Comment

Glenn Beck: Reform Judaism is Almost Like Radicalized Islam - Update 35% of U.S Jews are Reformed Jews

22
Nyet2/22/2011 5:21:39 pm PST

re: #19 LudwigVanQuixote

What are you talking about? Comparing a large group of law abiding Americans and their take on religion (ironically a deeply anti-religious one) to Al-Queda is not a criticism. It is an egregious smear and a lie. In this case, one directed against Jews.

I am certain you have some marvelous philosophical distinction to make, however the truth of the matter is that a libel is still a libel and not a criticism.

There are two issues. The foolish object of comparison and what Beck intends to be a criticism (which is that RJ is allegedly about politics and not religion - not true, but he intends it as criticism). In the first comment I addressed the latter part, and it’s not antisemitic, simply incorrect.