LGF

-RetweetMcCain Photo Fallout at The Atlantic

Politics | Sun, Sep 14, 2008 at 6:48:13 pm PDT

Jeffrey Goldberg wakes up and notices that the leftist craziness The Atlantic has been encouraging has suddenly bitten the magazine on its back side: About that McCain Photo.

Like others at the Atlantic, I was appalled to read about the actions of Jill Greenberg, the freelance photographer who took the cover portrait that illustrates my article about John McCain. Greenberg doctored photographs of McCain she took during her Atlantic-arranged shoot, which took place last month in Las Vegas. She has posted these doctored photographs on her website, which you can go find yourself, if you must. Suffice it to say that her “art” is juvenile, and on occasion repulsive. This is not the issue, of course; the issue is that she betrayed this magazine, and disgraced her profession.

Advertisement

397 comments

  • Comments are open and unmoderated, and do not necessarily reflect the views of Little Green Footballs.
  • Obscene, abusive, silly, or annoying remarks may be deleted, but the fact that particular comments remain on the site in no way constitutes an endorsement of their views by Little Green Footballs.
  • Posts that contain phone numbers, street addresses, email addresses or other personal information will also be deleted, as will posts that consist only of a variation on the word, "First!"
  • Comments that advocate violence will be cause for immediate banning with no appeal.
  • Disagreement and debate are welcome, but insults and abuse are not, and may cause your account to be blocked.
  • REMEMBER: posting comments at LGF is a privilege, not a right. Abuse that privilege, and your account will be blocked.

Hide comments | Jump to bottom

1 Lively  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 6:48:45pm

The rest of America needs to wake up.

2 Lively  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 6:49:08pm

The MSM thinks we're stupid.

3 Lively  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 6:50:03pm

Next they will draw a mustache on Palin and devil horns on McCain for the cover of Time Mag.

4 Lively  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 6:50:13pm

Wow, this is a slow night.

5 BignJames  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 6:50:47pm

What?!? She wasn't vetted?!?

6 rawmuse  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 6:51:07pm

Blowback is a bitch.

7 greengolem64  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 6:51:28pm

No surprise there...

Maybe the MSM is finally getting the message? (yeah...one can only hope)

The Obamanator has been very quiet with TV spots this weekend...

8 RememberSekhmet?  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 6:52:37pm

Under the Bus, Madame Photoshoppe

9 Racer X  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 6:53:07pm

Of course, after McCain wins in November we can resume rounding up all members of the resistance and placing them in detention centers in Nebraska.

/

10 BlueCanuck  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 6:53:18pm

re: #5 BignJames

She probably was, liberal, photographer, okay she's good.

/how did that knife get in my back?

11 Sharmuta  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 6:53:49pm

It's about time some in the media woke up. If you're going to talk the "objective" talk, then you better walk the walk. Because those that don't are going to be hurting after this election- the American people and their awakening is well under way, and alienating your customers is a sure way to go out of business.

12 BlueCanuck  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 6:54:14pm

Anyone see the photoshop she did where she added shark teeth to McCain?

/disgusting.

13 Foldedspace  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 6:54:20pm

I wonder what her raise will be? Maybe a little promotion too.

Actions speak louder than words.

14 jcm  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 6:54:50pm

We have met the enemy and is the media.

(Apologizes to Walt Kelly)

15 zombie  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 6:54:53pm

Next thing you know, they'll be Photoshopping Palin's head on bikini photos!

Oh wait...

16 swamprat  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 6:55:35pm

Shocked! Shocked I tell you!
Can you say " Plausible Deniability? "


I knew you could.
17 David IV of Georgia  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 6:56:06pm

What strikes me as funny is that she thinks I won't notice that she is using an "Alfred Hitchcock" camera angle and lighting. Do I strike you as someone so stupid? Subtle, sly and clever you are not.

18 Ford_Prefect  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 6:56:18pm

It will be intersting to see on what magazine she shows up next. Whichever mag it is will have basically run up the Lib flag and thrown out any pretense of being a true news magazine.

19 Nancy  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 6:56:41pm

My, my, he didn't mince words did he. Good for him!

20 victor_yugo  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 6:57:10pm

re: #15 zombie

Next thing you know, they'll be Photoshopping Palin's head on bikini photos!

Oh wait...

Or McCain's head on bikini photos.

21 Alouette  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 6:57:11pm

FReep is down. FReepers are having withdrawal convulsions. Maybe a little open registration?

22 Sharmuta  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 6:57:26pm

I think some in the media realized the jig was up when US Weekly was given an earful over their treatment of Sarah Palin.

"Wait- you mean you people don't have to buy our product? And you can get by without us? Oh sh*t!"

23 jcm  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 6:57:45pm
24 HelloDare  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 6:58:08pm

Doctored photographs = Bad
Biased reporting = Okay

25 Alouette  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 6:58:49pm

re: #24 HelloDare

Doctored photographs = Bad
Biased reporting = Okay

Doctored photographs = Bad but only if you get caught.

26 JustMyView  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 6:59:01pm

re: #3 Lively

Next they will draw a mustache on Palin and devil horns on McCain for the cover of Time Mag.

I dunno. Her first appearance there seems pretty attractive.

27 Silhouette  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 6:59:05pm

Watch the spin on this one.

They can't deny the story. They can't cover that she hates McCain, tricked him into taking the bottom-lit photo, and photoshopped the ones on her website.

So they'll do the next best thing.

But by focusing on those things, they will convince many people that she did her job correctly for the one shot they used on the cover.

But remember her quote:

She delivered the image the magazine asked for—a shot that makes the Republican presidential nominee look heroic. ...“I left his eyes red and his skin looking bad,” she says.
28 Bubbaman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 6:59:26pm

What's better is the NY Post has picked this up...

What these wackos don't realize is that everytime they act up, thousands of Americans become McCain supporters.

29 CofactorMatrix  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 6:59:26pm

Good gawd, a liberal acting in a childish fashion? Say it ain't true! They're usually such paragons of maturity, those KosKiddie types.

30 victor_yugo  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 6:59:51pm

re: #25 Alouette

Doctored photographs = Bad but only if you get caught.

And biased reporting is okay even if you do get caught

31 JustMyView  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:00:04pm

re: #26 JustMyView
re: #3 Lively

Next they will draw a mustache on Palin and devil horns on McCain for the cover of Time Mag.

I dunno. Her first appearance there seems pretty attractive.

PIMF= Forgot link on previous post.

32 SpartanWoman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:00:53pm

re: #2 Lively

The MSM thinks we're stupid.

And I sent the asshats at the Atlantic a letter informing them that they have lost credibility.

33 victor_yugo  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:01:11pm

re: #31 JustMyView

That still wasn't a link, just boldfaced text.

34 Alouette  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:01:19pm

I dusted off the 'ol Photoshop:

Shieldmatron of Rohan.

35 JustMyView  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:01:26pm

re: #31 JustMyView

re: #3 Lively

Sheeesh! Here's how Palin looked in her first appearance on Time's cover.

36 Sharmuta  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:01:42pm

re: #28 Bubbaman

What's better is the NY Post has picked this up...

What these wackos don't realize is that everytime they act up, thousands of Americans become McCain supporters.

I think the reason behind it is, for the most part, Americans are fair minded people. When we see unfair treatment, we rally behind the underdog.

37 victor_yugo  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:01:43pm

re: #31 JustMyView

Correction: it's a link with no destination.

38 SpartanWoman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:01:45pm

re: #19 Nancy

My, my, he didn't mince words did he. Good for him!

Yeah, but I don't think it's a credible denial

39 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:02:01pm
40 lawhawk  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:02:09pm

She was asked to come up with something for the magazine by the editors, and they are culpable for their actions just as surely the photographer is. He's just pissed that she exposed her bias in such an overt manner.

Still, if the Atlantic was annoyed with her photograph, they wouldn't have run it.

It makes only one group of people look bad - everyone involved in the Atlantic, from the photographer on up to the editors who approved it and the cover.

41 Nancy  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:02:14pm

re: #9 Racer X

Or maybe Alaska has some remote island they aren't using. Like the one just offshore of Russian. Perhaps they will defect.

42 non-lib Nina  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:02:40pm

re: #30 victor_yugo

And biased reporting is okay even if you do get caught

You know they don't care if they get caught (rathergate).

43 SpartanWoman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:02:40pm

re: #40 lawhawk

And his bias too

44 Occasional Reader  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:03:12pm

Okay, Jeffrey. But what about the fact that The Atlantic's cover story on McCain is captioned "Why War Is His Answer" (boo! evil republican warmonger!), while the cover for the magazine's puff piece by Andrew Sullivan on The One was captioned "Why Obama Matters"?

45 Ford_Prefect  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:03:20pm

Well, time for my head to hit the pillow. Good night all. I will see you anon.

46 Sharmuta  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:03:26pm

re: #35 JustMyView

Never mind the insulting title, huh?

48 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:03:37pm
49 Silhouette  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:03:46pm

This is misdirection. They are condemning her photoshops on her website, and condemning the bottom-lit photo.

Making it seem she just misbehaved off-duty or for photos they didn't use. Note this quote: T

he Atlantic opted not to use the distorted McCain shot on its cover, selecting instead a more straightforward portrait. 'We stand by the picture we are running on our cover," said Atlantic editor James Bennet. 'We feel it's a respectful portrait. We hope we'll be judged by that picture.'

They're condemning one sin hoping that it will cover the other worse one. But she admits in the regular photo she left his eyes red and skin looking bad.

50 Racer X  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:04:00pm

Waffles 'n Plugs
or
Maverick and Jugs

Easy choice.

51 Maine's Michael  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:04:15pm

This is very ugly.

She basically ambushed, in the most juveile fashion imaginable, a decent, trusting, and honorable man.

And Charles Gibson disgusts me the more I think about it.

Good natured Sarah Palin, calling him 'Charlie' rein the freindliest manner imaginable, again trsutiong him to be decent and professional.

And he betrays his profession to try and kick her in the teeth.

Thes people have no decency.

We are in for a long and nasty cultural war.

52 SpartanWoman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:04:16pm

re: #44 Occasional Reader

Indeed the fact that Sullivan writes puffery for them tells me that the editors knew perfectly well what Jill was planning. LIARS all

53 Cartman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:04:20pm

Shouldn't somebody on McCain's team insist that all formal photos be approved before publication? Or at least there during the session to determine if there's monkey business going on?

54 rawmuse  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:04:30pm

I am pretty sure that there are some photographers who are not flat-out raving deranged. The mag ought to try to hire one for a change.

55 Sharmuta  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:04:40pm

re: #47 HelloDare

Jill Greenberg is the woman who intentionally makes children cry, takes pictures of them and calls it art.

Why are all those children topless? Is she some sort of pervert?

56 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:04:43pm
57 SagamoreGal  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:04:50pm

O/T - The History Channel's "102 Minutes that Changed the World" is one powerful documentary.

This should be shown every Sept 11 in every classroom throughout the country. I know that won't happen, however, in world controlled by the uber-Marxist NEA.

58 Sharmuta  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:05:06pm

re: #50 Racer X

Stop with the objectifying!

59 Rocko  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:05:19pm

re: #9 Racer X

Of course, after McCain wins in November we can resume rounding up all members of the resistance and placing them in detention centers in Nebraska.

/

Sorry, we don't want them here.

60 J'accuzzi  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:05:45pm

Perhaps they could print The Tale of The Scorpion on the back of their business cards from now on.

61 astronmr20  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:05:55pm

re: #54 rawmuse

I am pretty sure that there are some photographers who are not flat-out raving deranged. The mag ought to try to hire one for a change.

O/T,

Just watched a preview for next season's 24. They were liberally using Clint Mansell's requiem for a dream for the music.

62 JustMyView  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:06:44pm

re: #46 Sharmuta

Never mind the insulting title, huh?

It's hardly a secret that Palin has spent many hours being briefed by various members of McCain's campaign staff, foreign policy experts, and others since she was selected.

63 Colin Nelson  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:06:57pm

The harsh public glare of this willfully deranged act will not be accepted quietly by the American people.

As I type this post, CNN is attempting another smear of Gov Palin over the troopergate thing.

For the first time and after watching US presidential politics for 50 years+ I believe the back room handlers and zealots have lost it, aided and encouraged if not led to these excesses by the MSM.

What is needed is a calm, senior non-political national voice who will denounce this type of anti-democratic incitement before some lunatic acts on the hatred that is in the ascendancy.

64 reine.de.tout  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:07:30pm

re: #47 HelloDare

Jill Greenberg is the woman who intentionally makes children cry, takes pictures of them and calls it art.

That was Jill Greenberg?

I remember seeing those photos awhile back and thought what an awful person it would take to taunt children 'til they cried, just for a photo. Disgusting behavior.

65 Racer X  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:08:00pm

re: #58 Sharmuta

Stop with the objectifying!

Lots of people have them, some are more noticeable. In fact I barely noticed until I saw an old picture of Joe.

66 lawhawk  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:08:12pm

re: #49 Silhouette

Of course, compare and contrast to every photo seemingly taken of Obama, that shows him with a halo.

Old and ugly.

The new hotness.

/seems like a MIB skit...

67 Sharmuta  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:08:20pm

re: #62 JustMyView

It's hardly a secret that Palin has spent many hours being briefed by various members of McCain's campaign staff, foreign policy experts, and others since she was selected.

So that makes it okay to paint her as ignorant and that she needs an education, huh?

68 Tigger2005  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:08:22pm

re: #46 Sharmuta

Never mind the insulting title, huh?

Well, they did have one just like that for Obama.

/Oh, no they didn't.

69 SpartanWoman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:08:27pm

re: #63 Colin Nelson

I think it's too late, the "Obama or ELSE" T-shirts roaming around NYC say it all for me

70 Red Cloud  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:08:29pm

I'd call her a scumbag, but that would be an insult to bags filled with scum.

71 Yankee Division Son  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:08:30pm

I'm Shocked! Shocked I tell you!

/

72 zombie  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:08:54pm

re: #39 buzzsawmonkey

Interview with the Palin bikini photoshopper.

Thanks for that. Bored, left-wing Web mistress. Predictable.

73 RossM3838  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:09:03pm

Doctored photos and forgeries OK if done to people detested by the media. Again, the media are playing a dangerous game here. Dangerous to themselves and dangerous to the nation. If Obama himself gets tied to this kind of fraud he will be in serious trouble and all will backfire on the media.

74 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:09:08pm
75 Red Cloud  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:09:17pm

re: #69 SpartanWoman

I think it's too late, the "Obama or ELSE" T-shirts roaming around NYC say it all for me

Tell them... ELSE.

76 Killian Bundy  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:09:21pm
I was appalled

I'll bet.

/*snicker*

77 Alouette  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:09:25pm

re: #39 buzzsawmonkey

Interview with the Palin bikini photoshopper.

Naomi, you suck!

78 Josephine  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:09:52pm
79 victor_yugo  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:10:12pm

re: #61 astronmr20

O/T,

Just watched a preview for next season's 24. They were liberally using Clint Mansell's requiem for a dream for the music.

Well, it's 24.

80 reine.de.tout  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:10:13pm

re: #62 JustMyView

It's hardly a secret that Palin has spent many hours being briefed by various members of McCain's campaign staff, foreign policy experts, and others since she was selected.

It's hardly a secret that they all get briefed by various experts and advisors. If they didn't, they would be foolish.

81 Alouette  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:10:49pm

re: #51 Maine's Michael


Good natured Sarah Palin, calling him 'Charlie' rein the freindliest manner imaginable, again trsutiong him to be decent and professional.

She called him "asshole" but pronounced it "Charlie."

82 Luigi  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:10:57pm

Unfortunately, what they are doing to Palin and McCain works. Most people are not like us. They get their news from the usual suspects on television and then go about their business. I really don't think McCain can be hurt very much. He's a square peg in a square hole. But Palin is vulnerable because of sexism. She's also vulnerable because of xenophobia. She's sort of a foreigner. This invites the opposition to play on stereotypes. Still, none of this would work if the media were not complicit in the agenda-driven smear campaign.

Each smear they can carry onto the network airtime is like a paper cut against Palin. There will be just some people who believe it. If it were one of two it would not matter very much. But 6 or 7 or 8 or 10 smears later, she is reduced to a dirty word and her polls will suffer. That's probably already happening. Yes, the GOP is a little ahead in the polls today, but they would probably be a lot more ahead if the coverage were evenhanded. You may notice at RCP that MCCain has taken a big lead in the Electoral College count, but only a small lead in the National Average...

[Link: www.realclearpolitics.com...]

I understand that sort of state polling that goes into the Electoral College is nearly a week behind the National Average polling. Perhaps this indicates the actual advantage is waning quickly due to the heavy smear campaign.

We here can hardly believe the smear campaign is working because we see right through it. But I think it is. And I think the backlash, though real, is not quite as significant as we'd like to believe.

Nothing would please me more than to be proved wrong.

83 Silhouette  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:11:04pm

re: #68 Tigger2005

Well, they did have one just like that for Obama.

/Oh, no they didn't.

But the Obama has never had to be briefed by anyone anywhere at anytime. Nor Biden. They were born knowing all and have no advisors.

He only took three days to come up to speed on the Georgia -Russia thing because he was busy healing the earth and receding the ocean.

84 Racer X  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:11:06pm

re: #74 taxfreekiller

Its no secret that Just My View is a full raging commie, having been msm'd life long and lusting for more commie lies to hug at night alone.

I disagree. My perception of JMV is that she wants to believe in Barry, but her brain keeps trying to override. Its why she keeps reading the comments here.

85 SpartanWoman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:11:25pm

re: #75 Red Cloud

Tell them... ELSE.

Sadly they were all bigger than me and sometimes in groups. Me thinks people on the street would side with them

86 reine.de.tout  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:11:34pm

re: #78 Josephine

What the...

She taunted them by offerenig them candy or something, then took it away for the reactions.

87 lummox  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:11:35pm

Leave it me to post on a thread, only for a new thread to pop up.
For your enjoyment , some neomythology.

The pitiful Zero slew the Hildabeast and dreamed he had rendered the genderasp harmless. He returned to his minions to celebrate his supposed triumph. "This victory is the victory we have been waiting for" he proclaimed.

No sooner had their cheers died did they turn to behold the SarahHydra. At the behest of the McC U.S. she was called to battle the minions of ignorance. In their fury, the minions lashed out blindly, attacking the many headed menace, only to find that each time they severed one head, two would grow in its place. In his fear, the Zero removed his gloves (for the fifth time) and attempted to enjoin in battle but the SarahHydra proved elusive. "I will call on the Mediasaurus to battle in my place" Zero thought , but his hopes were in vain. Those who were loathe to support the McC U.S. were rallied and the tide of battle was reversed. The Mediasaurus retreated in disgrace and confusion, their strengthth and power forever diminished.

Return to Illinoisus, Zero, and get your shinebox.

88 victor_yugo  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:11:39pm

re: #64 reine.de.tout

That was Jill Greenberg?

I remember seeing those photos awhile back and thought what an awful person it would take to taunt children 'til they cried, just for a photo. Disgusting behavior.

Worse.

Psychotic.

If that's what she finds aesthetically pleasing, she needs to be in a padded cell somewhere.

89 Killian Bundy  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:11:40pm

CAUTION!

/Obama tongue bath Xing, next 300 comments

90 Tigger2005  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:12:19pm

re: #69 SpartanWoman

I think it's too late, the "Obama or ELSE" T-shirts roaming around NYC say it all for me

Or else what, punks?

Somehow I doubt Obama fans have it in them to strap on a suicide vest, much less undertake an armed revolution.

91 Josephine  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:12:29pm

re: #55 Sharmuta

Why are all those children topless? Is she some sort of pervert?

Clothing might distract the viewer from the child's distress and draw the eye away from the beauty of it all.

/

92 Thanos  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:12:47pm

Expect even more unhinged madness as Barry's polls slide, this is going to be a fun election folks. Hold on to your hats.

/on the other hand I do kind of like the bottom lit photo a little bit... that's how I want Putin picturing McCain.

93 BignJames  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:12:51pm

re: #89 Killian Bundy

Seen your bud Sal today?

94 oh_dude  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:12:58pm

What's that old line about laying down with dogs?

95 SpartanWoman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:12:59pm

re: #88 victor_yugo

Worse.

Psychotic.

If that's what she finds aesthetically pleasing, she needs to be in a padded cell somewhere.

We don't use padded cells, not very hygenic. We go with cinder block.

96 Josephine  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:13:04pm

re: #86 reine.de.tout

She taunted them by offerenig them candy or something, then took it away for the reactions.

What a nasty piece of work.

97 JustMyView  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:13:12pm

re: #80 reine.de.tout

It's hardly a secret that they all get briefed by various experts and advisors. If they didn't, they would be foolish.

True, but, in her case, they are starting from a little further back.

98 WarBicycle  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:13:27pm

I think it is safe to assume her career is ruined.

99 reine.de.tout  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:13:34pm

re: #81 Alouette

She called him "asshole" but pronounced it "Charlie."

LOL. I like the way you think . . .

100 Racer X  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:14:04pm

re: #92 Thanos

Expect even more unhinged madness as Barry's polls slide, this is going to be a fun election folks. Hold on to your hats.

/on the other hand I do kind of like the bottom lit photo a little bit... that's how I want Putin picturing McCain.

Expect things to get really, really nasty as Obama continues to slide. McCain picked exactly the right PERSON to weather this storm.

101 SpartanWoman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:14:10pm

re: #98 WarBicycle

I think it is safe to assume her career is ruined.

Probably not, she'll be a celeb in NYC and get lots of gigs

102 David IV of Georgia  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:14:10pm

re: #91 Josephine

Clothing might distract the viewer from the child's distress and draw the eye away from the beauty of it all.

/

It makes me wish I could do something tangible, perhaps physical, to show my appreciation of this beauty...

103 victor_yugo  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:14:11pm

re: #91 Josephine

Clothing might distract the viewer from the child's distress and draw the eye away from the beauty of it all.

/

And another thing about this Greenburg nutcase...

104 jcm  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:14:12pm

re: #89 Killian Bundy

CAUTION!

/Obama tongue bath Xing, next 300 comments

No, just Obamacat!

105 SummerSong  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:14:18pm

Betrayed, eh?

*Yawn*

106 Tigger2005  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:14:27pm

re: #98 WarBicycle

I think it is safe to assume her career is ruined.

Oh, no. She's a shoo-in at the New York Times.

107 Sharmuta  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:14:34pm

re: #82 Luigi

When you have a poll being conducted by the Minneapolis Star Tribune showing 0bama losing a 12 point lead, and the state is even- from the Star Tribune- known for jacked polling and favoring liberals in their sample- then you have to know that McCain is doing well. Minnesota hasn't been red since Nixon.

108 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:15:01pm
109 PSGInfinity  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:15:44pm
"This is not the issue, of course; the issue is that she betrayed this magazine, and disgraced her profession."

No, the issue is you played footsie with deranged infrahuman monsters, and are reaping the whirlwind. And to think I used to subscribe to what I considered the finest opinion magazine on the newsstand.

Michael Kelley, and all the good ones before him are ashamed and appalled at what you've become.

Begone vile filth!

110 reine.de.tout  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:15:52pm

re: #97 JustMyView

True, but, in her case, they are starting from a little further back.

And you positive that is correct . . . how?

111 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:16:02pm
112 JustMyView  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:16:13pm

re: #67 Sharmuta

So that makes it okay to paint her as ignorant and that she needs an education, huh?

The cover doesn't say anything about her being ignorant, but I think if you are spending every available moment learning things you didn't know before, it's safe to say that's what's going on is education--and thank goodness for it. Of course, since neither of us has read the article, we don't really know what they had to say about her. I only pointed out the cover because lively said that Palin would probably have horns when she first appeared on the cover of TIME.

113 Occasional Reader  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:16:16pm

re: #62 JustMyView

It's hardly a secret that Palin has spent many hours being briefed by various members of McCain's campaign staff, foreign policy experts, and others since she was selected.

Yeah, it's amazing how Obama was just born knowing all this stuff.

114 HelloDare  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:16:19pm

Jill Greenberg answers the critics who claim she abuses toddlers in the name of art

Your images have certainly caused an uproar. What do you say to people who call you a child abuser?
I think they're insane. I know the comment you're talking about. I don't know what the guy's personal problems are. I don't think he's got kids. I have a two-and-a-half-year-old daughter, and she cries for no reason, a hundred times a day. It's normal. Maybe getting kids to cry isn't the nicest thing to do, but I'm not causing anyone permanent psychological damage.

How many kids did you shoot altogether?
Around 35. Some were the children of friends, plus my own daughter; others came from the Ford or Jet Set model agencies. Kid models aren't very expensive—not as expensive as monkeys, for example.

How did you get the kids to cry?
Mostly we did it by giving them something, a lollypop, and then taking it away. Some would just cry for no reason—my daughter did that; she didn't like standing on the apple box I used for a platform because it was a little wobbly. Some just wouldn't cry at all. For all the kids I worked really fast. We would book 12 or so for one day, and see who we could make cry. At the end of the day I was not in a good mood. I don't like making little kids cry.

The lighting is very dramatic. How did you accomplish that?
It's the same lighting I used for my portraits of monkeys, and I've been using it for some recent magazine cover portraits. It's really flattering frontal light, so the subject doesn't have to have any actual shine on his or her skin to appear shiny. None of the kids had any makeup on. And also I work on that shiny quality in postproduction.

How did you come up with the idea for the project?
I saw this little girl who'd come to a party with her mom, and she was beautiful, so I thought it might be interesting to photograph her. When they came to my studio, the mother brought along her toddler son, and I decided to shoot him too. We took off his shirt because it was dirty. He started crying on his own, and I shot that, and when I got the contact sheets back I thought, "This could go with a caption, 'Four More Years,'" like he was appalled at George Bush's reelection. The images have a real power—they immediately get under your skin. The emotion you see is just so compelling, yet they're beautiful at the same time. That was one of the things that interested me about the project—the strength and beauty of the images as images. I also thought they made a kind of political statement about the current state of anxiety a lot of people are in about the future of the country. Sometimes I just feel like crying about the way things are going.

115 victor_yugo  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:16:22pm

re: #101 SpartanWoman

Probably not, she'll be a celeb in NYC and get lots of gigs

A half-page ad in the Post, with a screenshot of the Google results, will take care of that. Just add the quote from #47 above:

Jill Greenberg is the woman who intentionally makes children cry, takes pictures of them and calls it art.

116 Silhouette  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:16:24pm

A nice little insult at McCain thrown in at the end by Goldberg.

Every so often, journalists become deranged at the sight of certain candidates, and lose their bearings. Why, this has even happened in the case of John McCain once or twice. What I find truly astonishing is the blithe way in which she has tried to hurt this magazine.

He can understand hating McCain, but he is most upset, not at attacking McCain or at a member of the press intentionally trying to manipulate a US Presidential election, albeit rather impotently, but that it hurts the magazine.

At least he has his priorities straight.

117 Nancy  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:16:43pm

re: #96 Josephine

I guess I would be asking what kind of parent would subject their child to be used like that in the name of "art?"

118 Alouette  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:17:06pm

re: #72 zombie

Thanks for that. Bored, left-wing Web mistress. Predictable.

I mean, really, what is the big accomplishment of photoshopping somebody's head on to somebody else's body? It takes less than a minute, once you find the photos you want to use.

119 WinstonChurchill  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:18:12pm

Now she can go back to her former job of drawing a d**k and b*lls on advertisements in the subway.

120 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:18:24pm
121 Ojoe  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:18:36pm
122 Killian Bundy  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:18:53pm

re: #93 BignJames

Seen your bud Sal today?

Nope.

13) Staring at a Screen Darkly
The advent of the Internet recombines the abolition of space-time barriers to communication with the constant and instant availability of (potentially) practically all textual knowledge, as computer aided design and computer assisted manufacture threaten to leave the proletariat with little beyond bourgeois leisure and a subsistence stipend. The underclass will be known not as the unwashed, but as the unwired. With every computer terminal a samizdat, governments (and religions) will progressively lose their ability to tell the big lies and make them stick (see Zapatista). Guerilla semioticians will increasingly 'poach' the icons and symbols of governmental, religious and corporate institutions and imbue them with different and frequently subversive meanings (The Practice of Everyday Life, Michel de Certeau, 1984). Authority will issue not from age, race, gender or status, but from the internal consistency, logical cogency, linguistic clarity and external coherence of one's positions. Spoken and written language forms will continue vanishing as quickly as endangered species, as informational selection takes its Darwinian toll. The hegemony of employment over location will melt away as more and more jobs can be performed from anywhere with power and a telephone line. Global democracy will supersede multiple national sovereignties as humanity's attachments to borders and boundaries will shrink along with their relevance to the lives of an increasingly individually sovereign citizenry (as Francis Fukuyama foresaw in The End Of History, 1992). The policy debates now occurring within electronic 'town meetings' will be settled by cyber-votes. The Human Genome Project will allow human beings to genetically know themselves (Socrates and Hippocrates would be pleased) and to re-engineer their codes to remove textual errors (inherited defects). If they like the result, genocopies (clones) will be possible, and there is already talk of exploiting the shared binary codes of computer language and the double helix to create DNA computers. The meme will then have traveled full circle, finding its way back to the gene. In the coming millennium, homo sapiens will be both weavers of and woven by, for better or for worse, the informational warp and communicational weft of a co-evolutionary New Web Order.

/he only comes out for evolution threads

123 Alouette  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:19:00pm

re: #114 HelloDare

If this woman photographed my grandkids, her teeth would look like John McCain's, the ones she had left.

124 victor_yugo  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:19:22pm

re: #116 Silhouette

A nice little insult at McCain thrown in at the end by Goldberg.

He can understand hating McCain, but he is most upset, not at attacking McCain or at a member of the press intentionally trying to manipulate a US Presidential election, albeit rather impotently, but that it hurts the magazine.

At least he has his priorities straight.

Yes, just like imams rebuking terrorists because they damage the image of Islam.

125 Sparkizzy  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:19:49pm

Her website address is "manipulator.com"

Calling Sigmund Freud...

126 PSGInfinity  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:19:52pm

re: #59 Rocko

Sorry, we don't want them here.

How about tossing them, along with the molesters, on one of the uninhabited Aleutian Islands? Nice and secure, jobs and tax money for Alaska, chew toys for the diddlers, and the occasional volcanic eruption to spice things up. What's not to like?

127 Cartman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:20:22pm

re: #98 WarBicycle

I think it is safe to assume her career is ruined.

I doubt it. In fact, I'm sure she's being privately applauded for this by her peers, and by most who might commission her work.

128 Tigger2005  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:20:26pm

I thought everyone hated Bush because he was, you know, all inarticulate, and a cowboy, and dumb, but also an evil genius. I thought that was where BDS came from. But now we have PDS and McDS, and they appear to be even more virulent. Thank goodness the majority of the people seem to be immune.

129 Sharmuta  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:21:29pm

re: #112 JustMyView

The cover doesn't say anything about her being ignorant

I think it's you who is ignorant.

130 Who Watches the Watchmen?  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:21:35pm

re: #78 Josephine

What the...

... is wrong with that ...

131 SpartanWoman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:21:46pm

re: #115 victor_yugo

A half-page ad in the Post, with a screenshot of the Google results, will take care of that. Just add the quote from #47 above:

Jill Greenberg is the woman who intentionally makes children cry, takes pictures of them and calls it art.

You're too optimistic. NYT is full of sterile cuckoos lie Maureen Dowd who probably begrudge the existence of children at all. I picture her as the Vulgarian Countess in Chitty-Chitty- Bang Bang

133 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:22:03pm
134 Who Watches the Watchmen?  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:22:31pm

re: #94 oh_dude

What's that old line about laying down with dogs?

You wake up as a registered Democrat?

135 Old Guy  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:22:53pm

OT--This is for TFK--the answer to your question about the song "smoke, smoke, smoke" that cigarette was by Phil Harris, either late 1940's or early fifties--I have the record.

136 BlueCanuck  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:23:04pm

re: #122 Killian Bundy

/he only comes out for evolution threads

And after the sun goes down. I noticed that he only posts after the sun is down and usually only on the dead threads.

/hhmmm, Think I am onto something here.

137 SpartanWoman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:23:34pm

re: #127 Cartman

I doubt it. In fact, I'm sure she's being privately applauded for this by her peers, and by most who might commission her work.

Including the editor at the Atlantic who is toying with being sorry and outraged and is probably laughing his asshat off

138 Josephine  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:23:41pm

re: #117 Nancy

I guess I would be asking what kind of parent would subject their child to be used like that in the name of "art?"

I'm shaking my head.

Who is that nuts? And that mean?

Who would put it on a wall?

Imagine them sending it out with their "seasonal celebration" card or yearly family newsletter.

Who would they leave it to in their will? Would that be the long-awaited time when the child is finally able to destroy it and put that childhood demon to rest?

139 Pawn of the Oppressor  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:23:41pm

re: #98 WarBicycle

I think it is safe to assume her career is ruined.

Never. For every one person who's annoyed by her childish idiocy, there's another person somewhere on the East Coast who has a good laugh and talks about what a hero she is over their latte.

140 astronmr20  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:23:50pm

re: #121 Ojoe

The gloaming. September 14, 2008, Pacific time zone, San Gabriel Mountains, California. (Towercam.)


These views will continue after November.

..and still no sun spots. We are in for a very cold several decades...

141 PSGInfinity  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:23:59pm

re: #69 SpartanWoman

I think it's too late, the "Obama or ELSE" T-shirts roaming around NYC say it all for me

Seriously?!

142 victor_yugo  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:24:25pm

re: #131 SpartanWoman

You're too optimistic. NYT is full of sterile cuckoos lie Maureen Dowd who probably begrudge the existence of children at all. I picture her as the Vulgarian Countess in Chitty-Chitty- Bang Bang

Screw them. That's why I said "the Post" and not "the Times".

143 SouthAmericanWay  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:24:29pm

Goldberg's not "appalled" at all. They're only disappointed that this lady has outed them for what The Atlantic has become: a partisan pamphlet, undoing 150 years of great literary achievements and mostly balanced political commentary.

144 ted  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:24:35pm

This was monstrous. This scum Greenberg deliberately tried to make a man look bad complexionwise who survived 4 bouts of melanoma ...the deadliest form of skin cancer. And she admitted it.

Unbelievably sick.

145 Nancy  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:24:40pm

re: #107 Sharmuta

Michigan has been solid blue for a long time as well and it's now "neutral" grey--a toss up.

McCain has lost NO solid reds that he started with and has gained some that were leaning.

But Obama is losing some that have been solid blue that are now only leaning blue and others that have gone to neutral and a couple that are even now leaning red.

He is in trouble. He isn't holding on to his solid blue states much less picking up the weaker blues or neutrals.

146 Killian Bundy  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:25:18pm

re: #136 BlueCanuck

And after the sun goes down. I noticed that he only posts after the sun is down and usually only on the dead threads.

/hhmmm, Think I am onto something here.

/Bomb 20

147 SpartanWoman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:25:23pm

re: #141 PSGInfinity

Seriously?!

Very seriously. All bright with the colors of Pan-African unity

148 Mich-again  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:25:38pm

Found this out there.

When PDNPulse asked Greenberg if she had any reservations about accepting the photography assignment – which originally was to create a shot that made McCain look heroic – given her political leanings, she pleaded caveat emptor, buyer beware.

"I didn't," she said. "It's definitely exciting to shoot someone who is in the limelight like that. I am pretty hard-core Democrat. Some of my artwork has been pretty anti-Bush, so maybe it was somewhat irresponsible for (the Atlantic) to hire me."

Greenberg also told PDNPulse that she's considered altering the photo to replace McCain's mouth with bloody shark teeth and posting the image on a billboard, depicting the candidate as a bloodthirsty warmonger.

149 ted  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:25:56pm

re: #125 Sparkizzy

Her website address is "manipulator.com"

Calling Sigmund Freud... Thorazine 1000mg

150 Cartman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:26:11pm

re: #122 Killian Bundy

Where did that come from?

151 livefreeor die  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:26:16pm

re: #114 HelloDare

She is a freaking loon. And a sadistic, insensitive mother.

152 EIDE_Interface  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:26:17pm

Did anyone see the photoshop she did showing McCain looking like a zombie freak with gore on his fangs?

153 Dewie  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:26:21pm

I would think that Atlantic would have some recourse here...
This is more than just a freshman stunt on her part.

154 Josephine  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:27:12pm

re: #136 BlueCanuck

Thank you for making me laugh.

Now I can calm down (after reading about sharia in England and a nasty photographer who demeans patriots and makes babies cry) and go to bed.

Good night, folks.

155 hermeneutics  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:27:14pm

I like the Atlantic -- a good read. After this, though, I'll read it in the library or at the bookstore, but never buy it.

156 Alouette  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:27:18pm

re: #152 EIDE_Interface

Did anyone see the photoshop she did showing McCain looking like a zombie freak with gore on his fangs?

Projection.

157 SpartanWoman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:27:20pm

re: #149 ted

Her website address is "manipulator.com"

Calling Sigmund Freud... Thorazine 1000mg

Dose is a little high, but so what!

158 Sharmuta  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:27:36pm

re: #145 Nancy

Exactly- and even if those states end up going for him- he now has to spend money there to retain them instead of focusing that money on swing states or leaning states to turn them to him.

159 Tigger2005  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:27:38pm

re: #140 astronmr20

..and still no sun spots. We are in for a very cold several decades...

Maybe the Muslims will decide it's too damn cold for them, and go home.

160 Thanos  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:28:01pm

On the other hand the right has it easy. We don't have to use special lighting or have to doctor anything to make the Left's candidate look bad, Reality Speaks for itself.

161 jcm  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:28:04pm

re: #140 astronmr20

..and still no sun spots. We are in for a very cold several decades...

The Goracle spoke, the sun has squat to do with it...
///

162 PSGInfinity  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:28:08pm

re: #98 WarBicycle

I think it is safe to assume her career is ruined.

I don't. Enough derangement in the ad industry that she'll not only find work, she'll be a cause celebre...

163 SpartanWoman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:28:25pm

re: #153 Dewie

I would think that Atlantic would have some recourse here...
This is more than just a freshman stunt on her part.

Recourse? You mean you believe this nonsense about being fooled and blind-sided?

164 JustMyView  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:28:47pm

Here's the link to Greenberg's profile of McCain--in case you want to see how he is portrayed there.

165 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:28:51pm
166 LoFlyer  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:28:52pm
167 victor_yugo  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:28:59pm

re: #138 Josephine

I'm shaking my head.

Who is that nuts? And that mean?

Who would put it on a wall?

Imagine them sending it out with their "seasonal celebration" card or yearly family newsletter.

Who would they leave it to in their will? Would that be the long-awaited time when the child is finally able to destroy it and put that childhood demon to rest?

I would question the fitness of any parents who would subject their kids to that kind of treatment for a fast buck.

168 gman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:29:04pm

re: #125 Sparkizzy

Her website address is "manipulator.com"

Calling Sigmund Freud...

manipulator.com speaks for itself.

The Atlantic knew exactly what they were buying.

169 lifeofthemind  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:29:13pm

This is like bad out takes from The Sweet Smell of Success.

The Editor spoke strongly to some here but to me he just sounded like a guy trying to keep his job.

170 hermeneutics  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:29:15pm

re: #158 Sharmuta

Exactly- and even if those states end up going for him- he now has to spend money there to retain them instead of focusing that money on swing states or leaning states to turn them to him.

Hi Sharm!~

Don't the polls look beautiful? And Intrade. Republicans supposedly poll lighter on weekends (having families and all that) so we'll see if the numbers go up on Monday.

So many tracking polls ... so little time.

171 ted  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:29:22pm

re: #157 SpartanWoman

Dose is a little high, but so what!

Im a shrink...She'll handle it.

172 PSGInfinity  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:29:23pm

re: #106 Tigger2005

Oh, no. She's a shoo-in at the New York Times.

Editorial Page fill-in, no less..

173 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:29:34pm
174 RTLM  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:29:48pm

/I am appalled as well.

175 Killian Bundy  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:29:59pm

re: #150 Cartman

Where did that come from?

/MySpace

176 Pawn of the Oppressor  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:30:08pm

re: #141 PSGInfinity

Seriously?!

I heard about that here too... Will have to ask NYC Ex the next time politics comes up.

I was planning on telling her to take two days off right after the election, in case Emperor Zero loses and his "supporters" in various riot-prone cities decide to take it out on The Man***.

***in this case, The Man is "anybody white, well-dressed, with a good job, over the age of 25", and she is all of the above.

177 dentate  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:30:10pm

re: #121 Ojoe

The gloaming. September 14, 2008, Pacific time zone, San Gabriel Mountains, California. (Towercam.)


These views will continue after November.

I am fortunate enough to live at the base of those mountains, down to the right of the picture. I can see that observatory out the window every day. You quickly become accustomed to such things and forget how beautiful they are. Thank you for reminding me.

178 Ojoe  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:30:27pm
179 hermeneutics  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:30:42pm

There has to be a way McCain can use his photoshopped image in a political ad.

180 victor_yugo  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:30:54pm

re: #152 EIDE_Interface

Did anyone see the photoshop she did showing McCain looking like a zombie freak with gore on his fangs?

You mean... zombie is really McCain?

And he chomps Al Gore for a mid-morning snack?

My respect for McCain/zombie just reached a new high.

181 hermeneutics  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:31:22pm

re: #177 dentate

I am fortunate enough to live at the base of those mountains, down to the right of the picture. I can see that observatory out the window every day. You quickly become accustomed to such things and forget how beautiful they are. Thank you for reminding me.

You are blessed.

182 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:31:29pm
183 Nancy  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:31:32pm

Bet the Governor of Alaska can help Jill Greenburg find a REAL Grizzly bear instead of those stuffed ones!

184 JustMyView  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:31:53pm

re: #164 JustMyView

Here's the link to Greenberg's profile of McCain--in case you want to see how he is portrayed there.

PIMF = Goldberg's profile, not Greenberg

185 Cognito  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:31:55pm

Schadenfreude.

186 jcm  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:32:40pm

re: #164 JustMyView

Here's the link to Greenberg's profile of McCain--in case you want to see how he is portrayed there.

The issue isn't the ARTICLE. Or did you skip what Goldberg said, Like others at the Atlantic, I was appalled to read about the actions of Jill Greenberg, the freelance photographer who took the cover portrait that illustrates my article about John McCain. The issue is the PHOTOGRAPH.

187 Occasional Reader  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:32:49pm

re: #160 Thanos

On the other hand the right has it easy. We don't have to use special lighting or have to doctor anything to make the Left's candidate look bad, Reality Speaks for itself.

That's quite a damning video clip.

Obama looks like he can barely wait to get out of there.

188 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:32:50pm
189 Mich-again  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:32:57pm

re: #114 HelloDare

Terminal BDS inspired her to take those photos.

Greenberg's End Times, a series of photographs featuring toddlers, was the subject of controversy in 2006. The work featured stylized hyper real closeups of children's faces contorted by various emotional distresses. The pieces were titled to reflect Greenberg's frustration with both the Bush administration and Christian Fundamentalism in the United States. The method for getting the children to cry (achieved by offering the children candy and suddenly taking it away) spurred allegations of unethical conduct and provoked the submission of numerous complaints to the art gallery that hosted a public showing of Greenberg's work.[2] [3]
190 EIDE_Interface  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:33:15pm

re: #180 victor_yugo

You mean... zombie is really McCain?

And he chomps Al Gore for a mid-morning snack?

My respect for McCain/zombie just reached a new high.

*2 thumbs up*

The Atlantic is in the toilet. BTW, Andrew Sullivan has nothing to say about this. He's gone completely batshit insane if you read his latest posts. Where is the incisive political analyst that he used to be? He can only rage and shake his fist now.

191 syndicate  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:33:24pm

Jill Greenberg is a disgrace to all photographers. I hope she is never hired again and is forced to live out the rest of her life working in a cubicle.

Her previous work with animals and babies is contrived, boring and all looks the same. She is a hack and now the rest of the world will see her for what she is.

192 LoFlyer  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:33:29pm

re: #121 Ojoe

The gloaming. September 14, 2008, Pacific time zone, San Gabriel Mountains, California. (Towercam.)


These views will continue after November.

Ojoe, it looks like they rotated the Dome!

193 Sharmuta  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:33:39pm

re: #170 hermeneutics

The polls do look beautiful. I must say, the star tribune poll shocked me because I've spoken to someone who used to work in their polling apparatus, and he confirmed to me that their sample is off kilter. If a poll like the star tribune is showing a long time blue state being tied- it's not looking good for 0bama.

Let the msm do thier worst. I still say it's in the American nature to rally behind the one being bullied.

194 Shug  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:33:51pm

re: #185 Cognito

Schadenfreude.

I don't think so

195 hermeneutics  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:34:00pm

re: #178 Ojoe

The sun today. Not many spots.

The sun looks like molten metal.

196 EIDE_Interface  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:34:18pm

re: #195 hermeneutics

The sun looks like molten metal.

Globular clusters?

197 jcm  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:35:00pm

re: #193 Sharmuta

The polls do look beautiful. I must say, the star tribune poll shocked me because I've spoken to someone who used to work in their polling apparatus, and he confirmed to me that their sample is off kilter. If a poll like the star tribune is showing a long time blue state being tied- it's not looking good for 0bama.

Let the msm do thier worst. I still say it's in the American nature to rally behind the one being bullied.

WA is play also now.

198 EIDE_Interface  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:35:06pm

I wonder if the worst of these photos(like the zombie one) will make the MSM rounds... If they do I believe Obama is completely sunk.

199 Mich-again  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:35:10pm

re: #191 syndicate

It will be interesting to see how she weathers this controversy. Its not like she's a nobody.

Greenberg has done commercial work for corporations such as Phillip Morris, Microsoft, Compaq, Polaroid, Dreamworks, Sony Pictures, Paramount Pictures, MGM, Disney, Fox, Coca Cola, Pepsi, Smirnoff, MTV, Warner Bros., Sony Music, and Atlantic Records. Her photos have appeared on the covers of Time Magazine, TV Guide, Newsweek, US News and World Report, Wired, Entertainment Weekly and numerous other publications.[1]

200 hermeneutics  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:35:15pm

re: #193 Sharmuta

The polls do look beautiful. I must say, the star tribune poll shocked me because I've spoken to someone who used to work in their polling apparatus, and he confirmed to me that their sample is off kilter. If a poll like the star tribune is showing a long time blue state being tied- it's not looking good for 0bama.

Let the msm do thier worst. I still say it's in the American nature to rally behind the one being bullied.

You'd think the Star Tribune would be able to get a viable sample in their own backyard.

201 stevieray  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:35:20pm

re: #135 Old Guy

OT--This is for TFK--the answer to your question about the song "smoke, smoke, smoke" that cigarette was by Phil Harris, either late 1940's or early fifties--I have the record.

Smoke, Smoke, Smoke That Cigarette

202 fat.elvis  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:35:20pm

I'm sure someone's said it already but I'm in advertising and have known about this photographer for years and she seemed nasty and abrasive last article I read about her. She basically got famous taking photos of babies crying -- babies she MADE cry. (By giving them lollipops and taking them away is the one she would admit to.) She sounds really pleasant.

203 musicman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:35:32pm

Anyone mention the banner across the upper left-hand corner of the Atlantic?

Catch a glimpse here.

It reads "Is pRon Adultery?" on a red corner banner.

204 Cartman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:35:45pm

re: #175 Killian Bundy

That there's some disturbing shit!

205 Silhouette  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:35:52pm

The classic villain with the Snydly Whiplash mustache in cartoons is always taking candy away from a baby, causing the baby to cry.

This woman actually does this, but somehow feels she is the one out fighting evil in the world.

If she can just get rid of those Christians and that president who keeps freeing nations from slavery...

206 LoFlyer  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:35:54pm

re: #161 jcm

The Goracle spoke, the sun has squat to do with it...
///

Like sustaining all life on Earth?

/Buy more Gore carbon credits! They don't mean jack, but it makes you feel good! Al is laughing all the way to the bank...

207 EIDE_Interface  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:36:34pm

re: #197 jcm

WA is play also now.

I hope so. I can't stand these liberal loonies that "represent" me. McDermott, Gregoire, Murray, Cantwell. Although McDermott is not my congresscritter he's a HUGE embarrassment the entire Puget Sound region.

208 jcm  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:36:48pm

re: #206 LoFlyer

Like sustaining all life on Earth?

/Buy more Gore carbon credits! They don't mean jack, but it makes you feel good! Al is laughing all the way to the bank...

Buy Soylent Carbon Green!

209 Mich-again  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:36:52pm

Imagine the outrage if a photographer took a picture of Obama with lighting and background that made only his eyes and teeth visible.

210 HelloDare  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:37:10pm

re: #195 hermeneutics

The sun looks like molten metal.

Impossible. Rosie O'Donnell says fire can't molt metal.

211 Fat Bastard Vegetarian  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:37:21pm

Her assignments will probably decrease.

Just guessing.

G'night folks.

212 Sharmuta  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:37:25pm

re: #200 hermeneutics

You'd think the Star Tribune would be able to get a viable sample in their own backyard.

It's not that they can't- it that they skew their samples intentionally towards the democrats. So for me, if the strib says MN is tied, it's probably leaning McCain.

213 Killian Bundy  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:37:26pm

re: #200 hermeneutics

You'd think the Star Tribune would be able to get a viable sample in their own backyard.

They could.

/if they wanted to

214 hermeneutics  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:37:49pm

re: #196 EIDE_Interface

Globular clusters?

To me, globular clusters look like white dots gathered against a black background. In the sun pic, perhaps the globular clusters could be seen as dotting the surface of the sun like little bright areas on its orange molten surface (as opposed to the dark ones of sunspots).

I am not a scientist. Duh.

215 wright1  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:37:52pm

Living in the Tri-State, all news is slanted Obama-mania and McCain & Palin = foolishness. I tell myself, it is ok, this is just New Jersey - the rest of the countrydoes not read the New York Times, or listen to Jonathan Alter on a Sunday Morning purported News show, or listen to Tom Brokaw spin Tim Russert in his grave by quoting Donna Brazille's accusation that to accuse Obama of being a C.O., is to miss that J.C. was one as well. That made me ill. And that the rest of the country does not know what some washed out Air America has been is spewing, or that the so called serious piece on "Joe Biden" on the Clinton News Network forgot to mention that the reason he dropped out of the pres. race was essentially for plagiarism, or that John McCain is computer illiterate despite all evidence to the contrary...Yes, I am from N.J. but II have faith in the rest of this country that the ill winds that blow in this socialist part of out nation do not transcend into other more noble areas of the country. Because frankly, it is really depressing reading the headlines where I live despite the fact that the Emperor, Lord Obama has no clothes.

216 livefreeor die  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:37:59pm

re: #205 Silhouette

The classic villain with the Snydly Whiplash mustache in cartoons is always taking candy away from a baby, causing the baby to cry.

This woman actually does this, but somehow feels she is the one out fighting evil in the world.

If she can just get rid of those Christians and that president who keeps freeing nations from slavery...

She's a classic, deranged liberal. It's all about what she feels and anything she does to express her feelings is okay (including mentally torturing children). Actually, the children she photographed were probably more mature than her.

217 PSGInfinity  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:38:15pm

re: #200 hermeneutics

You'd think the Star Tribune would be able to get a viable sample in their own backyard.

Nope. BDS, or should we say Reality Derangement Syndrome (RDS)?

218 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:38:18pm
219 jcm  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:38:32pm

re: #207 EIDE_Interface

I hope so. I can't stand these liberal loonies that "represent" me. McDermott, Gregoire, Murray, Cantwell. Although McDermott is not my congresscritter he's a HUGE embarrassment the entire Puget Sound region.

I'm in that weird bump in N. King Co. Jay Inslee, not a lot better.

220 lummox  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:38:35pm

This one's shaping up like Mondale / Ferraro.

221 HelloDare  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:38:54pm

I'd like to take a picture of Jill Greenberg crying when McCain wins the election.

222 EIDE_Interface  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:39:06pm

re: #215 wright1

Living in the Tri-State, all news is slanted Obama-mania and McCain & Palin = foolishness. I tell myself, it is ok, this is just New Jersey - the rest of the countrydoes not read the New York Times, or listen to Jonathan Alter on a Sunday Morning purported News show, or listen to Tom Brokaw spin Tim Russert in his grave by quoting Donna Brazille's accusation that to accuse Obama of being a C.O., is to miss that J.C. was one as well. That made me ill. And that the rest of the country does not know what some washed out Air America has been is spewing, or that the so called serious piece on "Joe Biden" on the Clinton News Network forgot to mention that the reason he dropped out of the pres. race was essentially for plagiarism, or that John McCain is computer illiterate despite all evidence to the contrary...Yes, I am from N.J. but II have faith in the rest of this country that the ill winds that blow in this socialist part of out nation do not transcend into other more noble areas of the country. Because frankly, it is really depressing reading the headlines where I live despite the fact that the Emperor, Lord Obama has no clothes.

Obama is only leading in Jersey by +6 on the RCP average if that's any consolation.

223 Fat Bastard Vegetarian  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:39:09pm

By the way...again...

I liked the photo.

224 Ojoe  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:39:21pm

re: #177 dentate

I grew up in the San Gabriel Valley, and since I don't live there anymore, I set the Towercam page to be my default internet opener.

Usually I post a link her at sunrise and sunset.

Glad you like it.

225 Killian Bundy  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:39:24pm

re: #204 Cartman

That there's some disturbing shit!

/Oh, there's more, just ask him for it, that's what I did

226 Who Watches the Watchmen?  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:39:38pm

re: #135 Old Guy

OT--This is for TFK--the answer to your question about the song "smoke, smoke, smoke" that cigarette was by Phil Harris, either late 1940's or early fifties--I have the record.

Abraham DeLacey Guiseppe Casey Thomas O'Mally, the alley cat

227 EIDE_Interface  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:39:54pm

re: #219 jcm

I'm in that weird bump in N. King Co. Jay Inslee, not a lot better.

Fortunately Sheriff Reichert is my congresscritter. Still a RINO, but infinitely better then Ditzy Darcy.

228 EIDE_Interface  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:40:13pm

re: #220 lummox

This one's shaping up like Mondale / Ferraro.

Lets not get arrogant.

229 ted  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:40:26pm

re: #218 taxfreekiller

the msm is dead, just smell if you dare

Yes...and they helped BHO lose.

230 Ojoe  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:40:27pm

re: #192 LoFlyer

I think that is a subsidiary telescope.

231 hermeneutics  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:40:36pm

re: #212 Sharmuta

It's not that they can't- it that they skew their samples intentionally towards the democrats. So for me, if the strib says MN is tied, it's probably leaning McCain.

Wouldn't their poll, then, get a reputation for inaccuracy? I've seen polling firms get rated on accuracy, though they usually only use the final poll and compare it to election data. Perhaps they're fudging the data now and will be more straightforward and honest later?

232 Typicalwhitey  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:40:44pm

WTF?

RCP:
McCain 47.4
Obama 45.5
+2.1 McCain

Kos website:
McCain 45
Obama 47
+2 Obama

Who does he think he is kidding?
His poll shows a swing of 4 points to Obama?

233 LoFlyer  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:40:47pm

re: #209 Mich-again

Imagine the outrage if a photographer took a picture of Obama with lighting and background that made only his eyes and teeth visible.

Reminds me of "black-face" comedy. Not P/C. Negative stereotyping of a minority is not allowed. Go to the back of the line and prepared to be sued by "community activists".

234 cybermonk  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:40:56pm

re: #79 victor_yugo

filmed mostly in South Africa and features a woman president

235 Biff  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:41:38pm

This is a battle for the future of America. It is a battle between those who want to conserve and preserve the Horace Greely vision and the American Judeo-Christian culture and ethic, and those who seek change by moving towards global parity. Unfortunately, the latter hope means that we, as Americans, lose.

236 JustMyView  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:41:46pm

re: #186 jcm

The issue isn't the ARTICLE. Or did you skip what Goldberg said, Like others at the Atlantic, I was appalled to read about the actions of Jill Greenberg, the freelance photographer who took the cover portrait that illustrates my article about John McCain. The issue is the PHOTOGRAPH.

I understand. My point was that there is more to The Atlantic's treatment of McCain than this photograph. I think you would find the article interesting. It's all about McCain's ideas on national security.

237 lifeofthemind  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:41:49pm

If The Atlantic doesn't sue her for breach of contract and loss of reputation then won't they will be admitting complicity and possible liability on the magazine's part?

238 hermeneutics  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:42:37pm

re: #221 HelloDare

I'd like to take a picture of Jill Greenberg crying when McCain wins the election.

smiling here.

239 Archimedes  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:42:41pm

I saw the flash video at her website. Yeah, I pretty much know what she "thinks" of McCain.

[Link: manipulator.com...]

240 Cartman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:42:50pm

re: #225 Killian Bundy

I don't think I wanna go there. I've spent the past year working on a mini-restoration of my sanity. I don't wish to undo it all in one fell swoop. ;)

241 lawhawk  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:43:00pm

For those tracking polls, it looks like NJ is going to remain solidly in the Blue. The Record ran a poll and it shows Obama comfortably ahead.

I looked at the underlying split of d/r/i, and it matches my impression of the state's political makeup - generally D, with a large I contingent. GOP makes up a smaller portion, which makes it more difficult for a GOPer to gain traction here. Palin didn't do much to convince independents that she's their kind of woman.

242 Sharmuta  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:43:02pm

re: #231 hermeneutics

When Jesse Ventura ran for Governor, the last poll before the election had him in dead last with the democrat candidate winning. I would hope they've improved their sample since then, but who knows. It's just my hunch that McCain might actually be leading slightly if the strib has it tied.

243 kynna  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:43:11pm

They've done it to others. Remember Mark Warner and the cover of the NY Slimes magazine?

They'll do anything to get what they want. They can lie about it later.

Sadly, it works.

244 hermeneutics  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:43:22pm

re: #232 Typicalwhitey

WTF?

RCP:
McCain 47.4
Obama 45.5
+2.1 McCain

Kos website:
McCain 45
Obama 47
+2 Obama

Who does he think he is kidding?
His poll shows a swing of 4 points to Obama?

Kos has a +9 sample of Dems.

245 cliffster  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:43:52pm

re: #228 EIDE_Interface

Lets not get arrogant.

Lots of time to go. Lots of wacko outspoken right-wing crazies for the media to sniff out. Victory comes the day after election day, or later. Until then, we have to do everything we can to bring victory home..

246 Cognito  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:44:02pm

re: #186 jcm

The issue isn't the ARTICLE. Or did you skip what Goldberg said, Like others at the Atlantic, I was appalled to read about the actions of Jill Greenberg, the freelance photographer who took the cover portrait that illustrates my article about John McCain. The issue is the PHOTOGRAPH.

Just out of curiosity, what is it you don't like about that photograph?

247 EIDE_Interface  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:44:16pm

Fellow Lizards:

I'm more convinced then ever that this election is a battle between good and evil. The left has taken off their mask and the American people are finally seeing the true ugliness under that mask. It's too late for the left to put the moderate mask back on, genie out of the bottle. However, we MUST capitalize on this by making sure we keep on the attack.

248 Mich-again  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:44:30pm

I think it is very telling that Jill Greenberg took lollipops away from babies to get the kids to make crying faces to shows her contempt for George Bush.

Perfect really.

249 Larry L. Sharp  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:44:37pm

She is better suited for taking pictures of hemorrhoid flare ups at Folsom Street Fair and Up Your Alley in San Francisco.

250 Killian Bundy  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:44:38pm

re: #232 Typicalwhitey

WTF?

RCP:
McCain 47.4
Obama 45.5
+2.1 McCain

Kos website:
McCain 45
Obama 47
+2 Obama

Who does he think he is kidding?
His poll shows a swing of 4 points to Obama?

Take all polls with an unfortunate, yet real, grain of salt, just like in the primaries.

/Bradley effect

251 victor_yugo  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:45:06pm

re: #209 Mich-again

Imagine the outrage if a photographer took a picture of Obama with lighting and background that made only his eyes and teeth visible.

Ben Vereen did almost that in Pippin.

252 Mich-again  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:45:09pm

re: #237 lifeofthemind

I doubt that. She has a long history of being a deranged Bush hater. They knew that going in.

253 Nancy  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:45:19pm

re: #158 Sharmuta

Plus as I roughly calculate it from various figures released today for the August fundraising and what they each had on hand the end of July --Barry is going to have to raise ANOTHER 100,000 million just to match McCain and the RNC.

But even if he matches McCain, Obamas administrative costs -staff, advisors, rent etc. are DOUBLE McCains. Either he has to cut down on staff to save money or he isn't going to have enough for the the last couple weeks advertising.

I guess the DNC doesn't have that much in their coffers.

He will probably raise it but for the really big bucks he is going to have to make an appearance. And fundraisers are "preaching" to the choir so he isn't out getting votes.

He has already spent twice as much as McCain.

254 LoFlyer  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:45:25pm

re: #215 wright1

Living in the Tri-State, all news is slanted Obama-mania and McCain & Palin = foolishness. I tell myself, it is ok, this is just New Jersey - the rest of the countrydoes not read the New York Times, or listen to Jonathan Alter on a Sunday Morning purported News show, or listen to Tom Brokaw spin Tim Russert in his grave by quoting Donna Brazille's accusation that to accuse Obama of being a C.O., is to miss that J.C. was one as well. That made me ill. And that the rest of the country does not know what some washed out Air America has been is spewing, or that the so called serious piece on "Joe Biden" on the Clinton News Network forgot to mention that the reason he dropped out of the pres. race was essentially for plagiarism, or that John McCain is computer illiterate despite all evidence to the contrary...Yes, I am from N.J. but II have faith in the rest of this country that the ill winds that blow in this socialist part of out nation do not transcend into other more noble areas of the country. Because frankly, it is really depressing reading the headlines where I live despite the fact that the Emperor, Lord Obama has no clothes.

I haven't watched TV in weeks. Many Americans have learned to rely on Internet for faster, accurate news. I only keep my cable because I love the sports play-offs. The only unscripted entertainment in the world. I'll take a good bowl game over anything Hollywood can do...

255 Pawn of the Oppressor  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:45:27pm

re: #215 wright1

the rest of the country does not

And that's the plain truth.

There are the Left Coasts, and then there is Everybody Else. The Left Coasties only know about each other, and don't believe that anybody else matters.

We don't have jobs, we don't have health insurance***, we don't do anything productive for this country or any other, we all have sex with our relatives, we're poor (but not the noble, Holy Brown Community-To-Be-Organized kind of poor), we talk funny, we deserve to die when disaster strikes, nobody does anything between California and NYC except grow corn, smoke meth, fuck our sisters, drive pickups, and watch NASCAR. We can all go to hell and die because we're what stands between the Noble Enlightened Ones of the coasts and the glorious future of Utopian Happiness that they're always just one more election away from realizing.

Politics is the sum of human dysfunction, and they're just as big a bunch of fucked-up suckers and dupes as any, but they will never, ever be able to admit it to themselves, or anybody else, because they're too SMART to be lied to, see? The attitude re-inforces itself.

Trust me, I grew up in Massachusetts, I know how these people see the world.

256 EIDE_Interface  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:45:42pm

re: #241 lawhawk

For those tracking polls, it looks like NJ is going to remain solidly in the Blue. The Record ran a poll and it shows Obama comfortably ahead.

I looked at the underlying split of d/r/i, and it matches my impression of the state's political makeup - generally D, with a large I contingent. GOP makes up a smaller portion, which makes it more difficult for a GOPer to gain traction here. Palin didn't do much to convince independents that she's their kind of woman.

Palin shouldn't waste time in New Jersey or New York.

257 lawhawk  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:45:49pm

re: #232 Typicalwhitey

The only poll that matters is the general election in November. Everything else is just fun with numbers... they're informative, and if DKos wants to make it appear that McCain is down, that's fine by me... use it as incentive to get out and make sure Obama never gets in the WH except as a visitor.

258 hermeneutics  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:45:53pm

re: #242 Sharmuta

When Jesse Ventura ran for Governor, the last poll before the election had him in dead last with the democrat candidate winning. I would hope they've improved their sample since then, but who knows. It's just my hunch that McCain might actually be leading slightly if the strib has it tied.

Didn't Ventura run against Coleman, the same guy that's running now against Al Franken?

259 dentate  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:46:01pm

re: #224 Ojoe

Arcadia here. There is nothing like driving the Angeles Crest Highway and coming over the south rim of the San Gabriels, with the LA Basin and the Pacific stretched out in front of you. Thanks for bringing that page to my attention.

260 Cartman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:46:03pm

re: #246 Cognito

Just out of curiosity, what is it you don't like about that photograph?

Now you're being contrary once again, for its own sake. Sheesh.

261 PSGInfinity  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:46:20pm

re: #237 lifeofthemind

If The Atlantic doesn't sue her for breach of contract and loss of reputation then won't they will be admitting complicity and possible liability on the magazine's part?

Yes

262 nyc redneck  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:46:20pm

re: #86 reine.de.tout

She taunted them by offerenig them candy or something, then took it away for the reactions.

only the left wouldn't consider that child abuse.

263 Cognito  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:46:49pm

re: #260 Cartman

Now you're being contrary once again, for its own sake. Sheesh.

What can I say. I'm curious.

264 Dahveed  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:46:55pm

I was going to say that Jeffrey Goldberg was a stand-up guy for saying what he did about the sick photos. But I am curious if there wasn't already pressure on the media for their treatment of the Republican candidates, if he would have said anything at all. No one but he could know the answer to that.

I want to take him at his word, but the mainstream media has made its position all too clear in this election. I will have to see more evidence of contrition by the people of The Atlantic before I truly feel that they are sorry for this.

265 SpartanWoman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:46:58pm

re: #260 Cartman

Now you're being contrary once again, for its own sake. Sheesh.

Why even respond?

266 lawhawk  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:47:05pm

re: #256 EIDE_Interface

I happen to agree... they could gain PA, OH, IN, WI, and grab CO and do what's expected elsewhere to win.

267 Ojoe  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:47:07pm

re: #247 EIDE_Interface

It is good vs. evil for sure if you ask me

"punished with a baby" ; Abortion "rights"

vs.

Life begins at conception

& I carried my downs baby to term

268 EIDE_Interface  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:47:10pm

re: #257 lawhawk

The only poll that matters is the general election in November. Everything else is just fun with numbers... they're informative, and if DKos wants to make it appear that McCain is down, that's fine by me... use it as incentive to get out and make sure Obama never gets in the WH except as a visitor.

If polls don't matter, then why were conservatives panicking a month ago? Come on, the state polls DO matter since it's about the electoral college.

269 Cognito  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:47:21pm

re: #265 SpartanWoman

Why even respond?

It's a legitimate question. What about the cover portrait is offensive?

270 Nancy  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:47:27pm

re: #189 Mich-again

Again, doesn't the responsiblity lie with the parents who allowed their children to be used that way? A parent must have given her permission to do it.

271 hermeneutics  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:47:29pm

re: #250 Killian Bundy

Bradley effect ... I know it is supposed to mean voters lying to pollsters because they're closet racists, but in this election voters are lying to pollsters because they're AFRAID of being called racists.

272 Pawn of the Oppressor  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:47:58pm

About my asterisks in 255

***actual quote from somebody close to me when I was talking about moving back down to TX: "Do they have health insurance in Texas?"

"No, you get issued a bottle of whiskey. If you get shot in a street gunfight, you disinfect the wound with it, and then you drink what's left to dull the pain."

/OK, I didn't say that at the time - I thought of it later.

273 reine.de.tout  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:48:03pm

re: #246 Cognito

Just out of curiosity, what is it you don't like about that photograph?

It's a matter of what the photographer did . . .

274 jcm  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:48:23pm

re: #227 EIDE_Interface

Fortunately Sheriff Reichert is my congresscritter. Still a RINO, but infinitely better then Ditzy Darcy.

Reichert definitely disappointed, I hoped for better. I know one thing, he's a straight shooter I don't agree with him on a bunch of things, but I can respect his reasoning.

275 Cartman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:48:28pm

re: #265 SpartanWoman

Why even respond?

What can I say. I'm curious.

;)

276 EIDE_Interface  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:48:39pm

I don't think the Bradley effect counts for more then 1 point. The real big news story is that white women are deserting Obama in droves.

277 wright1  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:48:57pm

re: #222 EIDE_Interface


I have already played that game in other elections where I think maybe just maybe Florio will not win, or McGreevy will not or Corzine, or Bush will take N.J. but alas it does not happen. That is all ok as long as the Prez goes to, in this case, John McCain and Sarah Palin!

278 Tigger2005  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:48:58pm

re: #257 lawhawk

The only poll that matters is the general election in November. Everything else is just fun with numbers... they're informative, and if DKos wants to make it appear that McCain is down, that's fine by me... use it as incentive to get out and make sure Obama never gets in the WH except as a visitor.

In a tour group, not by invitation, I hope.

279 reine.de.tout  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:49:12pm

re: #262 nyc redneck

only the left wouldn't consider that child abuse.

Well, she sure didn't. It was despicable and it goes against every instinct of a good and loving parent to treat children that way.

280 Cognito  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:49:12pm

re: #273 reine.de.tout

No. I didn't ask that.

He said,

The issue isn't the ARTICLE. Or did you skip what Goldberg said, Like others at the Atlantic, I was appalled to read about the actions of Jill Greenberg, the freelance photographer who took the cover portrait that illustrates my article about John McCain. The issue is the PHOTOGRAPH.

So I'm asking what about the Atlantic's photograph is so offensive.

281 PSGInfinity  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:49:13pm

re: #248 Mich-again

I think it is very telling that Jill Greenberg took lollipops away from babies to get the kids to make crying faces to shows her contempt for George Bush[, decency and humanity].

Perfect really.

FTFY!

282 Mich-again  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:49:23pm

re: #246 Cognito

Just out of curiosity, what is it you don't like about that photograph?

If it scares Europeans and moonbats I am all for it. But I repeat myself.

283 tee866  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:49:23pm

I've said since O won the bid that in Nov. everyone better have lot's of supplies on hand because I think things are going to get ugly if he loses, and the more I see these nut jobs the more I think I'm right.

284 newsjunkie_ky  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:49:36pm
285 JHW  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:49:40pm

Jill Greenberg and her photo shoots making children cry ... I wonder if there are any other aspects of the Aztec religion she looks to for inspiration.

Tlaloc, the Aztec God

To appease this god, the Aztec people would offer up human sacrifices; in Tlaloc’s case it was usually children. The priest would however, would collect the tears of these young terrified victims as an additional offering. He would sometimes make them cry more through tortures like pulling out their nails. The tears were seen as rain, so the more they cried the better the season of rainfall. Parents saw the sacrifice of their children as an honor; other children were those taken captive from outside villages. Whichever the case, the important thing was to keep Tlaloc happy. By doing so, they believed they were provided the rains to produce healthy crops. Anyone who died from drowning, dropsy, lightning or anything else associated with water was thought to pass on to a place called Tlacocan, the paradise of fertility in the tallest mountain where Tlaloc lived and clouds were formed.
286 EIDE_Interface  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:50:06pm

re: #277 wright1

I have already played that game in other elections where I think maybe just maybe Florio will not win, or McGreevy will not or Corzine, or Bush will take N.J. but alas it does not happen. That is all ok as long as the Prez goes to, in this case, John McCain and Sarah Palin!

What can I say... Move to a red state or at least a purple one.

287 FightingBack  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:50:45pm

re: #114 HelloDare

What? She intentionally caused her infant distress by standing her on a wobbly surface? They cry 100x per day? Where? Not in my family.
This is making me sick.

288 LoFlyer  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:51:04pm

re: #247 EIDE_Interface

Fellow Lizards:

I'm more convinced then ever that this election is a battle between good and evil. The left has taken off their mask and the American people are finally seeing the true ugliness under that mask. It's too late for the left to put the moderate mask back on, genie out of the bottle. However, we MUST capitalize on this by making sure we keep on the attack.

Noam and I discussed the issue of McCain's sincerity and Obama refusing to discuss his political ideology this afternoon. We are both convinced that this is Obama's weakness. Obama cannot reveal his true ideology because few in America will vote for a Marxist...

289 reine.de.tout  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:51:28pm

re: #280 Cognito

No. I didn't ask that.

He said,

So I'm asking what about the Atlantic's photograph is so offensive.

McCain's skin is pasty looking and his eyes are red, and she took the photos in a such a way to deliberately play up his age.

Other than that . . . nothing, I guess.

290 Tigger2005  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:51:36pm

re: #280 Cognito

No. I didn't ask that.

He said,

So I'm asking what about the Atlantic's photograph is so offensive.

Some find the photograph itself offensive. Others don't mind if certain people look at it and think McCain is one crazy scary mofo. But everyone is offended by the unprofessionalism and deception Jill Greenberg employed to get the photograph in the first place.

291 PSGInfinity  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:51:37pm

re: #271 hermeneutics

Bradley effect ... I know it is supposed to mean voters lying to pollsters because they're closet racists, but in this election voters are lying to pollsters because they're AFRAID of being called racists.

THIS

292 EIDE_Interface  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:51:54pm

re: #288 LoFlyer

Noam and I discussed the issue of McCain's sincerity and Obama refusing to discuss his political ideology this afternoon. We are both convinced that this is Obama's weakness. Obama cannot reveal his true ideology because few in America will vote for a Marxist...

How many Americans know he has the most liberal voting record in the Senate? He's wearing a moderate mask. McCain is ripping off that mask with his cutting ads.

293 Syrah  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:52:19pm

re: #283 tee866

I've said since O won the bid that in Nov. everyone better have lot's of supplies on hand because I think things are going to get ugly if he loses, and the more I see these nut jobs the more I think I'm right.

I am stocking up on Chocolate and Tequila.

294 Mich-again  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:52:20pm

re: #270 Nancy

Again, doesn't the responsiblity lie with the parents who allowed their children to be used that way? A parent must have given her permission to do it.

I'm guessing the parents were there and in on it. Probably all moonbat parents with BDS as well.

"Look, I'm making a series of photographs of crying children to protest the evil Bush administration. Can I use your kid?"

"Sure, that would be great!

295 drpangloss  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:53:06pm

The one answer is: stop buying Atlantic and US magazine. Tell the advertisers too!

Make the 2008 election the end of MSM

296 Cognito  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:53:24pm

re: #289 reine.de.tout

McCain's skin is pasty looking and his eyes are red, and she took the photos in a such a way to deliberately play up his age.

Other than that . . . nothing, I guess.

Thanks. I didn't see that in the photograph at all -- you really think John McCain looks younger in life, than in that photo? -- but that's a perfectly legitimate criticism.

297 reine.de.tout  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:53:33pm

re: #290 Tigger2005

Some find the photograph itself offensive. Others don't mind if certain people look at it and think McCain is one crazy scary mofo. But everyone is offended by the unprofessionalism and deception Jill Greenberg employed to get the photograph in the first place.

Thank you. It would seem to me that folks with a connection to the media would be able to put two and two together without having a gajillion folks explain it to them.

298 Nancy  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:53:50pm

I am not defending the photographer. Only the parents are responsible for allowing it.

SOME adult, who has the responsibility to protect the child, is giving their permission for the child to be teased that way by another adult who they think is just going to take their photo.

Talk about betrayal!

299 Syrah  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:54:24pm

re: #295 drpangloss

The one answer is: stop buying Atlantic and US magazine. Tell the advertisers too!

Make the 2008 election the end of MSM

I haven't bought one of those magazines in over 15 years.

When is the last time you bought one?

300 lifeofthemind  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:54:25pm

re: #284 newsjunkie_ky

This is being passed off as a McCain ad but it is not.


That needs to be flagged it uses McCains endorsement that may be copyright theft, it certainly is fraud.

301 livefreeor die  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:54:35pm

re: #287 FightingBack

What? She intentionally caused her infant distress by standing her on a wobbly surface? They cry 100x per day? Where? Not in my family.
This is making me sick.

I know, the insensitivity of her reaction to her child's distress and her capitalizing on it make me ill. As a mom, the last thing I want to do is make my child cry. And I sure wouldn't be letting her anywhere near my kids for one of her little photo shoots.

I'd love to hear her own children's take on her in twenty years.

302 stuck in california  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:54:48pm

Would the GOP send Palin to NJ if their polls said it would be a waste of time and money? Just asking...

303 JustMyView  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:54:56pm

re: #215 wright1

. . . the so called serious piece on "Joe Biden" on the Clinton News Network forgot to mention that the reason he dropped out of the pres. race was essentially for plagiarism . . .

Did we watch the same hour-long piece, the one that was running back-to-back w/ the show about Palin? The one I watched certainly made clear that it was the plagiarism charges that drove him out of the race.

304 reine.de.tout  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:55:03pm

re: #296 Cognito

Thanks. I didn't see that in the photograph at all -- you really think John McCain looks younger in life, than in that photo? -- but that's a perfectly legitimate criticism.

No, he does not look younger than that.
I actually think the photo looks like a real person, unlike Obama and his halos.

But I'm not a real sophisticated person, and a person sophisticated in the ways of professional photographers would probably think she could have done a better job.

She didn't, and it was on purpose.

305 PSGInfinity  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:55:08pm

re: #288 LoFlyer

Noam and I discussed the issue of McCain's sincerity and Obama refusing to discuss his political ideology this afternoon. We are both convinced that this is Obama's weakness. Obama cannot reveal his true ideology because few in America will vote for a Marxist...

I'm with you and Noam. His "uhs" are where he's trying to formulate an answer that appeases the "rubes" while containing a reassuring 'wink' to the kewl kidz. We are very lucky he took off four-eight years too soon. By 2016, 2020 at the latest, he'd have it down cold...

306 musicman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:55:32pm

re: #280 Cognito

No. I didn't ask that.

He said,

So I'm asking what about the Atlantic's photograph is so offensive.

The photograph used for the magazine is not the issue. It's the other photographs that were taken at the same time by the photographer and then photoshopped. Most photographers give their clients all the photos that were taken. They are the property of the magazine. That's the way I read it.

307 RJ77  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:55:49pm

I believe Marxist filth like her should be deported to Mexico, along with about 12 million others, on January 2009.

308 EIDE_Interface  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:55:59pm

re: #302 stuck in california

Would the GOP send Palin to NJ if their polls said it would be a waste of time and money? Just asking...

A bit of Palin-fu to put NJ in the GOP column... Her powers are ungraspable...

309 reine.de.tout  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:56:00pm

re: #296 Cognito

Thanks. I didn't see that in the photograph at all -- you really think John McCain looks younger in life, than in that photo? -- but that's a perfectly legitimate criticism.


And, that's not what I said.

310 capitalist piglet  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:56:19pm

re: #21 Alouette

FReep is down. FReepers are having withdrawal convulsions. Maybe a little open registration?


Oh God, no. Please, no.

311 Nancy  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:56:43pm

re: #276 EIDE_Interface

And even more than women --one of the polls found that MEN overwhelmingly --around 58% --both Democrat and Republican would chose Palin for president over ALL the other 3!

So much for the myth that men do not like strong women!

312 Cognito  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:56:47pm

re: #306 musicman

The photograph used for the magazine is not the issue.

Exactly.

They are the property of the magazine.

No, they're not.

313 EIDE_Interface  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:56:57pm

No open registration! We have a very nice community here free of awful trolls.

314 EIDE_Interface  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:57:59pm

re: #311 Nancy

And even more than women --one of the polls found that MEN overwhelmingly --around 58% --both Democrat and Republican would chose Palin for president over ALL the other 3!

So much for the myth that men do not like strong women!

The simple math of this election is if McCain can win 56% of the male vote and 50% of the female vote he wins. He's getting very close to 50% female vote if not there already.

315 FightingBack  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:58:02pm

re: #294 Mich-again

What what she said about the Agency, most (parents) got money.
Disgusting.

316 SpartanWoman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:58:23pm

re: #302 stuck in california

Would the GOP send Palin to NJ if their polls said it would be a waste of time and money? Just asking...

No. And NJ has been known to elect GOP Governors, so it seems like a good move. I know plenty of McCain voting PUMAs who'd love to see Gov. Palin

317 FightingBack  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:59:00pm

re: #315 FightingBack

What what she said about the Agency, most (parents) got money.
Disgusting.

I'm so furious, I can't even type straight.

318 Archimedes  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 7:59:40pm

The art one chooses, or, even more so, renders tells you much more about a person's soul than almost anything else. Jill Greenberg must have a very dark soul judging by her work here.

319 musicman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:00:41pm

re: #312 Cognito

No, they're not.

I am only referring to what I read here


It's a question, you see, of the disposition of all the McCain "out-takes" from this shoot. Out-takes are images taken of a subject at a photo shoot that are not used for publication by the client commissioning them. Typically, when you hire a photographer for a shoot -- and I have hired dozens over the years -- the photographer delivers all the film or digital images taken to the editor and art director for their review and selection. In a professional shoot these can easily be dozens if not hundreds of images.
320 Syrah  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:00:49pm

re: #316 SpartanWoman

No. And NJ has been known to elect GOP Governors, so it seems like a good move. I know plenty of McCain voting PUMAs who'd love to see Gov. Palin

Palin has put the Dems on the Defensive. If New Jersey is at all close, forcing the Dems to spend money somewhere they thought they could ignore is good for our side.

Make them pay to play.

321 JustMyView  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:00:56pm

re: #264 Dahveed

I was going to say that Jeffrey Goldberg was a stand-up guy for saying what he did about the sick photos. But I am curious if there wasn't already pressure on the media for their treatment of the Republican candidates, if he would have said anything at all. No one but he could know the answer to that.

I want to take him at his word, but the mainstream media has made its position all too clear in this election. I will have to see more evidence of contrition by the people of The Atlantic before I truly feel that they are sorry for this.

Goldberg is a center-right guy, a strong Zionist. I think you can take him at his word. After all, McCain agreed to a long interview with him, knowing that it would be a cover story in a major magazine. He wouldn't have done that if he hadn't expected sympathetic treatment. Again, the article is online. check it out.

322 wright1  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:01:14pm

re: #303 JustMyView

Did we watch the same hour-long piece, the one that was running back-to-back w/ the show about Palin? The one I watched certainly made clear that it was the plagiarism charges that drove him out of the race.

No - I saw a different piece - it was devoid of that story.

323 FightingBack  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:01:14pm

re: #318 Archimedes

The art one chooses, or, even more so, renders tells you much more about a person's soul than almost anything else. Jill Greenberg must have a very dark soul judging by her work here.

I'll show her dark. Filthy child abuser.

324 Biff  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:01:45pm

McCain and Palin should spend every Saturday for the rest of the campaign going to college football games at Penn State, Pitt, Ohio State, Michigan, Michigan State, Minnesota, Indiana, Colorado, North Carolina, and New Mexico - sometimes two in one day.

325 Silhouette  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:01:50pm

It is offensive that a national publication hired a photographer, in theory both of whom are supposed to safeguard and ensure the democratic process, but who intentionally made McCain look worse than she would have made a candidate look whom she supported. A weak attempt but an attempt nonetheless to manipulate a US Presidential election, if 'only' by presenting an unattractive picture. And then laughing/bragging about it.

It is irrelevant how successful or unsuccessful one thinks she was by looking at the cover shot. Dan Rather tried to manipulate an American election and was called out, but that doesn't mean he still isn't an asshole because he failed.

326 RememberSekhmet?  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:02:54pm

re: #72 zombie

Thanks for that. Bored, left-wing Web mistress. Predictable.

So, can we photoshop Naomi in the Supermodelsfart picture with Michael Moore?

327 Big Boots that's BOOTS  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:03:36pm

Goldberg: 'We feel totally blind-sided,' he said. 'Her behavior is outrageous. Incredibly unprofessional.'

doubtful that he/they were caught by surprise. She has a history that shows she hated bush & since mccain is just another bush to her...

328 capitalist piglet  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:03:37pm

re: #69 SpartanWoman

I think it's too late, the "Obama or ELSE" T-shirts roaming around NYC say it all for me


Tell me you're kidding. Are there really "Obama or ELSE" t-shirts out there?

329 EIDE_Interface  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:03:39pm

re: #325 Silhouette

It is offensive that a national publication hired a photographer, in theory both of whom are supposed to safeguard and ensure the democratic process, but who intentionally made McCain look worse than she would have made a candidate look whom she supported. A weak attempt but an attempt nonetheless to manipulate a US Presidential election, if 'only' by presenting an unattractive picture. And then laughing/bragging about it.

It is irrelevant how successful or unsuccessful one thinks she was by looking at the cover shot. Dan Rather tried to manipulate an American election and was called out, but that doesn't mean he still isn't an asshole because he failed.

The history texts will have a special section for 2008 called "The Historic Ugliness of the American Left-Wing in the 2008 Presidential Election".

330 lifeofthemind  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:04:05pm

re: #284 newsjunkie_ky

This is being passed off as a McCain ad but it is not.

Reported it at johnmccain.com and multiple reports to them might get faster action.

331 ugetwhatuputout  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:04:19pm

I'm just sitting back and watching these hateful and overtly malicious acts and I wait for all to unfold. Individuals and groups cannot operate like this and expect something good to come back to them. They choose to use this hate as a tool and I am finding peace knowing that they are going to get that hate planted right back in their laps.

332 Archimedes  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:04:37pm

re: #325 Silhouette

It is offensive that a national publication hired a photographer, in theory both of whom are supposed to safeguard and ensure the democratic process, but who intentionally made McCain look worse than she would have made a candidate look whom she supported. A weak attempt but an attempt nonetheless to manipulate a US Presidential election, if 'only' by presenting an unattractive picture. And then laughing/bragging about it.

Yeah, the cover picture isn't very flattering either. I've seen many photos of McCain where he looks better than that, just snap shots taken by amateurs.

333 Syrah  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:05:25pm

re: #319 musicman

It would depend on the contractual arrangements.

If the Photographer stipulated that only a license for use was being sold, the Photographer still owns the photographs. If the Atlantic stipulated that they would own, or bought all rights to the photographs, they would belong to the Atlantic.

334 EIDE_Interface  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:05:33pm

re: #332 Archimedes

Yeah, the cover picture isn't very flattering either. I've seen many photos of McCain where he looks better than that, just snap shots taken by amateurs.

Lighting. Deliberately putting his face in a shadow. Subliminal message = McCain is sinister.

335 ploome hineni[deleted]  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:05:51pm
336 Archimedes  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:05:52pm

She's not really an artist, in that she renders the entire image. Rather, she takes pictures and photoshops them in various ways.

337 FightingBack  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:06:19pm

re: #332 Archimedes

I took a snap of W once. He looked intelligent and compassionate. I sent it to his Mother.

338 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:06:56pm
339 Alouette  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:07:13pm

re: #321 JustMyView

Goldberg is a center-right guy, a strong Zionist.

He is a fucking anti-Zionist who threw Israel under the bus.

340 musicman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:07:34pm

re: #333 Syrah

It would depend on the contractual arrangements.

If the Photographer stipulated that only a license for use was being sold, the Photographer still owns the photographs. If the Atlantic stipulated that they would own, or bought all rights to the photographs, they would belong to the Atlantic.

That gets out of my league. I was only going on what I read from the American Digest article.

341 Nancy  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:07:50pm

re: #327 Big Boots that's BOOTS

I am not so sure they were not caught by surprise. The hiring of the photographer may well be done by the art or layout department not by the editors or publishers.

That is probably a decision that is made as some department level. And she may not have brought them all the shots she took.

I can easily see how they may not have known which photographer had been hired before it was done.

342 alien_mind  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:07:58pm

re: #163 SpartanWoman

Recourse? You mean you believe this nonsense about being fooled and blind-sided?


right, their response is "We're shocked, shocked to find out about this manipulation".

i guess they didn't vet her properly before hiring her?

343 Silhouette  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:08:05pm

re: #306 musicman

The photograph used for the magazine is not the issue. It's the other photographs that were taken at the same time by the photographer and then photoshopped. Most photographers give their clients all the photos that were taken. They are the property of the magazine. That's the way I read it.

Yes it is. I mentioned earlier that they would try to use the photographs that were indeed worse to draw attention away from the one used, giving the unspoken but perhaps intentional impression that the cover shot was NOT subjected to her bias.

But she admits that she skipped the typical retouching, and submitted it with his eyes red and skin looking bad.

In other words, she presented a product that intentionally made a candidate that she didn't support look worse than she would have for a candidate she did support.

344 ploome hineni[deleted]  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:08:13pm
345 Celtic Templar  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:08:28pm

Has anyone seen the replacement photo? Much worse, IMO:
Allusion to POW cell

From Goldberg's article Wars of John McCain

Who is this guy kidding?

346 livefreeor die  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:08:29pm

She and Randi Rhodes can be BFF.

347 ploome hineni[deleted]  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:08:44pm
348 musicman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:08:46pm

Didn't several people go all ballistic on the picture of O.J. Simpson looking dark and foreboding?

349 SpartanWoman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:09:21pm

re: #328 capitalist piglet

Tell me you're kidding. Are there really "Obama or ELSE" t-shirts out there?

Lots of them. Undoubtedly, "or else" isn't something nice

350 ploome hineni[deleted]  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:09:35pm
351 livefreeor die  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:09:39pm

re: #348 musicman

Didn't several people go all ballistic on the picture of O.J. Simpson looking dark and foreboding?

But, but...they were railroading good ol' OJ!

/

352 FightingBack  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:11:16pm

re: #348 musicman

Didn't several people go all ballistic on the picture of O.J. Simpson looking dark and foreboding?

Abject apologies ensued.

353 SpartanWoman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:11:56pm

OT: I am very pleased that ML will merge with BoA and save us from another Lehman.

354 Ruthless  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:13:38pm

I am coming late to this thread and have jumped ahead, so forgive me if there are previous posts that cover this same ground. I am a professional photographer and am enraged at Jill Greenberg's atrocious behavior and the way it reflects on my profession. I have just sent her the following e-mail:

Dear Ms. Greenberg -- I am a Life Member of ASMP and am disappointed to learn that you are also a member. You know what I am talking about, and you have brought shame to our entire profession.

Should any of you care to add your voice to her ear, here is her email address: jill@manipulator.com. "Manipulator" indeed. This is disgusting.

355 Silhouette  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:14:56pm

re: #332 Archimedes

Yeah, the cover picture isn't very flattering either. I've seen many photos of McCain where he looks better than that, just snap shots taken by amateurs.

And even if it turned out very flattering, or if people turn out to be more impressed by a candidate who isn't as 'pretty', the point is that wasn't her intention.

She chose to deliver a shot without the typical retouching, thereby resulting in an image of McCain worse than one she would have done for Obama. She admits/brags that she left off the retouching.

And the magazine (and other media apologists) try to take the focus off that and pretend that the only problems are with the bottom lit shot.

356 Big Boots that's boots  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:14:59pm

re: #348 musicman

Didn't several people go all ballistic on the picture of O.J. Simpson looking dark and foreboding?

Yeah- but OJ was guilty.

357 EIDE_Interface  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:15:17pm

If there is any justice in the world. Ms. Greenberg will only find employment at McDonald's.

358 wright1  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:16:11pm

re: #356 Big Boots that's boots

Yeah- but OJ was guilty.

The ends never justifies the means - that is the way the Left do things not us.

359 Celtic Templar  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:16:34pm

re: #357 EIDE_Interface

If there is any justice in the world. Ms. Greenberg will only find employment at McDonald's.

Running the fryolater with Scott Beauchamp.

360 Dar ul Harb  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:20:46pm

re: #108 buzzsawmonkey

Lest you think that this photographer is the only one, here is some art--with comments--by the artists who illustrate the mainstream media.
[snips]
Here
[snips]

Oh, yeah?

Well... here!

361 Price_of_Peace  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:23:22pm

re: #94 oh_dude

What's that old line about laying down with dogs?

You wake up as a registered Democrat?


Don't belittle my dogs! They are both conservatives.

362 Syrah  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:23:51pm

re: #333 Syrah

This was in the article that you posted:

Depending on the contract, the film would or would not go back to the photographer. When digital came it, it was always understood that the out-takes or images we commissioned and paid for would be kept confidential by the photographer -- as specified in the rights agreement. At the very least, we would have exclusive use of them for a considerable period of time.

The contract is everything.

Vanderleun sounds like he has a much tighter contract, though if I were he, I think I would not want to just rely on it being "understood that the out-takes or images we commissioned and paid for would be kept confidential by the photographer." It should be spelled out in the contract.

Greenberg's poor manners may cause photographers to have account for her type of indiscretions in their future contracts.

363 justadot  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:23:52pm
Every so often, journalists become deranged at the sight of certain candidates, and lose their bearings.

Hey, Goldberg – For evidence of this, you need look no further than that lunatic posting at the Daily Dish.

364 yesandno  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:24:10pm

Where are the serious people, the adults?

We have turned into a country with too many children over the age of 30...dependent, insecure, lacking self-esteem. hating competition because all they think about is coming in last rather then them doing better today then yesterday, accepting lying because "everyone" does it, thinking being free means you don't have to be grounded, honest, or well mannered.

They have no respect for anyone because they hate themselves...and why shouldn't they, they have occupied time and space and left little behind that is matter or will matter.

365 Lynn B.  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:25:41pm

I saw the cover photo on line this afternoon and didn't think it looked all that bad. The caption "Why War is his Answer" and the red banner in the corner we'll leave aside for now.

This evening I ran over to Whole Foods to pick up something I needed for dinner and, for some reason, they had several issues of the magazine all lined up side by side in front of the check-out counters. Seeing the actual thing, especially in multiple copies like that, gave a very different impression and it wasn't good.

And may I say, it's really depressing when you can't even run out for groceries without being subjected to pathetically transparent political propaganda. Usually, the only magazines WF displays like that, if any, are food mags.

It's enough to make you lose your appetite.

366 Neo_  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:36:33pm
367 Wild Thing  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:39:14pm

What a total Psycho she is maybe one day all these things she has done will smack her hard in her career. Justice would be so wonderful.

368 Dar ul Harb  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:39:15pm

re: #366 Neo_

Jill Greenberg redux

That's pretty good.

369 rawmuse  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:40:20pm

re: #300 lifeofthemind

That needs to be flagged it uses McCains endorsement that may be copyright theft, it certainly is fraud.

I flagged it.

370 redvoter  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:42:30pm

This is just sad. Incredibly disrespectful and I don't care what excuse the Atlantic makes, they are part to blame. They should have gotten rid of the photo and just used one of McCain during his naval days. It would have fit the story title.

It pains me to see a former P.O.W treated like this. Greenberg has a high profile list of clients from Phillip Morris (big tobacco what?) to Pepsi to Disney to Miller. MTV will most likely give her higher paying gigs after this but most her clients, like Proctor and Gamble should drop her for such unprofessionalism and malice.

371 redvoter  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:43:25pm

Everyone should be "buzzing" this so the story gets maximum exposure.

372 Throbert McGee  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:48:24pm

re: #3 Lively

Next they will draw a mustache on Palin

L.H.O.O.Q.!

(That's Frawnch for "MILF"...)

373 EIDE_Interface  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:53:10pm

*buzz*

374 EIDE_Interface  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:54:16pm

To see all of Jill Greenberg's photos:

Jill Greenberg's McCain photo collage

Prepare to be sickened.

375 Throbert McGee  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 8:58:26pm

re: #355 Silhouette

She chose to deliver a shot without the typical retouching

Is this necessarily unusual? I mean, I would've thought that nowadays, publications would often prefer to do retouching in-house -- I mean, not necessarily for every single photo in the issue, but certainly for the cover photo.

376 Silhouette  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 9:03:33pm

re: #375 Throbert McGee

She made a point of mentioning it. So it was of some importance to her.

Greenberg is well known for her highly retouched images of bears and crying babies. But she didn’t bother to do much retouching on her McCain images. “I left his eyes red and his skin looking bad,” she says.
377 Zonie  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 9:09:25pm

re: #21 Alouette

Do you mean FreeRepublic, or the Detroit Free Press?

378 whitehatguy  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 9:19:52pm

If the Atlantic is really repulsed by this woman's work they should
make sure to never hire her work.

379 EIDE_Interface  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 9:22:28pm

re: #378 whitehatguy

If the Atlantic is really repulsed by this woman's work they should
make sure to never hire her work.

It goes beyond that. Her career is over. SHe is toxic, no magazine aside from Mother Jones will hire her for anything.

380 Throbert McGee  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 9:23:41pm

re: #114 HelloDare

Jill Greenberg answers the critics who claim she abuses toddlers in the name of art

Well, Ms. Greenberg, I myself once got a digital photo of a mallard duck published in Popular Photography, so don't think you're anything special.

(Really, it's true! It was just a two-page review of a mid-market digital camera, but I still got into the "Contributing Editors" list on the masthead for that issue, plus a photo credit for the duck, and even a little bit of extra money when the review and the duck photo were reprinted in one of their "Holiday Shopper's Guide" issues.)

381 Pope Insouciance IV  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 9:25:16pm

Meanwhile, in Milwaukee:
Someone threw a rock through the window of Obama's campaign HQ downtown. Everyone was bracing for a revelation that some insane Republican racist thug did it.
Turns out it was a drunk Marquette University student.

Seems like you can't work up a good righteous indignation anymore.

382 pepper  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 9:25:54pm

The exurbs are rife with Obama signs on the front lawns. The "smarter" zip codes. As I drove from the outer counties to the city today, I saw the difference. The "or ELSE" is a veiled threat, but not by the wearer who is a dupe.

We will one day have a reckoning internally between the areas of population density and the perception that the rest are outliers.

Perception is the key to misinformation, not fact.

The MSM and entities within our government are the same in many respects.

There will be no scandal on the portraits nor will their be any reckoning. Why should there be?

383 Throbert McGee  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 9:31:47pm

re: #56 buzzsawmonkey

Jill Greenberg is the woman who intentionally makes children cry, takes pictures of them and calls it art.


At least she doesn't photograph them submerged in urine sitting in the seven-inch-deep "baby pool" at every single public swimming facility in the world..

There, fixed it for you -- means the same thing, but sounds nicer.

384 deanayer  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 9:44:23pm

Man! When even the Atlantic gets mad at you you must be an extreme leftist tool ! Nice Career-ender there Jill, So I guess its back to Walmart doing Family Portraits then ? Good luck with that.

385 mattm  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 9:47:39pm

She is a disgrace to every honest photographer.

386 gman  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 9:56:19pm

All I want to know is:

What does Matt Damon think about this?

387 GGMac  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 10:03:22pm

re: #18 Ford_Prefect

It will be intersting to see on what magazine she shows up next. Whichever mag it is will have basically run up the Lib flag and thrown out any pretense of being a true news magazine.

Magazine? How about a sale flyer for Payless Shoes. If she's lucky.

388 GGMac  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 10:30:22pm

re: #55 Sharmuta

Why are all those children topless? Is she some sort of pervert?

She has to be perverted, as is anyone who derives "artistic" gratification from portraying suffering babies/children - or from admiring such photos, or exhibiting them in an art gallery, let alone buying them for home "decor".

As I said on the earlier thread - this is one twisted sister.

389 tyree  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 10:56:04pm

"the issue is that she betrayed this magazine, and disgraced her profession." It is time for the left to stop treating Republicans like they are the enemy. We have at least one real enemy out there. You might have heard of them.

390 Ezekiel2517  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 11:07:37pm

Hopefully the only jobs Greenberg can score after this are crime scene photos and the occasional school yearbook gig.

391 Mel Lono  Sun, Sep 14, 2008 11:27:09pm

re: #390 Ezekiel2517

Hopefully the only jobs Greenberg can score after this are crime scene photos and the occasional school yearbook gig.

I'm sure George Soros and Michael Moore would give her a job.

392 MagnaniomousCoward  Mon, Sep 15, 2008 4:53:20am
393 sealizard  Mon, Sep 15, 2008 6:28:13am

US magazine on Line 2 for Ms. Greenberg.

394 hillbilly geek  Mon, Sep 15, 2008 7:19:15am

Leaving aside professional/not, she's simply shown that she'sa nasty little person with no standards. Anything is ok, if she wants to do it.

395 DaddyG  Mon, Sep 15, 2008 7:46:02am

If I were McCain I'd send a framed copy to Putin for his office.

396 DrCruel  Mon, Sep 15, 2008 8:46:42am

1) She's a very talented photographer and artist.
2) Apparently talent does not imply either scruples or maturity.
3) I am very glad she did this, then hammed it up to gain national attention for personal gain. It shows in a very effectual way the adolescent attitude that has kept the Democrats out of power since Clinton.

It might actually give McCain a good point or two in the polls. We should be thanking the arse.

397 wrenchwench  Mon, Sep 15, 2008 12:19:16pm

Jeffery Goldberg posted an update with a link to an article at Fox, which contains this sentence:

Editor James Bennet said Greenberg behaved improperly and will not be paid for the session. He said the magazine is also considering a lawsuit.

I hope they go through with the suit.


This entry has been archived.
Comments are closed.

^ back to top ^

log in
Name:
Pass:

Register Forgot Your Password? My Account Re-send Confirmation (To log in, cookies must be enabled in your browser!)

► LGF Headlines

  • Loading...

► Top 10 Comments

  • Loading...

► Bottom Comments

  • Loading...

► Recent Comments

  • Loading...

► Tools/Info

► LGF Hits

► Slideshows

► Resources

► Never Forget

► Statistics

► Tag Cloud

► Contact

You must have Javascript enabled to use the contact form.
Your email:

Subject:

Message:


Messages may be published in our weblog, unless you request otherwise.
Tech Note:
Using the Contact Form

► News/Opinion

  • Loading...

More Partners

Compare Electricity Prices in your area. Texas Electricity is deregulated; you have the right to choose Texas Electric Rates from among many Texas Electric Companies.

Nobody would have the idea.

Follow Lizardoid on Twitter

Fast & Free Delivery 160x600

 Frank says:

Ugly as I mights be, I am your futum!