Comment

Which One of These Anti-Semitic Cartoons Is Not Like the Others

102
Buck1/29/2013 7:12:03 am PST

re: #101 Obdicut

Seriously, look at the other guy’s cartoons. This is how he draws everyone. Calling this a blood libel is a gigantic stretch. I didn’t think so at first, it certainly seemed to me like an antisemitic cartoon, but then I actually looked at the rest of what the guy has done.

Of course there is a difference when you put a large hanging nose on a Jewish leader than when you make any nose red.

AND of course to ignore that he put a sharp blood dripping weapon in the Jewish leaders hand and shows him using the blood of Palestinian women and children would be to ignore the entire history of Blood liable.

So in this case you knowingly subtract from the story that which doesn’t fit your view.

This is a Gatestone article that was retweeted by Camera.

[Link: www.gatestoneinstitute.org…]


It accuses the persecution of Christians as being rooted in “Sharia”— which is followed, in one form or another, by all Muslims.

How is that not a bigoted position?

And here you add to the story to make it fit your view.

Maybe you can quote from the article that says “which is followed, in one form or another, by all Muslims.”

The article actually is reporting on Christian persecution in Muslim and Arabs countries. He is reporting hundreds of cases (this is a long running series). It is his conclusion that strict adherence to Sharia is a root cause.

ProBosniaLiberal seems to have an opinion on this as well, although he didn’t flush it out completely.

Allowing for a more full role of Islamic women has been set back by what they call “the Islamic Dark Age”. Where “things have gone backwards”.

Is that strict adherence to what has been a perverted version of Sharia? They don’t say.

The series is written by someone who’s family is Egyptian Catholic Coptic. He is writing a series that details the persecution of Christians in Muslim and Arab countries.

Sure we could ignore that persecution. That might be the way you want to go. That actually might seem to some to be prejudiced AGAINST Christians in Muslim and Arab countries.

Disagree with something that he writes. Fine, but ban his writing?

I question that idea.

In this thread alone, War on Music #63 displays the exact same (by your standard) sort of bigoted position.