re: #492 Sharmuta

Ken Miller is a fine man, but why rely on anyone to tell you what someone else is thinking? Especially when everyone has their self interest at heart?

Note that both Ken Miller AND Behe are both religious Catholics: do you not think it possible that each thinks the other is trying to define the relationship of science to their Church? I am not saying that thery are of equal intellectual probity and authority: I am saying that there are personal issues at stake, and the judgement of one on the person of the other should not be acceoted at face value, especially when it is irrelevant to the point: ID IS crap. You can show that empirically.