The Behavioral Economist’s Guide to Buying Presents
Christmas cheer isn’t cheap. Not in America. According to the National Retail Federation, U.S. shoppers spent more than $700 each on presents last holiday season — about the same as a median month’s rent.
Gift buying, as we all know, can be a fraught experience. Do you try and pick out that perfect shawl-neck sweater for your brother, or play it safe with a J. Crew gift card? Do you buy your college-age cousin that Velvet Underground box set you loved so much at their age (and which they’ll obviously learn to enjoy!), or go with the XBox game you know they really want?
These are painful, perennial questions. Thankfully, dorky academics have been investigating the nuances and norms of gift giving for decades. We’ve compiled a few of their findings into a Behavioral Economist’s Guide to Gift Giving. Read up, and shop confidently.
What is the single best possible gift?
Cash money.
Money is the soundest gift for one simple reason: It guarantees that the recipient gets exactly what they want.
In 1993, economist Joel Waldfogel published a study with a title that only the Grinch could love: “The Deadweight Loss of Christmas.” Deadweight loss is the term economists use to describe the gap between what we spend on something and what it’s actually worth. Because people rarely know exactly what their friends and loved ones want, Waldfogel decided to ask a simple, slightly uncomfortable question: How much value do we waste every year by picking the wrong holiday gifts?
To find an answer, he surveyed a group of Yale undergraduates. He concluded that gift giving “destroys” between a tenth and a third of the value in what we buy. In other words, if you spend $100 on that Santa-red cardigan at Macy’s, chances are whoever gets it will only value your gift between $70 and $90. Some groups had a better gift radar than others. Grandparents, aunts and uncles had the worst sense of what to buy. Friends and significant others had the best. But ultimately, cash was just more efficient.
So if you’re feeling uncertainty, don’t guess. Do everyone a favor and go with greenbacks. Or at least a gift card.