re: #118 Walter L. Newton

Who is going to hold their feet to the fire? I really ask that with no idea of the answer. It appears that there has actually been peer reviewed scientist that have been locked out of the process, at least as far as CRU is concerned, so, how tight does CRU hold the lid on other valid research?

At this point another peer review of the CRU papers will mean exactly nothing to me. I don’t like what I’ve seen about the peer reveiw process applied to Climate Science and it has inherent limitations I find unacceptable for such critical work.

I require their temperature constructions to be independently repeated in an open and verifiable manner, adhering to proper scientific procedures. Until they everything to do with “combating climate change” should be placed on hold except for research.