The Twisted Ideology That Appeals to Jihadists and Neo-Nazis Alike
This overview of Third position tribal nationalism from Chip Berlet outlines some of the reasons that the new Nazis don’t care if you are left or right, capitalist or communist as long as you are tribal first. Chip’s point regarding jihadists seems to be a stretch until you look close at the most active areas of Islamic terror groups. In the hinterlands of Pakistan, Iran, and Afghanistan ethno-nationalists sometimes leverage religious nationalism by pitting Hazara vs Pahktun tribes, and there are valleys where multi generational wars have been found for decades over shrines. Where it breaks down is Syria, where you see Sunni Ba’athists allying with Hezballah Shia against ISIS.
The Third Position has a more intellectual aristocratic ally called the European New Right (Nouvelle Droit ) which is different from the U.S. New Right.6) Intellectual leaders of the European New Right, such as Alain de Benoist, are hailed as profound thinkers in U.S. reactionary publications such as the Rockford Institute’s Chronicles. The more overtly neo-Nazi segment of the Third Position has intellectual links to the Strasserite wing of German national socialism, and is critical of Hitler’s brand of Nazism for having betrayed the working class. See magazines such as Scorpion or Third Way published in England. Third Position groups believe in a racially-homogeneous decentralized tribal form of nationalism, and claim to have evolved an ideology “beyond communism and capitalism.”
White supremacist leader Tom Metzger promotes Third Position politics in his newspaper WAR which stands for White Aryan Resistance. In Europe, the Third Position defines its racial-nationalist theories in publications such as Third Way and The Scorpion. Third Position adherents actively seek to recruit from the left. One such group is the American Front in Portland, Oregon, which ran a phone hotline that in late November, 1991 featured an attack on critics of left/right coalitions. Some Third Position themes have surfaced in the ecology movement and other movements championed by progressives.7)
The convergence among racial nationalists in North America and Western and Eastern Europe is discussed at length in Jeffrey Kaplan and Tore Bjørgo, eds., Nation and Race, and Jeffrey Kaplan and Leonard Weinberg, The Emergence of a Euro-American Radical Right.8) There is a theoretical discussion of the European Third Position and racially separate nation-states by Robert Antonio in “After Postmodernism: Reactionary Tribalism.9) The anti-U.S. aspect of the Third Position is examined in “´Neither Left Nor Right´” in the Southern Poverty Law Center magazine, Intelligence Report.10)
More: The Twisted Ideology That Appeals to Jihadists and Neo-Nazis Alike