LGF

 RetweetRussian Military Invades West Georgia

Mon, Aug 11, 2008 at 8:47:55 am PDT

A very dangerous situation is getting worse, as the Russian military moves into Georgia from the west while Georgian forces are engaged in South Ossetia.

TBILISI, Georgia - Russia opened a second front of fighting in Georgia on Monday, sending armored vehicles beyond two breakaway provinces and seizing a military base and police stations in the country’s west, officials said.

The new forays into Georgia — even after Georgian President Mikhail Saakashvili signed a cease-fire pledge — appeared to show Russian determination to subdue the small, U.S.-backed country, which has been pressing for NATO membership.

The latest developments indicate that Russian troops have invaded Georgia proper from the separatist province of Abkhazia while most Georgian forces are locked up in fighting around South Ossetia.

Meanwhile, the Russia Blog run by the anti-evolution Discovery Institute responds to my post pointing out that they support Russia’s assault on Georgia—by reaffirming their support for Russia’s assault on Georgia, in a post that reads like a press release from the Kremlin: Russia Blog: War in Georgia: Misreading Ossetia — Chronology Matters.

Advertisement

875 comments

  • Comments are open and unmoderated, and do not necessarily reflect the views of Little Green Footballs.
  • Obscene, abusive, silly, or annoying remarks may be deleted, but the fact that particular comments remain on the site in no way constitutes an endorsement of their views by Little Green Footballs.
  • Posts that contain phone numbers, street addresses, email addresses or other personal information will also be deleted, as will posts that consist only of a variation on the word, "First!"
  • Comments that advocate violence will be cause for immediate banning with no appeal.
  • Disagreement and debate are welcome, but insults and abuse are not, and may cause your account to be blocked.
  • REMEMBER: posting comments at LGF is a privilege, not a right. Abuse that privilege, and your account will be blocked.

Hide comments | Jump to bottom

1 victor_yugo  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 8:50:03am

I'd love to see the Disco Institute's "chronology" of John Edwards' lies.

2 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 8:50:05am
3 trailortrash  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 8:50:54am

they are poking us in the eyes

4 victor_yugo  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 8:51:22am

re: #2 taxfreekiller

We have put up with Russia long enough, all the dead in Vietnam are dead via Russia, all the ones in Iraq, via Iran, Russian doings.

Don't forget the Fwench.

5 Catttt  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 8:52:24am

Oh no. Bad made worse. But then, Russia is involved.

6 rawmuse  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 8:52:33am

This is a perfect time to elect as POTUS a crypto-Marxist! Oh, wait, no, it isn't.

7 jcm  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 8:53:02am

Georgia is a friend of the US.
Georgia is trying very hard to be representative democracy.
Russia has been escalating since Putin took power.

I think it's time to render aid to Georgian. Airlift of hardware and supplies, even air support.

I believe this is one of those times it is necessary to show our core values as a country mean something.

8 Kragar (Proud to be Kafir)  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 8:53:49am
The new forays into Georgia — even after Georgian President Mikhail Saakashvili signed a cease-fire pledge — appeared to show Russian determination to subdue the small, U.S.-backed country, which has been pressing for NATO membership.

No calls of War Crimes? Nothing from the UN or the ICC or any other group claims to care about international relations?

9 Crusader Rabbit  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 8:53:59am

I'd like to believe our administration will do anything about this besides bluster.

Alas I cannot, and another western democracy bites the dust.

10 Ben Hur  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 8:54:05am

re: #7 jcm

Georgia is a friend of the US.
Georgia is trying very hard to be representative democracy.
Russia has been escalating since Putin took power.

I think it's time to render aid to Georgian. Airlift of hardware and supplies, even air support.

I believe this is one of those times it is necessary to show our core values as a country mean something.

By doing nothing.

Not that I agree with doing nothing, but that is what we will do.

11 MrSilverDragon  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 8:55:37am

The Russians went down to Georgia,
they were looking for some land to steal...

Sorry, Charlie Daniels... I leave it up to someone else to complete because I just can't get the creative juices a-flowin'.

12 laZardo  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 8:55:48am

re: #8 Kragar (Proud to be Kafir)

Well, it is a U.S. backed country pressing for NATO membership (read satellite-puppet state that's oppressing South Ossetia like it was Palestine or something.)

/

13 scottishbuzzsaw  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 8:55:51am

re: #7 jcm

Georgia is a friend of the US.
Georgia is trying very hard to be representative democracy.
Russia has been escalating since Putin took power.

I think it's time to render aid to Georgian. Airlift of hardware and supplies, even air support.

I believe this is one of those times it is necessary to show our core values as a country mean something.

Agreed.

14 Kragar (Proud to be Kafir)  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 8:55:57am

re: #10 Ben Hur

By doing nothing.

Not that I agree with doing nothing, but that is what we will do.

Oh, we'll do something. Maybe we'll send a letter expressing concern and maybe a fact finding committee in a few months to see how bad it was.

15 blutonazi98  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 8:56:14am

Georgia is waiting for our help. they have been our friend and have giving treasure and lives to help us. will we help them?

this is a TRUE war for oil... how will the US respond.
are there any good options? this is getting scary.

16 Dirk Diggler  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 8:56:16am

Kragar,

The new forays into Georgia — even after Georgian President Mikhail Saakashvili signed a cease-fire pledge — appeared to show Russian determination to subdue the small, U.S.-backed country, which has been pressing for NATO membership.

No calls of War Crimes? Nothing from the UN or the ICC or any other group claims to care about international relations?

There's the dreaded "U.S. backed" label too.

17 Ben Hur  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 8:57:28am

It's all to get McCain elected.

See the spin-offs.

18 laZardo  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 8:57:35am

And on this facepalming moment of frustration, I shall head to bed. G'night.

19 yma o hyd  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 8:57:50am

'Chronology matters' - indeed it does, so does a proper definition of the 'species' one looks at. Isn't it amazing that according to Mr Armstrong South Ossetia is a proper republic - and not an integral part of Georgia?
I've linked this editorial comment from the TIMES/London
in a thread further down - it is Russia which is interfering in the internal affairs of Georgia, not Georgia attacking a poor, helpless nation ...

And as for chronology - yeah, right, as if Russia hadn't planned for this coup for quite a long time, as Lizards well versed in military matters have been pointing out already.

20 Ben Hur  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 8:57:53am

re: #16 Dirk Diggler

Kragar,


There's the dreaded "U.S. backed" label too.

That's the one thing worse than saying "Jew."

21 Dr. Shalit  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 8:58:11am

RUSSIA - fast becoming the nation that can't take YES for an answer.

-S-

22 jcm  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 8:58:18am

re: #10 Ben Hur

By doing nothing.

Not that I agree with doing nothing, but that is what we will do.

*spit*
You're probably right.
Rhineland '36.
Stop it now. or Stop it later.

23 Ben Hur  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 8:58:41am

What is the population of Russia?

I think Georgia's is 4 million.

So you could understand how this is a holocaust against Russia.

24 scottishbuzzsaw  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 8:58:44am

re: #16 Dirk Diggler

Kragar,


There's the dreaded "U.S. backed" label too.

It's showing up in many places/reports. Infuriating.

25 yma o hyd  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 8:58:56am

re: #8 Kragar (Proud to be Kafir)

No calls of War Crimes? Nothing from the UN or the ICC or any other group claims to care about international relations?

Yeah - interesting, innit - where is the condemnation from the UN?

26 Peacekeeper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 8:59:05am

Georgia's going to get hosed. Bush isn't going to do a damn thing.

27 Kosh's Shadow  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 8:59:13am

And Russia has been waging cyberwar against Georgia; the official Georgian government sites are redirected to servers in Russia and Turkey.
Cyberattacks knock out Georgia's Internet presence

"Many of Georgia's Internet servers were under external control from late Thursday," Armin said early Saturday in an entry on his Web site. According to his research, the government's sites dedicated to the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, the Ministry of Defense, and the country's president, Mikhail Saakashvili, have been blocked completely, or traffic to and from those sites' servers have been redirected to servers actually located in Russia and Turkey.
28 Kosh's Shadow  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:00:07am

re: #22 jcm

*spit*
You're probably right.
Rhineland '36.
Stop it now. or Stop it later.

Don't worry. Obama will negotiate "peace in our time".
/do I need to?

29 Salamantis  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:00:12am

This is an object lesson in why we cannot allow Iran to get nukes.

30 Ben Hur  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:00:16am

re: #24 scottishbuzzsaw

It's showing up in many places/reports. Infuriating.


Well, you know, the smarter than thou elitist journos who in reality know no more than you and I and were probably sent to Georgia after covering Broadway plays, want us to focus on the "Big Picture."

31 victor_yugo  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:00:22am

re: #25 yma o hyd

Yeah - interesting, innit - where is the condemnation from the UN?

Blocked by Russia's UNSC veto power.

32 blutonazi98  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:00:23am

Europe will do nothing, the Russian energy tit is too far down their throats. this could be the first step into regaining their superpower empire back.

those evil Jews... er Zionist also support Georgia.
will this get more attention than John Edwards?

i have many questions help me lizards

33 Dirk Diggler  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:00:34am

PK,

Georgia's going to get hosed. Bush isn't going to do a damn thing.

What would you propose he do?

34 ShumBaayaMyLord  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:00:58am

Is it bad form to wish simultaneous balinitis and multiple bleeding hemorrhoids on Vlad Putin?

35 Kosh's Shadow  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:01:03am

re: #25 yma o hyd

Yeah - interesting, innit - where is the condemnation from the UN?

They're too busy writing condemnations of Israel and the US in advance.
Either that, or they're still trying to blame this on Israel.

36 ducktrapper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:01:26am

So where are the useful idiots? They make a lot of noise if one poor Iraqi or Afghan gets caught in the crossfire but are strangely quiet as Russian forces bomb civilians in an outright manner.

37 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:01:33am

Iraq's Malika had better pick up the action because we're needed elsewhere by better friends, the eastern Georgians who really like us, enough to support Iraq's fight for freedom.

38 Ben Hur  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:01:43am

re: #33 Dirk Diggler

PK,


What would you propose he do?

Raise his voice a little.

And sit up straight when in an effen chair being interviewed.

And to stop looking at the ceiling when answering questions.

That would be a good start.

39 Nevergiveup  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:01:53am

Note to all other USA allies ( that means you also Israel ): You had better be able to defend your own interests. Kind words from the USA may be all you get in time!

40 itellu3times  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:03:40am

re: #7 jcm

It's already far too late.

I assume you think the US should do something, as opposed to say the rest of NATO. Maybe Turkey should send 50,000 troops to help Georgia? B-52 flights out of Batman, show the Russians what a few hundred Paveways look like up close? Maybe a barrage of cruise missiles, could be there in a few hours, but aimed at what? The Russian army may be clunky, but it's not the Taliban.

Any counter to Russia will have to be political and economic. They appear to be apeshit crazy. If this doesn't wake up the rest of NATO, well then.

41 Peacekeeper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:03:43am

re: #33 Dirk Diggler

Be persuasive.

42 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:03:52am

re: #36 ducktrapper

So where are the useful idiots? They make a lot of noise if one poor Iraqi or Afghan gets caught in the crossfire but are strangely quiet as Russian forces bomb civilians in an outright manner.

* * *
2,000 killed this weekend by Russia! Where's the outrage? Anyone hear reports of any jihadi catching a cold in Guantanamo?

43 blutonazi98  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:04:39am

the US is Flying Georgian troops home. Could Russia interpret this as action by the US against them?

44 jcm  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:04:44am

In this kind of conflict a SEAL team on the ground and a B-2 orbiting loaded with 80 JDAMs better yet JSOWs would make a significant difference.

45 Crusader Rabbit  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:04:46am

re: #31 victor_yugo

as though we needed more evidence that the UN is at best useless.

46 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:05:13am

re: #43 blutonazi98

the US is Flying Georgian troops home. Could Russia interpret this as action by the US against them?

* * *
They already have said something to that effect.

47 yma o hyd  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:05:13am

re: #17 Ben Hur

It's all to get McCain elected.

See the spin-offs.

A-ma-zing!
What blithering idiots are posting at Huffpo - that one takes the biscuit!

49 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:06:21am
50 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:06:29am

Drill here, drill now is more important than ever, for us & Europe whose gas & oil supply is controlled by Russia.

51 Honorary Yooper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:07:23am

re: #43 blutonazi98

the US is Flying Georgian troops home. Could Russia interpret this as action by the US against them?

Putin's already said that it is interpreted as US action against Russia.

52 yma o hyd  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:07:29am

re: #35 Kosh's Shadow

They're too busy writing condemnations of Israel and the US in advance.
Either that, or they're still trying to blame this on Israel.

Yeah - of course Israel is guilty, after all, they did send some weapons, didn't they ...

///

53 MandyManners  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:07:41am
54 Fenboy  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:07:56am

Can we call it an invasion yet?

/sarc

55 bosforus  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:07:59am

re: #36 ducktrapper

So where are the useful idiots? They make a lot of noise if one poor Iraqi or Afghan gets caught in the crossfire but are strangely quiet as Russian forces bomb civilians in an outright manner.

If they can pin the dubya to it, it doesn't matter.

56 Dirk Diggler  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:08:13am

U.S.-Backed Ben Hur,

President Bush has been lousy with the press for seven and a half years. I doubt that is likely to change over the next six months.

When it comes to Georgia, good options are simply non-existent.

57 bosforus  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:08:47am

re: #55 bosforus

If they can pin the dubya to it, it doesn't matter.

Oops...

if they can't pin the dubya to it, it doesn't matter


PIMF

58 Fenboy  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:08:48am

re: #55 bosforus

Plus, they see Sakashvilli as an American ally, i.e. an enemy.

59 wiffersnapper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:08:51am

seems kind of fitting right now:

Blix: I'm sorry, but the UN must be firm with you! Let' me see your whole palace, or else!
Kim: Or erse, what?
Blix: Or else we will be very, very angry with you, and we will write you a letter telling you how angry we are.

60 MandyManners  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:09:01am

FNC says Gori is under Russian control. Forty miles from Tblisi.

61 Kenneth  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:09:28am

re: #43 blutonazi98

the US is Flying Georgian troops home. Could Russia interpret this as action by the US against them?

That is indeed the message the US is sending.

62 jcm  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:09:30am

re: #51 Honorary Yooper

Putin's already said that it is interpreted as US action against Russia.

If a Soviet (looks like the Soviets are back) fighter takes a shot at one...
New ball game.

63 MandyManners  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:10:08am

I never say "G-d" but, I just thought it.

64 yma o hyd  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:10:20am

re: #48 MandyManners

Russian forces are in control of Zugdidi, a town on the Georgian side of the Abkhaz ceasefire line, the Georgian authorities said.

SNIP

The residents left yesterday.

From that link:
"Zugdidi is within the 12-km security zone – a buffer zone between the Georgian and Abkhaz sides – which is monitored by the Russian peacekeeping troops stationed there under the CIS aegis."

Easy, innit, if you're 'peace-keeping' in a 'buffer zone' ...

65 itellu3times  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:10:22am

re: #60 MandyManners

FNC says Gori is under Russian control. Forty miles from Tblisi.

Belmont Club was saying yesterday Gori is the military control point for the rest of the country. IOW, it's over.

66 Iron Fist[deleted]  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:10:36am
67 victor_yugo  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:10:43am

re: #59 wiffersnapper

seems kind of fitting right now:

Blix: I'm sorry, but the UN must be firm with you! Let' me see your whole palace, or else!
Kim: Or erse, what?
Blix: Or else we will be very, very angry with you, and we will write you a letter telling you how angry we are.

Putin is so ronery.

He arways rooks so ronery...

68 Dirk Diggler  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:10:43am

jcm,

If a Soviet (looks like the Soviets are back) fighter takes a shot at one...
New ball game.

I'm generally opposed to the U.S. getting involved in this conflict, but I fully agree with that.

69 trailortrash  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:10:54am

they are in control of gori now...

70 Peacekeeper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:10:54am

re: #56 Dirk Diggler

When it comes to Georgia, good options are simply non-existent.

That's the spirit...

71 Nevergiveup  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:11:16am

re: #53 MandyManners

Map.

[Link: www.aboutgeorgia.net...]

Russia apparently has taken the town of Gori, which is only about 100 miles from the capital of Tbilisi. It now appears Russia intends to essentially over throw the duly elected government of Georgia, and install a puppet government.

72 lawhawk  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:11:30am

re: #8 Kragar (Proud to be Kafir)

No calls of War Crimes? Nothing from the UN or the ICC or any other group claims to care about international relations?

No, it's the Russians and their South Ossetian propagandists who say that the Georgians are the ones engaging in ethnic cleansing and genocide.

73 J.S.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:11:37am

re: #42 alegrias

2,000 killed -- according to Russia, it was done by Georgians murdering their own civilians...and, according to the BBC -- those are Russian "peacekeepers" (yeah, that's right -- going in with the tanks and aerially bombing apartment buildings -- but, hey, the BBC says it's all due to the aggression of Georgians...) (This all reminds me of the dark days of the KGB and Kremlin's "truth" -- along with media outlets in Europe and elsewhere backing up/endorsing the Russian lies.)

74 astronmr20  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:11:45am

/ is anyone else having trouble submitting links? I cannot access any of the fields after clicking submit a link.

Running Safari 3.1.2

75 Dustoff-507  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:12:01am

Reuters is at it again.


[Link: russia-insider.livejournal.com...]

76 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:12:08am
77 itellu3times  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:12:31am

re: #66 Iron Fist

Russia isn't the Big Dog she used to be. Her navy is drastically smaller, and her air force hasn't kept up with ours. Our troops are better trained and better motivated. A nuclear exchange would be crazy, and whatever else you may say about him, Putin isn't crazy. He's pushing to see how far we'll let him go.

What is this *we*, does anyone propose the US take on Russia about this, without the rest of NATO also clammoring for action?

78 Fenboy  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:12:38am

re: #75 Dustoff-507

Reuters? Never heard of it. Perhaps you mean al-Reuters?

;)

79 Cato  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:13:02am

Apparently, from what I have read, Georgia was stupid in trying to militarily do something (what it is is confusing) is SO. However, now it looks as if Russia will use the opportunity to take back control over a sovereign nation in an attempt to replicate the USSR, only this time under a non-idealogical thugocracy.

80 Peacekeeper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:13:06am

Part of the President's job is to have options ready when crises erupt.

81 Dirk Diggler  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:13:29am
DD: When it comes to Georgia, good options are simply non-existent.


PK:
That's the spirit...

So the U.S. should pursue "bad options" in Georgia?

82 Ackomanyuki  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:13:30am

...so this is how Russia shows us gratitude for Bill Clinton giving the Russian Mafia start up funding in the form of nuclear disarmament finacial assitance and loaning out our NRO assests during the razing of Grozny.

83 realwest  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:13:42am

Partial repost from the DT:

Please remember that Mother Russia ISN'T as strong militarily as it used to be when it was part of the Soviet Union - and they have NOT kept up the necessary maintenance on their weapons systems, particularly air force and navy and are WAAAY short on qualified pilots - and it wouldn't just be Russia vs. U.S.; it would be Russia vs. U.S., Georgia, Urkrain, Poland and all of what used to be the "Eastern Bloc" of the Soviet Empire. But even just Russia vs the U.S. and Georgia, Russia loses.
I think, if the US had the balls to do the right thing here and truly support our ally, Putin would be screwed.
And if we don't do the right thing here, ultimately Israel is screwed. And maybe South Korea and Taiwan.

84 Abu Al-Poopypants  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:13:43am

I wonder if Dubya told Putin to pull his troops out of Georgia and to keep his damned hands off Alabama, too?

85 Honorary Yooper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:13:53am

re: #79 Cato

Czar Vladimir I.

86 itellu3times  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:13:56am

And of course the UN - is blocked by Russia's veto in the security council.

87 MandyManners  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:14:04am

Links here.

Georgian Forces Hold Defensive Positions in South of Conflict Zone ...
Civil Georgia, Georgia - 54 minutes ago
Georgian forces are continuing to reinforce and maintain defensive positions in the south of the South Ossetian conflict zone, despite heavy artillery fire, ...

Georgia Claims Shooting Down Russian Jet
Civil Georgia, Georgia - 57 minutes ago
Georgian said its air defense system shot down one Russian aircraft after it flew over Gori at the time when President Saakashvili was visiting Gori ...

Georgia Agrees to European-Brokered Ceasefire
Civil Georgia, Georgia - 1 hour ago
President Saakashvili said on August 11 he had signed a ceasefire deal proposed by senior European envoys. French and Finnish Foreign Ministers Bernard ...

Overnight Air Strikes Across Georgia
Civil Georgia, Georgia - 1 hour ago
The Russian air forces carried out series of strikes mainly on military installation across Georgia. Sound of two powerful explosions was heard in Tbilisi ...

Russian Forces in Zugdidi
Civil Georgia, Georgia - 1 hour ago
Russian forces are in control of Zugdidi, a town on the Georgian side of the Abkhaz ceasefire line, the Georgian authorities said. ...

88 FrogMarch  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:14:19am

What's sickening is the world is just standing by and watching. Come on Europe - do something!

89 Dustoff-507  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:14:25am

re: #78 Fenboy

LOL, that too... but this is in Russia, so what name do we use now?

90 Nevergiveup  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:14:30am

re: #81 Dirk Diggler

So the U.S. should pursue "bad options" in Georgia?

No. We should now pursue "good" options in Cuba and Venezuela!

91 yma o hyd  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:14:49am

The Russians have now entered Zenaki - deep into Georgia - scroll down to the bottom to see the map ...

92 Kenneth  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:15:09am

re: #64 yma o hyd

From that link:
"Zugdidi is within the 12-km security zone – a buffer zone between the Georgian and Abkhaz sides – which is monitored by the Russian peacekeeping troops stationed there under the CIS aegis."

These "Russian peacekeeping troops" are not recognized as legitimate by the Georgian gov't or even by the UN. They are a covert colonial garrison force.

93 jcm  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:15:11am

re: #68 Dirk Diggler

jcm,

I'm generally opposed to the U.S. getting involved in this conflict, but I fully agree with that.

I can understand that.
Here's how I look at it. Russian has been moving back into Soviet habits since Putin took power. Georgia is a friend and a burgeoning democracy.
The parallels to Rhineland '36 are many. IMHO it's a pay now or pay later.

A short sharp conflict, showing the Russians where the line is. Or another 50 years of cold war with a heightened possibility of it going hot.

94 victor_yugo  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:15:26am

re: #88 FrogMarch

What's sickening is the world is just standing by and watching. Come on Europe - do something!

And lose all that cheap fuel?

95 Ackomanyuki  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:15:28am

PIMF and Spellcheck, clumsy fingers...so this is how Russia shows us gratitude for Bill Clinton giving the Russian Mafia start up funding in the form of nuclear disarmament financial assistance and loaning out our NRO assists during the razing of Grozny.

96 CIA Reject  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:15:30am

re: #80 Peacekeeper

Part of the President's job is to have options ready when crises erupt.

It seems to me that this President has been consistently ill-served by the people who are supposed to provide him with those options.

97 realwest  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:15:48am

re: #90 Nevergiveup
Yes AND the US DOES have good options in Georgia.
But we're running out of time to use them.

98 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:16:03am
99 J.S.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:16:18am

re: #93 jcm

I agree with the revertin' of Russia...(and don't forget about the oil, and that pipeline in Georgia).

100 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:16:25am

re: #66 Iron Fist

Russia isn't the Big Dog she used to be. Her navy is drastically smaller, and her air force hasn't kept up with ours. Our troops are better trained and better motivated. A nuclear exchange would be crazy, and whatever else you may say about him, Putin isn't crazy. He's pushing to see how far we'll let him go.

I say we don't let him go very far.

* * *
Russia controls energy supplies to Europe & pumps its own oil.

They have "strategic" weapons which SILENCE their clients. Have you heard a peep from anyone besides us?

101 itellu3times  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:16:29am

re: #93 jcm

And what does our Russia-expert secretary of state say? Wear is she?

102 Dustoff-507  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:16:30am

re: #88 FrogMarch


Hell the Eu can't even change their own diapers!

103 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:16:35am

re: #94 victor_yugo

Putin has Europe exactly where he wants them.

104 gibsonz  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:16:36am

Time for the Messiah to come to the rescue, he can carpet bomb Moscow in his Cessna 182 with leaflets of love and compassion, change and hope will be the answer to this crisis!

105 Ackomanyuki  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:16:44am

Damn...did it again...assets not assists

106 itellu3times  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:16:48am

re: #101 itellu3times

Where is she?

107 jcm  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:17:09am

re: #97 realwest

Yes AND the US DOES have good options in Georgia.
But we're running out of time to use them.

Once Russian is entrenched it's over for all tense and purposes.

108 yma o hyd  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:17:15am

re: #92 Kenneth

These "Russian peacekeeping troops" are not recognized as legitimate by the Georgian gov't or even by the UN. They are a covert colonial garrison force.

Ah - but 'peace-keeping forces' sounds sooo much nicer to Western ears - especially those in the MSM ...

109 Peacekeeper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:17:23am

re: #81 Dirk Diggler

So the U.S. should pursue "bad options" in Georgia?

What I fault Bush for is not being prepared for this, for looking like a kid caught chewing gum in class. His administration led Georgia down a path that brought them into a war with Russia. They apparently believed we would back them.

Somebody should have told the Georgians months if not years ago that if the push comes to shove we won't be starting a war with Russi to save them.

We screwed those people almost as bad as if we were dropping the bombs ourselves.

110 rawmuse  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:17:28am

re: #90 Nevergiveup

No. We should now pursue "good" options in Cuba and Venezuela!

Hell, I have been for overthrowing the commies in Cuba since I was old enough to form a reasonable opinion, if for no other reason than the supply lines would be shorter. I'm good to go right now, really. Let's mount up.

111 itellu3times  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:17:31am

re: #104 gibsonz

Time for the Messiah to come to the rescue, he can carpet bomb Moscow in his Cessna 182 with leaflets of love and compassion, change and hope will be the answer to this crisis!

He can bring the dead back to life, and unexplode the bombs.

112 Iron Fist[deleted]  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:17:50am
113 victor_yugo  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:17:55am

re: #104 gibsonz

Time for the Messiah to come to the rescue, he can carpet bomb Moscow in his Cessna 182 with leaflets of love and compassion, change and hope will be the answer to this crisis!

Irradiate the leaflets first. ("Weaponized leaflets"?)

114 Kenneth  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:17:56am

re: #104 gibsonz

Time for the Messiah to come to the rescue, he can carpet bomb Moscow in his Cessna 182 with leaflets of love and compassion, change and hope will be the answer to this crisis!

Didn't Obama have a uncle or maybe a great aunt who helped liberate Stalingrad? I think I heard that...

115 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:18:23am

re: #73 J.S.

2,000 killed -- according to Russia, it was done by Georgians murdering their own civilians...and, according to the BBC -- those are Russian "peacekeepers" (yeah, that's right -- going in with the tanks and aerially bombing apartment buildings -- but, hey, the BBC says it's all due to the aggression of Georgians...) (This all reminds me of the dark days of the KGB and Kremlin's "truth" -- along with media outlets in Europe and elsewhere backing up/endorsing the Russian lies.)

* * *
It's obscene non-reporting, they've got their "best" reporters stationed at GITMO in case a jihadi sneezes and we don't jump to provide a tissue.

116 Opinionated  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:18:31am

Last week Georgia was a US ally that supplied troops in Iraq.

Next week Georgia will be a Soviet Russian ally.

Accepting that fact, the impotent State Dept will then move on to what it does best and only- criticise and delegitimize Israel.

117 Kenneth  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:18:31am

re: #108 yma o hyd

Ah - but 'peace-keeping forces' sounds sooo much nicer to Western ears - especially those in the MSM ...

Russia keeps alive the Orwellian language of the USSR.

118 Cap'n DOC  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:18:49am

re: #2 taxfreekiller

I updinged that one in error. My information indicates Chinese backing in VN, not Russia. Where did you get that information?

119 MandyManners  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:18:54am

Gotta' go. Can't stand this. Must finish shopping for school supplies. Am thinking about filling up car. Where are pronouns?

120 Fenboy  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:19:10am

re: #114 Kenneth

It was Auschwitz IIRC, which still led to all us lizards mocking him for claiming having a relative in the Red Army.

121 jcm  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:19:26am

re: #101 itellu3times

And what does our Russia-expert secretary of state say? Wear is she?

The U.S. is continuing to try to find a diplomatic solution to the fighting between Russia and Georgia. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice made 50 calls over the weekend, her spokesman said, and this morning the U.S. is again calling for the Russians to stand down and accept a ceasefire.

I thinks it a bit past diplomacy.

122 Catttt  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:19:27am

OT - AWESOME QUOTE:

When I flipped at the 50, and saw how far ahead he was, knowing he was the world record holder, for a split second a thought crossed my mind: There is no way. But I said 'You know what? This is ridiculous. This is the Olympics and I'm here for the United States of America. I don't care how bad it hurts.' Honestly, in like five seconds, I was thinking all these things. I just got like a super charge and just took it from there. It was unreal. - Jason Lezak.

123 JohnnyReb  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:19:37am

Didn't Georgia have nukes there in the old days? I am thinking they might have just kept a few after the collapse.

124 realwest  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:19:51am

re: #100 alegrias Well the Ukraine has said it will not allow the Russian Naval Squadron back into it's bases in the Black Sea.
But I think - in reality - most of the World is waiting to see what the U.S. does or doesn't do before jumping in or staying silent.
We are, after all, supposed to be the leader of the Free World. Sure wish we'd act like it.

125 jcm  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:20:14am

re: #112 Iron Fist

If necessary. If we don't stop Russia here, where will we stop her? Another war in Europe? Or do we tell the French it's been nice knowing them, but we're not helping out this Century?

'zactly.

126 Fenboy  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:20:30am

re: #123 JohnnyReb

Doubtful, the post-Soviet president was very pro-Russian, which is why Sakashvilli was such a big deal.

127 Kenneth  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:20:52am

re: #120 Fenboy

Yes, I know. I was referring to that and making fun of the Anointed One.

128 jcm  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:21:00am

re: #123 JohnnyReb

Didn't Georgia have nukes there in the old days? I am thinking they might have just kept a few after the collapse.

Doubtful, Russia took all them when it pulled out.

129 BakiShamil  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:21:07am

Scumbags russians and their hatred towards kavkazkie people. Kavkazkie people get second class treatment in moscow.

All my support with Georgia people

130 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:21:21am
Independent for three years (1918-1921) following the Russian revolution, Georgia was forcibly incorporated into the USSR until the Soviet Union dissolved in 1991. As part of its Soviet legacy, Georgia possesses a decommissioned nuclear reactor and three nuclear research institutes, as well as a number of military bases contaminated with radioactive waste. Nonproliferation issues concerning Georgia stem primarily from the area of export controls. Georgia does not possess or produce nuclear, chemical, or biological weapons, but the country's industrial and medical sectors use components that could also be used in WMD systems.


[Link: www.nti.org...]

131 DeafDog  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:21:31am

re: #122 Cattt

That is a great quote and that was an awesome race!

132 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:22:21am
133 Ben Hur  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:22:35am

Ribbons!

We should all wear ribbons!

It's working in Darfur!

And shirts!

T-shirts that we'll wear to premieres!

134 trailortrash  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:22:42am

re: #110 rawmuse

Hell, I have been for overthrowing the commies in Cuba since I was old enough to form a reasonable opinion, if for no other reason than the supply lines would be shorter. I'm good to go right now, really. Let's mount up.

i put my dog tags back on 2 days ago, they havent been out of reach since 1991...

135 Kenneth  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:22:58am

re: #129 BakiShamil

Hello, where are you posting from?

136 Fenboy  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:23:21am

re: #127 Kenneth

You dare make with the fun of His Holiness, scion of the Prophet Jeremiah, blessed by the Prophet Algore of Nobel and Oscar? He who will cause the oceans to fall?

I KEEEL YOOUU!

/hehe

137 experiencedtraveller  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:23:24am

What about our friends the Turks?

They have a long history of fighting Russians in the Caucuses...

138 rawmuse  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:23:28am

We find ourselves in a bad position because we are
a) in hock up to our eyeballs (last count was just under half a mil per US household) to the
b) Chinese, who are largely financing that debt (and don't think that doesn't have strings attached) and
c) we are presently deployed on two fronts, and one of those is not exactly going according to the script.

139 Ben Hur  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:23:44am

kavkazkie = causcuses.

140 DeafDog  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:23:44am

re: #133 Ben Hur

Where's Batman George Clooney! He'll know what to do!

141 jcm  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:24:14am

re: #124 realwest

Well the Ukraine has said it will not allow the Russian Naval Squadron back into it's bases in the Black Sea.
But I think - in reality - most of the World is waiting to see what the U.S. does or doesn't do before jumping in or staying silent.
We are, after all, supposed to be the leader of the Free World. Sure wish we'd act like it.

A few FA-18E/F's with a load of AGM-154B JSOW anti-armor weapons would go a long way.

142 Kenneth  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:24:14am

re: #137 experiencedtraveller

The Turkish gov't has issued a statement in support of the Georgians.

143 Right Brain  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:24:27am

Thank God Georgia is not yet in NATO, it almost is.

Not good.

Sorry to be divisive Obama, but you better take a hike.

144 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:24:33am

re: #140 DeafDog

Where's Batman George Clooney! He'll know what to do!

Please. The correct spelling is George C. Looney.
Thank you.

145 J.S.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:25:02am

re: #109 Peacekeeper

I would also suggest that's it not just the U.S. not coming to Georgia's aid -- it's NATO. NATO has no desire, no interest in aiding (militarily) Georgia. (There's some talk about removing Russia from the G-8 -- that's about it...)

146 itellu3times  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:25:05am

re: #112 Iron Fist

If necessary. If we don't stop Russia here, where will we stop her? Another war in Europe? Or do we tell the French it's been nice knowing them, but we're not helping out this Century?

We could not beat Russia alone, on their ground. Not to mention the temptation of one side or the other to go nuclear.

I mean, the rest of NATO would deny us landing and air rights, no ports, etc.

Have to be realistic.

This is as ugly an event as the world has seen since WWII. The parellels with the Rhineland may be just too accurate. Or with Sarajevo.

The silence on the morning news was eerie.

Frankly, I'm not sure even Bush is up to this kind of challenge.

Putin wins this one. We need to look ahead.

147 Kenneth  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:25:59am

re: #143 Right Brain

On the contrary. If Georgia was in NATO, Russia never would have pulled this. The whole point of Russia's strategy is to keep NATO out of Georgia.

148 Fenboy  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:26:06am

re: #142 Kenneth

Interesting, the Turks have one of the most powerful militaries in NATO (other than the US, natch). I'm sure they can't be happy with Russian imperialism on their doorstep.

149 yma o hyd  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:26:10am

And I'm sick fo the unreflected, fence-sitting, 'give-everybody-a-voice-regardless' reporting in the MSM>
Look at this:
"Fighting also continued in South Ossetia, with local officials accusing Georgia of bombing targets in the capital, Tskhinvali, by helicopter."
(From the Beeb report I linked further up this thread).

Didn't the reports from the Ossetians say that Tskhinvili 'doesn't exist any more', yesterday?
So how come there are still 'targets'?

Are there no reportes who ask themselves such questions? Does their memory not go back further than 6 hours? HAve they never heard of archives, or been taught how to use them?

Disgusting!

150 Peacekeeper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:26:45am

re: #145 J.S.

If the US doesn't provide leadership, nobody in NATO will.

151 Nevergiveup  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:26:45am

In war civilians get hurt – like in Gaza'
Russian Chargé D’affaires in Tel Aviv sits down with Ynet to explain his country's military objectives in Georgia: 'We're only there to push the Georgian army out of the region. We have no plans to annex South Ossetia.' As for civilian casualties, says Dr. Yurkov, 'sometimes civilians get hurt in war, just like in Israeli operations in Gaza'
Dana Zimmerman
Published: 08.11.08, 18:54 / Israel News
"Russia will halt its military operation once the Georgians are pushed out of South Ossetia," the Russian Embassy's Chargé D’affaires in Tel Aviv, Dr. Anatoly Yurkov told Ynet on Monday afternoon.

"Russia has no interest in taking over South Ossetia – and certainly none in invading Georgia-proper," Yurkov said, adding that Russia
Advertisement


had not prepared for a military conflict of any sort with Georgia, and was forcibly dragged into one.

[Link: www.ynetnews.com...]

Hum. I hope the Russians remember people get hurt in war next time Israel has to go to war. And I guess they don't count GORI as part of Georgia anymore?

152 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:26:46am

re: #138 rawmuse

We find ourselves in a bad position because we are
a) in hock up to our eyeballs (last count was just under half a mil per US household) to the
b) Chinese, who are largely financing that debt (and don't think that doesn't have strings attached) and
c) we are presently deployed on two fronts, and one of those is not exactly going according to the script.

* * *
We were in much worse position when someone invaded Poland back in 1939.

We're wrapping things up in Iraq & we ought to pivot and assist Georia.

Tell Maliki to step it up, take out the Iraqi checkbook & quit playing footsie with Iran.

153 Fenboy  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:27:15am

re: #149 yma o hyd

It's classic BBC reporting, lies coated with implication.

154 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:27:17am
155 Peacekeeper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:27:18am

At least maybe the Europeans are getting a reminder of why the US Army is still over there.

156 Kenneth  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:27:35am

re: #148 Fenboy

I read a report the Turks have sent a warship to "visit" the Georgian port. The purpose would be a subtle hint to Russia to bugger off.

157 realwest  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:27:39am

re: #107 jcm I don't know if I'd agree with you on that either, my friend.
Russia's supply lines are really stretched very thin right now and there are, iirc, only THREE roadways through the mountains into Georgia. Dustoff-057 has reported on the DT that the US has in fact armed Georgian troops with our latest anti-tank missiles (shoulder fired) - seems to me that Georgia all by itself could close those roads.
And, again - at the risk of being repetitive - should the US WANT TO, the US could control the skies over Georgia for just about as long as it wanted/needed to.
And I'd shudder to think what the A-10 Warthogs could do to the Russian Armor and mechanized infantry, especially when said A-10's are protected by either the F-16 SuperHornets or the F-22 Raptors (which, iirc, could be in Iraq within less than 12 hours if we wanted to bring 'em in).

This WAR is really between Russia and the U.S. and it's not really over Georgia - it's over whether or not the U.S. will keep it's word to it's allies, like Georgia, ISRAEL, South Korean and Taiwan. It is a test of wills and I regrettably don't see the will on the U.S. part, just words.

158 Sifty  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:28:33am

The Rainbow Hope Change Machine will blow a gasket on this one.

Obama is surely conferring with Pooh and the rest of his cabinet on this sensitive issue.

What would Pooh do?

B-Ho: Can we surrender to the Russians?
Pooh: We aren't at war with Russia.
B-Ho: Surrender anyway, maybe we can save Atlanta for Freaknik.

159 steveeas  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:28:42am

Now, I can say "Look! It's a Caucasian war!"

160 trailortrash  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:29:02am

re: #159 steveeas

omg racist

161 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:29:09am

re: #155 Peacekeeper

At least maybe the Europeans are getting a reminder of why the US Army is still over there.

If only.

162 itellu3times  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:29:13am

re: #157 realwest

Even supplying the Georgians with US weapons would escalate this ridiculously. Face it, they are far too small to stand on their own.

163 victor_yugo  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:29:31am

re: #140 DeafDog

Where's Batman George Clooney! He'll know what to do!

Batman got the crap beat out of him.

164 itellu3times  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:29:50am

re: #162 itellu3times

I should have added, pointlessly.

165 Ben Hur  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:30:00am

So, which Euro leader will be the first to swallow their pride and call us?

166 itellu3times  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:30:33am

re: #165 Ben Hur

So, which Euro leader will be the first to swallow their pride and call us?

They're all on vacation, or at the Olympics. They won't hear about it for weeks.

167 Jouth  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:30:42am

PRC is going to grab Russia far east! !

168 yma o hyd  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:30:48am

re: #153 Fenboy

It's classic BBC reporting, lies coated with implication.

I know - the Beeb has been totally taken over by NuLabs LLL.
It used to be reliable and impartial - not any more.

Good thing we don't need the MSM to get our information!

169 Fenboy  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:30:50am

re: #161 J.D.

Yeah, its amazing to watch really, in Europe we've chased the barbarians over the horizon, and now we're convinced that barbarians don't exist, never existed, and were just made up by our own 'warmongering' right, even as we invite the barbarians back into our homes.

Its a funny old world, huh?

170 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:30:52am

re: #165 Ben Hur

So, which Euro leader will be the first to swallow their pride and call us?

I'm guessin' -0-.

171 J.S.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:30:54am

re: #150 Peacekeeper

the U.S. has urged the NATO forces to do X, Y, and Z (and it's been consistent -- NATO doesn't budge...or when NATO finally gets around to doing something, as per a U.S. request, it's months and months later...)

172 abolitionist  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:30:58am

re: #137 experiencedtraveller

What about our friends the Turks?

They have a long history of fighting Russians in the Caucuses...

From the cyberwar component of this conflict, I'm not confident Turkey can be counted as a friend of the US. Please note:

re: #27 Kosh's Shadow

And Russia has been waging cyberwar against Georgia; the official Georgian government sites are redirected to servers in Russia and Turkey.
Cyberattacks knock out Georgia's Internet presence

173 Sifty  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:31:00am

Let's ask the Russians to please stop when they get to the Chunnel..

174 realwest  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:31:08am

re: #118 Cap'n DOC
Hey Cap'n! Russia was the major supplier of the VC and the North Vietnamese Army - Vietnam has been at war with China for over 1000 years.
It was the Soviet ships in Haiphong Harbor that LBJ and then Nixon were worried about hitting with bombing runs over North Vietnam.

175 trailortrash  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:31:15am

russia sure did have alot of stuff ready for this operation...

176 itellu3times  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:31:29am

This is all Rush Limbaugh's fault, he took the day off.

177 Iron Fist[deleted]  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:32:27am
178 Kenneth  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:32:55am

re: #157 realwest

I don't think the US would send in an A-10. But the Georgian special forces could, if they have enough Javelins, destroy the Russian armor. The only catch is Russian air superiority. The Georgians are calling for a ceasefire right now, which is a wise strategy. They longer this drags out, the worse it will be on the Russians. They've sent an armored division, with a long vulnerable tail, across a mountain range. If they're not gone soon it's going to be a lousy winter for the Russians in Georgia.

179 jester6  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:33:03am

re: #100 alegrias

* * *
Russia controls energy supplies to Europe & pumps its own oil.

They have "strategic" weapons which SILENCE their clients. Have you heard a peep from anyone besides us?

You are spot on. Just look at what Putin has been doing for the last few years. He was getting ready to play the new game. It's all about energy baby.

180 Abu Al-Poopypants  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:33:31am

re: #165 Ben Hur

So, which Euro leader will be the first to swallow their pride and call us?


That one who spoke to 200,000 in Tiergarten Park in Berlin a few weeks ago? That famous celebrity guy -- name escapes me.

181 yma o hyd  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:33:38am

re: #169 Fenboy

Yeah, its amazing to watch really, in Europe we've chased the barbarians over the horizon, and now we're convinced that barbarians don't exist, never existed, and were just made up by our own 'warmongering' right, even as we invite the barbarians back into our homes.

Its a funny old world, huh?

Heh - you forgot that there are a lot of people in Europe who are trying their best to convince us that we actually are the barbarians ...

182 Dianna  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:33:49am

Is anyone else suffering weirdness when clicking "new comments"? I've frozen three times.

183 Sizzlack  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:34:09am

The tin foil is completely on for this one at Daily Kos:

Is Georgia Being Staged to Raise Gas Prices?

184 Ayatollah Ghilmeini  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:34:17am

Stalin-Brezhnev-Putin

The invasion of Georgia is pure Soviet style aggression. Putin is the real man in power in Russia. This is his war. Just Afghanistan brought future disasters to the world, so will Putin's war crime- Georgia's sin was their democratic existence. Putin had the army ready and struck while the world's eyes were on Beijing.

If the US government spotted the military buildup in Russia they did not appear to warn the Georgians or anyone else of the danger. Ralph Peter's observation that the Russian Army could never react this fast and be ready with fully working tanks in position to invade Georgia is spot on- this was planned aggression from the get go. Putin provoked the Georgians into invading and then dropped the hammer.

Bush should declare a no fly zone for Russian aircraft over Georgia- by sending enough stinger missiles to make any Russian plane below 5,000 feet dead meat. He should send the Russian delegation to the US home from the US until the Russians pull out AND announce that the US is ordering all Swiss banks to freeze all Russian nationals' funds pending clearance from Interpol that the money is not the property of the Russian people (this is called a kick in the nuts).

Announce the US is prepared to reinstitute the Jackson-Vanik laws, the very technology and economic sanctions that crippled and helped bring down the USSR and that we will ensure that the entire western world puts in place the same measures.

Inform Putin that Russian shipments of oil and gas to Europe will be required Russian to pay NATO security fee for ensuring the safe transit of their shipments. In addition, payments to Russian companies will require that the directors and owners of those companies pass a criminal background check.

Demand hand over of the suspects of the Livornenko murder in London.

Demand that the UK appoints the head and majority of the board of BP-Gazprom.

Vladimir Putin has some very dangerous and wrongheaded ideas of his power and position. A nicely administered pimp-slap (this is a French term of diplomacy similar to cordone sanitaire). Russia lost one cold war and fast on their way to losing another.

185 bosforus  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:34:20am

OT
Is this photo of Obama supposed to make him look insightful or confused?
[Link: www.gallup.com...]

186 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:34:31am

re: #182 Dianna

Is anyone else suffering weirdness when clicking "new comments"? I've frozen three times.

Not me. IE7, WinXP.

187 realwest  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:34:36am

re: #142 Kenneth That's GREAT NEWS Kenneth - do you have a link for it?

188 Sifty  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:34:41am

the CIA missed 180,000 Soviet troops massing on the border with Afghanistan a few years back.

looks like they blew another call.

Chinese landing craft will be coming on shore in Hermosa Beach before we get warning at this rate.

189 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:35:02am

re: #169 Fenboy

Yeah, its amazing to watch really, in Europe we've chased the barbarians over the horizon, and now we're convinced that barbarians don't exist, never existed, and were just made up by our own 'warmongering' right, even as we invite the barbarians back into our homes.

Its a funny old world, huh?

True. It is.

...If you want to put it in perspective, it's like we're the guy who ended up being the designated driver for the planet. Sure, we'd love to sit back and drink ourselves into a stupor with the rest of the globe but we're responsible for getting as many people home safe and sound as possible. Ever so often while we're sitting around wishing we could kill a few beers like the rest of the planet, a sloppy drunk, drooling Europe comes over to where we're sitting. Then they take another swig of Vodka straight out of the bottle and tell us not to worry about a thing because they'll drive everyone home in their "international law" van. But we know if we go ahead and drink up, we'll just get a call at 4 A.M. asking us to bring our tow truck and the "jaws of life" to clean up the bloody mess on dead man's curve. That's the burden of being an American. ...


Confessions Of An Isolationist Wannabe

190 Dustoff-507  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:35:06am

re: #162 itellu3times


True, but they could be a major pain in Puttins backside. (if we gave them what the need to fight back)

191 FrogMarch  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:35:16am

re: #183 Sizzlack

The tin foil is completely on for this one at Daily Kos:

Is Georgia Being Staged to Raise Gas Prices?

The left is staggeringly cluesless about all matters.

192 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:35:42am
193 Clio  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:36:02am

There is a parallel situation a lot farther back than the 1930s.

Plataea -- fifth century BCE.

194 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:36:11am
195 JHW  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:36:19am

Watch Ukraine very, very closely. This out of a Ukrainian source, no confirmation, but notice who claimed the shoot-down happened.Start of a new propaganda offensive? Or the 24 hour rule? your guess is as good as mine.

KIEV, Aug. 10 – At least one Russian strategic Tu-22 bomber deployed on targets throughout Georgia, was probably shot down by a Ukrainian long-range anti-aircraft missile, Russian media reported, citing a source in the Russian command.


Ukrainian Journal

This is the website of Yulia Tymoshenko, Prime Minister of Ukraine, and very,very hot if I may say so.
Yulia Tymoshenko
Wiki bio of MS. Tymoshenko, with extract of magazine article she wrote in Foreign Affairs last year warning about Russia,

Tymoshenko wrote an article called "Containing Russia" in the May-June 2007 edition of the journal Foreign Affairs.[18][19] In the article she sharply criticized alleged authoritarian developments under Vladimir Putin and opposed the alleged new Russian expansionism. Consequently, the article irked Russia and more than a week before the article was published, Russia responded to the article, calling it an "anti-Russian manifesto" and "an attempt to once again draw dividing lines in Europe."[20] It was subsequently revealed that significant portions of the article had been paraphrased from an article written by former U.S. Secretary of State Henry Kissinger. Tymoshenko's staff denied allegations of plagiarism on the grounds that the Foreign Affairs format does not usually include attributions.[2


Wiki Yulia Tymoshenko

196 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:36:25am

re: #174 realwest

Hey Cap'n! Russia was the major supplier of the VC and the North Vietnamese Army - Vietnam has been at war with China for over 1000 years.
It was the Soviet ships in Haiphong Harbor that LBJ and then Nixon were worried about hitting with bombing runs over North Vietnam.


* * *
John McCain's father, Admiral John "Jack" McCain, sent the planes to bomb Hanoi while future Senator John McCain sat in Hanoi POW camp.

McCain knows a thing or two about Soviet client states who tortured & imprisoned US troops!

Did anyone see McCain's tv conference on the Russian invasion two hours ago? Summarize please! Pres. Bush might still be in transit from China.

197 realwest  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:36:28am

re: #146 itellu3times
We don't have to beat Russia on it's ground - we just need to clear the air over Georgia of Russian aircraft and that we CAN do.
And if Putin takes this to nuclear war, it'll be the end of Russia - and maybe most of the rest of the World.

198 Right Brain  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:36:31am

re: #147 Kenneth

And with the Europussys tending the gate, they probably won't get in now.

199 Dustoff-507  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:36:52am

re: #175 trailortrash


Yep, theu didn't just think of this yesterday

200 Fat Bastard Vegetarian  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:37:16am

Now what? Shit.

201 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:38:07am

re: #175 trailortrash

russia sure did have alot of stuff ready for this operation...

* * *
I think Russia waited until Solzhenitsyn was buried to invade Georgia.

202 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:38:16am

Mornin' {realwest}.

203 astronmr20  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:39:12am

The media has been relatively quiet over this, precisely because they are waiting to see how to spin this as America's fault.

204 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:39:50am

re: #177 Iron Fist

No, and it's not just the oil. If nothing else shows it, the silence on the so-called "anti-war" Left exposes the fact that they are just anti-US. The Republicans (the only patriotic Party we have in the US) needs to be driving this point home. We need to make a lot of noise, bare minimum. Right now we aren't doing much.

* * *
I repeat, absent the President, McCain just gave a news conference on live tv, anyone see it?

McCain could get 200,000 Georgians to rally for him, he's been to Georgia many times and knows Saakashvilli personally.

205 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:40:17am

re: #203 astronmr20

The media has been relatively quiet over this, precisely because they are waiting to see how to spin this as America's fault.

Correction: How to spin this as W's and the Republicans' fault.

206 lifeofthemind  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:40:45am

1) Blow the tunnel.
2) Destroy any Russian submarines in the Black Sea
3) Establish a US manned FOB on Georgian soil with CAP over Tblisi
4) Roumanian and Bulgarian troops should move into the Ukraine.
5) The Ukrainian army should occupy Sevastapol
6) The Turkish army should move to Batumi
7) Give Putin a blank look if he asks about his submarines
8) Suggest that all Russian troops evacuate from Georgian soil within 96 hours.
9) Propose a UN peacekeeping force on the border, Iraqis, Columbians and Kiwis.

207 Kenneth  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:40:53am

Obama & Kremlin reading from the same page.

The Kremlin tore in to John McCain via his chief foreign policy adviser, Randy Scheunemann, on Saturday. The Russians, angry at McCain's strong statement denouncing Russia's invasion of Georgia, pointed out that Scheunemann had lobbied for American ally Georgia.

At the same time the Kremlin was attacking John McCain for Scheunemann's ties to Georgia . . . you guessed it . . . Barack Obama's campaign attacked McCain for Scheunemann's connection to the Republic of Georgia.

Coincidence?

208 Saif al Kufr  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:41:10am

I disagree with the characterization of the Russia Blog post reading like "a press release out of the Kremlin." I find the arguments in the post to be reasonable and well-defended by evidence. A major reason I enjoy reading LGF posts is that Charles goes for the substance of his ideological opponents' arguments instead of resorting to ad hominem. It is unfortunate that that is not the case here.

209 realwest  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:41:24am

re: #162 itellu3times
I said in my comment that it's a war of will between the U.S. and Russia - Georgia (our ally in Iraq) was merely the ground Russia chose to start it.
And yes, look what the Afghans did over 10 years to the much superior Soviet Armed Forces in Afghanistan.
We COULD win the airwar, no doubt about it in my mind or in the minds of folks I know who get paid to keep abreast of that sort of thing; close Russian access to Georgia and yes the Georgian's themselves could win against what's there now.

210 Cap'n DOC  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:41:37am

re: #174 realwest

I sure saw an awful lot of Chinese characters on captured supplies...

211 Cognito  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:42:00am

Dangerous, indeed. I wouldn't be surprised to hear word of an attempted coup d'etat any day.

I'm not sure a change in Presidential leadership would be so bad -- I know someone who's got harrowing tales Misha Saakashvili's personal craziness.

(And hey: Thanks to the AP for another useful story.)

212 Kenneth  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:42:11am

re: #183 Sizzlack

The tin foil is completely on for this one at Daily Kos:

Is Georgia Being Staged to Raise Gas Prices?

Daily Kos is being staged to make the Democrats look like raving moonbat idiots.

213 Dianna  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:42:20am

re: #201 alegrias

* * *
I think Russia waited until Solzhenitsyn was buried to invade Georgia.

I was thinking that last night.

214 Honorary Yooper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:42:27am

re: #195 JHW

If true, and Ukraine gets involved, this could be a much wider war, on many fronts for Russia.

215 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:42:37am

re: #212 Kenneth

Oh brother.

216 yma o hyd  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:42:49am

re: #184 Ayatollah Ghilmeini

Excellent proposals - do you think the now lame-duck government of GWB has the balls (still) to do this?

217 Cognito  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:43:47am

re: #203 astronmr20

The media has been relatively quiet over this, precisely because they are waiting to see how to spin this as America's fault.

What? This is a huge story.

218 Charles  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:43:49am

re: #208 Saif al Kufr

I disagree with the characterization of the Russia Blog post reading like "a press release out of the Kremlin." I find the arguments in the post to be reasonable and well-defended by evidence. A major reason I enjoy reading LGF posts is that Charles goes for the substance of his ideological opponents' arguments instead of resorting to ad hominem. It is unfortunate that that is not the case here.

There's a very good reason why the Russia Blog reads like propaganda straight from the Kremlin:

[Link: larussophobe.wordpress.com...]

219 Dianna  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:43:52am

re: #211 Cognito

While Georgia suffers the usual problems of corruption and crony-ism, and Saakashvili has moments when he's a little...strange...does not mean a coup would be a good thing, or help with leadership.

220 realwest  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:44:17am

re: #178 Kenneth Yes, you're right Kenneth, but as I've said eleventy-million times on this topic, IF the US WANTED TO, we could own the skies over Georgia - the Russian Air Force can't deal with our vastly superior aircraft, weaponry and - most importantly - pilots.

221 Quintus_Arius  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:44:29am

Somebody refresh me. What did Eisenhower do when Soviet tanks rolled into Hungary in 1956. My recollection is 'nada'.

The current Russian military action against Georgia is not the same but Georgia has western allies. NATO can not let this stand or else- "Here we go again".

222 FrogMarch  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:44:46am

Fuck it. Lets go to war with Russia.
re: #122 Cattt

OT - AWESOME QUOTE:

When I flipped at the 50, and saw how far ahead he was, knowing he was the world record holder, for a split second a thought crossed my mind: There is no way. But I said 'You know what? This is ridiculous. This is the Olympics and I'm here for the United States of America. I don't care how bad it hurts.' Honestly, in like five seconds, I was thinking all these things. I just got like a super charge and just took it from there. It was unreal. - Jason Lezak.

So amazing. So so so Amazing. The French had it in the bag and this guy pulled it from behind. Yeah Lezak.

/cheering for Phelps to get the 8!

223 astronmr20  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:44:55am

So will the hand-wringing continue? Will Ukraine get involved?

Yes- McCain and Obama's responses subsequent responses are very telling. This is a situation that could certainly show McCain's depth of knowledge on the topic.

224 J.S.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:44:59am

In a few minutes BBC "News" World will be discussing how a major (world's second largest) pipeline (that's oil to Europe) may be in danger by the war in Georgia.

225 Dustoff-507  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:45:07am

re: #214 Honorary Yooper


Let's hope it's more than Puttin can chew off.

226 Kenneth  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:45:28am

re: #198 Right Brain

The new NATO members form eastern Europe all want Georgia in NATO. And don't forget: Italy, France & Germany all have conservative gov'ts. The EU doesn't have a voice in NATO.

227 Sifty  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:45:42am

If Putinia takes over Europe, maybe they will be able to fight the jihad without the New York Times tying their hands.

228 Saif al Kufr  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:45:58am

re: #213 Dianna

Solzhenitsyn fully supported Putin's new Russia:

[Link: www.boston.com...]

229 pat  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:46:25am

From the KOS thread.


"... Bush's pal "I was able to get a sense of his soul" Putin, scratches his itchy trigger finger, on Bush's blessing, and attacks Georgia- making sure to disrupt the flow of oil in the process. It accomplishes three things:

1. It keeps gas prices high, which keeps up the political pressure to open up oil leases

2. It gives McCain and the GOP the one and only issue on which they can win (side benefit: it lets McCain talk tough on foreign policy)

3. It puts a foreign policy issue, a COMPLEX foreign policy issue, squarely into the Presidential debate, which McCain's people believe help him.

If they're willing to start a war with American lives, what's to say they're not willing to start one with Russian and Georgian lives as well?
Poll

Did Bushco have a hand in starting the Russia-Georgia conflict?
Yes
39% 13 votes
No
60% 20 votes

| 33 votes | Vote

230 Cognito  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:46:49am

re: #219 Dianna

While Georgia suffers the usual problems of corruption and crony-ism, and Saakashvili has moments when he's a little...strange...does not mean a coup would be a good thing, or help with leadership.

Oh, no -- I should clarify -- I'm not advocating a coup by any stretch. I mean the Georgians could probably elect a better President.

I should have separated those ideas better.

231 FrogMarch  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:46:56am

re: #218 Charles

There's a very good reason why the Russia Blog reads like propaganda straight from the Kremlin:

[Link: larussophobe.wordpress.com...]

Would it surprise you then, knowing all this, gentle reader, to find out that DI’s “Director of Foreign Policy” is a 24-year-old Russian “composer” with an undergraduate degree from a Russian “Tax Academy” whose parents were Soviet aparachiks?

As usual - great detective work, Charles.

232 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:47:13am
233 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:47:17am

re: #221 Quintus_Arius

Somebody refresh me. What did Eisenhower do when Soviet tanks rolled into Hungary in 1956. My recollection is 'nada'.

The current Russian military action against Georgia is not the same but Georgia has western allies. NATO can not let this stand or else- "Here we go again".

* * *
What did Pres. Johnson do when Soviets rolled into Czechoslovakia & silence the Prague Spring (of freedom)?

234 J.S.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:47:18am

They're talking about deliberate sabatoge of the world's second largest pipeline in Georgia -- so then the oil to Europe would have to be re-routed -- go through mainland Russia (as opposed to through Georgia).

235 realwest  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:47:39am

re: #202 J.D. Hey good morning to you {J.D.} How are you doing?!

236 Honorary Yooper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:47:51am

re: #225 Dustoff-507

Let's hope it's more than Puttin can chew off.

It jolly well may be, if the other former Soviet states get involved. Some of them have a burning dislike for Putin and his cohorts. Of course, I would too, if they tried to assassinate me and install their own puppet.

There's something said about reaping what one sows.

237 Honorary Yooper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:48:23am

re: #224 J.S.

In a few minutes BBC "News" World will be discussing how a major (world's second largest) pipeline (that's oil to Europe) may be in danger by the war in Georgia.

Oh shit.

Thank goodness I filled up this morning.

238 yma o hyd  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:48:24am

re: #194 buzzsawmonkey

The CIA seems to be useful primarily for providing "intelligence" that is the opposite of the actual facts on the ground.

I've just had a horrible thought.
What if the CIA knew - Bush was informed - and warned Georgia about the Russian build-up? And Georgia didn't believe it, and went ahead anyway?

Its not something the US Government would scream from the rooftops, and it would perhaps explain this a tiny bit.

239 Kenneth  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:48:30am
240 Sifty  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:48:34am

re: #232 buzzsawmonkey

quit shitting on my silver lining. lol

241 J.S.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:48:37am

BBC also noted that Kazakshstan may have an interest in sabatoging the Georgia pipeline...

242 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:48:58am

re: #223 astronmr20

So will the hand-wringing continue? Will Ukraine get involved?

Yes- McCain and Obama's responses subsequent responses are very telling. This is a situation that could certainly show McCain's depth of knowledge on the topic.

* * *
Depth of knowledge? Anti-communism is hardwired in McCain's DNA!

243 Sifty  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:49:34am

re: #241 J.S.

That Borat guy is such a jerk.

244 Ben Hur  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:49:40am

bbl

245 Wendya  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:49:53am

re: #23 Ben Hur

What is the population of Russia?

I think Georgia's is 4 million.

So you could understand how this is a holocaust against Russia.

Russian has been quick to trot out "ethnic cleansing" and "holocaust" and a host of other claims against Georgia. They've done a pretty good job convincing a lot of people on the left and the Buchananites that Georgia is a totalitarian state.

246 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:49:58am

re: #224 J.S.

In a few minutes BBC "News" World will be discussing how a major (world's second largest) pipeline (that's oil to Europe) may be in danger by the war in Georgia.

* * *
Drill here, drill now, baby!

Papa Putin's putting the squeeze on petroleum.

247 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:50:02am

The War in Georgia Is a War for the West By MIKHEIL SAAKASHVILI

...As Europe expanded its security institutions to the Black Sea, my government appealed to the Western community of nations -- particularly European governments and institutions -- to play a leading role in resolving our separatist conflicts. The key to any resolution was to replace the outdated peacekeeping and negotiating structures created almost two decades ago, and dominated by Russia, with a genuine international effort.

But Europe kept its distance and, predictably, Russia escalated its provocations. Our friends in Europe counseled restraint, arguing that diplomacy would take its course. We followed their advice and took it one step further, by constantly proposing new ideas to resolve the conflicts. Just this past spring, we offered the separatist leaders sweeping autonomy, international guarantees and broad representation in our government. ...

248 Honorary Yooper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:50:07am

re: #229 pat

From the KOS thread.

Did Bushco have a hand in starting the Russia-Georgia conflict?
Yes
39% 13 votes
No
60% 20 votes

| 33 votes | Vote

Sickening that almost 2/5ths of Kos Kooks think Bush had a hand in starting this.

249 Kenneth  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:50:20am

re: #215 J.D.

You know I'm being sarcastic, right?

250 JHW  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:50:43am

re: #214 Honorary Yooper

Yes and there is quite a bit of info on the naval base story also, complicated like everything else there, with joint operating agreements, dual citizenships and various other opportunities and pretexts for trouble.
I found this statement interesting, no doubt there are those in the Kremlin who find it interesting also.

Lithuania and Poland, as well as Ukraine and Georgia, are the key members of a regional bloc that is being created to counterbalance Russia’s influence, including its energy monopoly, in the region.


Yushchenko Reaches out to world on Georgia
Mr. Yushchenko is President of Ukraine.

251 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:50:49am

re: #229 pat

From the KOS thread.


Did Bushco have a hand in starting the Russia-Georgia conflict?
Yes
39% 13 votes
No
60% 20 votes

| 33 votes | Vote

Nite, pat.

So...I guess you voted, too?

252 tfc3rid  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:50:54am

Russia out of Georgia now... Keep your hands off Florida and Alabama as well...

People have no idea what this all about and some I talked to yesterday actually thought the Russians were bombing Georgia, yes, OUR Georgia...

Putin needs to be put in his place. We are all talk and no action on this one... And Russia begins her rebirth...

253 Dianna  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:51:18am

re: #221 Quintus_Arius

As I've said - granted, while suffering from extreme gloom - we can't get through a decade without betraying an ally.

This time, it looks like we're not even waiting for the Democrats to take office.

254 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:51:19am

re: #235 realwest

Better all the time {realwest}. You?

255 papawhisky  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:51:29am

What exactly was Mikheil Saakashvili thinking? Both of those provinces were gone and have been gone from Georgia since 2002. And to make matters worse ... the Russians drove out the last remaining ethnic Georgians. The only people left there are Russian 'peacekeepers' and ethnic Ossetians - ostensibly loyal to Russia.

So what does he do? Launch artillery attacks on South Ossetia knowing full well that Russia had dozens of tanks massed at the border.

What does Russia do? Invade and smash the Georgians and now that they're in, they won't stop.

(Surprise surprise ... the Russians are usually so subtle.)

It's clear what was happening ... his popularity was down so he seized on the one topic that would unite the country behind him: "territorial integrity".

This is a farce like Canadian Bacon but with real missiles

What was he expecting? That we would fly in and bail him out? The guy is nuts.

256 Dustoff-507  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:51:45am

re: #236 Honorary Yooper

As i keep saying... Bush could send arms to these countires to help them out. Puttin can only lose so many aircraft until it hurts .

Realwest is right. Puttin loses the air, he loses it all.

257 Wendya  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:51:49am

re: #188 Sifty

the CIA missed 180,000 Soviet troops massing on the border with Afghanistan a few years back.

.

What do we keep them around for... other than to undermine any Republican President?

258 Dianna  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:51:53am

re: #230 Cognito

OK.

259 realwest  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:52:17am

re: #210 Cap'n DOC When were you there and where were you when you saw them? The Chinese were STILL fighting the North Vietnamese on their border when I was there (class of '70) and the trucks I saw on the Ho Chi Minh "Trail" were all Soviet built.
Not denying that China didn't send SOME supplies to the NVA, but all the SAM's used were Russian made as were the radar systems that guided them and the few tanks and fighter aircraft used by the NVA were all Soviet made.

260 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:52:31am
261 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:53:12am

re: #249 Kenneth

You know I'm being sarcastic, right?

Of course.
It's what passes for a "normal" day at kos.
Sad, really.

262 FrogMarch  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:53:13am

re: #248 Honorary Yooper

Sickening that almost 2/5ths of Kos Kooks think Bush had a hand in starting this.

what are the Kos kids and Andrew Sullivan going to do when Bush is no longer president? How will their paranoid schizophrenia survive?

263 CIA Reject  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:53:25am

re: #257 Wendya

What do we keep them around for... other than to undermine any Republican President?

Don't get me started...

264 realwest  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:53:48am

re: #211 Cognito
Hey Cog - didja by any chance catch the Times of London's take on this: [Link: www.timesonline.co.uk...]

265 Wendya  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:53:48am

re: #255 papawhisky

What exactly was Mikheil Saakashvili thinking?

I imagine he was thinking he was going to lose his entire country piece by piece to the Russians.

266 jcm  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:54:00am

re: #157 realwest

I really don't care how. Just that we do it. It can be short and sharp. Or we can let it drag out. Right now it's our choice.

I like the JSOW anti-armor because it's effective. and demoralizing, 4 F-16s in the Iraq war loaded with those things rendered the 3rd Republican Guard combat ineffective.

267 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:54:00am
268 Sifty  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:54:15am

re: #255 papawhisky

Poland fought back. And Hungary.
Even the French fought back for an afternoon or two.

269 yma o hyd  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:54:44am

re: #221 Quintus_Arius

Somebody refresh me. What did Eisenhower do when Soviet tanks rolled into Hungary in 1956. My recollection is 'nada'.

The current Russian military action against Georgia is not the same but Georgia has western allies. NATO can not let this stand or else- "Here we go again".

He did 'nada' because the soviets invaded Hungary at precisely the time England, France and israel were trying to wrest the Suez Canal from Egypt - and Eisenhower had his hands full to get them to desist and go back home.

The Soviets, and Putin, planned long ahead and chose their time to strike with utmost precision, always.

270 Dianna  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:54:50am

re: #234 J.S.

Have the Russians managed to hit the pipeline yet?

271 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:54:54am

re: #268 Sifty

Poland fought back. And Hungary.
Even the French fought back for an afternoon or two.



Two?

Really?

272 Catttt  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:55:07am

re: #66 Iron Fist

Russia isn't the Big Dog she used to be. Her navy is drastically smaller, and her air force hasn't kept up with ours. Our troops are better trained and better motivated. A nuclear exchange would be crazy, and whatever else you may say about him, Putin isn't crazy. He's pushing to see how far we'll let him go.

I say we don't let him go very far.

Well, of course it would be cool if we could do that. My point is that Russia is wacked. It may be a game to Russia, but it's more like three dimensional chess on LSD than tiddly winks or tick tack toe - they are freaking unpredictable.

273 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:55:10am

re: #218 Charles

There's a very good reason why the Russia Blog reads like propaganda straight from the Kremlin:

[Link: larussophobe.wordpress.com...]

VERRRY interesting, Charles. Thanks!

This guy has certainly had a full life during his 24 years. Who says it's impossible to be a Renaissance Man nowadays?! I am humble before his ... his ... *yawn* ... *snore*

274 lifeofthemind  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:55:23am

re: #210 Cap'n DOC

I sure saw an awful lot of Chinese characters on captured supplies...

THe bulk of Soviet supplies got to North Vietnam by rail across China. The Chinese took maybe a third for themselves and relabeled some of the rest. Communists would routinely relabel American relief supplies to 3rd world disasters to indicate that they came from someplace else.

275 Sifty  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:55:28am

Has anyone declared this Cold War II yet?

should we have a ribbon-cutting or something?

276 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:55:49am

re: #260 taxfreekiller

More and more tfk thinks this Obama out of the line of fire on vacation was a plan, they had a commie tip off and Edwards gave him one also,
its all to convenient.

* * *
Probably, he's windsurfing on Oahu right now! Like John Kerry windsurfed in 2004.

Meanwhile McCain's on the watch, keeping a lookout for the US of A and defending little Georgia with rhetoric until USA decides to act.

C'mon, let's pivot out of IRaq and deal with the Bear.

277 pat  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:56:11am

If i understand this map correctly, the section the oil line being bombed primarily affects Georgian exports to Europe, via Tanker. Note that natural gas is not affected. BTW, it looks like American money paid for this pipeline via contributions to worl bank etc.

[Link: en.wikipedia.org...]

278 Sifty  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:56:24am

re: #271 J.D.

Their girlfriend was watching so they fought for two days to impress her.

279 Dustoff-507  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:56:39am

re: #262 FrogMarch


They will still bame Bush... It's all they know how to do

280 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:56:47am
281 lifeofthemind  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:57:03am

re: #221 Quintus_Arius

Somebody refresh me. What did Eisenhower do when Soviet tanks rolled into Hungary in 1956. My recollection is 'nada'.

The current Russian military action against Georgia is not the same but Georgia has western allies. NATO can not let this stand or else- "Here we go again".

That weekend in 1956 Dulles and Eisenhower were busy destroying our alliance with the French and British over Suez. They still haven't forgiven us.

282 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:57:04am

re: #278 Sifty

Their girlfriend was watching so they fought for two days to impress her.

But only under the shade trees.

283 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:57:13am

re: #268 Sifty

Poland fought back. And Hungary.
Even the French fought back for an afternoon or two.

* * *
They were making lattes for German Kaffee Klatch mit Kuchen that afternoon...

284 cygnus  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:58:05am

re: #34 ShumBaayaMyLord

Is it bad form to wish simultaneous balinitis and multiple bleeding hemorrhoids on Vlad Putin?

All of that on top of looking like Dobby the house-elf. The little twit.

285 Honorary Yooper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:58:07am

re: #262 FrogMarch

what are the Kos kids and Andrew Sullivan going to do when Bush is no longer president? How will their paranoid schizophrenia survive?

McDS.

286 papawhisky  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:58:09am

re: #268 Sifty

Poland fought back. And Hungary.
Even the French fought back for an afternoon or two.

16 years after the fact?

287 Colonel Panik  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:58:14am

They'd be smart to stop there. If those Russkies move from West Georgia into Alabama their gonna run smack into a bunch of angry Bear Bryant fans.

288 realwest  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:58:15am

re: #239 Kenneth
Excellent and thank you!

289 pat  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:58:18am

re: #251 J.D.

lol, I was undecided/

290 maddogg  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:58:21am

When Putin gets to France, will we be expected to save their sorry asses for a 3rd time?

291 jordash1212  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:58:50am

This conflict needs to be resolved very quickly. The Soviets want the Ukraine, and Georgia is on the doorstep of the Ukraine. Ukraine is a Nato country which would drag us and practically the rest of the world into a fight against the Soviets. Talk about a war that I don't want to be fighting in, but the draft would be almost certain.

292 Cap'n DOC  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:58:52am

re: #259 realwest

69-70 - and what I saw was ak ammo boxes and bandoliers with oriental characters on them.

293 Kuffar  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:59:07am

5 years and the Europeans will be begging us Imperialist Cowboy Pigs to come to their rescue...

294 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:59:40am

re: #290 maddogg

When Putin gets to France, will we be expected to save their sorry asses for a 3rd time?

* * *
Will those yootful car-b-ques deter them or us?

295 pat  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 9:59:54am

New link to map.
[Link: en.wikipedia.org...]

frickin wikipedia images

296 blutonazi98  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:00:01am

re: #183 Sizzlack

the Russians would benefit from that

297 Sifty  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:00:03am

re: #282 J.D.

We should start a betting pool on how long it takes France to surrender this time.

Put me down for 36 hours. $5 a square.

298 Cap'n DOC  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:00:04am

re: #274 lifeofthemind

Yah, well - I saw medical supplies from BERKELEY, too.

299 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:00:19am

re: #289 pat

lol, I was undecided/

LOL!
Fence sitting? No way!

300 Athos  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:00:21am

re: #221 Quintus_Arius

I think that NATO's refusal, on the basis of the German veto, to consider Georgia's membership in the organization is a key step that helped Russia make the decision to help escalate this action.

Frankly, in my opinion, NATO, for all practical purposes, challenges the United Nations and the World Bank / IMF as one of the most obsolete organizations in existence today.

Putin's Russia (and its still Putin's Russia) has a well documented history of using cyberwarfare and economic warfare to intimidate and cow other former Soviet republics and Western Europe. This is only the next logical step to use military force to take advantage of a lame duck administration, a political campaign with one side strongly represented by an appeasement / surrender preference of action. Putin has bet that the US will not do more than just transport Georgian troops from Iraq to Georgia...just as the US refuses to do more when faced with previous Putin aggression.

It's very telling that the Ukraine and Turkey have come out very strong in support of Georgia.

301 realwest  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:00:26am

re: #254 J.D. Ah, ok, I guess - gotta have one, maybe two teeth pulled next week. Other than that just fine! LOL!

302 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:01:02am

re: #297 Sifty

We should start a betting pool on how long it takes France to surrender this time.

Put me down for 36 hours. $5 a square.

I love an optimist.

303 yma o hyd  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:01:24am

re: #270 Dianna

Have the Russians managed to hit the pipeline yet?

Its underground trhough Georgia, iirc - precisely to make it difficult for terrorists to attack.

304 Sifty  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:01:46am

re: #302 J.D.

OK, gimme 18 hours too.

305 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:01:52am

re: #301 realwest

Oooo.
Sorry to hear about your teeth.
When it rains, it pours, huh?

306 pat  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:02:15am

Are the quality of the troops in the Western front different than that of the Eastern?

307 debutaunt  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:02:19am

re: #194 buzzsawmonkey

The CIA seems to be useful primarily for providing "intelligence" that is the opposite of the actual facts on the ground.

The CIA consists of too many inept holdovers.

308 HoosierHoops  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:02:37am

re: #274 lifeofthemind

THe bulk of Soviet supplies got to North Vietnam by rail across China. The Chinese took maybe a third for themselves and relabeled some of the rest. Communists would routinely relabel American relief supplies to 3rd world disasters to indicate that they came from someplace else.

I didn't know that life..very interesting..I thought i was mostly chinese weapons...

309 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:02:57am

re: #306 pat

Are the quality of the troops in the Western front different than that of the Eastern?

I think they're generally warmer...

310 Wendya  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:03:07am

re: #300 Athos

I think that NATO's refusal, on the basis of the German veto, to consider Georgia's membership in the organization is a key step that helped Russia make the decision to help escalate this action.

It wasn't just Germany, it was France as well. They didn't want to "upset" Putin.

311 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:03:09am
312 J.S.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:03:10am

re: #270 Dianna

According to most reports, the Russian fighter planes (targeting the pipeline) have missed (there was one fire which the Georgians have put out)...

313 maddogg  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:03:44am

I'll bet the CIA saw this coming a year ago, right?

314 realwest  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:03:57am

re: #255 papawhisky

papawhiskey: Registered since: Jan 7, 2007 at 7:01 am
No. of comments posted: 10

So, really, who are you? And blaming Georgia for starting all this is just so much bullshit. Georgia is a functioning DEMOCRACY - not like Russia, a real one. And you think it's president started a war he couldn't win so he could get re-elected?
Hope you keep up your "rapid pace" of commenting.

315 Athos  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:04:06am

re: #245 Wendya

They've done a pretty good job convincing a lot of people on the left and the Buchananites that Georgia is a totalitarian state.

With those groups, I doubt a lot of convincing was really needed.

316 CommonCents  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:04:08am
Georgia Agrees to European-Brokered Ceasefire
Civil Georgia, Georgia - 1 hour ago
President Saakashvili said on August 11 he had signed a ceasefire deal proposed by senior European envoys. French and Finnish Foreign Ministers Bernard ...

I find this almost humorous. As if the Russians would really trust these 2 as honest brokers. The Russians fought the Fins in the 30's and Napoleon made it 1/2 way across the country before he was turned back. Ancient history but still ironic.

317 Dave_Da_Kid  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:04:37am

re: #44 jcm

In this kind of conflict a SEAL team on the ground and a B-2 orbiting loaded with 80 JDAMs better yet JSOWs would make a significant difference.


Smart pigs would definitely be of use here. Good call.

318 Honorary Yooper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:04:54am

re: #291 jordash1212

This conflict needs to be resolved very quickly. The Soviets want the Ukraine, and Georgia is on the doorstep of the Ukraine. Ukraine is a Nato country which would drag us and practically the rest of the world into a fight against the Soviets. Talk about a war that I don't want to be fighting in, but the draft would be almost certain.

Ukraine is far from Georgia, on the other side of the Black Sea, and is not a NATO member. Turkey, on the other hand, is south of Georgia, and is a NATO member.

319 galloping granny  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:05:01am

re: #293 Kuffar

5 years and the Europeans will be begging us Imperialist Cowboy Pigs to come to their rescue...

Won't take that long. Putin is within a hair of controlling all of the oil to Western Europe.

320 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:05:06am

re: #317 Dave_Da_Kid

lol

321 lifeofthemind  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:05:38am

re: #298 Cap'n DOC

Yah, well - I saw medical supplies from BERKELEY, too.

Would you take any pills from Berkeley?

322 Spiritualized  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:05:43am
Daily Kos: Is Georgia Being Staged to Raise Gas Prices?

I thought moonbats liked higher gas prices? After all, less gas being used = less Global Warmingness!

323 CommonCents  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:05:56am

re: #307 debutaunt

The CIA consists of too many inept holdovers.liberals

Fixed it for you.

324 looking closely  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:06:12am

The Russians are acting up precisely because they know Bush is weak, and the US is already stretched thin fighting a two front war.

Tactically smart on their part. . .not good for Georgia.

325 Ojoe  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:06:15am

re: #49 taxfreekiller

Yes TFK

In sum, it is us

Watching TV

Obsessed with sports

Not educating ourselves to the big picture

Not developing solar energy since the mid 1970s

Wanting government to do things for us

Lazy

326 Wendya  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:06:15am

re: #318 Honorary Yooper

Ukraine is far from Georgia, on the other side of the Black Sea, and is not a NATO member. Turkey, on the other hand, is south of Georgia, and is a NATO member.

Turkey doesn't want Russia breathing down their neck again and stirring up shit in their country.

327 Cygnus  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:06:28am

re: #53 MandyManners

Map.

[Link: www.aboutgeorgia.net...]

Another map - showing Russia, Georgia, and the Middle East. Scary!

328 Athos  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:06:29am

re: #307 debutaunt

The CIA consists of too many inept holdovers.

There is that, however, I think there are 2 other contributing factors with the CIA - the effects of nearly 30 years of being gutted by Democratic administrations and the apparent preference to try to fit all intel into their preconceived ideas and viewpoints as opposed to analyzing the intel and letting that define the interpretations.

329 Dustoff-507  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:06:29am

re: #292 Cap'n DOC


WOW they were shooting REAL bullets at us... LOL

330 galloping granny  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:06:36am

re: #315 Athos

With those groups, I doubt a lot of convincing was really needed.

Especially since many of them also think that the USA is a totalitarian state.

331 realwest  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:07:03am

re: #275 Sifty I just wanted to tell you I down dinged you because this is NOT a situation for those kind of comments.
Sorry.

332 The Other Les  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:07:04am

re: #7 jcm

Georgia is a friend of the US.
Georgia is trying very hard to be representative democracy.
Russia has been escalating since Putin took power.

I think it's time to render aid to Georgian. Airlift of hardware and supplies, even air support.

I believe this is one of those times it is necessary to show our core values as a country mean something.

Dear Mr. President,

Please provide all possible military aid to the Nation of Georgia.

Leslie Bates
Minneapolis, MN

Just sent it.

333 Sifty  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:07:10am

If we went to war with Putinia, would the libtards still say we only bomb brown people?

334 Athos  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:07:22am

re: #310 Wendya

It wasn't just Germany, it was France as well. They didn't want to "upset" Putin.

Just as France and Britain didn't want to upset 'Mr. Hitler' in 1938.

335 jcm  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:07:29am

History...

In 1936 German troops re-militarized the Rhineland. The German military opposed Hitler's plan. They were not ready for a conflict, and if France should any opposition might have deposed Hitler.

German troops marched, France did not because Britain would not back them up.

A conflict over the Rhineland would have been fairly short and changed the dynamics of German politics.

As in 1936 it's not a question of if we will face off with Russian expansion. It's when and how much it will cost.

A fight over the Rhineland would have been short and cheap compared to WWII.

A fight over Georgia will be short and cheap compare to what looms beyond.

336 lifeofthemind  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:07:35am

re: #302 J.D.

I love an optimist.

He's right, the French may be on strike so it would take an extra day for the word of their surrender to get out. Besides, how could you tell the difference?

337 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:07:36am

re: #322 Spiritualized

I thought moonbats liked higher gas prices? After all, less gas being used = less Global Warmingness!

I have it on good authority (my driver from the airport) that it's all over, global warming or not, when the rock shelf on the west coast of Africa detaches.

Put that in your pipe and smoke it!

338 Dustoff-507  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:07:44am

re: #314 realwest


Must be reading them Russian news papers. Yeah that's it. LOL

339 CyanSnowHawk  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:07:56am

re: #275 Sifty

Has anyone declared this Cold War II yet?

should we have a ribbon-cutting or something?

Pop open a few Coor's Lights.

340 Spiritualized  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:08:37am

No-one is going to stop Russia.

However, this would be an ideal time to start flattening the Jihadnuke programme in Iran.

341 redc1c4  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:08:46am

re: #33 Dirk Diggler

PK,

What would you propose he do?

airlift ATGM's, MANPADS, trainers, and use a few B-2's to blow the tunnels and other choke points on the Russian LOC's. cut off their supplies and let the Georgians kill them all.

342 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:09:01am

re: #336 lifeofthemind

He's right, the French may be on strike so it would take an extra day for the word of their surrender to get out. Besides, how could you tell the difference?

OK. I'll bite.
How?

;-P

343 CIA Reject  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:09:09am

re: #307 debutaunt

The CIA consists of too many inept holdovers.

They are not inept. They are very competent at what they do. Unfortunately what they do is serve their own interests. Not the interests of the country.

Not all of them of course, but enough of them in positions high enough to render the rest ineffective.

344 CommonCents  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:09:15am

re: #333 Sifty

If we went to war with Putinia, would the libtards still say we only bomb brown people?

Didn't you see Iowa? Bush hates white people too.

345 realwest  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:09:22am

re: #221 Quintus_Arius - uh, take out a map of Europe - remember where the Iron Curtain was in place and please tell me what YOU would have done if you were IKE?

346 Saif al Kufr  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:09:24am

re: #231 FrogMarch

As usual - great detective work, Charles.

I fail to see the logical progression from the premise that a blog operator is the "spawn of Soviet apparatchiks" to the conclusion that a post on that blog "reads like a press release from the Kremlin."

I don't want to seem like I support Discovery Institute idiots like Yuri Mamchur in any way, but I'm not impressed by an ad hominem rant from "La Russophobe" as an argument against the substance of the Russia Blog post.

By the way, here's an article from a spawn of a Soviet apparatchik. Does it read like a press release from the Kremlin?

[Link: www.guardian.co.uk...]

347 Abu Al-Poopypants  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:09:55am

re: #337 J.D.

I have it on good authority (my driver from the airport) that it's all over, global warming or not, when the rock shelf on the west coast of Africa detaches.

This is some Art Bell crap that someone I know is all worried about.

348 huggy77  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:09:56am

this is very sad... The Georgian people have been very supportive of us... We are letting them down.

349 Sifty  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:10:06am

re: #331 realwest

I will try to be more solemn. Events like these bring out the bad gallows humor.

350 HoosierHoops  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:10:09am

re: #314 realwest

papawhiskey: Registered since: Jan 7, 2007 at 7:01 am
No. of comments posted: 10

So, really, who are you? And blaming Georgia for starting all this is just so much bullshit. Georgia is a functioning DEMOCRACY - not like Russia, a real one. And you think it's president started a war he couldn't win so he could get re-elected?
Hope you keep up your "rapid pace" of commenting.

LOL
some people would claim quality over quantity...
but not in this case...

351 yma o hyd  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:10:26am

Some press opinions from Russia and Georgia, here, from the Beeb 'listening post' ...

352 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:11:03am

re: #347 Abu Al-Poopypants

This is some Art Bell crap that someone I know is all worried about.

Well, this guy's moving back to Ohio, where he'll be safe, y'see...

353 Killgore Trout  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:11:26am

re: #341 redc1c4

I think the Georgians are so outclassed that no amount of help would save them. They'll be crushed by the time we could mobilize. NATO could possibly get involved but I don't think they're willing to do anything.

354 trailortrash  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:11:26am

re: #341 redc1c4

airlift ATGM's, MANPADS, trainers, and use a few B-2's to blow the tunnels and other choke points on the Russian LOC's. cut off their supplies and let the Georgians kill them all.


i like your way of thinkin, :thumbsup:

355 Westward Ho  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:11:33am

I am watching BBC now and their washington correspondent says that the US is planning to introduce a strongly worded resolution in the UN and then their are dark whispers of throwing out Russia from the G8.

356 pat  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:12:30am

What is so special about African rock shelf?

357 Sifty  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:12:41am

Fred Thompson should be sent to meet with Vlad. In a dark alley.

358 lifeofthemind  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:13:12am

re: #342 J.D.

OK. I'll bite.
How?

;-P

If they still expect to be paid.

359 sattv4u2  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:13:17am

I know this will place me in a very small minority, and at odds with Charles, but could Charles (and most of our) disdain for the Discovery Institutes stance on evolution be clouding our judgement of their stance on this conflict? As much as I've read about this "war", there does not really seem to be a clear cut culprit. Conflicting "facts', times, "he saids/ she saids" muddle the issue. I have no love nor trust of Putin. I have posted here before that I beleive his ultimate goal is to be THE regions #1 (I stated they cannot be the WORLDS #1, that train left the station thanks to Reagan/ Thatcher et al).
Is DI pro- Russia? Of course, or else they would not have a Russia Blog! But for me to immediatly jump on the "IT'S RUSSIA'S FAULT" bandwagon just because Charles says so would morally and conciously be wrong of me (and perhaps you also)

If this gets me in trouble with any of you, or a stern look from the head lizard, so be it.

360 The Other Les  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:13:32am

re: #43 blutonazi98

the US is Flying Georgian troops home. Could Russia interpret this as action by the US against them?

It's not a matter of could they. They certainly will.

361 Cygnus  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:13:46am

re: #104 gibsonz

Time for the Messiah to come to the rescue, he can carpet bomb Moscow in his Cessna 182 with leaflets of love and compassion, change and hope will be the answer to this crisis!

And if Russia decides to pay Israel a 'visit', the real Messiah will kick their asses! Ezekiel 38-39!

362 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:13:48am

re: #356 pat

What is so special about African rock shelf?


pat, I will be underwater! You, no doubt, will be too! So, there!

363 Colonel Panik  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:13:55am

re: #356 pat

What is so special about African rock shelf?


Actually I think he's thinking of a volcano in the Canary Islands that supposedly could cause a massive tidal wave hitting the east coast if part of it slides into the sea.

364 Pvt Bin Jammin  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:14:14am

Here's a good blog post with some great maps:
[Link: www.thedonovan.com...]

365 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:14:41am

re: #358 lifeofthemind

It's always about the money. *sigh*

366 paradox42  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:14:53am

This whole situation illustrates the supreme folly of nuclear disarmament. Why have we not intervened directly when the Russians attack our allies? Because they can turn NYC, Miami, D.C., LA, Chicago, and every other major US city into glass craters all at once in less than 12 hours. True, we can do the same thing to them, but at that point it is to late. Had Stalin never gotten the bomb, the Cold War would have lasted years instead of decades, and the world would be a much better place.

We may not be perfect, and we've definitely made mistakes, but we are the good guys overall and the only way for the good guys to survive in this cruel world is to have the biggest and baddest kids on the block.

Just because we give up our nukes doesn't mean the other guy is giving up his. Would you?

367 maddogg  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:15:03am

I say would we are getting pretty sorry service/dollar expenditure from the CIA.

368 redc1c4  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:15:06am

re: #346 Saif al Kufr

all that from someone with a whopping 17 posts...

who's spawn are you?

369 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:15:27am

re: #363 Colonel Panik

Now that's a whole different issue.
If it's not one thing, it's another.

370 Colonel Panik  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:15:36am

re: #357 Sifty

Fred Thompson should be sent to meet with Vlad. In a dark alley.

Vlad would kick his ass. He's a judo expert, and is much younger. Fred might even fall asleep on the way to the alley and never make it.
Duncan Hunter, on the other hand, was an Army Ranger and may know a few moves that would surprise Vlad.

371 wiffersnapper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:16:00am

re: #359 sattv4u2

I have wondered the same thing. Didn't Georgia "attack" first by trying to take back Ossetia or something? Either way, I think Georgia is still in the right, and Russia is the real aggressor

372 Cognito  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:16:08am

re: #264 realwest

Hi realwest, no, I'd missed that -- thanks for the link. I'll check it out.

373 lifeofthemind  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:16:12am

re: #343 CIA Reject

They are not inept. They are very competent at what they do. Unfortunately what they do is serve their own interests. Not the interests of the country.

Not all of them of course, but enough of them in positions high enough to render the rest ineffective.

I guarantee that when the post mortem on this is done the CIA will produce an estimate that almost kinda predicted this 6 months ago. It was hedged in caveats and obscure language and on page 36 of a 148 page document that was delivered on a Friday afternoon along with athletic equipment requisitions but they will find it.

374 Catttt  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:16:14am

re: #222 FrogMarch

Michael Phelps is my homeboy. :D

375 reine.de.tout  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:16:25am

re: #218 Charles

There's a very good reason why the Russia Blog reads like propaganda straight from the Kremlin:

[Link: larussophobe.wordpress.com...]

Wow - from that link - a lot of very telling information:

Would it surprise you then, knowing all this, gentle reader, to find out that DI’s “Director of Foreign Policy” is a 24-year-old Russian “composer” with an undergraduate degree from a Russian “Tax Academy” whose parents were Soviet aparachiks? Would it surprise you that said “Director of Foreign Policy” - Mr. Yuri Mamchur, who operates Russia Blog - twists facts to suit his ideology? Perhaps not. What might surprise you, however, is that Mamchur is using DI’s own tactics to undermine conservatism itself, which ought to be (and is) vigorously opposing the rise of the Neo-Soviet Union, which Mamchur by contrast does everything he can to facilitate.

So let’s see now: Yuri is the ripe old age of twenty-four. He has an unspecified undergraduate degree from a Russian institution called the “Tax Academy School of Law.” And this qualifies him as an expert on foreign policy (actually, as the manager of other experts)? Hard to see how, but perhaps the voice of God was whispering in the ears of the folks at DI when they hired Yuri. Do you dare to imagine the qualifications of the folks they rejected? An image of the three stooges leaps to mind.

If you Google the “Tax Academy School of Law,” you will find out exactly nothing about it. In fact, you will get only three hits for that exact phrase on Google, and all three will be for Yuri’s biography (which, conveniently, does not provide any links or further information about his alma mater). This is a matter of significant concern, since even people casually familiar with Russia know that it is full of unlicensed, fly-by-night educational institutions whose diplomas are not worth the paper they are printed on.

376 realwest  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:16:32am

re: #310 Wendya Well that certainly worked out well, didn't it?!
/

377 reine.de.tout  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:16:55am

re: #122 Cattt

OT - AWESOME QUOTE:

When I flipped at the 50, and saw how far ahead he was, knowing he was the world record holder, for a split second a thought crossed my mind: There is no way. But I said 'You know what? This is ridiculous. This is the Olympics and I'm here for the United States of America. I don't care how bad it hurts.' Honestly, in like five seconds, I was thinking all these things. I just got like a super charge and just took it from there. It was unreal. - Jason Lezak.

This is the difference between an athlete who is very very good, and an athlete who is a champion.

378 Sifty  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:17:14am

re: #370 Colonel Panik

your blasphemy will be forgiven. this time

/

379 American Jewess In Jerusalem  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:17:44am

Why is the Discovery Institute pro-Russia? Why would they be? What is the connection?

Secondly, are we stepping into WWIII with this Russian invasion?

380 pat  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:17:59am

Oh. The Canary Island stuff. Canary Islands are pretty stable actually. Hawaii is a geographical fun ride compared to them.

381 CIA Reject  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:18:16am

re: #104 gibsonz

Time for the Messiah to come to the rescue, he can carpet bomb Moscow in his Cessna 182 with leaflets of love and compassion, change and hope will be the answer to this crisis!

Cessna 172: The original "stealth" aircraft !

382 galloping granny  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:18:24am

re: #366 paradox42

This whole situation illustrates the supreme folly of nuclear disarmament. Why have we not intervened directly when the Russians attack our allies? Because they can turn NYC, Miami, D.C., LA, Chicago, and every other major US city into glass craters all at once in less than 12 hours. True, we can do the same thing to them, but at that point it is to late. Had Stalin never gotten the bomb, the Cold War would have lasted years instead of decades, and the world would be a much better place.

We may not be perfect, and we've definitely made mistakes, but we are the good guys overall and the only way for the good guys to survive in this cruel world is to have the biggest and baddest kids on the block.

Just because we give up our nukes doesn't mean the other guy is giving up his. Would you?

Maybe they can. If they can find all the nukes and if the nukes haven't rusted to shit so bad they can't get them out of the silos from decades of lousy maintenance.

383 lawhawk  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:18:41am

re: #359 sattv4u2

I think there's good reason to be skeptical of the Russian actions here aside from the DI link - which is about their propagandist efforts more than the facts on the ground.

The facts on the ground suggest that the Russians have been gaming towards this very conclusion of events for some time now. They've had forces in South Ossetia for years, thumbing their noses at the Georgians who consider the territory theirs. Now, they started skirmishes with Georgian forces, and when the Georgians took to the offensive to push out the Russians, in come the main Russian assault with serious armor and even naval action to open a second front. The timing of those efforts suggests that the Russians had been prepared for this very eventuality.

Then, look at what kinds of claims had been made about the Georgian push into South Ossetia - that they engaged in ethnic cleansing and genocide. Yet, when you see various news reports, the facts show something quite different - the Russians flattening Georgian apartment buildings and attacking Georgian civilians with ruthlessness typcial to Russian military exploits of the past.

The Russians are loathsome here, and if you want to chastize the Georgians, it should be over their belief that the US and the West woudl come to their defense immediately. The most the US could do, and has done, is provide airlift capabilities to sent their peacekeepers from Iraq back to Georgia to defend the nation against the ongoing Russian invasion.

I suspect the US might be doing some more behind the scenes, but they can't do too much for fear of sparking a wider war or getting into a shooting match with the Russians directly.

384 Iron Fist[deleted]  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:18:43am
385 Sifty  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:18:51am

re: #379 American Jewess In Jerusalem

The wars are starting so fast I forget what number we are on. It's like a deli.

386 lifeofthemind  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:19:18am

re: #370 Colonel Panik

Vlad would kick his ass. He's a judo expert, and is much younger. Fred might even fall asleep on the way to the alley and never make it.
Duncan Hunter, on the other hand, was an Army Ranger and may know a few moves that would surprise Vlad.

2 to the body 1 to the head. I don't care how many dance moves the guy has.

387 Saif al Kufr  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:19:20am

re: #368 redc1c4

Not much of a poster, only post when I disagree and there's not usually anything for me to disagree with at LGF.

When I do post, I like to keep it civil...

388 galloping granny  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:19:21am

re: #367 maddogg

I say would we are getting pretty sorry service/dollar expenditure from the CIA.

Thank the Congress that has tied them up in so darned many knots they might just as well take their marbles and go home.

389 sattv4u2  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:19:37am

re: #368 redc1c4

all that from someone with a whopping 17 posts...

who's spawn are you?

number of posts determines relevence? Then I guess anything I post (6900) trumps yours (5350)

390 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:19:40am

re: #379 American Jewess In Jerusalem

Why is the Discovery Institute pro-Russia? Why would they be? What is the connection?

Secondly, are we stepping into WWIII with this Russian invasion?


* * *

The USA is involved in a world war right now while others sit on their hands!

It's Russia who's stepping in illegally okkupyin.

391 Westward Ho  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:19:47am

BTW please do not construe the BBC coverage to be wholly pro russian, they went way out of their way to show the brave president of Georgia outside in flak jackets trying to put on a brave face under terrible circumstances..

392 CIA Reject  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:19:58am

re: #373 lifeofthemind

Indeed.

393 sattv4u2  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:19:59am

re: #371 wiffersnapper

I have wondered the same thing. Didn't Georgia "attack" first by trying to take back Ossetia or something? Either way, I think Georgia is still in the right, and Russia is the real aggressor

thanks

394 FrogMarch  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:20:11am

re: #279 Dustoff-507

They will still bame Bush... It's all they know how to do

And that will get old and backfire on them.

395 Killgore Trout  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:20:11am

re: #371 wiffersnapper

I think "who started it" or even "who's right" are almost minor issues here. Russia was looking for an excuse to crush Georgia and took this opportunity. They've been reverting to old Soviet style paranoia for quite some time and I think this is just another manifestation.

396 redc1c4  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:20:20am

re: #353 Killgore Trout

I think the Georgians are so outclassed that no amount of help would save them. They'll be crushed by the time we could mobilize. NATO could possibly get involved but I don't think they're willing to do anything.

why do we need to mobilize? from what i've seen/read, cutting the major roads could be done in one night of bombing. the terrain is mountainous, with multiple tunnels. target the tunnels and any sheer faces where land slides will carry away the roads, and presto, the russian mech forces are just poorly equipped infantry a long way from home, with no resupply. if the russians go for airlift, use the MANPADS to hit them over the drop zone approaches. big targets flying low & slow.

think asymmetrical warfare: you don't have to take them head on, you just have to hit their weaknesses.

397 American Jewess In Jerusalem  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:20:27am

re: #385 Sifty

The wars are starting so fast I forget what number we are on. It's like a deli.

"Order up!"

398 Quintus_Arius  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:20:35am

re: #300 Athos

Thanks for that reply. Much more knowledge (and intelligence) here at LGF than any other blog on the net. With few exceptions, Charles has a magnificent following.

399 realwest  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:20:40am

re: #332 The Other Les
HEY Y'ALL DON'T WANT YOUR NAME OUT HERE DO YA?!
I've reported it but you should to - get Charles to delete it immediately unless you WANT your name out there!

400 Dark_Falcon  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:20:56am

re: #348 huggy77

this is very sad... The Georgian people have been very supportive of us... We are letting them down.

Our options in this matter are very limited. We can act economically and perhaps diplomatically, but we have no military option here. The bottom line is that if no measures short of war will stop Putin from taking what he whats from Georgia, then Putin will take what he wants.

401 sattv4u2  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:21:12am

re: #383 lawhawk

thank you. You state "They've had forces in South Ossetia for years, thumbing their noses at the Georgians who consider the territory theirs"

Whose territory IS it?

402 Sifty  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:21:56am

re: #391 Westward Ho

Did the BBC broadcast his GPS coordinates along the bottom of the screen?

403 Ariel  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:22:16am

How about if we go all in - help Georgia and attack Iran at the same time? The Russians might get distracted if we go for a two-front strike against both of their games.

404 paradox42  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:22:17am

re: #382 galloping granny

They have a couple thousand nukes IIRC, that we know about. Lets say that only 1% are in full working, then that's 10 nukes per 1,000 which is all they need to jump start Armageddon.

405 yma o hyd  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:22:35am

re: #364 Pvt Bin Jammin

Here's a good blog post with some great maps:
[Link: www.thedonovan.com...]

Yep - thats an an excellent blog post!

406 J.S.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:22:36am

re: #367 maddogg

I agree...I mean, really...there had to have been "clues" of what Russia intended...(you don't get a land, air, and sea attack without first building up your forces...)

407 CommonCents  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:23:22am

re: #370 Colonel Panik

Vlad would kick his ass. He's a judo expert, and is much younger. Fred might even fall asleep on the way to the alley and never make it.
Duncan Hunter, on the other hand, was an Army Ranger and may know a few moves that would surprise Vlad.

Yeah! And didn't you see the studly pictures of Vlad fishing? Scaaary.
/s

408 redc1c4  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:23:38am

re: #359 sattv4u2

I know this will place me in a very small minority, and at odds with Charles, but could Charles (and most of our) disdain for the Discovery Institutes stance on evolution be clouding our judgement of their stance on this conflict? As much as I've read about this "war", there does not really seem to be a clear cut culprit. Conflicting "facts', times, "he saids/ she saids" muddle the issue. I have no love nor trust of Putin. I have posted here before that I beleive his ultimate goal is to be THE regions #1 (I stated they cannot be the WORLDS #1, that train left the station thanks to Reagan/ Thatcher et al).
Is DI pro- Russia? Of course, or else they would not have a Russia Blog! But for me to immediatly jump on the "IT'S RUSSIA'S FAULT" bandwagon just because Charles says so would morally and conciously be wrong of me (and perhaps you also)

If this gets me in trouble with any of you, or a stern look from the head lizard, so be it.

no clear cut culprit? who invaded a sovereign nation? russia. who instigated the unrest in said nation? russia. who has continued to attack said sovereign nation even after their original demands were met? russia. who has ignored outside intermediaries trying to stop the fighting? russia.

you're right, it's *so* hard to tell who's to blame here.

409 mglazer  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:24:01am

Meanwhile...

Back at the World Olympics where the important stuff is going on like Bush signing a law to allow Anyone with Aids/HIV into the USA and force tax payers to pay for their healthcare.

410 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:24:07am

re: #400 Dark_Falcon

Our options in this matter are very limited. We can act economically and perhaps diplomatically, but we have no military option here. The bottom line is that if no measures short of war will stop Putin from taking what he whats from Georgia, then Putin will take what he wants.

* * *
World Citizen Metro Wimpfactor not wanted here.

411 The Other Les  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:24:12am

re: #142 Kenneth

The Turkish gov't has issued a statement in support of the Georgians.

Some folks have been calling for sending a Carrier Battle Group into the Black Sea.

The Asia Minor peninsula is an unsinkable aircraft base.

412 redc1c4  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:24:32am

re: #397 American Jewess In Jerusalem

"OrderGuns up!"

/old GPMG line...

413 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:25:24am

re: #409 mglazer

Meanwhile...

Back at the World Olympics where the important stuff is going on like Bush signing a law to allow Anyone with Aids/HIV into the USA and force tax payers to pay for their healthcare.

Huh?

414 lawhawk  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:25:37am

re: #401 sattv4u2

From the maps I've seen, I'd have to say it was Georgia's. The Russians have been backing the South Ossetian separatists for years.

However, given that folks in that part of the world like to go back not just to the last decade or even 100 years ago, the question becomes a wee bit more difficult.

415 redc1c4  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:25:37am

re: #411 The Other Les

Some folks have been calling for sending a Carrier Battle Group into the Black Sea.

The Asia Minor peninsula is an unsinkable aircraft base.

as i understand things, the Black Sea is kind of small for a CBG...

416 opnion  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:25:38am

re: #259 realwest

When were you there and where were you when you saw them? The Chinese were STILL fighting the North Vietnamese on their border when I was there (class of '70) and the trucks I saw on the Ho Chi Minh "Trail" were all Soviet built.
Not denying that China didn't send SOME supplies to the NVA, but all the SAM's used were Russian made as were the radar systems that guided them and the few tanks and fighter aircraft used by the NVA were all Soviet made.


Real, there were Chineese troops in South Viet Nam.
No units but Chineese volunteers atached to the NVA.
The Chinnese & Viet Namese hate each othe for age old feuds, but had to show some solidarity with a socialist brother.
However the Chineese were not pleased that we did not have a better outcome.

417 Dustoff-507  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:25:49am

re: #407 CommonCents

Vlad would kick his ass. He's a judo expert
===

I have to wonder, saying he is with no real proof (judo) means nothing.

418 J.S.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:26:07am

re: #383 lawhawk

Even right now, btw, there's a "dispute" between MSM outlets about whether or not Gori is under Russian occupation. The Kremlin says, "No. there are no Russians in Gori." The people on the ground (even the BBC) say that Gori is under Russian occupation.

419 lifeofthemind  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:26:12am

The US should raise our armed forces by 15% a year for four years. That would get us back up to a million man army from the current 530,000 active duty and get the Navy and Air Force also up to where they can respond to a flexible set of simultaneous threats in a world that is messier than it was 20 years ago. Sorry children the Peace Dividend was a pipe dream.

420 Sifty  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:26:12am

re: #413 J.D.

I thought Bono was paying for it?

421 sattv4u2  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:26:14am

re: #408 redc1c4

no clear cut culprit? who invaded a sovereign nation? russia. who instigated the unrest in said nation? russia. who has continued to attack said sovereign nation even after their original demands were met? russia. who has ignored outside intermediaries trying to stop the fighting? russia.

you're right, it's *so* hard to tell who's to blame here.

Actually, Georgian forces went into South Ossetian 1st, In my #401 I ask whpose territory is that?

422 Spenser (with an S)  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:26:31am

re: #375 reine.de.tout

Wow, the Disco Institute apparently likes Islamists and bloodthirsty commies if they support their narrow views, but a Bible-believing Christian like myself who thinks the earth is more than 6-8k years old? Dangerous!

423 mglazer  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:27:05am

re: #332 The Other Les

He's very busy at the great Chinese commie olympics wasting his careless time and signing laws to help our country become weaker.

He Doesn't care

424 Sifty  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:27:13am

re: #417 Dustoff-507

Elvis was a black belt and a secret agent too.

/Just sayin. love the King

425 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:27:13am

re: #418 J.S.

Even right now, btw, there's a "dispute" between MSM outlets about whether or not Gori is under Russian occupation. The Kremlin says, "No. there are no Russians in Gori." The people on the ground (even the BBC) say that Gori is under Russian occupation.

* * *
World news is taking Baghdad Bob's opinion seriously. Again!

426 Fat Bastard Vegetarian  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:27:37am

re: #424 Sifty

eggzakly the same thing I was about to post.

427 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:27:48am

re: #420 Sifty

Well, so did I. But anyway, I think George Soros has the money to do it.

428 yma o hyd  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:27:58am

re: #401 sattv4u2

thank you. You state "They've had forces in South Ossetia for years, thumbing their noses at the Georgians who consider the territory theirs"

Whose territory IS it?

It is, in fact Georgia's.

429 Kosh's Shadow  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:28:01am

re: #396 redc1c4

why do we need to mobilize? from what i've seen/read, cutting the major roads could be done in one night of bombing. the terrain is mountainous, with multiple tunnels. target the tunnels and any sheer faces where land slides will carry away the roads, and presto, the russian mech forces are just poorly equipped infantry a long way from home, with no resupply. if the russians go for airlift, use the MANPADS to hit them over the drop zone approaches. big targets flying low & slow.

think asymmetrical warfare: you don't have to take them head on, you just have to hit their weaknesses.

We could have our special forces help Georgia blow up the supply routes without using any fancy weapons; nothing traceable. Use some Czech semtex instead of American-made stuff.

430 sattv4u2  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:28:14am

re: #414 lawhawk

From the maps I've seen, I'd have to say it was Georgia's. The Russians have been backing the South Ossetian separatists for years.

However, given that folks in that part of the world like to go back not just to the last decade or even 100 years ago, the question becomes a wee bit more difficult.

thats my point. One nation claims a region to be "theirs", even though there it is not clear. That region is a mess, in that regard

431 Sifty  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:28:24am

re: #426 Fat Bastard Vegetarian

We are smrat.

432 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:28:32am

re: #419 lifeofthemind

The US should raise our armed forces by 15% a year for four years. That would get us back up to a million man army from the current 530,000 active duty and get the Navy and Air Force also up to where they can respond to a flexible set of simultaneous threats in a world that is messier than it was 20 years ago. Sorry children the Peace Dividend was a pipe dream.

* * *
China has a million man army right now, though they're busy parading in Olympics events.

We could use a few good men.

433 Ojoe  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:28:33am

re: #366 paradox42

It is very important that the most moral people have the biggest weapons.

Upon the instant that they do not, the evil prey upon the innocent.

434 Quilly Mammoth  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:28:43am

re: #396 redc1c4

why do we need to mobilize? from what i've seen/read, cutting the major roads could be done in one night of bombing. the terrain is mountainous, with multiple tunnels. target the tunnels and any sheer faces where land slides will carry away the roads, and presto, the russian mech forces are just poorly equipped infantry a long way from home, with no resupply. if the russians go for airlift, use the MANPADS to hit them over the drop zone approaches. big targets flying low & slow.

think asymmetrical warfare: you don't have to take them head on, you just have to hit their weaknesses.

A flight of F117 several days ago could have put that exact scenario in play. Which is why I suspect they've come in through Abkhazia.

435 Dustoff-507  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:28:43am

re: #424 Sifty

LOL... and drugs kicked his butt!

436 J.S.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:28:46am

Now the BBC is saying that Senaki, Georgia is under Russian attack...(I believe it's becoming clear that Russia intends to annex all of Georgia.)

437 maninthemiddle  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:28:49am

I am sickened by the left's rationalizing and obfuscating the actions of the Russians.

As I have said for the last week - this is purely about Georgia's dalliance with the West, and that nice fat pipeline that is an obstacle to Russia's hegemony over supplies to Europe - as is their oil port.

It is being reported that the port facilities - through which 1 million barrels a day flow - has been destroyed. The capital of Tbilisi has been bombed.

The pipeline has been attacked several times, and has been severely damaged.

The Russians not only have bombed Georgian targets in the western province of Abkhazia, but have massed significant armor and mechanized infantry.

Abkhazia (which is part of Georgia), you see, is flat - all the better to sweep into central Georgia if the conflict continues.

I too had hopes for a change in the new Russia. At this point, however, support of Putin ranks of the same mental detritus that led the far left to - for so many years - bestow moral equivalency with the West on the Soviet Union.

This really is about imperialism and oil.

438 mglazer  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:28:56am

re: #413 J.D.

USA to open borders to those with AIDS

[Link: www.mysanantonio.com...]

Signed by Bush

439 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:29:09am

re: #433 Ojoe

It is very important that the most moral people have the biggest weapons.

Upon the instant that they do not, the evil prey upon the innocent.

Too true.

440 Dark_Falcon  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:29:19am

re: #396 redc1c4

why do we need to mobilize? from what i've seen/read, cutting the major roads could be done in one night of bombing. the terrain is mountainous, with multiple tunnels. target the tunnels and any sheer faces where land slides will carry away the roads, and presto, the russian mech forces are just poorly equipped infantry a long way from home, with no resupply. if the russians go for airlift, use the MANPADS to hit them over the drop zone approaches. big targets flying low & slow.

think asymmetrical warfare: you don't have to take them head on, you just have to hit their weaknesses.

And when their fighters scramble against our bombers, what then? Who knows how they might see a group of American bombers heading their way. Georgia is not worth a shooting war with Russia.

441 freetoken  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:29:36am

re: #359 sattv4u2

About the DI... I suspect that any proclivities at LGF in feelings about Russia are strongly influenced by anything the DI believes.

Perhaps I am in a small minority here (not unusual...) but I find it hard to feel any strong support for the Georgian's territorial claims, even though I do believe Russia is clearly over using force by stepping outside of S. Ossetia.

All throughout Asia there are numerous small groups at conflict (many times centuries old)... We (the US) should not be suckered into having to take sides in these disputes, many of which we really can't contribute much positive. As such I've never been in favor of expanding NATO outside of Europe.

442 Bubblehead II  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:30:09am

re: #363 Colonel Panik

You mean this one?

443 Saif al Kufr  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:30:51am

re: #375 reine.de.tout

Wow - from that link - a lot of very telling information:

Also from that link, some more telling information:

[Link: larussophobe.wordpress.com...]

Top 10 reasons for being a russophobe:

10 Russian cuisine is wretched.
9 Russians are greedy and arrogant.
8 Russia is sick and doesn’t care.
7 Russians are lazy and inefficient.
6 Sports and Russia are like oil and water.
5 Vladimir Vladimirovich Putin.
4 Russians are crazed authoritarians.
3 Nobody likes Russia.
2 Russia is insanely aggressive and militaristic.
1 Russia hates families, especially women and children.

Sounds like this La Russophobe is a classy fellow.

444 JHW  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:30:54am

Some of this stuff sounds right out of the shitty days of the Cold War. This from a Russian source, no doubt keeping the folks back home informed who they consider really responsible for all this.

Aug. 11, 2008 U.S. Military Instructors Command Hirelings in Georgia Thousands of mercenaries are fighting for Georgia in this burning conflict with South Ossetia. They are commanded by the U.S. military instructors, RIA Novosti reported with reference to a high-ranked officer of Russia’s military intelligence. “From 2,500 to 3,000 mercenaries fight against Russia’s peacekeepers on behalf of Georgia,” the unnamed source said. Amid them are the natives of Ukraine, some Baltic states and the Caucasus regions. The U.S. military instructors directly command and coordinate actions of mercenaries without being involved in actual fighting, the source specified. According to intelligence data, there are roughly 1,000 military instructors of the United States in Georgia. Task force of Russia has annihilated a few groups of mercenaries. Some of mercenaries have been captured, and investigators are working with them, the source said.

I especially liked "the unnamed source said" , weasel words used by journalists world wide when they try to snow their readership.

Kommersant, Moscow

445 sattv4u2  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:31:29am

re: #441 freetoken

About the DI... I suspect that any proclivities at LGF in feelings about Russia are strongly influenced by anything the DI believes.

Perhaps I am in a small minority here (not unusual...) but I find it hard to feel any strong support for the Georgian's territorial claims, even though I do believe Russia is clearly over using force by stepping outside of S. Ossetia.

All throughout Asia there are numerous small groups at conflict (many times centuries old)... We (the US) should not be suckered into having to take sides in these disputes, many of which we really can't contribute much positive. As such I've never been in favor of expanding NATO outside of Europe.

you said it better than I phrased it, thanks

446 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:31:36am

re: #438 mglazer

USA to open borders to those with AIDS

[Link: www.mysanantonio.com...]

Signed by Bush

Well, true, but it is a little more complicated than that.

447 CommonCents  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:32:07am

re: #417 Dustoff-507

Vlad would kick his ass. He's a judo expert
===

I have to wonder, saying he is with no real proof (judo) means nothing.

I'm not standing up the Judo comment. I was busting chops on his shirtless fishing photo-op. However, I wouldn't be surprised with the Judo comment since he was in the KGB.

448 mglazer  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:32:11am

re: #446 J.D.

Yeah taxpayers foot the bill for their health once in

449 Sifty  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:32:43am

I'll go ape-shit on Putinia if they mess with Ireland. I'll start my own damn army of volunteers.

The 1st Guinness Irregulars

450 realwest  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:33:07am

re: #353 Killgore Trout
With all due respect my friend, all we are or have been suggesting, is to close down (bomb) the THREE roads into Georgia through the mountains, give the Georgian's relief from the Russian bombing by using, if necessary our Airforce and Naval Air capability which is already mobilized in Iraq and could be fairly quickly (less than 18 hours) supplemented by additonal air assests.

It is, as I've said somewhere up above(!) not a question of military capability, but of WILL. We have an ally in Georgia - which sent 2,000 troops into Iraq to fight on our side - and are badly letting them down - not even recalling our Russian Ambassador for consultations, no striking Russia off the list of Most Favored Nations trade documents, and other non-military methods to sorta, ya know GRAB PUTIN'S attention.
And if we DON'T stand by this ally, how on earth could Israel, South Korea, Taiwan and other "allies" think we'd stand by them, either?

451 Saif al Kufr  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:33:14am

re: #408 redc1c4

no clear cut culprit? who invaded a sovereign nation? russia. who instigated the unrest in said nation? russia. who has continued to attack said sovereign nation even after their original demands were met? russia. who has ignored outside intermediaries trying to stop the fighting? russia.

This sounds like a leftist argument against our war in Iraq with "russia" replacing "Amerikkka."

452 Honorary Yooper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:33:22am

re: #421 sattv4u2

Actually, Georgian forces went into South Ossetian 1st, In my #401 I ask whpose territory is that?

South Ossetia is Georgian territory. The Georgians were dealing with rebels in a province. The Russians invaded another country. Big difference there.

453 Iron Fist[deleted]  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:33:27am
454 The Other Les  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:33:51am

re: #252 tfc3rid

Russia out of Georgia now... Keep your hands off Florida and Alabama as well...

People have no idea what this all about and some I talked to yesterday actually thought the Russians were bombing Georgia, yes, OUR Georgia...

Putin needs to be put in his place. We are all talk and no action on this one... And Russia begins her rebirth...

If this isn't stopped now someday they WILL be boumbing our Georgia.

455 mglazer  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:33:53am

America will do nothing and lose another ally

great leaders

456 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:33:59am

re: #448 mglazer

Yeah taxpayers foot the bill for their health once in

I don't think California would so much mind doing it. We can send them all there.

457 Cygnus  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:34:19am

re: #176 itellu3times

This is all Rush Limbaugh's fault, he took the day off.

No, it's Kirby Wilbur's (KVI in Seattle) fault. He took the whole week off!

458 reine.de.tout  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:34:21am

re: #359 sattv4u2

I know this will place me in a very small minority, and at odds with Charles, but could Charles (and most of our) disdain for the Discovery Institutes stance on evolution be clouding our judgement of their stance on this conflict? As much as I've read about this "war", there does not really seem to be a clear cut culprit. Conflicting "facts', times, "he saids/ she saids" muddle the issue. I have no love nor trust of Putin. I have posted here before that I beleive his ultimate goal is to be THE regions #1 (I stated they cannot be the WORLDS #1, that train left the station thanks to Reagan/ Thatcher et al).
Is DI pro- Russia? Of course, or else they would not have a Russia Blog! But for me to immediatly jump on the "IT'S RUSSIA'S FAULT" bandwagon just because Charles says so would morally and conciously be wrong of me (and perhaps you also)

If this gets me in trouble with any of you, or a stern look from the head lizard, so be it.

People may have had a suspicion what the DI's stance would have been, but written confirmation of their pro-Russian take on this didn't appear until after the conflict began and Charles posted about it, I think.

There are maps and explanatory materials here: re: #364 Pvt Bin Jammin

Here's a good blog post with some great maps:
[Link: www.thedonovan.com...]

459 freetoken  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:34:24am

re: #441 freetoken


... that should have been, "not influenced by..."

460 redc1c4  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:34:26am

re: #389 sattv4u2

number of posts determines relevence? Then I guess anything I post (6900) trumps yours (5350)

few posts, coupled with contrarian posts are a prime indicator of a troll coming out from under their bridge.

as for your posts on the subject at hand, your lack of understanding certainly trumps mine.

461 Dark_Falcon  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:34:29am

re: #410 alegrias

* * *
World Citizen Metro Wimpfactor not wanted here.

Sir, I am nothing of the kind. It is however, my belief that it would be unwise for us to attempt any sort of military intervention in Georgia. That doesn't mean we don't make Vlad the Impaler of Liberty pay. He needs to be punished for this. Our best option for that would be to immediately admit Ukraine to NATO coupled with well aimed sanctions. Again, I'm not some Obambi coward, but I don't want war with Russia either.

462 lifeofthemind  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:35:11am

re: #432 alegrias

* * *
China has a million man army right now, though they're busy parading in Olympics events.

We could use a few good men.

I am not calling for a wild mass mobilization. This is very in keeping with what we can afford and the size of our population. In WW-II with half the population we raised a 12,500,000 man military. We can easily afford to spend 5% of GDP on defense and keep 2,000,000 active duty in uniform across all services. The Chinese are a long term threat, if we act responsibly now then we forestall reckless miscalculation by them later. THe Russians are in a very weak position. They have some equipment due to the oil bubble but the structure and the demographics are against them. Putin shouldn't have tried this and he has to be seen to lose.

463 reine.de.tout  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:35:21am

re: #422 Spenser (with an S)

Wow, the Disco Institute apparently likes Islamists and bloodthirsty commies if they support their narrow views, but a Bible-believing Christian like myself who thinks the earth is more than 6-8k years old? Dangerous!

Huh?

464 realwest  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:35:22am

re: #364 Pvt Bin Jammin

Here's a good blog post with some great maps:
[Link: www.thedonovan.com...]


Most excellent PBJ! Thank you!

465 Charles  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:35:33am

re: #359 sattv4u2

I know this will place me in a very small minority, and at odds with Charles, but could Charles (and most of our) disdain for the Discovery Institutes stance on evolution be clouding our judgement of their stance on this conflict?

No.

466 Sifty  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:35:51am

re: #456 J.D.

Great. as if we need another aids factory besides Frisco.

Another bunch of immigrants stamped POSTAGE DUE.

467 Dustoff-507  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:35:52am

re: #440 Dark_Falcon

Georgia is not worth a shooting war with Russia.
===

So when do we stand up? Just wondering.

I don't think Puttin has that big of B*lls to go head to head.

468 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:35:55am

...in a word...

469 soccerdad  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:36:11am

re: #43 blutonazi98

the US is Flying Georgian troops home. Could Russia interpret this as action by the US against them?

Yes -- they have noticed and said it is 'unhelpful interference'.

470 opnion  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:36:15am

re: #449 Sifty

I'll go ape-shit on Putinia if they mess with Ireland. I'll start my own damn army of volunteers.

The 1st Guinness Irregulars

Man, am I down with that. Don't mess with the Olde Sod, or will go all Brian Buru on ya!

471 reine.de.tout  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:36:15am

re: #422 Spenser (with an S)

Wow, the Disco Institute apparently likes Islamists and bloodthirsty commies if they support their narrow views, but a Bible-believing Christian like myself who thinks the earth is more than 6-8k years old? Dangerous!

OK, ignore my previous "huh?". (I must not be quite awake yet or sumpin).

472 quickjustice  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:36:18am

It's no secret that the U.S. has been providing military assistance to the Georgians for some time. From the reports of Russian invasions of Georgian territory that is undisputed, it sounds like it's time to move a carrier group to the area, and start providing some air cover to the Georgians.

Without air supremacy, the war will turn against the Russians quickly.

473 redc1c4  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:36:18am

re: #421 sattv4u2

Actually, Georgian forces went into South Ossetian 1st, In my #401 I ask whpose territory is that?

it's part of Georgia. russia had been fomenting the trouble that caused the Georgian government to take military action to stop it.

474 Killgore Trout  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:36:41am

re: #450 realwest

I think whatever help we give the Georgians would only postpone the inevitable. If we had the will we could offer them around the clock air support and permanent bases for ground forces but I don't think Bush is even considering that. It does stink that we are going to turn our backs on an ally but I'm afraid that's exactly what is going to happen.

475 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:36:55am

re: #466 Sifty

Great. as if we need another aids factory besides Frisco.

Another bunch of immigrants stamped POSTAGE DUE.

I was kidding.
Well, sort of kidding...

476 HoosierHoops  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:37:22am

re: #458 reine.de.tout
good link reine..thanks

477 Cognito  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:37:23am

One of the most fascinating things about the Georgia-Russia conflict, to me at least, is studying who exactly is directing Russia's moves. Is it the newish President Medvedev? Or is Putin still calling the shots?

So far there's no sign that Czar Putin has relinquished an ounce of power.

478 Thunderbottom  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:37:26am

Not to worry - when this is all over, President Saakashvili will still have a position in the new Georgian government - as Vladimir Putin's bitch (you must have seen the photos of Vladimir Putin strolling along with Russian President Mendeleev following right behind, hanging on to one Vlad's turned-inside-out trouser pockets).

479 Dustoff-507  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:37:52am

re: #447 CommonCents


I wasn't saying you did... the dang system posted before I finshed the rest of my writing... )-: dang.

480 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:37:53am
481 J.S.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:37:58am

re: #452 Honorary Yooper

Georgia is a democracy; Georgia has/had sent troops to Iraq; Georgia is pro-U.S.A.; there have been hints that Georgia would/could become a member of NATO.

482 sattv4u2  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:38:08am

re: #452 Honorary Yooper

South Ossetia is Georgian territory. The Georgians were dealing with rebels in a province. The Russians invaded another country. Big difference there.

Actually, Goergia had previously promised South Ossetia autonomy for yeard now to allow it to unify with North Ossetia under the Russian Federation.
As I stated above the entire regions geographic and autonomous lines have been a mess for centuries, even under the old Soviet Union

483 reine.de.tout  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:38:29am

re: #401 sattv4u2

thank you. You state "They've had forces in South Ossetia for years, thumbing their noses at the Georgians who consider the territory theirs"

Whose territory IS it?

There is a South Ossetia that is Georgian territory; there is a North Ossetia that is Russian territory.

484 paradox42  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:38:33am

re: #433 Ojoe

Unfortunately as it stands now, they have ICBMs as well. The only way we could do anything more than glare is to render their ICBM arsenal irrelavent and harmless. We need a better weapon, one that can neutralize their nukes and one that they have no means of countering. A weapon that is right now only in the mind of a sci-fi writer. Even then it would be painful. Russia's geography is a blender for ground troops.

The near future looks very bad and with Obama as president, I imagine our superweapon development budget will be severely slashed. We'll need those superweapons if we ever want to stop Russia without triggering the end times.

485 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:38:43am

re: #430 sattv4u2

That region is a mess, in that regard.

True. It's been a crossroads of invasion and migration for millennia. The ethnic map looks like an Italian restaurant after a food fight. That's what's driving the current (and long-running) feud. There's no simple long-term answer, unless some new kind of trans-national quasi-governmental entity is invented -- one which can overlay national boundaries.

/biting my tongue in #$&%# frustration

486 Wendya  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:38:54am

re: #371 wiffersnapper

I have wondered the same thing. Didn't Georgia "attack" first by trying to take back Ossetia or something? Either way, I think Georgia is still in the right, and Russia is the real aggressor

Ossetia was never recognized as a part of Russia by anyone other than Russia.

Russia gave citizenship and passports to people in South Ossetia as a way of trying to claim the territory and use it to overwhelm Georgia.

487 LionFromzion  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:39:07am

I hope the Russians get "bled" pretty good in Georgia! Monsters!

488 Fat Bastard Vegetarian  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:39:28am

Simple question...
Why in the hell would anybody want to be POTUS right now?

489 Sifty  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:40:05am

re: #488 Fat Bastard Vegetarian

The cool towels.

490 Wendya  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:40:19am

re: #486 Wendya

Ossetia was never recognized as a part of Russia by anyone other than Russia.

That should read South Ossetia.

491 realwest  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:40:43am

re: #400 Dark_Falcon
" but we have no military option here." With all respect, that's just not true. I know it's a LOOONG thread, but if you look above at my, jcm's, and many others comments out here, you'll see that we do have some military options - not GREAT ones, I'll grant you, but we do have some.

492 sattv4u2  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:40:44am

re: #460 recd1c4

few posts, coupled with contraries posts are a prime indicator of a troll coming out from under their bridge.

as for your posts on the subject at hand, your lack of understanding certainly trumps mine.

way to go ad hominen on both me and the "troll" . If you can't win an argument on it's merits, try throwing mud !

493 Dark_Falcon  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:41:14am

re: #467 Dustoff-507

Georgia is not worth a shooting war with Russia.
===

So when do we stand up? Just wondering.

I don't think Puttin has that big of B*lls to go head to head.

Ukraine would be my choice for a ground of contention. Done right, pressure could be brought to bear on Russia and we could place sufficient forces on the ground to deter attack.

494 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:41:20am

re: #488 Fat Bastard Vegetarian

Simple question...
Why in the hell would anybody want to be POTUS right now?


And the plane.

Actually, I think there are really still people who believe they can help make the world a better place.
Well, I know there are.

495 sngnsgt  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:41:27am

I'm sure the Obamessiah has a plan for this too.

496 trailortrash  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:41:28am

we are trying to evacuate our people there now...

497 sattv4u2  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:41:31am

re: #483 reine.de.tout

There is a South Ossetia that is Georgian territory; there is a North Ossetia that is Russian territory.

True, and Georgia has been promising for a long time more autonomy for the south so they can re-unite with the north

498 lifeofthemind  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:41:46am

re: #488 Fat Bastard Vegetarian

Simple question...
Why in the hell would anybody want to be POTUS right now?

It's the pension plan

499 jorline  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:41:49am

re: #229 pat

From the KOS thread.


Did Bushco have a hand in starting the Russia-Georgia conflict?
Yes
39% 13 votes
No
60% 20 votes

| 33 votes | Vote

Down over $2.00 a barrel here.

Damn Kos Kids and their tinfoil hats.

500 experiencedtraveller  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:41:56am

re: #461 Dark_Falcon

I'm with you Dark_Falcon. Georgia is a bridge too far.

/It doesn't mean we like what's happening...

501 Dustoff-507  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:42:06am

re: #491 realwest

Yeah buddy. After being shot it... You learn the tactics of war! (-:

502 mglazer  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:42:09am

Israel isn't worth a shooting war either.

Would America help Israel When they were being bombed by Lebanon and syria?

Of course not

we don't really care about others

Thats how hedonists live only for their own pleasure like the greeks, I mean Olympics perfection of the body not the spirit

The world is messed up lots of heathens, hedonists - I call them modernists from greece to today - same thing - 15% of the world glorify the perfection of the human body over the spirit and God. Thats why the helenists that were fought by the Jews in Greecian ancient times are now the beliefs the entire world embrace.

Pathetic hedonisim is hellenism and that means heathenism.
Welcome to the Summer Olympics human idolators

503 HoosierHoops  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:42:16am

re: #488 Fat Bastard Vegetarian

Simple question...
Why in the hell would anybody want to be POTUS right now?

me me me me!
pick me!
/raises hand...I'll drop those ruskies like a bad habit..

504 paradox42  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:42:43am

re: #488 Fat Bastard Vegetarian

It varies by candidate
McCain: Love of country.
Hillary: Power, plain and simple.
Obama: Depending on when you ask him, either hope, change, or both.

505 Kenneth  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:42:46am

re: #421 sattv4u2

Before Georgia gained independence from the Soviet Union, Ossetia was part of Georgia. The Russians had moved thousands of Russians to Ossetia to colonize the area: Russification" was the long standing policy. Since Georgian independence, Russia has supported separatists in Osssetia and many other areas in the now independent Caucasus region. At the same time, Russia has brutally suppressed independence among nationalist groups with the Russian federation (ie Chechnya, Igushetia...)

Clearly, Russia is acting to extend Russian control & empire. This has nothing to do with the self-determination of Ossetian people.

506 mglazer  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:42:47am

re: #487 LionFromzion


Dont bet on it
no one is gonna help Georgia
and Georgia will lose

507 sattv4u2  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:43:04am

re: #485 pre-Boomer Marine brat

True. It's been a crossroads of invasion and migration for millennia. The ethnic map looks like an Italian restaurant after a food fight. That's what's driving the current (and long-running) feud. There's no simple long-term answer, unless some new kind of trans-national quasi-governmental entity is invented -- one which can overlay national boundaries.

/biting my tongue in #$&%# frustration

I agree ,, but hey , lets meet at that restaurant BEFORE the food fight. I'll buy

508 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:43:16am

re: #503 HoosierHoops

me me me me!
pick me!
/raises hand...I'll drop those ruskies like a bad habit..

See?

509 Sifty  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:43:27am

re: #500 experiencedtraveller

Maybe we can send a nice card and a wreath after the massacre.

510 realwest  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:43:30am

re: #416 opnion Ah well, I was perhaps waaay too far to the West to be aware of that!

511 opnion  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:44:01am

This is not a perfect analogy, but lets say Arizona decided that they wished no longer to be part of the U.S?
They claim a diofferent language & culture & feel at home with Mexico.
Beyond that they kinda pushed Anglos out.
Let"s say Mexico sends in "Peacekeepers".
How are we going to feel about that?

512 itellu3times  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:44:02am

re: #396 redc1c4

why do we need to mobilize? from what i've seen/read, cutting the major roads could be done in one night of bombing. the terrain is mountainous, with multiple tunnels. target the tunnels and any sheer faces where land slides will carry away the roads, and presto, the russian mech forces are just poorly equipped infantry a long way from home, with no resupply. if the russians go for airlift, use the MANPADS to hit them over the drop zone approaches. big targets flying low & slow.

think asymmetrical warfare: you don't have to take them head on, you just have to hit their weaknesses.

Because once we start shooting at Russians anywhere, they may start shooting at us anywhere.

513 Dustoff-507  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:44:15am

re: #493 Dark_Falcon


We could help them both with out using our forces. Our air to ground systems would make a mess of Puttins planes. Then go after his tanks. You lose that, you lose the war! ( this we can supply them)

514 Kosh's Shadow  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:44:39am

re: #450 realwest

With all due respect my friend, all we are or have been suggesting, is to close down (bomb) the THREE roads into Georgia through the mountains, give the Georgian's relief from the Russian bombing by using, if necessary our Airforce and Naval Air capability which is already mobilized in Iraq and could be fairly quickly (less than 18 hours) supplemented by additonal air assests.

It is, as I've said somewhere up above(!) not a question of military capability, but of WILL. We have an ally in Georgia - which sent 2,000 troops into Iraq to fight on our side - and are badly letting them down - not even recalling our Russian Ambassador for consultations, no striking Russia off the list of Most Favored Nations trade documents, and other non-military methods to sorta, ya know GRAB PUTIN'S attention.
And if we DON'T stand by this ally, how on earth could Israel, South Korea, Taiwan and other "allies" think we'd stand by them, either?

And what message does this send to Iranians who want to overthrow the theocracy and want US support for that?

515 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:44:49am

re: #507 sattv4u2

I agree ,, but hey , lets meet at that restaurant BEFORE the food fight. I'll buy

You're on!

516 The Other Les  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:44:57am

re: #399 realwest

HEY Y'ALL DON'T WANT YOUR NAME OUT HERE DO YA?!
I've reported it but you should to - get Charles to delete it immediately unless you WANT your name out there!

I've put my name on a lot of things.

517 sattv4u2  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:45:20am

re: #488 Fat Bastard Vegetarian

Simple question...
Why in the hell would anybody want to be POTUS right now?

re: #498 lifeofthemind

It's the pension plan

naaahhh ,,, it's because you get great seats at all the cool sporting events ,,, Olympics ,, Super Bowl ,,, World Series ,,,

518 Wendya  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:45:22am

re: #440 Dark_Falcon

Georgia is not worth a shooting war with Russia.

Most of the world felt the same way about Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Poland, Czechoslovakia, Romania, Bulgaira, Albania. etc...

519 Cap'n DOC  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:45:22am

re: #321 lifeofthemind

LOL. These were in caves, marked "courtesy of", and no, we blew it all up...

520 LionFromzion  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:45:28am

re: #506 mglazer

Dont bet on it
no one is gonna help Georgia
and Georgia will lose

you're right! Noone will help Georgia! Dosen't mean im not rooting for more than a few body bags to be sent back home to Csar Putin!

521 Dustoff-507  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:45:32am

re: #500 experiencedtraveller

There is NO close bridge either. Do you think Puttin will stop after this?

522 Athos  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:45:33am

re: #474 Killgore Trout

It does stink that we are going to turn our backs on an ally but I'm afraid that's exactly what is going to happen.

That's the ultimate Catch-22 that we need to deal with. I believe that the last dozen years have proven without a doubt that the United Nations is as morally and intellectually bankrupt as the League of Nations was in the mid-1930's. It has also proven that the NATO alliance is an empty alliance that belongs in history with the Warsaw Pact.

Either this country decides that it has to use our strength to provide peace (Reagan's Peace through Strength) including the use of our economic and military strengths to protect the weak and stand up against thugs, tyrants, and those who insist on victimizing the weaker or we ignore these events and turn our focus inwards putting our attentions on improving this country...and becoming the self-centered, arrogant, elitist pinheads that so many on the left accuse us of being - yet call for us to do (ie Iraq wasn't worth the investment or treasure, etc.).

We should have learned from the 1930's & 1990's is that aggression ignored will ultimately have to be confronted at a later time when it will be more expensive to combat. We also should have learned from the 1970's that abandoning friends because we lack the will to support them will result in far fewer friends since they will be unable to trust us.

523 Sifty  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:46:12am

re: #513 Dustoff-507

yep. airdrop some Patriots and some Javelins. Maybe a few advisers to run the training.

524 redc1c4  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:46:29am

re: #440 Dark_Falcon

And when their fighters scramble against our bombers, what then? Who knows how they might see a group of American bombers heading their way. Georgia is not worth a shooting war with Russia.

they're going to *see* B-2's at night?... that will be a first.

as for a shooting war with russia, they have no navy worth the term, their strategic bomber forces are laughable,the missile forces are suspect due to maintenance issues, and they are unable to project power outside their contiguous border. take them on asymmetrically in Georgia, and they haven't a chance. asymmetrical will also deny them the grounds for a further widening of the war, since all we're going to do is support an ally internally. the bombs will fall in Georgia, and the supplies will be used there.

do nothing now, and you *will* have a problem in a few years.

525 Dark_Falcon  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:46:30am

re: #491 realwest

" but we have no military option here." With all respect, that's just not true. I know it's a LOOONG thread, but if you look above at my, jcm's, and many others comments out here, you'll see that we do have some military options - not GREAT ones, I'll grant you, but we do have some.

You are right about us having military options, I was wrong. My concern with those options is that they would run risks that I do not think Georgia is worth running.

526 vapig  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:46:39am

re: #512 itellu3times

That was the same response we got when we decided to go to war with Afghanistan/ Iraq.

I don't see that the repercussions in doing nothing are any less dire in this instance than the last.

527 RememberSekhmet?  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:47:27am

Anything we are doing right now is going to be under the radar. All assets in the area are dedicated either to helping with Iraq or keeping pressure on Iran. Would you put it past Putin to be doing this in part to draw off American assets from pressuring Iran so they can launch an expedition of their own? You forget what good friend Russia and Iran are.

Just like with Katrina, it takes time to call in a carrier group to somewhere like Norfolk, combat-load it, and send it in the right direction, either towards the Black Sea or towards the Persian Gulf to relieve a carrier group there. Unlike the Russians, we didn't have our military ready to jump into Georgia.

But I am sure we are doing what we can right now

528 opnion  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:47:48am

re: #510 realwest

Ah well, I was perhaps waaay too far to the West to be aware of that!

We were in I corp. We actually captured some of them. They wore Chineese uniforms.
It was really weird, but the whole experience was, wasn't it

529 HoosierHoops  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:47:49am

re: #511 opnion

This is not a perfect analogy, but lets say Arizona decided that they wished no longer to be part of the U.S?
They claim a diofferent language & culture & feel at home with Mexico.
Beyond that they kinda pushed Anglos out.
Let"s say Mexico sends in "Peacekeepers".
How are we going to feel about that?

As long as we get to keep Sedona and all the golf courses..who cares?
/heh

530 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:47:52am

re: #461 Dark_Falcon

Sir, I am nothing of the kind. It is however, my belief that it would be unwise for us to attempt any sort of military intervention in Georgia. That doesn't mean we don't make Vlad the Impaler of Liberty pay. He needs to be punished for this. Our best option for that would be to immediately admit Ukraine to NATO coupled with well aimed sanctions. Again, I'm not some Obambi coward, but I don't want war with Russia either.

* * *
Sorry, didn't mean to offend, just don't like Carter-like handwringing and passing batons to "diplomats" who were ASLEEP AT THE WHEEL again.

531 Sifty  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:48:00am

Paging Charlie Wilson...

532 A. van Hilten  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:48:28am

re: #75 Dustoff-507

Reuters is at it again.


[Link: russia-insider.livejournal.com...]

Are you saying that Reuters staged the pictures of Georgian civilians being butchered by Russian war criminals?

533 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:48:31am
534 J.S.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:48:39am

re: #511 opnion

So then the Mexicans come in militarily to take over Arizona, then, while they're at it they take over a couple of other states, then start bombing Washington, D.C. so how'd ya feel about it...

535 trailortrash  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:48:42am

if we are going to move,we need to move soon.
they are about to cut the country in half as the world sits on its thumbs...

536 reine.de.tout  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:48:45am

re: #497 sattv4u2

True, and Georgia has been promising for a long time more autonomy for the south so they can re-unite with the north

But as of now, it's still Georgian territory, I think.

Also, reuniting South Ossetia with the North doesn't create an autonomous Ossetia, I don't think. It simply would give Russia a larger Ossetia, part of which would have split Georgia.

537 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:48:46am

re: #511 opnion

This is not a perfect analogy, but lets say Arizona decided that they wished no longer to be part of the U.S?
They claim a diofferent language & culture & feel at home with Mexico.
Beyond that they kinda pushed Anglos out.
Let"s say Mexico sends in "Peacekeepers".
How are we going to feel about that?

Good point (having lived in Tucson for 25 years).

To draw the discussion out, see my frustrated, pie-in-the-sky suggestion in:
re: #485 pre-Boomer Marine brat

538 Wendya  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:48:54am

re: #497 sattv4u2

True, and Georgia has been promising for a long time more autonomy for the south so they can re-unite with the north

Saakashvili was elected under a promise to unite Georgia. Giving South Ossetia to Russia was never in the cards.

539 realwest  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:49:08am

re: #461 Dark_Falcon
But what do you do if Russia wants war with you?
Not standing by your allies in fear of being at war with Russia means that NONE of your allies can believe in your alliance with them.
None.

540 Cap'n DOC  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:49:14am

re: #528 opnion

Where in I CORPS and when? Please.

541 HoosierHoops  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:49:33am

re: #517 sattv4u2

naaahhh ,,, it's because you get great seats at all the cool sporting events ,,, Olympics ,, Super Bowl ,,, World Series ,,,

that would be a great perk..forgot about that...
ok folks..vote for the hoopster for POTUS...
/

542 A. van Hilten  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:49:48am

re: #89 Dustoff-507

LOL, that too... but this is in Russia, so what name do we use now?

Actually, this is in Georgia.

543 NY Nana  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:49:56am

There was just a bulletin on my news station, newsradio880, in NYC, that the American Embassy has evacuated about 150 Americans from Georgia...not on line yet.

544 opnion  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:50:02am

re: #529 HoosierHoops

As long as we get to keep Sedona and all the golf courses..who cares?
/heh

Yeah, could go for that. Sedona is one great place.

545 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:50:20am

re: #522 Athos

Well put.

546 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:50:27am

re: #543 NY Nana

There was just a bulletin on my news station, newsradio880, in NYC, that the American Embassy has evacuated about 150 Americans from Georgia...not on line yet.

What took so long?

547 Dark_Falcon  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:50:29am

re: #513 Dustoff-507

We could help them both with out using our forces. Our air to ground systems would make a mess of Puttins planes. Then go after his tanks. You lose that, you lose the war! ( this we can supply them)

How can we supply them. We may well be able to attack Russia with stealth aircraft, but airdrops are a different story. Supply drops have a history of going off course and the aircraft that would carry the supplies are not stealthy. The Russians could attack them and then we'd be looking at open war.

548 sattv4u2  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:50:46am

re: #538 Wendya

Saakashvili was elected under a promise to unite Georgia. Giving South Ossetia to Russia was never in the cards.

Although a Russian-mediated and OSCE-monitored ceasefire was implemented in South Ossetia in 1992, the Georgian-Ossetian conflict still remains unresolved even though a recent peace plan proposed by the government of Georgia promised the South Ossetians larger autonomy and pledged expanded international involvement in the political settlement of the conflict

[Link: en.wikipedia.org...]

549 Westward Ho  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:51:00am

re: #402 Sifty

Did the BBC broadcast his GPS coordinates along the bottom of the screen?

Can Russia precision bomb?

550 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:51:05am

re: #477 Cognito

One of the most fascinating things about the Georgia-Russia conflict, to me at least, is studying who exactly is directing Russia's moves. Is it the newish President Medvedev? Or is Putin still calling the shots?

So far there's no sign that Czar Putin has relinquished an ounce of power.

* * *
Medvedev is just lipstick on the Putin pig.

551 Dustoff-507  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:51:17am

re: #525 Dark_Falcon


You maybe right... The worse part of all. If Putin get's this country and the large supply of oil. He'll have the means to UP-Grade his forces.

The next battle could be far worse. Do we lose 100.000 or 100.000.000?

552 redc1c4  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:51:24am

re: #500 experiencedtraveller

I'm with you Dark_Falcon. Georgia is a bridge too far.

/It doesn't mean we like what's happening...

it is not. i defy you to prove otherwise.

553 Dianna  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:51:31am

re: #436 J.S.

Yes, that's exactly what's about to happen.

554 paradox42  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:51:45am

re: #550 alegrias

I once saw him on the news talking to a crowd and I swear I could see strings.

555 opnion  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:51:51am

re: #540 Cap'n DOC

Where in I CORPS and when? Please.

Parts of 66 & 67. We based in Dong Ha, but got to Con Thien, Cam Lo, Hue Phu Bai & the environs.
You too?

556 Dustoff-507  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:51:56am

re: #532 A. van Hilten

WHO ME...

557 Dianna  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:52:32am

re: #547 Dark_Falcon

Now or later, we are going to have to engage the Russians. I'd rather do it now, while Russia is extended.

558 Wendya  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:52:37am

re: #548 sattv4u2

Although a Russian-mediated and OSCE-monitored ceasefire was implemented in South Ossetia in 1992, the Georgian-Ossetian conflict still remains unresolved even though a recent peace plan proposed by the government of Georgia promised the South Ossetians larger autonomy and pledged expanded international involvement in the political settlement of the conflict

[Link: en.wikipedia.org...]

Expanded autonomy doesn't mean they get to become a part of Russia. South Ossetia would remain a part of Georgia

559 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:52:42am

re: #529 HoosierHoops

As long as we get to keep Sedona and all the golf courses..who cares?
/heh

Oh m'Gawd NO! Give 'em Sedona!

/moonbats galore

560 Honorary Yooper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:52:53am

re: #535 trailortrash

if we are going to move,we need to move soon.
they are about to cut the country in half as the world sits on its thumbs...

It's Czechoslovakia all over again.

561 Dianna  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:52:57am

re: #549 Westward Ho

Evidently not.

562 redc1c4  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:52:58am

re: #525 Dark_Falcon

You are right about us having military options, I was wrong. My concern with those options is that they would run risks that I do not think Georgia is worth running.

dropping bombs inside Georgia, at the request of the Georgian government is risky? giving them supplies that they will use themselves is risky?

the only risk i see is in doing nothing, because we're afraid of the big bad russian bear, who isn't that big nor bad.

563 willowone  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:53:23am

re: #472 quickjustice is that a real option can we do it? no snarking here, is it possible without it becoming full fledged war with iran stalking from behind? i wish seriously i feel we should assist , but can we.

564 Wendya  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:53:33am

re: #559 pre-Boomer Marine brat

Oh m'Gawd NO! Give 'em Sedona!

/moonbats galore

Can we throw in Santa Fe as well?

565 sattv4u2  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:54:06am

re: #558 Wendya

Expanded autonomy doesn't mean they get to become a part of Russia. South Ossetia would remain a part of Georgia

It stated that what the SouthO's wanted was to be reunited with the North O's, who ARE part of ther Russian Federation

Don't get me wrong. I'm not taking Russias side (nor the DI's ) I'm just askin!

566 lifeofthemind  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:54:14am

One of the awkward secrets is that you always end up fighting for imperfect causes or imperfect allies. If you refuse to help anyone then the real threat will grow unopposed until you may be destroyed by it or only survive at crippling cost. That is what happened to the British, they tempered and delayed and kicked the can down the road and tried to bluff and in both World Wars they ended up suffering so greatly that it cost them their Empire and crippled their civilization. In both cases they could have moved more decisively 2 years earlier at vastly lower cost. In WW-II the immediate casus belli was the invasion of Poland. By no standard was Poland as morally worthy of sacrificing blood and treasure for as Czechoslovakia was. But in September of 1939 the democratic and modern Czechs were already lost so Poland was all that was left. Now we have Georgia being attacked. If we let it go then the next slice of the sausage may be a less perfect case such as the unlovely dictatorship in Uzbekistan.

567 sattv4u2  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:54:22am

BBIAB

568 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:54:23am
569 Cap'n DOC  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:54:47am

re: #555 opnion

Yup. 69-70. Hai Van Pass, Monkey Mountain, Namo Bridge. Saw Danang once...

570 Dustoff-507  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:54:49am

re: #555 opnion

Hue
Been there done that. (-:

571 Dianna  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:54:51am

re: #551 Dustoff-507

Georgia has the pipeline. Azerbaijan has the oil (think Baku).

This is a territory matter, in many ways. Look at the map - the Caucasus is a dagger pointed at Russia's vitals.

At least if you're Russia, and paranoid basically.

572 NY Nana  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:55:02am

re: #546 J.D.

What took so long?

That's a very good question that I do not have an answer for. After Putin was slobbered over by President Bush, in China, it seems to have done no good. As far as I am concerned, Putin is the de facto head of the USSR.

/KGB is such a wonderful resource to prepare a future despot leader.

573 realwest  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:55:02am

re: #474 Killgore Trout
Yeah, Killgore, I'm afraid that's what's gonna happen too.
BUT - while I still think denying Russia air surpremecy over Georgia would be a good idea, I certainly think that:
a) Recalling our Ambassador to Russia for "consultations"
b) Removing Russia's Most Favored Trade Status
c) IMMEDIATELY admit Ukraine to NATO (and while we're at it, boot the Germans out - it's my understanding that they are the ones who blocked Georgia's entry into NATO)
d) keep all diplomatic and economic pressure turned up to "11"
would have some salutory effect. But if I led Israel, South Korea or Taiwain, I sure has hell wouldn't count on the U.S. as our "ally" if things got difficult.

574 redc1c4  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:55:40am

re: #512 itellu3times

Because once we start shooting at Russians anywhere, they may start shooting at us anywhere.

they don't have the capability to project power anywhere away from their border and their "navy" is a joke, as are their strategic forces. it's 2008, not 1978. they are counting on us doing nothing. i say we disabuse them of the notion.

575 opnion  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:56:29am

re: #569 Cap'n DOC

Yup. 69-70. Hai Van Pass, Monkey Mountain, Namo Bridge. Saw Danang once...

Well welcome home. I saw DaNang coming & going.
Now they had some creature comforts , especially the Air Force.

576 Athos  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:56:39am

From Stratfor in an email update:

So far, apart from Russian airstrikes, most of the combat has been limited to the north-central Georgian secessionist province of South Ossetia. But on Aug. 11, Russia beefed up its 2,500-strong peacekeeping force in Abkhazia — a secessionist region in northwestern Georgia — to more than 9,000 troops. And now the Russian Defense Ministry has announced — and the Georgian Interior Ministry has confirmed — that Russian forces have advanced up to the western Georgian city of Senaki.

The presence of Russian troops in Senaki has a number of important implications.

First, the Russian forces used in the operation approached from Abkhazia. There has been a U.N. buffer force between Abkhaz- and Georgian-controlled territory, so for Russian forces to be near Senaki, the Russians would have had to move through — and ultimately beyond — that buffer. Georgia’s best troops are also typically kept near Abkhazia, suggesting that those forces have been either bypassed or destroyed. Several reports indicate the Georgians are engaged in combat with Abkhaz forces in the upper reaches of the Kodori Gorge, so it seems likely they were bypassed.

Second, Senaki sits astride a railroad juncture that links the rest of the country not only to Abkhazia, but to Georgia’s largest port: Poti. The Russians have already bombed Poti several times, but taking Senaki completely removes the port from the equation.

Third, another Georgian city — Samtredia — is only an hour’s march from Senaki. Samtredia sits astride the Baku-Tbilisi-Supsa oil pipeline, transit fees from which are a major portion of Georgia’s economic wherewithal. But its military significance for Georgia cannot be overstated.

It's now apparent that Russia has opened a new front into Georgia that is far removed from South Ossetia - yet strategic in its ability to economically and militarily gut Georgia. If they press forward here, then the Russian intent is nothing but to totally eliminate the current pro-Western regime and ingest Georgia back into the Rodina.

577 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:56:40am
...On the U.S. presidential campaign trail, meanwhile, Sen. John McCain (Ariz.), the presumptive Republican nominee, said there was no justification for "Moscow's path of violent aggression" and charged that Russian actions were "in clear violation of international law."...


U.S. Leaders Increasingly Critical of Russian Escalation

578 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:56:42am

Where's Nancy Pelosi "I'm saving the World here" when you need Manolo Blahniks on the ground?

Have the GOP energy revolt people keeping vigil in the Capitol said anything about Russia's invasion today?

579 Dark_Falcon  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:57:07am

re: #539 realwest

But what do you do if Russia wants war with you?
Not standing by your allies in fear of being at war with Russia means that NONE of your allies can believe in your alliance with them.
None.

I'm not counseling the abandonment of Georgia. We should help them with all means short of open war. However, I not willing to risk open war with Russia over Georgia. The risks are too high.

580 HoosierHoops  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:57:13am

re: #559 pre-Boomer Marine brat

Oh m'Gawd NO! Give 'em Sedona!

/moonbats galore

Have you ever played Sedona? It's worth at least one minuteman missle...Nobody takes Sedona from the US!
LOL

581 Spider Mensch  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:57:14am

re: #568 buzzsawmonkey

Has Obama said anything about the Russian aggression yet?

Has McCain?


obama...1st response"talk with russia, negotiate"...later response, stand by ally Georgia but no specifics.

McCain..."we must stand by ally Georgia, Russian actions uncalled for"

582 opnion  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:57:16am

re: #570 Dustoff-507

Hue
Been there done that. (-:

583 Dianna  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:57:29am

re: #562 redc1c4

If I could upding you more than once, I would.

584 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:57:31am

re: #564 Wendya

Can we throw in Santa Fe as well?

WHEEE!

585 Dustoff-507  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:57:33am

re: #571 Dianna


Putin still get's to control it. $$$

586 NY Nana  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:57:39am

re: #550 alegrias

Medvedev is just lipstick on the Putin pig.

If there were still rotating titles, that would be perfect!

Are they in hiding?

587 vapig  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:57:55am

re: #562 redc1c4

dropping bombs inside Georgia, at the request of the Georgian government is risky? giving them supplies that they will use themselves is risky?

the only risk i see is in doing nothing, because we're afraid of the big bad russian bear, who isn't that big nor bad.

I don't even think it's the big bad bear we fear - it's the UN/ World Media "opinion" we are concerned with.

Besides, I believe this sits well with the dem party and their fellow travelers of the left. It means they're gaining territory again.

588 Dianna  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:59:07am

re: #568 buzzsawmonkey

McCain's said plenty - he's annoyed.

589 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:59:15am

re: #568 buzzsawmonkey

Has Obama said anything about the Russian aggression yet?

Has McCain?

* * *
McCain had a press conference this morning on the subject.

590 Killgore Trout  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:59:27am

re: #573 realwest

This situation reminds me of why I liked Rudy's NATO plan so much. NATO should be transformed into a league of democracies including Israel, Ukraine, India, etc. They would make a nice counterweight to agressive dictatorships. I just read that the UN is going to meet over this but Russia has veto power on the Security Council. It's a joke.

591 Honorary Yooper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:59:34am

re: #586 NY Nana

If there were still rotating titles, that would be perfect!

Are they in hiding?

There still are, look at the text just above the Lizard Lounge.

592 Serge GoFan  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:59:34am

I think this Russian show is not about oil, even not about to convince the West that Russia can do whatever it wants. The show has ohe precise target - Ukraine (size - like France, so the population).

593 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 10:59:40am

re: #580 HoosierHoops

Have you ever played Sedona? It's worth at least one minuteman missle...Nobody takes Sedona from the US!
LOL

I'm not a duffer.
Okay, let's ship out the moonbats and keep the links.

594 Cap'n DOC  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:00:11am

re: #575 opnion

I made a run to the Naval Hospital once with a 'wounded' Lt. Blew his hand wide open by letting go of half a stick of C4 a little late. We'd heard the AF had it good but we surely didn't! We ate CRats for six months!

595 opnion  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:00:32am

re: #570 Dustoff-507

Hue
Been there done that. (-:

Before or after the Tet Offensive? When I saw it (before) the Citadel was in one piece. Men were walking around in business suits & women in Western dress.
Really strange coming out of the Stone Age (the Bush) into a real city.

596 Cap'n DOC  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:01:01am

re: #582 opnion

We never got that far.

597 lifeofthemind  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:01:03am

re: #550 alegrias

* * *
Medvedev is just lipstick on the Putin pig.

Medvedev is Señor Wences

598 realwest  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:01:16am

re: #516 The Other Les
Oh, ok, didn't know that and was just trying to help!

599 willowone  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:01:17am

re: #578 alegrias
[Link: latimesblogs.latimes.com...]
of course minus their spin

600 willowone  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:01:39am

or[Link: ap.google.com...]

601 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:01:44am
McCain, an outspoken critic of Moscow, said it was clear the situation in Georgia was dire. "Tensions and hostilities between Georgians and Ossetians are in no way justification for Russian troops crossing an internationally recognized border," he said in a statement.

"I again call on the government of Russia to immediately and unconditionally withdraw its forces from the territory of Georgia."

Obama called for direct talks among all sides and said the United States, the U.N. Security Council and other parties should try to help bring about a peaceful resolution.

"I condemn Russia's aggressive actions and reiterate my call for an immediate ceasefire," Obama said in a statement.

"Russia must stop its bombing campaign, cease flights of Russian aircraft in Georgian airspace, and withdraw its ground forces from Georgia."

McCain has long criticized Russia, particularly for what he sees as its backsliding on democratic reforms and human rights. "For many years, I have warned against Russian actions that undermine the sovereignty of its neighbors," he said. "Unfortunately, we have seen in recent days Russia demonstrate that these concerns were well-founded."

Obama has stepped up his criticism of Russia since the crisis started. He called for an international peacekeeping force and said Russia could not be a neutral mediator for political disputes over South Ossetia and Abkhazia -- both pro-Russian separatist regions backed by Moscow.

"The current escalation of military conflict resulted in part from the lack of a neutral and effective peacekeeping force operating under an appropriate UN mandate," Obama said. "Russia cannot play a constructive role as peacekeeper."


McCain, Obama step up criticism of Russia over Georgia
~al-Reuters

602 experiencedtraveller  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:02:05am

re: #552 redc1c4

it is not. i defy you to prove otherwise.

Classic Burden of Proof logical fallacy.

603 vagabond trader  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:02:12am

Sickening, this is an indirect challenge to the US, make no mistake.Putin has one goal and that is to control access to energy for all of Europe and hook up with the other oil whores to hold the entire planet hostage.More vital than ever to exploit our own resources.

604 A. van Hilten  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:02:17am

re: #271 J.D.


Two?

Really?

I know its "fashionable" in certain jingoistic and uninformed cricles to poke fun at the French for their poor performance during WWII, but you may want to remember who fought at Yorktown with you guys to help you become a free nation...

605 Athos  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:02:30am

re: #579 Dark_Falcon

The risks are too high.

Isn't there always risk? At what point does risk become acceptable? After all, there was risk and incomplete intell that prevented this country from taking a harder line against jihadi terrorism in the 1990's. What did that bring us?

Yes, this is a slippery slope argument. It's no different from the points made earlier about Britain and France failing to act in the Rhineland and Sudatenland which resulted in a far greater and costlier conflict?

Is Georgia the Rhineland? Sudatenland? If so, will that make the Ukraine today's 'Poland'? Or do we only accept the cyber and economic warfare waged by Putin's Russia and wait until we are the direct target?

Shouldn't the strong defend and protect the weak from thugs and bullies?

606 Dianna  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:02:36am

re: #579 Dark_Falcon

I'm not counseling the abandonment of Georgia. We should help them with all means short of open war. However, I not willing to risk open war with Russia over Georgia. The risks are too high.

I must disagree. I think the risks are too high not to confront and depress Russian pretensions.

Not that anyone's listening to me.

607 Dustoff-507  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:02:37am

re: #595 opnion


Late 71... I was with the 57th medical back then.
I was one of the late guys to see action... Medics were there right up till the end in 73

608 The Other Les  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:02:57am

re: #598 realwest

Oh, ok, didn't know that and was just trying to help!

I understand your concern.

Putin isn't going to waste any Polonium on me.

609 NY Nana  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:03:16am

re: #568 buzzsawmonkey

Has McCain?

Yes. Here it is. He is the best one to handle anything like this; too much personal experience, sadly, but he has the right stuff!

Hussein would be hiding under the bed.

610 Dustoff-507  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:03:33am

re: #595 opnion


I flew everywhere. Very little ground pounding time.

611 redc1c4  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:03:34am

re: #513 Dustoff-507

We could help them both with out using our forces. Our air to ground systems would make a mess of Puttins planes. Then go after his tanks. You lose that, you lose the war! ( this we can supply them)


even easier: cut the LOC's via B-2's dropping deep penetrating ordnance, and supply ATGM & MANPADS to the Georgians, so they can finish off the now cut off russian troops. minimal involvement, minimum risk, and no strikes on russian territory.

612 Dianna  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:03:36am

re: #585 Dustoff-507

A point I've done to death over the weekend.

613 yma o hyd  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:03:54am

Here are some remarks of David Cameron, Tory, leader of the opposition, and the next Prime Minister of the UK (as soon as Gordon B. holds a General election ...):

"Tory leader David Cameron branded Russia a "dangerous bully" and urged the international community to stand up and condemn its action in Georgia.

He also called for Georgia's membership of Nato to be "speeded up"

Mr Cameron told the BBC: "The only language that bullies understand is when someone stands up to them."

And:
"Earlier, Mr Cameron warned that there were "very, very worrying consequences" if Europe failed to speak with one voice that what Russia is doing "is wrong".

"What Russia has done here is used massive and disproportionate force. It's breached international law and it has violated Georgia's territorial integrity," he told BBC Radio 4's The World at One.

"It has acted as a massive and dangerous bully and we can't allow this to go ahead without it being challenged."

Mr Cameron conceded that Georgia's decision to send troops into South Ossetia "was a bad strategy", but he said there could be implications for Baltic states that still identify with Russia if nations fail to speak out. "
(Here's the link, also with the usual waffle from our NuLab politicians ...)

614 opnion  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:04:15am

re: #594 Cap'n DOC

I made a run to the Naval Hospital once with a 'wounded' Lt. Blew his hand wide open by letting go of half a stick of C4 a little late. We'd heard the AF had it good but we surely didn't! We ate CRats for six months!

Ham &futher muckers. Lord , those crats sucked .
Unless you could cobble together a meal of beans & meatballs.
Then work some trades , so that you had sponge cake & peaches. Slurp!

615 wolfie  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:04:18am

re: #573 realwest

If the NATO countries got together NOW and IMMEDIATELY admitted the Ukraine to NATO, and issued a stern reminder of what that means, THAT would be a very strong message.
After Georgia is eaten, the Bear will want the Crimea for dessert.
No doubt about that in my mind.

616 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:04:24am

re: #599 willowone

[Link: latimesblogs.latimes.com...]
of course minus their spin

* * *
Thanks--good to know Darth Cheney is on the job!

617 realwest  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:04:57am

re: #528 opnion I were in Cambodia Far western South Vietnam most of the time and yes it was...weird (though it deserves a stronger term than that!).

618 iirightii  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:04:59am

Don't think for a moment that this isn't Russian flexing it's muscles in the face of US successes in Iraq and Afghanistan. No one wants to be known as the guy with the little dick.

Russia wants the world to know that the US isn't the only military power that has the "Shock and Awe" sauce.

Plus, they know that there's nothing short of open conflict with Russia that the US (or their pussy EU counterparts) can do to curtail their "annexation" of the former sovereignty known as Georgia (they HAVE done this before, you know). Not that taking on a guy with 80 tanks and 100 artillery pieces, and whose soldier's uniforms don't even match, is much of a accomplishment.

"Yeah, so what... I just beat up a Boy Scout troop and stole their mulch. What are YOU going to do about it?"

IF we had gotten them into NATO, treaties would have curtailed Russian meddling in NATO-aligned nation's affairs. As it stands, the only possible check to Russian aggression would be other former republics which are not NATO aligned to try and put up a coordinated defense of their sibling nation. That seems far-fetched, and somewhat suicidal. There are some nascent democracies that need to think long and hard about what's happening here.

Thank you for purchasing Cold War v2.0; now with improved low- and medium- intensity proxy conflicts. I can't abide by the fact that we will abandon Georgia, but the only way to protect them would be to espouse going tow-to-sagger with the rooskies. That's too hawkish, even for me.

619 Dianna  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:05:24am

re: #592 Serge GoFan

If they take Georgia, then Ukraine will be reincorporated by the end of next year.

620 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:05:26am

re: #604 A. van Hilten

I know its "fashionable" in certain jingoistic and uninformed cricles to poke fun at the French for their poor performance during WWII, but you may want to remember who fought at Yorktown with you guys to help you become a free nation...

Yes, and we also have done plenty to help them, but their policies with respect to us since that time have not been quite so friendly, have they?

621 opnion  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:05:28am

re: #596 Cap'n DOC

We never got that far.

You did not really miss anything. The whole country was a freaking delight!

622 Athos  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:05:42am

re: #615 wolfie

Particularly after the Ukraine has locked the Russian Black Sea Fleet out from their bases...if that information is accurate.

623 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:05:56am

re: #603 vagabond trader

Sickening, this is an indirect challenge to the US, make no mistake.Putin has one goal and that is to control access to energy for all of Europe and hook up with the other oil whores to hold the entire planet hostage.More vital than ever to exploit our own resources.

* * *
Drill here, drill now, an oil rig in every backyard...

624 wolfie  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:06:05am

re: #588 Dianna

McCain's said plenty - he's annoyed.

Downright cranky.

625 The Other Les  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:06:17am

re: #605 Athos

Shouldn't the strong defend and protect the weak from thugs and bullies?


In a civilized world (or a world that we shove toward civilization), yes.

It is in barbarism that the strong prey on the weak. (See Islam, Bolshevism, Fascism, National Socialism, Etc.)

626 paradox42  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:06:26am

re: #623 alegrias

And a refinery in every town.

627 CyanSnowHawk  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:06:45am

re: #580 HoosierHoops

Have you ever played Sedona? It's worth at least one minuteman missle...Nobody takes Sedona from the US!
LOL

We couldn't let Mexico have the technology that is embodied in Cardinal's Stadium. We have to keep Arizona.

/

628 Vergeltung  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:06:49am

re: #604 A. van Hilten

I know its "fashionable" in certain jingoistic and uninformed cricles to poke fun at the French for their poor performance during WWII, but you may want to remember who fought at Yorktown with you guys to help you become a free nation...

and who kicked the rest of civilizations ass from 1799-1815.

629 akak  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:06:53am

Divide all US$ going to Russia that we have control over, and give it to Turkey & Ukraine with direct instructions/results.

630 Tarkus289  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:07:08am

re: #586 NY Nana

They are on top of the Lizard on the upper right.

631 opnion  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:07:37am

re: #617 realwest

I were in Cambodia Far western South Vietnam most of the time and yes it was...weird (though it deserves a stronger term than that!).

Ok , lets brainstorm. I've got it , it was a hell hole.
Gawd! Even the water buffalo wanted to kill us.
Remeber those things? You would need an M60 to bring one down.

632 Honorary Yooper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:08:06am

re: #615 wolfie

If the NATO countries got together NOW and IMMEDIATELY admitted the Ukraine to NATO, and issued a stern reminder of what that means, THAT would be a very strong message.
After Georgia is eaten, the Bear will want the Crimea for dessert.
No doubt about that in my mind.

And what's next after Georgia and Ukraine? Does anyone seriously think the Bear will stop at eating that? If I were in the Baltics, or Poland, or Finland, or Armenia, I'd start preparing for what could come next.

It must stop here. A line in the dirt must be drawn.

633 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:08:10am

re: #604 A. van Hilten

I know its "fashionable" in certain jingoistic and uninformed cricles to poke fun at the French for their poor performance during WWII, but you may want to remember who fought at Yorktown with you guys to help you become a free nation...

* * *
Oui, point taken. And we can thank L'Enfant for designing Washington DC-- beautiful but traffic nightmare! Nice style, no worky.

634 RememberSekhmet?  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:08:19am

re: #177 Iron Fist

No, and it's not just the oil. If nothing else shows it, the silence on the so-called "anti-war" Left exposes the fact that they are just anti-US. The Republicans (the only patriotic Party we have in the US) needs to be driving this point home. We need to make a lot of noise, bare minimum. Right now we aren't doing much.

Which brings me to another point:

How much of the El Cubo's defending of Russia's actions is due to pure habit? What kept overtly communist and socialist parties from succeeding in the US was the WWII-era flip-flopping on whether or not to get involved---which always tracked Russian foreign policy and the health of the Stalin-Von Ribbentrop Pact. I call those policies Russian, because they were due to interests that predated the 1917 revolution. By tracking a Russian line, rather than a party line more in line with the works of Marx, it became obvious who paid the American commies' bills.

Americans don't want folks beholden to foreign powers in charge of the country. It was obvious the commies worked for the USSR, and even prior to the Cold War, that was enough to scuttle the communists' and socialists' chances.

Now the Lefties seem to be reading their talking points straight from the Kremlin---again. Maybe folks will start remembering why we stopped listening to the socialists and communists in the first place.

635 A. van Hilten  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:08:36am

re: #556 Dustoff-507

WHO ME...

Well it was certainly you who smeared Al Reuters by linking to an abject pro-Russian blog which suggests those pics are staged while claiming that "Reuters is at it again".

636 Dianna  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:08:49am

re: #615 wolfie

My problem is letting Russia take Georgia!

637 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:09:01am

re: #604 A. van Hilten

I know its "fashionable" in certain jingoistic and uninformed cricles to poke fun at the French for their poor performance during WWII, but you may want to remember who fought at Yorktown with you guys to help you become a free nation...

Dutifully up-dinged, as a matter of honor.

/now can I go back to bashing the French? ... heh

638 wolfie  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:09:28am

re: #590 Killgore Trout

Indeed. I was glad to see McCain endorse that League of Democracies idea early on, although I haven't heard him say much about it lately. In any case, he should take that ball and run w/ it.
If he were elected and if he could set an alliance like that up...
What a legacy that would be!

639 realwest  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:09:35am

re: #568 buzzsawmonkey Yeah, don't have the links handy, but Obama said "X" , McCain came down REALLY hard on the Russians and Obama said "Me too, sorta, I think".

640 JHW  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:09:35am

South Ossetia has been a problem child for both Georgia and Russia. From Wiki, but can be confirmed by other sources if you like.

Eduard Dzhabeyevich Kokoity (Ossetian Кокойты Джабейы фырт Эдуард, Russian Эдуа́рд Джабе́е&# 1074;ич Коко́йт&# 1099;, surname also rendered as Kokoyty or Kokoiti or in a Russified version as Kokoyev) is the current President of South Ossetia, a de facto independent (though internationally unrecognised) republic within Georgia .
Born in 1964, Kokoity is a former member, and champion, of the former Soviet Union's national wrestling team. Prior to 1989, he was the First Secretary of the Tskhinvali branch of the Komsomol, the Young Communist League. He moved to Moscow in 1992 where he became a businessman after learning about the intrigues of capitalism, before moving back to South Ossetia in 2001.

A former wrestler, reportedly a nightclub bouncer ,"he moved to Moscow where he became a businessman...after learning about capitalism"

Kokoity's victory was unexpected but owed much to the backing of the Tedeyev clan, one of South Ossetia's most powerful families.


Eduard Kokoity Wiki Bio.

Powerful families, became a businessman, etc., we've had powerful families "in business" here and we called them by other names

Last year he incurred the displeasure of the Russians for stirring up tension with Georgia . Quotes from a Russian source., last year.

South Ossetia’s security structures completely blocked on Friday the traffic in the zone of the Georgia-Ossetia conflict. They shut off the Trans-Caucasian main road and the roads leading to Georgian villages. Tskhinvali’s actions boosted the escalation of tension in the region, and received Russia’s disapproval. Moscow, never before hiding its liking towards the unrecognized republic, this time demanded that South Ossetia implement agreements on the conflict’s peaceful settlement.
Apparently, Moscow does not welcome Kokoity’s recent actions. Russia does not need now another cause for a showdown with the West, especially due to the upcoming visit of U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice to Russia. Georgia calls South Ossetian authorities “Moscow’s puppets”, and Washington keeps a watchful eye on the situation in South Ossetia.

null

Eduard Kokoity Makes Siege Mistake

Times have changed, Kokity calls for help this year, the world situation is different and this time Moscow obliges. He's their good buddy this year, and he gets what he wanted last year. Everybody's happy...except the Georgians , who are getting blamed for stirring up trouble.

641 NY Nana  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:09:36am

re: #591 Honorary Yooper

There still are, look at the text just above the Lizard Lounge.

Thank you!

642 Salamantis  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:09:47am

Bidinotto has it about right; anticipatory capitulation is what the tepid response is all about:

[Link: bidinotto.journalspace.com...]

The greatest terror of postmodern Westerners is "confrontation": to be compelled into situations in which they must actually face down a bully. And, of course, taking a moral stand may sometimes lead to such "confrontations."

So, in anticipation of any course of action that could possibly lead to a "confrontation," postmoderns never take a moral stand. They look into the future, at where such a stand might lead them -- and, terrified by the prospect, they back down pre-emptively. Often, they seek some sort of "compromise" with thugs that takes the "confrontation" option off the table. "Compromise" here means: anticipatory capitulation.

This is the policy that Border's Books, Comedy Central, and the entire MSM adopted when contemplating even a hypothetical "confrontation" with Islamists who might become angry about their circulation of those Muhammad cartoons: They capitulated and refused to publish the cartoons, in mere anticipation of a possible showdown.

This is the policy that has, in fact, lay beneath much of Western foreign policy -- as in endless, toothless UN resolutions (when they can even agree on one), and in our State Department's anemic practice of tepidly voicing "concern" about this or that international bully's actions, while evading any "provocative" language of condemnation that might "escalate" to a direct confrontation.

And this is the same policy we see in the "international community's" moral, rhetorical, economic, and (of course) military paralysis in the face of naked Russian aggression in Georgia -- including the U.S.'s muted, invertebrate response. President Bush spoke of his "grave concern about the disproportionate response" by the Russians. In fact, we have U.S. diplomats openly acknowledging that we won't do a damned thing about it.

Bullies, of course, can always smell fear: It's their special talent. They accurately perceive the cowardice that underlies responses of whining, pleading, dithering, and mollycoddling, and know that they will confront no barriers on the paths of aggression.

643 The Other Les  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:10:01am

re: #626 paradox42

And a refinery in every town.

I normally have no use for Nimbyism, but you really need to build refineries out in the open country.

644 Dianna  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:10:07am

re: #622 Athos

They're trying.

645 redc1c4  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:10:17am

re: #579 Dark_Falcon

I'm not counseling the abandonment of Georgia. We should help them with all means short of open war. However, I not willing to risk open war with Russia over Georgia. The risks are too high.

"Never take counsel of your fears."
Stonewall Jackson

the only real risk is in doing nothing, since that will encourage Putin to do this again, but on a larger scale. what, exactly, is your price point, risk wise?

646 Dark_Falcon  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:10:39am

re: #615 wolfie

If the NATO countries got together NOW and IMMEDIATELY admitted the Ukraine to NATO, and issued a stern reminder of what that means, THAT would be a very strong message.
After Georgia is eaten, the Bear will want the Crimea for dessert.
No doubt about that in my mind.

I agree with your idea. Put the screws to Putin, right now. We can't throw him out of South Ossetia at an acceptable cost, but we can make him sorry he went in.

647 markos  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:10:50am

Dick Morris has an article says this is like Hitler's move on the Sudetenland.

648 wolfie  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:10:55am

re: #592 Serge GoFan

I think this Russian show is not about oil, even not about to convince the West that Russia can do whatever it wants. The show has ohe precise target - Ukraine (size - like France, so the population).

That is what I also firmly believe.

649 Cap'n DOC  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:11:15am

re: #614 opnion

You're right - the Beans and Balls were worth trading for.

650 A. van Hilten  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:11:39am

re: #620 J.D.

Yes, and we also have done plenty to help them, but their policies with respect to us since that time have not been quite so friendly, have they?

But that is another matter entirely, isn't it? The French can bleed like anybody else. Verdun goes a long way in proving that fact.

651 paradox42  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:12:19am

re: #642 Salamantis

Absolutely right. I was recipient of antisemitic death threats in school, until I convinced the bastards that I'd literally castrate them if they didn't leave me the hell alone.

Many people don't listen to reason, but most listen to an M16.

652 yma o hyd  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:12:27am

re: #615 wolfie

If the NATO countries got together NOW and IMMEDIATELY admitted the Ukraine to NATO, and issued a stern reminder of what that means, THAT would be a very strong message.
After Georgia is eaten, the Bear will want the Crimea for dessert.
No doubt about that in my mind.

Yes - one look at the map shows that from where Russian troops are now standing, Crimea to the West (ice-free Black Sea ports for the Russian fleet) and Armenia and Azerbeidjan (on the Caspian, lots of oil ... thats where the pipeline is coming from ...) to the Eats will be the next targets.

653 opnion  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:12:41am

re: #639 realwest

Yeah, don't have the links handy, but Obama said "X" , McCain came down REALLY hard on the Russians and Obama said "Me too, sorta, I think".

Real, we lost Black Moses yesterday. Shaft! But we still have Black Messiah, our New Age Deity. As soon as he finishes his surfing and luau parties he will issue a cease & Desist fatwa, & all will be well.

654 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:12:46am

re: #650 A. van Hilten

But that is another matter entirely, isn't it? The French can bleed like anybody else. Verdun goes a long way in proving that fact.

No. It isn't.

655 realwest  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:13:05am

re: #590 Killgore Trout
Yeah, me too - but hasn't McCain said something about a League of Democracies and to hell with the UN?
Thought I'd read that somewhere!

656 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:13:47am

Where are those 200,000 germans who so recently stood where Reagan told the USSR what to do?

Mr. Putin, get the H out of Georgia!

657 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:13:53am

re: #650 A. van Hilten

What is your icon, btw?

658 opnion  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:13:58am

re: #649 Cap'n DOC

You're right - the Beans and Balls were worth trading for.

That was some good eatin!

659 Dustoff-507  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:14:01am

re: #621 opnion

LOL... he it was pretty cool at 3000 ft. (-:

660 Honorary Yooper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:14:02am

re: #647 markos

Dick Morris has an article says this is like Hitler's move on the Sudetenland.

That's what I keep saying.

It's Czechoslovakia all over again.

661 Athos  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:14:16am

re: #645 redc1c4

Exactly. I would rather expend the energy to stop the boulder from cresting the hill and just starting it's downhill run rather than waiting at the bottom of the hill and try to stop it.

Sure, it's harder to walk up the hill to the crest than to stay in the valley...but in the long run, it will be easier and safer to stop it at the start of its run.

662 Dianna  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:14:45am

re: #640 JHW

Look up "siloviki." You'll see something very interesting.

663 willowone  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:15:09am

re: #623 alegrias
and nuclear, and any freaking alternative energy thing that makes sense

664 experiencedtraveller  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:15:28am

re: #604 A. van Hilten

I know its "fashionable" in certain jingoistic and uninformed cricles to poke fun at the French for their poor performance during WWII, but you may want to remember who fought at Yorktown with you guys to help you become a free nation...

Black Jack Pershing and company never forgot. ;)

665 Honorary Yooper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:15:48am

re: #652 yma o hyd

Yes - one look at the map shows that from where Russian troops are now standing, Crimea to the West (ice-free Black Sea ports for the Russian fleet) and Armenia and Azerbeidjan (on the Caspian, lots of oil ... thats where the pipeline is coming from ...) to the Eats will be the next targets.

Plus, historically, Russia has always had its eye on Istanbul. I'd be rather nervous if I were a Turk right now.

666 redc1c4  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:16:07am

re: #602 experiencedtraveller

Classic Burden of Proof logical fallacy.

yawn...

neither one of you armchair strategists has had anything to say but verbal hand wringing...nary a fact to be seen, only "feelings".

unless either of you can articulate why Georgia is a "bridge to far" or why we should be afraid of russia, should we actively support Georgia, your opinions on this issue are meaningless.

667 wolfie  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:16:23am

re: #618 iirightii

I think you are right that it is too late for Georgia.
What we need to do immediately is admit Ukraine into NATO, send Georgia everything we can to help their resistance, NEVER recognize Russian sovereignty in Abhkasia, S. Ossetia, much less Georgia, and BEEF UP OUR ARMED FORCES.

668 JHW  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:16:36am

re: #662 Dianna

Will do Dianna, thanks, I saw you mention that the other night, but I forgot about it.

669 kuffar  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:16:40am

Turkey's military is no slouch, 2nd largest in NATO. And well equipped. Not sure about their expertise.

670 Dustoff-507  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:16:43am

re: #649 Cap'n DOC
Heck we always had a case in our Huey. I was asked why and i told everyone. It's our back up ammo. You ever seen what a can of 'rats' can do to someone head! (-:

671 opnion  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:16:47am

re: #659 Dustoff-507

LOL... he it was pretty cool at 3000 ft. (-:

Yup, on the way out. The area down on the South China Sea was beautiful though. The beaches were pristine, but oh well, no Hilton mega resort.

672 paradox42  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:17:11am

re: #643 The Other Les

I was speaking metaphorically. We do need to build more refineries. All the while developing better, cleaner, and cheaper forms of energy. We should have done this 20 years, but better late than never.

673 A. van Hilten  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:17:20am

re: #654 J.D.

No. It isn't.

Oh, so we should poke fun at the French like little children simply because you're mad at their current foreign policy? Silly jokes and national slurs won't change their attitude towards the US. If anything, it will serve to reinforce their cliches.

674 A. van Hilten  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:17:34am

re: #657 J.D.

What is your icon, btw?

Yeast.

675 Ward Cleaver  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:18:08am

re: #574 redc1c4

they don't have the capability to project power anywhere away from their border and their "navy" is a joke, as are their strategic forces. it's 2008, not 1978. they are counting on us doing nothing. i say we disabuse them of the notion.

Use our attack subs to sink any surface ships they have in the region. Then, when they bitch about it, say, "Who, us?"

676 opnion  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:18:42am

re: #673 A. van Hilten

Oh, so we should poke fun at the French like little children simply because you're mad at their current foreign policy? Silly jokes and national slurs won't change their attitude towards the US. If anything, it will serve to reinforce their cliches.

Who cares?

677 Ward Cleaver  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:19:11am

J.D.!

678 de La Valette  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:19:16am

re: #396 redc1c4

If your going to go asymmetrical, you might as well go for Russia's pipelines.

If you want to get the Europeans to notice this little invasion - start turning off their gas. This would also highlight that this is a resource grab, not a concerned patriarch trying to protect the huddled Russian masses. I have heard the best way to send a message to the Kremlin would be to put a few fingers on there personal pocketbooks, which are being filled by those pipelines.

You have to fight this in six dimensions - if you knock out the roads and kill Russians -- you can still lose the global PR battle and the economic war.

679 Wendya  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:19:27am

re: #565 sattv4u2

It stated that what the SouthO's wanted was to be reunited with the North O's, who ARE part of ther Russian Federation

Don't get me wrong. I'm not taking Russias side (nor the DI's ) I'm just askin!

North and South Ossetia are divided by mountains. Until the Russians built a highway between the two, contact was limited to people who were willing to cross the mountains on trail to trade. They never been "united" in the sense we think of. The South Ossetians are pretty much just looking for whoever will give them the better deal.

680 wolfie  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:19:39am

re: #632 Honorary Yooper

And what's next after Georgia and Ukraine? Does anyone seriously think the Bear will stop at eating that? If I were in the Baltics, or Poland, or Finland, or Armenia, I'd start preparing for what could come next.

It must stop here. A line in the dirt must be drawn.

I'm saying the line must stop BEFORE the Ukraine. Absolutely MUST.

681 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:19:42am
682 Cap'n DOC  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:19:50am

re: #659 Dustoff-507

You are a comedian...

683 J.S.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:19:52am

A BBC person, in a debate about the current war in Georgia, has reiterated that Georgia's Ministry officials are all lying -- that there are no Russians in Gori, Georgia...(I don't really know how this BBC person, sitting behind a desk located somewhere in the West, can speak with such absolute certainty -- but that's what BBC personnel maintain -- no Russians in Gori.). (guess we'll have to wait and see who's telling the truth..)

684 Dustoff-507  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:20:11am

re: #676 opnion


Bingo... we don't give a S*it

685 so.cal.swede  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:20:15am

This almost sounds like the opening chapter(s) of Red Storm Rising.

686 realwest  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:20:28am

Well it's been grand as usual, but I gotta go mush some food.
Hope you all have a great day and that I get the chance to see you all down the road.

687 Peacekeeper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:20:30am

re: #660 Honorary Yooper

More like Clinton's move on Lewinsky...

688 Dustoff-507  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:20:41am

re: #682 Cap'n DOC


Either that or blood & guys talk? 0-:

689 vagabond trader  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:20:51am

The Obama's response to the crisis, er, uh, ummm, ah, gah, can't I just eat my pineapple waffles and how is this helpful to Michele and the kids?

690 markos  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:21:09am

re: #660 Honorary Yooper


What do you think is going to happen? I always thought it would be clear when going over the run up to WWII. Not so clear to me now.

691 lori lane  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:21:09am

re: #686 realwest

{realwest}

692 jcm  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:21:10am

re: #660 Honorary Yooper

That's what I keep saying.

It's Czechoslovakia all over again.

Yep, history all over again...

693 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:21:14am

re: #673 A. van Hilten

Oh, so we should poke fun at the French like little children simply because you're mad at their current foreign policy? Silly jokes and national slurs won't change their attitude towards the US. If anything, it will serve to reinforce their cliches.

For my part, it's known as "letting off steam".
What, do you think, will change their attitude, if what we have done thus far is not enough?

694 Honorary Yooper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:21:26am

re: #669 kuffar

Turkey's military is no slouch, 2nd largest in NATO. And well equipped. Not sure about their expertise.

Very true, but Russia has fought wars in the past to try to control the outlet to the Black Sea. Wiki has a short listing of Russo-Turkish Wars

695 WriterMom  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:21:30am

re: #683 J.S.

Hmmm...sounds like an Iraqi "there are no kufars in Iraq" speech...remember that whopper?

696 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:21:46am

re: #677 Ward Cleaver

J.D.!



WARD!

697 Dustoff-507  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:21:50am

re: #686 realwest
C-ya buddy

698 Ward Cleaver  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:22:25am

re: #685 so.cal.swede

This almost sounds like the opening chapter(s) of Red Storm Rising.

We kicked their asses in that book.

699 so.cal.swede  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:22:47am

re: #647 markos

Dick Morris has an article says this is like Hitler's move on the Sudetenland.

GODWIN'S LAW! seriously though, it's eerily similar.

700 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:23:07am

re: #686 realwest

Well it's been grand as usual, but I gotta go mush some food.
Hope you all have a great day and that I get the chance to see you all down the road.

* * *
Eat hearty & stay strong Real, we need you now more than ever.

701 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:23:15am

re: #674 A. van Hilten

Interesting.

702 WriterMom  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:23:22am

re: #603 vagabond trader

this is an indirect challenge to the US, make no mistake

FOR SURE.

703 redc1c4  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:23:28am

re: #618 iirightii

(snipage occurs)
Thank you for purchasing Cold War v2.0; now with improved low- and medium- intensity proxy conflicts. I can't abide by the fact that we will abandon Georgia, but the only way to protect them would be to espouse going tow-to-sagger with the rooskies. That's too hawkish, even for me.

there are other options on the table besides force on force and doing nothing. cutting the russian LOC's through the mountains and supplying MANPADs to Georgia would effectively isolate the forces currently deployed, effectively destroying them. a few B2 raids one night, over Gerogian territory, and a C130 or two worth of ammo, and they're pretty much FUBAR.

704 DeafDog  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:23:30am

re: #683 J.S.

The reporting does seem to be exagerated/deceitful on both sides.

705 Dark_Falcon  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:23:33am

re: #666 redc1c4

yawn...

neither one of you armchair strategists has had anything to say but verbal hand wringing...nary a fact to be seen, only "feelings".

unless either of you can articulate why Georgia is a "bridge to far" or why we should be afraid of russia, should we actively support Georgia, your opinions on this issue are meaningless.

We would confronting Russia directly, close to their bases of supply and within what Russia perceives as its sphere of control. Such a conflict could easily spill out of control. I'd rather place forces in Ukraine and exert pressure that way. I'd not disagreeing about our overall interests and obligations, merely how we fulfill said obligations.

706 Dianna  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:23:40am

re: #665 Honorary Yooper

Which is why Turkey is backing Georgia, not because they so love Georgian wines.

707 A. van Hilten  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:23:45am

re: #676 opnion

Who cares?

You speak like a true isolationist, sir.

Guess what? That's exactly what most liberal-leaning Euros think about America. "But Americans liberated Europe. Who cares?"

708 Cap'n DOC  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:23:59am

re: #688 Dustoff-507

Actually. I blew that one since what I was making the reference to was this wonderful shot from opnion -

The whole country was a freaking delight!
709 vagabond trader  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:24:10am

Oooo, I so want us to kick their asses right here and now. I know, not likely, but man do they deserve it.

710 WriterMom  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:24:13am

re: #687 Peacekeeper

Sloppy, desperate and angst-ridden?

711 Dustoff-507  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:24:20am

Have to go too... have a great afternoon and pray for Georgia

712 Cognito  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:24:24am

re: #647 markos

Dick Morris has an article says this is like Hitler's move on the Sudetenland.

I'd be interested in reading that... got a link, by any chance?

713 Ben Hur  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:24:33am

re: #660 Honorary Yooper

That's what I keep saying.

It's Czechoslovakia all over again.

C'mon, it's Czechoslovakia! We zip in, we pick 'em up, we zip right out again! We're not going to Moscow. It's Czechoslovakia! It's like we're going into Wisconsin!

714 Spider Mensch  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:24:55am

I know another lizard mentioned it either in the dead thread or earlier in this one...but just for shits and giggles...while Russia is fiddling about( so to speak, not to make light of the current situation), NOW is the perfect time to neutralize the iranian nuclear capability threat. I bet some in Israel and the US are already thinking this over seriously.

715 Honorary Yooper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:25:18am

re: #690 markos

What do you think is going to happen? I always thought it would be clear when going over the run up to WWII. Not so clear to me now.

The run-up to major wars is not always as clear as it was in WWII. WWI started with the assassination of an Arch-duke of Austria-Hungary, and escalated from there. I figure the next one will (other than the GWoT) will start with some small war or silly incident that otherwise would have minial meaning.

716 paradox42  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:25:20am

re: #709 vagabond trader

They totally deserve it, but we need to be smart about this. I'm not at all anti war, but a hot war between the US and Russia will have no winners. We need to hurt them bad enough to curb their aggression, but not bad enough for them to reach for the button.

We're gonna have to walk one hell of a tightrope on this one.

717 Peacekeeper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:25:20am

re: #710 WriterMom

prideful and not uninstigated.

718 A. van Hilten  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:25:33am

re: #684 Dustoff-507

Bingo... we don't give a S*it

Then don't act surprised if other people "don't give a S*it" either about 9/11.

719 redc1c4  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:25:59am

re: #646 Dark_Falcon

I agree with your idea. Put the screws to Putin, right now. We can't throw him out of South Ossetia at an acceptable cost, but we can make him sorry he went in.

evidently your "acceptable cost" is zero... would you care to define it otherwise? what *is* "acceptable" in your eyes?

720 markos  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:26:08am

re: #712 Cognito

[Link: www.newsmax.com...]

721 scottishbuzzsaw  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:26:24am

re: #662 Dianna

Look up "siloviki." You'll see something very interesting.


Wow.

722 wolfie  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:26:28am

re: #636 Dianna

My problem is letting Russia take Georgia!

I am in complete sympathy with you (and them) on that.
I do not know enough about military affairs to have a worthy opinion on the present military situation. I know we HAVE to draw a line, but sometimes the best military line to draw doesn't coincide with the one drawn in ours hearts.
I do know that contemporary wars are also propaganda wars. In that respect, Icertainly think it would be easier to draw the line at the Ukraine than somewhere in the messy Caucasus.

723 vagabond trader  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:26:30am

re: #716 paradox42

They are no longer the USSR we once knew.

724 quickjustice  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:26:44am

re: #706 Dianna

Two brief points: The Turkish military is tough. And Russia has threatened Turkey in the past, hence the Crimean War.

If the Pentagon doesn't have contingency plans for this, someone should be sacked.

725 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:27:14am

re: #707 A. van Hilten

You speak like a true isolationist, sir.

Guess what? That's exactly what most liberal-leaning Euros think about America. "But Americans liberated Europe. Who cares?"

I would have guessed you were of Dutch descent.
Did I spell that right?

726 WriterMom  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:27:16am

re: #718 A. van Hilten

That is an insane comparison. Because Americans don't care about French foreign policy-we shouldn't be suprised that people don't care about 9/11? Is that really what you are saying?

727 Dark_Falcon  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:27:29am

re: #703 redc1c4

there are other options on the table besides force on force and doing nothing. cutting the russian LOC's through the mountains and supplying MANPADs to Georgia would effectively isolate the forces currently deployed, effectively destroying them. a few B2 raids one night, over Gerogian territory, and a C130 or two worth of ammo, and they're pretty much FUBAR.

As I have said, the B2s could work. The C130s however, would be spotted and shot down. I don't believe that prop planes could survive the air defenses the Russians can field.

728 NY Nana  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:27:35am

Here are statements from our next President and that other guy...just compare them...Hussein? A lightweight Marxist. McCain? A mensch.

729 J.S.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:27:39am

re: #695 WriterMom

Yeah. the good ol "Baghdad bob" (I heard he died, though...didn't someone want to bring him to the West so he could do a stand-up routine? he would have made a fine Beeb "reporter.")

730 Honorary Yooper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:27:52am

re: #713 Ben Hur

C'mon, it's Czechoslovakia! We zip in, we pick 'em up, we zip right out again! We're not going to Moscow. It's Czechoslovakia! It's like we're going into Wisconsin!

Well, I got the shit kicked out of me in Wisconsin once. Forget it.

/Funny movie.

731 so.cal.swede  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:27:53am

re: #714 Spider Mensch

I know another lizard mentioned it either in the dead thread or earlier in this one...but just for shits and giggles...while Russia is fiddling about( so to speak, not to make light of the current situation), NOW is the perfect time to neutralize the iranian nuclear capability threat. I bet some in Israel and the US are already thinking this over seriously.

There's no way the US will step into this one. Bush has to look after his legacy at this point... I could see him doing it earlier in his administration, when he pushed hard his "i'll do what's right even though it's not popular" - then he might have. Not now, however.

732 Cognito  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:28:00am

re: #683 J.S.

A BBC person, in a debate about the current war in Georgia, has reiterated that Georgia's Ministry officials are all lying -- that there are no Russians in Gori, Georgia...(I don't really know how this BBC person, sitting behind a desk located somewhere in the West, can speak with such absolute certainty -- but that's what BBC personnel maintain -- no Russians in Gori.). (guess we'll have to wait and see who's telling the truth..)

Got a link for that BBC assertion? (Was it made on behalf of the BBC, or offhand?)

The notion that "there are no Russians in Gori" is a bit ridiculous. Apparently observers of every stripe have been fooled...

733 Dianna  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:28:00am

re: #669 kuffar

I'm concerned about their logistics; Turkey shares a border with Georgia, but it's in Eastern Turkey, and there's a honking great mountain range between the central bases and any ability to help Georgia.

I'm not a military expert, but I was looking at the maps, and got a bit nervous.

734 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:28:14am

re: #721 scottishbuzzsaw

Wow.

Share?

735 Ben Hur  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:29:20am

Riots in Montreal?

736 opnion  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:29:35am

re: #607 Dustoff-507

Late 71... I was with the 57th medical back then.
I was one of the late guys to see action... Medics were there right up till the end in 73

You made it back. Good for you & thank you.

737 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:29:50am

re: #718 A. van Hilten

Then don't act surprised if other people "don't give a S*it" either about 9/11.

Who's surprised?

738 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:30:17am

re: #728 NY Nana

Here are statements from our next President and that other guy...just compare them...Hussein? A lightweight Marxist. McCain? A mensch.

* * *
NY Nana,

McCain's a mensch whose 96 year old anit-communist mother flew the Taiwanese flag from her DC apartment window across from the CHINESE embassy, just to poke Communists in the eye.

739 RedPepper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:30:27am

re: #681 taxfreekiller

Dear Two Party Evil Money Cult Cowards in Washington D.C.

"Not in my name."

Get off your ass's and act like men.

Yours true,

taxfreekiller

Amen, tfk.

Hell of a moment to be "led" by the likes of Harry Reid and Nancy Pelosi, ain't it ?

/

740 paradox42  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:30:40am

re: #723 vagabond trader

I think if Putin believed that it was over, and was truly backed into a corner, he'd have no qualms about firing all of Russia's ICBMs.

This is a guy that doesn't value human life one bit. All he cares about is power and if he's going down, I think he'd be more than willing to take us with him.

I do see a solution, but it would be extraordinarily difficult to pull of. If we could do it, we'd create a huge power vacuum in Russia, with various players killing each other for the top spot. By the time the dust settled, Russia would be a 3rd world shell of its former self.

741 WriterMom  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:30:41am

re: #735 Ben Hur

Yep. "Youths".

742 so.cal.swede  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:31:11am

re: #735 Ben Hur

Riots in Montreal?

Sounded like a " "Youths" attack police, get shot " incident...

743 markos  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:31:23am

re: #715 Honorary Yooper

The run-up to major wars is not always as clear as it was in WWII. WWI started with the assassination of an Arch-duke of Austria-Hungary, and escalated from there. I figure the next one will (other than the GWoT) will start with some small war or silly incident that otherwise would have minial meaning.

I'm thinking the run up to WWII wasn't clear at the time, only in retrospect. Clear now. Not so clear then. Explains us not getting in till 41 instead of when? 39, sooner? I just don't know.

744 Spider Mensch  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:31:40am

re: #714 Spider Mensch

I know another lizard mentioned it either in the dead thread or earlier in this one...but just for shits and giggles...while Russia is fiddling about( so to speak, not to make light of the current situation), NOW is the perfect time to neutralize the iranian nuclear capability threat. I bet some in Israel and the US are already thinking this over seriously.


part 2 of my post... and wouldn't that send a message to poottie and his kgb crew...play the old crocodile dundee, "that's not a Knife Mate, THIS is a knife!" game. pussy footing with georgia may send a certain message but taking out irans capability in one quick swift move is a whole other message. a real loud message.

745 wolfie  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:31:42am

re: #669 kuffar

Turkey's military is no slouch, 2nd largest in NATO. And well equipped. Not sure about their expertise.

Traditionally, the Turks haven't needed expertise when facing Russians.
They have evolved (!) to have an automatic kill response.

746 Saif al Kufr  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:31:47am

There is an unfortunate cold war mentality among both Russians and the West which holds that any interaction between the two may not be a positive-sum game. This often leads to negative-sum strategies on both sides. E.g.: As part of this mentality we support anti-Semitic (but anti-Russian) movements in the former Soviet republics like Lithuania ([Link: www.haaretz.com...] and Ukraine ([Link: www.globalresearch.ca...] Vice versa, as part of this mentality Russia supports Iran (for which it's only a matter of time before it begins to bite the hand that feeds it).

We need to reach a rapprochement with Russia that results in a deal where Russia may do whatever it pleases with its hegemonic fiefdoms in return for supporting us on the issue of Iran. It is unfortunate that Georgia, which is one of the better societies in the post-Soviet world (not saying much), would have to be sacrificed in the process. However, aside from the oil pipeline, it offers us very little in terms of our global interests. This political realism is necessary if we are to achieve a relationship with Russia that brings it on board in our fight against the two major threats to our security today - Iran and Sunni radical Islam.

747 Dark_Falcon  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:31:51am

re: #719 redc1c4

evidently your "acceptable cost" is zero... would you care to define it otherwise? what *is* "acceptable" in your eyes?

Acceptable to me refers to the risk of war with a large nuclear power. Ukraine keeps that risk low, attacking Russia raises it higher than I am willing to go.

748 redc1c4  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:31:53am

re: #705 Dark_Falcon

We would confronting Russia directly, close to their bases of supply and within what Russia perceives as its sphere of control. Such a conflict could easily spill out of control. I'd rather place forces in Ukraine and exert pressure that way. I'd not disagreeing about our overall interests and obligations, merely how we fulfill said obligations.

and the geographical differences between where Gerogia & the Ukraine are in relation to russia are what, exactly? both have contiguous borders with them, both were part of the Soviet Union, and both are, AIUI, considered by the russians to be inside their "sphere of influence"

since, at least with my plan, would not be directly confronting the russians, i don't see what the problem is. i want to drop ordnance inside Georgia, at that countries request, on it's own assets. there's no grounds for a russian complaint, especially if the bombs fall when there none of their troops present. the fact that they would be cut off from resupply, etc, is a function of their being in the country illegally to begin with. as for the Georgians shooting down foreign A/C over their territory illegally, that's perfectly legitimate under international law.

749 papawhisky  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:31:58am

re: #314 realwest

papawhiskey: Registered since: Jan 7, 2007 at 7:01 am
No. of comments posted: 10

So, really, who are you? And blaming Georgia for starting all this is just so much bullshit. Georgia is a functioning DEMOCRACY - not like Russia, a real one. And you think it's president started a war he couldn't win so he could get re-elected?
Hope you keep up your "rapid pace" of commenting.

Please do let me know what frequency of posting is required to validate my comments.

My only query/comment is that this was an incredibly stupid thing for Misha to do. He tried to take back territory that had been lost by force in 1992 - said loss reinforced by 'softer' techniques such as the forced expulsion of Georgians, Russian military presence and Russian passports.

The Russians were massed on the border and took full advantage of this. Now they're going to overrun this country, control the one 'free' pipeline of Caspian oil and totally scupper our chances to get the first Russian border country into NATO.

Why did Misha do this? Did he think we were going to swoop in and back him up?

750 Dianna  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:32:06am

re: #692 jcm

I'm struggling with gloom.

751 markos  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:32:13am

re: #723 vagabond trader

They are no longer the USSR we once knew.


Barry, is that you throwing the USSR under the bus. ; )

752 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:32:43am

re: #745 wolfie

Traditionally, the Turks haven't needed expertise when facing Russians.
They have evolved (!) to have an automatic kill response.

Precisely.

753 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:32:59am

re: #731 so.cal.swede

There's no way the US will step into this one. Bush has to look after his legacy at this point... I could see him doing it earlier in his administration, when he pushed hard his "i'll do what's right even though it's not popular" - then he might have. Not now, however.

* * *
It was CLINTONIAN to ignore attacks on the USS Cole during the 2000 Presidential debates.

It wouldn't be Bush-like to ignore Russian invasions on his watch.

Legacy planning is Clintonian wishful thinking.

754 jorline  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:32:59am

re: #737 J.D.

Who's surprised?

They think that 9/11 was done by Bush and or Israel anyway.

755 Ben Hur  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:33:29am

re: #728 NY Nana

Here are statements from our next President and that other guy...just compare them...Hussein? A lightweight Marxist. McCain? A mensch.

Unbelievable!

Baruch's reads like a BBC press report!

"Outbreak of violence?"

“I strongly condemn the outbreak of violence in Georgia, and urge an immediate end to armed conflict. Now is the time for Georgia and Russia to show restraint, and to avoid an escalation to full scale war. Georgia’s territorial integrity must be respected. All sides should enter into direct talks on behalf of stability in Georgia, and the United States, the United Nations Security Council, and the international community should fully support a peaceful resolution to this crisis.”

THere is no wrong or right, guilty or innocent, all sides are legitimate in a POST MODERNIST world.

More "both sides" BS.

"Cycle of violence" can't be far behind.

756 Honorary Yooper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:33:36am

re: #733 Dianna

I'm concerned about their logistics; Turkey shares a border with Georgia, but it's in Eastern Turkey, and there's a honking great mountain range between the central bases and any ability to help Georgia.

I'm not a military expert, but I was looking at the maps, and got a bit nervous.

Mountains or not, I'd be sure that Turkey is always in the Kremlin's mind. They have a history of going to war (often) with the Turks over the control of the Bosporus and Dardanelles, and have had designs over Istanbul for centuries.

As I said before, I'd also be nervous if I were in the Baltics, Poland, Ukraine, and Armenia. Gotta wonder if Baku is also on Putin's hit list.

757 so.cal.swede  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:34:04am

re: #749 papawhisky

And the world will just shrug ...

758 Ben Hur  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:34:08am

re: #741 WriterMom

Yep. "Youths".


Youths...or Youths?

759 Dark_Falcon  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:34:21am

re: #751 markos

Barry, is that you throwing the USSR under the bus. ; )

I don't think you can throw a tank under the bus. They have a habit of crushing buses.

760 A. van Hilten  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:34:29am

re: #725 J.D.

I would have guessed you were of Dutch descent.
Did I spell that right?

Actually, I am. But I'll never consider myself anything other that an individual citizen (of the world?)—that's why I don't like indulging in national stereotyping, because I have seen too many people do that with the US or Israel.

761 Dianna  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:34:49am

re: #705 Dark_Falcon

So writing off Georgia is just the price of doing business? I think that would be a terrible mistake.

762 NY Nana  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:34:55am

170 Americans evacuated from Georgia: U.S.

The U.S. State Department said on Monday it had helped to evacuate at least 170 American citizens from Georgia as well as dependents of embassy staff in the capital Tbilisi because of fighting with Russia.

State Department spokesman Robert Wood said about 170 private American citizens joined several U.S. convoys bound for Armenia. Dependents of U.S. embassy staff were also in those convoys, he said.

He said the U.S. Embassy in Tbilisi was open despite these departures and it was unclear how many other Americans had fled the fighting, which broke out last Thursday over the breakaway region of South Ossetia.

763 so.cal.swede  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:35:00am

re: #758 Ben Hur

Youths...or Youths?

"Youths"

764 opnion  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:35:15am

re: #693 J.D.

For my part, it's known as "letting off steam".
What, do you think, will change their attitude, if what we have done thus far is not enough?


Actually, the French attitude toward us is getting really tedious.
I have a French neighbor who ranted to me about how unsophistiacated Americans are . I did point out that , you know saved them from Hitler. He said 'How long do you expect us to be grateful."
At that point I looke at he and his wife & said, 'Ya know the plane that brought yo here will take you back to the Euro trash hellhole that you came from. I do not expect a Christmas card.

765 lostlakehiker  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:35:23am

re: #7 jcm

Georgia is a friend of the US.
Georgia is trying very hard to be representative democracy.
Russia has been escalating since Putin took power.

I think it's time to render aid to Georgian. Airlift of hardware and supplies, even air support.

I believe this is one of those times it is necessary to show our core values as a country mean something.

Is anybody thinking about the likely outcome of war between the U.S. and Russia? If we render minimal aid, Georgia will lose all the same. If we render more aid, Georgia will lose after a more prolonged and destructive fight. If we send combat aircraft to clear the skies of Russian warplanes, Georgia will lose on the ground anyhow, even assuming that the Russians do not pick up the glove thrown down by U.S. air intervention.

If we bomb Russian ground combat forces, the Russians will have to drop any polite pretense we may have tacitly agreed on, and consider herself in a direct fight with the U.S. The fight would cost far more than the stakes are worth, even in the most optimistic dream of how it might go. And it might go badly. It might get out of hand, with incalculable consequences.

There is nothing we can do, militarily, to tilt the scales in this fight. The risks are insane, the prospects of success just about nil, and the payoff if we did gain some kind of success, dubious. Sometimes, war is not the answer.

We do have some economic and diplomatic cards to play. What, after all, can Russia gain by a full-blown conquest of Georgia? The occupation of the place would be a pointless expense. The rest of Russia's neighbors would be put on their guard, and the ones geographically connected to NATO would have reason to want to join, while NATO would have more reason to admit them to the alliance. Russia's trading partners would have reason to take a more cautious line with investments, and to try to diversify their sources of raw materials now bought mainly from Russia.

If we play the cards we do have, we stand a good chance of convincing Russia that conquest and victory are counterproductive. Russia can settle for the status-quo ante, perhaps with a Georgian guarantee to let that stand from now on. Russian face is not imperiled. Russian dignity is intact. Nothing of any real consequence for Russia rides on whether the Imperial Legions devastate Tbilisi or go back into camp.

766 J.S.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:35:27am

re: #732 Cognito

It was at the "top of the hour" (noon Mountain Standard time) on BBC World "News" television channel...(I don't know the name of the program...there was a BBC "host" doing interviews -- and the "host" stated that the Georgian officials were lying...(as a matter of fact, he expressed it in much stronger terms -- like, "such utter rubbish coming from...[name of Minister here]" -- very strongly worded...)

767 redc1c4  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:35:57am

re: #727 Dark_Falcon

As I have said, the B2s could work. The C130s however, would be spotted and shot down. I don't believe that prop planes could survive the air defenses the Russians can field.

we're flying the Georgian troops back to Georgia and nothing is happening. what makes you think the russians want to piss us off by shooting down one of our cargo A/C? it's be one thing if we were to set up a CAP and defend Georgian airspace, but routine trash hauler flights are an entirely different issue. AIUI, we've got flights in & out all the time.

768 A. van Hilten  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:36:17am

re: #726 WriterMom

That is an insane comparison. Because Americans don't care about French foreign policy-we shouldn't be suprised that people don't care about 9/11? Is that really what you are saying?

Yes, that seems to be the prevailing mood around here.

769 so.cal.swede  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:36:40am

I just realized this would be an excellent opportunity for the Russians to invade the US ... right up on the shores of Savannah

Imagine the confusion

The russians are where? ... I know it's been in the news for days! What?

770 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:36:58am

re: #762 NY Nana

170 Americans evacuated from Georgia: U.S.

* * *
Thanks for this Nana. Is it my imagination or is our State Dept. always cutting & running instead of standing & fighting.

771 A. van Hilten  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:37:27am

re: #737 J.D.

Who's surprised?

WriterMom.

772 Dark_Falcon  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:37:41am

re: #761 Dianna

So writing off Georgia is just the price of doing business? I think that would be a terrible mistake.

I've never advocated writing Georgia off. But I am not willing to risk open war over it.

773 so.cal.swede  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:37:59am

re: #770 alegrias

* * *
Thanks for this Nana. Is it my imagination or is our State Dept. always cutting & running instead of standing & fighting.

What would you want? Send in a brigade of marines onto foreign soil?

774 abolitionist  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:38:09am

re: #568 buzzsawmonkey

Has Obama said anything about the Russian aggression yet?

Has McCain?

From Georgia: Russia 'conducting cyber war'

Barack Obama, the Democratic US Presidential candidate, has demanded Moscow halt the internet attacks as well as observing a ceasefire on the ground.

Also, I went to that site looking for info about where Turkey stands in this, and found a clue. Emphasis mine:

Analysts have immediately accused the Russian Business Network (RBN), a network of criminal hackers with close links to the Russian mafia and government, of the Georgian attacks.

Jart Armin, a researcher who runs a website tracking the activity of the RBN, has released data claiming to show that visits to Georgian sites had been re-routed through servers in Russia and Turkey, where the traffic was blocked. Armin said the servers "are well known to be under the control of RBN and influenced by the Russian Government."

Mr Armin said that administrators in Germany had intervened at the weekend, temporarily making the Georgian sites available by re-routing their traffic through German servers run by Deutsche Telekom. Within hours, however, control over the traffic had been wrested back, this time to servers based in Moscow.

775 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:38:34am

re: #764 opnion

Actually, the French attitude toward us is getting really tedious.
I have a French neighbor who ranted to me about how unsophistiacated Americans are . I did point out that , you know saved them from Hitler. He said 'How long do you expect us to be grateful."
At that point I looke at he and his wife & said, 'Ya know the plane that brought yo here will take you back to the Euro trash hellhole that you came from. I do not expect a Christmas card.

* * *
May their next Joyeux Noel be in France!

776 Saif al Kufr  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:39:06am

re: #765 lostlakehiker

Well said!

777 experiencedtraveller  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:39:30am

re: #666 redc1c4

Thanks for the ad hominem, the Petitio Principii and identifying your terms for the thread.

I usually don't argue with those unable to master the art of capitalization but if you wish to fight for Georgia you can travel there via sailboat from the Aegean. All other routes are long closed.

778 so.cal.swede  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:39:41am

re: #768 A. van Hilten

Yes, that seems to be the prevailing mood around here.

I'm confused now... People at LGF think : "because we don't care about the French, we shouldn't be surprised they don't care about 9/11".

That seems contrary to what people think here.

779 redc1c4  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:39:42am

re: #747 Dark_Falcon

Acceptable to me refers to the risk of war with a large nuclear power. Ukraine keeps that risk low, attacking Russia raises it higher than I am willing to go.

and russia is going to go nuke over Georgia? do they even have functional nukes delivery systems anymore? you keep making all your decisions based on direct confrontation, rather than thinking outside the box. there is no need to directly confront the russians in Georgia. however, it is still possible to make them wish they'd never gone there, and that all they get back are coffins & repatriated POW's. the Georgians can keep the AFV's where they run out of fuel.

780 Dark_Falcon  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:40:05am

re: #767 redc1c4

we're flying the Georgian troops back to Georgia and nothing is happening. what makes you think the russians want to piss us off by shooting down one of our cargo A/C? it's be one thing if we were to set up a CAP and defend Georgian airspace, but routine trash hauler flights are an entirely different issue. AIUI, we've got flights in & out all the time.

I've got to think on this some more. You've given we some good points to consider. I'll post on a later thread after I've thought this over a bit more.

781 Wendya  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:40:10am

re: #772 Dark_Falcon

I've never advocated writing Georgia off. But I am not willing to risk open war over it.

We saw a lot of that mentality between WWI and WWII.

782 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:40:32am

re: #773 so.cal.swede

What would you want? Send in a brigade of marines onto foreign soil?

* * *
I would have wanted our STate Department to have been aware of Russian activity & reporting on faux Russian "peacekeeping" in Georgia, and Russian troop movements, instead of conducting tea parties in Tbilisi.

783 Dianna  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:41:09am

re: #722 wolfie

A good and thoughtful reply, but I must disagree.

The messy Caucasus is exactly the place to stop the expansionist Russians.

Azeri spring wheat, Azeri, Georgian and Armenian produce, Azeri and Armenian oil are issues. To say nothing of the territorial position the Caucasus occupies; the Caucasus cannot be re-incorporated into the Russian Empire without strengthening it to a dangerous degree.

That would make Ukraine nice, but not absolutely necessary.

784 so.cal.swede  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:41:58am

re: #782 alegrias

* * *
I would have wanted our STate Department to have been aware of Russian activity & reporting on faux Russian "peacekeeping" in Georgia, and Russian troop movements, instead of conducting tea parties in Tbilisi.

I see. So the Americans should have been evacuated earlier because we should have known this was coming. I think you got a point there.

785 Dianna  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:42:12am

re: #756 Honorary Yooper

As I said before, I'd also be nervous if I were in the Baltics, Poland, Ukraine, and Armenia. Gotta wonder if Baku is also on Putin's hit list.

Baku's the next target.

786 debutaunt  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:42:21am

re: #683 J.S.

A BBC person, in a debate about the current war in Georgia, has reiterated that Georgia's Ministry officials are all lying -- that there are no Russians in Gori, Georgia...(I don't really know how this BBC person, sitting behind a desk located somewhere in the West, can speak with such absolute certainty -- but that's what BBC personnel maintain -- no Russians in Gori.). (guess we'll have to wait and see who's telling the truth..)

BBC Bob!

787 Ben Hur  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:42:28am

re: #782 alegrias

* * *
I would have wanted our STate Department to have been aware of Russian activity & reporting on faux Russian "peacekeeping" in Georgia, and Russian troop movements, instead of conducting tea parties in Tbilisi.

The world (and especially our State Dept) LOVE faux peacekeepers.

See:

Sinai
Lebanon
SOmalia
Georgia


Where else?

788 A. van Hilten  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:43:01am

re: #778 so.cal.swede

I'm confused now... People at LGF think : "because we don't care about the French, we shouldn't be surprised they don't care about 9/11".

That seems contrary to what people think here.

Sorry. Around "here" was meant to refer to Europe and more specifically, France.

789 opnion  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:43:07am

re: #775 alegrias

* * *
May their next Joyeux Noel be in France!

Two more years, but they are moving to New Jersey

790 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:43:09am

re: #760 A. van Hilten

Actually, I am. But I'll never consider myself anything other that an individual citizen (of the world?)—that's why I don't like indulging in national stereotyping, because I have seen too many people do that with the US or Israel.

That's the difference, then, between you and I. I consider myself a citizen of the United States of America. Nevertheless, I do understand your point of view.

791 NY Nana  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:43:30am

re: #683 J.S.

Does this sound like there aren't, anymore than 'there are no homosexuals in Iran'? Maybe Ahmadinnerjacket also works for al-Beeb?

Georgia: Gori evacuated as fears of Russian advance into Georgia grow

The photo will make you cry. May G-d help the Georgians.

792 scottishbuzzsaw  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:43:39am

re: #764 opnion

Actually, the French attitude toward us is getting really tedious.
I have a French neighbor who ranted to me about how unsophistiacated Americans are . I did point out that , you know saved them from Hitler. He said 'How long do you expect us to be grateful."
At that point I looke at he and his wife & said, 'Ya know the plane that brought yo here will take you back to the Euro trash hellhole that you came from. I do not expect a Christmas card.

That reminded me of a song from the 'Wicked' musical..."No good deed goes unpunished, no act of charity goes unresented..."

793 Honorary Yooper  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:43:52am

re: #743 markos

I'm thinking the run up to WWII wasn't clear at the time, only in retrospect. Clear now. Not so clear then. Explains us not getting in till 41 instead of when? 39, sooner? I just don't know.

I think a lot of folks could see a potential war on the horizon (in Europe) as early as 1938 in Munich. Hence why everyone wanted to buy "peace in our time". In Asia, it was obvious as early as the Japanese invasion of Manchuria in 1931 that there would be war there. The US threatened to cut off Japan's oil as they were marching toward SE Asia. The US had also cut off manufactured goods from Japan as well. When we did cut them off from the oil, they struck at Pearl, and also in the Philippines. Most folks don't realise they attacked Hong Kong, Hawai'i, the Philippines, the Dutch East Indies, and Malaya the exact same day.

794 Dianna  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:44:02am

re: #740 paradox42

Putin is not going to risk nuking us. Georgia, maybe. Not us or Europe.

795 so.cal.swede  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:44:03am

re: #785 Dianna

Baku's the next target.

That would be interesting ... very very interesting.

796 willowone  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:44:28am

so McCain; Russian military forces crossed an internationally-recognized border into thesovereign territory of Georgia. Russia should immediately and unconditionally cease its military operations and withdraw all forces from sovereign Georgian territory
.U.S. should immediately convene an emergency session of the United Nations Security Council to call on Russia to reverse course. The U.S. should immediately work with the EU and the OSCE to put diplomatic pressure on Russia to reverse this perilous course it has chosen. We should immediately call a meeting of the North Atlantic Council to assess Georgia’s security and review measures NATO can take to contribute to stabilizing this very dangerous situation. Finally, the international community needs to establish a truly independent and neutral peacekeeping force in South Ossetia.”
Obama:Now is the time for Georgia and Russia to show restraint, and to avoid an escalation to full scale war. Georgia’s territorial integrity must be respected. All sides should enter into direct talks on behalf of stability in Georgia, and the United States, the United Nations Security Council, and the international community should fully support a peaceful resolution to this crisis.” McCain seems to direct fault where it lies. and Obama seems to favor no fault . (kids behave) let tommy have his things

797 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:44:34am

re: #765 lostlakehiker

Very cogent.

We do have some economic and diplomatic cards to play.

These are our strengths.

798 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:44:35am

re: #771 A. van Hilten

WriterMom.

I doubt if she's surprised.
Disappointed, yes.

799 quickjustice  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:44:40am

re: #765 lostlakehiker

At this point, it doesn't matter whether the Georgians "win" or "lose". What matters is that our reputation as an ally remains intact, and that the Russians pay heavily for acts of aggression. This war must become a Pyrrhic victory for the Russians.

In future, they must have second, and third, thoughts about attacking our allies, no matter how small. Any calculation on the part of the West that rewards aggression is dangerous, and ensures a repeat of the events leading up to the Second World War.

800 alegrias  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:44:49am

re: #787 Ben Hur

The world (and especially our State Dept) LOVE faux peacekeepers.

See:

Sinai
Lebanon
SOmalia
Georgia


Where else?

* * *
Sudan & Bosnia.

Worthless faux people.

801 redc1c4  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:45:10am

re: #765 lostlakehiker

Is anybody thinking about the likely outcome of war between the U.S. and Russia? If we render minimal aid, Georgia will lose all the same. If we render more aid, Georgia will lose after a more prolonged and destructive fight. If we send combat aircraft to clear the skies of Russian warplanes, Georgia will lose on the ground anyhow, even assuming that the Russians do not pick up the glove thrown down by U.S. air intervention.

If we bomb Russian ground combat forces, the Russians will have to drop any polite pretense we may have tacitly agreed on, and consider herself in a direct fight with the U.S. The fight would cost far more than the stakes are worth, even in the most optimistic dream of how it might go. And it might go badly. It might get out of hand, with incalculable consequences.

There is nothing we can do, militarily, to tilt the scales in this fight. The risks are insane, the prospects of success just about nil, and the payoff if we did gain some kind of success, dubious. Sometimes, war is not the answer.

We do have some economic and diplomatic cards to play. What, after all, can Russia gain by a full-blown conquest of Georgia? The occupation of the place would be a pointless expense. The rest of Russia's neighbors would be put on their guard, and the ones geographically connected to NATO would have reason to want to join, while NATO would have more reason to admit them to the alliance. Russia's trading partners would have reason to take a more cautious line with investments, and to try to diversify their sources of raw materials now bought mainly from Russia.

If we play the cards we do have, we stand a good chance of convincing Russia that conquest and victory are counterproductive. Russia can settle for the status-quo ante, perhaps with a Georgian guarantee to let that stand from now on. Russian face is not imperiled. Russian dignity is intact. Nothing of any real consequence for Russia rides on whether the Imperial Legions devastate Tbilisi or go back into camp.


you lack imagination. there are plenty of things we can do that avoid direct confrontation. there are only 5 LOC's between Georgia and russia. cut those on the Georgian side, and their forces are stranded. give Georgia some MANPADS, and the russian ability to resupply via air is negated. it's a given that the russian troops have only a few days fuel & food on hand, and once that runs out, they're FUBAR. their two choices will be to surrender or die.

next problem please...

802 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:45:53am

re: #764 opnion

Tedious is an understatement, imho.

803 so.cal.swede  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:45:56am

re: #788 A. van Hilten

I see. Dangit. this "everyone post in a single thread" format is not conducive for reading comprehension.

CHARLES!

804 willowone  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:47:07am

re: #799 quickjustice

agree, and i hope our response it quick and smart.

805 opnion  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:47:09am

re: #792 scottishbuzzsaw

That reminded me of a song from the 'Wicked' musical..."No good deed goes unpunished, no act of charity goes unresented..."

There actually is a resentment about us saving them in World War II.
France had the largest army in Europe & got creamed.
Their opposition to us in Viet Nam had a lot to do with them getting whipped at Bien Diem Phu & trown out.

806 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:47:43am

re: #754 jorline

They think that 9/11 was done by Bush and or Israel anyway.

I guess they sleep better at night if they can convince themselves of that.

807 JHW  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:47:53am

re: #750 Dianna

Reading about your reference on siloviki, and kind of allied to what I posted about a shady character, I'm reminded nothing more so than organized crime families running a nation. There have been all kinds of reports and allegations about looting and Swiss bank accounts by the modern politicians controlling Russia.

Medvedev, President of the Russian Federation (a figurehead I.M.O ) was Chairman of the board of Gazprom. Mikhail Khodorkovsky, at one time the head of Yukos and at one time the richest man in Russia, is now in prison for tax evasion. Gang warfare without tommy- guns and Valentine's Day massacres?

808 Silhouette  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:48:06am
“I strongly condemn the outbreak of violence in Georgia, and urge an immediate end to armed conflict. Now is the time for Georgia and Russia to show restraint, and to avoid an escalation to full scale war. Georgia’s territorial integrity must be respected. All sides should enter into direct talks on behalf of stability in Georgia, and the United States, the United Nations Security Council, and the international community should fully support a peaceful resolution to this crisis.”

Obama's statement doesn't sound like a socialist so much as it sounds like a statement from a beauty pagent contestant.

"I think war is bad. And I think they both should stop fighting right now. And if they should just talk about it, maybe at the UN and stuff."

It's better if you image him up-talking: ending each sentence as if he is asking a question.

809 so.cal.swede  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:48:33am

re: #801 redc1c4

Hmmm.. what if they use traditional resupply by using roadways? I don't think Georgia has the manpower to shut down the Russian resupply convoys. They might dent it, but they can't stop it.

810 Dianna  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:49:04am

re: #765 lostlakehiker

That's saying, "It's all much too difficult, and we should just give up now."

I don't know whether I'm appalled, depressed, or angry, reading that.

811 BeerDrinking_VictoryMonkey  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:49:30am

re: #801 redc1c4

you lack imagination. there are plenty of things we can do that avoid direct confrontation. there are only 5 LOC's between Georgia and russia. cut those on the Georgian side, and their forces are stranded. give Georgia some MANPADS, and the russian ability to resupply via air is negated. it's a given that the russian troops have only a few days fuel & food on hand, and once that runs out, they're FUBAR. their two choices will be to surrender or die.

next problem please...

What's a MANPAD - aside from what I call my apartment?

812 Biff  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:49:38am

How would we all feel if in the near future the Palestininians are given a nation-state on the West Bank? Furthermore, there are Jewish settlement communities in the West Bank that refuse to give up their homes and properties, and under the terms of the peace agreement, are permitted to remain within the new Nation of Palestine, while holding Israeli passports. Some time later, the Palestinians begin to shell and attack the Jewish communities within the Nation of Palestine. (Who would ever have imagined?!) At this point, the government of Israel (probably not led by Kadima) invades the Nation of Palestine; first driving the Palestinian Army out of the Jewish areas of the West Bank, then continuing into the heart of the West Bank in an effort to punish and cripple the Palestinian Army as a result of the attacks on the Jewish communities.

I think these hypothetical actions of the Israelis would be expected and reasonable. So, what's the difference?

813 least  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:49:55am

re: #673 A. van Hilten

Yes, the French supported the American fight for independence . . . and they haven't stopped reminding the US about that support.
But all the while, the French maintain an attitude of disdain (if not outright hostility) toward anything from the US -- unless, of course, the Americans are once again saving their butts (or spending copious amounts of cash).

814 wolfie  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:50:04am

re: #770 alegrias

* * *
Thanks for this Nana. Is it my imagination or is our State Dept. always cutting & running instead of standing & fighting.

Non-essential, civilian embassy personnel are always evacuated when their is a clear and present danger to their safety.

815 Silhouette  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:50:10am

re: #800 alegrias

* * *
Sudan & Bosnia.

Worthless faux people.

Worthless is the best we can hope for in peacekeeping forces. When they actually get something done it is ususally along the lines of setting up a youth brothel.

816 NY Nana  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:51:04am

re: #770 alegrias

Is it my imagination or is our State Dept. always cutting & running instead of standing & fighting.

State? Feh. I have a feeling that they do not want to be involved, as they just do not give a damn.

Damn it, Georgia is an ally. And there is a community of Georgians in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, who are going through hell right now...

Somebody had better do something, or I fear that this inaction will convince Putin that he can go back to the bad old days..he is a monster.

817 redc1c4  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:51:22am

re: #777 experiencedtraveller

Thanks for the ad hominem, the Petitio Principii and identifying your terms for the thread.

I usually don't argue with those unable to master the art of capitalization but if you wish to fight for Georgia you can travel there via sailboat from the Aegean. All other routes are long closed.

iow, you have nothing...

thanks for playing!

818 Dianna  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:51:57am

re: #772 Dark_Falcon

It's now or later, I think.

The Russians are expansionist totalitarians. We either slap them down now, as hard as we can, or we do it when Russia has better resource depth.

819 BeerDrinking_VictoryMonkey  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:52:00am
“I strongly condemn the outbreak of violence in Georgia, and urge an immediate end to armed conflict. Now is the time for Georgia and Russia to show restraint, and to avoid an escalation to full scale war. Georgia’s territorial integrity must be respected. All sides should enter into direct talks on behalf of stability in Georgia, and the United States, the United Nations Security Council, and the international community should fully support a peaceful resolution to this crisis.”

I hate to break it to you, Barry, but Russian tanks crossing the border into Georgia proper means there already is a full-scale war. So not ready for prime-time, this one is.

820 Dark_Falcon  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:52:56am

re: #811 BeerDrinking_VictoryMonkey

What's a MANPAD - aside from what I call my apartment?

MAN Portable Air Defense. Our Stinger and the Russian SA-16 are examples of MANPADS SAMs.

821 BeerDrinking_VictoryMonkey  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:53:47am

re: #820 Dark_Falcon

thanks.

822 J.D.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:54:02am

re: #819 BeerDrinking_VictoryMonkey

So not ready for prime-time, this one is.

Scary.

823 mglazer  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:54:11am

re: #770 alegrias

You'll be lucky if they help you period - run, walk, stand anything.

If you can't hlp yourself don't expect help from others - even your own country you are a citizen of and pay taxes to.

erewhon
[Link: en.wikipedia.org...]

[Link: www.erewhonmarket.com...]

A Utopia where everyone is expected to maintain their own health - wow how reasonable and unsocialistic

"universal healthcare"
anyone, anyone...

824 Dianna  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:54:21am

re: #795 so.cal.swede

No, it's predictable.

First, Russia consolidates the Caucasus so they can't be cut in half, and has control of all its resources. Then? I have some ideas. But if we don't do something now, it will get much, much worse, and that quickly.

825 redc1c4  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:55:05am

re: #809 so.cal.swede

Hmmm.. what if they use traditional resupply by using roadways? I don't think Georgia has the manpower to shut down the Russian resupply convoys. They might dent it, but they can't stop it.

the LOC's *are* the roadways... there are only 5, and all go through mountainous terrain with multiple tunnels and shear faces. bomb those and their are no roads. when the switch to airdrop, use the MANPADS on those lovely low & slow cargo craft full of fuel, ammo, etc... fireworks!

826 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:55:39am
827 mglazer  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:56:24am

Why do rich Canadians come to America to get treated when it is free there. They say because they want the best health treatment available.

828 Dianna  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:56:51am

re: #807 JHW

It's a good analogy, yes.

Don't forget to add in other elements, though: Russian territorial issues; bureaucratic empire-building and loyalties; the peculiarly aggressive and paranoid mind-set of the KGB/FSB.

829 wolfie  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:58:05am

re: #808 Silhouette

Obama's statement doesn't sound like a socialist so much as it sounds like a statement from a beauty pagent contestant.

"I think war is bad. And I think they both should stop fighting right now. And if they should just talk about it, maybe at the UN and stuff."

It's better if you image him up-talking: ending each sentence as if he is asking a question.

I'm laughing because it's spot on. Too true, too true.
But what else is his campaign but a pageant?

830 JHW  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:58:17am

re: #828 Dianna

Agreed.

831 Silhouette  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:58:33am

re: #827 mglazer

Why do rich Canadians come to America to get treated when it is free there. They say because they want the best health treatment available.

And it isn't really "free." In essence, they are paying twice, and freely choosing to pay the second time.

Much like every American who chooses to send their child to private school.

832 Dark_Falcon  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:59:12am

re: #825 redc1c4

the LOC's *are* the roadways... there are only 5, and all go through mountainous terrain with multiple tunnels and shear faces. bomb those and their are no roads. when the switch to airdrop, use the MANPADS on those lovely low & slow cargo craft full of fuel, ammo, etc... fireworks!

Could they resupply by sea? They do control the water nearby, they might have sufficient landing craft to move supplies that way.

833 J.S.  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:59:16am

BBC world "news" tv channel is claiming that Russians are beginning a withdrawal of troops from previously occupied areas...(..?) Can we have that independently verified -- I mean by someone not linked to the Kremlin?

834 Westward Ho  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 11:59:41am

re: #779 redc1c4

and russia is going to go nuke over Georgia? do they even have functional nukes delivery systems anymore?

The problem is that not many decision makers in the west want to find that out - thankfully in my opinion though against the spirt of general tone of the thread.

835 kuffar  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 12:00:32pm

That is why the Turks if they wanna help the Georgians they don't take the east Turkey route.

I am not sure about the political situation. But Ukraine, Bulgaria and Romania were former Soviet satellite states, how do they feel toward the Rodinia?

A northern end run launching from Ukrainia, sort of like Schwartzkopf's Hail Mary writ large. A relief force heading south from Ukraine with a thrust toward Volgagrad to cut off lines of communications and secure the southern forces rear.

It'd be a close run thing. With American air-power... Good God...

836 Dianna  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 12:01:26pm

re: #809 so.cal.swede

Russian logistics are - how shall we put this? - less than stellar.

837 Silhouette  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 12:02:10pm

re: #833 J.S.

BBC world "news" tv channel is claiming that Russians are beginning a withdrawal of troops from previously occupied areas...(..?) Can we have that independently verified -- I mean by someone not linked to the Kremlin?

I don't think I'd trust anybody except maybe a couple of bloggers on the ground in Georgia and South Ossetia.

838 Dianna  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 12:03:10pm

re: #812 Biff

You don't know much of the history of the region, do you?

The situations are not analogous.

839 Wendya  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 12:03:45pm

re: #808 Silhouette

Obama's statement doesn't sound like a socialist so much as it sounds like a statement from a beauty pagent contestant.

"I think war is bad. And I think they both should stop fighting right now. And if they should just talk about it, maybe at the UN and stuff."

It's better if you image him up-talking: ending each sentence as if he is asking a question.

I guess Barry forgot that Russia has a veto on the Security Council.

840 quickjustice  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 12:04:39pm

re: #826 buzzsawmonkey

Not to put too fine a point on it, but "peacekeepers" are used to keep an existing peace, not as combat troops. They have extremely limited rules of engagement that do not include engaging invading combat troops.

An example was the U.S. Marine force that was peacekeeping in Lebanon when Hezbollah blew up the barracks. They weren't in Lebanon as combat troops. They had reason to expect cooperation from the locals, but were stabbed in the back by Hezbollah treachery. Their rules of engagement didn't permit them to protect themselves properly, or to go after Hezbollah like combat troops. It turned out they were sitting ducks, which made the attack on them especially heinous. It's also why President Reagan was so incensed.

Letting the Russians act as "peacekeepers" in a situation where they weren't neutral exposes the bankruptcy of the U.N. for the umpteenth time. Sweeping aside existing peacekeepers who are true neutrals exposes Russian aggression in defiance of international law.

So the question remains-- what does the U.N., a "collective security" organization, do now?

841 A. van Hilten  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 12:04:57pm

re: #790 J.D.

That's the difference, then, between you and I. I consider myself a citizen of the United States of America. Nevertheless, I do understand your point of view.

Hey, I do enjoy French surrender jokes as much as the next guy. Thing is by turning it into a cliché, you risk cheapening the sacrifice of those who fought and bled with the Allies in WWII. A bunch of them died at Dunkirk, whereas they could have surrendered to the Germans just as easily.

I can understand your position as an American citizen, but painting Ze French with the wide surrender-monkey brush is ineffective, unfair and counterproductive IMO. The Dissident Frogman comes to mind:

[Link: www.thedissidentfrogman.com...]

842 Dark_Falcon  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 12:05:38pm

re: #839 Wendya

I guess Barry forgot that Russia has a veto on the Security Council.

He didn't forget. He just thinks his "we-are-all-united" charm can solve any problem. What a fool he is.

843 jorline  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 12:07:14pm

re: #806 J.D.

I guess they sleep better at night if they can convince themselves of that.

I agree and it's not as if they haven't had several wake up calls as well. It's always easier to blame Bush and the Jooos.

844 BeerDrinking_VictoryMonkey  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 12:07:23pm

re: #842 Dark_Falcon

He didn't forget. He just thinks his "we-are-all-united" charm can solve any problem. What a fool he is.

You forgot Obama's secret weapons - He also grew up overseas & doesn't look like the other presidents on the dollar bills. That will solve any problems his charm can't.

845 Biff  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 12:07:44pm

re: #838 Dianna

Probably much more than you. Certainly, way more than you think.

846 itellu3times  Mon, Aug 11, 2008 12:07:46pm