Comment

Infant's Death at Maimonides Hospital Linked to Circumcision 

112
Obdicut (Now with 2% less brain)3/09/2012 1:52:40 pm PST

re: #111 Buck

Maybe he was hearing voices, OR maybe he was making it all up. I don’t know. It doesn’t matter. I am in awe that it could start there and grow just as he said it would. No matter if it was delusion or cunning plot.

Why are you certain he existed?

Back to the subject, the one commandment and the one promise.

That’s not the subject, Buck. The subjects are:

1. Why you think that religion and culture are separate entities, which you haven’t done anything to show.

2. Why you think religious practice has rational roots.

So far, you’ve actually done more to show religious practice has irrational roots than rational ones. Were you going to get around to showing a rational root at some point?