Comment

Overnight Open Thread

420
Obdicut (Now with 2% less brain)4/25/2011 11:15:31 am PDT

re: #416 marjoriemoon

What do you think Israel means in that sentence? Who are we talking to?

Who is ‘we’? I think that it is something said by religious Jews about the nation of Jews, asserting that (name of god) is the god of the Jews.

Again:


What does that have to do with the importance of secular Zionism in the foundation of Israel, or the way that Herzl envisioned religion not playing a large part in the politics of Israel?

Herzl did not have a life-change where he became more religious. He simply saw that the Jews would never be unpersecuted.