LGF

more options

  

Advertisement

Russia Continues Georgia Assault

Sun, Aug 10, 2008 at 9:12:22 am PDT

The Russian military has forced Georgian troops to retreat from South Ossetia.

GORI, Georgia - Georgian troops retreated from the breakaway province of South Ossetia on Sunday as their U.S.-allied government ordered a cease-fire and pressed for a truce, overwhelmed by Russian firepower in a conflict that threatened to set off a wider war.

Russia deployed a naval squadron off the coast of another of Georgia’s separatist regions, Abkhazia, and its jets bombed the outskirts of Tblisi, the Georgian capital.

Georgia’s Foreign Ministry said its soldiers were observing a cease-fire on orders of the president and notified Russia’s envoy to Tbilisi.

“Georgia expresses its readiness to immediately start negotiations with the Russian Federation on cease-fire and termination of hostilities,” the ministry said in a statement.

The Russian Foreign Ministry had no immediate response to the Georgian offer.

Advertisement

535 comments

  • Comments are open and unmoderated, and do not necessarily reflect the views of Little Green Footballs.
  • Obscene, abusive, silly, or annoying remarks may be deleted, but the fact that particular comments remain on the site in no way constitutes an endorsement of their views by Little Green Footballs.
  • Posts that contain phone numbers, street addresses, email addresses or other personal information will also be deleted, as will posts that consist only of a variation on the word, "First!"
  • Comments that advocate violence will be cause for immediate banning with no appeal.
  • Disagreement and debate are welcome, but insults and abuse are not, and may cause your account to be blocked.
  • REMEMBER: posting comments at LGF is a privilege, not a right. Abuse that privilege, and your account will be blocked.

Hide comments | Jump to bottom

1 JammieWearingFool  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:12:54am

Funny how silent the anti-war left is these days.

2 Forever  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:15:05am

I guess the rest of the world is busy with the Olympics. :)

3 Truck Monkey  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:15:12am

re: #1 JammieWearingFool

Funny how silent the anti-war left is these days.

They are only anti-war when it involves the US with a Republican President or Israel at all times.

4 ggt  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:15:16am

em>re: #1 JammieWearingFool

You mean the pro-revolution socialists?

CHANGE! CHANGE! CHANGE!

5 StudSupreme  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:15:20am

No, it's normal.
The left will not criticize bully regimes like Iran and the Russians because they're intimidated. However, the left will shrilly rant against America because they know they can do it with impunity, including the commiting of treasonous acts.
In this way, one can clearly observe how the behavior of leftists reflects the attitude of spoiled, pampered children.

6 akak  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:15:24am

re: #1 JammieWearingFool

Funny how silent the anti-war left is these days.

Not really, they line up with Russia & Islam without regret.

7 itellu3times  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:15:32am

Putin's march from Tbilisi to the sea.

8 laxmatt1984  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:15:36am

Their not silent at all. They are supporting Russia.

[Link: dailykos.com...]

9 markx  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:16:09am

This is not good.

Jammie has a good point. Hearing crickets from the moonbats.

10 MikeySDCA  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:16:23am

Let's have a clear understanding of what's happening. The Georgians having failed to dragoon the South Ossetians into compliance, are surrendering.

BTW, the Georgians are our friends, deservedly, but our friends can be fools.

11 jemima  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:17:58am

One might hope that all the former Iron Curtain countries would band together for their mutual protection against Russia so that none of them would be reassimilated into a new USSR.

And on a side note, I had a guy from Belarus tell me yesterday that it's all America's fault. Russia is the victim in all this.

12 lawhawk  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:18:16am

The anti-war leftists only are anti-war when it comes to the US defending itself and its interests around the world. When other leftists engage in war, they turn a willing blind eye.

13 Basho  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:18:56am

re: #8 laxmatt1984

Oh gosh... I actually read that crap.

14 Charles  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:19:14am

re: #8 laxmatt1984

Their not silent at all. They are supporting Russia.

[Link: dailykos.com...]

This puts the anti-evolution Discovery Institute on the same side with the Kos Kids.

15 ggt  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:19:34am

re: #13 Basho

I DON'T go over there anymore for any reason. I just puts me in a bad mood.

16 trailortrash  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:19:37am

im watching the rusian fed try to justify this further aggression in a un security council meeting here
[Link: foxnews-stream1.wm.llnwd.net...]
paste that in wmp or go to fox for a live link

17 laxmatt1984  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:19:39am

And yes, I realize it's "they're".

18 dmandman  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:19:40am

re: #1 JammieWearingFool

Ted Kennedy and the Democratic Party are still delivering to the Kremlin just like they promised 25 years ago in their initiative to the KGB when it was obvious that Reagan was going to be President for at least a little while longer. BTW this is documented and vetted, just not publicized by the MSM when the info came to light after the fall of the KGB. Wish I still had the link to the author of the book that had the full info in it. It looks like the selective see no evil, hear no evil applies to other Dems besides Edwards.

19 MandyManners  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:19:51am

re: #1 JammieWearingFool

Funny how silent the anti-war left is these days.

I've read at one place where the little fuckers are blaming Pres. Bush for this.

20 Colonel Panik  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:20:06am

re: #11 jemima

Belarus is a Stalinist throwback region.

21 akak  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:20:27am

If Ukraine blocks Russian ships & Turkey follows suit, this will indeed tip the scale.

22 MikeySDCA  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:20:36am

re: #11 jemima

It's always America's fault. LOL.

23 MandyManners  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:20:43am

Georgian reports here.

[Link: www.aboutgeorgia.net...]

24 lawhawk  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:20:45am

re: #10 MikeySDCA

It's true that our friends can be fools - see Musharraf and his appeasement/attack cycle of violence that ensued in Pakistan as exhibit A. However, Georgia has legitimate claims to South Ossetia, and the Russians have been playing games there ever since the breakup of the Soviet Union. Georgia saw what the Russians had been doing, and all it takes is a look at a map to understand the security risk posed by allowing Russia to have unfettered access there.

25 DeafDog  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:21:04am

re: #8 laxmatt1984

Their not silent at all. They are supporting Russia.

[Link: dailykos.com...]

I was confused by this rant. Does Kos wants a war with Russia?

26 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:21:25am
The Russian Foreign Ministry had no immediate response to the Georgian offer.

Translation: The Russians are going to take everything they can.

Question: Are we going to let them reincorporate Georgia as a province of Imperial Russia?

27 Westward Ho  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:21:26am
“Georgia expresses its readiness to immediately start negotiations with the Russian Federation on cease-fire and termination of hostilities,”

The mob boss just bitchslapped some respect into Mikhail come latelys ass. Where are your new friends now Mikhail where is Bush, Sarkozy, Angela, Solana...?

28 ggt  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:21:52am

re: #23 MandyManners

Interesting, the Scientology Channel had an ad on that website.

29 lifeofthemind  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:21:55am

One Word: Turkey
The Turks are the big dogs in the region. If they move in then the Russians go down. The Turkish Navy has submarines that could sink the Russian Black Sea fleet transports and the Ukrainians have already threatened to bar the Russians from returning to port. Putin may have stuck his schlong way out on a chopping block. This may not be over. Even if the Georgians have to pull back. They have Israeli advisors in place. Do wish that the tunnel had been blown on day one.

30 jemima  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:22:22am

Teddy & the KGB
[Link: www.frontpagemag.com...]

31 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:22:30am

re: #7 itellu3times

Wrong way 'round: from the sea to Tblisi.

Grrrr.

32 zombie  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:22:56am

Anybody know what country has the "lv" domain? Because I'm getting a lot of links from blogs there linking to my Up Your Alley event.

Wish I knew what they were saying! Weird-looking language.

33 dmandman  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:23:30am

re: #30 jemima

thanks, it's pretty damning and Teddy should be in Prison costume at the very least.

34 Charles  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:23:35am

re: #32 zombie

Anybody know what country has the "lv" domain?

Latvia.

35 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:23:48am

re: #14 Charles

Will that change their position? Or will they say, "Well, politics make strange bedfellows"?

36 trailortrash  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:24:04am

re: #32 zombie

looks like latvia
[Link: www.iana.org...]

37 lifeofthemind  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:24:19am

re: #32 zombie

Hello Zombie, how was the smorgasbord?

38 jemima  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:24:44am

#22

We should stop trying to help Belarus obtain greater independence, bunch of skanky ingrates. They only get news from Moscow but I'm sure it's fair and balanced.

39 Desert Dog  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:24:51am

re: #32 zombie

Lativa

40 MandyManners  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:25:07am

Putin doesn't want just South Ossetia and Abkhazia. He wants Georgia, too.

41 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:25:13am

re: #18 dmandman

Ted Kennedy and the Democratic Party are still delivering to the Kremlin just like they promised 25 years ago in their initiative to the KGB when it was obvious that Reagan was going to be President for at least a little while longer. BTW this is documented and vetted, just not publicized by the MSM when the info came to light after the fall of the KGB. Wish I still had the link to the author of the book that had the full info in it. It looks like the selective see no evil, hear no evil applies to other Dems besides Edwards.

It always applies to a Kennedy.

42 Colonel Panik  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:25:20am

re: #32 zombie

Anybody know what country has the "lv" domain? Because I'm getting a lot of links from blogs there linking to my Up Your Alley event.

Wish I knew what they were saying! Weird-looking language.

Lativa? Are they suing roman characters or cyrillic? Latvians use roman characters and the language looks somewhat like Finnish.

Judging from the words in the link I'm guessing Latvia.

43 trailortrash  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:25:52am

re: #40 MandyManners


yep

44 galloping granny  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:25:52am

re: #26 Dianna

Translation: The Russians are going to take everything they can.

Question: Are we going to let them reincorporate Georgia as a province of Imperial Russia?

The Russians are after the Georgian oilfields and the pipeline that handles a full 1% of the world's oil supply. Bombing it now by most reports. And there probably is not enough of Georgia to stop the Russian bear.

45 ggt  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:26:02am

re: #30 jemima

Thanks for that, sounds like a good email to send around.

46 zombie  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:26:18am

re: #34 Charles

Latvia.

Ah, OK. Latvia. Who knew?

The only connection I ever had with Latvia is: I met and had conversations with famous historian Professor Leon Litwack (which is the prototypical Latvian name). It was only later that I found out he was a stone-cold Communist.

47 Spiny Norman  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:26:42am

re: #8 laxmatt1984

Their not silent at all. They are supporting Russia.

[Link: dailykos.com...]

They want Bush and Cheney strung up for it, no less.

Nice little bloodthirsty shitforbrains Ché wannabes. A rather stark confirmation of StudSupreme's comment #5.

48 FrogMarch  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:26:44am

Up next - a roll of lies from the Kremlin.

49 zombie  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:26:49am

re: #37 lifeofthemind

Hello Zombie, how was the smorgasbord?

I didn't eat it myself: I just had to lie perfectly still.

50 jemima  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:26:50am

#45, your welcome.

{Galloping Granny}

51 Desert Dog  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:26:54am

re: #32 zombie

Anybody know what country has the "lv" domain? Because I'm getting a lot of links from blogs there linking to my Up Your Alley event.

Wish I knew what they were saying! Weird-looking language.

IANA - Root Zone Database

52 akak  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:27:02am

re: #40 MandyManners

Putin Gazprom doesn't want just South Ossetia and Abkhazia. He wants Georgia, too.

Lest we not forget Putin & Mdvedev were former heads of Gazprom.

53 Sharmuta  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:27:12am

re: #11 jemima

One might hope that all the former Iron Curtain countries would band together for their mutual protection against Russia so that none of them would be reassimilated into a new USSR.

And on a side note, I had a guy from Belarus tell me yesterday that it's all America's fault. Russia is the victim in all this.

I agree with the idea of an alliance of former Iron Curtain countries. If we're not going to let them into NATO, they should have something else.

Although- I now understand why Russia has been so opposed to our willingness to allow some of these countries into NATO. If Georgia had been let into NATO, Russia would now have NATO to deal with, because an attack on one is an attack on all.

54 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:27:35am

re: #28 ggt

Doesn't matter - it's information. At this point, I'll take what I can get!

55 FrogMarch  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:28:14am

re: #8 laxmatt1984

Their not silent at all. They are supporting Russia.

[Link: dailykos.com...]

DKOS - left-wing mind pollution for proggies.

56 lifeofthemind  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:28:14am

The worst case line-up is looking like this.
Russia, Iran, China vs.
USA, Ukraine, Turkey, Poland, & most of rest of Nato.

Honestly I think if the worst happens we win but Putin should be able to pull back.

57 MikeySDCA  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:28:15am

re: #39 Desert Dog

Latvia

58 Spiny Norman  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:28:23am

re: #12 lawhawk

The anti-war leftists only are anti-war when it comes to the US defending itself and its interests around the world. When other leftists engage in war, they turn a willing blind eye.

Blind eye? Hell no, they cheer them on.

59 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:28:30am

re: #29 lifeofthemind

Yeah, me too!

However, then the Georgians would have had to rebuild it.

They still should have blown it.

60 ggt  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:28:40am

re: #54 Dianna

I already sent the link around. There's nothing on snopes to refute it, so it should get some ears steaming.

61 lawhawk  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:29:16am

re: #53 Sharmuta

Many of those former Iron Curtain countries and former Soviet Republics are fearful that they'll be treated worse should Russia decide to go after them after siding with the West over closer ties to Moscow. There's a long history of Russian interference in the domestic affairs of its neighbors going back centuries. And Putin and his crowd are clearly looking to take advantage of the situation in the West by going for ripe pickings.

62 Ringo the Gringo  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:29:35am

re: #32 zombie

Anybody know what country has the "lv" domain? Because I'm getting a lot of links from blogs there linking to my Up Your Alley event.

Wish I knew what they were saying! Weird-looking language.

zombie, the word "Latvijas" - which appears in the first sentence in your link - is how Latvians write the word Latvia.

63 realwest  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:29:57am

re: #27 Westward Ho
As you know, we covered this discussion fairly thoroughly in the Dead Thread today and I asked you the following - though I suppose you'd left by then, so I'll repost it here:
"So lemme ask you a question. That he "overplayed his cards" bit, does that justify Russia bombing civilian occupied towns? In moving towards taking over Georgia completely? IF so, what about the Ukraine if they do in fact deny that little Russian naval squadron access back to their bases? Would that justify the Russians going after the Ukraine and killiing Ukranian civilians? The tenor of virtually every one of your posts would lead me to believe that the answer to that is yes".

64 Desert Dog  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:30:02am

We can thank OIL for Putin, for the Saudis, for Iran, for UAE, for Venezuela, etc, etc...Oil is the root of all evil these days. Most of the countries that have alot A)do not like us and B)are world class tyrants

65 ggt  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:30:16am

Anyone ever read Ali & Nino? It was OOP (out-of-print) for a while, but I, but I noticed it is back in print at Borders anyway.

It is a novel set in Georgia. The insights it gives seem to be accurate.

66 Truck Monkey  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:30:27am

re: #53 Sharmuta

I agree with the idea of an alliance of former Iron Curtain countries. If we're not going to let them into NATO, they should have something else.

Although- I now understand why Russia has been so opposed to our willingness to allow some of these countries into NATO. If Georgia had been let into NATO, Russia would now have NATO to deal with, because an attack on one is an attack on all.

I'd rather have most of the former eastern block countries on my side than most of NATO.

67 lifeofthemind  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:30:31am

re: #44 galloping granny

The Russians are after the Georgian oilfields and the pipeline that handles a full 1% of the world's oil supply. Bombing it now by most reports. And there probably is not enough of Georgia to stop the Russian bear.

Georgia doesn't have the oil field just the pipelines. The oil fields are farther East in Azerbaijan and the Caspian.

68 MikeySDCA  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:30:34am

re: #61 lawhawk

Yes indeed.

69 Spiny Norman  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:31:03am

re: #40 MandyManners

Putin doesn't want just South Ossetia and Abkhazia. He wants Georgia, too.

Putin wants not just Georgia, but all of the former Soviet Empire.

What will we do when he invades the Baltic States?

70 Desert Dog  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:31:07am

re: #57 MikeySDCA

Latvia

Lativa? A small unknown country?....that sounds more like a new laxative...pimf

71 Sharmuta  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:31:22am

The BBC website is reporting Georgia's international airport has been hit by Russian bombs- details soon.

72 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:31:38am

re: #53 Sharmuta

Europe had better realize that they are about to let Russia control their energy completely.

73 Sharmuta  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:31:59am

re: #66 Truck Monkey

I'd rather have most of the former eastern block countries on my side than most of NATO.

I can't argue with that- they seem to understand how precious Freedom is.

74 trailortrash  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:32:07am

the french dont seem to be on russias side...

75 Colonel Panik  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:32:55am

re: #70 Desert Dog

Lativa? A small unknown country?....that sounds more like a new laxative...pimf

One of the three Baltic States on the seacoast between Poland and Russia. Latvia, Lithuania and Estonia.

76 sbvft contributor  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:32:58am

Given the pipeline angle, anyone want to venture a guess how much oil will spike tomorrow?

77 ggt  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:33:31am

re: #67 lifeofthemind

"Access to the sea" seems to be a reoccurring theme in world history.

Help me out here Lizards, wouldn't George have the idea that they are in a precarious position and have their ducks in a row before they involved themselves with a bigger adversary?

Just sayin' there is something here I'm missing. I tend to see and understand things in the broad scope.

78 zombie  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:33:38am
. Kā raksta "Zombie", tas tā nav visās šāda veida izdarībās - vismaz šajā noteikti nē.

Does that say, "We must target this diabolical "Zombie" character for immediate termination!" or, alternately, "Why hasn't somebody given "Zombie" a Pulitzer Prize yet?"

Could go either way!

Though it does look like they're gearing up for an international boycot of all SABMIller beers:

Kā savus svarīgākos starptautiskos zīmolus SABMiller min Pilsner Urquell, Peroni Nastro Azzurro, Miller Genuine Draft (un protams viss, kas sākas ar Miller), un Castle Lager. Pēc MillerCoors mājaslapās pieejamās informācijas, caur ASV tirgum veidotu kopuzņēmumu ar MolsonCoors, pie kompānijas zināmākajiem zīmoliem būtu pieskaitami arī visi, kas sākas ar Coors, Molson, Fosters, un Killian's Irish Red.
79 lifeofthemind  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:33:49am

If Congress hadn't spent the last 35 years shrinking the American armed forces to handcuff the President and fund pork barrel welfare for liberals then the US military would be twice its' present size and the Russians wouldn't have tried anything.

80 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:33:50am

re: #61 lawhawk

Well said - I truly believe we're looking at the reincorporation of Imperial Russia. Maybe we can get the old "Prisonhouse of Nations" tag revived?

81 jemima  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:33:59am

The leftists would be happy with a Soviet type diet. "I'm too fat anyway, cabbage will fine but I'll pass on the potatoes."

82 Colonel Panik  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:34:02am

re: #76 sbvft contributor

Given the pipeline angle, anyone want to venture a guess how much oil will spike tomorrow?

I don't even want to think about it. Gas is back down to 3.71 a gallon for regular here in AZ. Better fill up the Camry today.

83 Sharmuta  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:34:19am

re: #74 trailortrash

the french dont seem to be on russias side...

Is France ever on anybody's side?

84 itellu3times  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:34:39am

re: #26 Dianna

Question: Are we going to let them reincorporate Georgia as a province of Imperial Russia?

Answer: Yes.

Now, I'll take Broadway Shows for $200, Alex.

85 trailortrash  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:34:46am

lol sharm, true

86 Charles  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:35:05am

OT notice: I am completely fed up with these delusional Obama birth certificate stories, and I'm going to delete any and all links that are posted about it. This morning someone posted a link to a blog that cited LARRY JOHNSON as a source for this, despite Johnson's long history of fraud and lies.

I do not want this garbage at LGF. Don't post links to it here.

87 MikeySDCA  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:35:15am

re: #70 Desert Dog

Latvia, if you could learn to read, not to mention spell. Latvia

88 _RememberTonyC  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:35:38am

the anti war movement confirms all of its own bad traits at a time like this. for example:

cowering in silence while a war they have no clue about claims many innocent victims.

backing down in the face of brute force. let's be honest, they hate it when we use force but show (through their silence and cowardice) they understand that it works. it's working on them. putin is playing them big time.

that said, I am in no way equating the USA's use of force with that of putin. their motives could not be more different. and since the anti war crowd can't admit that fact, it really tells me their patriotism is very much worth questioning.

89 pat  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:35:39am

France is always on the side.

90 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:35:53am

re: #69 Spiny Norman

Putin wants not just Georgia, but all of the former Soviet Empire.

What will we do when he invades the Baltic States?

I think he might settle for the old Russian Empire...but I don't think I'll count on that.

91 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:36:44am

re: #71 Sharmuta

We are definitely looking at the whole-sale conquest of Georgia.

92 MandyManners  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:37:17am

Sen. John McCain.

"For many years, I have warned against Russian actions that undermine the sovereignty of its neighbors. Unfortunately, we have seen in recent days Russia demonstrate that these concerns were well-founded.

"This afternoon I spoke, for the second time since the crisis began, with Georgian President Saakashvili. It is clear the situation is dire. Russian aggression against Georgia continues, with attacks occurring far beyond the Georgian region of South Ossetia. As casualties continue to mount, the international community must do all it can to avert further escalations. Tensions and hostilities between Georgians and Ossetians are in no way justification for Russian troops crossing an internationally recognized border. I again call on the Government of Russia to immediately and unconditionally withdraw its forces from the territory of Georgia.

"Given this threat to Euro-Atlantic security, I am pleased to see the United States, the European Union, and NATO acting together by sending a delegation to the region, in an effort to broker a cease fire. This is an important first step.

SNIP

93 aboo-Hoo-Hoo  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:37:24am

Why does the Bear sit on its own trap when it poops in the woods?

Vlad's blowin' it.

94 realwest  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:37:37am

It's pretty simple to me: regardless of who started this conflict, it's obvious that a US ally, who has had 2,000 troops fighting alongside us in Iraq, is now being visciously attacked - not over the "disputed" territory, but all over Georgia. Our ally. And Russia is bombing Georgian cities without regard to the deaths of civilians from that bombing.
And now the Ukraine has said it may not allow the Russian naval squadron to get back to it's base
in the Caspian sea.
And, apparently, Bush and Putin had some hard, harsh words and turned their backs on each other at the Olympics and stomped away.
Methinks this is a whole lot more than what the MSM has portrayed it so far.
And btw, thank you MANDY MANNERS for your excellent coverage of events over there, out on the Dead Thread.
And Fox News is now reporting that the international CIVILIAN airport in Georgia's capital is being bombed.
And what have we (the U.S.) done about any of this?

95 galloping granny  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:37:54am

re: #89 pat

France is always on the side.

No, they are front and center when surrender is required.

96 MandyManners  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:37:57am

re: #92 MandyManners

BHO: "Just lemme' hang ten."

97 soccerdad  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:38:08am

re: #8 laxmatt1984

Their not silent at all. They are supporting Russia.

[Link: dailykos.com...]

What a rant -- written by Jerome A Paris. A french guy. no wonder

98 MandyManners  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:38:43am

re: #94 realwest

You're welcome.

99 galloping granny  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:38:56am

re: #92 MandyManners

Sen. John McCain.

"For many years, I have warned against Russian actions that undermine the sovereignty of its neighbors. Unfortunately, we have seen in recent days Russia demonstrate that these concerns were well-founded.

"This afternoon I spoke, for the second time since the crisis began, with Georgian President Saakashvili. It is clear the situation is dire. Russian aggression against Georgia continues, with attacks occurring far beyond the Georgian region of South Ossetia. As casualties continue to mount, the international community must do all it can to avert further escalations. Tensions and hostilities between Georgians and Ossetians are in no way justification for Russian troops crossing an internationally recognized border. I again call on the Government of Russia to immediately and unconditionally withdraw its forces from the territory of Georgia.

"Given this threat to Euro-Atlantic security, I am pleased to see the United States, the European Union, and NATO acting together by sending a delegation to the region, in an effort to broker a cease fire. This is an important first step.

SNIP

This is from yesterday, BTW.

100 Alouette  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:38:58am

How come nobody wants to talk about the massive explosion in Toronto?

101 Truck Monkey  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:39:17am

re: #83 Sharmuta

Is France ever on anybody's side?

France is essentially round and has no sides, but they are one of the more powerful nations in NATO. Think about it.

102 sbvft contributor  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:39:29am

Russia is nothing w/o their huge advantage in oil/natural gas resources financing their economic & military expansionism. Yet another reason to drill here/drill now.

103 pat  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:39:39am

Mandy, in fact McCain has been saying just that. And has been pooh-poohed by the MSM and the Obama camp.

104 zombie  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:39:39am

This war is a direct result of Stalin's policies -- the countries of the former Soviet Union are still paying for what Stalin wrought, decades after the fact.

Stalin, craving more and more territory, and especially wanting to expand southward, forced millions of ethnic Russians to move to the southern Republics (like Georgia, Uzbekistan, and Chechnya), to "overwhelm" the natives demographically. Problem with this attempted ethnic cleansing is that it stopped halfway, so that all these places ended with with sharp Balkan-style ethnic divisions. One the Soviet Union collapsed, the old ethnic hatreds erupted again.

105 itellu3times  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:39:56am

re: #26 Dianna

Question: Are we going to let them reincorporate Georgia as a province of Imperial Russia?

More serious answer, is exactly who do you mean by 'we'?

If the rest of NATO doesn't wake up, and what are the odds, the US is just piss tired of going it alone.

Russia has publically hog-tied the UN, I think the US ambassador ought to propose shutting down the UN officially, rezone the area agricultural.

106 lifeofthemind  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:40:00am

This meme of the left that Georgia started it has to stop. They invaded their own country after the Russians occupied a portion of it and handed out Russian passports. The argument that the West did the same thing in Kosovo is not only childish but irrelevant. The Kosovo action may have been questionable but it was caused by massive human rights violations on the part of the Serbian army throughout the region after the breakup of Yugoslavia. That simply does not apply to the Georgian case.

107 galloping granny  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:40:07am

re: #100 Alouette

How come nobody wants to talk about the massive explosion in Toronto?

Massive explosion in Toronto. Will be written off as accidental, lousy storage, no connection whatever to terrorism. No matter what the real case might be. What more is there to discuss?

108 ggt  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:40:11am

Bear with me here.

South Ossetia wanted independence. WTF, why? When you know you are vulnerable --or at least surrounded by bullies, why would you want to be stand all by your lonesome?

Kinda reminds me of the group that wants a Free Alaska --why would a state sitting on lots of oil and just a short raft trip away from Russia want free themselves of American Military protection?

Sorry, antibiotics have kicked-in and my brain is de-fuzzed. Just getting to where I can think again.

109 dmandman  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:40:13am

re: #100 Alouette

It looks like a Industrial Accident...who knows the Canadian media isn't saying anything that makes any sense.

110 Sharmuta  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:40:24am

According to wikipedia- Georgia was promised membership in NATO. I would think it would be in NATO's interests to stand up for Georgia now, lest any future countries who've been promised membership think NATO won't be there for them in their time of need.

111 DeafDog  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:40:33am

re: #92 MandyManners

He may have his foilables on domestic policy, but when it comes to foreign policy McCain is very good.

112 Spiny Norman  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:40:44am

re: #90 Dianna

I think he might settle for the old Russian Empire...but I don't think I'll count on that.

No, the Baltic States are still an issue for Russia, as there are a lot of ethnic Russians in those countries who do not think of themselves as Lithuanian, Latvian, or Estonian and complain that they are discriminated against (probably true to some extent) and would welcome the Soviet Russian Gazprom tanks rumbling over the border.

113 Truck Monkey  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:41:09am

re: #86 Charles

OT notice: I am completely fed up with these delusional Obama birth certificate stories, and I'm going to delete any and all links that are posted about it. This morning someone posted a link to a blog that cited LARRY JOHNSON as a source for this, despite Johnson's long history of fraud and lies.

I do not want this garbage at LGF. Don't post links to it here.

I would also say that you cannot prove a virgin birth. You must have faith.

114 nyc redneck  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:41:09am

re: #81 jemima

The leftists would be happy with a Soviet type diet. "I'm too fat anyway, cabbage will fine but I'll pass on the potatoes."

the leftists don't think they will be eating peasant food.
they intend to dine on caviar.
we'll get the slop.

115 Colonel Panik  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:41:23am

re: #100 Alouette

How come nobody wants to talk about the massive explosion in Toronto?

Any indications it might be ROPer economic sabotage?

116 pat  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:41:34am

re: #100 Alouette

How come nobody wants to talk about the massive explosion in Toronto?

Propane factories (propane is manufactured) do explode from time to time.

117 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:41:37am

re: #92 MandyManners

A bloody delegation?!

Great. Let's dither and wring our hands. That will help so very much, while Russia bombs undefended civilians.

Just freakin' peachy.

Excuse me. I think I'm losing my temper. I shall take a break.

118 MandyManners  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:41:51am

re: #99 galloping granny

No shit?

119 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:42:06am
120 Sharmuta  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:42:13am

re: #101 Truck Monkey

Oh- I know, and I think it's good they're not taking the side of the Russians, but you'll forgive me if I make a little joke.

121 MandyManners  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:42:13am

bbiab

122 itellu3times  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:42:16am

re: #100 Alouette

How come nobody wants to talk about the massive explosion in Toronto?

Linky?

All I see on the news sites is that Clay Aiken is a father.

123 Colonel Panik  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:42:21am

re: #116 pat

Propane factories (propane is manufactured) do explode from time to time.

True, but they can also be made to explode. Lot's of ROPers in Canada.

124 DeafDog  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:42:28am

re: #104 zombie

This war is a direct result of Stalin's policies --

I Believe Stalin was from Georgia.

125 zombie  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:43:14am

re: #124 DeafDog

I Believe Stalin was from Georgia.

Yup.

126 lifeofthemind  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:43:24am

re: #94 realwest


And now the Ukraine has said it may not allow the Russian naval squadron to get back to it's base
in the Caspian sea.

Correction. It's the Black Sea.

127 itellu3times  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:43:31am

re: #124 DeafDog

I Believe Stalin was from Georgia.

Irony never sleeps.

128 ggt  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:43:35am

re: #122 itellu3times

Blame for both (Aiken and Toronto) can be squarely rested on Bush.

Case closed, now, let's here more about Edwards . .

/arghhhhhhhh!

129 MikeySDCA  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:43:46am

re: #94 realwest

Sorry, it's the Black Sea, not the Caspian Sea.

130 galloping granny  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:43:46am

re: #110 Sharmuta

According to wikipedia- Georgia was promised membership in NATO. I would think it would be in NATO's interests to stand up for Georgia now, lest any future countries who've been promised membership think NATO won't be there for them in their time of need.

I think that Georgia is also one of the countries that Russia has been issuing dire warnings to about even thinking of hosting an early warning site for the US missile defense system.

/which tells me they have every intention of using those missiles.

131 zombie  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:43:50am

But you'll note that he dropped his Georgian name, once he entered poilitics.

132 sbvft contributor  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:43:58am

re: #124 DeafDog

I Believe Stalin was from Georgia.

Jimmy Carter too. Why do the worst of the Bolsheviks seem to come from Georgia?.... :)

133 akak  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:44:19am

re: #100 Alouette

How come nobody wants to talk about the massive explosion in Toronto?


That's 2 in recent years, people may not want to live/work near them.

134 ggt  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:44:21am

re: #124 DeafDog

Ah, so we can't let the birthplace of the grand whatever leave the motherland . . .

yes, I see.

135 noshariaincanada  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:44:37am

on the one hand Russia fights a multiyear bloody war in Chechnya to prevent that region from seceding.

On the other hand Russia encourages South Ossetia to secede from Georgia (and thus join Russia.)

Makes perfect sense, if you consider Russia's desire to maintain its power in the region.

136 pat  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:45:09am

Usually propane is stored in an open field, well away from other gases. So the explosions are impressive, but cause little damage.

137 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:45:22am

re: #100 Alouette

Because I hadn't heard about it - sorry. I've been chasing the Georgia-Russia story.

In brief, what happened?

138 The Other Les  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:45:58am

re: #1 JammieWearingFool

Funny how silent the anti-war left is these days.

The anti-war movement as it presently exists was created by the Soviets. Tyrannophila is an inherent characteristic of it.

139 pat  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:46:07am

re: #132 sbvft contributor

lol

140 ggt  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:46:15am

So, ultimately, it's Catharine the Great who is to blame for all of this?

(Great Russian Expansion pathology)

141 galloping granny  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:46:24am

re: #118 MandyManners

No shit?

Yeah - that second paragraph at least is a big part of his official statement from yesterday. Couple of sites have the whole thing, along with the contrasting "statement" from Obama.

I was impressed that he had already talked twice to the President of Georgia yesterday. Mac is a good guy.

142 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:46:31am

re: #105 itellu3times

If Europe's that stupid, they deserve what they get.

143 _RememberTonyC  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:46:32am

#132 ... Funny ...

But Georgia did redeem itself with Zell Miller.

144 jorline  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:46:42am

re: #32 zombie

Anybody know what country has the "lv" domain? Because I'm getting a lot of links from blogs there linking to my Up Your Alley event.

Wish I knew what they were saying! Weird-looking language.

I only understood a few words. Miller Brewing Company?

Neskatoties uz negatīvo publicitāti pēc pagājušajā gada pasākumiem, viens no galvenajiem sponsoriem joprojām esot Miller Brewing Company (arī MillerCoors). Šī kompānija savukart pieder pie SABMiller - vienas no pasaules lielākajām alus darītavu "apvienībām".

145 noshariaincanada  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:46:49am

re: #140 ggt

So, ultimately, it's Catharine the Great who is to blame for all of this?

(Great Russian Expansion pathology)

Yes, and yet the leftists call the USA an "imperialist" nation.

146 Sharmuta  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:46:54am

The Discovery Institute's Russia Blog wants us to believe that Russian Authoritarianism is just a misconception. So this foray into Georgia can't be due to imperialism. And if you can't trust the Discovery Institute to tell you like it is, who can you trust?

///

147 zombie  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:46:55am

Ooooh, these are the modern descendants of the Alans. I didn't realize that. I once studied the Alans a bit. Dark Ages history is actually pretty interesting.

148 MikeySDCA  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:47:11am

re: #131 zombie

He adopted "Stalin" (and several other names) in accordance with underground practice at the time.

149 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:47:27am

re: #140 ggt

The largest expansion of Russian territory occurred under Ivan IV, otherwise known as "The Terrible."

That's when Russia claimed Siberia.

150 Westward Ho  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:47:35am

re: #63 realwest

Realwest sorry for the delay,

Realwest,

What I am trying to put across is that Mikhail acted just like Mahmoud Ahmedinejad and Hugo Chavez, leaders of shitholes acting like completely disrespectful punks, totally pissing of the great powers with impunity in the region till they get their asses kicked.

You can call it the Iron Fist theory of Geopolitics.

151 ggt  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:47:45am

re: #147 zombie

Dark Ages is a misnomer. And, yes, it is very interesting.

152 descolada9  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:47:47am

So is this what we get for recognizing Kosovo's independence? I believe Russia did warn us that there might be long run consequences regarding Kosovo statehood.

153 DeafDog  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:48:12am

re: #132 sbvft contributor

Jimmy Carter too. Why do the worst of the Bolsheviks seem to come from Georgia?.... :)

Hah!

Side note - I work with folks from Atlanta. At their office there are TVs in the elevator. I got an e-mail from a guy Friday who was riding the elevator with a young lady of the blonde persuasion. The elevator TVs were broadcasting that Russia had invaded Georgia and the young lady was ashen..."How is that even possible?" she asked.

154 MandyManners  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:48:20am

re: #130 galloping granny

I think that Georgia is also one of the countries that Russia has been issuing dire warnings to about even thinking of hosting an early warning site for the US missile defense system.

/which tells me they have every intention of using those missiles.

From NY Sun in 2007.

MOSCOW — Georgia risked provoking a furious response from its powerful Russian neighbor yesterday by saying it was prepared to host part of America's new missile defense shield.

Gela Bezhuashvili, the Georgian foreign minister, said his country was ready, if asked, to join the Czech Republic and Poland in allowing its territory to be used for the deployment of new missile batteries and radar sites.

"If the Americans came and told us they wanted to, we are certainly minded to talk with them about it," said Mr. Bezhuashvili. "There is no formal application, not even informal discussions. But if they ask for help, we will talk with them."

SNIP

155 pat  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:48:28am

Peter the Great commenced the Ottoman rollback. It was a sad day when he struck peace with the Ottomans so he could wage war against Sweden in the Baltics. He had the Ottomans about ready to abandon Europe.

156 noshariaincanada  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:48:29am

where's Obama stand on all this ?

157 ggt  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:48:31am

re: #149 Dianna

It would be terrible to want Siberia. yes?

oh, and thanks for the clarification.

158 Truck Monkey  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:48:42am

re: #122 itellu3times

Linky?

All I see on the news sites is that Clay Aiken is a father.

Clay Aiken is a boy? Who knew.....

159 sbvft contributor  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:49:08am

re: #143 _RememberTonyC

#132 ... Funny ...

But Georgia did redeem itself with Zell Miller.


True dat. Spitballs!

160 ggt  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:49:16am

gotta go.

Have a great day all!

161 galloping granny  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:49:18am

re: #138 The Other Les

The anti-war movement as it presently exists was created by the Soviets. Tyrannophila is an inherent characteristic of it.

As are many if not all of the various groups involved. Oldsters like me will recognize Students for a Democratic Society and the International Solidarity Movement (still active on college campuses today) as prime players from the 60s - and known Communist organizations.

162 realwest  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:49:24am

re: #126 lifeofthemind
Thanks for the correction, but the point still stands.

163 lifeofthemind  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:49:59am

re: #147 zombie

Ooooh, these are the modern descendants of the Alans. I didn't realize that. I once studied the Alans a bit. Dark Ages history is actually pretty interesting.

Attila and the Huns came crashing through and the tribes that were wandering around the Eurasian plains as the Roman Empire collapsed suddenly scattered in all directions.

164 MandyManners  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:50:02am

re: #156 noshariaincanada

where's Obama stand on all this ?

Just let him hang 10.

165 itellu3times  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:50:04am

re: #142 Dianna

If Europe's that stupid, they deserve what they get.

I'm confused, what do you mean by 'If'?

Here's a link about Toronto, where apparently a propane plant blew up. Had to go search it on Google to find reports!

Maybe it was attacked by Russian stealth bombers.

166 itellu3times  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:51:03am

re: #158 Truck Monkey

Clay Aiken is a boy? Who knew.....

There was apparently massive technological assistance involved.

167 MandyManners  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:51:06am

re: #147 zombie

Ooooh, these are the modern descendants of the Alans. I didn't realize that. I once studied the Alans a bit. Dark Ages history is actually pretty interesting.

Here's some history.

[Link: www.aboutgeorgia.net...]

168 DeafDog  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:51:16am

re: #156 noshariaincanada

where's Obama stand on all this ?

Forgainst, of course

169 lawhawk  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:51:27am

re: #156 noshariaincanada

where's Obama stand on all this ?

All over the map.

170 Truck Monkey  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:51:35am

re: #143 _RememberTonyC

#132 ... Funny ...

But Georgia did redeem itself with Zell Miller.

Minus major points for giving the world Cynthia McKinney.

171 realwest  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:51:36am

re: #150 Westward Ho
Well I don't know if you were referring to LGF's Iron Fist (who wouldn't kill civilians) or the idea of Might Makes Right, but regardless, the killing of civilians in Georgian cities and now at the International (Civilian) Airport in Georgia is not the sort of thing one would expect to be supported on LGF.

172 The Other Les  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:51:48am

re: #40 MandyManners

Putin doesn't want just South Ossetia and Abkhazia. He wants Georgia, too.

"A little piece of Poland, a little piece of France..."

173 MandyManners  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:52:06am

re: #156 noshariaincanada

where's Obama stand on all this ?

Just let him eat his pineapple.

174 aboo-Hoo-Hoo  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:52:07am

re: #156 noshariaincanada

where's Obama stand on all this ?

Everywhere and nowhere.

175 rorschach  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:52:12am

"Mr. Putin, rebuild this wall!"

/doh-bama

176 noshariaincanada  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:52:26am

re: #164 MandyManners

Just let him hang 10.

actually, I found out from HotAir that he's already flip-flopped. Surprised ?

177 MandyManners  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:52:44am

re: #172 The Other Les

"A little piece of Poland, a little piece of France..."

So help me, I'd rather deal with Islam. Putin has a lot of missiles.

178 itellu3times  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:52:50am

re: #156 noshariaincanada

where's Obama stand on all this ?

He recommended the Georgians check their tire pressure.

179 Alouette  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:52:50am

re: #137 Dianna

Because I hadn't heard about it - sorry. I've been chasing the Georgia-Russia story.

In brief, what happened?

Check the spinoffs.

180 Spiny Norman  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:53:17am

re: #140 ggt

So, ultimately, it's Catherine the Great who is to blame for all of this?

(Great Russian Expansion pathology)

And wasn't she German? How does one spell "liebensraum" in Cyrillic?

181 MandyManners  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:53:23am

re: #176 noshariaincanada

actually, I found out from HotAir that he's already flip-flopped. Surprised ?

He needs to stay on the porch and let the big dogs figure this out.

182 nyc redneck  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:53:24am

re: #141 galloping granny

Yeah - that second paragraph at least is a big part of his official statement from yesterday. Couple of sites have the whole thing, along with the contrasting "statement" from Obama.

I was impressed that he had already talked twice to the President of Georgia yesterday. Mac is a good guy.

i think mccain has good instincts. unlike the bumbling pontificator, b.o., mccain can see the issues and formulate some coherent thoughts that are not just abt. him.

183 pat  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:53:26am

Is this the change that Obama believes in?

184 galloping granny  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:54:09am

re: #156 noshariaincanada

where's Obama stand on all this ?

He urged diplomacy until somebody read John MacCain for him and he looked up what side to be on.

185 yma o hyd  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:54:21am

re: #72 Dianna

Europe had better realize that they are about to let Russia control their energy completely.

They know that - after all, some are making a nice load of money from those 'deals', the former German Chancellor Schroeder (he was a leftie ...) right amongst them ...

186 The Other Les  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:54:53am

re: #48 FrogMarch

Up next - a roll of lies from the Kremlin.

More of the usual Soviet Russian propaganda.

See the children give flowers to the Soviet Russian soldiers at about 1:30 on the video.

187 realwest  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:54:55am

re: #154 MandyManners
Huh, wonder what that means for Poland and Czechoslovakia? If the U.S. doesn't stand by Georgia, why would Poland expect us to stand by them (iirc, Poland also has troops in Iraq)?

Bush needs to get his ass in gear, pronto.

188 swamprat  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:55:25am

re: #150 Westward Ho

You can call it the Iron Fist theory of Geopolitics.




If you think that you are too drunk too overthrow a country; you are.
189 realwest  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:55:40am

re: #156 noshariaincanada Great Question! Anyone hear anything from Obama at all?

190 dmandman  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:55:43am

re: #183 pat

I think the change Obama believes in is the coins you get back after buying something. Everything else is about him.

191 MikeySDCA  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:55:44am

re: #185 yma o hyd

Of course the Euris are weasals and/or crooks.

192 lifeofthemind  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:56:12am

re: #162 realwest

Thanks for the correction, but the point still stands.

Of course. It is complicated. Azeri (Moslem) oil needs to traverse either Russia and Chechnya (Moslem territory the Russians are invading) or a new pipeline through Georgia. There is a long standing dispute between the Azeris and the Armenians because Stalis nationalities policy deliberately set up the enclave of Nagorno-karabakh that Armenia invaded. The Armenians of course hate the Turks because of the genocide of 1915 that the Turks refuse to admit. Is everyone following this?

193 Sharmuta  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:56:24am

re: #155 pat

Peter the Great commenced the Ottoman rollback. It was a sad day when he struck peace with the Ottomans so he could wage war against Sweden in the Baltics. He had the Ottomans about ready to abandon Europe.

The Crimean War pitted the UK, France and the Ottomans against the Russians. The UK was very worried about the Russians becoming a major player, and worked against them in more than a couple instances. Had England not sided with the Turks, the Russians may have taken back Constantinople at some point.

194 rorschach  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:56:27am
#187 realwest Bush needs to get his ass in gear, pronto.

That would interfere with the ass-kissing fest in bejing.

195 galloping granny  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:56:28am

re: #180 Spiny Norman

And wasn't she German? How does one spell "liebensraum" in Cyrillic?

Yes she was German. By the time the Tsar was overthrown each and every one of the royal families of Europe was close to 100% German - including the British royal family, who changed their name from house of Hanover to house of Windsor at the beginning of WWI. All of whom were directly related to Victoria. WWI was the single biggest family feud in history.

196 MandyManners  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:56:44am

re: #187 realwest

Huh, wonder what that means for Poland and Czechoslovakia? If the U.S. doesn't stand by Georgia, why would Poland expect us to stand by them (iirc, Poland also has troops in Iraq)?

Bush needs to get his ass in gear, pronto.


What is Pres. Bush supposed to do? Go to war with Russia?

197 MikeySDCA  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:57:31am

re: #192 lifeofthemind

Yes, though you're giving the short version.

198 galloping granny  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:57:56am

re: #182 nyc redneck

i think mccain has good instincts. unlike the bumbling pontificator, b.o., mccain can see the issues and formulate some coherent thoughts that are not just abt. him.

Foreign policy has always been one of MacCain's interests and one of his strong suits.

199 opinionated  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:58:11am

"It's none of our business"

Patrick J. Buchanan

200 itellu3times  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:58:21am

re: #196 MandyManners

What is Pres. Bush supposed to do? Go to war with Russia?

Effectively, yes.

201 lifeofthemind  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:58:51am

re: #172 The Other Les

"A little piece of Poland, a little piece of France..."

Peace is vhat ve vant und vill haf unkluding und piece of anyting you haf.
- Bored of the Rings

202 American Jewess In Jerusalem  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:59:15am

re: #156 noshariaincanada

where's Obama stand on all this ?

He stands wherever you want him to stand.

203 debutaunt  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 9:59:51am

re: #1 JammieWearingFool

Funny how silent the anti-war left is these days.

Privately, they must be giggling like crazy.

204 Nevergiveup  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:00:06am

re: #187 realwest

Huh, wonder what that means for Poland and Czechoslovakia? If the U.S. doesn't stand by Georgia, why would Poland expect us to stand by them (iirc, Poland also has troops in Iraq)?

Bush needs to get his ass in gear, pronto.

Well I think there is a huge difference between Georgia and Poland and Czech. Both in geographical terms and in geopolitical terms. I think President Bush should definitely make the Soviets ( and I use the term soviets here instead of Russia to characterize what I think Putin is up to ) pay for this. But it other than material and moral support, I am not sure how far we can or should go in helping.

205 sbvft contributor  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:00:09am

re: #187 realwest

Huh, wonder what that means for Poland and Czechoslovakia? If the U.S. doesn't stand by Georgia, why would Poland expect us to stand by them (iirc, Poland also has troops in Iraq)?

Bush needs to get his ass in gear, pronto.

George Will said this morning on "This Week" that GW should get his ass back to Washington and deal with this. Too busy patting volleyball players on the bum I guess.........can u blame him?

206 opinionated  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:00:11am

Anyone hear from "Russian Expert" Condoleezza Rice?

Maybe she can be pried away from spending her time concerned that Israel is not allowing Gazan terrorists to get a US education.

207 galloping granny  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:00:27am

re: #196 MandyManners

What is Pres. Bush supposed to do? Go to war with Russia?

I think that is what Putin wants Mandy. And go look at the map. Georgia is just about a spit and a stone's throw from the northern border of Iraq. Iran on one side, Syria (long time Russian satellite) on the other.

Add in the threat last week from Iran to close the Straights.

I don't like the way things stack up for sure.

208 Sharmuta  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:00:36am

More on the Georgian airport:

Russian jets were still carrying out bombing raids late on Sunday. Witnesses said jets had hit Tbilisi International Airport, as well as a military airfield close to the Georgian capital.

A Georgian official said Russian planes had also bombed the western town of Zugdidi and Georgian-controlled territory inside Abkhazia. The claims could not be independently verified.

The attack on the airport came only a few hours before the scheduled arrival of French Foreign Minister Bernard Kouchner and Finnish Foreign Minister Alexander Stubb, on a peace mission.

209 A. van Hilten  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:01:24am

re: #187 realwest

Huh, wonder what that means for Poland and Czechoslovakia? If the U.S. doesn't stand by Georgia, why would Poland expect us to stand by them (iirc, Poland also has troops in Iraq)?

Bush needs to get his ass in gear, pronto.

Poland and the Czech Republic are already NATO members. Any attack against their territorial integrity would trigger an 'armed response' by the rest of the Alliance member states. Or so the story goes.

[Link: www.nato.int...]

210 itellu3times  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:01:34am

Belmont Club is covering and commenting on events, suggests Gori will be the military decision point. The question is whether Russia will advance on that point. I think the answer is yes, the Russian military is obviously driving events, and will find it irresistable.

map

(Gori is small city just east of Tbilisi)

211 kynna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:02:15am

I'm not being facetious so please don't take this the wrong way.

What can we do? As we know (and Barack 'Surge in Afghanistan' Obama doesn't), one size doesn't fit all where these foreign affairs are concerned.

As I've said before, this conflict chills me to the bone. I want to be able to see a clear option for the US, but it's hard to wrap my head around it.

Anyone got any ideas?

212 jorline  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:02:37am

re: #156 noshariaincanada

where's Obama stand on all this ?

Doing his best Rodney King impersonation..."Why can't we all just get a long"...

213 DeafDog  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:02:43am

re: #204 Nevergiveup

Well I think there is a huge difference between Georgia and Poland and Czech. Both in geographical terms and in geopolitical terms. I think President Bush should definitely make the Soviets ( and I use the term soviets here instead of Russia to characterize what I think Putin is up to ) pay for this. But it other than material and moral support, I am not sure how far we can or should go in helping.

The announcement from the ukrain to not allow 'soviet' warships to return to port was good stuff. To the extent that these sort of diplomatic coups can be arranged they need to be made. Strong world support against the 'soviets' may push the ruskies out....it's worth a try.

214 pat  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:03:10am

re: #199 opinionated

"It's none of our business"

Patrick J. Buchanan

"The invasion of Georgia would never have happened if the Georgians were not so foolish as to covet their own territory on a week in which the Olympics were scheduled."

Patrick Buchanan

215 itellu3times  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:03:25am

re: #206 opinionated

Anyone hear from "Russian Expert" Condoleezza Rice?

Maybe she can be pried away from spending her time concerned that Israel is not allowing Gazan terrorists to get a US education.

Yeah. Condi. Snort. I presume she's also in Beijing, negotiating to become the next volleyball czarina in 2009.

216 rorschach  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:03:32am
From The Astute Bloggers...

PIPELINE WAR: AZERBAIJAN HALTS OIL FLOW THROUGH GEORGIA


"We should definitely empty our strategic petroleum reserve immediately."

/doh-bama

217 MikeySDCA  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:03:38am

re: #195 galloping granny

Sorry, House of Saxe-Coburg and Gotha

218 The Other Les  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:04:30am

re: #186 The Other Les

Forgot the link

219 MandyManners  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:04:36am

re: #207 galloping granny

I think that is what Putin wants Mandy. And go look at the map. Georgia is just about a spit and a stone's throw from the northern border of Iraq. Iran on one side, Syria (long time Russian satellite) on the other.

Add in the threat last week from Iran to close the Straights.

I don't like the way things stack up for sure.

Nor do I.

220 Sharmuta  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:04:38am

re: #211 kynna

Georgia has been promised NATO membership- they should be granted full NATO protection right now, and the Russians told to back off or they'll have all of NATO to deal with. Let Russia either then back off, or push their luck.

221 MandyManners  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:04:51am

re: #208 Sharmuta

More on the Georgian airport:

Oh, no.

222 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:04:57am

re: #148 MikeySDCA

Stalin's initial alias was Koba, after the hero of a novel. Most of the Old Bolsheviks addressed him, and spoke of him, as Koba.

223 itellu3times  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:05:06am

re: #207 galloping granny

... Add in the threat last week from Iran to close the Straights.

I don't like the way things stack up for sure.

Well, Iran says that a lot, so I'd discount it. But remember WWI and the way things can snowball out of control.

If they haven't already.

Putin has bet they will not.

224 pat  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:05:10am

Interesting that the American volleyball team is coached by a ChiCom star.

225 Nevergiveup  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:05:19am

re: #213 DeafDog

The announcement from the ukrain to not allow 'soviet' warships to return to port was good stuff. To the extent that these sort of diplomatic coups can be arranged they need to be made. Strong world support against the 'soviets' may push the ruskies out....it's worth a try.

I agree. It may be time to start kicking some ruskie ass out of certain international organizations. The G-8 comes to mind.

226 galloping granny  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:05:59am

re: #217 MikeySDCA

Sorry, House of Saxe-Coburg and Gotha

Oh, you are correct. Victoria was the last Hanover.

[Link: en.wikipedia.org...]

227 gymnast  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:06:15am

Perhaps Russia is more interested in maintaining $150 a barrel oil and a strangle hold on European energy supplies than "World Peace" and EU prosperity. Seems that they have found a way to accomplish this goal and it is unlikely that any OPEC states will have a real problem with Russia's actions.

228 swamprat  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:06:19am

re: #188 swamprat I.F., I will treasure that rating for a long, long time.

229 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:06:20am

re: #155 pat

Ah, no.

The Ottomans were pretty weak by the time Peter came to power.

230 DeafDog  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:06:23am

re: #216 rorschach

"We should definitely empty our strategic petroleum reserve immediately."

/doh-bama

You know, if there is an actual constriction in world supply as a result of this action, then that is not a bad use of the SPR. Incidents lik this are exactly the reason that we should not have released the reserves just because of price increases.

231 itellu3times  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:06:37am

re: #216 rorschach

"PIPELINE WAR: AZERBAIJAN HALTS OIL FLOW THROUGH GEORGIA

Well, if I was operations manager for the line, I think I'd halt the flow about now, too.

232 A. van Hilten  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:06:53am

re: #222 Dianna

Stalin's initial alias was Koba, after the hero of a novel. Most of the Old Bolsheviks addressed him, and spoke of him, as Koba.


[Link: www.amazon.com...]

233 debutaunt  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:07:33am

re: #42 Colonel Panik

Lativa? Are they suing roman characters or cyrillic? Latvians use roman characters and the language looks somewhat like Finnish.

Judging from the words in the link I'm guessing Latvia.

Who is suing Lativa? What happened?
- Emily Litella

234 The Other Les  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:07:45am

re: #214 pat

"The invasion of Georgia would never have happened if the Georgians were not so foolish as to covet their own territory on a week in which the Olympics were scheduled."

Patrick Buchanan

WTF?

Are you kidding?

235 sbvft contributor  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:07:47am

re: #221 MandyManners

Oh, no.

"Georgian President Mikhail Saakashvili told the BBC his forces had observed a ceasefire since 0500 on Sunday morning, but had still been bombed by Russian planes. He said his government had been trying "all day" to contact Russia to discuss a ceasefire."

Hmmmm. Must be something wrong with Czar Putin's receiver. Right.

236 galloping granny  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:07:48am

re: #223 itellu3times

Well, Iran says that a lot, so I'd discount it. But remember WWI and the way things can snowball out of control.

If they haven't already.

Putin has bet they will not.

Putin has bet that we will back down. Or that he, Iran and Syria have collectively decapitated us. Mark my words: this is not about Georgia. It is about US.

237 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:07:50am
238 MikeySDCA  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:07:57am

re: #226 galloping granny

Hanover by birth, but SCG by marriage. Victoria held no Hanoverian title, due to Salic Law.

239 MandyManners  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:08:16am

A year ago.

Russia has committed an "act of aggression" against Georgia by firing a guided missile at its territory, officials in Tbilisi say.
They say the missile landed outside the village of Tsitelubani on Monday, some 60km (37 miles) north-west of the capital Tbilisi, but did not explode.

Georgia has now made a formal protest to Russia over the incident. Moscow denies all the accusations.

Relations between the two countries have been strained in recent years.

Moscow is angry about Georgia's plans to join Nato, while Tbilisi accuses Russia of trying to destabilise Georgia.

SNIP

South Ossetia's leader Eduard Kokoiti said Georgian planes fired the missile to discredit Russia.

"This is a well-planned provocation," said Mr Kokoiti, who holds Russian citizenship.

SNIP

240 pat  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:08:31am

re: #234 The Other Les

yes

241 debutaunt  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:08:57am

re: #49 zombie

I didn't eat it myself: I just had to lie perfectly still.

HAHAHAHAHAHAHA Sushi server?

242 FrogMarch  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:09:21am

re: #156 noshariaincanada

where's Obama stand on all this ?

Your standard man-of-the world progressive flip flop.

243 lawhawk  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:09:31am

re: #220 Sharmuta

The problem there is that the rest of the NATO countries are in no position to take offensive military action to back up those kinds of threats. They can barely handle their responsibilities in Afghanistan, so why would they stick their necks out for the Georgians? Realpolitik is a bitch, and right now, the Russians know that they can do what they want without repercussions.

The Ukrainians are probably the best hope to thwart those Russian ambitions right now since they hold the trump card of the Russian Black Sea fleet homeport. Ukraine has pretty much told the Russians that if their ships are used in the fight against Georgia, they're not welcomed back in the Ukraine. That leaves them without a port or facilities, and the Ukrainians have a sizable military force as well.

244 yma o hyd  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:09:39am

re: #192 lifeofthemind

Of course. It is complicated. Azeri (Moslem) oil needs to traverse either Russia and Chechnya (Moslem territory the Russians are invading) or a new pipeline through Georgia. There is a long standing dispute between the Azeris and the Armenians because Stalis nationalities policy deliberately set up the enclave of Nagorno-karabakh that Armenia invaded. The Armenians of course hate the Turks because of the genocide of 1915 that the Turks refuse to admit. Is everyone following this?

Yep - and to make it even more interesting, the pipeline ends in Northern Turkey, where it was attacked by Kurd rebels a few days ago - Mandy Manners linked the story on one of the threads below.

245 sbvft contributor  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:09:54am

re: #224 pat

I saw a story on that last night. Disgrcaeful. Call me old-fashioned, but what the hell is an American doing helping the ChiComs beat us in volleyball? TRAITOR. Send this coach to Club Gitmo. Yesterday.

246 Basho  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:10:15am

re: #211 kynna


What can we do? As we know (and Barack 'Surge in Afghanistan' Obama doesn't), one size doesn't fit all where these foreign affairs are concerned.

As I've said before, this conflict chills me to the bone. I want to be able to see a clear option for the US, but it's hard to wrap my head around it.

Anyone got any ideas?

There's probably nothing we can do. Some air support perhaps. But I still believe that America is on its way to becoming a paper tiger (for a variety of reasons). All the righties who wanted America to become isolationist, and all the lefties who wanted a world where the US is militarily weak are slowly starting to get their wish. And it won't turn out to be the paradise they imagined.

247 lawhawk  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:10:45am

re: #230 DeafDog

Actually, it still wouldn't be a good use of the SPR since the oil supply to the US isn't constricted - most of our oil imported comes from Canada, KSA, and Mexico.

248 opinionated  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:11:07am
"We will not allow the deaths of our fellow citizens to go unpunished. The perpetrators will receive the punishment they deserve."

DMITRY MEDVEDEV

Israel should shove this statement in Russia's face anytime they dare criticize an Israeli response to the barbarians.

249 MandyManners  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:11:34am

re: #243 lawhawk

The problem there is that the rest of the NATO countries are in no position to take offensive military action to back up those kinds of threats. They can barely handle their responsibilities in Afghanistan, so why would they stick their necks out for the Georgians? Realpolitik is a bitch, and right now, the Russians know that they can do what they want without repercussions.

The Ukrainians are probably the best hope to thwart those Russian ambitions right now since they hold the trump card of the Russian Black Sea fleet homeport. Ukraine has pretty much told the Russians that if their ships are used in the fight against Georgia, they're not welcomed back in the Ukraine. That leaves them without a port or facilities, and the Ukrainians have a sizable military force as well.

KIEV, Ukraine - Ukraine warned Russia on Sunday it could bar Russian navy ships from returning to their base in the Crimea because of their deployment to Georgia's coast.

Ukraine's Foreign Ministry said the deployment of a Russian naval squadron to Georgia's Black sea coast has the potential of drawing Ukraine into the conflict

SNIP

250 A. van Hilten  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:12:02am

Article 5

The Parties agree that an armed attack against one or more of them in Europe or North America shall be considered an attack against them all and consequently they agree that, if such an armed attack occurs, each of them, in exercise of the right of individual or collective self-defence recognised by Article 51 of the Charter of the United Nations, will assist the Party or Parties so attacked by taking forthwith, individually and in concert with the other Parties, such action as it deems necessary, including the use of armed force, to restore and maintain the security of the North Atlantic area.

Any such armed attack and all measures taken as a result thereof shall immediately be reported to the Security Council. Such measures shall be terminated when the Security Council has taken the measures necessary to restore and maintain international peace and security.

[Link: www.nato.int...]

251 Nevergiveup  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:13:37am

re: #243 lawhawk

And the Ukrainians have a vested interest in seeing the Russian bear doesn't get up a head of steam. It seems I remember that Ukraine is on that long list of Provence's to be reacquired!

252 Colonel Panik  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:14:00am

re: #229 Dianna

Ah, no.

The Ottomans were pretty weak by the time Peter came to power.

Because Jan Sobieski, the King of Poland, kicked the crap out of them at Vienna.

253 BingoBunny  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:14:07am

The left calls GWB a war criminal for going to the UN to get permission for attacks on Iraq.. and our own congress..I think they say they didn't know what they were voteing to allow.. Putin goes into invasion without a peep from the left.. I guess they will learn later what he expects them to vote for.

254 pegcity  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:15:09am

re: #64 Desert Dog

canada is the only country in the world with oil thats not a criminal gangster state

255 pegcity  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:15:22am

re: #254 pegcity

oh and norway

256 DeafDog  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:15:26am

re: #247 lawhawk

Actually, it still wouldn't be a good use of the SPR since the oil supply to the US isn't constricted - most of our oil imported comes from Canada, KSA, and Mexico.

According to that logic, there are not two prices of oil: (1) a North American price and (2) a European price. But that's not how it works. It's a global energy market and the price reflects global demand. If the SPR could ease the pain in Western Europe, it would benefit both the US and are European 'sometimes allies."

257 Colonel Panik  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:15:37am

re: #216 rorschach

"We should definitely empty our strategic petroleum reserve immediately."

/doh-bama

Don't forget Nancy P. Lousy. She said that too.

258 Colonel Panik  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:16:08am

re: #254 pegcity

canada is the only country in the world with oil thats not a criminal gangster state

You forget Norway and the UK (North Sea).

259 Opinionated  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:16:12am

George Bush- I looked in Putin's eyes and saw a good soul

John McCain- I looked into Putin's eyes and saw three letters- KGB

260 galloping granny  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:16:43am

re: #253 BingoBunny

The left calls GWB a war criminal for going to the UN to get permission for attacks on Iraq.. and our own congress..I think they say they didn't know what they were voteing to allow.. Putin goes into invasion without a peep from the left.. I guess they will learn later what he expects them to vote for.

Note that the Congress is gone for 4 more weeks.

And if Bush does anything at all militarily then he risks the election for McCain.

Like I said, we are being decapitated.

261 The Other Les  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:16:58am

re: #257 Colonel Panik

Don't forget Nancy P. Lousy. She said that too.

Can we call her Putin's whore now?

262 Nevergiveup  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:17:15am

re: #259 Opinionated

George Bush- I looked in Putin's eyes and saw a good soul

John McCain- I looked into Putin's eyes and saw three letters- KGB

Obama- I looked in Putin's eyes, and who is Putin again?

263 DeafDog  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:17:20am

re: #258 Colonel Panik

You forget Norway and the UK (North Sea).

Also forgotten is the USA (with a trillion + barrels of shale)...oh, that's right, we aren't allowed to refine it.

264 galloping granny  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:17:33am

re: #255 pegcity

oh and norway

You are forgetting that WE have oil of our own. Quite some bit of it.

265 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:17:42am

I would like to throw another fact into the mix:

Two weeks ago, I commented about Russia placing new restrictions on agricultural exports, and also new controls on internal agriculture. The US - led by Condi - objected strongly. No one paid any attention.

Now the Russians are invading Georgia.

This is not an impulse. This is a plan.

266 Killian Bundy  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:17:52am

re: #250 A. van Hilten

NATO charter?

/what's your point?

267 MandyManners  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:17:56am

re: #244 yma o hyd

Yep - and to make it even more interesting, the pipeline ends in Northern Turkey, where it was attacked by Kurd rebels a few days ago - Mandy Manners linked the story on one of the threads below.

I linked it on yesterday's over night open thread.

268 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:18:16am

re: #252 Colonel Panik

Many years before Peter came to power.

269 pat  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:18:22am

The Ottomans were an economic basket case in most of Europe, with the exception of Istanbul, when Peter came along. Absentee land ownership and jizya had virtually depopulated entire regions, leaving only garrisons. Peter emplying shallow water craft, rowed for the most part, was able to grab the momentum and commence an historical rollback.

270 galloping granny  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:19:23am

re: #265 Dianna

I would like to throw another fact into the mix:

Two weeks ago, I commented about Russia placing new restrictions on agricultural exports, and also new controls on internal agriculture. The US - led by Condi - objected strongly. No one paid any attention.

Now the Russians are invading Georgia.

This is not an impulse. This is a plan.

And I was reading somewhere or other this morning a comment that it is a plan that has to have been in the works for a while, just to move all of the various military resources within invasion distance of Georgia.

271 Sharmuta  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:19:38am

re: #243 lawhawk

I thought part of what was going on with NATO countries and Afghanistan was that some countries didn't want to go to Afghanistan.

272 MandyManners  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:19:59am

re: #259 Opinionated

George Bush- I looked in Putin's eyes and saw a good soul

John McCain- I looked into Putin's eyes and saw three letters- KGB

273 DeafDog  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:20:07am

re: #247 lawhawk

Actually, it still wouldn't be a good use of the SPR since the oil supply to the US isn't constricted - most of our oil imported comes from Canada, KSA, and Mexico.

re: #256 DeafDog

According to that logic, there are not two prices of oil: (1) a North American price and (2) a European price. But that's not how it works. It's a global energy market and the price reflects global demand. If the SPR could ease the pain in Western Europe, it would benefit both the US and are European 'sometimes allies."

Also, releasing the SPR might prevent the soviets from getting a windfall in the price they receive from oil exports.

274 A. van Hilten  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:20:09am

re: #260 galloping granny

Note that the Congress is gone for 4 more weeks.

And if Bush does anything at all militarily then he risks the election for McCain.

Like I said, we are being decapitated.

It's more like emasculated, actually.

275 Basho  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:20:13am

re: #270 galloping granny

Ralph Peters in the NY Post mentioned that.

276 lawhawk  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:20:46am

re: #256 DeafDog

As we've come to learn about the SPR, the amount of oil that would be released in a crisis such as this would be a mere blip on the US usage (a few pennies at most), it would be even less if applied to usage worldwide.

I understand the fact that the oil market prices are worldwide - not two tiered as you suggest, but the fact is that the SPR is meant for strategic crises to the US directly.

The President could announce SPR releases to buoy the Europeans, but he's going to want to get something in return for that - since it would mean that the US has to refill those oil reserves and it undercuts US oil stocks should the US need them down the road now that we're not adding to the SPR with the prices where they are now. What exactly are we going to want the Europeans to do? They're not going to stick their necks out for the Georgians. The UN is useless (Russia holds veto in SC). The EU can barely decide on its own constitution, let alone a strategic doctrine for the continent.

277 yma o hyd  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:21:06am

re: #243 lawhawk

The problem there is that the rest of the NATO countries are in no position to take offensive military action to back up those kinds of threats. They can barely handle their responsibilities in Afghanistan, so why would they stick their necks out for the Georgians? Realpolitik is a bitch, and right now, the Russians know that they can do what they want without repercussions.

The Ukrainians are probably the best hope to thwart those Russian ambitions right now since they hold the trump card of the Russian Black Sea fleet homeport. Ukraine has pretty much told the Russians that if their ships are used in the fight against Georgia, they're not welcomed back in the Ukraine. That leaves them without a port or facilities, and the Ukrainians have a sizable military force as well.

I would guess that if Putin did make a move towards Poland, a NATO member, Germany would not hesitate to throw her full forces behind Poland.
The situation, if I understand rightly, is that the Germans hate to be regarded as militaristic (no wonder!) and thus feel fighting in Afghanistan is not really a case of defending Germany.
However, should stuff happen in Poland, they would feel more than obliged to pile in.

278 pat  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:21:20am

re: #265 Dianna

I would like to throw another fact into the mix:

Two weeks ago, I commented about Russia placing new restrictions on agricultural exports, and also new controls on internal agriculture.

what controls, Dianna? I missed that.

279 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:21:31am

re: #270 galloping granny

Considering Russian logistics? Yes, it has to have begun quite some time ago.

280 debutaunt  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:21:45am

re: #166 itellu3times

There was apparently massive technological assistance involved.

Turkey basters and soft music.

281 A. van Hilten  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:22:29am

re: #266 Killian Bundy

NATO charter?

/what's your point?

That Putinstan would never attack a NATO member country. That's why Ukraine and Georgia were seeking membership.

282 MandyManners  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:23:09am

re: #265 Dianna

I would like to throw another fact into the mix:

Two weeks ago, I commented about Russia placing new restrictions on agricultural exports, and also new controls on internal agriculture. The US - led by Condi - objected strongly. No one paid any attention.

Now the Russians are invading Georgia.

This is not an impulse. This is a plan.

It's been heating up since March, with things really going in May.

283 lawhawk  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:23:21am

re: #271 Sharmuta

Some of those European countries don't have the ability to sustain a military effort for sustained periods of time since their capabilities atrophied. Others don't want to put their soldiers in harm's way, even though they're operating under NATO's banner.

284 realwest  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:23:29am

re: #196 MandyManners
Well, keeping in mind that Georgia is our ally in Iraq, having sent 2,000 troops to fight by our side (and that's a lot of troops for a small nation to send) and that the U.S. has trained Georgian military and conducted an "Operation Red Flag" (basically air force vs. air force in "play" not war) it seems to me that Bush should:
a) recall the U.S. Ambassador to Russia for "consultations"
b) revoke (iirc he doesn't need Congressional approval for this) Russia's most favored nation status in trade with us (or at least suspend it)
c) move one or more Aircraft Carrier Battle Groups (we now have FOUR in the region) closer to the action and
d) prepare to and if necessary, use US Air Power to stop the Russian bombing of Georgia.
I don't want to go to war, but if someone is your ally and you are the only superpower left in the world, then what else do you do? The failure of the US to stand by Georgia would have terrible ramifications all over the world, not just in Eastern Europe or the ME. What would the US do if China decided (after the Olympics, of course) to take over Taiwan?
What would the U.S. do if Russia and Iran attacked Israel?
Alliances either mean something - sometimes very unpleasant and difficult - or they don't.
And, as I stated above, our anti-missile system DEPENDS on the cooperation of Poland, Czechoslovakia and perhaps other former Soviet Russian satellite nations colonies.

285 debutaunt  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:24:12am

re: #172 The Other Les

"A little piece of Poland, a little piece of France..."

The Eastern half of your Western Sandwich.

286 Nevergiveup  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:24:19am

re: #276 lawhawk

Therefore once again it all falls on the USA to contain the Bear and make the world safe for Democracy and EU type quasi-socialism. It is also why any talk of trying to make the "World" love us again is such crap. The Free World needed us before, needs us now, and will need us in the future. History 101!

287 opnion  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:25:20am

If you look at this coldly, Putin is an evil genuis.
He inavdes a neighbors territory & calls it peacekeeping.
When the aggrieved party strikes back, he plays the victoim & strikes back with overwhelming force.
Moonbats defend him & the U.S is bogged down with the WOT.
He catches some protests from some World leaders & beins to rebuild the Soviet Union.

288 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:25:39am

re: #278 pat

i saw the story in the Financial Times - not my copy, unfortunately, so I could only skim the first couple paras, and no one seems to have followed it up - but as I recall, Russia is proposing the next thing to re-institution of the old collective farms. Price controls were proposed, dictation of what gets planted, and a number of other dangerous restrictions on movement, sale and purchase of land.

289 yma o hyd  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:26:46am

re: #265 Dianna

I would like to throw another fact into the mix:

Two weeks ago, I commented about Russia placing new restrictions on agricultural exports, and also new controls on internal agriculture. The US - led by Condi - objected strongly. No one paid any attention.

Now the Russians are invading Georgia.

This is not an impulse. This is a plan.

It is indeed, and it had nothing, nada, to do with poor innocent Ossetians pining for 'freedom'. It looks like the first step on the way to get the evil empire back, fully and as it was before the break-up.
I wonder what the muslim states of the former Soviet Union are thinking of their chances of survival ... having Chechnia as a vivid example.

290 realwest  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:27:40am

re: #260 galloping granny Hi gallopin granny! I'm not sure, but doesn't the POTUS have the right to call Congress back into an emergency session?

291 Killian Bundy  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:28:16am

re: #284 realwest

Well, keeping in mind that Georgia is our ally

Maybe you've forgotten.

/last time I checked, Russia is our "ally" too, not to mention the one country left that can destroy us

292 Charles  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:28:31am

re: #106 lifeofthemind

This meme of the left that Georgia started it has to stop.

It's not just a meme of the left.

There are people at LGF promoting this same line of propaganda.

293 FrogMarch  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:28:50am
294 galloping granny  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:28:53am

re: #290 realwest

Hi gallopin granny! I'm not sure, but doesn't the POTUS have the right to call Congress back into an emergency session?

Yes, he does, but I'm not sure that would actually help matters any.

295 DeafDog  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:28:59am

re: #276 lawhawk

The President could announce SPR releases to buoy the Europeans, but he's going to want to get something in return for that - since it would mean that the US has to refill those oil reserves and it undercuts US oil stocks should the US need them down the road now that we're not adding to the SPR with the prices where they are now. What exactly are we going to want the Europeans to do?

I'm not convinced that we should release oil from the SPR, I'm just saying that the option might have something to it. There would be nothing wrong if we got some actions from the Euros as a result, but if the price spikes as a result of this war and releasing the SPR might help mitigate that price spike, then it's exactly why we have it. The move would benefit Americans. Also, it would prevent the ruskie's from enjoying a higher price.

Regarding the future buy back - If the govt. sold actual oil today and bought futures contracts for a year out, then the cost of restocking could be mitigated.

296 Charles  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:29:17am

re: #292 Charles

And the very right-wing, very Christian Discovery Institute is promoting the "Georgia started it" line too.

297 galloping granny  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:29:39am

re: #292 Charles

It's not just a meme of the left.

There are people at LGF promoting this same line of propaganda.

You should have seen the rant out of a Bylorussian another LGFer and I know at a gardening site yesterday.

298 JHW  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:30:29am

I'm still trying to sort out all the players in here, what a tangled mess, Abkhazia has been the focus of international concern for some time, and also apparently there is a lucrative criminal smuggling operation in the region , who benefits the most is a question.What somewhat surprises me, probably foolishly,there is an Islamic player in all this, " The Caucasus Emirate: Umara of Caucasian Mujahidin" ,primarily allied to neighboring Chechnya, and from reading their site, with typical jihadi stuff and the bearded thugs, they seem to be playing the situation opportunistically . There seem to be a few nuggets of information on local activities at their site, most of their stuff concerning outside of the area seems to originate from Al Jazeera. They seem to fancy themselves a major player in all this:

Udugov: ''For the time being neither Tbilisi nor Washington has not appealed to us with any requests''


If anyone else can extract anything useful, besides the usual self-serving stuff, feel free, I'll link it here.
Kavkaz Center

299 realwest  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:30:41am

re: #292 Charles
Thank you Charles.

300 DeafDog  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:31:27am

re: #287 opnion

If you look at this coldly, Putin is an evil genuis.
He inavdes a neighbors territory & calls it peacekeeping.
When the aggrieved party strikes back, he plays the victoim & strikes back with overwhelming force.
Moonbats defend him & the U.S is bogged down with the WOT.
He catches some protests from some World leaders & beins to rebuild the Soviet Union.

Yes. Putin is Dr. Evil!

{and Medvedev is Mini-me}

301 opnion  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:31:40am

re: #296 Charles

And the very right-wing, very Christian Discovery Institute is promoting the "Georgia started it" line too.

On the McLaughlin group last night, Buchannan & the hysterical Elenor Clift completely blamed 'Georgian Aggression."

302 pat  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:31:40am

re: #288 Dianna

i saw the story in the Financial Times - not my copy, unfortunately, so I could only skim the first couple paras, and no one seems to have followed it up - but as I recall, Russia is proposing the next thing to re-institution of the old collective farms. Price controls were proposed, dictation of what gets planted, and a number of other dangerous restrictions on movement, sale and purchase of land.

Hmmm. This means that Russia has a serious inflation problem. And of course this will only exasperate it ()bamanomics=do the opposite of what makes sense).

303 Sharmuta  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:32:40am

re: #283 lawhawk

Thanks, lawhawk. I would just think the euros would be more concerned about the events in their own backyard that will end up directly affecting them. Let's hope the Ukraine's involvement will help.

304 The Other Les  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:33:11am

re: #296 Charles

And the very right-wing, very Christian Discovery Institute is promoting the "Georgia started it" line too.

As far as I'm concerned, witch doctors (Ayn Rand's charming term for such people) are, regardless of their claimed ideological stand, on the f***ing Left.

305 Charles  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:34:19am

re: #301 opnion

On the McLaughlin group last night, Buchannan & the hysterical Elenor Clift completely blamed 'Georgian Aggression."

It's not surprising that Buchanan is on the side of the Russians. The man is despicable.

306 right_on_target  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:34:28am

re: #11 jemima

One might hope that all the former Iron Curtain countries would band together for their mutual protection against Russia so that none of them would be reassimilated into a new USSR.

And on a side note, I had a guy from Belarus tell me yesterday that it's all America's fault. Russia is the victim in all this.

That figures, a lot of the people of Belarus are ethnic Russians. The Soviets invaded Poland from the east while the NAZIs invaded from the west in 1939. They partitioned Poland and after the war Poland never re-gained her bread basket territory in the east. The USSR kept it and it eventually became part of Belarus.
Ethnic cleansing and re-location after the war tipped the territories to the Soviets' favor. So people from Belarus are for the most part pro-Russian.

307 yma o hyd  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:34:42am

re: #293 FrogMarch

Black Five's take:

He had a link to this.

It is a very important article from a Russian journalist, of the caliber of those who get themselves murdered in Moscow ...

308 Opinionated  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:34:46am

This is a good time to remind everyone of the World's mantra that if only there was a 'Palestinian' State, peace would reign everlasting.

309 Spiny Norman  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:34:46am

re: #208 Sharmuta

More on the Georgian airport:


The Russian radio station Echo Moscow reported that two journalists, including a photographer for the Russian news agency Itar-Tass, were shot dead by separatists after entering South Ossetia.

The Ossetian separatists are shooting Russians now, too? WTF?

310 realwest  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:35:26am

re: #301 opnion Are
Buchannan & Elenor Clift associated with the Disco Institute? I thought Buchannan was associated with the Neo-Nazi's? (don't recognize the name Elenor Clift).

311 pat  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:35:38am

re: #301 opnion

On the McLaughlin group last night, Buchannan & the hysterical Elenor Clift completely blamed 'Georgian Aggression."

Which goes to show that extremists always end up at the same place. Nut jobs, both.

312 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:35:47am

re: #298 JHW

Any military distraction benefits the Chechen insurrection.

313 itellu3times  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:36:07am

re: #243 lawhawk

The problem there is that the rest of the NATO countries are in no position to take offensive military action to back up those kinds of threats. They can barely handle their responsibilities in Afghanistan, so why would they stick their necks out for the Georgians? Realpolitik is a bitch, and right now, the Russians know that they can do what they want without repercussions.

The Ukrainians are probably the best hope to thwart those Russian ambitions right now since they hold the trump card of the Russian Black Sea fleet homeport. Ukraine has pretty much told the Russians that if their ships are used in the fight against Georgia, they're not welcomed back in the Ukraine. That leaves them without a port or facilities, and the Ukrainians have a sizable military force as well.

If the Ukrainians want to keep those ships out of port, they'd better be prepared to use military force in a major way.

314 Opinionated  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:36:28am

re: #301 opnion

On the McLaughlin group last night, Buchannan & the hysterical Elenor Clift completely blamed 'Georgian Aggression."

That's where I got the quote above. I saw it this morning.

The way he was talking about Georgia, you would think it was a Jewish State.

315 opnion  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:36:35am

re: #305 Charles

It's not surprising that Buchanan is on the side of the Russians. The man is despicable.

He sinks lower & lower. What was a little surprising though was his vitriol toward Georgia.

316 A. van Hilten  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:37:48am

re: #296 Charles

And the very right-wing, very Christian Discovery Institute is promoting the "Georgia started it" line too.

Why do I have the feeling that they're aligned with the white supremacists and even the Holocaust deniers too?

Heck, I wouldn't be surprised if they ran a Russian bride marriage agency.

317 opnion  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:38:08am

re: #311 pat

Which goes to show that extremists always end up at the same place. Nut jobs, both.

OK, you just won the 'Convergence Award" The loony left intersected the loony right.

318 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:38:18am

re: #302 pat

The ruble has been in trouble practically since the break-up of the Soviet Union. The "banking reforms", including the currency re-issue, have not improved that situation.

Russia's trying to solve its problems by recreating their empire, and hoping that they can force growth through internal trade (doubtful), while using oil and gas to buy hard currency.

319 lifeofthemind  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:38:45am

re: #254 pegcity

canada is the only country in the world with oil thats not a criminal gangster state

America has oil

320 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:39:31am

re: #303 Sharmuta

Thanks, lawhawk. I would just think the euros would be more concerned about the events in their own backyard that will end up directly affecting them. Let's hope the Ukraine's involvement will help.

Ha!

"What about my five week vacation?!"

Usually, I'm a lot nicer about Europe. I'm just rather irate, today.

321 galloping granny  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:40:48am

re: #317 opnion

OK, you just won the 'Convergence Award" The loony left intersected the loony right.

I have said for years that it is erroneous to look at the spectrum of political thought as a line. It is really a circle. Go far enough right or left and the two become identical.

322 opnion  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:41:09am

re: #319 lifeofthemind

America has oil

Well yeah, but like Obama says it is no help in the short run to drill. It would take, oh 2,093 years to you know get it out of the ground.

323 Spiny Norman  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:41:26am

re: #307 yma o hyd

He had a link to this.

It is a very important article from a Russian journalist, of the caliber of those who get themselves murdered in Moscow ...

Interesting:

However, alas, I also cannot say this regime is "pro-Russian." On the contrary, all the recent actions of Eduard Kokoity, the leader of the breakaway South Ossetian government, have run counter to the interests of Russia in the Caucasus -- beginning with his embarrassing Russia in the eyes of the international community and ending with his ratcheting up the tensions in the very region where Russia might begin to come undone. South Ossetia is not a territory, not a country, not a regime. It is a joint venture of siloviki generals and Ossetian bandits for making money in a conflict with Georgia. For me, the most surprising thing in this entire story is the complete lack of any strategic goals on the part of the South Ossetians.

So the Russians are being sucked in by gangsters in South Ossetia?

324 affenkopf  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:42:29am

re: #1 JammieWearingFool

Funny how silent the anti-war left is these days.


(v) Pacifism. The majority of pacifists either belong to obscure religious sects or are simply humanitarians who object to the taking of life and prefer not to follow their thoughts beyond that point. But there is a minority of intellectual pacifists whose real though unadmitted motive appears to be hatred of western democracy and admiration of totalitarianism. Pacifist propaganda usually boils down to saying that one side is as bad as the other, but if one looks closely at the writings of younger intellectual pacifists, one finds that they do not by any means express impartial disapproval but are directed almost entirely against Britain and the United States. Moreover they do not as a rule condemn violence as such, but only violence used in defence of western countries. The Russians, unlike the British, are not blamed for defending themselves by warlike means, and indeed all pacifist propaganda of this type avoids mention of Russia or China. It is not claimed, again, that the Indians should abjure violence in their struggle against the British. Pacifist literature abounds with equivocal remarks which, if they mean anything, appear to mean that statesmen of the type of Hitler are preferable to those of the type of Churchill, and that violence is perhaps excusable if it is violent enough. After the fall of France, the French pacifists, faced by a real choice which their English colleagues have not had to make, mostly went over to the Nazis, and in England there appears to have been some small overlap of membership between the Peace Pledge Union and the Blackshirts. Pacifist writers have written in praise of Carlyle, one of the intellectual fathers of Fascism. All in all it is difficult not to feel that pacifism, as it appears among a section of the intelligentsia, is secretly inspired by an admiration for power and successful cruelty. The mistake was made of pinning this emotion to Hitler, but it could easily be retransfered.

- Orwell in 1945 ([Link: www.orwell.ru...]

Funny (or rather sad) how little has changed.

325 realwest  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:42:40am

re: #322 opnion
Uh, did you see my comment #310 above?

326 opnion  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:44:07am

re: #321 galloping granny

I have said for years that it is erroneous to look at the spectrum of political thought as a line. It is really a circle. Go far enough right or left and the two become identical.

You have just won the "Karl Hegel" award.
It will be delivered within 10 business days.

327 Opinionated  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:45:02am

re: #262 Nevergiveup

Obama- I looked in Putin's eyes, and who is Putin again?

Obama sees the same thing he sees when he looks into anyone's eyes- his own refection.

328 galloping granny  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:45:21am

I guess we can start saying that Requiem for the former Republic of Georgia.

Israel Considers Ban on Military Sales to Georgia
Meanwhile, Israel is considering a complete halt to its sale of arms and other military equipment to Georgia as a result of the fighting, a move that follows a decision made a year ago to limit such sales to defensive-related items only.

Jerusalem officials expressed concern that Russia would retaliate against Israel by selling more advanced weaponry to Syria and Iran.

[Link: www.israelnationalnews.com...]

329 The Other Les  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:45:55am

re: #301 opnion

On the McLaughlin group last night, Buchannan & the hysterical Elenor Clift completely blamed 'Georgian Aggression."

I've always held Comrade Elinor Clift to be the gold standard for brain-dead moonbattery. That Buchannan is now in agreement with her would fully confirm his status as a false authority. What Ayn Rand used to call a witch doctor.

And blaming this war on "Georgian Aggression" is as willfully depraved as the so-called peace activists who condemn the State of Israel for the Six-Day War while willfully blanking out the actions of the Arab States, the blockade of Eliat and the calls for genocide, prior to the Israeli response.

For all practical purposes Buchannan is now on the Left.

330 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:46:43am

re: #323 Spiny Norman

No, they're conspiring with South Ossetian gangsters to increase siloviki power and influence at the court of Vladimir the non-Tsar.

331 The Other Les  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:49:14am

re: #310 realwest

Are
Buchannan & Elenor Clift associated with the Disco Institute? I thought Buchannan was associated with the Neo-Nazi's? (don't recognize the name Elenor Clift).

Clift is the idealized form of the complete barking moonbat journalist.

She is a living, breathing, utterly brain dead case for defining journalism as a mental disease.

332 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:49:16am

re: #328 galloping granny

Well, heck.

The US and its allies got through almost a whole decade without betraying an ally. That's something of a record.

333 opnion  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:50:40am

re: #310 realwest

Are
Buchannan & Elenor Clift associated with the Disco Institute? I thought Buchannan was associated with the Neo-Nazi's? (don't recognize the name Elenor Clift).

Real, sorry I missed this earlier. Buchannon is a nasty contrarian.
Yeah he is a lot like a neo-nazi, but so really is Putin.
Elenor Clift is just some Demiocrat hack from Newsweek.
She still misses the Viet Nam War Becuse she was on the poms squad for the North. She has been on Mclaughlin forever.

334 BingoBunny  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:51:52am

how close is the Ukraine to be allowed into NATO? without them in a position to have real muscle behind any actions they take.. Ukraine will be invaded too.

335 opnion  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:52:38am

re: #329 The Other Les

I've always held Comrade Elinor Clift to be the gold standard for brain-dead moonbattery. That Buchannan is now in agreement with her would fully confirm his status as a false authority. What Ayn Rand used to call a witch doctor.

And blaming this war on "Georgian Aggression" is as willfully depraved as the so-called peace activists who condemn the State of Israel for the Six-Day War while willfully blanking out the actions of the Arab States, the blockade of Eliat and the calls for genocide, prior to the Israeli response.

For all practical purposes Buchannan is now on the Left.

Your reasoning is sound. The major crime that georgia comitted was allying with the U.S.
Pat & Elenor find that so distateful.

336 sammysdad  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:53:39am

Have we heard from Celine Dion yet ?

337 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:55:27am

re: #334 BingoBunny

If so, then Russia will be seriously overextended. Remember, they have to hold down Chechnya, and Georgia is not exactly unsuited to guerrilla operations. And Ukraine may not have all that much of an army, but I think Ukrainians have had quite enough of being a province of Great Russia.

No guarantees, and I know less about military matters than a lot of folks on this board, but I think the Russians would hesitate to further complicate their situation.

338 realwest  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:55:50am

re: #334 BingoBunny
I don't think close enough and I'm not sure what good NATO would be in this situation - NATO not including the U.S., I mean.
OTOH, Ukraine is NOT Georgia - it is large, well organized and the "breadbasket" of the Soviet Union Russian Federation.
Methinks the leaders of the Ukraine thought about the ramifications of blocking the Russian Naval Squadron from access to the Black Sea.
I sure as hell hope they did.
BTW, is President Bush still in China?

339 Green Helmet Guy  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 10:56:34am

Some interesting background on the conflict in in the caucus


Georgian-Abkhaz conflict

Main articles: Georgian-Abkhaz conflict and Battle of Gagra

The following year, 1992, [Shamil] Basayev [Wikipedia puts it mildly as so: "militant Islamist and a leader of the Chechen separatist movement."] traveled to Abkhazia, a breakaway region of Georgia, to assist the local separatist movement against the Georgian government's attempts to regain control of the region -- a conflict in which, ultimately, a minority of 93,000 Abkhaz were successful in ethnically purging a majority of Georgians (numbering some 250,000) from the region. Basayev became the commander-in-chief of the forces of the Confederation of Mountain Peoples of the Caucasus (a volunteer unit of pan-Caucasian nationalists, composed mainly of Chechens and Cossacks. Their involvement was crucial in the Abkhazian war and in October 1993 the Georgian government suffered a decisive military defeat, after which the entire ethnic Georgian population of the region was driven out by ethnic cleansing.

It was rumored that the volunteers were trained and supplied by some part of the Russian army GRU military intelligence service, although no evidence to support these allegations was ever found...

scroll down to: Georgian-Abkhaz conflict

Another incident this time in Ossetia
2006 October incident

On October 31, 2006, the South Ossetian police reported a skirmish in the Java, Georgia district in which they killed a group of 4 men.[10][11] The weapons seized from the group included assault rifles, guns, grenade launchers, grenades and explosive devices. Other items found in the militants' possession included extremist Islamic literature, maps of Java district and sets of Russian peacekeeping uniforms.

scroll down to:
2006 October incident

340 DeafDog  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:01:15am

re: #307 yma o hyd

He had a link to this.

It is a very important article from a Russian journalist, of the caliber of those who get themselves murdered in Moscow ...

That was a very good read. This excerpt, part of a paragraph on russian lies, exposed everything:

What are we to make of their claims during the night that Georgian airplanes had bombed a column of humanitarian aid coming out of the Roki Tunnel between North and South Ossetia? I'd like to know who was the Russian general who -- on the very night when Saakashvili had been issued a moratorium and tanks and heavy equipment were moving from Russia to Tskhinvali -- decided to clog up the only road with a humanitarian convoy. If there is such an idiot, he should, at the least, be demoted to the ranks.

341 right_on_target  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:03:00am

I'm pretty sure our USAF 1A8X1's are keeping very busy!

342 Wishbone  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:03:08am

re: #319 lifeofthemind

America has oil

Add the UK, Germany, Denmark, Norway and the Netherlands to that list.

343 Killian Bundy  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:03:31am

After reading a few of the blogs Blackfive linked to that are actually covering this, the theme seems to be that we have no idea what's really happening on the ground. First hand, objective reporting is pretty much nonexistent so far.

/both sides are pushing their competing propaganda

344 BingoBunny  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:05:21am

Well I hope you people are correct.. Ukraine captured by Russia will pretty much end NATO IMO.. and up until morals began to rear it's ugly head it was never any bother to oppress conquered people. I don't see KGB trained world leaders as being very influenced by morals, I expect instead that as long as Russian troops get a supply of bullets they will control where ever they want.

345 Biff  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:07:57am

re: #152 descolada9

So is this what we get for recognizing Kosovo's independence? I believe Russia did warn us that there might be long run consequences regarding Kosovo statehood.

And maybe one reason why we aren't hearing many countries complain, is because the Russians had a legitimate sovereign and strategic rationale. Is it possible that South O. had nuclear assets that were slipping from Russian control? It seems to me that the Russians have not shown any prior recent inclination to act in this way, and when they have (Chechniya) their actions were legitimate. I I think it is more than a bit hypocritical for some on this board to support our war, and then pull an anti-Ruskie knee jerk when the Russians need to take care of business along their own border.

I'm also guessing that W's discussions with Putin were much more understanding, than the WH has let on.

346 Green Helmet Guy  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:08:17am

Wikipedia already has got an article going on the war between Russia/the Ossetian separatists and Georgia:

and they are calling it...

2008 South Ossetia War

347 lifeofthemind  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:10:08am

re: #337 Dianna

If so, then Russia will be seriously overextended. Remember, they have to hold down Chechnya, and Georgia is not exactly unsuited to guerrilla operations. And Ukraine may not have all that much of an army, but I think Ukrainians have had quite enough of being a province of Great Russia.

No guarantees, and I know less about military matters than a lot of folks on this board, but I think the Russians would hesitate to further complicate their situation.


I would not completely discount the Ukrainian military's potential.
The biggest problem the Russians have is the shortage of Russians. Due to the demographic implosion and extraordinary rates of alcoholism and HIV infection the country is literally disappearing. The best strategy would have been to pull in and abandon the hostile periphery then concentrate on building wealth in the European core and Siberia. Instead Putin is fighting to reestablish control over every scrap that swore allegiance to Czar Nicholas or Czar Brezhnev.

348 kevinmumaw  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:10:35am

re: #11 jemima

One might hope that all the former Iron Curtain countries would band together for their mutual protection against Russia so that none of them would be reassimilated into a new USSR.

And on a side note, I had a guy from Belarus tell me yesterday that it's all America's fault. Russia is the victim in all this.

Got an email from a friend of mine in Lithuanian Army this morning. First, he assured me Lithuania would beat Argentina in Olympic basketball, which they did, and second, wants to know when I will be in Europe as he is eager to punch a Russian in the face. Except he put it more crudely and in Russian. Neither of us has been able to contact with a Ukrainian friend of ours, Alex, but watch for the Russians to begin laying the context for a similar action there. The Russians planned this, and the Georgians fell for it.

349 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:10:52am

re: #340 DeafDog

The Russians think that all they have to do is publish their propaganda, and everyone will eat it up.

I think they've forgotten that the Cominform no longer exists.

350 yma o hyd  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:11:01am

re: #346 Green Helmet Guy

Wikipedia already has got an article going on the war between Russia/the Ossetian separatists and Georgia:

and they are calling it...

2008 South Ossetia War

From that wiki artcile '... as Russia was drawn into the war ...'
Blimey - pull the other one!

351 kevinmumaw  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:12:12am

re: #19 MandyManners

I've read at one place where the little fuckers are blaming Pres. Bush for this.

That is their reflex. Like pulling your hand off a hot stove. They will assemble their reasons later.

352 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:12:42am

re: #345 Biff

My stars!

I'm reading Russian propaganda on LGF. I don't believe it.

353 jaunte  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:13:23am

The Russians have started an operation to storm the Kodori gorge in Abkhazia:
[Link: www.alertnet.org...]

354 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:14:23am

re: #349 Dianna

However, I seem to have overlooked some sources - and repeaters - of Russian propaganda.

355 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:15:08am

re: #353 jaunte

I hope it goes very badly for them.

356 kevinmumaw  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:18:07am

re: #29 lifeofthemind

One Word: Turkey
The Turks are the big dogs in the region. If they move in then the Russians go down. The Turkish Navy has submarines that could sink the Russian Black Sea fleet transports and the Ukrainians have already threatened to bar the Russians from returning to port. Putin may have stuck his schlong way out on a chopping block. This may not be over. Even if the Georgians have to pull back. They have Israeli advisors in place. Do wish that the tunnel had been blown on day one.

Which land route did the 58th Russian Army use? Georgian sappers should have blown that route...as the Russians were coming through. They obviously weren't prepared for this. BTW, the Russians do not have enough competent tank crews to fill an entire armored regiment. They pulled crews from other units to fill out the 58th ahead of time. Wherever they pulled them from, those units are probable combat ineffective right now. Probably Siberia.

357 Killian Bundy  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:18:37am

re: #353 jaunte

The Russians have started an operation to storm the Kodori gorge in Abkhazia:
[Link: www.alertnet.org...]

That's a good example.

/notice how almost all of these news releases are sourced to either the Georgian or Russian governments?

358 Spiny Norman  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:19:04am

re: #350 yma o hyd

From that wiki artcile '... as Russia was drawn into the war ...'
Blimey - pull the other one!

What should we expect, it's Wikipedia.

Some more interesting background:

As soon as Russia tamped down the war in Abkhazia, tensions in South Ossetia started rising. South Ossetian forces start shelling Georgian villages, and as soon as Georgia returns fire, the airwaves are filled with accusations of "Georgian aggression."

Whenever someone starts telling us about shelling in Tskhinvali, it is important to keep in mind exactly what Tskhinvali is. It is not a city somewhere in the middle of a republic that is being fired upon by saboteurs. On three sides, Tskhinvali is surrounded by Georgian villages. The edge of Tskhinvali is a military outpost. South Ossetian forces fire from there into the Georgian villages, and the Georgians respond with fire of their own. To help keep Georgian fire from hitting civilians in the city, all the South Ossetians would have to do is move their military base forward a couple hundred meters.

But, of course, it is a fundamental principle of terrorists the world over -- set up firing points in civilian areas and then when your enemy fires on you, you gleefully parade the bodies of your own children in front of the television cameras. Kokoity's terrorists are following this same principle. If South Ossetia can in any way be considered a state, it must be considered a terrorist state...

When we are told about "peaceful civilians" in South Ossetia, we must keep in mind that the situation there is similar to that in Palestinian refugee camps. South Ossetia, like the Palestinian Liberation Organization before it, is not a state or an ethos or a territory. It is a peculiar form of mutated government in which residents have been turned into militarized refugees. It is a quasi-armed force that is not allowed by the authorities to occupy itself with anything other than war -- a situation that gives the authorities absolute power and absolute control over the money at its disposal...

When the Media holds up the Palis as "victims", other unsavory people are watching and taking notes.

359 Biff  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:20:12am

re: #354 Dianna
I haven't read anything from the Russians. Just a general observation of people reacting without adequate information.

360 A. van Hilten  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:20:21am

From the Wikipedia link:

"The Office of the President of Poland has provided help with access to the Internet for Georgia's government after breakdowns of local servers caused by cyberattacks.[161]"

It seems Russia's neighbors are growing uneasy.

361 JHW  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:20:29am

On the Black Sea Fleet, and Ukraine, another recipe for mischief making waiting to happen.The Ukraine government has to really be burning the midnight oil. From Wiki, on the Russia and Ukraine naval bases at Sevastopol, and another front group "advocating Russian citizenship", with the dual-passport gambit.

The ex-Soviet Black Sea Fleet with all its facilities was divided between Russia's Black Sea Fleet and the Ukrainian Navy after a continuous, sometimes violent struggle. The two navies now co-use some of the city's harbours and piers, while others were demilitarised or used by either country. Sevastopol remains the home of the Russian Black Sea Fleet Headquarters with the Ukrainian Naval HQ also based in the city. A judicial row continues over the naval hydrographic infrastructure both in Sevastopol and on the Crimean coast (especially lighthouses used in civil navigation support).


The WE Youth Political Organization, which advocates Russian citizenship for Sevastopol residents,[6] published a poll in 2004 claiming "72% of the Sevastopol citizens support the idea of the independent status of Crimea... Besides, 95% of the respondents support the constant stationing of the Russian Black Sea Fleet in Sevastopol even after 2017, when the time of the corresponding agreement between Russia and Ukraine is up. Also, 100% of the interrogated people are for the accordance of the having a double citizenship, Russian and Ukrainian, right to the Sevastopol citizens. Although it is notable those in case of obtaining the Russian citizenship only 16% of the Sevastopol citizens are ready to give up the Ukrainian one."[7]

Sevastopol.....Wiki

The Russians could probably stir up a lot in the Ukraine if they decide to. I got into a row with a Ukrainian woman on another forum , she was full of conspiracy theories about the US and how benign Russia was. She was from Kharkov, IIRC, in the eastern Ukraine, and proceeded to let me know that the Ukrainians in the western part of the country were semi- Ukrainians, not the real deal,in her opinion, they were from the part of Poland seized by the USSR when they were allies of the Nazis and were too pro-Western for her tastes.Undoubtedly Russia could play some games here if they decide to ratchet things up.

362 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:20:30am

re: #356 kevinmumaw

Safe enough to do that, provided it doesn't go on too long. China's busy keeping things silent as the grave during the Olympics.

363 wolfie  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:21:16am

re: #353 jaunte

The Russians have started an operation to storm the Kodori gorge in Abkhazia:
[Link: www.alertnet.org...]

Perhaps my SIL (Russian scholar) is right.
She thinks its 75% about Abkhasia.
.... 15% about revenge for Kosovo
.....10% just because Putin is a bastard.

364 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:21:24am

re: #357 Killian Bundy

Yes.

I've become curious about the utter silence from State and the intelligence agencies.

365 GregInSeattle  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:22:21am

Bush was a fool for saying he looked into Putin's eyes, and saw a guy he could do business with. That being said, I think Bush will be firm and resolute in dealing with the Russian imperialists (REAL imperialists, invading foreign soil for fun, profit and power)

366 jaunte  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:22:51am

re: #363 wolfie

I think the major percentage is in Russia dominating the energy flow to Europe.

367 kevinmumaw  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:23:14am

re: #32 zombie

Sounds like Latvia.

368 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:23:38am

re: #359 Biff

If you were being sarcastic, it wasn't clear.

If you believe what you wrote, I worry about you.

369 A. van Hilten  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:24:48am

re: #359 Biff

I haven't read anything from the Russians. Just a general observation of people reacting without adequate information.

Adequate information provided by the Disco Institute?

370 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:25:00am

re: #363 wolfie

Your SIL is a very astute woman. I can tell, because she agrees with me! We differ on details, but not on the broad outline.

371 Biff  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:25:08am

re: #368 Dianna


/sarc off

for everything I just posted

/end

372 Dianna  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:26:08am

re: #371 Biff

Good. I am relieved.

Now I'm off. I actually do have things I need to do today!

373 kevinmumaw  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:27:21am

re: #32 zombie

Obviously I should read a bit more before answering. I see it has been answered 11-teen thousand times already.

374 Biff  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:27:22am

re: #372 Dianna

I meant I was NOT being sarcastic, and meant every word.

375 Spiny Norman  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:28:01am

re: #371 Biff

/sarc off

for everything I just posted

/end

That's better.

376 Spiny Norman  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:28:39am

re: #374 Biff

I meant I was NOT being sarcastic, and meant every word.

Nevermind then, Mr Buchanan.

377 Opinionated  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:30:58am
WASHINGTON — The image of President Bush smiling and chatting with Prime Minister Vladimir V. Putin of Russia from the stands of the Beijing Olympics even as Russian aircraft were shelling Georgia outlines the reality of America’s Russia policy. While America considers Georgia its strongest ally in the bloc of former Soviet countries, Washington needs Russia too much on big issues like Iran to risk it all to defend Georgia.

[Link: www.nytimes.com...]

Unfortunately, proving once more that there is no benefit to being a friend to the United States.

Also proving that American policy is made by idiots who believe- even in the face of all rationality and facts- that Russia will ever help the US in Iran or anywhere else- is delusional.

378 Killian Bundy  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:31:00am

re: #364 Dianna

Yes.

I've become curious about the utter silence from State and the intelligence agencies.

It's going to take a few days to sort this all out.

/hopefully it'll be over by then

379 Sharmuta  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:31:31am

re: #345 Biff

And maybe one reason why we aren't hearing many countries complain, is because the Russians had a legitimate sovereign and strategic rationale.

Russia has claims to Kosovo?

Is it possible that South O. had nuclear assets that were slipping from Russian control?

I believe Russia took back all it's weapons, so no.

It seems to me that the Russians have not shown any prior recent inclination to act in this way, and when they have (Chechniya) their actions were legitimate.

This makes no sense- first in the historical context, second in the context of Chechnya, the Georgians would be doing the same thing. Trying to re-establish order in their own territory from aggressive separatists.

I I think it is more than a bit hypocritical for some on this board to support our war, and then pull an anti-Ruskie knee jerk when the Russians need to take care of business along their own border.

It is the Georgians who are trying to take care of business in their own territory- trying to protect their own citizens from hostilities being fueled by the Russians. Read some of the links and comments on this page- the Russians are slipping back into their Soviet ways.

380 yma o hyd  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:33:46am

re: #358 Spiny Norman

Good article, that - I put it in the spin-off links.
Yep - people are certainly watching what others do - I've got the suspicion that Putin has studied very diligently what the Saudis have been and are doing with their Oil money ...

381 GregInSeattle  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:34:19am

This crisis could give McCain a big boost in the polls. Most people would want an experienced foreign policy veteran in the White House to deal with crises like this, than some empty suit and America hater like Obama.

382 pingjockey  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:34:27am

re: #377 Opinionated
The Russians are actively helping the Iranians and will continue to do so. Like you said, the State Dept is delusional.

383 kevinmumaw  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:35:13am

re: #67 lifeofthemind

At the risk of commenting before reading the rest of the responses, the main point here is that the pipeline that runs from the oilfields in the east and though Georgia is going to be linked into Turkey and run through Europe, as opposed to running through Russia and through Europe. The ironic thing is that this war is absolutely about oil, and the left is cheering on the ones who started it. S Ossetia is nothing more than a pretext, fully planned and executed in the Kremlin. Congratulations DailyKos, you ARE in favor of "Blood for Oil." Something we fully suspected anyway. If only lying were painful.

384 Spiny Norman  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:36:03am

re: #381 GregInSeattle

This crisis could give McCain a big boost in the polls. Most people would want an experienced foreign policy veteran in the White House to deal with crises like this, than some empty suit and America hater like Obama.

If the Bush Administration bungles it, it could also be bad for McCain.

385 Biff  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:36:44am

re: #378 Killian Bundy

Remember that Stalin was from Georgia.

386 yma o hyd  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:36:45am

re: #360 A. van Hilten

From the Wikipedia link:

"The Office of the President of Poland has provided help with access to the Internet for Georgia's government after breakdowns of local servers caused by cyberattacks.[161]"

It seems Russia's neighbors are growing uneasy.

Poland has lived under Russian occupation of one sort or the other for centuries - they know indeed what the Bear is capable of. No wonder they become uneasy.
However, same as with Ukraine's trheat not to let the Russian Black fleet back into port, it would seem that these neighbours have a very good idea of showing Putin where the line is - without exposing themselves to direct attacks.

387 yma o hyd  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:39:15am

re: #361 JHW

To be sure - and iirc, they already did, trying to prevent the current President of the Ukraine to become elected instead of one of their puppets. The same sort of things were branished about which your Ukrainian friend was telling you.

388 pingjockey  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:43:38am

re: #385 Biff

What in hell does that have to do with anything?

389 JHW  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:46:42am

re: #387 yma o hyd

Yes and the old KGB were masters at propaganda, I find it very telling in the last year or so how many journalists in Russia have been silenced, one way or another, and news outlets have been purged.

390 Killian Bundy  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:47:07am

Russia says it is ready to negotiate with Georgia

UNITED NATIONS -- Russia declared itself ready to make peace with Georgia and U.N. officials confirmed Sunday that Georgia is prepared to negotiate with Russia by withdrawing troops from the breakaway province of South Ossetia and creating a safe travel zone.

/let's get a ceasefire in place before the markets open tomorrow

391 jaunte  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:49:24am

re: #358 Spiny Norman

Thanks for that link; very interesting and informative background on who the South Ossetian players are.
[Link: www.rferl.org...]

392 Biff  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:50:22am

re: #388 pingjockey
Just that I think a lot of you are choosing sides reflexively, and if San Ysidro was under attack from Mexico, you might feel a little different.

393 pingjockey  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:51:58am

re: #392 Biff
I'd feel the same. Georgia finally got rid of its Soviet overlords and now they're back.

394 FrogMarch  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:52:23am

re: #305 Charles

It's not surprising that Buchanan is on the side of the Russians. The man is despicable.

He is despicable.

395 lifeofthemind  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:53:04am

re: #383 kevinmumaw

At the risk of commenting before reading the rest of the responses, the main point here is that the pipeline that runs from the oilfields in the east and though Georgia is going to be linked into Turkey and run through Europe, as opposed to running through Russia and through Europe. The ironic thing is that this war is absolutely about oil, and the left is cheering on the ones who started it. S Ossetia is nothing more than a pretext, fully planned and executed in the Kremlin. Congratulations DailyKos, you ARE in favor of "Blood for Oil." Something we fully suspected anyway. If only lying were painful.

Yes you get it.

396 pingjockey  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:53:13am

re: #392 Biff
Plus I've never liked totalitarianism of any stripe. Be it Commies, Marxists, Fascists, Leftists, or Neo-Czarists.

397 lifeofthemind  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:54:24am

re: #392 Biff

Just that I think a lot of you are choosing sides reflexively, and if San Ysidro was under attack from Mexico, you might feel a little different.

Talk to the CBP and BP guys from there, it is.

398 swamprat  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:54:49am

They really don't want our defense missile shield on their border.(scroll down just a little)

399 Biff  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:55:16am

re: #393 pingjockey

My analogy was San Ysidro=S. Ossetra, Mexico=Georgia, US=Russia

400 FrogMarch  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:55:42am

re: #293 FrogMarch

Black Five's take:

...

For those that are still fixated on the idea that Georgia started this and Russia simply responded, answer me how what appears to be multiple combined-arms groups just happened to be able to respond so quickly, including the sortie of parts of the Black Sea fleet?
401 Biff  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:57:26am

re: #397 lifeofthemind

Exactly

402 FrogMarch  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:57:28am

re: #351 kevinmumaw

That is their reflex. Like pulling your hand off a hot stove. They will assemble their reasons later.

Yes- and how dare president Bush do what any other sitting president would do - go to the Olympics.

403 galloping granny  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:59:38am
#379 Sharmuta 8/10/08 11:31:31 am reply quote 2

re: #345 Biff

And maybe one reason why we aren't hearing many countries complain, is because the Russians had a legitimate sovereign and strategic rationale.

Russia has claims to Kosovo?

In a round-about, long forgotten kind of way. You might recall that what started World War I was the assassination of Grand Duke Ferdinand of the Austro-Hungarian Empire by a Serbian national. Russia considered Serbia (later to become Yugoslavia) a protectorate or sphere of influence and entered WWI in defense of the Serbs.

So yes, the Russians still figure they have a right to Kosovo and whatever else Yugoslavia has since become.

404 Biff  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:01:00pm

re: #403 galloping granny

Very doubtful.

405 lifeofthemind  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:01:47pm

re: #403 galloping granny

Great Slavic Nationalism, Big Brother Russia and Little Brother Serbia. Doesn't apply even as a fig leaf for Ossetia. There it is a simple case of power grab.

406 Biff  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:04:12pm

But many South Ossetians seem to consider themselves Russians.

407 galloping granny  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:04:21pm

re: #405 lifeofthemind

Great Slavic Nationalism, Big Brother Russia and Little Brother Serbia. Doesn't apply even as a fig leaf for Ossetia. There it is a simple case of power grab.

Never said that it did. I was answering the specific question of a perceived Russian claim to Kosovo.

However, what does apply to Georgia is the long held attitude of once part of the Russian Empire, always part of the Russian Empire. Much the same attitude as the muslims over Spain.

408 swamprat  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:05:13pm

re: #407 galloping granny Sorta like trying to quit the mafia.

409 Spiny Norman  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:07:07pm

re: #399 Biff

My analogy was San Ysidro=S. Ossetra, Mexico=Georgia, US=Russia

Ohfercrissakes. That's the lamest excuse of an analogy I've seen in a long time.

Keep drinking the Kremlin Kool-Aid, buddy.

410 pingjockey  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:07:14pm

re: #399 Biff
That is a totally ass backward analogy. The Russians been stirring shit up down there since Georgia got its independence. Mark my words, the Ukraine is next on Putins wish list.

411 yma o hyd  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:08:10pm

"Moscow said it had sunk a Georgian naval vessel after it tried to attack Russian warships, officials in Moscow were quoted as saying."

From the Beeb just now, scroll down a bit here.

412 galloping granny  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:09:02pm

re: #408 swamprat

Sorta like trying to quit the mafia.

Pretty much.

413 yma o hyd  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:10:29pm

re: #406 Biff

But many South Ossetians seem to consider themselves Russians.

Do please read this article!

Its been linked to several times further up, and partially quoted.
It might help you to make a bit more sense of things ...

414 swamprat  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:11:17pm

re: #398 swamprat

from my 2nd link;

An analysis must be made of what the real reason for the missile shield is. One possibility is that the U.S. is planning an attack on Iran. The second more likely reason is to use the missile shield to gain a strategic advantage over Russia, extending all the way into the Urals their ability to probe into the heart of the Russian Federation. Vladimir Putin has warned that the missile shield will “turn Europe into a powder keg.” The shield is clearly aimed at Russia. There is no other logical explanation for such a system.

...Please note the self-fulfilling prophecy uh, threat. Somehow he nailed it. Amazing.

415 Spiny Norman  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:12:24pm

re: #406 Biff

But many South Ossetians seem to consider themselves Russians.

Millions of US residents consider themselves Mexican, too. Your analogy in #399 would make more sense if Mexico invaded Southern California to protect their supporters here.

416 swamprat  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:14:18pm

re: #415 Spiny Norman

... No war for avocados!

417 yma o hyd  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:16:12pm

re: #414 swamprat

from my 2nd link;

An analysis must be made of what the real reason for the missile shield is. One possibility is that the U.S. is planning an attack on Iran. The second more likely reason is to use the missile shield to gain a strategic advantage over Russia, extending all the way into the Urals their ability to probe into the heart of the Russian Federation. Vladimir Putin has warned that the missile shield will “turn Europe into a powder keg.” The shield is clearly aimed at Russia. There is no other logical explanation for such a system.

...Please note the self-fulfilling prophecy uh, threat. Somehow he nailed it. Amazing.

Its the typical Russian paranoia - everybody is out to get them. Stalin suffered from it to a huge extent. Thus, for him, the Warsaw Pact states were not so much a nice cosy communist club, but the salient on which the baaad capitalist agressors would run out of steam, without getting into Mother Russia.
Hitler showed him why that was necessary ...

418 lifeofthemind  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:17:04pm

re: #407 galloping granny

Never said that it did. I was answering the specific question of a perceived Russian claim to Kosovo.

However, what does apply to Georgia is the long held attitude of once part of the Russian Empire, always part of the Russian Empire. Much the same attitude as the muslims over Spain.

We should have a simple answer to that, NO. Just like James Madison told the Europeans to get over their nostalgia for the lost New World empires. At one tie Chiang kai Shek's KT issued maps claiming everything that the mongols ever conquered. To bad so sad but it doesn't work. Russia has barely enough people to hold onto the real European districts of Russia and Siberia. THey have to give up this imperial dream.

419 lifeofthemind  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:17:52pm

re: #411 yma o hyd

"Moscow said it had sunk a Georgian naval vessel after it tried to attack Russian warships, officials in Moscow were quoted as saying."

From the Beeb just now, scroll down a bit here.

Thank you. I'm waiting for the Turks to decide.

420 JHW  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:18:22pm

This has been long planned,by Russia, for many reasons including the missile shield dispute , NATO membership,and Kosovo disagreements. Putin warned, back in February, that he would take military action, without specifying where. He aimed for what he evidently sees as the easiest pickings, least liable to entangle in a direct confrontation with the West.

Russia's envoy to NATO warned the alliance Friday against overstepping its mandate in Kosovo and said Moscow might be forced to use "brute military force" to maintain respect on the world scene.


American Intelligence, Russia

421 Dr. Shalit  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:19:44pm

re: #305 Charles

It's not surprising that Buchanan is on the side of the Russians. The man is despicable.

Charles -

Basically I am on Georgia's side as you know from my off-the-blog correspondence. Nevertheless, Georgia lives in the dangerous position of being an ex-possession of an ex-superpower. I hope that Ukraine's action of denying ports to the Russian Navy will put a damper on this. If not, unless other arrangements are made, I suspect the best outcome will be the "FINLANDIZATION" of Georgia. Not the best resolution, though a livable one.

-S-

422 debutaunt  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:23:11pm

re: #346 Green Helmet Guy

Wikipedia already has got an article going on the war between Russia/the Ossetian separatists and Georgia:

and they are calling it...

2008 South Ossetia War

Did Bush and Cheney start it?

423 Biff  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:25:51pm

re: #413 yma o hyd

Do please read this article!

Right, great source! How neutral is that? It's still my impression that the Georgians attacked S.O. first.

Also. from Wiki, "Religious minorities of Georgia include Russian Orthodox (2%), Armenian Christians (3.9%), Muslims (9.9%), Roman Catholics (0.8%), as well as sizeable Jewish Communities and various Protestant minorities.[62]"

I'd be a little concerned about the effect of that 9.9%. 10% is almost always a flashpoint.

424 debutaunt  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:27:14pm

re: #367 kevinmumaw

Sounds like Latvia.

We ruled out Lavitia.

425 Dirk Diggler  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:27:38pm

COEXIST!

426 Biff  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:29:36pm

re: #425 Dirk Diggler


I think a little Lizardoid in-fighting is a refreshing thing.

427 The Other Les  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:30:54pm

re: #425 Dirk Diggler

COEXIST!

FNORD!

428 yma o hyd  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:31:24pm

re: #423 Biff

Do please read this article!

Right, great source! How neutral is that? It's still my impression that the Georgians attacked S.O. first.

Also. from Wiki, "Religious minorities of Georgia include Russian Orthodox (2%), Armenian Christians (3.9%), Muslims (9.9%), Roman Catholics (0.8%), as well as sizeable Jewish Communities and various Protestant minorities.[62]"

I'd be a little concerned about the effect of that 9.9%. 10% is almost always a flashpoint.

Do I understand you correctly - are you saying thatm somehow its due to Muslims? And that Georgian Muslims are attacking orthodox Ossetians, thus Russia felt obliged to help?

Because it ain't so - as made quite clear in that article. Regarding her neutrality: she is Russian, and would seem to be the sort of journalist we have great trouble findng in our MSM. She is certainly not an instrument of Putin ...

429 pbird  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:32:15pm

re: #365 GregInSeattle

Bush was a fool for saying he looked into Putin's eyes, and saw a guy he could do business with. That being said, I think Bush will be firm and resolute in dealing with the Russian imperialists (REAL imperialists, invading foreign soil for fun, profit and power)

Actually, I think he was trying to steer Putin a bit.

430 Biff  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:39:34pm

re: #428 yma o hyd

No. There are two different point. I know, that's a lot. 1) the Georgians seem to have started things. 2) The Georgian government may not be as stable as you think due to the Muslim minority.

431 Biff  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:41:09pm

re: #428 yma o hyd


No. she's a VOA propagandist. Definitely not neutral. And I'm not taking sides.

432 JHW  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:50:05pm

re: #431 Biff

You're not likely to get neutral reporting out of Moscow these days, critics of the government seem to have a short lifespan .
Anna Politskovskaya

433 kevinmumaw  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:50:24pm

re: #301 opnion

On the McLaughlin group last night, Buchannan & the hysterical Elenor Clift completely blamed 'Georgian Aggression."

Eleanor Clift is a Soviet lap dog from way back.

434 Spiny Norman  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:54:01pm

re: #431 Biff

No. she's a VOA propagandist. Definitely not neutral. And I'm not taking sides.

Mouthing the Kremlin's line is NOT taking sides? Really?

435 Spiny Norman  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 12:57:03pm

re: #428 yma o hyd

Because it ain't so - as made quite clear in that article. Regarding her neutrality: she is Russian, and would seem to be the sort of journalist we have great trouble findng in our MSM. She is certainly not an instrument of Putin ...

An instrument of the Chimpy McBushitler, apparently, in Biff's view.

Voice of America is enemy propaganda now.

436 Biff  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 1:02:25pm

re: #435 Spiny Norman


No, I'm still very much a W supporter. Just recognize that VOA is not Fox News or the WSJ.

437 sultan_knish  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 1:11:08pm

re: #385 Biff

re: #385 Biff

Stalin however was half Georgian half Ossetian

438 JHW  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 1:14:24pm
439 Aylios  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 1:28:34pm

re: #97 soccerdad

What a rant -- written by Jerome A Paris. A french guy. no wonder

Yet another gaullic embarassment. The guy is an 'energy banker'. This of course in no way makes jerome in paris biased:

This is another diary critical of the West's position on Georgia.

Just as a bit of background, let me state here for the record that I wrote my PhD on the independence of Ukraine, and have thus studied how Russia behaves with its neighbors rather intensively. Following that, I worked for several years financing oil&gas projects in Russia and the Caspian;

440 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 1:28:36pm
441 Syrah  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 1:32:35pm

It seems to me that Russia has two significant weaknesses.

1. It's population is declining dramatically. Nations with declining populations have a difficult time supporting wars because each soldier lost is less replaceable, not only to the state, but to the families that the soldier came from. Short wars are supportable, but long wars could lead to revolutions.

2. Russia ships the bulk of it's oil by pipelines. They are not very easy to defend, especially when they run through foreign nations.

442 DCMacHead  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 1:39:03pm

re: #137 Dianna

For a brief moment, the Canadians were re-thinking their immigration policies, but realized it was just some poor soul who lit a cigarette where he shouldn't have and blew up a propane plant.

443 DCMacHead  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 1:39:59pm

re: #441 Syrah

They actually had a holiday within the past year or two specifically to address this problem.

444 Ojoe  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 1:40:53pm

re: #442 DCMacHead

If you live in the sticks
And your income is fixed

Propane

If your grandma is old
And often is cold

Propane

445 Syrah  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 1:42:16pm

re: #443 DCMacHead

They actually had a holiday within the past year or two specifically to address this problem.

A measure of how significant the problem is.

446 bungie  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 1:57:21pm

The timing of this was perfect (Opening Day of the Olympics, August vacations for Europeans and US Congress, US Presidential Election, and war with Iran threatening), it bespeaks of careful planning. It looks like a chess move.

Is it known whether Georgia, Ukraine, South Ossetia have nuclear weapons?

I agree with #383 re: Kevinmumaw that this may have something to do with the oil pipeline to run from the east through Georgia to the Ukraine with Iran threatening the Gulf of Hormutz. . .

447 JHW  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:05:16pm

re: #446 bungie

I believe Ukraine still has nukes, but I'm not sure. I don't know how I missed this lady, but she is the Prime Minister of Ukraine and is considered a candidate for President in 2010. Wow. She is drop-dead gorgeous. Apparently she's pretty damn tough too. I sure hope so.
Yulia Tymoshenko's Website
Wiki Bio of Ms. Tymoshenko, with her warnings about Russia

2007 Foreign Affairs article Tymoshenko wrote an article called "Containing Russia" in the May-June 2007 edition of the journal Foreign Affairs.[18][19] In the article she sharply criticized alleged authoritarian developments under Vladimir Putin and opposed the alleged new Russian expansionism. Consequently, the article irked Russia and more than a week before the article was published, Russia responded to the article, calling it an "anti-Russian manifesto" and "an attempt to once again draw dividing lines in Europe."[20] It was subsequently revealed that significant portions of the article had been paraphrased from an article written by former U.S. Secretary of State Henry Kissinger. Tymoshenko's staff denied allegations of plagiarism on the grounds that the Foreign Affairs format does not usually include attributions.[2
448 Wendya  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:06:38pm

re: #108 ggt


South Ossetia wanted independence. WTF, why? When you know you are vulnerable --or at least surrounded by bullies, why would you want to be stand all by your lonesome?

.


They don't want independence. They want to be part of Russia.

That's why Russia gave the people living there passports and Russian citizenship.... to stir shit up.

449 conservativeChick  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:08:47pm

re: #296 Charles

Charles. I am a Christan myself but there is no way I agree with th eDiscovery Institute. If anything I agree with you about them. I personally believe that religion should stay out of politics. I have been saying for years that Russia would try something like this and that they are the puppet masters with everything that has been going on. Nobody believed me until now.

450 ex cathedra  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:18:07pm

Either you believe in the right of nations to self-determination - and then Ossetia and Abkhasia should have a right to secede from Georgia. Or you don't believe in this right and believe, on the other hand, in the right of nations to preserve their territorial integrity. And in this case, Kosovo is an illegitimate entity. Take your pick. What's good for the goose is good for the gander.

451 ex cathedra  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:23:10pm

There is no question that the bad guys in the conflict are Georgia. They are the ones who started shelling Tschintvali, killing 2000 people and a douzen Russian peace-keepers. I am still on the fence regarding whether Russia shoudl have interfered. But let's not forget that in an analogous situation Nato started bombing Serbia, and the world applauded.

453 jaunte  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:31:22pm

re: #450 ex cathedra

Putin doesn't believe in the right of nations to self-determination.
It's not traditionally been a Russian idea.

454 Sharmuta  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:32:56pm

re: #451 ex cathedra

Bullshit. They were provoked. So you either believe a country has a right to protect their citizens from hostilities, or you don't. So what would you tell Israel?

456 MandyManners  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:38:26pm

re: #451 ex cathedra

There is no question that the bad guys in the conflict are Georgia. They are the ones who started shelling Tschintvali, killing 2000 people and a douzen Russian peace-keepers. I am still on the fence regarding whether Russia shoudl have interfered. But let's not forget that in an analogous situation Nato started bombing Serbia, and the world applauded.

Bullshit. Putin's been wanting to invade Georgia for quite some time. And, now, he's moving in from the NW, too.

Zugdidi, a Georgian town on the administrative border with breakaway Abkhazia, “is almost empty,” as local residents flee the town fearing a possible invasion by Russian troops, RFE/RL Georgian Service reported, quoting a local resident.

It also reported that eyewitnesses said they had seen hundreds of armored vehicles, including tanks, amassed on the Abkhaz side of the administrative border.

SNIP

457 Grok the Fullness  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:39:25pm

re: #451 ex cathedra

Please! Russia would LOVE to invade and reconquer ALL of the old USSR.

458 ex cathedra  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:39:27pm

re: #453 jaunte

Putin doesn't believe in the right of nations to self-determination.
It's not traditionally been a Russian idea.

Isn't it a Marxist idea? In any case, Marxists invoked it often when it was convenient for them. And now I'm seeing the same thing. When it's convenient, we hear cries about the right of nations to self-determination. When it's inconvenient, we hear cries about the right of nations to preserve their territorial integrity. And the culprits are both sides equally - the West and Russia.

I just hate lies and hypocrisy from the bottom of my heart. I would much prefer to hear a government say: "it's in our geopolitical interests to pursue such and such policy, and that is why we are doing it." At least, it's honest.

459 ex cathedra  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:41:32pm

re: #454 Sharmuta

Bullshit. They were provoked. So you either believe a country has a right to protect their citizens from hostilities, or you don't. So what would you tell Israel?

Once again. Gergia started shelling Ossetia and killed 200 peopel (by now). Read the history of the conflict.

460 Sharmuta  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:42:24pm

re: #459 ex cathedra

Once again. Gergia started shelling Ossetia and killed 200 peopel (by now). Read the history of the conflict.

You mean the Kremlin's version, right?

461 jaunte  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:43:02pm

re: #459 ex cathedra

Whose 'facts' are you using?

462 Sharmuta  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:43:29pm

re: #461 jaunte

Whose 'facts' are you using?

Maybe the DI's Russiablog's?

463 Grok the Fullness  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:43:57pm

Freaking grinds my gears... the only thing the Russians have between them and a full fledged asskicking is a shitload of nukes. Otherwise those backwards f**ks would get what they so richly deserve.

464 razorbacker  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:45:14pm

re: #455 Syrah

Russia sinks Georgian warship and 'bombs Tbilisi airport' as refugees flee in panic

But Russian bombers still appeared to be shelling a military airport at Tbilisi.

Jesus H. Christ in the foothills with sneakers on!

When you read something like that, you automatically wonder what other mistakes are in the story. The whole thing could be afflicted with the same level of accuracy.

Good thing they have those multiple layers of fact-checkers and editors.

465 pingjockey  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:45:51pm

re: #459 ex cathedra
Got Putins talking points down cold doncha. What are you going to say when Russia invades the Ukraine? That is next.

466 ex cathedra  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:46:10pm

re: #460 Sharmuta

You mean the Kremlin's version, right?

This is ridiculous. What is your version - the MSM brain-washing version? There were reports several days before the conflict about Georgia shelling Ossetia. You can google it in English.

467 jaunte  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:46:50pm

re: #466 ex cathedra

What does the port of Poti have to do with Ossetia?

468 Grok the Fullness  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:47:58pm

re: #467 jaunte

Perhaps there sewer system is down...

/sorry, just had to break some tension

469 JHW  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:48:50pm

re: #459 ex cathedra

It's not a good idea to statements out of that region at face value, there are a multitude of players, each putting the best face on things, each with different motivations.Simplicity is sometimes obscured. However, Russia made statements in February that they were going to use military force somewhere and gave many grievances and justifications, they just weren't specific who was going to get whacked.

470 DeafDog  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:51:09pm

re: #467 jaunte

What does the port of Poti have to do with Ossetia?

This is off topic, is there a connection between the port of Poti and a Port-o-potty?

471 Sharmuta  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:51:44pm

re: #466 ex cathedra

Uh-oh! Your rhetoric is revealing.

472 ex cathedra  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:52:23pm

Are the BBC news from the 4th of July kosher for you?
[Link: news.bbc.co.uk...]

Georgia shells breakaway Ossetia

Separatists in Georgia's breakaway South Ossetia region say at least two people were killed when Georgian forces started shelling the region overnight.

473 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:56:42pm
474 ex cathedra  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:57:47pm

re: #465 pingjockey

Got Putins talking points down cold doncha. What are you going to say when Russia invades the Ukraine? That is next.

I wouldn't mind, actually. I am from the Ukraine (don't live there though). Ukrainian nationalists discriminate against Russian speakers closing Russian schools and doing other things aimed at the suppression of the Russian speakers' rights. Many Russian speakers in East and Southern wouldn't mind either separating from west Ukraine or joining Russia. If Russia invaded Ukraine they would get a lot of supporters among the local population.

475 MandyManners  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:57:53pm

re: #472 ex cathedra

Are the BBC news from the 4th of July kosher for you?
[Link: news.bbc.co.uk...]

Georgia shells breakaway Ossetia

Separatists in Georgia's breakaway South Ossetia region say at least two people were killed when Georgian forces started shelling the region overnight.

And that excuses Russia's invastion from Abkhazia?

476 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:58:01pm
477 JHW  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:58:02pm

re: #472 ex cathedra

No, not without other sources to either confirm or deny, or at least compare to, the one you cited. There is no indication in that article where this reportage came from, ....people in the region? eye witnesses? a foreign ministry ? officials- officials of who?the BBC itself, the Russian ministries, the Georgian ones....who knows from this report, it could have just as easily came from a pub in Soho off the TV screen.

478 DeafDog  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:58:05pm

re: #466 ex cathedra

This is ridiculous. What is your version - the MSM brain-washing version? There were reports several days before the conflict about Georgia shelling Ossetia. You can google it in English.

It is not so ridiculous. The russian version includes many items that are obviously lies. For example, there was a soviet, I mean russian, claim that the Georgians bombed a humanitarian relief mission that was on the one road to combat zone. Do you believe that a humanatarian relief mission would be on a road with such a high miliatary value?

479 MandyManners  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:58:32pm

re: #474 ex cathedra

Damn, you're a fucking idiot.

480 pingjockey  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 2:59:08pm

re: #474 ex cathedraWasn't the Ukraine an independent country before WWII? Or did the Communists absorb it during the 1917 revolution?

481 jaunte  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:00:08pm

re: #472 ex cathedra

The Russian planning for this invasion was taking place months ago, or it wouldn't be happening now.

482 DeafDog  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:01:53pm

re: #450 ex cathedra

Either you believe in the right of nations to self-determination - and then Ossetia and Abkhasia should have a right to secede from Georgia. Or you don't believe in this right and believe, on the other hand, in the right of nations to preserve their territorial integrity. And in this case, Kosovo is an illegitimate entity. Take your pick. What's good for the goose is good for the gander.

All power dervices from the people. That is the political truth.

However, it does not follow that Ossetia has a right to set-up a thug government to break-away from their current government.

483 ex cathedra  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:08:14pm

re: #469 JHW

It's not a good idea to statements out of that region at face value, there are a multitude of players, each putting the best face on things, each with different motivations.Simplicity is sometimes obscured. However, Russia made statements in February that they were going to use military force somewhere and gave many grievances and justifications, they just weren't specific who was going to get whacked.


I don't take them at face value. And I am undecided so far about the Russian invasion. However, I don't see how what they are doing is different from what the West did by giving independence to Kosovo. Every side has its own geopolitical interests. Russian interests are at odds with Western interests. The two sides are competitors, they are not enemies. Neother are China and the West enemies. But reading the rhetoric on this board one sometimes forgets it. I think it's very important to distinguish between competitors and enemies. The Islamic world is the enemy of the West. Their goal is to destroy the West, killing or enslaving its people. The goal of Russia and China is not to destroy the West but to become stronger and more dominant. So is the goal of the West. I believe that one should be open about one's geopolitical interests.

484 Sharmuta  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:08:39pm

re: #479 MandyManners

Mandy- where is that LiveLeak video you had the other day?

485 ex cathedra  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:10:43pm

re: #479 MandyManners

Damn, you're a fucking idiot.

MandyManners - does your name mean you have manners? It doesn't sound like that.What about my comment that is idiotic? Or you just like to curse? And who then is intelligent?

486 pingjockey  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:13:19pm

re: #485 ex cathedra
Some of like to curse. Some of us like to call asshats, asshats. Some of us were cold warriors, me 1977 to 1997 and I don't trust the Russians be they communist of neo-czarist in any form.

487 Sharmuta  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:13:55pm

re: #485 ex cathedra

Do you dispute the recent skirmishes then that led to Georgia trying to protect their citizens?

488 ex cathedra  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:15:43pm

re: #480 pingjockey

Wasn't the Ukraine an independent country before WWII? Or did the Communists absorb it during the 1917 revolution?


Only West Ukraine was added to the Soviet Union after WWII. I have a Polish friend whose parents were kicked out of West Ukraine after the war when it became the Soviet Union. They left their house and walked all the way across Poland until they came to the Wroclaw area that was captued from the Germans and annexed to Poland. There they occupied an empty house that used to belong to German family that got kicked out. There was some interesting symmetry about it.

489 kevinmumaw  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:17:06pm

re: #451 ex cathedra

There is no question that the bad guys in the conflict are Georgia. They are the ones who started shelling Tschintvali, killing 2000 people and a douzen Russian peace-keepers. I am still on the fence regarding whether Russia shoudl have interfered. But let's not forget that in an analogous situation Nato started bombing Serbia, and the world applauded.

That is absolute, unadulterated Kremlin propaganda. You are purposely ignoring months of provacations and preparations by the Russians...and I for one am not that stupid.

490 ex cathedra  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:17:13pm

re: #481 jaunte

The Russian planning for this invasion was taking place months ago, or it wouldn't be happening now.

I am not defending Russia per se. I simply don't like double standards. I prefer honesty.

491 ex cathedra  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:18:45pm

re: #482 DeafDog

All power dervices from the people. That is the political truth.

However, it does not follow that Ossetia has a right to set-up a thug government to break-away from their current government.


And what are your thoughts on Kosovo? Did it have a right to break away from Serbia? How is it different?

492 pingjockey  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:18:51pm

re: #488 ex cathedra
What a fucking mess. So is WWIII gonna be the third european civil war? With jihadis thrown in for spice. Had a history teacher who called WWI the first european civil war since almost all the monarchies were related. With WWII being the curtain call for WWI.

493 DeafDog  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:19:35pm

re: #483 ex cathedra

I don't see how what they are doing is different from what the West did by giving independence to Kosovo.

Then you are blind, my russian friend. There is a BIG difference between providing a people a chance for legitimate sef determination vs. allowing a group of criminals to exploit an area for there own personal gain.

494 jaunte  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:19:44pm

re: #490 ex cathedra

Here's some honesty for you.
The Russians are making this move to consolidate their controltover energy supplies to the EU. A comparable move for the U.S. would be to invade part of Canada or Mexico.

495 jaunte  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:20:05pm

pimf: control over

496 JHW  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:20:24pm

re: #483 ex cathedra

Please look at the link I gave in post 298 and read their version of events, these are the jihadis in Abkhazia. As I said there are other players involved in this, and they are naturally milking the situation to their advantage, and possibly could have had a partial hand in stirring up as much mayhem as possible.Georgia, at first glance, appears to me to be more of a pawn to others' ambitions, not necessarily the identical players,who are going to strain every nerve to make them appear as the aggressor. There is also an organized crime-smuggling aspect to this region. This part of the world is famous for corruption, the very Russians who now are playing cavalry to the rescue are knee-deep in it, and during the Chechen war sold the very arms used to kill them to their enemies.

497 ex cathedra  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:23:08pm

re: #489 kevinmumaw

That is absolute, unadulterated Kremlin propaganda. You are purposely ignoring months of provacations and preparations by the Russians...and I for one am not that stupid.

Do Russian provocations justify Georgia's shelling civillians in Tskhinvali? To me this too creepily similar to the Israel situation with the "palestinians" shelling innocent people in Sderot. The righteous side would never shell innocent people. Now whether Russia is being opportunistic is another story. Of course, they don't want Nato next door. Who can blame them? But in any case, I think it's a good idea to stop the shelling.

498 jaunte  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:26:14pm

re: #497 ex cathedra

Are Russian military advisers to the Ossetians siting their posts within a population of civilian shields?

499 ex cathedra  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:29:02pm

re: #493 DeafDog

Then you are blind, my russian friend. There is a BIG difference between providing a people a chance for legitimate sef determination vs. allowing a group of criminals to exploit an area for there own personal gain.

First of all, I am not Russian, I am a Ukrainian Jew. Secondly, the Ossetians are no more thugs than Kosovars. There are criminal structures in both countries. Most of them are people that simply don't want to be under Georgians. It's the same with Abkhasians. They didn't want it back in the early nineties, as you will see if you research this issue. The situation is almost exactly symmetrical to that of Kosovo.

500 ex cathedra  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:31:11pm

re: #496 JHW

Please look at the link I gave in post 298 and read their version of events, these are the jihadis in Abkhazia. As I said there are other players involved in this, and they are naturally milking the situation to their advantage, and possibly could have had a partial hand in stirring up as much mayhem as possible.Georgia, at first glance, appears to me to be more of a pawn to others' ambitions, not necessarily the identical players,who are going to strain every nerve to make them appear as the aggressor. There is also an organized crime-smuggling aspect to this region. This part of the world is famous for corruption, the very Russians who now are playing cavalry to the rescue are knee-deep in it, and during the Chechen war sold the very arms used to kill them to their enemies.

Thanks, I'll read it. I agree so far with what you said.

501 DeafDog  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:31:57pm

re: #491 ex cathedra

And what are your thoughts on Kosovo? Did it have a right to break away from Serbia? How is it different?

The difference is the legitimacy of the government. If you have a constitution that was developed by a people legitimately and a government that was elected legitimately by the majority - then you have to submit to the govt. (this is why we at LGF hate the idea of an Obama election)

The warlords that seized control in South Ossetia have no claims at legitimacy, but the Govt. in Tbilisi does.

In Kosovo, it's questionable whether the Serbian govt. had any legitimacy. Regardless of that, the Serbian govt. lost legitimacy because of all the human rights violations on the part of the Serbian army throughout the region after the breakup of Yugoslavia.

502 DeafDog  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:37:45pm

re: #499 ex cathedra

First of all, I am not Russian, I am a Ukrainian Jew. Secondly, the Ossetians are no more thugs than Kosovars. There are criminal structures in both countries. Most of them are people that simply don't want to be under Georgians. It's the same with Abkhasians. They didn't want it back in the early nineties, as you will see if you research this issue. The situation is almost exactly symmetrical to that of Kosovo.

Again, there's a big difference. Karadzic was an evil man. I doubt the Georgians are saints, but I have no reason to believe they behaved as badly as the Serbians.

503 ex cathedra  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:38:25pm

re: #494 jaunte

Here's some honesty for you.
The Russians are making this move to consolidate their controltover energy supplies to the EU. A comparable move for the U.S. would be to invade part of Canada or Mexico.


Very possibly you are right. Another reason is not to have a Nato country next door. The situation with Mexico and Canada is not the same, because these are both friendly countries. But imagine someone like Hugo Chavez or Fidel Castro becoming the Mexican president. Suddenly the scenario would not appear as far-fetched.

The saddest thing is that historically Russia and Georgia have enjoyed good relations. Georgia joined the Russian empire voluntarily if my memory doesn't lie. The Russian aristocracy married the Georgian aristocracy. They mutually supported each other against militant islamic people in the region.

504 jaunte  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:42:50pm

re: #503 ex cathedra

Georgia 'joined' the Russian empire to avoid being eaten by the Ottoman empire.

505 Sharmuta  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:44:09pm

re: #499 ex cathedra

I think this comment is disgusting! Are you equating the Georgians with genocidal killers?

506 wiffersnapper  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:48:05pm

So the liberals on facebook are asking why the US is even bothering with Iran when Russia is invading Georgia.

507 Sharmuta  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:48:29pm

re: #499 ex cathedra

The Kosovars are thugs? The Kosovars?! What about the Serbians?!

508 JHW  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:50:08pm

re: #504 jaunte

What a neighborhood, Ottoman Turks and Safavid Persians to the south, the Tsar to the north. Devil and the deep blue sea for sure. Another reason, out of thousands, for me to be grateful to live in this time and place.

509 ex cathedra  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:50:26pm

re: #501 DeafDog

The difference is the legitimacy of the government. If you have a constitution that was developed by a people legitimately and a government that was elected legitimately by the majority - then you have to submit to the govt. (this is why we at LGF hate the idea of an Obama election)

The warlords that seized control in South Ossetia have no claims at legitimacy, but the Govt. in Tbilisi does.

In Kosovo, it's questionable whether the Serbian govt. had any legitimacy. Regardless of that, the Serbian govt. lost legitimacy because of all the human rights violations on the part of the Serbian army throughout the region after the breakup of Yugoslavia.


I think it depends very much on whose side you are reading. There was a lot of atrocities on the opposite side in the Yugoslav war. Many respectable writers, and I think Serge Trifkovitz would agree, would argue that it is not at all fair that the Serbs were portrayed as the bad guys. I think they got the short end of the stick. Similarly, the Kosovo situation could be described in the same terms - as "warlords who seized control." The criminal structures in Kosovo are well known in Europe. On top of that, Kosovo is established in the heart of the historical Serbian territory. I don't think it's true about Ossetia. The situations are indeed eerily similar, and just saying that one is legitimate and another one is bogus doesn't make it so. You might want to go read a recent article on Kosovo by James Jatras on the jihad watch site.

Well, I'm signing off. I'm tired now.

510 jaunte  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:50:41pm

re: #508 JHW

I would be tempted to sail west...

511 big L  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:52:38pm

Couldn't we slip the Georgians, the ones being shelled, a
whole shipment of SAMs or Cruise missles. I mean Would that be wrong? Get a caravan of FEDex Trucks or DHLs and fill them with crates of "Borscht" and run them into the country.
/"Not that there is anything wrong with that"(channelling Seinfeld)

512 Sharmuta  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:52:47pm

re: #509 ex cathedra

On top of that, Kosovo is established in the heart of the historical Serbian territory.

My understanding is it's Albanian.

You might want to go read a recent article on Kosovo by James Jatras on the jihad watch site.

Jatras is a Serbian nationalist.

513 JHW  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 3:52:55pm

re: #510 jaunte

Yes, as quickly as possible, Italy would be a nice first stop, I think the Georgians like their wine.

514 JHW  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 4:05:11pm

re: #503 ex cathedra

If you're still here, since you are Ukrainian, I'm wondering what you think of Yulia Tymoschenko. No ulterior motive in my question,just curiosity.

515 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 4:09:18pm
516 The Other Les  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 4:17:15pm

re: #1 JammieWearingFool

Funny how silent the anti-war left is these days.

Funny how the Russian propaganda machine is running at full power.

[Link: www.youtube.com...]

517 DeafDog  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 4:20:06pm

re: #509 ex cathedra

I think it depends very much on whose side you are reading. There was a lot of atrocities on the opposite side in the Yugoslav war. Many respectable writers, and I think Serge Trifkovitz would agree, would argue that it is not at all fair that the Serbs were portrayed as the bad guys. I think they got the short end of the stick. Similarly, the Kosovo situation could be described in the same terms - as "warlords who seized control." The criminal structures in Kosovo are well known in Europe. On top of that, Kosovo is established in the heart of the historical Serbian territory. I don't think it's true about Ossetia. The situations are indeed eerily similar, and just saying that one is legitimate and another one is bogus doesn't make it so. You might want to go read a recent article on Kosovo by James Jatras on the jihad watch site.

Well, I'm signing off. I'm tired now.

Without visiting either locale, we are very dependent on what we read and which side gives a believable explanation.

The Georgian explanation - that they were trying to regain control of a rougue area inside their borders - is believable. Was it foolish? Perhaps. But I understand what they were doing. Russia says they just happen to have a few tank columns handy to respond to a "shelling" situation. The "shelling" was all within Georgia's borders. So Russia breaking those borders with the handy tank columns already stretches credibility. Then, Russia says that Georgia bombed a humanitarian column and I can only think WTF was a humanatarian column doing alongside a bunch of tanks. No one is that big of an idiot. The Russian explanation fails the smell test... it stinks. They have no credibility. But you are taking their BS as believable. You are not a Ukranian Jew, you are a Ruskie through and through.

The only similarity between this situation and Kosovo is that Russia is on the side of conquest in both situations.

518 ex cathedra  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 4:27:12pm

I came back to share this Guardian editorial. It seems balanced and makes a lor of sense to me.

[Link: www.guardian.co.uk...]

"By the time the international community realised what was happening, it was already too late. It is like that in the Caucasus, a zone of self-igniting conflicts that burn as fiercely as they do instantly. A day which started with a Georgian military offensive to retake South Ossetia - a pro-Russian enclave they had lost control of 14 years ago - ended with Russian warplanes bombing Georgian airfields. Columns of Russian tanks were headed into Tskhinvali, the capital of South Ossetia, and refugees were streaming out.

Disentangling claim and counter-claim is as hard as working out the real sequence of events. But there can be little doubt that Georgia's attack with assault troops, multiple-rocket launchers and artillery was a planned military operation. It was not just a reaction to Russian bombing the day before, or a ceasefire that somehow went wrong. The timing of the offensive, when Russian prime minister, Vladimir Putin, was in Beijing for the opening of the Olympic games, was also significant. Georgia may have calculated that Mr Putin might be constrained by the company he was keeping in Beijing, not to order an instant counterattack.

Anyone familiar with the history of the region could have predicted that Russia would hit back hard. First, the majority of the 75,000 Ossetians are pro-Russian, and have long been angling to join North Ossetia, which is part of the Russian Federation. Second, many Ossetians have now got Russian citizenship and passports. Third, this is a dispute that predates both the Georgian president, Mikhail Saakashvili, and the Putin era. Fourth, rushing to the aid of separatists was a precedent set by the west in Kosovo. Russia gave us fair warning of the consequences.

Rather than keep the dispute within a local compass, Mr Saakashvili has done everything in his power to internationalise it. He has banged loudly on Nato's door, and some US leaders have been taken in. The Republican candidate John McCain got a St George's Cross for visiting the Georgian part of South Ossetia last year. The Germans and the French on the other hand resisted Georgia's demand for a membership action plan at the last Nato summit in Bucharest. Georgia's actions yesterday show just how wise Berlin was.

Russia is far from blameless. Its official role as peacekeeper in South Ossetia is questionable. It has a history of destabilising independent countries and refusing to accept retreat from empire. But this does not mean that Nato governments should take everything they see at face value. This is not about plucky Georgian democrats versus Russian tyrants. The players in this drama are more devious than that."

I highlighted what seems important. Russian is very likely being opportunitic. But Georgians are not blameless either.

519 ex cathedra  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 4:35:06pm

re: #514 JHW

If you're still here, since you are Ukrainian, I'm wondering what you think of Yulia Tymoschenko. No ulterior motive in my question,just curiosity.

I left Ukraine a very long time ago and am not very au courant. She belongs to the Ukrainian nationalist wing. Ukrainian nationalists are not popular with Eastern and Southern Ukrainians, who are mostly Russian speakers. There are large parts of Ukraine with Russian speaking population who don't like the fact that Russian schools are closing and they can't pass their language and culture onto their children. Other than that I don't have an opinion on her competence as a politician. There were some corruption scandals, but I don't remember what it was about.

I do think she is a very beautiful woman.

520 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 4:43:14pm
521 DeafDog  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 5:05:11pm

re: #518 ex cathedra

The artical was slanted against the Georgians. Notice what they started with, which packs the punch, and what they ended with, which most readers don't get to.

BTW - The Guardian is a left wing rag. They do not have a reputation of journalistic excellence, in my experience, and I have more reason to dobt them than to believe them.

522 jaunte  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 5:43:34pm

What better way to increase the price of Russian energy supplies to Europe than to shut down a pipeline with a little war.

523 Dom  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 5:43:35pm

See how war can so quickly break out, with Russia so suddenly aggressive, but when the USA and its allies geared up for war in Afghanistan and in Iraq, Russia and its allies used every facility available to hinder preparations and question America's reasoning at the UN. Clearly Russia recourses to the UN only when it happens to suit. The implications for "international law" are quite awesome, n'est ce pas?

524 Dom  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 6:11:39pm

poprostu,

I noticed you're working down the thread rating comments. If you get this far, since you have an informed opinion and it seems to differ from a number of commenters, I am curious as to what you believe. With respect.

525 deester  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 6:28:24pm

I think there are some parallels between post-WWI Germany and Russia today -- a country that wants to regain past glories; pride in having been a world power, resentment for losing world-power status, and a purposeful project to regain that status; a re-introduction of imperial symbols (Russia has reintroduced tsarist and soviet symbols over the past few years); a desire to reassert control over lost areas of influence; a lack of repentance for past policies; creeping introduction of a one-party state; and now military activity to assert world power status (remember that at first the Germans wanted to protect and absorb Germans in borderland areas). Russia has not yet admitted that the soviet state was cruel and should be rejected fully. Until that happens, I fear that Russia will pursue more wars to re-claim past influence. It's happening now, and will continue if the West does not exert some influence to slow it.

526 swamprat  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 7:19:20pm

re: #490 ex cathedra Oh, you're gonna love us then.

527 captain joe  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 7:37:42pm

VP Darth Vader has sent a warning to Putin. I wonder if he would send a carrier group into the Black Sea.

528 The Other Les  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 7:57:03pm

re: #527 captain joe

VP Darth Vader has sent a warning to Putin. I wonder if he would send a carrier group into the Black Sea.

Would your carrier group to be caught in the Black Sea?

529 barry the baptist  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 8:22:08pm

Hardly any world outcry over Russian bombing the Georgians in S Ossetia or in Georgia itself. Checked CNN and found nothing to the outcry that we had when we accidentally killed a few villagers in AFG a while back. Here, the Russians can bomb with impunity from any harsh investigation from any major news source or otherwise. Also, US released a statement essentially saying that since we need Russian help with Iran the Georgian's are on their own.

Welcome to NATO.

Other NATO leader responses:

Germany- 'Oh please stop it! Pleeeeaaasssseeee!'
UK- totally avoiding crisis.
Italy- all ready in retreat.
Spain- if we deploy then Muslims won't like us.
Turkey- what do we care? It's not Turkey.
Greece- we don't get involved in the eastern Black Sea area.
France- tough break.
Poland- we told you they would be back.
Luxembourg- we have sent this dilemma to a response committee. Check back with us in 3 years.
Bulgaria- as long as the Russians are on the other side of the Black Sea we're OK.
Belgium- What? Russia invaded the US?
Canada- we're disarming our military so we'll file a protest in the UN.
Estonia- don't look at us!
Denmark- looks like the Russians are mad.
Norway- we will be deploying 2 longships immediately!
Romania- see Bulgaria
Hungary- we'll be ready if they come this way!
Latvia- see Estonia.
Netherlands- Huh?
Iceland- if the Russians come this way, we''' petition the US for help.
Portugal- we're just an honourary member.....
Czech Republic- Slovakia better not get any ideas!
Slovakia- Let the Czech's try something!
Slovenia- we only have one plane..and it's broken.

Media responses:

BBC- Russia bombs civilians; 2000 dead-now for soccer news....
CNN- Bush/Cheney responsible for stopping Russians!
MSNBC- it's all our fault. We are responsible for the Russians bombing civilians.
NBC- The Russians have been bombing civilians.Back to Beijing!
ABC, CBS- if the US didn't do it, then we don't care to comment. Here's the latest on Brittany Spears...
Fox- fair and balanced: interviews Russian bomber pilots and victims on split screen.

What? No Code Pink on the case? No Amnesty INTL? No UN outcry? No anti-war loons marching in Moscow to stop this war? No INTL Answer? No human shields?

530 swamprat  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 8:28:15pm

re: #529 barry the baptist
There is no outcry because those deaths did not occur durring a wedding party.

531 Aussie Infidel  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 8:43:03pm

This is so typical of so called politics in the US. We have a major war beginning to brew in the Trans Caucuses and what do we hear in the US? Whether Phelps will win 8 medals or just 7 like last time and is John 'Haircut' the father of his girlfriend's brat?

Please wake up yanks. You guys are the world's sole su[per power. Try to start to behave like it and get a grip! Sheeesh!


As far as Georgia is concerned we have some interesting facts that seem to have been glossed over:-


1. How did the Russian army get to the start line in 8 hours?
2. What caused to Georgian army to push into South Ossetia in the first place?
3. Consider if this was just a Russian set up! It certainly smells suspiciously as if it is and the Georgians fell right in with both feet!
4. What could be the Russian reasons for starting this punch up?
a). As a pay back for NATO and especially US help to the Albanians in Kosovo against the Russian's fellow Slavs?
b). As a warning to the other restive minorities on the edges of the Russian Federation, especially the Ukraine whose eastern half has a majority Russian demographic. Also consider the Balts and the rest of the Caucuses states.
c). A grab for the only non-Russian controlled energy supply conduit to Europe. Remember that if one has Europe by the 'energy balls' their hearts and minds will follow!
d). A demonstration of Russian military prowess and ruthlessness to get Russia back onto the world stage.
e). An attempt to show the world that the US is currently a 'paper tiger' militarily, as combat fatigue and political distractions sap US power.

Expect other fringe state-lets to declare 'independence' . You guys in the US can blame yourselves as it was you who opened the Pandora's box of national 'rearrangements' and unilateral land grabs in the former Yugoslavia. Now you are reaping the whirlwind as russia pushes back after being lied to and humiliated in the Balkans. Did you really think that Moscow would let the US get away with the Kosovo treachery and back stabbing that went on?


But not to worry yanks. Busy yourselves with the DNC and which Hollywood star will appear and whether Obama can get both of his feet in his mouth at the same time when the auto-cue breaks again!

Oh and by the way. For those yanks who think that this is just a local punch up that means squat to the rest of the world. Remember that energy is involved and you guys will feel this in your pocket books in the days and weeks to come.

Especially now that the crisis looks as if it will widen with the Ukraine telling the Russian Black Sea navy that it is not welcome back in their home port on the Crimean coast!


and also now that you have stabbed Israel in the back over the threat from Iran. Do you really think that nuclear armed Israel will fall into the sea without taking a large chunk of the Middle east with it? That too will REALLY hurt you guys in the pocket book!


Think about it and please try to maintain your concentration for more that 10 minutes and spare me the Hollywood gossip attitude! You're the leader of the free world. Start acting like it and grow some stones!

532 lifeofthemind  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 8:59:07pm

re: #531 Aussie Infidel

I can't be really angry at you for this. If things really go to hell like in "On the Beach" can I move to Oz and get you to introduce me to a nice girl? Must be more frustrating being America's friend than enemy often enough.

533 Ledger1  Sun, Aug 10, 2008 11:46:28pm

re: #94 realwest

I agree.

It is bad policy. We should never turn out back on our friends. If we do then we will not have any friends.

I think the whole war was carefully calculated by the Russians. The timing was too exact. The world has it eyes of the Olympics and would be caught off guard.

The Russians look to have been planning this for a long time. There are Pearl Harbor aspects to this. –Wrechard of the Belmont Club

Here is a round-up of the news:

The vice president expressed the United States’ solidarity with the Georgian people and their democratically elected government... Cheney told Saakashvili “Russian aggression must not go unanswered, and that its continuation would have serious consequences for its relations with the United States, as well as the broader international community,” McBride said. –AP

[Wrechard of the Belmont Club]

The key terms here are “Russian aggression” and “must not go unanswered”.

See: What is next

[Wrechard of the Belmont Club]

Tskhinvali is the “cork in the bottle” leading from the Caucasus passes to the long plain that runs west to east across Georgia Sky News now says the Georgians are falling back on Gori, which is the key to keeping Georgia intact.

See: Wretchards comments (Aug 10, 2008 - 8:09 am)

[and]

Given the scale of the threat, the Georgians had no option but to fall back and trade time for space. But they have precious little space to trade… The alternative is to wire everything for demolition, mine every approach that can be mined and leave the Russians with a succession of Tskhinvalis.

See: Who’s winning Georgia part 2

Canoneer No. (Aug 10, 2008 - 10:13 am) notes there is a cyber war on Georgia

See cyber war

Wretchard (Aug 10, 2008 - 2:34 am):

I think the mask is off. The Russians look to have been planning this for a long time. There are Pearl Harbor aspects to this.


See: wretchard’s post Aug. 10 2008 2:34am

PL: War In Georgia: The Oil Angle

534 Aussie Infidel  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 4:39:56am

re: #533 Ledger1

I think the mask is off. The Russians look to have been planning this for a long time.


DUH.... ya think?


Of course the bloody Russians have been planning this for years. The US is being humiliated and its reputation as an ally is now being dragged in the dust for all to see. If you don't believe me then go ask the Israelis.

Sorry yanks, while you were mesmerized with the 'Obamarama' farce and the puerile spin campaigns of both sides in the White House electoral race, the world moved on. Actually I sort of agree with the Russians on some points. Perhaps Alexander Solzenitzen was right when he spoke at Yale. Half of the US is degenerate, puerile and narcissistic and deserves to go the way or other powers when they rot from the inside. Too bad a lot of very fine folks will go down as well in the US.

How in hell could the US throw its lot in with a bunch of muslim Albanian thugs i'll never know. If the US wanted to throw its lot in with anyone why not throw it in with a bunch of Christian Serb thugs? Or better still leave the mess to the French and the rest of the Euro weenies! But no the USN and USAF bombed a lot of blow up rubber tanks and even managed to kill a few real ones and eventually 'monstered' the Serbs to abandon the cradle of their civilization in Kosovo. And prey tell how long do you think the current state of affairs is going to last? The Balkan protagonists think in centuries when planning revenge. It will be served cold long after the USA is but another note in the history books. And what did it achieve?

To add insult to injury, the US knifed Russia in the back over its role in protecting Slavic interests in the Balkans. Having agreed in writing to allow Russian peacekeepers into the arena to keep some balance, the US lied, double dealed and virtually imprisoned a small Russian force of logisticians on a single airfield abrogating the signed deal between Bush and Putin. It doesn't take an Einstein to figure it out that if you twist the bear's tail you ... or in this case your friends..... are going to feel the bear's claws. On what planet do the denizens of Washington DC live? The US could have had Russia if not a friend then at least not an enemy. Now the US has bitten off more than it can chew and is suffering from over extension... just like so many 'empires' in the past. You guys seem to be smart in so many ways and yet you are unbelievably stupid at the same time. The nation who landed man on the Moon is also the nation of overweight hedonistic losers. How can that be? Sometimes I that you yanks have really lost the plot when it comes to 'real-politik'. I love you guys and it makes me sad to see you fall to bits like this and do some really stupid things. As a friend I have to question just what being a friend of the US actually means when the chips are really down!


...... The vice president expressed the United States’ solidarity with the Georgian people and their democratically elected government... Cheney told Saakashvili “Russian aggression must not go unanswered, and that its continuation would have serious consequences for its relations with the United States, as well as the broader international community,” McBride said. –AP....

One can't fire solidarity and when it comes right down to it....." serious consequences"..... are just words, and we all know about spin because talk is cheap in this world.

535 Jouth  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 6:03:45am

The worst case line-up is looking like this
PRC is going to grab Russia far east! !
Russia, vs. China Turkestan. Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, and Uzbekistan Ukraine Georgia


This entry has been archived.
Comments are closed.

^ back to top ^

log in
Name:
Pass:

Register Forgot Your Password? My Account Re-send Confirmation (To log in, cookies must be enabled in your browser!)

► LGF Headlines

► Top 10 Comments

► Bottom Comments

► Recent Comments

► Tools/Info

► LGF Hits

► Slideshows

► Resources

► Never Forget

► Statistics

► Tag Cloud

► Contact

You must have Javascript enabled to use the contact form.
Your email:

Subject:

Message:


Messages may be published in our weblog, unless you request otherwise.
Tech Note:
Using the Contact Form

► News/Opinion

Finish Line- $10 off $60- 125 x 125
More Partners

Compare Electricity Prices in your area. Texas Electricity is deregulated; you have the right to choose Texas Electric Rates from among many Texas Electric Companies.

Don't indiscriminately go wild!


Books You Want 160x600
Barnes & Noble Home