LGF

more options

  

Advertisement

Russia: 'Forget About Georgia's Territorial Integrity'

Thu, Aug 14, 2008 at 8:56:15 am PDT

Russia’s foreign minister said today, “the world can forget about Georgia’s territorial integrity.”

Advertisement

505 comments

  • Comments are open and unmoderated, and do not necessarily reflect the views of Little Green Footballs.
  • Obscene, abusive, silly, or annoying remarks may be deleted, but the fact that particular comments remain on the site in no way constitutes an endorsement of their views by Little Green Footballs.
  • Posts that contain phone numbers, street addresses, email addresses or other personal information will also be deleted, as will posts that consist only of a variation on the word, "First!"
  • Comments that advocate violence will be cause for immediate banning with no appeal.
  • Disagreement and debate are welcome, but insults and abuse are not, and may cause your account to be blocked.
  • REMEMBER: posting comments at LGF is a privilege, not a right. Abuse that privilege, and your account will be blocked.

Hide comments | Jump to bottom

1 jemima  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 8:57:00am

The world can forget about the UN doing anything about it.

2 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 8:57:28am

It was a candid statement -- no propaganda spin.

/gotta give it that

3 galloping granny  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 8:57:29am

They certainly have made that clear, haven't they?

4 Sharmuta  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 8:58:07am

There is no Georgia- there is only Mother Russia.

5 galloping granny  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 8:58:15am

re: #1 jemima

The world can forget about the UN doing anything about it.

Russia has a veto at the UN. Who in their right mind would think that the UN even has the power to do anything about it?

6 debutaunt  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 8:58:15am

I hope Krauthammer is right and we go on the offensive.

7 CIA Reject  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 8:58:54am

"What is ours is ours, what is your is negotiable"

--Leonid Brehznev

/The Bear is Back!

8 Happy Viking  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 8:59:10am

Appears that the old Soviet bear has come out of hibernation.

9 Killgore Trout  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 8:59:13am

It looks like they are going to install a puppet government. Maybe later this week.

10 jcm  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 8:59:20am

'kay then forget about seeing any of the troops or equipment in Georgia again.

11 galloping granny  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 8:59:30am

re: #7 CIA Reject

"What is ours is ours, what is your is negotiable"

--Leonid Brehznev

/The Bear is Back!

The bear never left. He was just hibernating.

12 laZardo  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 8:59:36am

I'm guessing "Forget" was a TV-friendly translation of the actual word.

13 Lawrence Schmerel  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 8:59:46am

re: #5 galloping granny

Barack Obama

14 debutaunt  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 8:59:47am

re: #7 CIA Reject

"What is ours is ours, what is your is negotiable"

--Leonid Brehznev

/The Bear is Back!

We just want the eastern half of your western sandwich - relax.

15 victor_yugo  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:00:23am

re: #1 jemima

The world can forget about the UN doing anything about it.

Precisely the case against our continued membership in the UN. When totalitarians are on equal footing with democracies, something pathological is going on.

16 galloping granny  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:00:24am

re: #5 galloping granny

Russia has a veto at the UN. Who in their right mind would think that the UN even has the power to do anything about it?

BTW, jemima, I was not alluding to you thinking that the UN had the power to do anything. Sorry if it seemed like that. I was thinking of HRH Obama's demand that the UN get right on it.

17 Dirk Diggler  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:00:41am

The disputed regions have been under de facto Russian control for a while now.

If that is all Georgia loses as a result of this conflict are two regions they don't have any control over anyway, then they should consider themselves lucky.

18 eschew_obfuscation  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:01:04am

re: #11 galloping granny

The bear never left. He was just hibernating.

Wait.....just a minute ago, the bear was swimming around looking for an iceberg.......I'm so confused

19 CIA Reject  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:01:09am

re: #11 galloping granny

The bear never left. He was just hibernating.

Yup - looks like this guy was right all along!

20 jemima  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:01:51am

#5

What's the UN for but to take "diplomats" from their stinking hellhole dictator run, thuggish countries and give them the opportunity to live in the civilized world, eat at the best restaurants and double-park with impunity. And of course give free rein to the French peacekeepers in Cote d'Ivoire to rape little girls.

21 Occasional Reader  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:01:57am

And this is their chief diplomat, mind you, announcing "we're thugs! Hey-oooh!".


So much for all that "end of history" crap, Mr. Fukuyama.

22 Iron Fist  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:02:16am

This makes ballistic missile defense even more imperative. So much for the ignorant "Peace Dividend". Time to ramp the military back up to what it was under Reagan.

23 BeerDrinking_VictoryMonkey  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:02:16am

re: #5 galloping granny

Russia has a veto at the UN. Who in their right mind would think that the UN even has the power to do anything about it?

Barry O - oh, wait - you said "right mind", didn't you?

24 Dirk Diggler  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:02:23am
If that is all Georgia loses as a result of this conflict are two regions they don't have any control over anyway, then they should consider themselves lucky.

PIMF

25 BlueCanuck  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:02:35am

The Cold War has been resurrected like a vampire that has had the stake removed from it's heart. Funny I have read a lot of science fiction stories with that premise behind it.

/and it always seems to be the military sci-fi for some reason.

26 marge45b  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:02:39am

Mother Russia will bilk NASA on trips to the ISS when the Shuttle retires.

27 CIA Reject  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:02:42am

re: #14 debutaunt

We just want the eastern half of your western sandwich - relax.

Well, assuming he can figure out east from west on a map I'm sure (G*d forbid!) President Obama will fix everything just fine....

28 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:02:46am
One Russian colonel, who refused to give his name, blamed the fires on looters.

I would sure as hell like to know just WHO the looters were. We've read reports of South Ossetian irregulars traveling with the Russian troops. If SO's are looting Georgian homes, that damns them in my eyes.

/In fairness, I suspect that few hands are clean in this mess.

29 Peacekeeper  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:03:05am

No wisdom in fighting over Georgia, probably not Ukraine either or those three little dots up there on the Baltic coast. Poland? Maybe Poland.

30 galloping granny  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:03:11am

re: #20 jemima

#5

What's the UN for but to take "diplomats" from their stinking hellhole dictator run, thuggish countries and give them the opportunity to live in the civilized world, eat at the best restaurants and double-park with impunity. And of course give free rein to the French peacekeepers in Cote d'Ivoire to rape little girls.

You forget the various enrichment programs they run for their delegates & cronies.

31 Occasional Reader  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:03:28am

re: #26 marge45b

Mother Russia will bilk NASA on trips to the ISS when the Shuttle retires.

I suspect we'll be re-thinking that decision.

32 Kragar (Proud to be Kafir)  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:03:42am

re: #1 jemima

The world can forget about the UN doing anything about it.

A pair of balls beats a full house.

33 eschew_obfuscation  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:03:56am

re: #22 Iron Fist

This makes ballistic missile defense even more imperative. So much for the ignorant "Peace Dividend". Time to ramp the military back up to what it was under Reagan.

I hate to display my ignorance, but what the heck....

How would missile defense have helped Georgia......or help the other balkan countries in similar circumstances?

34 Peacekeeper  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:04:06am

re: #21 Occasional Reader

And this is their chief diplomat, mind you, announcing "we're thugs! Hey-oooh!".


So much for all that "end of history" crap, Mr. Fukuyama.


Any author with a name like that has to be trouble.

35 redshirt  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:04:10am

Wow! What next, China moves on Taiwan?
OK President Bush, I have long been an admirer and supporter. What do we do now?

36 galloping granny  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:04:20am

re: #28 pre-Boomer Marine brat

I would sure as hell like to know just WHO the looters were. We've read reports of South Ossetian irregulars traveling with the Russian troops. If SO's are looting Georgian homes, that damns them in my eyes.

/In fairness, I suspect that few hands are clean in this mess.

In fairness, I suspect there are an awful lot of clean and innocent hands among the 4 million residents of Georgia, very few of whom signed up to be bombed, raped or looted.

37 yesandno  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:04:29am

“the world can forget about Georgia’sthe Ukraine's territorial integrity.”


Fixed it....think this was what he was really trying to say.......

38 calvin coolidge  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:04:37am

Nice of them to clarify that for us, we would have never guessed.

39 jemima  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:05:09am

#30

Oh yes. Enrichment programs. Money-for-Oil-Food-For-No-One and blonde comfort women looking to pay off student loans.

40 Eric Cartman's Conscience  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:05:27am

I'm a bit torn on this one. Georgia itself broke away from Russia for a chance at self-determination. It seems the regions within Georgia want to do the same - breakaway from the governing state for a chance at self-determination. Of course we can't have every friggin' neighborhood in the world basically seceding from the governing state. But it is clear these two regions prefer Russia to Georgia. I don't know how we can simultaneously laud Georgia for breaking away from Russia while insisting South Osettia and Abkhazia may not from Georgia.

41 jorline  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:05:31am

South Ossetia and the Arctic...the great Russian land grab.

42 realwest  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:05:46am

re: #29 Peacekeeper
Hey PK - you forgot (I hope) the sarc tag there.

43 Maine's Michael  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:05:58am

Wait till Russian Expert Condi here's about this. She's gonna be pissed.

I wouldn't want to be her black knee high boots when she starts stomping her feet.

I'm sure she'll take out the frustration on her piano as well.

That'll show Putin!

44 CIA Reject  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:06:15am

re: #33 eschew_obfuscation

I hate to display my ignorance, but what the heck....

How would missile defense have helped Georgia......or help the other balkan countries in similar circumstances?

I think the theory was that we could hit the Soviets with a nuclear strike without fear of reprisal and hence extend a "nuclear umbrella" to our allies in the region.

45 Kenneth  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:06:22am

Georgia: Refugees flee after Russian military breaches ceasefire

At a checkpoint set up by the Russian Army on the approach to the city of Gori from the Georgian capital, Tbilisi, an armoured personnel carrier blocked the road and riflemen had fanned out in the surrounding bushes, their weapons trained on anyone who approached.

All were ethnic Chechens, whose reputation for pitiless brutality in war made them feared throughout the Caucasus.

A stream of Georgians fled the area in cars, tractors and lorries, taking what belongings they could. A black Volga car crammed with passengers carried two more escapers on its roof.

One elderly couple were walking, the woman clearly in shock, her face swollen and one eye badly damaged. She pointed backwards and said: “They are killing people there, the Chechens and the Ossetians.”

The Bear's Bully-boys.

46 bulwrk  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:06:28am

re: #33 eschew_obfuscation

Russian troops may have thought twice before over running over a U.S military installation with U.S troops on the ground.

47 misfit138  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:06:44am

Russia’s foreign minister said today, “the world can forget about Georgia’s territorial integrity.”

Gee, ya think!?!

48 Pullus Iulius  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:06:58am

Can you say Sudetenland?
/I knew you could.

49 BlueCanuck  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:07:11am

re: #19 CIA Reject

Yup - looks like this guy was right all along!

Right about what? His autobiography sounds veeeddddy interesting. If e was originally from the KGB and fought against it, he might have a deeper understanding of Putin.

50 jorline  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:07:20am

Fox reporter on the ground in Georgia just reported that additional Russian troops are entering the country.

51 Maine's Michael  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:07:57am

re: #47 misfit138

Russia’s foreign minister said today, “the world can forget about Georgia’s territorial integrity.”

Gee, ya think!?!

Paraphrase:

'Get stuffed, 'President' Bush.'

52 galloping granny  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:08:02am

re: #40 Eric Cartman's Conscience

I'm a bit torn on this one. Georgia itself broke away from Russia for a chance at self-determination. It seems the regions within Georgia want to do the same - breakaway from the governing state for a chance at self-determination. Of course we can't have every friggin' neighborhood in the world basically seceding from the governing state. But it is clear these two regions prefer Russia to Georgia. I don't know how we can simultaneously laud Georgia for breaking away from Russia while insisting South Osettia and Abkhazia may not from Georgia.

Does that mean we should now release the Southern States from the Union, because they did, after all, exercise the right of self determination and decide that they preferred to make their own compact with each other. You remember the Confederate States of America, right?

53 faraway  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:08:08am

re: #35 redshirt

Wow! What next, China moves on Taiwan?


After the Olympics, grasshopper.

54 FrogMarch  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:08:08am

Pussy Europe
Pussy UN
Pussy us

55 karmic_inquisitor  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:09:09am

Juan Cole went out of his way today to outline the "progressive" talking points on this whole affair.

1) It is George Bush's fault because we did the same unilateral think to Iraq.

2) No side is virtuous in this matter, so there isn't a good side to root for.

Odd, that logic. Let's assume the core assertions to be true-

1) If the left found the U.S. to be completely and totally wrong in Iraq and in need of a comeuppance, why aren't they applying the same standard to Russia if Russia has done the same thing?

2) Cole himself spoke of the "virtue" of "insurgents" rallying against the U.S. Shouldn't that same standard bestow virtue on the Georgians.

The left shows its knee jerk apologism and sentimentality for Stalinist Russian tactics.

56 realwest  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:09:25am

re: #40 Eric Cartman's Conscience Respectfully, "But it is clear these two regions prefer Russia to Georgia." isn't all that clear, at all.
Georgia is an independent, democratic nation, recognized as such (for what little it's worth) by the UN.
Russia has had folks infiltrating South Ossetia for some time now; hence the "sudden and magical" appearance of all those Russian Tanks, Mechanized Infantry, Bombers and Naval Squadron.

Real question is what happens when the US Navy aid ships try to enter and unload in Poti.

57 eschew_obfuscation  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:09:32am

re: #46 bulwrk

Russian troops may have thought twice before over running over a U.S military installation with U.S troops on the ground.

Good point....I've been hoping for something similar with our aid ships and planes.

58 Eric Cartman's Conscience  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:09:34am

#52 GG

Precisely why wars are fought.

59 Kenneth  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:09:39am

Analysis from StratFor:

The war in Georgia, therefore, is Russia’s public return to great power status. This is not something that just happened — it has been unfolding ever since Putin took power, and with growing intensity in the past five years. Part of it has to do with the increase of Russian power, but a great deal of it has to do with the fact that the Middle Eastern wars have left the United States off-balance and short on resources. As we have written, this conflict created a window of opportunity. The Russian goal is to use that window to assert a new reality throughout the region while the Americans are tied down elsewhere and dependent on the Russians. The war was far from a surprise; it has been building for months. But the geopolitical foundations of the war have been building since 1992. Russia has been an empire for centuries. The last 15 years or so were not the new reality, but simply an aberration that would be rectified. And now it is being rectified.

60 Sharmuta  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:10:01am

Russia will now proceed with their bullying ways- fully aware that no one has the balls to stand up to them. They can act with impunity. Look out, Ukraine.

And don't think China isn't paying attention and eyeing Taiwan.

61 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:10:16am

re: #36 galloping granny

In fairness, I suspect there are an awful lot of clean and innocent hands among the 4 million residents of Georgia, very few of whom signed up to be bombed, raped or looted.

Yes.

I was thinking of "irregulars" on both sides. Somehow, I distrust the lack of information coming out about what Georgians were doing prior to a week ago. Color me suspicious.

Don't get me wrong. South Ossetia, Abkhazia and Russia are in the wrong here, and the Georgian gov't has been generous in some of its actions re the breakaway provinces. I simply do NOT trust the media.

62 faraway  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:10:29am
Boeing announced today the first ever test firing of a real-life ray gun that could become US special forces’ way to carry out covert strikes with “plausible deniability.”

Firing a frikkin laser in Georgia perhaps?

63 SusanL  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:10:35am

If we let this stand and do not stand up for our allies, what the hell good are we?

64 Iron Fist  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:11:02am

re: #33 eschew_obfuscation

All Russia has to threaten the United States with are land based ballistic missiles. That is a big enough threat that we are unwilling to fight for Georgia or, likely, the Balkans. Give us a credible missile defense, and the Russian nuclear threat goes away.

Without that, the calculus for the battlefield radically favors the US. The Russians aren't playing in the same league. Tanks, planes, down to the individual soldier on the battlefield, we are way above our enemies.

Then it is simply a matter of American will.

65 lefty201  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:11:13am

our world credibilty looks like crap now, we are no longer a "superpower". It's unfortunate that we allow our friends to suffer, and our enemies to gloat in this manner. They were so hip on democracy, they named streets after our president. We let them down, and they will never trust us again. This is Georgia were talking about, and like the russians they lived next to, they never forgive, they never forget.

66 galloping granny  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:11:16am

re: #63 SusanL

If we let this stand and do not stand up for our allies, what the hell good are we?

Hasbeen.

67 realwest  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:11:34am

re: #60 Sharmuta
I'd add a look out Israel to that list, as well as look out South Korea.

68 CIA Reject  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:11:37am

re: #49 BlueCanuck

Right about what? His autobiography sounds veeeddddy interesting. If e was originally from the KGB and fought against it, he might have a deeper understanding of Putin.

He understands Putin very well. In fact he was a "voice in the wilderness" warning that Russia under Putin would seek to re-establish the Soviet Union. Apparently the only people listening to him at the time was the Putin government who convicted him of treason in abstentia.

69 galloping granny  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:11:52am

re: #65 lefty201

our world credibilty looks like crap now, we are no longer a "superpower". It's unfortunate that we allow our friends to suffer, and our enemies to gloat in this manner. They were so hip on democracy, they named streets after our president. We let them down, and they will never trust us again. This is Georgia were talking about, and like the russians they lived next to, they never forgive, they never forget.

Not only that, the President of Georgia is US educated and was an attorney in New York.

70 yma o hyd  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:11:58am

I absolutely loathe the way these Ossetians and Russians use the word 'genocide'.
It demeans the true victims, those of the Holocaust first and foremost, and the Tutsis in Rwanda and now the people in Darfur.
Get a grip - 'ethnic cleansing', bad as it is (and thats all that 'uprooting' means) is in no way genocide.

71 faraway  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:12:04am

re: #56 realwest


Real question is what happens when the US Navy aid ships try to enter and unload in Poti.


President Bush has already told the Russkies we will have unfettered access. I don't think he was kidding around.

72 BlueCanuck  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:12:15am

re: #56 realwest

An "International Incident" with much hand wringing and apologies around. I hate to say this, but I believe Bush dropped the ball on this. I just hope history will reveal the truths of what happened this past week, and show all the decisions made.

73 galloping granny  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:12:40am

re: #67 realwest

I'd add a look out Israel to that list, as well as look out South Korea.

I'm not so sure about SK, but I hope Israel is gearing up in a very big way.

74 Ben Hur  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:12:43am

Forget about European integrity.

75 looking closely  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:12:49am

Looks like Russia is the one without integrity, though that is hardly news.

76 laZardo  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:13:02am

And with this blatant admission of Russia's true intentions, I must go to sleep and hope I can wake up with a straight face.

/good night, LGF...

77 jorline  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:13:25am

re: #60 Sharmuta

Russia will now proceed with their bullying ways- fully aware that no one has the balls to stand up to them. They can act with impunity. Look out, Ukraine.

And don't think China isn't paying attention and eyeing Taiwan.

Excellent point...ding me up Scotti.

78 Dustoff-507  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:13:26am

But, but Obama told them to stop!

what do you mean they didn't... (-:

79 Ben Hur  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:13:42am

And I find it amazing that the LLL would support Russia for no other reason than that it makes the US look bad.

80 eaglewingz08  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:13:52am

The Soviet Union transplanted hundreds of thousands of ethnic Russians to Georgia and these two provinces during and since Stalin's rule. It was the commies divide and conquer strategy, and if you want to see it in another venue just look at Tibet where the commies have used ethnic Chinese migrations to suppress and impoverish the native Tibetan community.
If Pres Bush doesn't go to Tblisi, then Obama should and must, since one word form the Obamessiah will end this war and lead the world to utopia.

81 Sharmuta  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:14:11am

re: #67 realwest

I'd add a look out Israel to that list, as well as look out South Korea.

Good point. I believe at times America is hated by people because we are the ones who should stand up for the little guys. Instead- we're viewed by these people as supporting thugs. If this is true, then we can expect more people to hate us in the near future.

82 rawmuse  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:14:12am

If you can't defend what you have, the chances are great that you will lose it.
History is replete with that one lesson, over and over.

83 Kenneth  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:14:17am

#40 Eric Cartman's Conscience

The Russians did not act to protect the right to self-determination of the Ossetians. They have oppressed the various ethnic groups on their side of the border (Chechens) while providing money, guns & support to the separatists in their neighboring countries. Most of the "gov't officials" in Ossetia were also employees of the Russian security services. This was not about protecting ethnic independence, it's about the enforcing the dominance of the Russian Empire.

84 karmic_inquisitor  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:14:21am

Russia should be stripped of the 2014 Winter Olympics.

A 15 minute drive from Georgia.

85 Dustoff-507  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:14:37am

re: #65 lefty201


No we still are, but it just proves that the rest of the world.. can you say UN & EU will do nothing with out us first.

damn shame.

86 galloping granny  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:14:40am

re: #78 Dustoff-507

But, but Obama told them to stop!

what do you mean they didn't... (-:

Not only did he tell them to stop, did you hear the guy from Virginia publicly crowing that Russia had listened to HRH Obama and done just what The One asked?

87 pegcity  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:14:41am

And this is why Mcain will win, who should lead, a War hero, or a guy who organized picnics ummm,

88 jamgarr  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:14:45am

re: #70 yma o hyd

I absolutely loathe the way these Ossetians and Russians use the word 'genocide'.
It demeans the true victims, those of the Holocaust first and foremost, and the Tutsis in Rwanda and now the people in Darfur.
Get a grip - 'ethnic cleansing', bad as it is (and thats all that 'uprooting' means) is in no way genocide.

Slightly OT

This a.m. I heard an NPR person use the word "crisis" to describe a reporter's inability to get a hotdog at the Olympics basketball venue. I sh*t you not!

89 Iron Fist  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:15:05am

re: #79 Ben Hur

Why? They are just the L³eft doing what the L³eft does. I would find it amazing if they did anything else.

90 BlueCanuck  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:15:08am

re: #59 Kenneth

Good point. The term "Potemkin Village" was from the Russian Empire era(can't remember the Empress's name) but applied equally well to the Soviet.

91 Eric Cartman's Conscience  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:15:10am

#71 faraway

I don't think Bush is in any position to insist upon it. Putin is a viscious little bastard. The lil' Judo blackbelt welcomes Bush's big talk. I think, like that Mexican asshole-president who basically called Bush a fraud as a "cowboy", Putin thinks Bush is all hat no cattle.

92 Sharmuta  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:15:22am

re: #84 karmic_inquisitor

Russia should be stripped of the 2014 Winter Olympics.

A 15 minute drive from Georgia.

Riiiiight. Come on- the IOC gave the summer games to China- you really think they care if the games are given to thugs?

93 jorline  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:15:31am

re: #78 Dustoff-507

But, but Obama told them to stop!

what do you mean they didn't... (-:

Has anyone even heard from Beach Boy Barry lately?

94 galloping granny  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:16:20am

re: #80 eaglewingz08

The Soviet Union transplanted hundreds of thousands of ethnic Russians to Georgia and these two provinces during and since Stalin's rule. It was the commies divide and conquer strategy, and if you want to see it in another venue just look at Tibet where the commies have used ethnic Chinese migrations to suppress and impoverish the native Tibetan community.
If Pres Bush doesn't go to Tblisi, then Obama should and must, since one word form the Obamessiah will end this war and lead the world to utopia.

That is about the worst suggestion I have ever heard! The Secret Service has already had to request $9.5 MILLION extra to cover the extra security for the World Tour and the Stadium Coronation.

95 Dustoff-507  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:16:21am

re: #86 galloping granny


Ya wonder what he has to say now... LOL

did you hear that cricket.

96 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:16:26am
97 Occasional Reader  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:16:26am

re: #65 lefty201

our world credibilty looks like crap now, we are no longer a "superpower".

Oh, please.

You're declaring utter defeat after a week?

98 rawmuse  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:16:29am

re: #93 jorline

Has anyone even heard from Beach Boy Barry lately?

No, and it is a welcome respite, actually.

99 jcm  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:16:33am

re: #72 BlueCanuck

An "International Incident" with much hand wringing and apologies around. I hate to say this, but I believe Bush dropped the ball on this. I just hope history will reveal the truths of what happened this past week, and show all the decisions made.

He statement yesterday was 5 days to late, that may have been due to get the assets in place for the move, but I believe a good move. It put the ball back in Putin's court. The key is we must follow up to line drawn, no interference with US movements and status quo ante Aug. 6.

We have to follow up, If Russia does anything to hinder our operations, or refuses to move. It must be responded to forcefully.

100 reine.de.tout  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:16:39am
101 godfrey  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:16:52am

Are we going to "defend" our allies in Ukraine, too?

102 lifeofthemind  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:16:54am

Now that everything is on the table for negotiation:
1. India replaces Russia in the UN Security Council.
2. Future of Konigsberg is to be determined by Germany, Poland and Lithuania.
3. Sevastapol is closed to the Russians, The Black Sea Fleet no longer exists.
4. Every person who takes a foreign passport can lose their original citizenship.
5. Georgia, like the US, has the right to expel all non citizens.
6. No Russian troops except embassy guards south of 44º N anywhere on earth.

Then smile sweetly and say, "Next?"

103 Ben Hur  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:16:57am

re: #89 Iron Fist

Why? They are just the L³eft doing what the L³eft does. I would find it amazing if they did anything else.


True.

104 jcm  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:17:07am

re: #78 Dustoff-507

But, but Obama told them to stop!

what do you mean they didn't... (-:

And Gov. Kaine confirm as soon as Obamessiah spoke, Russia obeyed.

105 Dustoff-507  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:17:19am

re: #93 jorline


You haven't hear.... He's golfing..
Very imporant you know. 0-:

106 Sharmuta  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:17:19am

re: #100 reine.de.tout

OT:

Hillary's name will be put into nomination at Dem convention

Operation Chaos Lives!

107 SusanL  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:17:21am

re: #73 galloping granny

I think the South Korean populous has been so propagandized about the EVIL US that they would welcome the Chinese. That is until they have been there a while.

I am becoming a real advocate of pulling our military from everywhere, stacking them on the borders and saying f-u to the rest of the fricking world. If we are so damn bad, then you sob's are on your own.

No matter what we do, we are the bad guy. I'm really getting tired of it.

108 CIA Reject  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:17:27am

re: #69 galloping granny

Not only that, the President of Georgia is US educated and was an attorney in New York.

He must not of been much of a lawyer if he can allow himself to be placed into a situation such as the one he currently occupies.

109 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:17:30am

re: #80 eaglewingz08

The Soviet Union transplanted hundreds of thousands of ethnic Russians to Georgia and these two provinces during and since Stalin's rule. It was the commies divide and conquer strategy, and if you want to see it in another venue just look at Tibet where the commies have used ethnic Chinese migrations to suppress and impoverish the native Tibetan community.
If Pres Bush doesn't go to Tblisi, then Obama should and must, since one word form the Obamessiah will end this war and lead the world to utopia.

They did do that in the outer regions of the USSR, however, I've read that Alani-descended Ossetians have lived in this "South Ossetia" region for centuries. If so, it's not so clearcut in this particular case.

110 BlueCanuck  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:17:39am

re: #68 CIA Reject

Thank you for the further clarification.

/Book is on the ever expanding list. :(

111 opinionated  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:17:49am

When Bush was looking into Putin's eyes and saw a good soul, Putin was looking into Bush's eyes and saw a modified Jimmy Carter.

112 Iron Fist  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:17:53am

re: #93 jorline

You get an up-ding for "Beach Boy Barry". I think that is a precise trivilization of the man who would be the One, the Obamessiah, as he confronts this challenge.

113 realwest  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:18:18am

re: #71 faraway
and
re: #72 BlueCanuck

I wish I had the wisdom to know what will happen.
I know that IF the US Navy responds with force (including the use of Superhornets from Carrier(s))
that the entire situation in Georgia will change almost instanteously. Russia is still not a top-notch conventional power, even in it's own backyard - their supply lines are stretched to the Max and we could cut them very easily (and keep them cut); moreover we have Amphibious Assault Ships that carry a fully equipped Brigade (roughly 1,500) of combat tested US Marines - who, together with the msyteriously missing 2,000 battle tested Georgians we airlifted in two days ago, could make things VERY DIFFICULT to say the least, on the Russians.
And I know I'm swimming upstream out here, but Georgia IS our ALLY and is a real democracy - if we don't stand by them, shame on us. Period.

114 Dustoff-507  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:18:31am

re: #101 godfrey


I have a bad feeling about that too. Most of all if Obama get's in

115 cygnus  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:18:32am

re: #41 jorline

South Ossetia and the Arctic...the great Russian land grab.

Next up - Turkey and the Middle East.

116 Maine's Michael  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:19:11am

re: #111 opinionated

When Bush was looking into Putin's eyes and saw a good soul, Putin was looking into Bush's eyes and saw a modified Jimmy Carter.weak Saudi shill.

117 Occasional Reader  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:19:30am

re: #96 buzzsawmonkey

Catherine the Great.

Now there was an empress who didn't horse around. Well, she did, but only in the privacy of her own home.

118 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:19:34am

re: #115 cygnus

Next up - Turkey and the Middle East.

I think not. Russia would lose teeth in Turkey, and the Russians know it.

119 cygnus  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:19:39am

re: #54 FrogMarch

Pussy Europe
Pussy UN
Pussy us

Don't insult my cat!

120 yma o hyd  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:19:41am

re: #40 Eric Cartman's Conscience

It didn't 'break away' - it was a republik within the system of the Soviet Union - same as Kzakhstan, Uzbekistan, Azerbeijan, Ukraine, the Baltic States. They re-claimed their former statehood which was forcibly subsumed under Stalin into Russia.
Thanks to Stalins way of ordering things, South Ossetia was part of the former Georgian Soviet republic, as was Abchasia.
If we think its fine for the South Ossetians to have their own republic, with Russias help, then why are the Chechens denied their own republic, why can Russia bomb the Chechens into the stone age and we nod and say, yeah, fine?

121 Catttt  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:19:45am

re: #100 reine.de.tout

OT:

Hillary's name will be put into nomination at Dem convention

I still think she's going to win it. It's just a feeling I have.

122 Ward Cleaver  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:19:51am

re: #84 karmic_inquisitor

Russia should be stripped of the 2014 Winter Olympics.

A 15 minute drive from Georgia.

Nah, then the IOC would just move them to Iran.

123 lifeofthemind  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:20:15am

re: #69 galloping granny

Not only that, the President of Georgia is US educated and was an attorney in New York.

Despite that he likes us and we like him. I do worry about the Soros connection.

124 Eric Cartman's Conscience  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:20:15am

re: #107 SusanL

YUP!

I think the South Korean populous has been so propagandized about the EVIL US that they would welcome the Chinese. That is until they have been there a while.

I am becoming a real advocate of pulling our military from everywhere, stacking them on the borders and saying f-u to the rest of the fricking world. If we are so damn bad, then you sob's are on your own.

No matter what we do, we are the bad guy. I'm really getting tired of it.

125 Ward Cleaver  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:20:17am

re: #121 Catttt

I still think she's going to win it. It's just a feeling I have.

I think so too.

126 Kosh's Shadow  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:20:23am

re: #26 marge45b

Mother Russia will bilk NASA on trips to the ISS when the Shuttle retires.

We need to see how much Burt Rutan would need to have a spacecraft in time.

127 Boondock St. Bender  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:20:30am

re: #109 pre-Boomer Marine brat

classic balkans,folks living in one general area of different religions,and different"nationalities"they all want control,and suspect anyone not of their group.

128 Catttt  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:20:39am

re: #54 FrogMarch

Pussy Europe
Pussy UN
Pussy us

Hey! Stop dissing pussycats.

129 karmic_inquisitor  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:20:46am

re: #92 Sharmuta

Riiiiight. Come on- the IOC gave the summer games to China- you really think they care if the games are given to thugs?

The Chinese made all sorts of promises about how they'd reform and improve conditions if they got the games and the IOC was flattered by it.

I am not thinking that the IOC will do the right thing, BTW. I am simply assuming that the whole idea of them losing the games ought to be in public discussion. Put a spotlight on Russia and on the IOC. The Olympics is a pet project of Putin - it should be threatened.

Also, the Winter Games are dominated by European teams - lets see if they have the spine to threaten boycott. If Europe boycotted, it would be the end of the games in 2014.

Again, the issue should be pushed not in expectation of getting the result but as a way to humiliate Putin, the IOC and Europe at the same time.

130 Dustoff-507  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:20:48am

re: #113 realwest
roughly 1,500) of combat tested US Marines -

Buddy I think they are all combat tested now. LOL


Morning sir.

131 Kenneth  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:21:05am

re: #61 pre-Boomer Marine brat

Here's a timeline of events in Georgia/Ossetia going back several years. Clearly the Russians have been working on this for a while. The last stray for them was the West granting independence to Kosovo and placing Ukraine & Georgia on the NATO membership plan. The Russians figured now is the time to act, while the US is in an election, tied up in Iraq & Afghanistan & wary of Iran. Putin calculated correctly that the Americans will issue angry statements but in the end, can't do much about it.

132 Colonel Panik  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:21:13am

re: #100 reine.de.tout

OT:

Hillary's name will be put into nomination at Dem convention


YEEEEHAAAAW! DENVER, ARE YOU READY TO RUMBLE?!?!?


/puttin' the popcorn in the popper.

133 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:21:25am
134 guftafs  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:21:25am

Russia grows bolder as the US betrays its ally and Western Europe yawns or engages in meaningless diplomacy. It's just a statement of fact, it's already taken place.

135 faraway  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:21:42am

Never forget this little gem from yesterday morning

Kaine Says Russians "Complied With" Obama's Request for a Ceasefire
136 galloping granny  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:21:52am

re: #121 Catttt

I still think she's going to win it. It's just a feeling I have.

I think you might be right. Because I think the powers that be in the Dems have come to realize that Obama cannot win this. But then I also think that the Democrats are going to schism over this.

137 BlueCanuck  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:21:53am

re: #96 buzzsawmonkey

Thanks, I new it was a she. At least I got the terminology correct. 18th century?

re: #99 jcm

Let us just hope it wasn't too late, and we stand by the line drawn in the sand.

138 Pullus Iulius  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:22:15am

re: #93 jorline

I believe BO is still in the islands, no doubt negotiating to give Hawaii back to its aspirant peoples. That would reduce the US to 66 states? 67? I forget. Seriously though, we cannot allow the relativists and apologists of the Obama left wing to divert the blame for this tragedy from anywhere except where it belongs: squarely on Russia.

139 CIA Reject  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:22:17am

re: #110 BlueCanuck

Thank you for the further clarification.

/Book is on the ever expanding list. :(

You're very welcome! If you ever get to hear one of his lectures don't pass up the opportunity- he has a fascinating story to tell.

140 Ford_Prefect  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:22:19am

re: #125 Ward Cleaver

I think so too.

I hope not. The riots throughout the country would be very bad.

141 cutestguy[deleted]  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:22:49am
142 Ford_Prefect  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:23:10am

re: #133 taxfreekiller

Wait,,,,

NEWS FLASH!

Congress is being called back into session, Georgia will be named an "earmark", no vote required.

Nancy Out.

BHO will vote 'present'.

143 cygnus  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:23:11am

re: #93 jorline

Has anyone even heard from Beach Boy Barry lately?

I think that he was scheduled to take a tour of Hilo Hattie's today.

144 rawmuse  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:23:18am
145 lurking faith  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:23:22am
Russia’s foreign minister said today, “the world can forget about Georgia’s territorial integrity FOAD.”

Fixed that for him

146 lefty201  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:23:30am

re: #97 Occasional Reader

No. But it does seem like we're all talk and no action anymore. Nations that should pay attention to us, blow us off now and try to disregard us. (Try Hugo Chavez, Iran, Russia, Syria, Pakistan (and we should be going in there after Bin Laden but can't)). How are we supposed to look at nations around the world and say "hey, we're you buddies and were going to help you build a democracy because it works!" when we turn tail and run from our friends at the first sign of trouble.

147 Killgore Trout  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:23:53am
148 galloping granny  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:23:58am

re: #132 Colonel Panik

YEEEEHAAAAW! DENVER, ARE YOU READY TO RUMBLE?!?!?


/puttin' the popcorn in the popper.

Yup. The Denver Police even have a special holding tank set up for demonstrators that the activists are calling Gitmo II.

149 Kosh's Shadow  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:23:59am

re: #63 SusanL

If we let this stand and do not stand up for our allies, what the hell good are we?

And what will the Ukraine, Poland, etc. think?
And any Iranians who want to overthrow the theocracy?

As bad as it could be, if we don't stand up for Georgia now, the US won't be a major power any more. No one will take us seriously.

150 Dustoff-507  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:24:12am

re: #143 cygnus


No, no, no. His wife has a headace. will call back later.

151 opinionated  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:24:27am

re: #136 galloping granny

I think you might be right. Because I think the powers that be in the Dems have come to realize that Obama cannot win this. But then I also think that the Democrats are going to schism over this.

If it's a draw, they might turn to Al Gore. Which would be smart because he would win convincingly.

152 pegcity  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:24:33am

Anyone here play the first Tom Clancy's Splinter cell on XBOX?

The games plot is very similar to what's happening right now, the whole thing involved the russians Invading Georgia to stop an oil pipeline being built in Azerbijan.

153 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:24:41am

re: #127 Boondock St. Bender

classic balkans,folks living in one general area of different religions,and different"nationalities"they all want control,and suspect anyone not of their group.

That's precisely my read on it too.

Spitting on Russia in this matter doesn't mean I give ANYONE else a pass.

154 yma o hyd  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:24:41am

re: #84 karmic_inquisitor

Russia should be stripped of the 2014 Winter Olympics.

A 15 minute drive from Georgia.

So it should - would hurt Putin quite a bit, apparently its his pet project ...

155 ducktrapper  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:24:44am

The world's democracies need to reject the U.N. The U.S. should ask the U.N., as an active enemy organization, to immediately leave its territory. These democracies should then start a new world body that would demand something, other than a flag, from those who would wish to join.

156 Occasional Reader  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:24:54am

I'm getting a little irritated about all the defeatist talk about this great Russian "victory" and our corresponding "impotence". This game is just getting started, folks.

157 Ben Hur  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:25:00am

re: #136 galloping granny

I think you might be right. Because I think the powers that be in the Dems have come to realize that Obama cannot win this. But then I also think that the Democrats are going to schism over this.


Buyer's remorse.

158 calcajun  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:25:18am

re: #5 galloping granny

Glad someone is pointing this out. Even the Lightworker himself failed to take this into account when he made the suggestion.

159 SusanL  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:25:33am

re: #140 Ford_Prefect

So? Spoiled children throw a trantrum when you take away their toys. The dems have turned half of this country into spoiled brats.

Anyone with a brain will get out of high risk areas. If the cops are smart, the will encircle and let it burn its self out.

160 Kragar (Proud to be Kafir)  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:25:39am

re: #100 reine.de.tout

OT:

Hillary's name will be put into nomination at Dem convention

Barry actually agreed to that? What a dumb bastard.

161 pegcity  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:25:41am

re: #156 Occasional Reader

Yup the new cold war is offically on.

162 BlueCanuck  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:25:42am

re: #117 Occasional Reader

I read some where that was just vicious rumours to sully a great empress.

/but nothing would surprise me these days.

163 jorline  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:25:51am

re: #98 rawmuse

No, and it is a welcome respite, actually.

Sadly I agree, but what's he going to due if elected Potus...put on his speedo and hide under the Oval Office desk during the next international incident.

164 galloping granny  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:25:56am

re: #138 Pullus Iulius

I believe BO is still in the islands, no doubt negotiating to give Hawaii back to its aspirant peoples. That would reduce the US to 66 states? 67? I forget. Seriously though, we cannot allow the relativists and apologists of the Obama left wing to divert the blame for this tragedy from anywhere except where it belongs: squarely on Russia.

Speaking of HRH Obama, I happened into Borders yesterday. Right inside the front door they had a big display of political books. Every single one of the Obama Unmasked books had a huge stack. There was not a single copy of Dreams and just two of Audacity - near the back of the store on a next to the bottom shelf. HEH.

165 lifeofthemind  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:26:08am

re: #147 Killgore Trout

OT: New Saudi Bike Invention.

Add to the long list of Saudi gifts to humanity.

166 opinionated  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:26:14am

re: #147 Killgore Trout

OT: New Saudi Bike Invention.

When all your women are hiding beneath sacks, you do stupid things to occupy your mind.

167 BlueCanuck  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:26:18am

re: #130 Dustoff-507

I think he's talking about the total number, not the amount of combat tested in THAT number.

168 Dustoff-507  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:26:18am

re: #152 pegcity

Didn't they also have a James Bond movie on this too?

169 TN_Vol  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:26:23am

Domino theory anyone?

170 lurking faith  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:26:25am

re: #79 Ben Hur

And I find it amazing that the LLL would support Russia for no other reason than that it makes the US look bad.

I don't. They've always loved genuine fascists and mass murderers.

171 cygnus  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:26:42am

re: #100 reine.de.tout

OT:

Hillary's name will be put into nomination at Dem convention

This is gonna be fun.
/Going to Costco for industrial-sized popcorn bags

172 karmic_inquisitor  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:26:47am

re: #122 Ward Cleaver

Nah, then the IOC would just move them to Iran.

Kidding aside, the second best vote getter for host in 2014 is South Korea, so they'd get the games.

173 Boondock St. Bender  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:26:48am

we seem a little pessimistic this morning.This thing is far from over.I like the fact that bush did not react with a kaiser wilhelm type of statmentor action.his message was terse,and he was plainly pissed.We are sending in relief,with our military.bush is daring putin to do something about it.the ball is still in play.lets not act like the msm and declare defeat till this whole thing is over.

174 Sharmuta  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:26:51am

re: #156 Occasional Reader

I'm getting a little irritated about all the defeatist talk about this great Russian "victory" and our corresponding "impotence". This game is just getting started, folks.

Well- one thing that might scare the crap out of the Russians is a President McCain. It's rumored he has a temper......

175 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:26:57am

re: #131 Kenneth

Here's a timeline of events in Georgia/Ossetia going back several years. Clearly the Russians have been working on this for a while. The last stray for them was the West granting independence to Kosovo and placing Ukraine & Georgia on the NATO membership plan. The Russians figured now is the time to act, while the US is in an election, tied up in Iraq & Afghanistan & wary of Iran. Putin calculated correctly that the Americans will issue angry statements but in the end, can't do much about it.

THANKS for the link! I'll make time (sometime soon) to crawl through it, line by line.

176 faraway  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:26:59am

re: #147 Killgore Trout
This guys Obama avatar is funny. here

177 Occasional Reader  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:27:05am

re: #146 lefty201

No. But it does seem like we're all talk and no action anymore.

I'm pretty sure we took down two hostile regimes since 9/11.

And it looks to me like it was the appearance of US military assets on the scene yesterday that stopped the Russians from rolling on Tbilisi.

178 rawmuse  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:27:19am

re: #163 jorline

BHO as POTUS will be busy domestically, installing Federal judges that will find ways to negate the Constitution in ways that we can only imagine.

179 jorline  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:27:37am

re: #100 reine.de.tout

OT:

Hillary's name will be put into nomination at Dem convention

Another 4th of July? Calling all Dems...everyone in the gutter, this is going to get nasty.

180 pegcity  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:27:40am

re: #168 Dustoff-507

life is now offically stranger than a video game.

It's too bad America dosen't really have a third Echelon and a Sam Fischer to go in a mop up.

181 Dustoff-507  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:27:40am

re: #167 BlueCanuck


I was making a joke buddy.. Realwest and I go WAY back. LOL

182 realwest  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:28:14am

re: #130 Dustoff-507
Hey my friend - yeah but a Marine Amphibious Brigade is made up of about 1,500 marines, plus helicopters (I know you remember them!) to transport and attack ground forces. One of those ships is an extremely lethal force to cope with; aided by airpower from a Carrier battle group (or preferably TWO Carrier Battle Groups) and those 2,000 Georgians and I think Russia is the one who would be in trouble.
Now if 16 or so F-22's - with in air refueling set up, were to land in Iraq, get pilots rested, planes fully armed, then I think the US will rule the skies over Georgia. And that is end game for Russia, cause even Putin isn't stupid enough to think Russia could beat us - or for that matter that anyone would be a winner - in a nuke exchange.

183 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:28:22am
184 jorline  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:29:01am

re: #143 cygnus

I think that he was scheduled to take a tour of Hilo Hattie's today.

Been there...nothing but crap...lol

185 calcajun  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:29:18am

I heard an interesting stat that Russia has only 145 million people due to the break-up of the USSR in 1991. That's less than half of the US and a 10th of China. Russia is certainly no longer a world leader and there is little chance of a return to the old Cold War. Russia is, more than anything, a regional threat and is probably looking to re-establish its regional dominance.

Its not the Cold War that has returned--it's the "Great Game", except this time, the players have nukes.

186 Kenneth  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:29:19am

Don't be too down on Bush about US inaction. There isn't much the US can do except to try to limit the damage. Putin is sending a message to his neighbors (Poland, the Balts & especially Ukraine):

"Don't expect too much help from far away America or lazy fat Europe We are your neighbors & you have to learn to live with us."

The message has been heard.

187 Pullus Iulius  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:29:56am

And by the way, folks, this is all happening in the Caucasus, not in the Balkans. Different mountains, different side of the Black Sea. Different history, but no less tragic.

188 Killgore Trout  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:30:13am

re: #176 faraway

Heh.

189 pegcity  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:30:17am

re: #185 calcajun

They are a dying people Putin knows this, he and his cronies just want to grab up what they can.

190 Dustoff-507  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:30:31am

re: #182 realwest

I think your right buddy. Putin is power hungery, but not stupid.
His forces are small and not even up to speed if he wants to go head to head.


even he knows the nukes would be a loser.

191 BlueCanuck  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:30:59am

re: #147 Killgore Trout

So, they have finally gotten to the penny farthing stage.

192 Occasional Reader  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:31:03am

re: #187 Pullus Iulius

And by the way, folks, this is all happening in the Caucasus, not in the Balkans. Different mountains, different side of the Black Sea. Different history, but no less tragic.

"Typical Caucasian people."

-BHO

193 Boondock St. Bender  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:31:36am

re: #153 pre-Boomer Marine brat

Thats why the only ones able to control the balkans have been brutal and replessive regimes.if you try to weld the region into nations actually capable of supporting a decent military/domestic production you get rebelion/breakaway movements.if you allow all these little feifdoms to have their independce,you'll get a shitload of little wars of conquest as the slightly larger try to swallow the slightly smaller.(oh,and throw in lots of ethnic cleansing)

194 opinionated  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:31:37am

re: #51 Maine's Michael

Paraphrase:

'Get stuffed, 'President' Bush.'

You mean that Putin is not shaking in his boots considering that Rice is on the way?

We have been at war from day one of this Bush term and as Michael Corleone made very clear- when at war you must have a wartime consiliary.

Only Bush considers Rice a wartime consiliary.

195 realwest  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:31:42am

re: #156 Occasional Reader From your lips to Bush's ears my friend.
And I apologize for thinking you didn't think the Georgian situation was worth fight Russia over.

196 eschew_obfuscation  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:32:04am

re: #164 galloping granny

Speaking of HRH Obama, I happened into Borders yesterday. Right inside the front door they had a big display of political books. Every single one of the Obama Unmasked books had a huge stack. There was not a single copy of Dreams and just two of Audacity - near the back of the store on a next to the bottom shelf. HEH.

That could mean that Obama's book is way outselling Unmasked?

197 Ford_Prefect  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:32:04am

re: #191 BlueCanuck

So, they have finally gotten to the penny farthing stage.

Who is farting pennies on stage? That's just gross.

198 Kilroy  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:32:28am

The former enslaved nations of eastern Europe would be wise to immediately seek nuclear capabilities as I don't believe they can rely on the commitment of NATO to assure their sovereignty. The annexation of eastern Poland will be short in coming.

199 jcm  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:32:31am

re: #156 Occasional Reader

I'm getting a little irritated about all the defeatist talk about this great Russian "victory" and our corresponding "impotence". This game is just getting started, folks.

Correct it's not done, not by a long shot.

GWB yesterday put the ball into Putin's court.
No interference with US assets.
Status quo ante Aug. 6.

I believe it may be a mistake in strategy, but it seems there will be the dipolmatic push first. Rice, shuttling between Tiblisi and Moscow, a UN resolution (Russia has to sit out as they are an involved party), and an EU consensus.

Any overt action against Russian forces is a couple weeks out. BTW that's not all bad, it give US, NATO, and EU 2 weeks to get spun up.

I would prefer an immediate no fly zone, and any Russian unit involved in anything but withdrawal gets a visit, but that's me.

200 HoosierHoops  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:32:43am

re: #100 reine.de.tout

OT:

Hillary's name will be put into nomination at Dem convention

Get the popcorn out..this is going to be fun!

201 Kosh's Shadow  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:32:54am

re: #174 Sharmuta

Well- one thing that might scare the crap out of the Russians is a President McCain. It's rumored he has a temper......

And this might just push more people to vote for McCain

202 calcajun  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:33:08am

re: #189 pegcity

I know. Demographics are killing them as they are not replacing themselves. They could use the tremendous oil and gas revenues to improve the GDP and they way of life so that more kids might have kids. But, that kind of correction will take a few generations. Russia might be finished in 50 years.

203 karmic_inquisitor  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:33:20am

re: #185 calcajun

They continue to shed population. One estimate I saw had them dwon to 100M in 30 years. They are only "thriving" on oil and gas.

One more STRATEGIC reason to drill our own. Force down prices and screw Putin at the same time.

Win Win.

204 BlueCanuck  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:34:01am

re: #181 Dustoff-507

I was making a joke buddy.. Realwest and I go WAY back. LOL

Ah, I see. Sorry, wasn't meant as a jump on you. besides I am usually on the night shift so I will no go update my score card.

/damn it, where did I put that farley file.

205 Kenneth  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:34:01am

re: #185 calcajun

Want to hear something even stranger? Long the dominant ethnic group in the Russian Empire, the ethnic Russian population is collapsing, while the Muslim population is growing. By 2030, most military age males will be Muslim. By 2050, Russia will be majority Muslim.

Think we have problems now? Just wait.

206 Boondock St. Bender  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:34:31am

re: #187 Pullus Iulius

yes,but the same problems,(usually refered to as balkanisation.a catch-all term for various areas of the world with this problem.)

207 calcajun  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:34:58am

re: #203 karmic_inquisitor

The question, though, is who is going to fill that vacuum in what used to be Russia. I hear the Chinese could use some living space.

208 pegcity  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:35:10am

re: #190 Dustoff-507

re: #202 calcajun

Keep in mind the avg life expectency is only 56 years for a Russian male mostly due to the massive consumption of Vodka, not to mention Aids which kills 750,000 russians every year.

209 Occasional Reader  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:35:17am

re: #195 realwest

And I apologize for thinking you didn't think the Georgian situation was worth fight Russia over.

Well, let me be clear. We had posters over the last several days who were advocating immediately putting US ordnance on Russian troops in Georgia. I was, and continue to be, against that. You just don't start blasting the troops of a country with six thousand nukes. But there are other ways of fighting this, and I think after some initial trouble out of the gate, Bush is playing wisely.

210 CIA Reject  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:35:27am

re: #177 Occasional Reader

I'm pretty sure we took down two hostile regimes since 9/11.

And it looks to me like it was the appearance of US military assets on the scene yesterday that stopped the Russians from rolling on Tbilisi.

And don't forget that as a result of doing that our troops have had seven years of, not just combat experience, but (despite what the MSM would have you believe) successful combat experience.

The last full-scale combat experience the Red Army had was retreating from Afghanistan. A place that our forces have since pacified.

211 calcajun  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:35:48am

re: #205 Kenneth

The Islamofascists don't have to buy nukes on the black market. They're going to inherit them.

212 pegcity  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:36:05am

re: #205 Kenneth

Muslims, Nukes, Muslim, Nukes

Nah what problem

213 Pullus Iulius  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:36:50am

re: #201 Kosh's Shadow

And this might just push more people to vote for McCain

If we keep the focus on who is the victimizer, who is the victim, and what the stakes are, I do not see how it could not. It's 3 AM, the phone is ringing, and Barry's on vacation, out in left field and playing football.

214 realwest  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:37:25am

re: #186 Kenneth Kenneth I respectfully disagree - there is still a HELLUVA LOT the US could do - see my prior posts about Russia's over-extended supply line, the US Navy, the US Marine Attack Ships - with their attack helicopters and some Harrier Jump Jets for tank busting and close in ground support, AND those F-22 Raptors. WE could control the skies over Georgia, cut Russia's supply line, seriously beat on their antiquidated armor and mechanized infantry - IF BUSH WANTS TO.

215 pegcity  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:37:35am

re: #210 CIA Reject

you need to keep in mind that if this gets ugly what is going to stop Putin from Arming Americas enemies openly, I don't want to see the Taliban with Strella's.

216 cygnus  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:37:43am

re: #184 jorline

Been there...nothing but crap...lol

Me too - a complete tourist trap - yuck.

217 Boondock St. Bender  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:37:50am

re: #208 pegcity

I often thought that a good stategy against the russian army was to keep many stockpiles of vodka around what would be typical invasion routes.aloww these areas to be taken,then let nature take its course.
(counter-attack the besotted)

218 SFGoth  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:37:53am

Here's my take. Whatever is left of Georgia, we should wholeheartedly support with infrastructure rebuilding, cheap loans, enhanced trade, etc. Enable Georgia to be a good place to live in that part of the world. Then take out ads crowing about how great Georgia is and how much life in the USSR sucks. Basically, throw it back in Russia's face. Let's see how much Abzakrap and South Ohsaycanyousee like living in the Bear's anus.

219 Occasional Reader  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:37:58am

re: #205 Kenneth

By 2050, Russia will be majority Muslim.

Think we have problems now? Just wait.

OTOH, I wonder what that will do to the still-signficant Russian scientific prowess. Majority-Muslim countries don't exactly have a sterling track record at coming up with cutting-edge weapons systems.

220 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:38:15am

re: #193 Boondock St. Bender

Thats why the only ones able to control the balkans have been brutal and replessive regimes.if you try to weld the region into nations actually capable of supporting a decent military/domestic production you get rebelion/breakaway movements.if you allow all these little feifdoms to have their independce,you'll get a shitload of little wars of conquest as the slightly larger try to swallow the slightly smaller.(oh,and throw in lots of ethnic cleansing)

Yes, but I'd add a personal suspicion that the Balkans are over-supplied with demagogues. There are, indeed, centuries-old animosities, but those require agitation to keep them alive.

Color me cynically optimistic.

221 BlueCanuck  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:38:30am

One more nail, one more drink and I am done. I am way up past my bedtime.

222 pegcity  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:38:57am

re: #217 Boondock St. Bender

best strategy is to take out there commander and watch the troops run around like chickens with their heads cut off.

223 Kenneth  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:39:31am

re: #199 jcm

The US will not put significant military assets in a position where they will come into direct confrontation with Russian military. The conflict will be run through US proxies, the Georgians. Some help may be quietly provided by the Turks. The US humanitarian deliveries will provide some air & sea cover for the Georgians, but it won't mean the US is attempting to enforce US air or sea supremacy. That's just not going to happen.

224 pegcity  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:40:01am

re: #219 Occasional Reader

um Flying Boats, stealth missles, invisible submarines, Rocks.

225 Land Shark  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:40:06am

Well, the mask is off. Russia tells us in so many words their true motives for the escalation of the war. The Russian Bear is back. Time for the world to adjust it's attitude towards the New Russian Empire.

Funny how the Left remains silent over Russia's war for oil. "No blood for oil!" What a bunch of phonies. With Russia now in control or soon to be of the Georgian oil pipeline, they can dictate to Europe and West.

DRILL! DRILL! DRILL!

226 calcajun  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:40:19am

re: #214 realwest

And provoke on hell of an incident, to boot. As much as I'd like to see that (BTW, we are hanging our Georgian allies out to dry right now) that's only going to make matters worse.

None of the parties can afford to look weak; none of them can withstand the loss of face. They have to find a way to tip-toe out of the minefield.

227 galloping granny  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:40:36am

re: #214 realwest

Kenneth I respectfully disagree - there is still a HELLUVA LOT the US could do - see my prior posts about Russia's over-extended supply line, the US Navy, the US Marine Attack Ships - with their attack helicopters and some Harrier Jump Jets for tank busting and close in ground support, AND those F-22 Raptors. WE could control the skies over Georgia, cut Russia's supply line, seriously beat on their antiquidated armor and mechanized infantry - IF BUSH WANTS TO.

I think he wants to. I think he is just being very careful about rushing in where even angels fear to tread. Also remember the amount of time that he has to operate a war without Congressional oversight.

228 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:40:40am

re: #205 Kenneth

Want to hear something even stranger? Long the dominant ethnic group in the Russian Empire, the ethnic Russian population is collapsing, while the Muslim population is growing. By 2030, most military age males will be Muslim. By 2050, Russia will be majority Muslim.

Think we have problems now? Just wait.

IIRC, the majority of the lower ranks in old Soviet Army was Muslim. It wasn't a comfortable situation for the Soviets back then.

229 Dustoff-507  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:40:45am

re: #204 BlueCanuck


Not a problem. (-:

230 pegcity  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:41:35am

re: #225 Land Shark

Well, the mask is off. Russia tells us in so many words their true motives for the escalation of the war. The Russian Bear is back. Time for the world to adjust it's attitude towards the New Russian Empire.

Funny how the Left remains silent over Russia's war for oil. "No blood for oil!" What a bunch of phonies. With Russia now in control or soon to be of the Georgian oil pipeline, they can dictate to Europe and West.

DRILL! DRILL! DRILL!

where's Shamesty international, wheres' (jews aren't) Humans right watch?

231 Dustoff-507  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:41:50am

re: #215 pegcity


What makes you think he isn't already

232 realwest  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:41:55am

re: #198 Kilroy "The annexation of eastern Poland will be short in coming."
Uh, no it won't be coming at all. Poland HAS a military - a damn good one that a part of has been battle tested alongside our Forces in Iraq (and iirc,
Afghanistan) and they won't go quietly into that good night. Same with Ukraine - population of 50 million or so, balls enough to deny Russia's Naval Squadron back into it's home ports, etc.
This "game" (which it most assuredly is not) is not only not over, I think it's just beginning.

233 Kosh's Shadow  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:42:17am

re: #215 pegcity

you need to keep in mind that if this gets ugly what is going to stop Putin from Arming Americas enemies openly, I don't want to see the Taliban with Strella's.

The same thing could happen later. If we don't stop Putin now, then we lose the rest of the Eastern bloc; they cannot stand against Russia on their own, and as much as they love freedom, they know what will happen to them if the Russians invade.

234 lifeofthemind  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:42:51am

Did Gates just have a press conference? I heard a comment on Belmont but no facts. What did he say?

235 pegcity  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:43:01am

re: #231 Dustoff-507

What makes you think he isn't already

well maybe Ak's but i haven't seen too many coalition aircraft being downed.

So i doubt they have heat seekers.

236 razorbacker  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:43:09am

Kinda OT, but not altogether...My daughter went to her Aunt's house to start the cooking necessary to uphold the family honor at last weekends cemetery meeting. She (daughter) accidentally sent off the burglar alarm in the house. About an hour later, a carload of Stuttgart's finest showed up to investigate.

Daughter said it only took two heaping bowls of banana pudding and a homemade brownie apiece to convince the coppers that there was nothing nefarious going on, since actual burglars seldom, if ever, stayed around long enough to do any serious baking.

So the Russkies are missing a bet if they're not cooking up homemade goodies for the actual 'peacekeepers' when they arrive.

237 lurking faith  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:43:35am

re: #173 Boondock St. Bender

I agree; we are currently in a staring contest, or a gigantic game of chicken.

Is Georgia the new West Berlin?

238 Kosh's Shadow  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:43:55am

re: #217 Boondock St. Bender

I often thought that a good stategy against the russian army was to keep many stockpiles of vodka around what would be typical invasion routes.aloww these areas to be taken,then let nature take its course.
(counter-attack the besotted)

That's why I had suggested yesterday we include some vodka for the "poor Russian soldiers" in our humanitarian supplies.

239 TN_Vol  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:44:13am

re: #233 Kosh's Shadow

The same thing could happen later. If we don't stop Putin now, then we lose the rest of the Eastern bloc; they cannot stand against Russia on their own, and as much as they love freedom, they know what will happen to them if the Russians invade.

I would prefer that Putin openly arm our enemies as opposed to arming them secretly. At least that way we know what the SOB is doing.

240 Boondock St. Bender  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:44:35am

re: #220 pre-Boomer Marine brat

Of course,the easiest way to get the populous behind you is to crow about old grudges and racial distrusts.(worked for hitler)The sounds of strengh and power (don't fuck with us!)are seductive to a populus.much more fun to listen to then a balanced plan for the future.(based on economic well being and reponsinble gonvernance)War (and the sound of war)is easier than peace/prosperity.look at the pali's.

241 Kenneth  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:45:01am

re: #214 realwest

Yes, yes, but the US is not going to choose to do that. In 40 years of the Cold War the US & USSR avoided direct confrontation. Bush isn't going to violate that rule today over Georgia. Just ain't gonna happen. The most we can expect is some key weapons supplied to the Georgians, a few military advisers, sharing satellite intel & some limited air & sea security coverage provided during the limited humanitarian deliveries. If the Georgians are going to keep their independence, they're going to have to do the heavy lifting themselves.

Sorry, but that's the cold hard facts.

242 eschew_obfuscation  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:45:28am

re: #225 Land Shark

Well, the mask is off. Russia tells us in so many words their true motives for the escalation of the war. The Russian Bear is back. Time for the world to adjust it's attitude towards the New Russian Empire.

Funny how the Left remains silent over Russia's war for oil. "No blood for oil!" What a bunch of phonies. With Russia now in control or soon to be of the Georgian oil pipeline, they can dictate to Europe and West.

DRILL! DRILL! DRILL!

Drilling is good......

And we may be 'growing' our own oil in a couple of years

(link might be a little troublesome.....I think the server is getting pounded)

243 pegcity  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:45:28am

re: #233 Kosh's Shadow

what happens if Russia and China both decide that there gonna take all of eastern Asia for themselves.

This is going to get very bad, i can see China seeing this as there chance to strike while the irons hot and take over a bunch of stans under the pretense of routing out terrorism.

Were offically living in a Tom Clancy novel.

244 Honorary Yooper  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:45:32am

re: #29 Peacekeeper

No wisdom in fighting over Georgia, probably not Ukraine either or those three little dots up there on the Baltic coast. Poland? Maybe Poland.

We did the Poland thing before (1939). When we fought over it, it was almost too damn late. Better to stop this shit early before it gets past this point.

245 Kosh's Shadow  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:46:03am

re: #226 calcajun

And provoke on hell of an incident, to boot. As much as I'd like to see that (BTW, we are hanging our Georgian allies out to dry right now) that's only going to make matters worse.

None of the parties can afford to look weak; none of them can withstand the loss of face. They have to find a way to tip-toe out of the minefield.

And that's why Bush started with humanitarian aid. We weren't directly threatening the Russians, but they don't want to shoot at us, either. So it gave us a non-threatening way to get in a protective position. If the Russians keep going, then they're escalating, and we need to take that into account.

246 Dirk Diggler  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:46:13am

OR,

Well, let me be clear. We had posters over the last several days who were advocating immediately putting US ordnance on Russian troops in Georgia. I was, and continue to be, against that. You just don't start blasting the troops of a country with six thousand nukes. But there are other ways of fighting this, and I think after some initial trouble out of the gate, Bush is playing wisely.

You coward! Nothing less than the use of tactical nuclear weapons on Russian troops is an effective response!

//////

247 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:46:25am

re: #240 Boondock St. Bender

Of course,the easiest way to get the populous behind you is to ...

How true, how true.

248 Dustoff-507  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:46:55am

re: #235 pegcity


True, but remember we have been preparing our birds for surface to air missiles for years know. One reason Saddam had such a hard time hitting our birds.
Plus once you turn on your radar to track our birds we have a system that will put a Mach 3 missile in you front door right now.

249 Occasional Reader  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:47:20am

Anyway, the Russians need to be made to understood that none of this is helping Michelle Obama's children. Once Putin realizes that, watch as the Russian forces scurry for home, apologizing all the way.

250 anotherindyfilmguy  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:47:26am

IMO it's to early to make dire predictions about the future based on the bits of information coming out of Georgia and the CCCP Russia at the moment. I have a feeling that Bush is going to take actions that will make the kgb thug led Russian attempt to rape, pillage and destroy "punish" Georgia etc a very painful proposition. VDH in past essays often mentions the "law of unintended consequences" and imo the Russians put to much weight on the POTUS being "lame duck" and not wishing to attempt power projection to stop their overwhelming force etc... There's a lot th west can do to make Putin and company Russia pay dearly for it's actions and we'll just have to see how it plays out...

251 pegcity  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:48:01am

re: #248 Dustoff-507

im thinking more about the Chinooks and older coalition craft, not so much your Apaches and planes.

252 Kosh's Shadow  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:48:03am

re: #243 pegcity

what happens if Russia and China both decide that there gonna take all of eastern Asia for themselves.

This is going to get very bad, i can see China seeing this as there chance to strike while the irons hot and take over a bunch of stans under the pretense of routing out terrorism.

Were offically living in a Tom Clancy novel.

If we back off, we're giving them permission to take over those countries. And they won't have to do it with guns; they can just make some subtle threats and get alliances because there will be no one they can count on to guarantee their independence.

253 filetandrelease  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:48:04am

re: #156 Occasional Reader

This game is just getting started, folks.


So true, and a dangerous game at that.

254 Boondock St. Bender  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:48:09am

re: #222 pegcity

True,the russian army is truly a beast that cannot be efficient without a head.Each level of command waits for orders from above.and dares not take iniatative for fear of screwing up(or being blamed for screwing up)some generals grand strategem

255 SFGoth  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:48:23am

re: #232 realwest

"The annexation of eastern Poland will be short in coming."
Uh, no it won't be coming at all. Poland HAS a military - a damn good one that a part of has been battle tested alongside our Forces in Iraq (and iirc,
Afghanistan) and they won't go quietly into that good night. Same with Ukraine - population of 50 million or so, balls enough to deny Russia's Naval Squadron back into it's home ports, etc.
This "game" (which it most assuredly is not) is not only not over, I think it's just beginning.

Agree. Poland and Ukraine will be much tougher. Frankly, Poland (errr, attempting to grab Poland) could well ignite a larger war. Ukraine is kind of weird historically vis-a-vis Russian, but Poland is a true nation (in the general sense of nation, not country).

256 Occasional Reader  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:48:43am

re: #246 Dirk Diggler

OR,


You coward! Nothing less than the use of tactical nuclear weapons on Russian troops is an effective response!

//////

Tactical? Just "tactical" nukes? Why don't we give the Rooskies free bl*w jobs while we're at it, Mr. Appeasenik?

/////

257 right_on_target  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:49:25am

re: #26 marge45b

Mother Russia will bilk NASA on trips to the ISS when the Shuttle retires.

WHY does the shuttle have to retire before the successor comes on line?

258 Dustoff-507  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:50:07am

re: #251 pegcity


I'm confused... are yu talking about OUR birds or say Englands.

259 Honorary Yooper  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:50:17am

re: #168 Dustoff-507

Didn't they also have a James Bond movie on this too?

Yes, The World is Not Enough.

260 realwest  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:50:51am

re: #209 Occasional Reader "there are other ways of fighting this" - respectfully, my friend, there are no other ways of fighting this if we aren't prepared to engage Russia in Georgia militarily. And BTW, Putin may (or may not) have 6,000 deliverable nukes (maitenance has been a massive problem for Russia) but Putin knows we have nukes too - better nukes and many of them aboard the "Boomers" - nuke powered subs just sitting at the bottom of the oceans, targets already keyed in and Putin knows that, too.
If we have NO credible will to use military force in Georgia (e.g., Putin decides to "teach us a lesson" and interfere with either Naval or Air Force attempts to deliver humanitarian aid and we just say "Oh, Ok") then there is No Other Way. With other nations maybe, but not with Russia.

261 anotherindyfilmguy  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:50:55am

re: #227 galloping granny

I think he wants to. I think he is just being very careful about rushing in where even angels fear to tread. Also remember the amount of time that he has to operate a war without Congressional oversight.

What would be interesting is if he counts backwards from his last day in office then launches any actual operations, covet or overt, with the intent of handing it over to the new POTUS to see if the new POTUS can have a reset on the war powers timeframe to adjust and finish etc - just in case congress is cowardly, bought off or anti-long term US survival/commie shills not friendly to the idea of conflict over Georgia...

262 tfc3rid  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:51:24am

Them's fightin' words!

263 Dustoff-507  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:51:33am

re: #254 Boondock St. Bender


Bingo... only the top guys can set the direction. Lower class cannot.
This is what causes them so many problems in war.

264 pegcity  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:51:35am

re: #258 Dustoff-507

im in Canada so im thinking the old Chinooks we are renting from you guys or say whatever piece of crap planes the Canadian airforce has flying.

265 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:51:46am

re: #254 Boondock St. Bender

True,the russian army is truly a beast that cannot be efficient without a head.Each level of command waits for orders from above.and dares not take iniatative for fear of screwing up(or being blamed for screwing up)some generals grand strategem

IIRC, the top-priority tactic against a Russian assault through the Fulda Gap would have been to ID and take out the command vehicles.

/wouldn't work against Israelis

266 SFGoth  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:51:47am

re: #244 Honorary Yooper

We did the Poland thing before (1939). When we fought over it, it was almost too damn late. Better to stop this shit early before it gets past this point.

We didn't, Britain and France did. You can pretty much count on the W. European governments to do fucking squat to back Georgia. They're feckless and useless -- and I'm not referring to the ordinary Joe 6 Liter -- so don't go apeshit on me you Brits here.

267 Honorary Yooper  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:51:49am

re: #255 SFGoth

Agree. Poland and Ukraine will be much tougher. Frankly, Poland (errr, attempting to grab Poland) could well ignite a larger war. Ukraine is kind of weird historically vis-a-vis Russian, but Poland is a true nation (in the general sense of nation, not country).

Grab ahold of something. I fear it may be a very rocky ride.

268 jcm  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:51:53am

re: #248 Dustoff-507

True, but remember we have been preparing our birds for surface to air missiles for years know. One reason Saddam had such a hard time hitting our birds.
Plus once you turn on your radar to track our birds we have a system that will put a Mach 3 missile in you front door right now.

And the new gen. only needs a peak. It used to be the radar had to be on for the missile to home in on it. Now if the turn edon the radar for a snap shot it is locked in.

269 Dustoff-507  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:51:55am

re: #259 Honorary Yooper


See i just knew it. LOL

270 anotherindyfilmguy  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:52:22am

re: #243 pegcity

Orwell's "1984" becomes reality. With our side being the last of the Republics/Democratically aligned states/confederation/alliance etc comrade...

271 Kenneth  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:52:38am

re: #255 SFGoth

By invading Georgia, the Russians are sending a blunt message directly to Ukraine: no NATO for you.

Poland is too far out of the Russian orbit to pull it back, but they do expect them to behave a little better.

272 SFGoth  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:52:38am

re: #265 pre-Boomer Marine brat

IIRC, the top-priority tactic against a Russian assault through the Fulda Gap would have been to ID and take out the command vehicles.

/wouldn't work against Israelis

IIRC the top-priority tactic against a Russian assault through the Fulda Gap would have been to nuke it. That's why we never renounced first strike.

273 Boondock St. Bender  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:53:22am

re: #260 realwest

puyin interferes with humanitarion aid,and within five minutes whatever made any provocative moves will be smoking wreckage.that was the message bush sent.

274 SFGoth  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:53:28am

re: #271 Kenneth

By invading Georgia, the Russians are sending a blunt message directly to Ukraine: no NATO for you.

Poland is too far out of the Russian orbit to pull it back, but they do expect them to behave a little better.

I didn't say what you quoted; probably an internal quote of what I quoted.

275 Honorary Yooper  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:53:37am

re: #266 SFGoth

We didn't, Britain and France did. You can pretty much count on the W. European governments to do fucking squat to back Georgia. They're feckless and useless -- and I'm not referring to the ordinary Joe 6 Liter -- so don't go apeshit on me you Brits here.

"We" as in the Allies. I also expect them to do nothing this time. What's different is that the US is not the same kind of isolationist nation it was in 1939.

276 Boondock St. Bender  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:54:02am

re: #265 pre-Boomer Marine brat

or marines!

277 Peacekeeper  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:54:10am

re: #257 right_on_target

WHY does the shuttle have to retire before the successor comes on line?

Why

On the heels of news about NASA engineers who feel the Constellation program is using the wrong kind of rockets comes word that efforts to build the spacecraft which will replace the shuttle and return astronauts to the moon is running behind and over-budget. NASA Watch published a leaked internal NASA document showing the Constellation Program has encountered financial and technical problems, and the Associated Press quoted Doug Cooke, NASA's deputy associate administrator for exploration as saying the first test flights for Orion may be delayed...

278 Dustoff-507  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:54:12am

re: #264 pegcity

ahhh, well I don't know what you have. Yes i know their older (damn shame)
But there is defense systems for them too.

279 realwest  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:54:20am

re: #226 calcajun
Respectfully, Russia has already created one hell of an incident - how badly we are damaged by it depends on what we do NOW.

280 Occasional Reader  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:54:54am

re: #260 realwest

respectfully, my friend, there are no other ways of fighting this

We did an entire Cold War without (explicitly) going head to head with the Soviet military.

281 pegcity  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:55:05am

re: #270 anotherindyfilmguy

funny that Clancy had Russia right all along, he knew that they would eventually pull this shit, makes sense if you look at there rehabilitation of Stalinism and the fondness for the USSR.

Well i guess it was fun while it lasted. So America has 1 choice Mcain or well Mcain.

It's going to be an ugly next 10 years that's for sure.

282 Dustoff-507  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:55:15am

re: #268 jcm


AND you don't want to be in the hut. LOL

283 Boondock St. Bender  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:56:26am

As i said before,putin may be crowing now,if this doesn't play out how he hopes,he may well end up out of a job,and disgraced.

284 Honorary Yooper  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:56:38am

re: #279 realwest

Respectfully, Russia has already created one hell of an incident - how badly we are damaged by it depends on what we do NOW.

Exactly. And, it'll be tough to handle this without either:

A. looking weak and allowing the Russian Bear to expand and walk in on the Baltics and Ukraine, or
B. escalating the smaller war into a larger one.

Like I said, hang on tight, it's going to be a bumpy ride.

285 Kenneth  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:56:43am

re: #274 SFGoth

I didn't quote you. Those were my words.

286 anotherindyfilmguy  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:57:08am

re: #257 right_on_target

Money and lack of both NASA and Congress having the combined foresight and willingness to deal with the problem outside of dire circumstances... oh wait - dire circumstances are here now! Let's see if NASA gets funding to make next generation shuttle or ramp up Orion quicker etc... not holding breath though...

287 Honorary Yooper  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:57:24am

re: #280 Occasional Reader

We did an entire Cold War without (explicitly) going head to head with the Soviet military.

Never really had to. Our proxies did the dirty work for the most part. This feels different somehow than the Cold War did.

288 KimZigfeld  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:57:26am

I can't help but wonder how Russia would react if the U.S. decides to start shipping arms to Chechnya, recognizes it as independent, invades and then Condi Rice declares that the world "can forget about" Russian soverignty.

It's now clear that Russia planned this attack well in advance and it had nothing to do with any action on Georgia's part, since massive cyber attacks began on Georgia long before the fighting on the ground.

Meanwhile, the Russians are installing nukes in Ossetia.

Ukraine must be admitted to NATO immediately and armed to the teeth. That is our best immediate response and it's a pity Krauthammer overlooked it in an otherwise excellent analysis.

If the world finally wakes up to the horror that is neo-Soviet Russia, Georgia's sacrifice will have been worthwhile.

289 JHW  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:58:15am

A couple of interesting articles from the Irish Times:
Commandant Putin aims for Regime Change

More on these so-called para-militaries and "volunteers". The hatreds run deep. The reporter recently returned from South Ossetia and Abkhazia.
Breakaway Regions Backed by Caucasian Neighbors

290 Boondock St. Bender  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:59:02am

re: #281 pegcity

you heard of "Manny being manny" in baseball,well this is "russia being russia".They have an inferiority complex of no mean order when it comes to comparing themselves with the west.it shows up in actions like this.

291 galloping granny  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 9:59:09am

re: #257 right_on_target

WHY does the shuttle have to retire before the successor comes on line?

Because it should not fly now truth be told - and it is a miracle every time it does.

292 Kenneth  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:00:02am

re: #288 KimZigfeld

Meanwhile, the Russians are installing nukes in Ossetia.

The Russians are not installing nukes in Ossetia. That report was from a raving moonbat leftist blog, which happens to be very pro-Russian. Please stop repeating it.

293 galloping granny  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:00:30am

re: #292 Kenneth

The Russians are not installing nukes in Ossetia. That report was from a raving moonbat leftist blog, which happens to be very pro-Russian. Please stop repeating it.

That would be an exceedingly bad move on their part.

294 Occasional Reader  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:00:36am

re: #284 Honorary Yooper

allowing the Russian Bear to expand and walk in on the Baltics and Ukraine

They don't have the military capability to simply re-take their empire, even if they wanted to.

I think part of what Putin wanted to do this week was to make us panic. It would be a mistake to take that bait. "This is not the Red Army I knew", as Obama might put it; yes, they can take on Georgia, but they do not have the capacity to roll back up to the edge of Germany. The game now is aggressive containment.

295 Hard Right  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:00:54am

Dr. Stinger, paging Dr. Stinger....

296 pegcity  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:00:59am

re: #293 galloping granny

that would be putting the doomsday clock to 11:55

297 yma o hyd  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:01:10am

Ah well - Gates seems to sing from a different songsheet, here ...

298 pegcity  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:01:35am

re: #295 Hard Right

Dr. Stinger, paging Dr. Stinger....

Get some Javelin's there stat.

299 Honorary Yooper  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:01:40am

re: #288 KimZigfeld

I can't help but wonder how Russia would react if the U.S. decides to start shipping arms to Chechnya, recognizes it as independent, invades and then Condi Rice declares that the world "can forget about" Russian soverignty.

It's now clear that Russia planned this attack well in advance and it had nothing to do with any action on Georgia's part, since massive cyber attacks began on Georgia long before the fighting on the ground.

That may be our 3-minute warning (so to speak) about Russia's (Putin's) next step.

Meanwhile, the Russians are installing nukes in Ossetia.

This is not a good sign, and I'd imagine the oil-rich folks in Azerbaijan have to be rather nervous about it.

Ukraine must be admitted to NATO immediately and armed to the teeth. That is our best immediate response and it's a pity Krauthammer overlooked it in an otherwise excellent analysis.

If the world finally wakes up to the horror that is neo-Soviet Russia, Georgia's sacrifice will have been worthwhile.

Absolutely, Kim. Ukraine must be protected, as must the Baltics. They could very well be the next targets of Russian aggression.

Geeze. I never thought I'd be speaking about Russian aggression again after 1991. I guess history has a funny way of repeating itself.

300 galloping granny  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:01:50am

re: #296 pegcity

that would be putting the doomsday clock to 11:55

Wouldn't that be moving it backwards?

301 Kenneth  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:02:16am

re: #293 galloping granny

And pointless.

302 Rune  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:02:44am

I don’t know why you are so insistent that South Ossetia should be forced to be part of Georgia. The spilt into North and South Ossetia was done by Stalin (himself Georgian) in a classic divide and conquer strategy. Georgia has systematically tried to suppress and marginalise the Ossetian culture, by things like mandating Georgian as the only language to be used in schools, public institutions, etc. Ossetians are a very small people which cannot for long survive being splint up in this way. By all accounts they do not wish to be part of Georgia. Significant, the South Ossetians are fleeing not to Georgia but to Russia – where North Ossetia since the first war in 1992 has been the region of Russian with the largest concentration of refugees per inhabitants. Why allow Kosovo independence and not South Ossetia?

303 Peacekeeper  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:02:45am

re: #294 Occasional Reader

the Ukraine is weak: it's a road apple.

304 pegcity  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:02:52am

re: #300 galloping granny

i forget how does it work again? isn't midnight doomsday.

305 Kosh's Shadow  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:02:56am

re: #294 Occasional Reader

They don't have the military capability to simply re-take their empire, even if they wanted to.

I think part of what Putin wanted to do this week was to make us panic. It would be a mistake to take that bait. "This is not the Red Army I knew", as Obama might put it; yes, they can take on Georgia, but they do not have the capacity to roll back up to the edge of Germany. The game now is aggressive containment.

They don't have to re-take the old Soviet Empire. They just need to frighten the parts that split off from getting closer to the West. Even if they only need to go after one of those countries, that's all it would take to get the others in line.
Bullies don't need to beat up every kid in the school; beat up one in front of the others, and then all of them will give up their lunch money.

306 Honorary Yooper  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:03:40am

re: #292 Kenneth

The Russians are not installing nukes in Ossetia. That report was from a raving moonbat leftist blog, which happens to be very pro-Russian. Please stop repeating it.

Thanks for the clarification. I'd still imagine Azerbaijan has to be a bit nervous, being as they are next to the fighting, south of Russia, and north of Iran.

307 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:04:09am

re: #272 SFGoth

IIRC the top-priority tactic against a Russian assault through the Fulda Gap would have been to nuke it. That's why we never renounced first strike.

My point was the fact that the Russian Army exhibited no initiative in the lower levels of command. Break the chain of command, and it would grind to a halt.

308 Kenneth  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:04:20am

re: #303 Peacekeeper

the Ukraine is weak: it's a road apple.

I from Ukraine! Ukraine not weak!

Yeah, well we're playing a game, buddy.

309 Honorary Yooper  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:04:31am

re: #304 pegcity

i forget how does it work again? isn't midnight doomsday.

Yes. It has been set at various times, usually in the 5 minutes to midnight range.

310 Occasional Reader  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:05:20am

re: #302 Rune

I don’t know why you are so insistent that South Ossetia should be forced to be part of Georgia

Who here is insisiting on that?

And do you really think that's what this is all about? Disinterested Russian love for Ossetian self-determination?

311 Egfrow  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:05:21am

The Soviet Union would have fell to the Germans during WWII if it was not for the United States Lend Lease. They were in shambles and on the brink. The Russians stole and copied as much as the could. Even copied or B-29 Bombers perfectly down to the detail of the repair marks. The managed to Steal our Atomic Weapons Secrets by means of traitors, promising the altruist collective utopia of prosperity for all. It is likely that Russians murdered more people than Hilter yet there were no Nuremberg trials. George S. Patton wanted to take on the Russians right after WWII he was considered a presidential candidate against Truman. He didn't make it out of Germany. We rewarded the losers by giving the weakest members of WWII veto powers in a corrupt organization that had the fortitude to only do one great thing in over 60 years, The Korean War.

Everything the Russians have produced is a knock off and copy of something the West has invented and produced, The entire Oil Industry is a result of Americans which included the Light bulb, Samuel Morey's Internal Combustion Engine, Electricity production, Electronics, Computers, Hughes Drill Bit, Super Tankers, Drilling Rigs, Mass refining of oil, Mass Media Film, The printing Press, The internet, Satellite Communications, The Cell Phone, all these innovations have been invented rapidly and have change the world forever. The time is rapidly approaching the point where the UN is not a tool for Nations of peace but rather a dangerous liability and obstruction to it.

America is at fault.

312 galloping granny  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:05:30am

re: #304 pegcity

i forget how does it work again? isn't midnight doomsday.

Yeah, but aren't we already sitting on something like 11:59?

313 jcm  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:05:46am

re: #260 realwest

I'm with you on this one. We either get status quo ante Aug. 6 by diplomacy for militarily in the next few weeks. Or Russian gets Georgia.

If Russia gets Georgia and we don't go to the mat on this we will be forced to later and much bigger.

314 pegcity  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:06:19am

re: #313 jcm

I'm with you on this one. We either get status quo ante Aug. 6 by diplomacy for militarily in the next few weeks. Or Russian gets Georgia.

If Russia gets Georgia and we don't go to the mat on this we will be forced to later and much bigger.

so now its 11:59 and um 10 seconds

315 jorline  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:06:21am

re: #280 Occasional Reader

We did an entire Cold War without (explicitly) going head to head with the Soviet military.

I agree OC, but the Cold War was entirely different then. Russia at that time was a super power holding a pair of twos in the hand...no one knew the extent of their bluff at that time.

This is different, we have a KGB Putin running the show who is hell bent on bring back the Mother Land to it's former glory. This will escalate and no telling what he will do next. The advantage we have this time is we know what cards they're holding.

316 calcajun  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:06:46am

re: #279 realwest

Which they can call, with a straight face, an internal matter. If our forces are in there, in harm's way, and come under--and return--fire, then the matter escalates. This is Clausewitz 101 -- war as an extension of diplomacy.

317 Peacekeeper  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:06:50am

re: #310 Occasional Reader

Who here is insisiting on that?

And do you really think that's what this is all about? Disinterested Russian love for Ossetian self-determination?

And they whirled and they twirled and they tangoed
Singin' and jingin' the jango
Floatin' like the heavens above
It looks like Disinterested Russian love

318 Kenneth  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:07:05am

re: #306 Honorary Yooper

The message Putin is making is directed to all of Russia's neighbors, but most importantly to Ukraine. Georgia & Azerbaijan are insults & nuisances. The Russian's view the possibility of Ukraine joining NATO as a direct and serious strategic threat. That's what this is all about.

319 BlueCanuck  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:07:23am

re: #268 jcm

And the new gen. only needs a peak. It used to be the radar had to be on for the missile to home in on it. Now if the turn edon the radar for a snap shot it is locked in.

Old tech actually. Back in 89, when I learned radio procedures, I was told that the minute you keyed a mike for transmission you were a target of artillery.

/okay the SECOND you did that.
//joys of the infantry, always moving and no place to call defensive. :)

320 realwest  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:07:50am

re: #280 Occasional Reader Yes we did - but look at the Cold War- we WERE PREPARED to use our military power against the Soviets (think Cuban Missile Crisis) and there were, in fact, many "accidental" sinking of ship, subs, clipped wings on aircraft etc.
I'm NOT SAYING WE SHOULD use our military in Georgia, but if we don't have any credible deterrence to Russia's annexation of all of Georgia (and that IS where Russia is headed) then WHERE do we make Russia face up to reality?
We won the Cold War for a lot of reasons, but not the least of them was our demonstrable willingness to use our military if we deemed it necessary (indeed, Korea occured during the Cold War, as well as the Cuban Missile crisis).
If we pose NO credible military deterrent to Russia, then there is NO OTHER WAY to stop Russia's aggression against Georgia or other nations.

321 Occasional Reader  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:08:01am

re: #305 Kosh's Shadow

They just need to frighten the parts that split off from getting closer to the West

With respect to the current new NATO members, that ship has already sailed (for the Russians, I mean). I expect the Poles and Baltics to be tighter with us as a result of this. It may work to intimidate Ukraine; that's where the next focus should be to make sure that doesn't happen.

322 jcm  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:08:19am

re: #302 Rune

I am insistent because the why to resolve the issue is not by Russian agent provocateurs fomenting a crisis and Russia invading, raping and pillaging.

323 Dirk Diggler  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:08:21am

Kenneth,

The Russians are not installing nukes in Ossetia. That report was from a raving moonbat leftist blog, which happens to be very pro-Russian. Please stop repeating it.

I'd have a hard time believing that tactical nuclear weapons aren't somewhere very near the theater of operations.

324 Tigger2005  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:08:39am

When did we turn tail and run? I must have missed that.

We are still in Afghanistan and Iraq.

Now we are sending our military into Georgia to distribute humanitarian aid. You think that's all there is to it? No, the presence of U.S. troops on Georgian soil on a "purely humanitarian mission" (wink wink) will make a difference. What will Russia do about them? What can they say about them?

I think we can look for this aid effort to ramp up in the coming days and weeks. American military planes landing regularly in Georgia's airports, American military ships porting in Georgia's harbors. What kinda victory and occupation is this, Russia, when your enemy's ally is pouring troops into the country daily?


re: #146 lefty201

No. But it does seem like we're all talk and no action anymore. Nations that should pay attention to us, blow us off now and try to disregard us. (Try Hugo Chavez, Iran, Russia, Syria, Pakistan (and we should be going in there after Bin Laden but can't)). How are we supposed to look at nations around the world and say "hey, we're you buddies and were going to help you build a democracy because it works!" when we turn tail and run from our friends at the first sign of trouble.

325 lifeofthemind  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:09:02am

re: #288 KimZigfeld

Meanwhile, the Russians are installing nukes in Ossetia.

Stop hyperventilating. The linked report merely states the Russian forces brought along a tactical surface to surface missile system that can be configured to carry a nuclear payload. Most aircraft can deliver a nuclear weapon but that doesn't mean that we treat every plane as if it was in itself the bomb. Similarly, 155 artillery can carry both conventional and special ordinance. With ICBMs and some other systems we do treat the delivery system as if it was in itself a nuclear device because that is it's only purpose. with the short range missiles the problem is harder. The US Pershing II missile is a nuclear system and if when Reagan threatened to install it in places within range of Russia panic ensued. We would have to target these launchers at the start of any larger campaign but they do not mean that nuclear war is imminent.

326 Egfrow  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:09:50am

re: #318 Kenneth

The message Putin is making is directed to all of Russia's neighbors, but most importantly to Ukraine. Georgia & Azerbaijan are insults & nuisances. The Russian's view the possibility of Ukraine joining NATO as a direct and serious strategic threat. That's what this is all about.

Well there is more to it than that. There is consolidation of power, nationalizing it's people, and securing economic monopolies for the Thugs and Cronies that have murdered and stolen companies and industries from others. Russia is the world's largest Organized Crime Syndicate that ever existed.

327 calcajun  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:10:08am

re: #245 Kosh's Shadow

Humanitarian Aid = trip wire

328 yma o hyd  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:10:16am

re: #302 Rune

Because it was, after WWII and the following establishment of links between western Germany and Poland, and relations between Soviet Russia and western Germany and the Allies, as well as agreements between the Allies when the wll came down - that borders, established after WWII, should not be redrawn, especially not by force.
Yes - that agreement was breached in former Yougoslavia, but if we do not finally draw the line here, then who is to stop Germany from taking back her former counties which are now in Poland?
And, going abck further - why not institute the area of the former Austrian Empire? The Grand Duchy of Lithuania, which occupied al of Poland?

This stuff about peples wanting self-determination is no more than modern, LLL hogwash.
Look at Switzerland - four nations, with four different languages, living together in a small country ...
Its a question of proper governance to keep differing people within the boundaries of one state - not of having a 'republic' for each and every tribe!

329 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:10:21am

re: #318 Kenneth

The message Putin is making is directed to all of Russia's neighbors, but most importantly to Ukraine. Georgia & Azerbaijan are insults & nuisances. The Russian's view the possibility of Ukraine joining NATO as a direct and serious strategic threat. That's what this is all about.

Hear hear.

330 Ford_Prefect  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:10:34am

You guys just missed a block and delete by Charles on the Saudi thread.

331 Logic Probe  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:10:45am

If Russia's moves on Georgia are evil, why was the US crushing the South and forcing them back into the Union not also bad? They look similar to me, except that the Russians are using more finesse than Sherman did.

If nothing else, I really have to admire the Russkies chess game, here. I just don't see why the Georgians took the bait and went for that pawn when they did. Seems like a dumb move when the US is busy and Europe wants heating oil and gas for next winter. Who else is going to lift a finger?

332 Eric Cartman's Conscience  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:10:48am

"I can't believe the US would want to get involved in a military stand-off with Russia, with US forces already over-stretched in Iraq and Afghanistan"

Mr Lukyanov adds another Russian calculation into the mix: "The Bush administration is outgoing - and after the US election, we will have the opportunity to start afresh. Little will be achieved until then in discussions with America."

Damn Russians. And he's right. No one fears Bush taking heads on the way out of office. Regardless of the raving mad-man bent on bombing Iran, the adversaries of America view Bush in much lighter, more accurate terms than our own Left.

333 jcm  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:11:39am

re: #319 BlueCanuck

Old tech actually. Back in 89, when I learned radio procedures, I was told that the minute you keyed a mike for transmission you were a target of artillery.

/okay the SECOND you did that.
//joys of the infantry, always moving and no place to call defensive. :)

It's even better now, the EA-18F doesn't need the snif. The E-3 or EC-135 can get the snif and relay the targeting data.

334 pegcity  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:11:47am

re: #331 Logic Probe

If Russia's moves on Georgia are evil, why was the US crushing the South and forcing them back into the Union not also bad? They look similar to me, except that the Russians are using more finesse than Sherman did.

If nothing else, I really have to admire the Russkies chess game, here. I just don't see why the Georgians took the bait and went for that pawn when they did. Seems like a dumb move when the US is busy and Europe wants heating oil and gas for next winter. Who else is going to lift a finger?

You admire Russia killing 1500 civilians to prove a point?

335 BlueCanuck  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:11:49am

re: #311 Egfrow

Back in the 80's I read about the Russians stealing tech from America. All the way down to calculators. They found a piece of USSR computer equipment (computer chip) that had been so reverse engineered it included the TI logo on the chip.

336 Kilroy  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:11:53am

As POTUS I believe Obama will be able to unilaterally extinguish our nuclear capabilities and stop current deployment of our antimissile shield.I believe he's basically stated this as his desire.This is total absurdity but seems to be our direction.What can Eastern Europe rely on other than combat hardened French troops?What will we in the US rely on?

337 Kenneth  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:12:26am

re: #323 Dirk Diggler

Maybe, but they would be well on the Russian side of the border. There is a major Russian military base in North Ossetia.

338 Occasional Reader  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:12:26am

re: #320 realwest

If we pose NO credible military deterrent to Russia

And where is anyone suggesting we pose NO military deterrent?

Poland and the Baltics being in NATO - that's a military deterrent, right off the bat.

339 Dirk Diggler  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:13:00am

lifeofthemind,

Stop hyperventilating.

Wrong. Now is the time to panic and absolutely freak out.

340 Tigger2005  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:13:50am

re: #331 Logic Probe

If Russia's moves on Georgia are evil, why was the US crushing the South and forcing them back into the Union not also bad? They look similar to me, except that the Russians are using more finesse than Sherman did.

If nothing else, I really have to admire the Russkies chess game, here. I just don't see why the Georgians took the bait and went for that pawn when they did. Seems like a dumb move when the US is busy and Europe wants heating oil and gas for next winter. Who else is going to lift a finger?

Uh, Georgia never willingly signed on to be a province of Russia. Russia forcefully incorporated Georgia into its empire.

341 jorline  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:14:07am

re: #288 KimZigfeld

I can't help but wonder how Russia would react if the U.S. decides to start shipping arms to Chechnya, recognizes it as independent, invades and then Condi Rice declares that the world "can forget about" Russian soverignty.

It's now clear that Russia planned this attack well in advance and it had nothing to do with any action on Georgia's part, since massive cyber attacks began on Georgia long before the fighting on the ground.

Meanwhile, the Russians are installing nukes in Ossetia.

Ukraine must be admitted to NATO immediately and armed to the teeth. That is our best immediate response and it's a pity Krauthammer overlooked it in an otherwise excellent analysis.

If the world finally wakes up to the horror that is neo-Soviet Russia, Georgia's sacrifice will have been worthwhile.


Welcome back Kim. I agree with your assessment, but I don't think Georgia needs to be the sacrificial lamb...we need to stop this now.

I don't want to encourage the bear to come back for more by feeding it.

342 Kenneth  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:15:10am

re: #339 Dirk Diggler

lifeofthemind,

Wrong. Now is the time to panic and absolutely freak out.

Ok, I've put my pants over my head & I'm running in circles screaming, "the Russians are coming!"

343 Occasional Reader  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:15:38am

re: #331 Logic Probe

why was the US crushing the South and forcing them back into the Union not also bad? They look similar to me

Rrriiight, and hopefully this will mean that the Georgians will finally abolish slavery.

Nice try, tovarisch.

344 eschew_obfuscation  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:15:41am

re: #342 Kenneth

Ok, I've put my pants over my head & I'm running in circles screaming, "the Russians are coming!"

"Every body to get from street!"

345 GreenBear  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:16:03am

re: #305 Kosh's Shadow

They don't have to re-take the old Soviet Empire. They just need to frighten the parts that split off from getting closer to the West. Even if they only need to go after one of those countries, that's all it would take to get the others in line.
Bullies don't need to beat up every kid in the school; beat up one in front of the others, and then all of them will give up their lunch money.

Very true but same analogy work the other way.

One way to stop a bully is to band together and let him know you won't take his crap. He can't beat everyone up. Russia can't fight them all if they stand together. It's a gamble for sure and a bitter pill, but it's also the price for having your own country: being willing to fight for it. If you don't have the heart to defend your own land, no one else will help you and your national pride is gone.

How about we move all those troops from Germany and western Europe to new bases in eastern Europe where they would be welcomed and appreciated?

The Cold War was relatively uneventful (open hostility speaking) because the US was there to push back when the Soviets pulled some crap. We need to send in some squadrons of A-10 Warthogs and Iraq-seasoned marines for "humanitarian purposes" and see the Russians pull back.

They'll never come to the peace table out of the goodness of their hearts, you know.

346 Dirk Diggler  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:17:52am

Kenneth,

Ok, I've put my pants over my head & I'm running in circles screaming, "the Russians are coming!"

What the hell do you care? You and Writermom live in Canada. The only national emergencies you people have are NHL lock-outs.

347 Boondock St. Bender  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:17:59am

re: #331 Logic Probe

I don't matbe because the area was ceded to them when georgia broke away from the soviet union.the area belongs to them.the russians just can't redraw the map where and when it suits them.If the russians were sooooo concerned with ethnic russians in the area,allow them to emmigrate to russia.after the old soviet union,their must be onclaves of russians in all the former soviet states.whats to stop them from using them as a reason for action anywhere?

348 tfc3rid  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:18:42am

re: #296 pegcity

that would be putting the doomsday clock to 11:55

It already IS 11:55 on the Doomsday Clock...

349 pegcity  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:18:56am

re: #346 Dirk Diggler

And when hockey night and canada lost the rights to the theme song, that was a leading item on the news for 2 days.

350 lurking faith  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:18:59am

re: #302 Rune

I don't know why you think, apparently, that Russia is only trying to take South Ossetia. Or that Russia actually gives a flying fig for the rights of South Ossetians.

Russia wants its empire back.

351 realwest  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:19:03am

re: #330 Ford_Prefect
Who was banned and deleted and why?

352 stevieray  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:19:36am

re: #347 Boondock St. Bender

I don't matbe because the area was ceded to them when georgia broke away from the soviet union.the area belongs to them.the russians just can't redraw the map where and when it suits them.If the russians were sooooo concerned with ethnic russians in the area,allow them to emmigrate to russia.after the old soviet union,their must be onclaves of russians in all the former soviet states.whats to stop them from using them as a reason for action anywhere?

Such as Brighton Beach.

353 Boondock St. Bender  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:19:45am

re: #339 Dirk Diggler

wrong.
"a cool head and a steady nerve are what the situation requires"
Al Swerengen

354 chukardog  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:19:58am

Can someone school me on whats really going on here? is there a link that can tell me exactly what has transpired and why? I understand that Russia's reason for invading was becuase georgia sent troops into South Ossetia. Who's territory is South Ossetia?

355 KimZigfeld  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:19:58am

re: #292 Kenneth

Would it be asking too much for you to source your statement? If this report has been discredited, would you mind linking me to the material?

Because, otherwise, I might just think you are a Kremlin stooge trying to put people off the scent.

Surely you're not suggesting that Russia "wouldn't do" such a thing, are you? I believe that position was laid to rest along with many citizens of the Georgian city of Gori.

356 Kenneth  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:20:40am

re: #345 GreenBear

The Cold War was relatively uneventful (open hostility speaking) because the US was there to push back when the Soviets pulled some crap. We need to send in some squadrons of A-10 Warthogs and Iraq-seasoned marines for "humanitarian purposes" and see the Russians pull back.

Actually, the Cold War never got thermonuclear hot because it was always fought through proxies. US & Soviet troops never once squared off and fought. We came close a few times... but thank God neither side figured it was worth going all out over a some stinking jungle.

That's why the US won't send combat forces into Georgia. We'll help the Georgians fight the Rushkies, but that's it.

357 Boondock St. Bender  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:20:43am

re: #352 stevieray

zactly.

358 BeerDrinking_VictoryMonkey  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:21:20am

re: #93 jorline

Has anyone even heard from Beach Boy Barry lately?

"Beach Barry, Beach Barry, lay on the sand from July to the end of November..."

359 itellu3times  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:21:56am

So Russia is just turning into a big pirate empire?

And whashisname the FM, is in charge of saying stupid stuff?

Lordy, how the world can change overnight.

360 Tigger2005  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:22:09am

re: #345 GreenBear

We need to send in some squadrons of A-10 Warthogs and Iraq-seasoned marines for "humanitarian purposes" and see the Russians pull back.

See my post #324 above. It seems to me we are already bringing in troops under cover of a "humanitarian mission." Not only are we landing planes and ships at will in Georgia's airports and harbors, we are putting American boots on the ground, right now.

There are also parallels to the Berlin Airlift here. Then, we couldn't, or wouldn't, aid the West Berliners directly. But we didn't abandon them, either.

I think we are in Georgia now, and will stay there. This "we turned tail and ran" stuff is crap.

361 KimZigfeld  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:22:12am

re: #354 chukardog

Here's the link (she said immodestly).

362 Boondock St. Bender  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:22:30am

re: #355 KimZigfeld

if putin wanted to die over this i guess he would move nukes into the area.i'm thinking he doesn't.

363 Charles  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:22:42am

re: #355 KimZigfeld

Would it be asking too much for you to source your statement? If this report has been discredited, would you mind linking me to the material?

Because, otherwise, I might just think you are a Kremlin stooge trying to put people off the scent.

Surely you're not suggesting that Russia "wouldn't do" such a thing, are you? I believe that position was laid to rest along with many citizens of the Georgian city of Gori.

That report comes from raving leftist Amy Goodman and her radio show "Democracy Now." It's not impossible, no -- but the source in this case is highly questionable.

364 BeerDrinking_VictoryMonkey  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:22:58am

re: #356 Kenneth

Actually,
the Cold War never got thermonuclear hot because it was always fought
through proxies. US & Soviet troops never once squared off and
fought.

Unless you count the North Korean pilots in the Korean War who had blonde hair & spoke fluent Russian.

365 Bubblehead II  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:23:16am

re: #330 Ford_Prefect

What happened or dare I ask?

366 pegcity  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:23:30am

re: #364 BeerDrinking_VictoryMonkey

And Vietnam

367 Kenneth  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:23:33am

re: #355 KimZigfeld

Follow your own damn link, maroon. The rumour was planted by the Russians. That story was thoroughly debunked here yesterday. Go look it up yourself.

368 realwest  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:23:36am

re: #354 chukardog
"Who's territory is South Ossetia?" Right now, Russia's. August 5th and before, it was part of Georgia.

369 KimZigfeld  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:23:38am

Former WaPo writer is telling us it's our fault in Georgia and "Putin is not Hitler," giving him advice on how he can take over the country most efficiently.

Yikes.

Didn't they at one time say Hitler wasn't Hitler, and Stalin wasn't Stalin?

370 GreenBear  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:23:47am

re: #347 Boondock St. Bender

If the russians were sooooo concerned with ethnic russians in the area,allow them to emmigrate to russia.after the old soviet union,their must be onclaves of russians in all the former soviet states.whats to stop them from using them as a reason for action anywhere?

Exactly.

Hitler used this little gambit with the Sudetenland, didn't he?

That's all we want. Just let us reunite with our kinsmen in an evil foreign land...

Hogwash.

Putin's got them "crazy eyes" just like old Adolph.

371 Ford_Prefect  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:24:04am

re: #351 realwest

Who was banned and deleted and why?

cutestguy AKA savage_nation

372 BeerDrinking_VictoryMonkey  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:24:32am

re: #363 Charles

That report comes from
Amy Goodman and her show "Democracy Now," which is a raving leftist
site. It's not impossible, no -- but the source in this case is highly
questionable.

It's "Democracy Now!" - except in Iraq, Georgia, Afghanistan, etc., etc., etc.

373 pegcity  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:24:41am

re: #369 KimZigfeld

So is Putin gonna be ubber cool now with the progressives, i mean they seem to love tyrants and dicators.

projection.

374 KimZigfeld  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:25:26am

re: #367 Kenneth

So you're saying the Russians say they have nukes there, and you don't believe them?

Talk about a maroon! Is personal abuse the only way you can deal with life? That's sad, if so. I'd get a dog or something.

Creep.

375 Kenneth  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:25:40am

re: #364 BeerDrinking_VictoryMonkey

Yes, that sort of thing happened... both directions. But there was always at least a slim cover. The US does have some 130 military trainers in Georgia right now. I don't imagine they're sitting on their hands.

376 GreenBear  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:25:51am

re: #360 Tigger2005

See my post #324 above. It seems to me we are already bringing in troops under cover of a "humanitarian mission." Not only are we landing planes and ships at will in Georgia's airports and harbors, we are putting American boots on the ground, right now.

There are also parallels to the Berlin Airlift here. Then, we couldn't, or wouldn't, aid the West Berliners directly. But we didn't abandon them, either.

I think we are in Georgia now, and will stay there. This "we turned tail and ran" stuff is crap.

Cool. Thanks.

Glad to hear it. Nothing dampens Russian vodka bash like GI Joe knocking at the door.

377 Boondock St. Bender  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:26:08am

re: #370 GreenBear

the russians have some trouble at home(double digit inflation or so i hear)nothing like a little bullying in another small country to get the rubes back in line.

378 BeerDrinking_VictoryMonkey  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:26:12am

re: #347 Boondock St. Bender

I
don't matbe because the area was ceded to them when georgia broke away
from the soviet union.the area belongs to them.the russians just can't
redraw the map where and when it suits them.If the russians were sooooo
concerned with ethnic russians in the area,allow them to emmigrate to
russia.after the old soviet union,their must be onclaves of russians in
all the former soviet states.whats to stop them from using them as a
reason for action anywhere?

Don't think that isn't next on their agenda.

379 realwest  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:26:19am

re: #371 Ford_Prefect
HUH? cutestguy was Savage_Nation?

380 Occasional Reader  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:26:31am

re: #355 KimZigfeld

Would it be asking too much for you to source your statement? If this report has been discredited, would you mind linking me to the material?

Because, otherwise, I might just think you are a Kremlin stooge trying to put people off the scent.

Surely you're not suggesting that Russia "wouldn't do" such a thing, are you? I believe that position was laid to rest along with many citizens of the Georgian city of Gori.

It's amazing. You've been registered at LGF for less than 48 hours, and already you've exposed Kenneth as a "Kremlin stooge". Nicely done!

//

Or, you could do your homework. The source for the "nukes in Ossetia" story goes back to "Democracy Now". Raving moonbat leftists? You bet.

381 Dustoff-507  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:27:00am

re: #314 pegcity


I'm sorry not buying. This doom clock has no real bearing now. (not that it ever did)
Yes Russia has nukes, but most of their armed forces are in shambles and nutty as Putin is. An all out war would destory his country.

He's playing a game of poker.

382 Sol Roth  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:27:22am

re: #79 Ben Hur

And I find it amazing that the LLL would support Russia for no other reason than that it makes the US look bad.

No you don't, not really. You and many others here understand the Left as it really is; America and Individualism's mortal enemy. And I do mean mortal, immediate.

383 jcm  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:27:31am

re: #364 BeerDrinking_VictoryMonkey

Or the nearly two dozen US aircraft shot down by the Soviets.

384 Ford_Prefect  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:27:59am

re: #379 realwest

HUH? cutestguy was Savage_Nation?

Looks that way.

385 Dustoff-507  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:28:22am

re: #355 KimZigfeld


Putin may wish to do it, but not yet.

386 GreenBear  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:28:23am

re: #380 Occasional Reader

"Kremlin stooge"

Which one was the "Kremlin stooge"?

I bet it was Shemp.

387 Bubblehead II  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:28:31am

re: #371 Ford_Prefect

Say What? Are you sure?

388 Kosh's Shadow  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:28:49am

re: #345 GreenBear

Very true but same analogy work the other way.

One way to stop a bully is to band together and let him know you won't take his crap. He can't beat everyone up. Russia can't fight them all if they stand together. It's a gamble for sure and a bitter pill, but it's also the price for having your own country: being willing to fight for it. If you don't have the heart to defend your own land, no one else will help you and your national pride is gone.

How about we move all those troops from Germany and western Europe to new bases in eastern Europe where they would be welcomed and appreciated?

The Cold War was relatively uneventful (open hostility speaking) because the US was there to push back when the Soviets pulled some crap. We need to send in some squadrons of A-10 Warthogs and Iraq-seasoned marines for "humanitarian purposes" and see the Russians pull back.

They'll never come to the peace table out of the goodness of their hearts, you know.

Yes, but leaving the Russians in Georgia is the opposite of banding together. It makes it much harder for us to get the team together.

389 BeerDrinking_VictoryMonkey  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:29:00am

re: #381 Dustoff-507

I'm sorry not buying. This doom clock has no real bearing now. (not that it ever did)
Yes
Russia has nukes, but most of their armed forces are in shambles and
nutty as Putin is. An all out war would destory his country.

He's playing a game of poker.

Might not be a good idea to play Texas Hold'em with a real Texan.

390 galloping granny  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:29:02am

re: #340 Tigger2005

Uh, Georgia never willingly signed on to be a province of Russia. Russia forcefully incorporated Georgia into its empire.

Twice.

391 Kenneth  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:29:05am

re: #374 KimZigfeld

You called me a Russian stooge. Frankly, "maroon" is a mild term, I have plenty others if you prefer.

You've been registered here since Aug 12, 2008 at 11:59 am. I've got a damn site better track record for my comments, thank you very much. You show up posting drivel from a moonbat site like it's breaking news. Please.

392 Boondock St. Bender  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:29:44am

re: #374 KimZigfeld

moving nukes into the area would be too provocative for the u.s. to ignore.we would move countering assets to the area.claiming that they are for the protection of u.s. forces/allies in near-by areas.

393 Ford_Prefect  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:29:47am

re: #387 Bubblehead II

Say What? Are you sure?

You can see it all (except his comments) on the Saudi thread.

394 Kenneth  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:29:59am

re: #380 Occasional Reader

She's on to me, OR!

395 Honorary Yooper  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:30:11am

re: #330 Ford_Prefect

You guys just missed a block and delete by Charles on the Saudi thread.

Yeah, it was quite amazing. A massive delete at that!

396 realwest  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:30:13am

re: #382 Sol Roth Indeed. How many times have Dem's crowed about situations where the US was hurt in some way?
I know that they - at least some of them - feel that if it's bad for America, then it's good for them cause if we look bad under a Republican Administration, then the Dem's are thatmuch closer to taking over the WH.

397 jorline  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:31:01am

re: #358 BeerDrinking_VictoryMonkey

LMAO

398 KimZigfeld  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:31:20am

re: #363 Charles

I'm aware of the identity of the source, it's so-stated in my post.

I'm asking for something more than that the source is questionable. Surely there must be a third-party link from a responsible source showing the statement is false.

Frankly, I think we need to make common cause with the left on this one. I doubt we can take down Putin with one arm tied behind our back.

399 Dustoff-507  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:31:48am

re: #389 BeerDrinking_VictoryMonkey


LOL... ok I just shot Pespi out my nose.

400 Honorary Yooper  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:31:59am

re: #337 Kenneth

Maybe, but they would be well on the Russian side of the border. There is a major Russian military base in North Ossetia.

This might be the source of the rumor. I'd imagine the Russians have a decent amount of materiel in North Ossetia at that base.

401 Occasional Reader  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:32:18am

re: #394 Kenneth

She's on to me, OR!

Exactly, Kenneth. Or should I call you "Kennethski"? ! !

402 KimZigfeld  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:32:20am

re: #391 Kenneth

Actually, you are lying. I said I WOULD call you that IF you didn't give me a link.

I implore you to stop lying.

403 realwest  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:32:28am

re: #395 Honorary Yooper A MASSIVE DELETE? What is that - you mean a lot of his comments were deleted?
Can y'all kindly point me to the banning comment, please?

404 BeerDrinking_VictoryMonkey  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:32:32am

re: #397 jorline

LMAO

Thank you, thank you. Wow, what a terrific audience.

405 Boondock St. Bender  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:32:41am

re: #391 Kenneth

yeah,and he's got that cool beaver avatar too!

406 Honorary Yooper  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:32:46am

re: #340 Tigger2005

Uh, Georgia never willingly signed on to be a province of Russia. Russia forcefully incorporated Georgia into its empire.

Not once, but several times. First by the czars, then by the Soviets.

407 Dustoff-507  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:33:12am

re: #391 Kenneth


Kim, best not piss off Kenneth. i hear he eats kids for lunch. (-:

408 GreenBear  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:33:15am

re: #388 Kosh's Shadow

Yes, but leaving the Russians in Georgia is the opposite of banding together. It makes it much harder for us to get the team together.

I agree. Kick their asses all the way back across the border. We can't let them stay in any of the "disputed territories".

Boy that sounds sadly familiar.

Just what we all need, an "South Ossetia Authority".

409 yma o hyd  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:34:13am

re: #347 Boondock St. Bender

I don't matbe because the area was ceded to them when georgia broke away from the soviet union.the area belongs to them.the russians just can't redraw the map where and when it suits them.If the russians were sooooo concerned with ethnic russians in the area,allow them to emmigrate to russia.after the old soviet union,their must be onclaves of russians in all the former soviet states.whats to stop them from using them as a reason for action anywhere?

If Russia isn't stopped right now in Georgia - there would be noting to stop Russia from doing just that to all the other former Soviet states.

410 itellu3times  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:34:33am

re: #374 KimZigfeld

So you're saying the Russians say they have nukes there, and you don't believe them?

I can't imagine *why* they would put nukes there.

411 Dirk Diggler  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:34:44am

Kenneth,

She's on to me, OR!

Hey Savage Nation was just exposed as a moby troll (see next thread). Apparently anything is possible.

412 reine.de.tout  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:34:48am

re: #403 realwest

A MASSIVE DELETE? What is that - you mean a lot of his comments were deleted?
Can y'all kindly point me to the banning comment, please?

All comments by savage_nation and cutestguy have been deleted.
Cutest guy was on the thread following this one; and somehow, Stinky figured out that cutestguy was the same person as savage, and all comments under either name have been deleted.

413 Ford_Prefect  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:34:57am

re: #403 realwest

A MASSIVE DELETE? What is that - you mean a lot of his comments were deleted?
Can y'all kindly point me to the banning comment, please?

"a lot"? Try all.

414 Occasional Reader  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:35:06am

re: #402 KimZigfeld

I said I WOULD call you that IF you didn't give me a link.

"If you don't give me a link proving a negative, I'll call you a 'Kremlin stooge'."

You're right, that's much more reasonable.

415 Sol Roth  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:35:15am

re: #336 Kilroy

As POTUS I believe Obama will be able to unilaterally extinguish our nuclear capabilities and stop current deployment of our antimissile shield.I believe he's basically stated this as his desire.This is total absurdity but seems to be our direction.What can Eastern Europe rely on other than combat hardened French troops?What will we in the US rely on?

Exactly.
[Link: www.americanthinker.com...]

Hey, nothing to see here. Just The Left's Messiah seeking to make us sitting ducks for destruction.

416 KimZigfeld  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:35:43am

re: #392 Boondock St. Bender

I see. So your talking about logic. What "logic" was it that caused Khrushchev to take off his shoe at the UN? What "logic" told Russians to elect a proud KGB spy president?

I think you've not spent enough time with Russia if you think they wouldn't do illogical things.

And how do you know what nukes we are moving? And the Bush administration has been pretty lame so far on Russia, what makes you think our response would be immediate in any case, or that it would be public?

It's one thing to day the report doesn't make sense, quite another to say it's false. I find it disappointing that some (not you my dear) can't tell the difference.

417 Honorary Yooper  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:35:44am

re: #403 realwest

A MASSIVE DELETE? What is that - you mean a lot of his comments were deleted?
Can y'all kindly point me to the banning comment, please?

Not just a lot, all of "cutest guy" and "savage_nation"'s comments got deleted.

418 Bubblehead II  Thu, Aug 14, 2008 10:35:49am

re: #403 realwest

Just went up thread. It started with comment #1

419 jcm