Comment

Saturday Night Open Thread

28
Vicious Babushka12/29/2012 6:50:01 pm PST

re: #26 Dark_Falcon

I agree with TP that her character’s death in not entirely certain, but removing her from the equation in the way Moriarty did served two purposes for the story:

1. It made the pursuit and exposure of Moriarty personal for Holmes, giving it added intensity and justifying Holmes being willing to die to take Moriarty down.

2. It cleared the way for Rapace’s character and also kept intact the diad relationship between Holmes and Watson. To keep McAdams’ character in the mix would have changed it to more of a triad at best and at worst would have left Watson as the 3rd wheel.

But then they brought in Mrs. Watson for what could have been just as easily accomplished by Irene.