re: #51 calochortus

If we don’t have birthright citizenship, how will “real” citizenship be decided? One parent? Both parents? 7th generation birthright? Children of naturalized citizens?

Germany confers birthright citizenship to children born here to legal resident parents. My kids were born German citizens to a US father (me) and a UK mother.

I would not have a problem with amending the US Constitution that way - if we had a comprehensive and fair system of immigration and naturalization.