a C-5 to take it to Murmansk. Moscow got the call from the Pentagon offering help about the same time they heard about the problem. That rattled them a bit, that we already had rescue equipment in motion before they even knew about it.

609 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:49:05am

re: #599 The Other Les

Suvorov's books should always be read with a touch of caution, but they are a very valuable resource.

610 The Other Les  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:49:24am

re: #590 realwest

This is the kind of barbarism that our own Leftists are going to have to practice if they try to rule as they wish to rule.

611 realwest  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:49:32am

Well this has been unusually grand and informative all y'all, but I gotta go mush some lunch now!
I hope you all have a GREAT DAY and that I get the chance to see you down the road!

612 JHW  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:49:50am

re: #603 Dianna

Me too. It's partly this feeling of persecution and paranoia, very ancient, I find disturbing.

613 medaura18586  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:50:08am

re: #583 A. van Hilten

He received death threats from Christians? Well, I'm pretty sure they must have been Christians in name only. No true Christian would ever do that.

/sarc, but not really.

Here, here!

614 David IV of Georgia  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:50:26am

re: #586 Dianna

I think you and I are feeling equally gloomy, here.

My trouble is that I know a lot of Russians. They are great people. They have the potential of being a great asset to the whole earth. But too many of them are just interested in the next paycheck or the next bottle of vodka. They seem to take the idea of Moscow being "Third Rome" (after Constantinople and Italian Rome) to mean they have the right to assume they have carte blanche in world affairs. It would do them well to imitate the best parts of Rome and not use the blood link between Tsar and Caesar as an excuse for boorishness.

615 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:51:08am

re: #608 jcm

And they still wouldn't let us help!

616 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:51:39am

re: #600 godfrey

PZ Myers, former Lutheran and now professed atheist, took a consecrated host from a Catholic Mass, did not consume it, and kept it at his home for a week.

Wrong. Are you lying or just uniformed?

617 godfrey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:51:52am

re: #613 medaura18586

Needless to say, I think any death threats against Myers are totally anti-Christian and despicable.

618 Dianna  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:52:17am

re: #614 David IV of Georgia

I know.

Sorry, but I must go. I have to walk dogs and then head over for martial arts.

Take care, and try not to get too depressed.

619 medaura18586  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:52:20am

re: #613 medaura18586

Here, here!


Attacking my husband with the real deal (no sarc tag for this person):
[Link: www.jihadwatch.org...]

Good grief...

When Christians act up it is in spite of Christianity, not because of it. When muslims act up it is because of Islam, not in spite of it...

620 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:52:56am

re: #612 JHW

Me too. It's partly this feeling of persecution and paranoia, very ancient, I find disturbing.

The Russian language is paranoid. I took Russian in college. We would say if asked, John went to the library. In Russian it translates as, John left to go to the library. The underlying thought is I don't know if he's there, he told me that's where he's going. That paranoia is all through the language.

621 godfrey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:53:08am

re: #616 Killgore Trout

The wiki on Myers is not contested. I freely admit that it's all I know of the controversy. If it's wrong, show where it's wrong.

622 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:54:11am

re: #615 Dianna

And they still wouldn't let us help!

Face, too much loss of face. That we could be on the Kursk with a rescue operation from 12,000 miles away before the Russians a hundred miles way was a huge blow to their ego.

623 godfrey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:54:32am

re: #621 godfrey

Killgore, you're right. I misread the Wiki.

624 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:56:38am

re: #620 jcm
The Russian language is paranoid. That paranoia is all through the language

Sounds as if Clinton and Obama have taken Russian (depends on what the definition of IS is,,,, Thats not the ((fill the blank)) that I knew)

625 JHW  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:56:57am

re: #620 jcm

interesting. About 5 minutes of listening to Russian speech convinced me it was a no go, I'd never be able to reproduce those sounds. I did study Japanese and you're on to something in my opinion, that you can discern a lot about national characteristics by the way they use language, their thought patterns in general.

626 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:57:37am

re: #624 sattv4u2

The Russian language is paranoid. That paranoia is all through the language

Sounds as if Clinton and Obama have taken Russian (depends on what the definition of IS is,,,, Thats not the ((fill the blank)) that I knew)

LOL! Good one.

627 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:58:21am

re: #621 godfrey

Read it more carefully. Somebody else had done that, he just commented on his blog about it. For his commentary (just words) he received death threats to him and his children and a campaign to get him fired. His response was to desecrate a Quran and a wafer himself. They were his property and nobody was actually harmed by his actions.

628 Quilly Mammoth  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:58:54am

I knew LTC Peters was going too fast. This just in:

A 19-year-old Russian conscript, a member of a tank crew, said his unit was supposed to take part in a military exercise in North Ossetia but was suddenly sent into South Ossetia. The soldier, who asked not be named because he wasn't allowed to speak to reporters, said that his tank accompanied a motorized infantry unit that was hit by Georgian shelling and suffered casualties. The tank was broken and the soldiers were trying to fix it on the edge of the woods.

629 David IV of Georgia  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:59:05am

re: #622 jcm


There are times when putting ego aside is the best course to follow. We would have no doubt gladly let them take credit for the initiative and the rescue. They could have turned this into moment that built pride and morale. But no...

630 Colonel Panik  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:59:15am

re: #620 jcm

The Russian language is paranoid. I took Russian in college. We would say if asked, John went to the library. In Russian it translates as, John left to go to the library. The underlying thought is I don't know if he's there, he told me that's where he's going. That paranoia is all through the language.

1500+ years of invasions by Mongols, Tatars, Turks, Germans, etc. etc., the burdens of living in a harsh climate and a history of authoritarian rule have contributed to the ingrained paranoia of the Russian mindset.

Is is what it is.

631 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 11:59:16am

re: #623 godfrey

That's ok, these things happen.

632 jcm  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:00:23pm

re: #630 Colonel Panik

1500+ years of invasions by Mongols, Tatars, Turks, Germans, etc. etc., the burdens of living in a harsh climate and a history of authoritarian rule have contributed to the ingrained paranoia of the Russian mindset.

Is is what it is.

Very likely, very likely.

633 Colonel Panik  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:01:10pm

re: #630 Colonel Panik

PIMF "It is what it is."

634 ashan  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:02:29pm

This confrontation is, above all, about that pipleline. Putin wants to control all of the energy resources available to his enemies, including the US, UK and Israel. (Israeli military advisors have been in Georgia for some time.) In addition to trying to wrest the pipleline away from Georgia, I get the feeling that this Russian invasion has something to do with deflecting attention away from its major client state, Iran.

Russia is speeding things along to a major international conflict. The sparks of world wars sometimes arise from less likely origins.

635 David IV of Georgia  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:03:57pm

re: #630 Colonel Panik

1500+ years of invasions by Mongols, Tatars, Turks, Germans, etc. etc., the burdens of living in a harsh climate and a history of authoritarian rule have contributed to the ingrained paranoia of the Russian mindset.

Is is what it is.

One reason the Russian people migrated further and further north was that most of the invaders and would be invaders hesitated to go to those frozen lands.
After all, how many times have you heard of the Eskimo peoples having to defend themselves from invaders?

636 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:04:59pm

re: #600 godfrey

PZ Myers, former Lutheran and now professed atheist, took a consecrated host from a Catholic Mass, did not consume it, and kept it at his home for a week. This isn't about "free speech," Killgore. This is the action of a low-class cad, nothing more. How can he, or anyone, possibly expect respect when he effectively lies about himself, takes something as sacred that he doesn't believe is sacred, mocks its believers, and then sets himself up as some kind of martyr when they protest?

He can mock and say whatever he wants, but don't expect him to be given a free pass for his mendacity.

So, in your view, desecrating a host is just as unrespectful as making death threats against the perpetrators and their families? Well, I don't think the FBI would agree with your moral yardstick, though.

Also, you're failing to notice here that to any non-believer the host is an inanimate object like any other. To Catholics it may represent something else, but PZ Myers can use and even abuse the thing without any moral qualms on his part. Just like a Qur'an or a Bible.

If you think a Qur'an is unholy and can thus be desecrated because it doesn't contain the true word of God, then you're applying a double standard whereby you selectively claim to find outrageous only the abuse of religious icons that don't mean anything to you.

OTOH, making death threats is objectively wrong from any moral POV deserving of that name (and a crime to boot).

637 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:12:18pm

re: #636 A. van Hilten

So, in your view, desecrating a host is just as unrespectful as making death threats against the perpetrators and their families?

I have read Godfreys post 3 times, and nowhere does he make that leap, as you assert he has. As a matter of fact, the worst he accuses Myers of is being "low-class cad, nothing more"

638 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:17:03pm

re: #637 sattv4u2

So, in your view, desecrating a host is just as unrespectful as making death threats against the perpetrators and their families?

I have read Godfreys post 3 times, and nowhere does he make that leap, as you assert he has. As a matter of fact, the worst he accuses Myers of is being "low-class cad, nothing more"

Sorry if I've misread his post, but the PZ Myers 'kerfuffle' is not about respect (for Myers' ideas), it's about his freedom to espouse whatever crap he likes and people making death threats because they can't suffer his crap to be published in a blog. This is what Godfrey wrote: "How can he, or anyone, possibly expect respect ...?"

Again, it's not about respect. It's about freedom of speech and death threats.

639 willowone  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:18:07pm

re: #637 sattv4u2
in fact he said at post above;re: Godfrey at post 617

Needless to say, I think any death threats against Myers are totally anti-Christian and despicable

640 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:19:46pm

re: #638 A. van Hilten

Which brings us back to Reynolds post: FREE SPEECH UPDATE


Will other religious groups take the lesson that violence works? Because, in a world of the spineless, it does, and at very low cost.

The answer is of course "yes".

641 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:22:03pm

re: #600 godfrey

PZ Myers, former Lutheran and now professed atheist, took a consecrated host from a Catholic Mass, did not consume it, and kept it at his home for a week. This isn't about "free speech," Killgore. This is the action of a low-class cad, nothing more. How can he, or anyone, possibly expect respect when he effectively lies about himself, takes something as sacred that he doesn't believe is sacred, mocks its believers, and then sets himself up as some kind of martyr when they protest?

He can mock and say whatever he wants, but don't expect him to be given a free pass for his mendacity.

Agreed.

Killgore has some doubts about whether Myers "stole" the consecrated host, or the preferred term here, cracker.

But since the "crackers" are consecrated immediately prior to communion, the only way to obtain one is to attend a Mass (or have some attend in your place), and take one.

I said on another thread that I don't think God cares much whether the term used is wafer, host or cracker, and I believe that.

But it is wrong, morally if not legally, to steal a consecrated host this way.

642 godfrey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:23:40pm

re: #631 Killgore Trout

'salright. I've been heaving into a toilet for the past 36 hours, so I appreciate being given a break. I wouldn't have defended Cook, though, who was no more than a cad for doing what he did.

re: #638 A. van Hilten

Cf. my 617.

If I were in that church, and Cook had done that in my presence, you can bet I would've invited him outside. And there would be no double-standard. I would get in his face about his scurrility and lying. Sacrilege? That one's ultimately on his head, not mine.

643 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:25:18pm

re: #638 A. van Hilten

Sorry if I've misread his post, but the PZ Myers 'kerfuffle' is not about respect (for Myers' ideas), it's about his freedom to espouse whatever crap he likes and people making death threats because they can't suffer his crap to be published in a blog. This is what Godfrey wrote: "How can he, or anyone, possibly expect respect ...?"

Again, it's not about respect. It's about freedom of speech and death threats.

No one here that I can see has argued for or excused the death threats. People making those threats should be prosecuted to the fullest extent possible.

Believing that Myers is a cad is, really, entirely different from making a death threat. GET over yourself.

And attening a Mass (or having someone do it in your place) for the sole purpose of stealing a consecrated host, violates the freedom of Catholics to worship in their own church, at their own service, free from this type of disruption.

644 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:25:35pm

re: #638 A. van Hilten

Sorry if I've misread his post, but the PZ Myers 'kerfuffle' is not about respect (for Myers' ideas), it's about his freedom to espouse whatever crap he likes and people making death threats because they can't suffer his crap to be published in a blog. This is what Godfrey wrote: "How can he, or anyone, possibly expect respect ...?"

Again, it's not about respect. It's about freedom of speech and death threats.

true, But you took Godfrey to task claiming that he was equating death threats to desecrating a host/ wafer/ cookie/ cracker or whatever else anyone wants to call it

645 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:25:43pm

re: #641 reine.de.tout

Killgore has some doubts about whether Myers "stole" the consecrated host, or the preferred term here, cracker.

I've thought more about it and I strongly suspect that he just lead people to believe they were consecrated because otherwise it wouldn't be blasphemous. But does it really matter? Can you tell by looking at it? If two crackers are sullied and only one was blessed how do you know which one is offensive. It's a very silly thing to be upset about.

646 willowone  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:26:24pm

just a question here. we all have different religious pursuasions here, do we really expect anyone outside of our particular religious ideal to have same respect as we do about our own, and even though those outside of our faith might do something classless to our religious "things" do we have any right to threatenn them?

647 willowone  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:26:52pm

in any way or form

648 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:27:12pm

re: #645 Killgore Trout

I've thought more about it and I strongly suspect that he just lead people to believe they were consecrated because otherwise it wouldn't be blasphemous. But does it really matter? Can you tell by looking at it? If two crackers are sullied and only one was blessed how do you know which one is offensive. It's a very silly thing to be upset about.

The thing I'm upset about is Myers' violating the religious freedom of Catholics to attend their own Mass, in their own church, at their own time, by setting up the theft of the cracker during the service.

649 medaura18586  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:27:43pm

Hilten, Killgore:

I have added 3 paragraphs to the very bottom of my piece which I think deserve some stand-alone thought. They're there now if you would want to check it out.

650 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:28:17pm

re: #640 Killgore Trout

Spencer is on a roll lately: First, he accuses Glenn Reynolds of moral relativism and now he endorses Jatras.

That is why Christians do not generally resort to threats of violence against those who say things about Jesus that they don't like.

Apparently, some folks didn't get the memo.

651 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:28:21pm

re: #644 sattv4u2

true, But you took Godfrey to task claiming that he was equating death threats to desecrating a host/ wafer/ cookie/ cracker or whatever else anyone wants to call it

I'm beginning to suspect there are some here who would dearly love to see the end of the free speech rights of religious folks to have and hold and express an opinion

652 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:29:01pm

re: #646 willowone

just a question here. we all have different religious pursuasions here, do we really expect anyone outside of our particular religious ideal to have same respect as we do about our own, and even though those outside of our faith might do something classless to our religious "things" do we have any right to threatenn them?

I've been invited to many services in a temple 9I'm Roman Catholic0 and I would not even THINK about going in wearing a yarmulke with a propeller on it, or some othre such foolishness

653 yma o hyd  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:30:45pm

re: #646 willowone

just a question here. we all have different religious pursuasions here, do we really expect anyone outside of our particular religious ideal to have same respect as we do about our own, and even though those outside of our faith might do something classless to our religious "things" do we have any right to threatenn them?

Good question.
I'd expect the same respect shown to mine as I'm showing to that of others.
If someone feels the need to do, as you say something classless to my religious things - well, its on their heads. No need for me to threaten them, nor assuming that I have the right to do so.

654 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:31:35pm

re: #646 willowone

just a question here. we all have different religious pursuasions here, do we really expect anyone outside of our particular religious ideal to have same respect as we do about our own, and even though those outside of our faith might do something classless to our religious "things" do we have any right to threatenn them?

No one here has approved of threats to Myers or his family, and those who issue those threats should be prosecuted fully.

However, I do believe, and will always believe, that the practitioners of any religion have a right to hold their services, in their own buildings, without having to worry about people coming in for the purpose of taking items that the church-goers hold to be valuable.

655 yma o hyd  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:31:56pm

re: #651 reine.de.tout

I'm beginning to suspect there are some here who would dearly love to see the end of the free speech rights of religious folks to have and hold and express an opinion

I agree.

656 willowone  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:32:12pm

i agree it would be in bad taste to do so in shul, yet although it would be pathetic, would I have the right to threaten a person? i think asking them to leave , in this case i see a choice wasn't given, and i understand the frustration with this deplorable behavior, but, it is more to you and yours then it was to them. and i would think the spirit of anything means more than our specific trappings we use to connect to G-d

657 Colonel Panik  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:32:35pm

re: #646 willowone

How do we even know these "threats" are real. This PZ Meyers a**wipe seems like an attention whoring moonbat to me, of the type that used to be roundly condemned on LGF.

658 willowone  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:32:48pm

re: #654 reine.de.tout

and i agree, it was deplorable ugly, and insulting to himself .

659 willowone  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:33:43pm

re: #657 Colonel Panik
actually i dont know who any of these people are other than robert spencer, and i am disturbed by whats being said about him, i will have to research to battle this idea, or validate it.

660 willowone  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:35:25pm

re: #653 yma o hyd
i would hope people ARE decent enough to repect others traditions . and i DO unless forced upon me .

661 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:35:39pm

re: #656 willowone

i agree it would be in bad taste to do so in shul, yet although it would be pathetic, would I have the right to threaten a person? i think asking them to leave , in this case i see a choice wasn't given, and i understand the frustration with this deplorable behavior, but, it is more to you and yours then it was to them. and i would think the spirit of anything means more than our specific trappings we use to connect to G-d

No you would not, and I will repeat what I have said above several times, because it keeps getting thrown back out there -
No one here that I've seen has advocated for or approved of death threats being made, and anyone who makes such threats should be prosecuted to the fullest extent possible.

Does that mean I have to like Myers and his actions?
No.

662 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:36:08pm

re: #657 Colonel Panik

How do we even know these "threats" are real. This PZ Meyers a**wipe seems like an attention whoring moonbat to me, of the type that used to be roundly condemned on LGF.

I believe they are real - he has, I think, put some up on his website with names.

663 willowone  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:37:09pm

re: #661 reine.de.tout
understood

664 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:37:41pm

re: #648 reine.de.tout

The thing I'm upset about is Myers' violating the religious freedom of Catholics to attend their own Mass, in their own church, at their own time, by setting up the theft of the cracker during the service.


You're assuming he stole it and disrupted a service. There's no evidence of that. He's not infringing on anybody's freedom. It's all in your head.

665 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:39:28pm

re: #657 Colonel Panik

There have been police investigations. Are you suggesting this is an inside job like the Twin Towers? C'mon, get real.

666 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:39:35pm

re: #644 sattv4u2

true, But you took Godfrey to task claiming that he was equating death threats to desecrating a host/ wafer/ cookie/ cracker or whatever else anyone wants to call it

Actually, I asked him if he thought both acts were equally disrespectful, because he seemed to imply that Myers had done something that could justify people getting pissed off. IMO, they're not comparable even if you're a Catholic:

How can he, or anyone, possibly expect respect when he effectively lies about himself, takes something as sacred that he doesn't believe is sacred, mocks its believers, and then sets himself up as some kind of martyr when they protest?

People were not protesting, they were theatening him and his family, and trying to get him fired. And I can't see how Myers was setting himself up "as some kind of martyr."

667 Shay4l  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:39:57pm

re: #388 Marvo76

[Link: europebusines.blogspot.com...]

I posted this on the overnight thread


The morons posting after that story act like Bush is the cause of all this crap going on in the world. Like Putin doesn't exist, the mullahs are puppets of American wishes, China has no free will, etc. What a bunch of BDS loons.

668 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:41:34pm

re: #664 Killgore Trout

You're assuming he stole it and disrupted a service. There's no evidence of that. He's not infringing on anybody's freedom. It's all in your head.

He could only have gotten it during a service. The crackers are consecrated immediately prior to communion. One cannot just buy box of crackers and say, voila, here is a consecrated cracker.

And no, no indication at all that whoever stole the cracker made any sort of big fuss about it at all, at the time. The fuss was made after the fact. But to go to a Mass, in a Catholic Church, for the sole purpose of taking something of value from that Mass, is a disruption to the religious freedom of Catholics to worship.

669 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:42:35pm

re: #651 reine.de.tout

I'm beginning to suspect there are some here who would dearly love to see the end of the free speech rights of religious folks to have and hold and express an opinion

Now this is what setting yourself up as some kind of martyr actually looks like.

670 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:42:36pm

re: #664 Killgore Trout

A), if he got it by purchasing it (which he can , as they are available in quantity at religious stores) then it is not a Communion "cracker', as it would have as yet to be consecrated

B) if he did go to a church and got it under false pretense during the service, he is, as Godfrey accused him of (and nothing else BTW) a "low-class cad, nothing more"

So either A) he lied or B) he is a cad

671 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:45:57pm

Killgore - Let's say someone came to your house, and pretended to be all nice and friendly and wonderful.

Then after they leave, it becomes apparent that during their visit, they have taken something of great monetary or sentimental value.

Would you consider that your space had been violated?

672 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:49:47pm

re: #668 reine.de.tout

He could only have gotten it during a service. The crackers are consecrated immediately prior to communion. One cannot just buy box of crackers and say, voila, here is a consecrated cracker.

And no, no indication at all that whoever stole the cracker made any sort of big fuss about it at all, at the time. The fuss was made after the fact. But to go to a Mass, in a Catholic Church, for the sole purpose of taking something of value from that Mass, is a disruption to the religious freedom of Catholics to worship.

How so?

673 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:50:18pm

re: #668 reine.de.tout

Once again. There's no evidence that he disrupted a service and he did not infringe on anybody else's rights. He does not deserve to lose his job, his life or his children over this. This is a campaign of intimidation to stifle free speech, which is why they solicited help from CAIR. You can't possibly imagine yourself or other Catholics as the victims here. Can you?

674 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:51:18pm

re: #671 reine.de.tout

Yes that would be stealing. There's no evidence he did that. It's stuck in you imagination and you can't let go of it.

675 Quilly Mammoth  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:51:25pm

re: #670 sattv4u2

A), if he got it by purchasing it (which he can , as they are available in quantity at religious stores) then it is not a Communion "cracker', as it would have as yet to be consecrated

B) if he did go to a church and got it under false pretense during the service, he is, as Godfrey accused him of (and nothing else BTW) a "low-class cad, nothing more"

So either A) he lied or B) he is a cad

Indeed. To those who are Catholic it _is_ the body of Christ...so it's deliberately insulting. And it looks like Pope Paul VI was right

It [Communion in the hand] carries certain dangers with it which may arise from the new manner of administering holy Communion: the danger of a loss of reverence for the August sacrament of the altar, of profanation, of adulterating the true doctrine." - Pope Paul VI in his instruction Memoriale Domini (May 29, 1969)

As a Lutheran I believe that once he took the Host under false pretenses it is no longer sacred. So it doesn't bother me at all.

676 kuchuklambat  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:52:00pm

re: #634 ashan

I am with you -- the Ezekiel Option, I can totally see it. Is Putin's PhD thesis available on the Web? Russian press and blogs are so full of adoration for their brave Medvedev who rose to defend etc., Russian troops referred to as "peacemakers" exclusively, it's Mother Russia far out. And suddenly these armed "volunteers" materialize to cross into South Ossetia, presumably for dirtier work than the regular army wants to touch.

677 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:54:02pm

re: #673 Killgore Trout

Once again. There's no evidence that he disrupted a service and he did not infringe on anybody else's rights. He does not deserve to lose his job, his life or his children over this. This is a campaign of intimidation to stifle free speech, which is why they solicited help from CAIR. You can't possibly imagine yourself or other Catholics as the victims here. Can you?

Once again:

I DO NOT APPROVE of the death threats, and neither has anyone here.

I DO NOT APPROVE of attempts to force his employer to fire him.

I HAVE NO GREAT RESPECT for the Catholic League or what they do.

I have said the above at other times.

Those points are agreed upon; to continue to ask me these questions is no longer a discussion, it is a harangue.

If he, or someone at his behest, attended a Mass, a religious service for Catholics by Catholics, for the purpose of taking something that Catholics hold to be of value, then yes, without making a sound, he violated (or caused to be violated) the absolute right of Catholics (or any religious group) in this country to worship in peace.

678 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:55:23pm

re: #674 Killgore Trout

Yes that would be stealing. There's no evidence he did that. It's stuck in you imagination and you can't let go of it.

How is someone visiting your house, pretending to be sincere in their friendship for you, and taking something of value from you, different form someone visiting a house of worship, in this case a Catholic Church, pretending to be sincere in their worship, and then taking something of value?

679 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:56:47pm

re: #675 Quilly Mammoth

Hell,. as a Roman Catholic I could give 2 rats asses how he got it or what he did with it IN PRIVATE. Once he flaunted what he was going too or did with it, it became public domain and can be held up for praise or ridicule

680 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:57:17pm

re: #675 Quilly Mammoth

As a Lutheran I believe that once he took the Host under false pretenses it is no longer sacred. So it doesn't bother me at all.

The issue for me is that this guy asked his readers to violate the sanctity of a religious worship service for the purpose of attaining this item.

He has no respect for the rights of others; but obviously expects everyone to honor his rights.

He's a hypocrite.

681 David IV of Georgia  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:57:52pm

I think what Myers did was disgraceful. I have no particular interest in the sacraments of the Roman Catholic Church. I do however, have an obligation to defend the Sacred Host of my Church even if it means I die doing so. I have no right to kill, or threaten harm but you would have to kill me before you desecrate the Host while I am able to hinder it. What the FBI or any other entity has to say is not even an issue. If that seems a double standard to you then I have a double standard.

As for threatening him after the fact, it's stupid, unChristian and pointless. At some point a person must step aside and let God decide how He wishes to defend His honor.

682 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 12:59:19pm

re: #681 David IV of Georgia

I think what Myers did was disgraceful. I have no particular interest in the sacraments of the Roman Catholic Church. I do however, have an obligation to defend the Sacred Host of my Church even if it means I die doing so. I have no right to kill, or threaten harm but you would have to kill me before you desecrate the Host while I am able to hinder it. What the FBI or any other entity has to say is not even an issue. If that seems a double standard to you then I have a double standard.

As for threatening him after the fact, it's stupid, unChristian and pointless. At some point a person must step aside and let God decide how He wishes to defend His honor.

Agreed. And I have not seen anyone here supporting those threats. Some people here keep bringing up those threats, as if some of us are arguing that it's OK.

THE THREATS ARE NOT OK, AND THOSE WHO ISSUED THEM SHOULD BE FOUND AND PROSECUTED.

683 Colonel Panik  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:00:30pm

re: #665 Killgore Trout

There have been police investigations. Are you suggesting this is an inside job like the Twin Towers? C'mon, get real.

No, Killgore, I'm suggesting he's a moonbat attention whore like that college professor in So Cal who covered her own car in "racist and sexist" graffiti and then claimed "hate crime".

If he has gotten actual death threats, as stated by an actual LE agency then I would condemn anyone who did that but I still think the guy is a moonbat attention whore.

And I am really, really, annoyed that you would compare me with a 9-11 Troofer.

If you don't apologise for that you have just earned yourself a permanent enemy on this blog. Those are fighting words as far as I am concerned.

I need to go eat a late brunch, but I will be back later and I expect to see your apology for comparing me with troofers.

684 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:02:16pm

re: #678 reine.de.tout


How is someone visiting your house, pretending to be sincere in their friendship for you, and taking something of value from you, different form someone visiting a house of worship, in this case a Catholic Church, pretending to be sincere in their worship, and then taking something of value?


Once again, there's no evidence that occurred. It's all in your imagination. But that's not really what this is about. This is about hurt feelings. He disrespected a symbol and that's upsetting to a lot of people. It causes some people to resort to violence and intimidation. Blasphemy is a victimless crime.

685 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:03:12pm

re: #683 Colonel Panik


If you don't apologise for that you have just earned yourself a permanent enemy on this blog.


Bite me, nuttsy.

686 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:03:40pm

re: #677 reine.de.tout

If he, or someone at his behest, attended a Mass, a religious service for Catholics by Catholics, for the purpose of taking something that Catholics hold to be of value, then yes, without making a sound, he violated (or caused to be violated) the absolute right of Catholics (or any religious group) in this country to worship in peace.

How is taking a consecrated host out of mass for whatever purpose an infringement on other people's right to worship as they wish? It may well be disrespectful (though respect is subjective), but if one doesn't even notice the host has gone missing, how does it make any difference (unless the person who took it actually acknowledges his actions after the fact)?

687 yma o hyd  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:04:00pm

re: #680 reine.de.tout

The issue for me is that this guy asked his readers to violate the sanctity of a religious worship service for the purpose of attaining this item.

He has no respect for the rights of others; but obviously expects everyone to honor his rights.

He's a hypocrite.

I also think he is a liar.
I simply do not believe that not a single one of the many hot-headed Muslims which prowl the internet hasn't left a threat on his site for desecrating the Qur'an. That is totally against the experience of many bloggers who have not even gone that far.
I believe this is a set-up, and while i accept that there were threats from Christina extremists, I'm beginning to think that these are now utilised to tar the whole of Christianity with the same brush and allow certain interested parties to compare Christians in toto to islamist jihadis.

688 Colonel Panik  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:06:34pm

re: #685 Killgore Trout

Fish rot from the head.

689 medaura18586  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:06:40pm

re: #683 Colonel Panik

Then just wait how annoyed you will be when I compare you to a Holocaust Denier.

/ooops.. already done that.

690 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:07:12pm

re: #684 Killgore Trout

Once again, there's no evidence that occurred. It's all in your imagination. But that's not really what this is about. This is about hurt feelings. He disrespected a symbol and that's upsetting to a lot of people. It causes some people to resort to violence and intimidation. Blasphemy is a victimless crime.

He claims to have used a consecrated cracker. Since the crackers are consecrated during Mass, immediately prior to distribution of communion, then the only way he could have a consecrated cracker is to have taken one from Mass, during Mass.

Going into a house of worship (or a private home), pretending to be sincere worshipful (or friendly), then taking an item of value, is a violation of that group's space (or the home owner's space).

691 right_on_target  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:07:52pm

Georgia needs some A10sre: #299 MadJadBad

Ironic or coincidental? Joseph Stalin was born in Gori, Georgia.

Stalin wasn't Russian and Hitler wasn't German and Napoleon was Corsecan.
All above were dictatorial despots.

That's why the POTUS needs to be BORN in the USA and the Constitution says he should!

692 right_on_target  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:09:18pm

Weird, I had two comments pending and they both came together!

693 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:09:51pm

re: #692 right_on_target

Weird, I had two comments pending and they both came together!

are they now both having a cigarette?

694 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:11:37pm

re: #681 David IV of Georgia

What the FBI or any other entity has to say is not even an issue. If that seems a double standard to you then I have a double standard.

Actually, it seems more like what Muslims invoke to justify their violence (and I'm not trying to lump you in with them, but the argument is equally valid): that they only abide by the Qur'an and Western laws be damned. By your own line of reasoning they're also justified in issuing 'death fatwas' against the Danish guy who made the Mohammed cartoon of blasphemy.

695 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:12:14pm

re: #687 yma o hyd

I believe this is a set-up, and while i accept that there were threats from Christina extremists, I'm beginning to think that these are now utilised to tar the whole of Christianity with the same brush and allow certain interested parties to compare Christians in toto to islamist jihadis.

Now it's a conspiracy? You are aware that the Islamists also use this "logic" for their perceived "war on Ilsam". The Danish cartoons were drawn by the Israelis to inflame the Muslims world into murderous riots thereby making them look bad. What's really at work here, like the Muslims, is a victim mentality. In this case an atheist gets death threats and risks losing his job but Christians are still the victims? It's insanity! Also this victim mentality allows people to overreact and send death threats because they are being victimized and must fight back. You are taking Christianity in the wrong direction.

696 David IV of Georgia  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:14:01pm

re: #684 Killgore Trout

Blasphemy is a victimless crime.

You don't bother with ontology and cosmology much, do you?

If all that is is material, then blasphemy is indeed just empty words and actions. However, there are some people who believe that blasphemy is an introduction of new evil into the universe; it gives the universe a case of the flu as it were.

"What do they teach in schools these days?" - C.S Lewis 'The Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe'

697 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:14:39pm

re: #680 reine.de.tout

The issue for me is that this guy asked his readers to violate the sanctity of a religious worship service for the purpose of attaining this item.

He has no respect for the rights of others; but obviously expects everyone to honor his rights.

He's a hypocrite.


"He has no respect for the rights of others; but obviously expects everyone to honor his rights."

That would be his righ to free speech versus the right of Catholics to conduct a church service, which he did NOT disrupt.

And there you have it. The comparison between violating "the sanctity of a religious worship service" and the death threats.

Oooops!

698 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:16:16pm

re: #683 Colonel Panik

If you don't apologise for that you have just earned yourself a permanent enemy on this blog. Those are fighting words as far as I am concerned.

I need to go eat a late brunch, but I will be back later and I expect to see your apology for comparing me with troofers.

And the threats keep coming...

699 right_on_target  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:16:47pm

re: #330 Nevergiveup

Serious question. I don't know why the USA doesn't send high tech cameras into the war zone and televise those images LIVE all over the world?

There are probably military satellites zeroing over Georgia right now.

700 Colonel Panik  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:20:13pm

re: #689 medaura18586

Then just wait how annoyed you will be when I compare you to a Holocaust Denier.

/ooops.. already done that.

It's so ridiculous I think I'll just ignore it, which will probably annoy you even more. Although I do think your antics on this blog and others could make for an amusing comedy. I've even got a potential title for it:

MEDAURA! Cultural Learnings Of LittleGreenFootBlogs For Make Benefit Great Nation Albania.


And with that I truly need to break for lunch.

Toodles!

701 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:20:29pm

re: #697 A. van Hilten

"He has no respect for the rights of others; but obviously expects everyone to honor his rights."

That would be his righ to free speech versus the right of Catholics to conduct a church service, which he did NOT disrupt.

And there you have it. The comparison between violating "the sanctity of a religious worship service" and the death threats.

Oooops!

Once more, the death threats are wrong, anyone issuing such threats should be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law, I've seen no one here advocating otherwise.

702 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:21:17pm

re: #696 David IV of Georgia

You don't bother with ontology and cosmology much, do you?

If all that is is material, then blasphemy is indeed just empty words and actions. However, there are some people who believe that blasphemy is an introduction of new evil into the universe; it gives the universe a case of the flu as it were.

"What do they teach in schools these days?" - C.S Lewis 'The Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe'

I agree with you; the question is, should there be "blasphemy" laws, with civil or criminal penalties? I'm not convinced that there should be.

I do, however, believe that religious folks in this country should have a right to hold a worship service, with all that is entailed in that service, without fear that insincere folks will come in to that service and violate the sanctity of it.

If I read Killgore's line of reasoning correctly, then apparently, while it would be theft if someone were to go to his home, insincerely pretending to be friendly but taking something of monetary or sentimental value when they left, but doing the same thing in a house of worship isn't any sort of a big deal to be upset about.

If that's the case, then any church, temple or any house of worship in this country would be in for total chaos, as anyone could come in and take whatever struck their fancy. And because it's a house of worship (rather than a private home), then, gee, no big deal.

703 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:24:01pm

re: #702 reine.de.tout

If I read Killgore's line of reasoning correctly, then apparently, while it would be theft if someone were to go to his home, insincerely pretending to be friendly but taking something of monetary or sentimental value when they left, but doing the same thing in a house of worship isn't any sort of a big deal to be upset about.


Let's suppose you are a judge at his trial. Let's also suppose there's evidence he stole it. What should his punishment be?

704 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:24:52pm

re: #703 Killgore Trout

Let's suppose you are a judge at his trial. Let's also suppose there's evidence he stole it. What should his punishment be?

three Hail Mary's and an Our Father

(then an ass-kicking by a burly altre boy)

705 yma o hyd  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:25:09pm

re: #695 Killgore Trout

Now it's a conspiracy? You are aware that the Islamists also use this "logic" for their perceived "war on Ilsam". The Danish cartoons were drawn by the Israelis to inflame the Muslims world into murderous riots thereby making them look bad. What's really at work here, like the Muslims, is a victim mentality. In this case an atheist gets death threats and risks losing his job but Christians are still the victims? It's insanity! Also this victim mentality allows people to overreact and send death threats because they are being victimized and must fight back. You are taking Christianity in the wrong direction.

I'm sorry, I obviously haven't expressed myself sufficiently clearly to cause this misunderstanding.
I've not said that Christians are the victims and are thus allowed to use death threats and threats to his job.
What I have tried to question is that he only received these threats from Christians, because as atheist he 'made fun' of their sacred symbols - but did not receive any such threats from Muslims, although he dissed the Qur'an in no uncertain fashion.
It is this fact which I find inconceivable, as it runs counter to the experience of a lot of bloggers who only criticise, not desecrate the Qur'an.
Because of this fact I do allow myself to ask if this might not be an undertaking to paint all, not just those fundamentalist, Christians with the same brush of irrational religionists which for the sake of rational atheism need to be resisted.
Iaw, all and any religion, all and any members of them, need to be shown up in the crudest way possible for the danger they pose to rational atheism.
How on earth can you say that this, my opinion, makes 'victims' of all Christians?

706 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:25:43pm

re: #704 sattv4u2

then an ass-kicking by a burly altre boy


How very Sharia of you.

707 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:27:06pm

re: #706 Killgore Trout

How very Sharia of you.

God Bless you!

708 medaura18586  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:27:59pm

re: #690 reine.de.tout

Enough with your cracker... Don't you realize how unhealthy the whole back and forth over a cracker is? All these subversive excuses for what happened are ridiculous!

709 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:28:57pm

re: #705 yma o hyd

I'm surprised by it too. But I think it demonstrates the problem that Muslims can muster self restraint where Christians cannot. It's a very troubling development. The Cotholic League tried to get CAIR involved and CAIR chose to pass. They are aware and chose not to get involved. That's a matter of record and you can easily check. It's not a conspiracy, it's reality.

710 medaura18586  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:29:54pm

re: #702 reine.de.tout

Sorry that was meant to be a decisive down-ding but my finger slipped...

711 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:30:30pm

re: #703 Killgore Trout

Let's suppose you are a judge at his trial. Let's also suppose there's evidence he stole it. What should his punishment be?

What should his punishment be if he took something from your house?

712 David IV of Georgia  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:31:45pm

re: #694 A. van Hilten

Actually, it seems more like what Muslims invoke to justify their violence (and I'm not trying to lump you in with them, but the argument is equally valid): that they only abide by the Qur'an and Western laws be damned. By your own line of reasoning they're also justified in issuing 'death fatwas' against the Danish guy who made the Mohammed cartoon of blasphemy.

As I said, I don't care if anyone sees this as a double standard. Islam is ----, so is the Quran. I'm not going to kill or threaten to kill or harm to defend the honor of God, but I will die doing so. Whether or not the service was interrupted or whether people's rights were violated is not the issue: The sacraments of the Church are not symbols or representations or mere memorials. I would not commit any crime except to hinder him if he tried to leave Church while I knew he had an unconsumed Host. I would be passive yet a very aggressive passivity. I would not hurt him. Whether or not I got arrested or sued would not even enter my mind until later.

As to the issue of blasphemy laws or inquisitions or whatever, they tend to do more harm than good and I could not support any such measures.

Do things like the "art" "Piss Christ" offend me? Yes they do. Will I do anything about it? I just did—I said I was offended—if I can influence the NEA in the future I will.

713 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:32:03pm

re: #708 medaura18586

Enough with your cracker... Don't you realize how unhealthy the whole back and forth over a cracker is? All these subversive excuses for what happened are ridiculous!

What excuses have I made?

My issue is with someone coming to a Catholic Church, pretending to be sincere, and taking something of value while at the service.

What would you do if someone did that to you in your home?

714 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:32:13pm

re: #689 medaura18586

Then just wait how annoyed you will be when I compare you to a Holocaust Denier.

/ooops.. already done that.

re: #696 David IV of Georgia

You don't bother with ontology and cosmology much, do you?

If all that is is material, then blasphemy is indeed just empty words and actions. However, there are some people who believe that blasphemy is an introduction of new evil into the universe; it gives the universe a case of the flu as it were.

"What do they teach in schools these days?" - C.S Lewis 'The Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe'

And then there are people who think the consecrated host is still a wafer and could care less about the über-delicate sensitivities of those who don't.

Fortunately for mankind, the US constitution protects free speech. Meaning it's illegal to make threats against them or coerce them into "respecting" any line of thought, be it religious or not, in any way, shape or form.

That's what civil discourse is about. Civil discourse is not about abstaining from offending those whom you disagree with, it is actually about refraining from threatening their lives, livelihood or property.

715 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:33:03pm

re: #711 reine.de.tout

touche'

(Hey ,,, Obama ,,, I just spoke FRENCH!)

716 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:34:17pm

re: #711 reine.de.tout

Restitution: The cost of the cracker was about 1 cent. Is that the same punishment you would give him.

717 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:34:21pm

re: #709 Killgore Trout

I'm surprised by it too. But I think it demonstrates the problem that Muslims can muster self restraint where Christians cannot. It's a very troubling development. The Cotholic League tried to get CAIR involved and CAIR chose to pass. They are aware and chose not to get involved. That's a matter of record and you can easily check. It's not a conspiracy, it's reality.

wow ,,, talk about throwing the baby out with the bath water !

718 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:35:13pm

re: #716 Killgore Trout

Restitution: The cost of the cracker was about 1 cent. Is that the same punishment you would give him.

If the punishment for theft from your house is restitution, then yes.

719 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:35:20pm

re: #716 Killgore Trout

Restitution: The cost of the cracker was about 1 cent. Is that the same punishment you would give him.

so if someone steals something from your house, all you would want is tha cash equivalent?

720 yma o hyd  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:35:54pm

re: #714 A. van Hilten

If one needs to be offensive, its no longer a civil discourse, in my books.

721 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:37:10pm

re: #719 sattv4u2

It's not as good as your idea for public flogging.
/

722 Forever  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:37:12pm

Russian bombings are cruel and so on, but in the Balkan war of Clinton the civilian casualties were of course of a different kind and not to be criticized. Or the bombing of the Chinese embassy 'by mistake' in that same war.
Hypocrits!

And Georgia is playing dangerous games.

723 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:37:26pm

re: #720 yma o hyd

If one needs to be offensive, its no longer a civil discourse, in my books.

In my book either. But we live, perhaps, by a different book.

724 David IV of Georgia  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:38:40pm

re: #716 Killgore Trout

Restitution: The cost of the cracker was about 1 cent. Is that the same punishment you would give him.

If someone stole and desecrated your grandmother's corpse (if she is indeed dead), you would value her body as ten dollars worth of chemicals? How charitable.

725 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:39:04pm

re: #721 Killgore Trout

It's not as good as your idea for public flogging.
/


I'll remember to place a SARC tag after every joke I make just for your benefit ,,,

OR ,,,
give me your address. i'll send you a check so you can go buy a sense of humor

726 medaura18586  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:39:13pm

re: #719 sattv4u2

so if someone steals something from your house, all you would want is tha cash equivalent?

Killgore is a pussy though. Me? I would want that thief's head on a plate.

727 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:39:22pm

re: #708 medaura18586

Enough with your cracker... Don't you realize how unhealthy the whole back and forth over a cracker is? All these subversive excuses for what happened are ridiculous!

And, how are my arguments "subversive"?

728 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:39:28pm

re: #705 yma o hyd

As another test I decided to check blogs to see if there was a raging sea of outraged Muslims out there: nope. It's not a cover up. It's reality.

729 yma o hyd  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:39:40pm

re: #723 reine.de.tout

In my book either. But we live, perhaps, by a different book.

Yes - that looks to be the case!
Gotta go now - have been given the 'Collie Stare' ...

730 Forever  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:39:50pm

Now Saakesjville wants a cease fire.
Where was he with his cease fire when he bombed the sleeping South-Ossetians in the morning on Friday.

731 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:40:08pm

re: #724 David IV of Georgia

What would the punishment be in your Sharia courtroom?

732 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:40:49pm

re: #726 medaura18586

Killgore is a pussy though. Me? I would want that thief's head on a plate.

I'll send you the burly alter boys telephone number

FOR KILGORE> ,,, /SARC

733 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:41:36pm

re: #731 Killgore Trout

What would the punishment be in your Sharia courtroom?

David IV apparently believes it would be wrong to steal and descrate a corpse - and you equate that to Sharia?

734 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:42:47pm

re: #733 reine.de.tout

David IV apparently believes it would be wrong to steal and descrate a corpse - and you equate that to Sharia?

don't you know? Sharia is the new 30 ! (or something like that)

735 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:43:19pm

re: #734 sattv4u2

don't you know? Sharia is the new 30 ! (or something like that)

oooppppsss

KILGORE > ,,, / SARC

736 David IV of Georgia  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:44:21pm

re: #731 Killgore Trout

What would the punishment be in your Sharia courtroom?

We have laws for desecrating graveyards. I'm just saying that for Roman Catholics, the consecrated wafer represented much more than just 1¢. Our courts do take into account sentimental value and such.

Did you want me to have him drawn and quartered? Very well call an artist and throw 25¢ pieces at him.

737 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:45:06pm

re: #708 medaura18586

Enough with your cracker... Don't you realize how unhealthy the whole back and forth over a cracker is? All these subversive excuses for what happened are ridiculous!

by the way - I have never ordered you to be quiet. Have you been given the right to shut people up, here?

738 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:48:13pm

re: #703 Killgore Trout

Let's suppose you are a judge at his trial. Let's also suppose there's evidence he stole it. What should his punishment be?

That would depend on whether he actually stole the host or whether it was actually given to him by the priest, which is the most likely explanation.

The thing is hosts are freely given away to members of the congregation and, whereas you're not supposed to take the communion unless you have confessed your, gasp, 'sins' to the padre (yes, really), their monetary value is non-existent and no one is going to check whether you're a real Catholic or not if you attend a mass in any medium-sized town, just like most Roman Catholics do not confess their 'sins' before the communion.

There's no need to disrupt a religious service to walk out of church with a host in your pocket. And no one would notice.

739 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:48:52pm

re: #733 reine.de.tout

No. There a criminal punishment for that. You can give him a criminal sentence too. My 1 cent is just a civil judgment. I find it interesting that nobody wants to answer the question. Why is that?

740 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:49:42pm

re: #739 Killgore Trout

No. There a criminal punishment for that. You can give him a criminal sentence too. My 1 cent is just a civil judgment. I find it interesting that nobody wants to answer the question. Why is that?

Which question? If the punishment for theft is restitution, then that is what the punishment should be. I thought that was my answer.

741 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:50:45pm

re: #740 reine.de.tout

Oh, ok. I thought you were leaning towards similar punishment for defiling a corpse.

742 Scion9  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:51:19pm

re: #548 Killgore Trout

I finally got around to checking out Spencer's criticism of Glenn Reynolds. In fact Mr. Reynolds is 100% correct and it's happening right now to PZ Meyers who called a communion wafer a "cracker". He received death threats from Christians and the Catholic League has started a campaign to get him fired. They also tried to align with CAIR after PZ Meyers desecrated a Quran and a communion wafer. They don't belief free speech covers blasphemy and hurting feelings.

Is Meyers' situation similar now to that of prominent critcs of Islam though, like Geert Wilders, who need 24/7 protection and essentially lives in hiding?

While I don't agree with the tactics of CAIR and others of their ilk, I'm sure Theo Van Gogh's friends and family really wish he had been the victim of frivolous lawsuits and a letter campaign.

Radical Christians like those seen in Army of God exist, they don't have the kind of support infrastructure that Muslim radicals do. Just look at the best vetted Muslim American person the Democrats could find for Obama's campaign for a perfect example.

I don't disagree with Reynold's diagnosis that capitulation to threats of violence from Muslims may result in other groups, religious or otherwise will be sent the message that violence works. However, I think a huge factor in the capitulation to Muslims specifically is because their threats are not idle by any means. In fact, there are numerous examples of the persons being threatened giving in to their intimidators commands and still being subjected to violence.

Radical Muslim violence is so widespread, so seemingly systemic that nothing that any random nut who happens to be a Muslim says can be taken idly at all. In the case of Random House, no one even had to issue the threat. It was assumed. It isn't just the threat of violence, it is actually violence carried out frequently with no end in sight. The Christian threats shouldn't be taken lightly (no threat should) but playing the odds, the Christian death threats are much more likely to be without teeth in comparison to the Muslim ones.

When Christians start behaving in a way consistent with what we see in the Muslim world towards infidels over perceived insults and injustices along with a complacent or even supportive broader populace fostering them, then independent secular organizations will start treating them with the same deferential behavior.

However, we are probably a really long way off from seeing 'Christian Republics' churning out what we see in Saudi Arabia, Iran, Pakistan, Afghanistan, Palestine, etc.

There is also still the issue that out of your Christian Fundamentalists, you still get a pretty big group of major peaceniks, while you really don't see that with Islam at all. While the Mullahcracy in Iran and Al Qaeda might not get along with each other, neither is 'guilty' of being non-violent, non-expansionist.

As far as not supporting freedom of speech, that shouldn't be surprising. It is sort of a core fact that religious fundamentalists that only their way of thinking is correct. Why would they want freedom of speech, thought, religion?

Look up all of the prominent post-Industrial American socialists. Most of them were also Christians, many ministers. Even today, many largely Republican southern Christians engage in their Collective Utopianism in providing sanctuary for illegal immigrants.

I'm not a fan of the Evangelicals (as a movement, preemptive apologies for any evangelical Christians in attendance), but until they start flying planes into buildings I'm going to have to extend the good will to just disagree with them, and oppose them in the most civil way possible.

For people that literally want to cut off my head, I'm not going to do that.

743 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:51:28pm

re: #738 A. van Hilten

That would depend on whether he actually stole the host or whether it was actually given to him by the priest, which is the most likely explanation.

The thing is hosts are freely given away to members of the congregation and, whereas you're not supposed to take the communion unless you have confessed your, gasp, 'sins' to the padre (yes, really), their monetary value is non-existent and no one is going to check whether you're a real Catholic or not if you attend a mass in any medium-sized town, just like most Roman Catholics do not confess their 'sins' before the communion.

There's no need to disrupt a religious service to walk out of church with a host in your pocket. And no one would notice.

And neither would there be any "disruption" if someone were to come into your home, visit with you in a sincere and friendly way, and then take something of monetary or sentimental value as they left.

But your space will have been violated. Why is that wrong, but it's OK to violate a person's space if that space happens to be a house of worhsip?

744 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:51:39pm

re: #739 Killgore Trout

I find it interesting that nobody wants to answer the question. Why is that?

Petty theft is a misdemeanor and is punishable by a fine and up to six months incarceration

Where does Myers live? The sentence varies (but only slightly) from state to state

745 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:52:56pm

re: #719 sattv4u2

so if someone steals something from your house, all you would want is tha cash equivalent?


Are you in the habit of giving away things of value that you store in your house on a daily basis? 'Cause that is exactly what happens in any Catholic church—they give their hosts away for FREE. Heck, some will even treat to you to wine.

Others simply treat you to whine, apparently.

746 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:54:53pm

re: #745 A. van Hilten

Are you in the habit of giving away things of value that you store in your house on a daily basis? 'Cause that is exactly what happens in any Catholic church—they give their hosts away for FREE. Heck, some will even treat to you to wine.

Others simply treat you to whine, apparently.

(((ssssshhhhhh,,,, I have a secret for you ,,, the wine ,, it's not really that good ! ))

747 David IV of Georgia  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:55:19pm

re: #738 A. van Hilten

The thing is hosts are freely given away to members of the congregation and, whereas you're not supposed to take the communion unless you have confessed your, gasp, 'sins' to the padre (yes, really), their monetary value is non-existent and no one is going to check whether you're a real Catholic or not if you attend a mass in any medium-sized town, just like most Roman Catholics do not confess their 'sins' before the communion.

Most Orthodox Churches in my experience still question strangers about their church affiliation and whether they've had a recent confession before giving them the sacraments. We get called unfriendly and uncharitable and such from time to time, oh well.

748 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:55:47pm

re: #745 A. van Hilten

Are you in the habit of giving away things of value that you store in your house on a daily basis? 'Cause that is exactly what happens in any Catholic church—they give their hosts away for FREE. Heck, some will even treat to you to wine.

Others simply treat you to whine, apparently.

Oh, I thought this was a discussion. I have not spoken to anyone in a discourteous way. I have simply written out what I think of this situation.

OR, or we to be limited to discussing only those topics that you feel are important? If so, tell me, please, and I will take Medaura's order to me to be quiet, along with your order to me to be quiet and I will fade away into the sunset.

I thought you folks were all for freedom of speech?

749 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:56:47pm

re: #724 David IV of Georgia

If someone stole and desecrated your grandmother's corpse (if she is indeed dead), you would value her body as ten dollars worth of chemicals? How charitable.

Desecrating human remains is a crime according to the laws of most Western countries.

Desecrating a host isn't. For obvious reasons, I might add.

750 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 1:59:20pm

re: #749 A. van Hilten

Desecrating human remains is a crime according to the laws of most Western countries.

Desecrating a host isn't. For obvious reasons, I might add.

so it's okay that they STOLE the human remains, you're just bothered that they DESECRATED it!
Thats the jump YOU made from stealing a host to desecrating it ~!

(oh ,, and BTW ,,, Charlize Theron is HOT,,, she's on a movie I'm watching)

751 medaura18586  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 2:00:16pm

re: #737 reine.de.tout

Ordered? That's some pretty figurative reading of my post...

752 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 2:01:45pm

...

753 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 2:02:18pm
Enough with your cracker... Don't you realize how unhealthy the whole back and forth over a cracker is?

Looks to me suspiciously like an order to cease and desist . . .

754 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 2:03:30pm

Off now to attend MASS at my CATHOLIC CHURCH now.

755 David IV of Georgia  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 2:04:02pm

re: #749 A. van Hilten

Desecrating human remains is a crime according to the laws of most Western countries.

Desecrating a host isn't. For obvious reasons, I might add.

Through the history of the West we have learned that using civil authority to punish religious offenses is detrimental to both church and state. But for those who believe that the stolen host is the Body of Christ, it is a matter and dishonor and offence as great as or more than having a beloved relative's corpse desecrated.

756 David IV of Georgia  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 2:05:58pm

A priest friend of mine used to get in trouble in Catholic school for calling the Host "Jesus cookies".

757 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 2:08:21pm

re: #750 sattv4u2

so it's okay that they STOLE the human remains, you're just bothered that they DESECRATED it!
Thats the jump YOU made from stealing a host to desecrating it ~!

(oh ,, and BTW ,,, Charlize Theron is HOT,,, she's on a movie I'm watching)


I'll probably have to go to confession for what i'm thinkin'!

758 Josephine  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 2:12:20pm

Hmmm, let's see.

A thread about a Michael Totten article devolves into questions about and accusations against Robert Spencer.

A thread about the iPhone devolves into questions about and accusations against Robert Spencer.

A thread about war in Georgia devolves into an argument about a Catholic sacrament... but Robert Spencer is also mentioned in a negative way.

759 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 2:12:28pm

re: #743 reine.de.tout

And neither would there be any "disruption" if someone were to come into your home, visit with you in a sincere and friendly way, and then take something of monetary or sentimental value as they left.

But your space will have been violated. Why is that wrong, but it's OK to violate a person's space if that space happens to be a house of worhsip?

First of all, because a Roman Catholic church (at least here in Spain) is a public venue open to everybody who wants to visit where supposedly genuine Catholic worshippers gather to conduct their religious services. If those services are not disrupted and the 'offender' gets the host just like anybody else, by standing in line, then why should he be punished? Out of disrespect for what the has later done with the host (instead of having a bowel movement)? It's silly. hosts are given away for FREE every day to millions upon millions of people—and there's no way to find out if they're genuinge Catholics or not.

760 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 2:14:43pm

re: #758 Josephine

hey ,, I tried to stear it towrads the virtues of Charlize Theron, but I'm just one man and I can only do so much

761 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 2:16:39pm

re: #748 reine.de.tout

Oh, I thought this was a discussion. I have not spoken to anyone in a discourteous way. I have simply written out what I think of this situation.

OR, or we to be limited to discussing only those topics that you feel are important? If so, tell me, please, and I will take Medaura's order to me to be quiet, along with your order to me to be quiet and I will fade away into the sunset.

I thought you folks were all for freedom of speech?

I wasn't referring to you, specifically, but anyway excusatio non petita, accusatio manifiesta.

762 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 2:18:03pm

re: #761 A. van Hilten

I wasn't referring to you, specifically, but anyway excusatio non petita, accusatio manifiesta.

sounds good. i'll have the antipasto also, and a side of calimari

KILGORE > ,,,, / SARC

763 Killgore Trout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 2:18:16pm

re: #759 A. van Hilten

If impersonating a Catholic becomes a crime the jails will be overflowing.

764 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 2:18:17pm

re: #750 sattv4u2

so it's okay that they STOLE the human remains, you're just bothered that they DESECRATED it!
Thats the jump YOU made from stealing a host to desecrating it ~!

(oh ,, and BTW ,,, Charlize Theron is HOT,,, she's on a movie I'm watching)

Careful there, the good padre will surely want to know what you've been doing...

765 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 2:19:07pm

re: #764 A. van Hilten

Careful there, the good padre will surely want to know what you've been doing...

for what ,,,,pointers?

766 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 2:19:52pm

re: #758 Josephine

Hmmm, let's see.

A thread about a Michael Totten article devolves into questions about and accusations against Robert Spencer.

A thread about the iPhone devolves into questions about and accusations against Robert Spencer.

A thread about war in Georgia devolves into an argument about a Catholic sacrament... but Robert Spencer is also mentioned in a negative way.

Are you Robert Spencer's PR flak or what?

767 godfrey  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 2:24:00pm

Thank you, AVH, for turning what could've been an interesting (and OT) aside into a full-blown OT AVH fest. I don't believe you've even read the wiki on Myers, or you would've seen this:

On June 29, 2008, Cook attended a Catholic Mass being held in the student union at UCF by a Catholic student group that receives funding from the student government. Cook received the Catholic Eucharist host but did not consume it immediately. He said later that he wanted to take it back to his seat to show a friend, but when stopped he put it in his mouth until back at his seat, then a church leader made forcible attempts to take the host from him.[19][20] Cook stored the host at his home, then returned it one week later after receiving e-mail threats and pleas.

Read up on Cook and what he was about. Cook was "given" the host, of course, but because he didn't consume it then and there, as Catholic canon law requires of its communicants, he most certainly did steal it when he left the building. So he misrepresented himself as a communicant, committed theft, and then probably cackled with glee when Catholics got upset. What a profile in courage, that one. This makes him, to say the least, a low-life cad.

Any physical threats against him, of course, were, and remain, wrong.

Cook's action is also a deliberate affront to Catholics who wish freely to maintain the integrity of the Mass and their faith. But according to the great enlightened AVH, they can't do anything about Cook's action, really, because that would be "threatening" to everyone who values freedom. But it's perfectly OK to AVH for a cad like Cook to go into a Mass, disobey its rules and degrade it, because affronting an exercise of religion and peaceable assembly, in its own house, is really "an expression of freedom of speech." To say a word against it is equivalent (get ready for this) to a Muslim's rioting against desecrating a Koran.

Thus, AVH puts the free exercise of Catholicism on a permanent defensive and tries to wrap his own AVH-ism in the cloak of "freedom of speech."

AVH, your position shows little real understanding of the US Constitution, and defending Cook makes you look as petty as he so clearly showed himself to be.

Reine.de.tout, thanks for holding the candle.

768 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 2:24:21pm

re: #766 A. van Hilten

Are you Robert Spencer's PR flak or what?

Is that Roberta Flak's husband?

769 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 2:26:16pm

re: #767 godfrey

Reine.de.tout, thanks for holding the candle

what am I,,, chopped liver?!?!?!

grumble grumble grumble !

770 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 2:26:34pm

re: #763 Killgore Trout

If impersonating a Catholic becomes a crime the jails will be overflowing.

If failure to confess one's sins (of omission and commission as well as sins of thought, word and deed) ever becomes a crime, the jails will be overflowing with Catholics, including the priests.

/sarc

771 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 2:33:44pm

OT ,, but the USA has swept the womens FENCING medels at the Olympics

Way to go, Ladies !

772 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 2:36:07pm

re: #767 godfrey

Thank you, AVH, for turning what could've been an interesting (and OT) aside into a full-blown OT AVH fest. I don't believe you've even read the wiki on Myers, or you would've seen this:


Read up on Cook and what he was about. Cook was "given" the host, of course, but because he didn't consume it then and there, as Catholic canon law requires of its communicants, he most certainly did steal it when he left the building. So he misrepresented himself as a communicant, committed theft, and then probably cackled with glee when Catholics got upset. What a profile in courage, that one. This makes him, to say the least, a low-life cad.

Any physical threats against him, of course, were, and remain, wrong.

Cook's action is also a deliberate affront to Catholics who wish freely to maintain the integrity of the Mass and their faith. But according to the great enlightened AVH, they can't do anything about Cook's action, really, because that would be "threatening" to everyone who values freedom. But it's perfectly OK to AVH for a cad like Cook to go into a Mass, disobey its rules and degrade it, because affronting an exercise of religion and peaceable assembly, in its own house, is really "an expression of freedom of speech." To say a word against it is equivalent (get ready for this) to a Muslim's rioting against desecrating a Koran.

Thus, AVH puts the free exercise of Catholicism on a permanent defensive and tries to wrap his own AVH-ism in the cloak of "freedom of speech."

AVH, your position shows little real understanding of the US Constitution, and defending Cook makes you look as petty as he so clearly showed himself to be.

Reine.de.tout, thanks for holding the candle.

I thought that it was actually KT who posted about the PZ Myers story. Anyway, I really couldn't care less about your religion, your obvious and blatant bias against Myers (and me) or the issue under discussion — namely, whether your own sensibilities have been hurt because of the actions PZ Myers performed on an consecrated wafer.

The only thing I do care about is the death threat someone who professes to be a Christian has made against PZ Myers and his family.

773 hazzyday  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 2:42:00pm

re: #390 A. van Hilten

Hi medaura18586,

You have put together an awesome exposé of the ties of Jatras and Spencer to the American (sic) Council for Kosovo at your site. Highly recommended. That's an actual piece of investigative journalism—and not some comedienne's tales and distortions about organ trafficking, but I digress.
--.....................
BTW, Josephine was acussing me of being your sock puppet a few threads back (the Antichrist one).

Josephine was just being logical and pointing our her objection to the type of language Medaura was using and your support of that language.

The Medaura piece you point seems very incomplete to me and no way an "awesome expose". I think she lets her political emotions cloud her analysis of JihadWatch. I would also point out Medaura goes out of her way to point out LGF lizards as "That Crowd"

From her site:

"Within less than 48 hours, Robert Spencer of Jihad Watch has labored to not only quasi-politely dismiss and marginalize Michael Totten’s reports from Kosovo in the comments section of LittleGreenFootballs.com (lest his positive, or at least non hysterical message gains any traction with that crowd and prompt readers to question Spencer’s colorful portrayal of Kosovars as Talibans) but to also attack Glenn Reynolds"

Medaura is here on LGF to sway us to her side of the Balkan conflict with some lose facts, opinions, and a lot of emotional angst and insults.

Balkans bloggers that I have come across here on LGF seem to have little middle ground.

774 medaura18586  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 2:47:12pm

re: #773 hazzyday

I'll let my sock puppet A. Van Hilten do the talking on that, if he's in puppet-master defense mode.

775 Scion9  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 2:47:28pm

re: #772 A. van Hilten


The only thing I do care about is the death threat someone who professes to be a Christian has made against PZ Myers and his family.

Well you could always go the Killgore Trout method of argument on this issue if you wanted.

What death threat? There is no proof that any Christian made a death threat outside of Meyers' own testimony, which apparently isn't reliable enough to believe in regards to the wafer.

The death threat, like the 'theft' of the wafer is 'all in your head'.

Seriously though, you accuse godfrey of an intentional bias, while presumably exluding any bias of your own. Seems fairly habitual of you.

Anyone who doesn't agree is obviously biased, and incapable of coming to their own conclusions using their own reasoning. It is all bias. The air must be so clear and fresh up on the high road.

776 hazzyday  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 2:53:42pm

re: #686 A. van Hilten

How is taking a consecrated host out of mass for whatever purpose an infringement on other people's right to worship as they wish? It may well be disrespectful (though respect is subjective), but if one doesn't even notice the host has gone missing, how does it make any difference (unless the person who took it actually acknowledges his actions after the fact)?

It's stealing the body of Christ isn't it? Why would anyone even want to try it? I view it more as the person should just ask for it and it would be given. I also kind of interpet it as the thiefs need for relgion. He prowls there because he is curious. A lot like a stray feral animal that comes to visit because of hunger. Most people would shoo it away or shoot it. There is always one kind person that takes it under wing, replenishes it and sends it on it's way.

777 sattv4u2  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 2:53:45pm

re: #775 Scion9

The air must be so clear and fresh up on the high road.

I'll bet if you mapquest it, there's not high road in Beijing!

778 Colonel Panik  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 2:56:29pm

re: #698 A. van Hilten

And the threats keep coming...

The only thing Killgore is being threatened with, Paris Van Hilton, is a permanent dingdown, not a beatdown.

All though, truth be told, it would give me great emotional satisfaction to do a Bluto Blutarsky number on one of his precious violins. Maybe then he would understand the emotional impact desecration of the host has on devout Catholics, Anglicans and Orthodox.

779 medaura18586  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 3:00:13pm

Paris Van Hilton?

That's embarrassingly bad... really... if you can't do better than that, best to not even try.

780 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 3:18:26pm

re: #773 hazzyday

First of all, because I happen to think Spencer is wrong on the Balkans, that doesn't mean I'm somehow somebody's sock puppet, any more than defending Robert Spencer and his comments about Kosovo being a Jihadist state makes you his sock puppet.

Secondly, why did *you* keep asking questions about her exposé here at LGF, when you can refute her contentions at her own blog?

BTW, care to answer my arguments on the Totten thread?

[Link: littlegreenfootballs.com...]

Actually, if you had checked her blog, you'd have realized that she supports her claims with facts. Wait! You already did! But then you keep posting the same, er, embarrassing statements again and again.

Last but not least, you write:

Medaura is here on LGF to sway us to her side of the Balkan conflict with some lose facts, opinions, and a lot of emotional angst and insults.

I see. She's Albanian, after all. Then I guess all the Jewish posters here are trying to sway us to *their* side of the IP conflict too? Or does your logic apply to Albanians only?

And pray tell, hazzyday, on which side of the Balkan conflict is Michael J. Totten? Because Totten happens to agree with Medaura on this issue.

781 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 3:19:33pm

re: #779 medaura18586

Paris Van Hilton?

That's embarrassingly bad... really... if you can't do better than that, best to not even try.

He sure makes lots of threats to go by such a sissy handle: Colonel Panik.

782 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 3:23:17pm

re: #776 hazzyday

It's stealing the body of Christ isn't it? Why would anyone even want to try it? I view it more as the person should just ask for it and it would be given. I also kind of interpet it as the thiefs need for relgion. He prowls there because he is curious. A lot like a stray feral animal that comes to visit because of hunger. Most people would shoo it away or shoot it. There is always one kind person that takes it under wing, replenishes it and sends it on it's way.

And there you have it—an open invitation to "shoot" people who steal hosts like "feral animals." Thanks for making my point better than I ever could, hazzyday.

783 medaura18586  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 3:36:49pm

re: #780 A. van Hilten

Oh I didn't know they were still trolling up on that thread... Why not make questions where they have a chance of being seen?

784 medaura18586  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 3:45:12pm
You Albanians and Serbs need a new world order. Hopefully some new religion will come along that can help you both out.

... he says in that thread.

Why I'll be damned! "We Albanians and Serbs" need a new world order and a new dogma.

Someone is finally realizing what "we" need, and that's the towering genius hazzyday.

Somehow, he says over there at the Totten thread, my usage of BabbaZee's words does not have the same sunny connotations as when she writes the same words.

Well who would have thought...

785 wiffersnapper  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 3:47:02pm

trees are the answer

786 Marvo76  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 4:12:36pm

re: #369 Ayatollah Ghilmeini

Georgia is very limited in what they can do here.

The best they can hope for is a military standstill.

Russia has strategic strike weapons that Georgia cannot defend against- cruise missiles and strategic bombers among other things.

The Russian army still has poor morale, awful officers and flawed equipment. Supplied with stingers and some anti tank rockets, assuming the Georgians are reasonably well trained and well led, they might just be able to stymie the Russians and get the conflict to the negotiating table.

The problem is Putin may decide to make an object lesson of Georgia and go all the way to reoccupation. Putin is a ruthless SOB, the only limitation on his behavior is he dare not provoke the US too much. Short of that though, expect at least several days of this and maybe even more.

Georgia wins by surviving and remaining independent. The US is not going to war for Georgia, however the Georgians may find that, with US supplied satellite real-time intel and some precision weapons that they can severely hurt the Russian Army.

And then their is the other imperial power in the region, Turkey. The opportunity to expand into Georgia may be too tempting for the Islamist government to pass up.

All in all, a excellent Caucasus clucsterf*** in the last year of lame duck deeply distracted by other wars presidency. The silver lining: Russia will have little to say when we paste Iran.

ture, but there is still China and they may not take to kindly to having Iran pasted, and try to ramp things up to spread us to thin....

787 docremulac  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 4:15:35pm

The first battle in Cold War II.

788 Marvo76  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 4:25:54pm

re: #467 Charles

The Discovery Institute runs that Russia Blog site.

How interesting that they are on the side of Russia.

I am stunned that they would.....

789 Colonel Panik  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 4:27:17pm

re: #781 A. van Hilten

He sure makes lots of threats to go by such a sissy handle: Colonel Panik.

If you must know, it is a joking reference to a Unix term: kernel panic.

Charles was experiencing kernel panics after an OS/X upgrade the day I registered and he had a whole thread about it.

790 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 4:27:59pm

re: #767 godfrey

Thank you, AVH, for turning what could've been an interesting (and OT) aside into a full-blown OT AVH fest. I don't believe you've even read the wiki on Myers, or you would've seen this:

Read up on Cook and what he was about. Cook was "given" the host, of course, but because he didn't consume it then and there, as Catholic canon law requires of its communicants, he most certainly did steal it when he left the building. So he misrepresented himself as a communicant, committed theft, and then probably cackled with glee when Catholics got upset. What a profile in courage, that one. This makes him, to say the least, a low-life cad.

Any physical threats against him, of course, were, and remain, wrong.

Cook's action is also a deliberate affront to Catholics who wish freely to maintain the integrity of the Mass and their faith. But according to the great enlightened AVH, they can't do anything about Cook's action, really, because that would be "threatening" to everyone who values freedom. But it's perfectly OK to AVH for a cad like Cook to go into a Mass, disobey its rules and degrade it, because affronting an exercise of religion and peaceable assembly, in its own house, is really "an expression of freedom of speech." To say a word against it is equivalent (get ready for this) to a Muslim's rioting against desecrating a Koran.

Thus, AVH puts the free exercise of Catholicism on a permanent defensive and tries to wrap his own AVH-ism in the cloak of "freedom of speech."

AVH, your position shows little real understanding of the US Constitution, and defending Cook makes you look as petty as he so clearly showed himself to be.

Reine.de.tout, thanks for holding the candle.

And thank you for the support. Your comment is beautifully stated.

791 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 4:31:46pm

re: #772 A. van Hilten

I thought that it was actually KT who posted about the PZ Myers story. Anyway, I really couldn't care less about your religion, your obvious and blatant bias against Myers (and me) or the issue under discussion — namely, whether your own sensibilities have been hurt because of the actions PZ Myers performed on an consecrated wafer.

The only thing I do care about is the death threat someone who professes to be a Christian has made against PZ Myers and his family.

Again, for the gazillioneth time here:

I have seen no one here argue that the death threats are OK.

Personally, I believe anyone who issues such death threats should be located and prosecuted to the fullest extent possible.

I do not believe there should be "blasphemy" laws.

I believe a house of worship should have, under the law, the same protections against invasions of its privacy as any homeowner has; it should not be excepted from those laws simply because it is a religious institution.

792 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 4:34:34pm

re: #773 hazzyday

Josephine was just being logical and pointing our her objection to the type of language Medaura was using and your support of that language.

The Medaura piece you point seems very incomplete to me and no way an "awesome expose". I think she lets her political emotions cloud her analysis of JihadWatch. I would also point out Medaura goes out of her way to point out LGF lizards as "That Crowd"

From her site:

"Within less than 48 hours, Robert Spencer of Jihad Watch has labored to not only quasi-politely dismiss and marginalize Michael Totten’s reports from Kosovo in the comments section of LittleGreenFootballs.com (lest his positive, or at least non hysterical message gains any traction with that crowd and prompt readers to question Spencer’s colorful portrayal of Kosovars as Talibans) but to also attack Glenn Reynolds"

Medaura is here on LGF to sway us to her side of the Balkan conflict with some lose facts, opinions, and a lot of emotional angst and insults.

Balkans bloggers that I have come across here on LGF seem to have little middle ground.

Bravo, bravo, bravo! Well stated.

Medaura may indeed have knowledge that could inform us, and I am here to be informed.

But her writings are such a mixed bag of invective, opinion, conclusions and perhaps some facts, that it's hard to figure out what is what.

793 Scion9  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 4:34:49pm

re: #780 A. van Hilten


I see. She's Albanian, after all. Then I guess all the Jewish posters here are trying to sway us to *their* side of the IP conflict too?

Sure. Some of them are. Look at the threads about Kuntar and the criticism of Israel's policy. There were Jewish and Israeli posters defending the decision to free Jihadis in exchange for corpses.

They might not be selling us their side, as if they were paid bloggers, but they had an agenda by way of defending their country/people.

I try to be rational (at least when not deliberately engaging in some reductio ad absurdum), but I can admit that my patriotism can get the best of me sometimes. That I would potentially defend America's position and policies the same way the Israeli posters did in regards to the Kuntar exchange, even when knowing that there it isn't the rational policy.

Despite my earlier jape, rather they want to recognize it or not, everyone is inherently biased to some degree. By virtue of only having lived our lives, and having access to only our firsthand experience we can never truly know the other side despite our best attempts to understand by way of a third party.

Could the Israeli posters have reached their conclusions about Israel's policy if they were of another nationality? Of course. Does it seem conspicuous that pretty much only the Israeli's and Jewish posters were throwing support behind the exchange, and in turn for the criticism some became emotional? Yes, it does.

This isn't any different here. Yes, Medaura being Albanian casts the shadow of potential bias over her position, and the often emotional rebukes doesn't make the case against that assumption any better.

Of course, there isn't anything that she is saying that someone anywhere else in the world, with any other background couldn't be saying as well, but you can't blame people for having their opinion that her position and her agenda isn't partially born from some inherent bias. No offense.

794 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 4:38:28pm

re: #791 reine.de.tout

Again, for the gazillioneth time here:

I have seen no one here argue that the death threats are OK.

Personally, I believe anyone who issues such death threats should be located and prosecuted to the fullest extent possible.

I do not believe there should be "blasphemy" laws.

I believe a house of worship should have, under the law, the same protections against invasions of its privacy as any homeowner has; it should not be excepted from those laws simply because it is a religious institution.

Again, a house of worship is a public venue. There can't be any privacy intrusion if one's welcomed by the congregation when entering the premises.

And hazzyday seems to be perfectly ok with "shooting" feral animals who steal hosts.

795 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 4:39:47pm

re: #792 reine.de.tout

Bravo, bravo, bravo! Well stated.

Medaura may indeed have knowledge that could inform us, and I am here to be informed.

But her writings are such a mixed bag of invective, opinion, conclusions and perhaps some facts, that it's hard to figure out what is what.


Perhaps you could actually care to discuss her facts instead of questioning her motives, as is usual in these quarters.

796 So?  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 4:41:44pm

Has the UN condemned Russia yet? Didn't think SO!

797 Marvo76  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 4:44:01pm

re: #594 sattv4u2

my guess is they wouldn't let us get near the Kursk so we wouldn;t be able to see how advanced or not their equipment was at the time

especially after we tried to recover one that they lost in deep water with the equipment provided by the guy who built the spuce goose

798 Marvo76  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 4:50:13pm

re: #634 ashan

This confrontation is, above all, about that pipeline. Putin wants to control all of the energy resources available to his enemies, including the US, UK and Israel. (Israeli military advisor's have been in Georgia for some time.) In addition to trying to wrest the pipeline away from Georgia, I get the feeling that this Russian invasion has something to do with deflecting attention away from its major client state, Iran.

Russia is speeding things along to a major international conflict. The sparks of world wars sometimes arise from less likely origins.

such as an assassinated arch duke?

799 medaura18586  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 4:50:59pm

re: #795 A. van Hilten

Perhaps you could actually care to discuss her facts instead of questioning her motives, as is usual in these quarters.

Or, perhaps she could click on the hyperlinks attached to nearly every other word in my report, so she could see that there are more than "perhaps, some facts" in it.

This same poster attacked me on another thread for responding to some most vicious personal insults. She seems to fancy herself some sort of blog policer, but of course, the only "opinions", "invectives", and "opinions" she rails out against are the ones that don't fit well with her bile.

Never let those, perhaps, facts, get in the way!

800 medaura18586  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 4:52:15pm

typo,

but of course, the only "opinions", "invectives", and "opinions" she rails out against...

is supposed to be

but of course, the only "opinions", "invectives", and "conclusions" she rails out against...

801 Marvo76  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 4:52:28pm

re: #667 Shay4l

The morons posting after that story act like Bush is the cause of all this crap going on in the world. Like Putin doesn't exist, the mullahs are puppets of American wishes, China has no free will, etc. What a bunch of BDS loons.

I agree

802 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 4:57:26pm

re: #795 A. van Hilten

Perhaps you could actually care to discuss her facts instead of questioning her motives, as is usual in these quarters.

Well, I would, if it were possible to figure out what her facts are.

I went to her site, and like hazzyday, I find that I think she lets her political emotions cloud her analysis.

This issue is not so important to me that I want to spend hours and hours trying to sort through the volumes of her writings on the topic, to try to find a few pertinent facts. Her emotions run all throughout her writing.

Why is it so difficult for her to simply state facts, then tell us the opinions or conclusions she has formed based on those facts?

She posts enormous comments filled with her opinions or conclusions, and then expects that everyone will simply accept as fact those opinions or conclusions.

It's been my experience that when someone clouds up the facts with opinions and emotions, and goes into emotional rantings against whoever has the audacity to have a question, is very often trying to mislead. That may not be the case with Medaura, and although I do wish to be informed, I don't care to incur Medaura's wrath, to be honest. It just doesn't lead anywhere productive.

803 reine.de.tout  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 4:58:11pm

re: #799 medaura18586

Or, perhaps she could click on the hyperlinks attached to nearly every other word in my report, so she could see that there are more than "perhaps, some facts" in it.

This same poster attacked me on another thread for responding to some most vicious personal insults. She seems to fancy herself some sort of blog policer, but of course, the only "opinions", "invectives", and "opinions" she rails out against are the ones that don't fit well with her bile.

Never let those, perhaps, facts, get in the way!

Please, show me the bile that has spewed from my hands.

804 Scion9  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 5:00:20pm

re: #794 A. van Hilten

Again, a house of worship is a public venue. There can't be any privacy intrusion if one's welcomed by the congregation when entering the premises.

There are already laws on the book in regards to disrupting religious services and inflicting stress upon, and intimidating parishioners.

Rather this particular example would be considered 'disrupting' or not would be a matter for the courts. Being that the gentlemen in question was fairly flagrant in his flouting the Priest's desire that he return the wafer when he didn't eat it, I'd say it was on some level, disruptive.

Injunctions have been issued against individuals that bar them from attending services after being disruptive, and then later upheld in court. If people were coming in, on even a semi-frequent basis and taking home wafers, that is in fact disruptive. The communion is part of a ritual. To come into the church, and deliberately not engage in the ritual, with no intent at all to engage in the rituals and activities being conducted, is not protected by freedom of speech. It is not protected behavior.

It was many years ago now, but a gentlemen dressed as Hitler attended service at a local Synagogue. That was his 'protest'. It also was not protected as any kind of freedom of expression. It was certainly a lot more inflammatory than walking off with a wafer, but it still constitutes the same kind of behavior. 'Political' protest during a religious service. The only reason to protest a religious service is to prevent the free practice of that religion, which infringes upon freedom of religion.

Anyone has the freedom of speech to say what they want about religion and protest a particular religious group; they just can't do it in the pews, during services in a disruptive fashion.

Plenty of other places, venues, methods and opportunities to air your grievances.

805 Marvo76  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 5:05:09pm

Uhm....are we not talking about Georgia anymore, if so I will quit posting about it...

806 medaura18586  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 5:09:02pm

re: #802 reine.de.tout

Well perhaps that post wasn't meant for you.

If you are incapable or unwilling to distinguish between my thoughts and quoted, sourced, factual material, than you are probably incapable of either understanding my thoughts, or of understanding quoted, sourced, factual material.

Oh how would I check my "political emotions which are clouding my analysis" at the door? Would you rather I just splashed dozens of links against the wall, with no commentary you could accuse me of "bias" over, and no context?

Even my "opinions", "invectives", and "conclusions" are meaningful in putting facts into context. You might not agree with my analysis, but it clarifies the facts, facts which you have not discussed at all or given any sign of remotely understanding.

807 A. van Hilten  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 5:16:33pm

re: #802 reine.de.tout

Well, I would, if it were possible to figure out what her facts are.

Well, if you can read, the facts are pretty compelling. Why not start with these?

[Link: savekosovo.org...]

The connection/friendship between Jatras and Spencer—and the latter's raving critique/open endorsement of a pamphlet titled "Hiding Genocide in Kosovo" and published by the so-called American Council for Kosovo, which is a front group for the Serbian National Council of Kosovo and Metohija, represented by Jatras' lobbying firm Venable LLC, is pretty revealing.

[Link: littlegreenfootballs.com...]

808 Josephine  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 5:20:34pm

re: #802 reine.de.tout

Reine:

Consider the source.

I will trust a respected scholar and author such as Robert Spencer before I trust someone who is so quick to use insults and profanity and resort to character assassination.

My opinion: don't waste your time repeatedly responding to their accusations: it's just a bully tactic. State your case once. If they don't get it after that, it's because they don't want to get it. Then put them on GAZE.

809 medaura18586  Sat, Aug 9, 2008 5:22:28pm

re: #807 A. van Hilten

Not to speak of Jatras' involvement with Larry Craig, through whose office he has planted propaganda pieces in Congress, his appearance as a defense witness in Milosevic's trial in Hague, his unbelievably anti-American statements, his outrageous revisionism and genocide denial...

And let's not get started on Milan Ivanovic, his connection with Karadzic, his leading role in organizing violent protests/rallies which have claimed innocent lives, and his support of the Serbian Radical Party...

These are just, of course, "opinions", "invectives", and "conclusions" spurring out of my head, with no reference whatsoever to objective reality.

Or, some people just turn more obtuse than usual when they are faced with inconvenient facts.