Pages

5 comments

Jump to bottom
1 Norman Branitsky  Sun, Jul 4, 2010 7:46:35pm

Seems to be a nicely laid out paper. I have two comments:
1. B4 "Climate change is driven by cosmic rays"
Claims of a CRF-climate link on the million year time scale (Shaviv and Veizer 2003)
have been disputed (Rahmstorf et al. 2004).

Here is Shaviv's response on his web site to the Rahmstorf et al.2004 paper:
"Rahmstorf et al. 2004 published a comment stating that almost all Veizer and I did was wrong. We showed in our response why every comment is irrelevant or invalid. In their response to the rebuttal, Rahmstorf et al. did not address any of our rebuttal comments (I presume because they could not). Instead, they used faulty statistics to demonstrate that our results are statistically insignificant. (Basically, they used Bartlett's formula for the effective number of degrees of freedom in a limit where the original derivation breaks down)."

Just because someone has written a paper with lots of citations, you still have to be diligent as a reader because not all the citations may be valid.

2. C6 "CO2 does not drive climate" is missing from this paper.
(The -=- was the only way I could make a reasonable table as more than 3 characters like "." or "-" are collapsed to just 3 characters.)

Time-=-=-=-=-Glaciation-=-=-=-=-=-=-CO2 (ppmv)
450-420 Ma-=-Ordovician-Silurian-=-=-4000(*)
360-260 Ma-=-Carboniferous-Permian-=400
151-132 Ma-=-Jurassic-Cretaceous-=-=2000(*)
Present Day-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-389

(*) Berner, R. A. and Kothavala, Z. 2001: Geocarb III: A revised model of atmospheric CO2 over Phanerozoic time.
American Journal of Science 301:182-204

The obvious question the Urs Neu paper neglects to answer is how the Earth could be covered in glaciers if the atmospheric CO2 was 5 or 10 times the present day value? Why wasn't the Earth's climate a runaway greenhouse with so much atmospheric CO2?

2 freetoken  Sun, Jul 4, 2010 7:50:16pm

re: #1 dinky

The obvious question the Urs Neu paper neglects to answer is how the Earth could be covered in glaciers if the atmospheric CO2 was 5 or 10 times the present day value? Why wasn't the Earth's climate a runaway greenhouse with so much atmospheric CO2?


These sort of questions get asked, and answered, all the time.

BTW, of what period are you thinking when you say "10 times the present day value"?

3 Norman Branitsky  Sun, Jul 4, 2010 8:31:38pm

re: #2 freetoken

These sort of questions get asked, and answered, all the time.


I'm just asking. Have any links you can direct me to that answers this specific question?

BTW, of what period are you thinking when you say "10 times the present day value"?


Ordovician-Silurian Glaciation (450-420 Ma) as listed in my table.

4 b_sharp  Sun, Jul 4, 2010 8:47:50pm

re: #1 dinky


The obvious question the Urs Neu paper neglects to answer is how the Earth could be covered in glaciers if the atmospheric CO2 was 5 or 10 times the present day value? Why wasn't the Earth's climate a runaway greenhouse with so much atmospheric CO2?

Although it isn't possible to know for sure, there have been several explanations given.

Simply put, during that time period, solar output was less than it is now, CO2 estimates for the time were high, the cooling preceded the CO2, and the increase in CO2 pulled the Earth out of the cooling period.

John Cook at Skeptical Science has a good write up on it including cites to specific papers.

5 b_sharp  Sun, Jul 4, 2010 8:58:29pm

Here is another paper disputing the work of Shaviv et al.

Again John Cook has an article on the Cosmic question including Shaviv's rebuttal to that paper and Sloan's response to the rebuttal.


This page has been archived.
Comments are closed.

^ back to top ^

TwitterFacebook

Turn off all ads for a full year by subscribing!
For about 33 cents a day (per month) or 22 cents a day (per year), our subscription option turns off all advertisements at LGF!
Read more...

► LGF Headlines

  • Loading...

► Tweeted Articles

  • Loading...

► Tweeted Pages

  • Loading...

► Top 10 Comments

  • Loading...

► Bottom Comments

  • Loading...

► Recent Comments

  • Loading...

► Tools/Info

► Tag Cloud

► Contact

You must have Javascript enabled to use the contact form.
Your email:

Subject:

Message:


Messages may be published unless you request otherwise.
Tech Note:
Using the Contact Form
LGF Pages

This button leads to the main index of LGF Pages, our user-submitted articles. You can post your own LGF Pages simply by registering a free account with us.

Create a Page

This is the LGF Pages posting bookmarklet. To use it, drag this button to your browser's bookmark bar, and title it 'LGF Pages' (or whatever you like). Then browse to a site you want to post, select some text on the page to use for a quote, click the bookmarklet, and the Pages posting window will appear with the title, text, and any embedded video or audio files already filled in, ready to go.

Or... you can just click this button to open the Pages posting window right away.

Last updated: 2014-03-07 2:19 pm PST

LGF User's Guide
Recent Pages
Randall Gross
The Two Things That Rarely Happen After a Medical Mistake
It's an interesting dilemma - if the harm was small do you undermine the patient's confidence in their treatment? If the harm was great, do you encourage the lawsuit? Also be warned that this is a non scientific, small sample ...

4 hours, 46 minutes ago
Views: 116 • Comments: 0
Tweets: 0 • Rating: 0
Lumberhead
Marion Barry, District Councilman and Former Mayor, Dies at 78
Despite his faults, Barry is credited with opening the city's government to black citizens; for creating a massive summer jobs program that while wasteful in many cases offered a job or paid internship to any city youth who wanted ...

5 hours, 39 minutes ago
Views: 87 • Comments: 1
Tweets: 0 • Rating: 0
teleskiguy
“Chelsea Hotel” performed by Tal Wilkenfeld
I first saw Austrailian bass player Tal Wilkenfeld play with Jeff Beck (not live, mind you. On YouTube) and was amazed at her skills and chops. She was only 20 when she scored that gig. She's coming into her own ...

1 day, 16 hours ago
Views: 130 • Comments: 0
Tweets: 0 • Rating: 4
FemNaziBitch
History of Laws Concerning Immigration and Naturalization in the United States -WIKI
The United States Constitution was adopted on September 17, 1787. Article I, section 8, clause 4 of the Constitution expressly gives the United States Congress the power to establish a uniform rule of naturalization.[1] Pursuant to this power, Congress ...

2 days ago
Views: 234 • Comments: 1
Tweets: 1 • Rating: 2
MichaelJ
COMFORTABLY NUMB - Peahi Nov 12 on Vimeo
Channel angle of the Nov 12th swell at Peahi.

5 days, 13 hours ago
Views: 412 • Comments: 0
Tweets: 1 • Rating: 2
Romantic Heretic
Money Makes Us Less Rational
Here's an interesting article on scientific studies that demonstrate how rationality and empathy break down is the presence of large amounts of money.

1 week, 1 day ago
Views: 625 • Comments: 2
Tweets: 0 • Rating: 2
Indy GOP Refugee
Dissent Goes Missing in Pro-Labor L.A. City Council - LA Times
That is not good govenance. The San Fernando Valley lawmaker stood up at a recent meeting and rattled off numbers from a new report on the city's economic health. Sales tax revenue? Up 26% since 2009. Business tax revenue? Up ...

1 week, 4 days ago
Views: 941 • Comments: 6
Tweets: 0 • Rating: -2
wheat-dogghazi-bola-trality
Uncomfortable Xi-Abe Handshake Spawns New Winnie the Pooh Comparison
Asian powerhouses China and Japan have not been on the best of terms lately, following disagreements over who has claim to some islands -- and possible undersea gas and oil fields -- in the South China Sea. So perhaps we ...

1 week, 5 days ago
Views: 1,984 • Comments: 0
Tweets: 1 • Rating: 4
EiMitch
CollegeHumor: If Call of Duty Were Treated Like A Real Thing
Mildly NSFW (bleeped-out language) CollegeHumor seems to be doing a bit of cross-promotion with CoD: Advanced Warfare. Consider that disclosure. That aside, it was funny because... Actually I can't explain without spoiling it. As for the game being advertised, I ...

1 week, 5 days ago
Views: 925 • Comments: 0
Tweets: 0 • Rating: 1
Three Chord Monty
Michael Moore defends Bill Maher
"You may not agree with Bill on everything. Yet I'm guessing you love it when he goes after the Uterun Police/Protectors of Child Rapists (also known as The Vatican), or when he brilliantly satirizes the crazy Christian Right which ...

1 week, 6 days ago
Views: 1,322 • Comments: 4
Tweets: 83 • Rating: 1
 Frank says:

I write the music I like. If other people like it, fine, they can go buy the albums. And if they don't like it, there's always Michael Jackson for them to listen to. -- Frank was talking about his music from the Yellow Shark.