Pages

Jump to bottom

9 comments

1 Kafitrar  Tue, Dec 24, 2013 9:25:51am

Arthur C. Clarke wrote a short story about this entitled, “The Star.” lucis.net

2 William Barnett-Lewis  Tue, Dec 24, 2013 10:46:05am

Beat me to it. That’s always the first thing I think of when I see these stories each year. Exquisite tale, well deserving the Hugo it took home.

3 SidewaysQuark  Tue, Dec 24, 2013 11:01:51am

The biggest “suspect” is that someone just plain made the story up. That would be consistent with the rest of the (most likely fabricated) narrative about the birth of Christ.

Merry Christmas!

4 CriticalDragon1177  Tue, Dec 24, 2013 11:29:51am

re: #1 Kafitrar

re: #2 William Barnett-Lewis

When I told some friends of mine on twitter about this article, one of them also recommended that “The Star” story. I guess it’s well known. Not surprising Arthur C. Clarke is really famous and considered one of the greatest sci fi writers of all time.


However, I’m not sure if I head about it, before today.

5 William Barnett-Lewis  Tue, Dec 24, 2013 11:49:07am

re: #3 SidewaysQuark

The biggest “suspect” is that someone just plain made the story up. That would be consistent with the rest of the (most likely fabricated) narrative about the birth of Christ.

Merry Christmas!

The stories were almost certainly made up. However folk memory of a spectacular astrological event could have played a part in the stories that got told about a seemingly miraculous healer & rabbi from Nazareth.

6 KingKenrod  Tue, Dec 24, 2013 4:02:01pm

re: #3 SidewaysQuark

The biggest “suspect” is that someone just plain made the story up. That would be consistent with the rest of the (most likely fabricated) narrative about the birth of Christ.

Merry Christmas!

Biblical authors rarely just made things up. Their audience at the time would remember or record odd celestial events, so they would know if the teller of the story was just making up the new star’s appearance circa 0BC.

The event (whatever it was) was probably real, just connected to Jesus’s birth after the fact.

7 wheat-dogghazi  Tue, Dec 24, 2013 6:20:47pm

re: #5 William Barnett-Lewis

The stories were almost certainly made up. However folk memory of a spectacular astrological event could have played a part in the stories that got told about a seemingly miraculous healer & rabbi from Nazareth.

Halley’s Comet makes several appearances in art over the ages, including the Bayeux Tapestry (commemorating the Norman Invasion of 1066). Strange stuff in the sky made an impact on people back then.

8 ausador  Tue, Dec 24, 2013 7:59:55pm

re: #6 KingKenrod

Biblical authors rarely just made things up. Their audience at the time would remember or record odd celestial events, so they would know if the teller of the story was just making up the new star’s appearance circa 0BC.

The event (whatever it was) was probably real, just connected to Jesus’s birth after the fact.

But the books of the New Testament were not written during Jesus’s lifetime or even during the entire next two generations. Biblical scholars put the date of the earliest written New Testament verses somewhere around 60 A.D.

The majority of New Testament scriptures were written between then and around 150 A.D although many scholars claim that at least two of the supposed letters of Paul/Saul are latter day forgeries and were not written until sometime considerably after 300 A.D.

So just like anyone reading the story today, the written account of the “Gospel” was written after anyone who might have actually witnessed it was already dead. (don’t forget the average lifespan then was considerably shorter).

There was no one still alive to cry foul and say “Hey, that never happened, there never was a star of the East that outshone all the other heavenly bodies, at least not when they say it did.”

Besides all of which the story of the “Three Magi” and the “Star of Bethlehem” only appears once in the bible, in the gospel of Matthew. Matthew was written between 70-110 A.D. based on earlier oral gospel stories and the gospel of Mark which scholars now believe was actually the first gospel to be written.

Many after-the-fact tales in the “gospels” were apparently written in order to fulfill (or appear to fulfill) earlier prophecies regarding the Jewish messiah. In this case the prophecy comes from the old testament book of Numbers…

I see Him, but not now;
I behold Him, but not near;
A Star shall come out of Jacob;
A Scepter shall rise out of Israel,
And batter the brow of Moab,
And destroy all the sons of tumult.

The kingdom of Moab had long since ceased to exist by the time of Jesus, but the prophecy of the star arising had become an accepted and anticipated sign of the messiah amongst Jewish theologians.

Therefore when someone got around to writing up the gospel of Matthew 80-90 years (scholarly best estimate) after the death of Jesus they included the story of the “Magi” and the “Star of Bethlehem.”

I have to rate the probability of the story of the Magi and the Eastern star being factual as exceedingly low given what we know about the formation of the written account.

9 jvic  Tue, Dec 24, 2013 8:38:41pm

re: #8 ausador

Well argued. Heck, I’m surprised at some accounts I read of things that happened in my adult lifetime, and that’s despite the communication & recording technology we have that didn’t exist two millennia ago.


This page has been archived.
Comments are closed.

Jump to top

Create a PageThis is the LGF Pages posting bookmarklet. To use it, drag this button to your browser's bookmark bar, and title it 'LGF Pages' (or whatever you like). Then browse to a site you want to post, select some text on the page to use for a quote, click the bookmarklet, and the Pages posting window will appear with the title, text, and any embedded video or audio files already filled in, ready to go.
Or... you can just click this button to open the Pages posting window right away.
Last updated: 2016-01-01 10:29 am PST
LGF User's Guide RSS Feeds Tweet

Help support Little Green Footballs!

Subscribe now for ad-free access!Register and sign in to a free LGF account before subscribing, and your ad-free access will be automatically enabled.

Donate with
PayPal
Square Cash Shop at amazon
as an LGF Associate!
Recent PagesClick to refresh
538: “It’s Way Too Soon to Count Trump Out” This is why we have to work like Biden is actually eight points behind, rather than ahead. Joe Biden currently has a robust lead in polls. If the election were held today, he might even win in a landslide, ...
thecommodore
2 hours, 15 minutes ago
Views: 47 • Comments: 0 • Rating: 0
Tweets: 1 • Share to Facebook
Harris, Parton, Ronstadt on Late Show, March 24, 1999 (Full, Stereo) "Trio II" was recorded in 1994 but not released until 1999, when Emmylou Harris, Dolly Parton, and Linda Ronstadt appeared on Late Show to perform Neil Young's "After the Gold Rush." The Glass Harmonica (or Armonica) was played by ...
Thanos
2 days, 10 hours ago
Views: 254 • Comments: 1 • Rating: 1
Tweets: 3 • Share to Facebook
Ratched You deserve someone to show you mercy. From the creator of American Horror Story, witness the origin of one of the world's most iconic characters, Nurse Ratched. Sarah Paulson stars in Ratched, coming to Netflix on September 18. SUBSCRIBE: ...
Thanos
3 days, 10 hours ago
Views: 278 • Comments: 0 • Rating: 0
Tweets: 0 • Share to Facebook
The Jaded Hearts Club - Reach Out I’ll Be There (Official Video) The Official Video for Reach Out I'll Be There by The Jaded Hearts Club. The new album You've Always Been Here is out 2 October, pre-order now: jadedhearts.lnk.to Listen to We'll Meet Again / Reach Out I'll Be There: ...
Thanos
3 days, 10 hours ago
Views: 401 • Comments: 0 • Rating: 0
Tweets: 1 • Share to Facebook
Raised by Wolves — New Ridley Scott Television Series Mother was programmed to protect everyone after Earth had been destroyed. When the big bad wolf shows up, she is the one we must trust. Subscribe: bit.ly Be the first to know more:HBO Max: hbom.axLike HBO Max on Facebook: ...
Thanos
5 days, 9 hours ago
Views: 557 • Comments: 0 • Rating: 0
Tweets: 3 • Share to Facebook
Black Pumas - Confines (Official Live Session With String Quartet) “Confines (Live in Studio)” is available now to stream/download. It is from the deluxe edition of the Black Pumas’ debut album which will be released digitally August 28 and physically October 9. Pre-order in 2xLP, 2xCD and digital formats: ...
Thanos
1 week ago
Views: 687 • Comments: 0 • Rating: 0
Tweets: 3 • Share to Facebook
Orville Peck - Smalltown Boy (Official Audio) Official audio for Orville Peck’s cover of "Smalltown Boy" by Bronski Beat out now: orvillepeck.lnk.to Pre-save / Pre-add Orville's new EP Show Pony here: orvillepeck.lnk.to Amazon - orvillepeck.lnk.toApple Music - orvillepeck.lnk.toiTunes - orvillepeck.lnk.toSoundcloud -  orvillepeck.lnk.toSpotify - orvillepeck.lnk.toYouTube Music - orvillepeck.lnk.toYouTube -  orvillepeck.lnk.to Follow Orville PeckFacebook - facebook.comInstagram - instagram.comTwitter - @orvillepeck orvillepeck.com LyricsTo ...
Thanos
1 week, 1 day ago
Views: 733 • Comments: 0 • Rating: 0
Tweets: 6 • Share to Facebook
Norah Jones - to Live "To Live" is taken from Norah's newest album 'Pick Me Up Off The Floor,' out now and available to stream/download here: norahjones.lnk.to Connect with Norah:norahjones.cominstagram.comfacebook.com@NorahJones See Norah live: norahjones.com Music video by Norah Jones performing To Live. © 2020 ...
Thanos
1 week, 5 days ago
Views: 908 • Comments: 0 • Rating: 0
Tweets: 1 • Share to Facebook
Future Islands - for Sure (Official Video) 'For Sure' by Future Islands, out now on all platforms: futureislands.ffm.to A Film by Samuel Jerome MasonFinishing by John HarrisonRendered with GarageFarmSpecial Thanks to Anna, Jemima, Mike, Willy, Saad, Eric, Arsen Perish the painI was impoverishedThose ties that windAnd ...
Thanos
1 week, 5 days ago
Views: 903 • Comments: 0 • Rating: 0
Tweets: 2 • Share to Facebook
Andrew McMahon in the Wilderness - Get on My Wave I wrote and produced “Get On My Wave” with Kyle “King Tuff” Thomas the day we met last summer. I’ve struggled with releasing the song during the pandemic because it felt too happy; detached from the tumult of our ...
Thanos
1 week, 5 days ago
Views: 877 • Comments: 0 • Rating: 0
Tweets: 2 • Share to Facebook