In Iowa you can fire a woman for being 'too hot'

Pages

In Iowa you can fire a woman for being ‘too hot’

Or so says the Iowa Supreme Court

Romantic Heretic

Law • 12/22/12 6:47:44 am • Views: 633

She worked for him for ten years, his wife decided they might some day think of having an affair and he fired her.

So far, the courts think he can do that.

I think this dentist needs to grow a spine, his wife needs to work on her insecurity and they should get professional relationship help, not from the pastor who advised the man to fire a good worker.

It’s incidents like these that make me roll my eyes when people talk about ‘hard work’. There are often far more important thing than the quality of your work when your employer decides you have to go.

Women Iowa Supreme Court Working World

Recent Pages by Romantic Heretic:
Jesus Christ sues GOP for slander The Day The Universe Changed There is no GOP Civil War Truck hits moose, catches fire, starts fireworks display Ray Bradbury has died

23 comments

Jump to bottom

Dark_Falcon Sat, Dec 22, 2012 8:10:47am

It’s incidents like these that make me roll my eyes when people talk about ‘hard work’. There are often far more important thing than the quality of your work when your employer decides you have to go.

Quoted for Truth.

I'd also note that the Iowa Supreme Court isn't the villain here. As their decision stated:

"As we have indicated above, the issue before us is not whether a jury could find that Dr. Knight treated Nelson badly," read the high court's decision.

"We are asked to decide only if a genuine fact issue exists as to whether Dr. Knight engaged in unlawful gender discrimination when he fired Nelson at the request of his wife. For the reasons previously discussed, we believe this conduct did not amount to unlawful discrimination, and therefore we affirm the judgment of the district court."

Whether or not Dr. knight was being a jerk wasn't a question before them, and as RH noted you can in fact be terminated (though not "for cause") because you are seen as disruptive to a boss's work or home environment. So while Mr. and Mrs. knight behaved badly, their actions aren't grounds for a tort.

philosophus invidius Sat, Dec 22, 2012 8:48:42am

At-will employment
[Link: en.wikipedia.org...]

HappyWarrior Sat, Dec 22, 2012 8:56:52am

Sheesh.

Obdicut Sat, Dec 22, 2012 11:01:23am

Why we need unions, part three million.

aagcobb Sat, Dec 22, 2012 11:03:01am

It sure seems like sex discrimination to me, but what do I know?

dragonath Sat, Dec 22, 2012 11:49:28am

Wow, a unanimous decision.

Remember, Iowa's Supreme Court lost it's most liberal justices after the judicial recall votes in 2010.

Dark_Falcon Sat, Dec 22, 2012 11:54:50am

re: #5 aagcobb

It sure seems like sex discrimination to me, but what do I know?

She wasn't fired for being a woman, she was fired because she become a liability to the owner of the dental practice. He replaced her with another woman, in point of fact. It's a raw deal, I agree, but not all raw deals are legally actionable.

Romantic Heretic Sat, Dec 22, 2012 11:56:38am

re: #2 philosophus invidius

At-will employment
[Link: en.wikipedia.org...]

Also known as, "You're property. Deal."

Dark_Falcon Sat, Dec 22, 2012 12:05:02pm

re: #8 Romantic Heretic

Also known as, "You're property. Deal."

No, not true. 'At Will' means that either party can terminate the employment at will. If someone 'at will' decides to leave for another job, her or his employer cannot stop them, whereas an employee under contract might well not be able to do so (at least not without notice).

wrenchwench Sat, Dec 22, 2012 12:08:41pm

re: #7 Dark_Falcon

She wasn't fired for being a woman, she was fired because she become a liability to the owner of the dental practice. He replaced her with another woman, in point of fact. It's a raw deal, I agree, but not all raw deals are legally actionable.

She would not have been fired if she weren't a woman, so she was fired for being a woman. If she 'became a liability', it was through no fault of her own. I think she has a case against him for sexual harassment as well as discrimination, based on what her employer is quoted as saying to her while she was working for him.

And if I'm not mistaken, aagcobb is an attorney, and the 'but what do I know' was tongue-in-cheek.

wrenchwench Sat, Dec 22, 2012 12:10:38pm

re: #2 philosophus invidius

At-will employment
[Link: en.wikipedia.org...]

re: #9 Dark_Falcon

No, not true. 'At Will' means that either party can terminate the employment at will. If someone 'at will' decides to leave for another job, her or his employer cannot stop them, whereas an employee under contract might well not be able to do so (at least not without notice).

'At will' does not mean you can fire someone based on gender. It's spelled out in philosophus invidius's link.

wrenchwench Sat, Dec 22, 2012 12:13:11pm

I give up on making a joke out of 'fire' and 'too hot'. I'm sure somebody can do it though.

Dark_Falcon Sat, Dec 22, 2012 12:15:41pm

re: #10 wrenchwench

She would not have been fired if she weren't a woman, so she was fired for being a woman. If she 'became a liability', it was through no fault of her own. I think she has a case against him for sexual harassment as well as discrimination, based on what her employer is quoted as saying to her while she was working for him.

And if I'm not mistaken, aagcobb is an attorney, and the 'but what do I know' was tongue-in-cheek.

She has a case for sexual harassment, I agree, but I still maintain this case was rightly decided. If Dr. Knight had been gay (Iowa allows gay marriage) and his husband had been angry about his flirting with a male employee, he would have been equally within the law in letting that man go.

Also remember that he did not fire his assistant 'for cause' and in fact paid her a month's severance and gave her a glowing recommendation. So this wasn't one of those dishonest terminations we read about (and that I've been subject to).

lostlakehiker Sat, Dec 22, 2012 12:22:02pm

The dentist, given his human weakness, together with his determination to remain faithful to his marriage promises, had other options. He could close down his practice and retire. He could close down his practice, move to another place, and start anew there.

He could see where his own faults were leading. He could see that he wasn't going to master them as a better man would have.

Now what?

His best option probably was to have done what he did, but give her six months severance pay rather than one.

But the court was correct. The decision will be upheld on appeal, if it's appealed. A mirror-image case in which the dentist was married to another man, and dismissed a male employee for similar reasons, would be decided the same way. It's not "sex discrimination" to avoid a specific person to whom one is sexually attracted to the point of making a professional, businesslike relation impossible.

wrenchwench Sat, Dec 22, 2012 12:25:50pm

re: #13 Dark_Falcon

re: #14 lostlakehiker

Making it about a hypothetical gay marriage and a fired man does not change my opinion that the firing was based on gender. It would still be based on gender in your hypothetical. Obviously the judges in Iowa see it differently, but that does not impress me either.

And lostlakehiker has the facts all wrong. The dentist didn't fire the woman because of the attraction. He fired her because his wife told him to.

Dark_Falcon Sat, Dec 22, 2012 12:34:18pm

re: #14 lostlakehiker

LLH, this was an appeal. The case had been appealed to the Iowa state supreme court. The next step would be SCOTUS, but I doubt they'll hear it or reverse it if they do.

Obdicut Sat, Dec 22, 2012 12:48:00pm

It's not sex discrimination, really. It's not much of anything. It's just another stupid reason for people to get fired or an excuse to fire people. And it's another reason we need strong unions again.

People shouldn't be fired or let go without cause. If the fault is on the side of the employer why the person can't do the job-- which it was, in this case, then the worker should be compensated for that.

lostlakehiker Sat, Dec 22, 2012 3:44:08pm

re: #17 Obdicut

It's not sex discrimination, really. It's not much of anything. It's just another stupid reason for people to get fired or an excuse to fire people. And it's another reason we need strong unions again.

People shouldn't be fired or let go without cause. If the fault is on the side of the employer why the person can't do the job-- which it was, in this case, then the worker should be compensated for that.

That's why I recommended 6 months severance. Compensation.

But UNIONS? How do you unionize a dentist's small practice? And suppose that was in place and she did belong to a union and he couldn't fire her? Then one of the other two options would have been the result. He quits outright, or he moves. There simply isn't a scenario in which they continue to work together.

Obdicut Sat, Dec 22, 2012 4:33:08pm

re: #18 lostlakehiker

That's why I recommended 6 months severance. Compensation.

But UNIONS? How do you unionize a dentist's small practice? And suppose that was in place and she did belong to a union and he couldn't fire her? Then one of the other two options would have been the result. He quits outright, or he moves. There simply isn't a scenario in which they continue to work together.

Unions raise standards in non-union jobs as well. And I have no idea why you're talking about them continuing to work together, since I said you should get compensated if you couldn't continue in the job not because of any fault, but because of something with your employer.

So why are you talking about them continuing to work together?

goddamnedfrank Sat, Dec 22, 2012 4:34:29pm

re: #7 Dark_Falcon

She wasn't fired for being a woman, she was fired because she become a liability to the owner of the dental practice. He replaced her with another woman, in point of fact. It's a raw deal, I agree, but not all raw deals are legally actionable.

She was fired for being an attractive woman. This still constitutes gender discrimination in as much as personal comeliness would not have been an issue in this instance for any male employee.

Obdicut Sat, Dec 22, 2012 4:36:41pm

re: #20 goddamnedfrank

She was fired for being an attractive woman. This still constitutes gender discrimination in as much as personal comeliness would not have been an issue in this instance for any male employee.

I hadn't thought of it that way. Yeah, it is gender discrimination; if she was male, she wouldn't have been fired. That there are other things that could have made her not fired-- like being unattractive-- doesn't matter. You can't decide you're going to fire all the women who have blue eyes but not fire the men who have blue eyes.

Dark_Falcon Sat, Dec 22, 2012 6:54:17pm

re: #21 Obdicut

I hadn't thought of it that way. Yeah, it is gender discrimination; if she was male, she wouldn't have been fired. That there are other things that could have made her not fired-- like being unattractive-- doesn't matter. You can't decide you're going to fire all the women who have blue eyes but not fire the men who have blue eyes.

But Dr. Knight only employs women. If she was a 'he', he'd not have been hired in the first place.

goddamnedfrank Sat, Dec 22, 2012 8:18:02pm

re: #22 Dark_Falcon

But Dr. Knight only employs women. If she was a 'he', he'd not have been hired in the first place.

Oh bullshit. The fact that both the original and replacement assistant happened to be women doesn't mean anything. It's a small practice, there aren't enough employee slots or known applicants to establish who the Dr. "only" hires. You just made that bit up. And if the Dr. did only hire women, that too would be gender discrimination.

Auto

This page has been archived.
Comments are closed.

^ back to top ^

Turn off ads by subscribing!
For about 33 cents a day, our subscription option turns off all advertisements at LGF!
Read more...

Featured Pages: Heywood Jabloeme
Fla. Poll: Hillary Clinton Beats Jeb Bush, Marco Rubio
Former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton would win Florida against both Sen. Marco Rubio and former Gov. Jeb Bush in the 2016 presidential election, a new poll finds. If the election were held today, Clinton would top Bush 50 percent to 43 percent, and she would best Rubio 53 percent to 41 percent, according to Wednesday's survey from Quinnipiac. Vice President Joe Biden would ...

28 minutes ago
Views: 51 • Comments: 1
Tweets: 0 • Rating: 2; Randall Gross
Conspiracy Theories Conspiracy
SOURCES: 0:01 "Sprinkler Rainbow Conspiracy"(mirrored from "HAARP's Rainbow Aerosol's" (sic)) 1:20 -- HAARP details from Wired magazinewired.com 1:46 -- Jesse Ventura's "Conspiracy" 2:38 "On the onset of HF-induced airglow at HAARP" -- Mishin et.al., Journal of Geophysical Research, 2004 2:44 "Magnetic Zenith enhancement of HF-induced airglow production at HAARP" -- Pederson et al., Journal of Geophysical Research, 2003 2:47 Ibid. 4:03 posters-wanted.com 4:57 -- ...

1 hour, 41 minutes ago
Views: 101 • Comments: 0
Tweets: 0 • Rating: 1; Vicious Babushka
Meet America’s Most Shameless Defender of the 1 Percent
More: Meet America's Most Shameless Defender of the 1 Percent, Harvard Economist Greg Mankiw It’s not really news that America’s economics departments, particularly at elite institutions, are stuffed with people whose careers are founded on protecting monied interests. But it’s pretty rare when someone just comes straight out and announces the fact. Meet Greg Mankiw, chairman and professor of economics at Harvard, one of ...

2 hours, 41 minutes ago
Views: 152 • Comments: 1
Tweets: 3 • Rating: 2; Baboon Cheeks
Nate Silver: Politico Co-Founders Lack ‘Curiosity for the World Outside of the Bubble’
"It's striking how preoccupied Harris and VandeHei are with the perception that Politico is too 'insidery,'" Silver wrote. "My personal critique of their work cuts a little deeper than that, however. It's not that they are too 'insidery' per se, but that the perceptions of Beltway insiders, which Politico echoes and embraces, are not always very insightful or accurate. In other words, the conventional ...

3 hours, 11 minutes ago
Views: 178 • Comments: 2
Tweets: 20 • Rating: 5; Randall Gross
Ayers Condemns Obama for ‘War Crimes’
As a reformed wingnut, I recall those times. There's a whole fringe camp out there full of folks just like Bill Ayers who are upset with our President for not being the far left revolutionary that they really want him to be. These hard bitten partisans are willing to stand shoulder to shoulder with the hard right right whenever the opportunity presents to fling ...

3 hours, 33 minutes ago
Views: 155 • Comments: 2
Tweets: 10 • Rating: 4; team_fukit
Journalist Michael Hastings Dies in Fiery Car Crash
HOLLYWOOD, Calif. (KTLA) — A man killed Tuesday in a fiery car crash in Hollywood was journalist Michael Hastings, his employer said. The wreck happened near the intersection of Highland and Melrose avenues around 4:15 a.m., according to LAPD Officer Lillian Carranza. The car, presumably driven by Hastings, slammed into a tree and caught fire. “I was just coming northbound on Highland and I ...

8 hours, 28 minutes ago
Views: 127 • Comments: 0
Tweets: 0 • Rating: 1; Cap'n Magic
TPM: Senate Intel Committee Blocks Former Staffer From Talking To Press About Oversight Process
Talking Points Memo: The Senate Select Committee on Intelligence has taken the unusual step of actively blocking a former committee aide from talking to TPM about congressional oversight of the intelligence community. At issue isn’t classified sources and methods of intelligence gathering but general information about how the committee functions — and how it should function. The committee’s refusal to allow former general counsel ...

9 hours, 6 minutes ago
Views: 50 • Comments: 1
Tweets: 0 • Rating: 0; Cap'n Magic
Angeline Jolie stunt double sues News Corp. in US over hacked phone
BBC: A former Hollywood stunt double has sued News Corp and its subsidiary News International, accusing the companies of ordering the hacking of her phone. The suit, the first such claim from the US, was filed by Eunice Huthart, a British former double for Hollywood star Angelina Jolie. In the suit, the Liverpool resident alleges messages from family, friends and Ms Jolie were intercepted ...

11 hours, 11 minutes ago
Views: 130 • Comments: 0
Tweets: 8 • Rating: 0; Stephen T.
3 Former NSA Employees Praise Edward Snowden, Corroborate Key Claims
From The Atlantic 2013-06-18 Conor Friedersdorf. USA Today has published an extraordinary interview with three former NSA employees who praise Edward Snowden's leaks, corroborate some of his claims, and warn about unlawful government acts. Thomas Drake, William Binney, and J. Kirk Wiebe each protested the NSA in their own rights. "For years, the three whistle-blowers had told anyone who would listen that the NSA ...

12 hours, 36 minutes ago
Views: 157 • Comments: 2
Tweets: 0 • Rating: 1; Randall Gross
Google Challenges NSA Secrecy in FISA Court
Google has petitioned a secret U.S. national security court to relax restrictions on the information the tech giant can disclose about government data requests, claiming such restrictions violate the company's right to free speech under the First Amendment. Google's motion, filed Tuesday with the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court, is the tech giant's latest attempt to address recent media reports that suggested it gives the ...

13 hours, 5 minutes ago
Views: 171 • Comments: 0
Tweets: 10 • Rating: 2

Recent Pages: Heywood Jabloeme
Bobby Jindal Is Confused About Tom Friedman and Economics
The thing about no longer being the stupid party is you actually have to do it. That means grappling with the world as it is; not as it was in 1980. It means grappling with your opponents as they are; not as Fox News imagines them. And it particularly means grappling with how to reapply conservative principles to these new realities; not how to ...

7 minutes ago
Views: 23 • Comments: 0
Tweets: 0 • Rating: 0; Randall Gross
In Berlin, Obama to Call for Reduction in Nuclear Arms
President Barack Obama is expected to use his speech at the iconic Brandenburg Gate on Wednesday to renew calls for a reduction in nuclear weapons. It is not the first time the president has called for a reduction in stockpiles, but by addressing the issue in a major foreign speech, Obama is hoping to rekindle the issue, which was at the center of his ...

3 hours, 38 minutes ago
Views: 56 • Comments: 0
Tweets: 0 • Rating: 0; Cap'n Magic
Jack Shafer: Snowden vs the Dragons
Reuters: But even the press in aggregate is not a friend to whistle-blowers, as its recent treatment of Snowden attests, what with the deep dives into his teen years (including photos), his education and employment history, his reputation as a loner and a “brainiac,” his pants-down hijinks, his online scribblings, his dancer girlfriend, his predilection for (in his own words) “post-coital Krispy Kremes.” Squeezing ...

9 hours, 17 minutes ago
Views: 47 • Comments: 0
Tweets: 0 • Rating: 0; Romantic Heretic
Jesus Christ sues GOP for slander
I wish this was true. If for no other reason than to watch heads explode.

13 hours, 35 minutes ago
Views: 156 • Comments: 5
Tweets: 0 • Rating: 4; William of Orange
Jail reckless bankers, standards commission urges
Senior bankers guilty of reckless misconduct should be jailed, a long-awaited report on banking commissioned by the government has recommended. The Parliamentary Commission on Banking Standards was set up by Chancellor George Osborne last year after a number of scandals involving the industry. Jail reckless bankers, standards commission urgesThe cross-party group's fifth report attacked the lack of accountability of bankers and also said some ...

14 hours, 20 minutes ago
Views: 99 • Comments: 1
Tweets: 1 • Rating: 2; Dancing along the light of day
Boeing nets orders for 102 stretch 787s
LE BOURGET, France — Boeing Co. won major orders from five customers for a stretched-out version of its popular 787 Dreamliner jet at the Paris Air Show Tuesday, further evidence of a strengthening market for more expensive long-haul jets.Boeing announced the formal launch of its 787-10 program at the Paris Air Show on Tuesday and says it already has commitments for 102 jets from ...

14 hours, 28 minutes ago
Views: 72 • Comments: 0
Tweets: 0 • Rating: 1; DO WINGNUT WORDS SHOW THEY EVOLVED BRAINS?11!!
Baker’s Graduation Cake Mix-Up Ends in Purr-fect Mistake
When Laura Gambrel, 22, of Zionsville, Ind., graduated from Indiana University in May, she wanted to keep the celebration pretty low key. She didn’t walk at the ceremony, nor did she have a party because she planned to go right back to the university this coming fall for grad school. It seemed only fitting then that the one thing her mother attempted to do ...

17 hours, 6 minutes ago
Views: 172 • Comments: 2
Tweets: 0 • Rating: 5; nines09
Liam Clancy - The Band Played Waltzing Matilda
Been a while since I was reminded of this one. Friend of mine posted it today. Let me share it with you. Liam Clancy

20 hours, 45 minutes ago
Views: 134 • Comments: 6
Tweets: 0 • Rating: 6; FemNaziBitch
Study: Reading Fiction Makes People Comfortable With Ambiguity
Are you uncomfortable with ambiguity? It's a common condition, but a highly problematic one. The compulsion to quell that unease can inspire snap judgments, rigid thinking, and bad decision-making. Fortunately, new research suggests a simple antidote for this affliction: Read more literary fiction. A trio of University of Toronto scholars, led by psychologist Maja Djikic, report that people who have just read a short ...

1 day ago
Views: 110 • Comments: 1
Tweets: 0 • Rating: 3; Skip Intro
Miss Utah USA Gives Worst Pageant Answer Since Miss South Carolina
Dye her hair blonde and she's got a job at Fox News. Question: "A recent report shows that in 40 percent of American families with children, women are the primary earners, yet they continue to earn less than men. What does this say about society?" Marissa Powell: "I think we can relate this back to education, and how we are ... continuing to try ...

1 day, 19 hours ago
Views: 413 • Comments: 6
Tweets: 0 • Rating: 0