re: #152 Obdicut

Yes, I do see that you don’t have an argument, just an assertion. I also see you can’t deal with your own argument— you’ve said that when something looks like something else, that’s a good argument for it being like that other thing. This picture looks more like Scarfe’s other drawings than it does a Jewish caricature.

No, my argument is that when you add an exaggerated long nose to a Jewish leader AND place a sharp blood dripping weapon in the Jewish leaders hand AND show him using the blood of Palestinian women and children AND consider the long and well documented history of using the imagery of using Jewish victims blood in Antisemitic cartoons you have a strong combination of FACTS that lead me to believe that this is another example of an Antisemitic cartoon.

Each FACT on it’s own might be an assertion. However all together, knowing the history, I am making an argument.

One you disagree with.