LGF

more options

  

Advertisement

Deseret News Attacks LGF For Publishing Facts

Thu, Feb 15, 2007 at 8:35:15 am PST

The Deseret News in Utah labels LGF an “ultraconservative web site,” because we’re concerned about the possibility of Islamic terror attacks, and unhappy with the media’s deliberate decisions to conceal information: Vitriolic e-mails zero in on ‘Muslim’. (Hat tip: LGF readers.)

And Elaine Jarvik and Deborah Bulkeley explicitly blame LGF for angry emails the paper has received, rather than examine their policy of hiding information from the public. They really don’t like it when their politically correct coverups are exposed.

On ultraconservative Web sites like littlegreenfootballs.com, the story of Monday’s shooting rampage at Trolley Square has been reduced to one fact: “Salt Lake City Killer Was a Muslim.” [A ridiculous, patently untrue assertion that shows their agenda. —ed.]

“The media did everything they could to avoid mentioning it, but it’s confirmed today that the mass murderer who terrorized a mall in Salt Lake City was a Bosnian Muslim,” reads the intro at littlegreenfootballs.com.

At MichaelSavage.com, the Muslim connection is a running-banner headline.

At jihadwatch.org, the story begins “Sudden Jihad syndrome? Maybe.”

The online stories, as well as Tuesday’s and Wednesday’s stories in the Deseret Morning News, have resulted in a barrage of vitriolic e-mails to the News from people either angry at the paper for not mentioning the religion of shooter Sulejman Talovic in Wednesday’s Web edition, or certain that because Talovic is Muslim that he must be a terrorist. [And we’re supposed to believe, apparently, that there is absolutely no connection between Islam and terrorism, and anybody who suspects one is either a racist or an ultraconservative. Or both. —ed]

There is no record that Talovic attended any of the mosques in the Salt Lake area, according to both Tarek Mosseir, a spokesman for the Islamic Society of Greater Salt Lake, or Bobby Ravish of Muslim Forum. Mosseir noted that many Bosnian Muslims are more secular than religious.

“Having lived under Soviet Union rules for decades, where religious freedom was not an option, a majority of these people” are not practicing Muslims, he added. “What I hear is that he came a couple of times at most, to Eid prayers, but I can’t confirm that he came.”

This attack from the Deseret News confirms that they were deliberately trying to hide this information from you.

UPDATE at 2/15/07 9:11:12 am:

Please note — I have not expressed any opinion on whether the mall attack was an act of jihad, personal or otherwise. I’ve raised the issue, with good reason. But I have deliberately refrained from expressing a conclusion, because we obviously do not know enough at this point to do that.

I have come to the conclusion, however, that the media are doing everything possible to hide connections to Islam in cases like this. It’s an absolutely predictable pattern, and they do it every time.

UPDATE at 2/15/07 12:02:21 pm:

Robert Spencer of Jihad Watch has also responded to the Deseret News attack piece: Deseret Morning News hits ‘ultraconservative’ websites for suggesting Salt Lake shooting was jihad-motivated.

UPDATE at 2/15/07 12:09:27 pm:

Bookworm Room has a post on the latest media meme about the SLC shootings—post-traumatic stress syndrome: Is that the reason he did it?

UPDATE at 2/17/07 9:38:41 am:

An answer to Guardian columnist Dan Glaister here: Guardian LA Correspondent Gets His Smear On.

Advertisement

690 comments

  • Comments are open and unmoderated, and do not necessarily reflect the views of Little Green Footballs.
  • Obscene, abusive, silly, or annoying remarks may be deleted, but the fact that particular comments remain on the site in no way constitutes an endorsement of their views by Little Green Footballs.
  • Posts that contain phone numbers, street addresses, email addresses or other personal information will also be deleted, as will posts that consist only of a variation on the word, "First!"
  • Comments that advocate violence will be cause for immediate banning with no appeal.
  • Disagreement and debate are welcome, but insults and abuse are not, and may cause your account to be blocked.
  • REMEMBER: posting comments at LGF is a privilege, not a right. Abuse that privilege, and your account will be blocked.

Hide comments | Jump to bottom

1 Chicken Kiev  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:36:23am

msm = enemy

2 Elric66  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:37:47am

If he wasnt a Muslim, they would be gloating.

3 skywarner  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:38:22am

Funny how when the MSM gets caught burying facts, their only defense is to attack those leveling the charges.

4 Killgore Trout  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:38:38am
Ultraconservative website


Uberfascist!

5 Chicken Kiev  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:39:08am

And I am just suuuuure the spokesman of the Islamic Society would honestly say, "Oh yes, young Suleyman was one of our most active, devout mosque-goers. We saw him every Friday!"

Taqiyyeh Bell has restaurants in Utah too.

6 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:39:56am
“The media did everything they could to avoid mentioning it, but it’s confirmed today that the mass murderer who terrorized a mall in Salt Lake City was a Bosnian Muslim,” reads the intro at littlegreenfootballs.com.

The msm doesn't seem to realize that the solution is to do their job.

7 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:40:08am
8 Joe Mama  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:40:33am

"There is no record .."

Parsing.

9 Killgore Trout  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:41:06am

Repost from the dead thread:
Dramatic Home Video Shows Utah Mall Rampage

The video isn't graphic. This is what I hear at 1:03....
Voice #1: "Allahu Ackbar"
Voice #2: "This is the police, put the gun down"

Can anyone clean up that audio?

10 Kragar (proud to be kafir)  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:41:27am

Was he a Muslim or not?

MSM Answer: Well, yes, but that is completely besides the point!

We all know damn well if this was a white kid from a christian background this would be splattered across every TV and radion in the country as "Tragedy in the Heartland" or some other catchphrase.

11 adela  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:42:03am

i would like to send them a message

12 kateca  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:42:16am

Right, and Talovic shot up the mall for no reason, just another disgruntled yout having a bad day.

13 shug  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:42:39am

Ismail Yassin Mohamed
Naveed Afzal Haq
Mohammed Reza Taheri-azar
Omeed Aziz Popal
Sulejmen Talovic


Hmmm, nothing in common here.

move along

14 Da Coyote  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:43:13am

We are only to know those things that the "experts" in the MSM want us to know. Bwahahahaha!

15 Elric66  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:43:17am

#10 Kragar (proud to be kafir) 2/15/2007 08:41AM PST

Was he a Muslim or not?

MSM Answer: Well, yes, but that is completely besides the point!

We all know damn well if this was a white kid from a christian background this would be splattered across every TV and radion in the country as "Tragedy in the Heartland" or some other catchphrase.


Yes they would. They would have damn well made sure everyone knew he was adevout Christian if it turned out that he was.

16 Pawn of the Oppressor  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:43:34am

Interesting.

It used to be "right wing". Then it was "right wing hate site". Now they're using the European moniker of "Ultraconservative". What's next, "Cowboys"? "White Supremacists"?

17 Ben Hur  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:44:35am

no tip for me

18 Shiplord Kirel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:44:41am

They can always threaten us with a "hate speech" prosecution, that seems to be the left's solution to everything these days: Criminalize all opposition because you don't have facts or logic on your side.

Hear this, left-beasts and petro-prostitutes: If you resort to force (and criminal prosecution is an act of force) you will get it back in spades.
Fuck these lying bastards and sell-outs.

Again, I am callling on any LGF member with the resources and know-how to investigate the financial dealings of dhimmi media figures and their academic allies.

19 HeatherRadish  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:44:44am
There is no record that Talovic attended any of the mosques in the Salt Lake area,

So? You can be radicalized outside of mosques.
Robert Spencer:

In October 2006, a pro-jihad internet site published a “Guide for Individual Jihad,” explaining to jihadists “how to fight alone.” It recommended, among other things, assassination with guns and running people over. Is it possible that Sulejmen Talovic and some of these others were waging this jihad of one? It is indeed, but with law enforcement officials trained only to look for signs of membership in al-Qaeda or other jihad groups, and to discount terrorism as a factor if those signs aren’t there, it is a possibility that investigators will continue to overlook.
20 demorgan  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:44:57am

“Having lived under Soviet Union rules for decades, where religious freedom was not an option, a majority of these people” are not practicing Muslims, he added. “What I hear is that he came a couple of times at most, to Eid prayers, but I can’t confirm that he came.”

Wasn't this kid 18 years old. When did he live under soviet rule....when he was 5?

21 bikermailman  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:45:51am

Methinks they doth protesteth too much...

22 kepiblanc  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:46:28am

Where I live (Denmark) decoding the MSM is straightforward :
If the article says : DANE kills man, he certainly is a Dane.
If the article says : Man kills man, it's a Muslim.
See ? - Easy.

23 mglazer  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:46:35am

The MEdia is the Enemy

Muslim Terrorism? Where?

24 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:48:14am
25 Poitiers-Lepanto  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:48:14am

The subversion of language is now complete.
Looking for facts and truth = being an ultraconservative.
The next step is sheer violence: re-education camps for the bloody "fascists" who dare SPEAK the truth.

26 loppyd  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:48:25am

So predictable....

Imagine if it had been a radical Christian who opened fire? Or some some pro-life guy gone mad?

27 Dianna  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:48:40am
“Having lived under Soviet Union rules for decades, where religious freedom was not an option, a majority of these people” are not practicing Muslims, he [Mosseir] added. “What I hear is that he came a couple of times at most, to Eid prayers, but I can’t confirm that he came.”


Bosnia was part of Yugoslavia, not the Soviet Union. And Tito, while no believer in freedom, was nowhere near as repressive as the Soviets on their best day. Religion wasn't repressed the same way. Most Bosnians (of any ethnicity) were fairly secular, but that doesn't mean anything.

Frankly, this statement is astonishing in its ignorance.

28 Ned the Red  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:48:41am

I read in one of the stories that he attended a mosque in Salt Lake City. They gave an address on 7th East. I will go back and try and find story.

29 Kragar (proud to be kafir)  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:49:00am

This sounds promising:

U.S. to shun all members of Palestinian unity govt

JERUSALEM (Reuters) - The United States will boycott all Palestinian unity government ministers, including non-Hamas members, unless international demands on policy toward Israel are met, a Palestinian official and diplomats said on Thursday.

Some U.S. officials had been advocating a shift in Washington's position that would allow limited diplomatic contacts with cabinet ministers from moderate President Mahmoud Abbas's Fatah faction and other parties.

But a senior Palestinian official said: "The Americans have informed us that they will be boycotting the new government headed by Hamas. The Fatah and independent ministers will be treated the same way that Hamas ministers are treated."

Diplomats familiar with discussions on the issue confirmed Washington's intention to shun members of a unity government unless it satisfied international calls for Hamas to recognize Israel, renounce violence and accept interim peace accords.

30 unreconstructed rebel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:49:04am

Dr. Josef Goebbels would be mighty proud of our media. Yes, he would.

31 budfox  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:49:27am

One question....

If the shooter was a Christian or a Jew, how fast would either word be placed in every headline or byline around the country?

Oh, silly me, I already know that answer!

32 Carolyn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:49:30am

Oh no, not backlash!

33 ladycatnip  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:49:31am

#10

We all know damn well if this was a white kid from a christian background this would be splattered across every TV and radion in the country as "Tragedy in the Heartland" or some other catchphrase.

You are absolutely right on the mark. Had he attended mass, church or attended a private Christian grammar school, they'd be touting him as a supressed, angry evangelical.

If he were Jewish...are there any Jewish serial killers?

The msm will only get it after the muslims are in full control of what they print according to shari'a. And even then they'll still be blaming Bush, the Christians and the Jews.

34 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:49:47am

Please write the authors of this article and tell them how pleased you are that they are so concerned about the possibility of a backlash against muslims.

jarvik@desnews.com, dbulkeley@desnews.com

Because what Elaine Jarvik and Deborah Bulkeley are saying is: Oh, all those people that were MURDERED IN COLD BLOOD, eh, too bad about them.

35 DavidJSchwartz  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:50:01am

Dear Deseret News:

In Saudi Arabia they are all Muslims, and they are our "friends." Ain't living under Shari'a laws simply wonderful?

Saudi Arabia beheads convicted Saudi murderer

Nov 19, 2006 International Herald Tribune

RIYADH, Saudi Arabia: Saudi Arabia on Sunday beheaded a Saudi man convicted of murdering his mother-in-law, the Saudi Interior Ministry said.

[Link: www.iht.com...]

36 Iron Fist  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:50:33am

It is interesting how wanting to win the WoT is now a conservative position.

37 Greg  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:50:39am

It is getting pretty clear over the past 3-4 years that 'slam is doing random acts of murder on American soil and to our citizens via guns, vehicles, bombs and MSM and the FBI/law enforcement is covering it up to preserve "harmony".

38 RedPepper  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:51:00am

Ultraconservative?

Yes, I am! More & more each day!

And proud of it, by the way ...

39 Fjordman  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:51:21am

YUSUF ISLAM 'APPALLED' AT RUSHDIE MISUNDERSTANDING

YUSUF ISLAM, the artist formerly known as CAT STEVENS, was "appalled" when newspapers accused him of calling for SALMAN RUSHDIE's head on a platter. Newspapers linked the singer to a Fatwa proclaimed after Rushdie committed blasphemy in his 1989 novel THE SATANIC VERSES. But Islam insists he merely questioned Islamic law. The 58-year-old says, "I never supported the Fatwa. "At a lecture back in 1989, I was asked a question about blasphemy according to Islamic law. I simply repeated the legal view according to my limited knowledge of the scriptural texts, based directly on the historical commentaries of the Koran (which states that blasphemy is a capital offence). "The next day, newspaper headlines read: 'Cat Says Kill Rushdie'. I was appalled."

South Africa's Democracy in Trouble

South Africa's democracy isn't looking too good these days. Not only is violent crime rampant, but so too is corruption in the upper echelons of government.

Nervous Censors and Staged Rebellion

Every year, Iran invites drama troupes from all over the world to its International Theater Festival in Tehran. The mullahs' censors keep busy, but they can't catch every offense to Islamic decency. The hard part is knowing what's taboo.

Serbia Resoundingly Dumps UN Proposal

To no one's surprise, the Serbian parliament has rejected a UN plan for Kosovo's independence. The fate of the ethnic Albanian province may now be up to the UN alone -- which isn't ideal, given that a UN police commissioner has resigned over the deaths of two protesters in Kosovo over the weekend.

Australia 'must limit Muslim immigration'

AUSTRALIA should limit Muslim immigration or a large Islamic population could pose a higher risk of violence, a visiting Jewish expert on Islam says. Professor Raphael Israeli is quoted in the Australian Jewish News as saying that without such a migration cap Australia risks being swamped by Indonesians.

“When the Muslim population gets to a critical mass you have problems,” he told Fairfax. “That is the general rule - so if it applies everywhere, it applies in Australia.” Prof Israeli, an expert on Islamic history at Hebrew University in Jerusalem, has been brought to Australia by the Shalom Institute of the University of NSW. He said Muslim immigrants had a reputation for manipulating the values of western countries, taking advantage of their hospitality and tolerance.

“When there are large Muslim populations who are prepared to use violence, you are in trouble. He said France, which has the highest proportion of Muslims in Europe at about 10 per cent, has passed a point of no return where the French “say they are strangers in their own country”.

AFGHANISTAN: PRESIDENT URGES BRITAIN TO PRESS PAKISTAN ON TALIBAN

Afghan president, Hamid Karzai, has urged Britain to intensify pressure on Pakistan over the cross-border activities of Taliban and al-Qaeda fighters. The president made the appeal during talks with British prime minister Tony Blair on Wednesday night in London, the first leg of Karzai's European tour. Afghan officials have accused Britain failing to press Pakistan president Pervez Musharraf to act because of British desires to win Pakistan's support in fighting against domestic terrorism.

40 unreconstructed rebel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:51:29am

#16 Pawn

Cowboys works for me. But, if you are in a hurry, Rednek is ok.

41 mica_ar  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:51:38am

Why does the msm spend half their time trying to convince us that muslims are peaceful, and the other half of their time telling us (as in this article) that the muslims who turn out not to be peaceful were "secular" muslims, or some such crap.

42 Chicken Kiev  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:51:39am

Soon after this story broke, and especially after the guy's name was revealed, I thought: They will spin this with sympathy for the KILLER not his victims. We will scarcely learn the names of the dead, nor will the heroic cop get properly honored for saving a whole mall full of men, women and children.

Guess I'm psychic.

43 kateca  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:51:42am

Reminds me of twenty years ago when the MSM couldn't bring themselves to mention a person's race if that person was black: "Suspect is described as a 6' tall male, black hair and brown eyes." Maybe throw in a clue like "suspect has an afro".

44 Sgt.Slappy  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:52:23am

The article continues:

Buba Roth, a spokeswoman for the Consortium of Multicultural Groups, said such reactions are evidence of a general lack of understanding of the refugee community. They are also at least partially to blame for a reluctance by many Bosnians to talk to reporters, said Roth, a Serbian who speaks for the Consortium's 26 ethnic organizations, including a Bosnian association.
"People living here 10 or more years in America still don't even feel the freedom to communicate with the media," she said. "They are so afraid, and so isolated."
Roth said she sees the potential for escalation of the harassment and is working to start discussions among refugees and the mainstream community to foster increased understanding.
"Someone needs to start communication," she said. "Maybe we will be able to express who we are. ... We are Americans, we want the best for this country."

So let's see if I got this straight...

This tragedy occurred because:
The poor, poor, misunderstood, isolated, afraid refugee (cough... you mean to say - victim?) was only trying to reach out to the community... to express his... uh, inner struggle?

Well, that makes it official. Elaine Jarvik and Deborah Bulkeley... you are apologist idiots.

45 Elric66  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:52:23am

If LGF is "ultra-conservative" what would they call Islam?

46 find your violent jihadi on ebay!  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:53:23am

Charles, you neglected to post the very best line in the article. After 3 or 4 paragraphs about the crazy right wingers who can't understand the difference between a Moslem who goes on a shooting rampage and "terrorism", and how these incidents bring the crazies out of the woodwork...

"Welcome to my world," said Ibrahim Hopper, communications director of the Council on American-Islamic Relations in Washington, D.C., about the angry e-mails.

47 Ojoe  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:54:32am

"... or certain that because Talovic is Muslim that he must be a terrorist."

Well, he WAS a terrorist because he shot innocent people at random in a mall.

“What I hear is that he came a couple of times at most, to Eid prayers, but I can’t confirm that he came."

This shows how dangerous islam is: 2 times and then kill.

This is why we have to intern/deport/proscribe.

48 Sponge  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:54:39am

msm hiding truths and seething when someone points it out? NO WAY! I'm just shocked and amazed...I don't know what to say.

49 Pawn of the Oppressor  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:54:44am
The video isn't graphic. This is what I hear at 1:03....
Voice #1: "Allahu Ackbar"
Voice #2: "This is the police, put the gun down"

That's not voice 1, it's the cop yelling something unintelligible.

Again, we have absolutely no idea what the shooter's motives were. Nobody's said anything, which either means that nobody is looking, or something is being hidden. Perhaps a combination of both.

How about we get some facts all up in this piece, doggs? Can't a news reader get some truth? Damn. Where my blogs at?

50 DavidJSchwartz  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:54:45am

Dear Deseret News:

All of us here at LGF, just love, Saudi T.V. Do you people feel the same too?

Egyptian Cleric and Former Islamic Lecturer in the U.S. Hazem Sallah Abu
Isma'il on Al-Risala TV: Lectures on the Jews' Conflicts With Islam's
Prophet Muhammad, Stating U.N. Documents Assert "82% of All Attempts to
Corrupt Humanity Originate from the Jews
"

[Link: www.memri.org...] .

In the April 14, 2006, edition of his weekly show on Al-Resala TV, The
Raids, in which he discusses the battles of the Prophet Muhammad,
Egyptian cleric Hazem Sallah Abu Isma'il explains to his audience that,
according to U.N. statistics, "Jews produce more than 82% of the video
clips in the world," and adds that "82% of all attempts to corrupt
humanity originate from the Jews."
Isma'il, a wealthy lawyer and businessman(1) who is also, according to
Al-Jazeera TV, head of the Committee for Implementation of Shari'a of
the Egyptian Lawyers' Union,(2) was a strong Muslim Brotherhood
candidate for the Dokki district in the November 2005 elections in
Egypt, but lost in a surprise upset to a member of Egyptian President
Hosni Mubarak's party. (3)

According to the Saudi channel Iqra TV, Ismail is the son of former
Egyptian MP Sheikh Sallah Abu Isma'il, and spent some time in the U.S.
with his mother Dr. Nawwal Nur, who lives in Los Angeles, with whom he
preached and taught Islam there. In a July 15, 2004 interview with Iqra
TV on the subject of 9/11, Isma'il stated that he believed that "these
events [i.e. 9/11] were fabricated from the outset as part of the global
groundwork for the distortion of Islam's image [...] a comprehensive
global plan that includes a media aspect," and that "the authorities
there [i.e. in the U.S.] don't want to conduct an investigation."

51 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:54:56am
52 Kirly  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:55:44am

This is so unfair to Charles. He takes such abuse.

Charles, I don't know how you manage to tolerate this idiocy but I appreciate you and what you do here.

Kirly

53 Ginn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:55:53am

Because of LGF the people who read the Desert News will find out that the shooter was a Muslim and then the readers can make up their own minds as to whether this person's rampage may have been related to his "religion."

Thanks LGF and those who emailed this paper.

54 raz  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:55:55am

MSM = Muslim Submitted Media.

In my country it is the
BBC = British Broadcasting Caphilate.

What's yours called?

55 GordonMcStraun  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:56:16am

#9

Hard to make out. Can't say for sure until the audio is cleaned up. Would have thought that the police and eyewitnesses would have been able to tell though.

56 American Soldier  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:56:21am
"Welcome to my world," said Ibrahim Hopper, communications director of the Council on American-Islamic Relations in Washington, D.C........."

The world of terrorists, Dougie?

57 Just_A_Grunt  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:56:44am

Anybody remember the good old days, just a couple of years ago when people and the MSM pooh-poohed the denizens of the internet and made comments about how this phenomheum of blogs was just a fad and would soon fade. And here we are in 2007 being used as fact checkers and truth tellers with the old last century media in the position of having to attack or debunk what appears on the blogs. Well nobody was upset at the Braves until they mad it to the World Series and suddenly folks were offended by the team name.

58 Ward Cleaver  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:56:48am

Who'd have ever thought Salt Lake would go dhimmi?

59 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:56:50am
This attack from the Deseret News confirms that they were deliberately trying to hide this information from you.


Standard tactic of shoot the messenger. Charles must have pushed a button. Keep up the good work, and more readers and viewers will slip away from the clutches of the msm.

60 unreconstructed rebel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:56:58am

#36 Ironfist

This Vietnam vet is pretty upset with the goins on in Congress just now. Never thought I would live to see the day. Five years of unrelenting propaganda has taken its toll, I guess.

61 Killgore Trout  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:57:34am

#32 Carolyn

Wedged into the door jamb was a sealed envelope with one hand-written and underlined word: “Sorry.” Inside it, visible through the address window, were $20 bills.


That's a thick envelope too. I'd guess there's about $3,000 in there.

62 Shiplord Kirel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:57:46am

#24 buzzsawmonkey

I wonder--if someone shot up a newspaper office, would that be an example of PMSM* Syndrome? Would the newspapers report it as such? Would the religious or political affiliation of the shooter be considered relevant?

That depends. If he were an Evangelical, even by the most extreme and obvious stretch of definitions or associations, that fact would become the basis for 24/7 coverage demonizing everyone with a remotely similar belief system. Leftist media, after all, manage to equate anti-abortion terrorists (7 dead in 25 years) with Islamic dictators (millions dead in 25 years).
They are capable of anything.
In the unlikely event that the shooter is a Muslim, the media beasts will privately blame themselves for being insufficiently sensitive to Muslim concerns. Publicly, they will blame the evil right-wing hate speakers for driving the perp to acts of irrational acts of desperation and inciting an attack on innocents.

63 Ginn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:58:03am

#36 Iron Fist 2/15/2007 08:50AM PST

It is interesting how wanting to win the WoT is now a conservative position.

Ultraconservative, babe, Ultra conservative

64 TalkinKamel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:58:04am

#51 taxfreekiller

LOL! Yes, I'm sure you-know-who is going to pop up any minute now, to tell us the proper way to interpret this article, and how we're really misunderstanding the whole thing.

65 THX-42  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:58:10am

The MSM is logic-challenged and truth-challenged. Deseret suggests that unless there is incontrovertible evidence (like what? a map of the mall signed by an imam, along with printed orders to kill infidels?) that the killer was on a mosque-ordered mission, they shouldn't mention that he was a muslim.

Newspapers have gotten completely away from the original hallmark of objective reporting: the 5 W's (who, what, when, where, why). It's all agenda-driven, minority-sensitive, multi-culti-protecting editorials masquerading as news.

In this case, the fact the perpetrator was a Bosnian muslim immigrant is a relevant fact (who AND why). There have been a series of similar incidents across the country of "sudden jihad syndrome" by individuals from similar circumstances (young male, immigrant, muslim).

Just give us the facts and let US determine if they are relevant to the story and to how we should protect ourselves and our families.

66 father_of_10  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:58:17am

Could you imagine what the MSM would be saying if this nutcase jihadist murderer was a Mormon? I'd like to know why these reporters are not doing the investigative journalism that ought to be REQUIRED of them. Why haven't they interviewed every neighbor and aquaintance of this kid. Why have they not grilled the local imams about him? Where is the picture on the front page of the Deseret News of the mosque where this kid went to services? I want to see copies of the receipts of the stores where he bought the ammo and the guns!

67 Sponge  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:58:39am
Diplomats familiar with discussions on the issue confirmed Washington's intention to shun members of a unity government unless it satisfied international calls for Hamas to recognize Israel, renounce violence and accept interim peace accords.

HOW EFFING DARE THEY!

68 Ward Cleaver  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:58:58am

#15 Elric66

They'd have called him one of those "Jesus Camp nuts".

69 jimash  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:59:15am

I couldn't download the video, but I could turn it up real loud.
boom
Alklahhuakhbar
boom boom boom
Allahhuakhbar
This is the poilice get on your knees
Boom Boom Boom
Allahhuakhbar
multiple booms

70 Killgore Trout  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:59:18am

#49 Pawn of the Oppressor
You might be right, I really wish the audio was better.

71 father_of_10  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:00:35am

Is this where our young murdering terrorist hung out?
SLC Mosque

72 jill e  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:00:41am

So what if this guy had instead had explosives strapped to his back and walked into the mall. Would the reaction have been any different? Certainly the result would have been the same—innocents killed by a terrorist.

73 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:00:42am
Having lived under Soviet Union rules for decades, where religious freedom was not an option, a majority of these people” are not practicing Muslims...

Uhhh.....hello? Soviet Union? Are you really that ignorant of history and geography?

74 uptight  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:00:43am

If the killer had been a member of Aryan Nations, would they have hushed that up?

Would they have deemed his political views to have no relevance to the killing?

Would they have worried about slurring all Nazis as killers?

No. They would have rightly thought "there could be a link here" and reported it.

Islam is not the same as Nazism, but both are belief systems that inspire people to acts of murder and violence. I know it's not politically correct to say this, but it is factually correct.

Sure - most Muslims are not going to go on kill sprees in the name of Allah, but whilst a significant number are going to perform "physical Jihad", the religion of Islam is involved.

75 NoSubmission  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:00:44am

#45 Elric66

If LGF is "ultra-conservative" what would they call Islam?

Good question.

76 AtlasShrugged  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:01:20am

never ever stop

we count on you

everyday

77 WriterMom  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:01:40am

Ibrahim Hooper and his "WELCOME TO MY WORLD" can shove it up his wazoo. No thanks-I will NEVER ENTER YOUR SICK WORLD.

La la la, mosque spokesman says he just was there MAYBE ONE OR TWO TIMES IN HIS WHOLE LIFE WE DON'T KNOW HIM LA LA LA SOME MUSLIMS ARE SECULAR LA LA LA.

TAQIY-O-RAMA!

78 unreconstructed rebel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:01:41am

#54 raz

NBC = Nothing But Calumny

79 Ward Cleaver  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:02:13am

#46 find your violent jihadi on ebay!

They go to the usual suspects.

Hopper? BWAHAHAHAHAHAHA!

80 wanumba  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:02:21am
There is no record that Talovic attended any of the mosques in the Salt Lake area, according to both Tarek Mosseir, a spokesman for the Islamic Society of Greater Salt Lake, or Bobby Ravish of Muslim Forum

.
This is just like those statements, "There are no recorded accounts of Killer Whales attacking people."
Yah. Mr. Eskimo went out in the kayak and never came back. No one ever saw him again. No record is not the same as

never done it

, but that's how it's always used. Saw a similar quote recently, "There is no credible record of mountain lions in Colorado attacking people." That was the standard line before ... well, it's effect was to lull people into a false sense of security while in the hunting grounds of predators. A few people have already paid with their lives. Just cause some lion sightings turned out to be bobcats and white labradors doesn't mean there isn't a problem out there.

Mosseir noted that many Bosnian Muslims are more secular than religious.


True enough, but conversely, "Many Bosnian Muslims are more religious than secular." It's also more intense, those people had a nasty civil war there that ran along religious lines, and NATO troops are still stationed in the Balkans.
Conclusion: wishful thinking is no substitute for a proper, and thorough, unbiased investigation. All the population wants to know is the truth, no matter which way it pans out.

that there is absolutely no connection between Islam and terrorism, and anybody who suspects one is either a racist


Pathetic that this statement had the appelation -ed after it as in editor. They should go back to the dictionary and look up the words, racist and then

Islam

. Tomorrow's correction: "We regret to note that we incorrectly used "racist" ..." Or is that wishful thinking?

81 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:02:22am

Another fine example of the depth of knowledge of a journalist.

82 FabioC.  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:03:13am

I think that religion and ethnicity (if known with sufficient precision) of a perp should always be reported, clearly but without undue emphasis - I'm talking about media intended for a wide public here; not outlets catering to a public with specific political views.

So, I don't think that a headline there should be "Muslim Slaughters Seven", but the religion of who did that shouldn't remain a secret either.

Anyone knows if the perp left a martyrdom video or somesuch, or yelled "Allah akbar" during the shooting spree? That's sure proof of SJS.

83 Kenneth  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:03:31am
“Having lived under Soviet Union rules for decades, where religious freedom was not an option, a majority of these people” are not practicing Muslims, he added. “What I hear is that he came a couple of times at most, to Eid prayers, but I can’t confirm that he came.”

Wrong: Yugoslavia was NOT part of the Soviet Union nor was it part of the Warsaw Pact. People were free to practive religion in the former Yugoslavia, provided the clergy did not critisize the government.

During the Bosnian civil wars of the 1990's, many mujahedin came from the Muslim world including Afghan Arab veterans and lots of Saudi money. The Bosnian mosques were radicalized during this period.

84 Carolyn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:03:32am

Killgore Trout ,
Is that not the craziest thing you've ever seen?
"WE are so sorry we had to be in front of your son's shotgun blasts!"

85 dicentra  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:03:33am

I don't know if it's a good idea to accuse the Deseret News of being deliberately obtuse ("ultraconservative" label notwithstanding). It's not what you'd call a bastion of MSM thought. It's owned by the LDS church and has traditionally been more conservative than its historic rival, The Salt Lake Tribune.

I am a long-time fan of LGF, but I think you guys have it wrong this time. The kid was probably a MINO, Muslim in name only, who was also disaffected and psychotic and trying to assimilate into a new culture (which is no piece of cake, BTW). The neighborhood he lived in was none too wealthy, and he had loner tendencies.

If he was waging jihad, he'd have at least popped off a good "Allahu akbar" at some point, but he didn't. It sounds more like your basic Columbine syndrome than jihad. This time, anyway. Don't lose perspective, lizards. Don't earn the reputation the LLL continually tries to foist on you. Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar.

86 THX-42  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:03:49am

#58 Ward Cleaver

Who'd have ever thought Salt Lake would go dhimmi?


In case you haven't noticed, EVERY state capital, even in red states, is a bastion of blue bastards. The reason is simple. They are overrun with state government workers, lawyers, unions, and teachers. These are the new communists ("neo-comms"). Socialist, multi-culti, eco-theology, Bush-haters.

87 TalkinKamel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:03:53am

#61 Kilgore Trout

If it is around $3,000.00 or so, that's an awful lot just to say you're sorry. (Wouldn't a sympathy card have done as well?)

Is this some sort of pay-off to the family, for giving a shaheed to martyrdom? Maybe, or maybe somebody really is just sorry, but I hope, I really, really, really, really hope that somebody is investigating this, and that it's not just going to be all swept under the rug as some poor soul just going nuts, donchaknow, and acting out his pain at our uncaring society.

Some questions:

1. Who was he in contact with, during those last few days before the killings? Has anybody taken a look at his cell phone? His computer?

2. How did he get the gun? Did somebody help him? Who? Where did he learn to shoot? Who taught him?

3. Was he holding a Koran during the shootings? One witness says he was. Can we clear this up? It's an important detail.

Look, there's are a lot of questions here; I hope they get answered, and that they we don't just get the usual pat on the head and "Move along, nothing to see here!"

88 Cartman  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:03:55am

Personally, the jury is still out with regards to this scumbag's motivation. Yet, I guarantee you one given - this incident will be railroaded towards renewed liberal attacks on the 2nd Amendment. Count on it.

89 Ward Cleaver  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:04:11am

CBS:

Caliphate

Broadcasting

System

90 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:04:15am

If Bosnia was part of the USSR, Nova Scotia is part of New England.......

91 Elric66  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:04:21am
#75 NoSubmission 2/15/2007 09:00AM PST

#45 Elric66


If LGF is "ultra-conservative" what would they call Islam?
Good question.

Perhaps the Deseret News can answer that since Im sure they are lurking. Excuse me Deseret News. Could you please answer the question? :-)

92 WriterMom  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:05:04am

#45 Elric66

If LGF is "ultra-conservative" what would they call Islam?

Duh-uh. What are ya, shtooopid?

"Islam-a RELIGION OF PEACE, with a TINY MINORITY of adherants, WHO DO NOT REPRESENT ISLAM, and who have HIJACKED ISLAM and given a very bad name to the majority of peaceful, loving, kumbaya-singing Muslims."

93 Ward Cleaver  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:05:13am

#86 THX-42

Dallas is heading that direction, too. Getting bluer by the day.

94 Ginn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:05:17am
There is no record that Talovic attended any of the mosques in the Salt Lake area, according to both Tarek Mosseir, a spokesman for the Islamic Society of Greater Salt Lake, or Bobby Ravish of Muslim Forum

Was does attending a local mosque have anything to do with this? How lucky for the Islamists that if someone does a single terrorist attack here in the US as long as they aren't dressed in camouflage and wearing a ski mask while chanting Arabic then the MSM will not include the info that this mass murderer, for no apparent reason, killed a bunch of people, happened to also be a Muslim.

If the killer in Salt Lake City had been Jewish, Evangelical, ect.. you can bet the headlines would something like this:

Jewish Man Goes On Rampage In Mall

95 Shiplord Kirel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:05:31am

#74 uptight

If the killer had been a member of Aryan Nations, would they have hushed that up?
Would they have deemed his political views to have no relevance to the killing?
Would they have worried about slurring all Nazis as killers?

Given the way things are going, they might have. The dhimmi media have no trouble concealing the Nazi ideology of the Iranian regime, for example, and they have completely ignored the massive and well-financed influx of recycled Nazi propaganda onto college campuses.

96 Pawn of the Oppressor  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:05:32am

44 Sgt.Slappy

The article continues:


Buba Roth, a spokeswoman for the Consortium of Multicultural Groups, said such reactions are evidence of a general lack of understanding of the refugee community. They are also at least partially to blame for a reluctance by many Bosnians to talk to reporters, said Roth, a Serbian who speaks for the Consortium's 26 ethnic organizations, including a Bosnian association.
"People living here 10 or more years in America still don't even feel the freedom to communicate with the media," she said. "They are so afraid, and so isolated."
Roth said she sees the potential for escalation of the harassment and is working to start discussions among refugees and the mainstream community to foster increased understanding.
"Someone needs to start communication," she said. "Maybe we will be able to express who we are. ... We are Americans, we want the best for this country."
So let's see if I got this straight...

This tragedy occurred because:
The poor, poor, misunderstood, isolated, afraid refugee (cough... you mean to say - victim?) was only trying to reach out to the community... to express his... uh, inner struggle?

Well, that makes it official. Elaine Jarvik and Deborah Bulkeley... you are apologist idiots.

How are they idiots for pointing out the proven fact that people who come here from repressive, war-torn shitholes usually feel isolated and afraid of the police and the media? And that immediately tarring and feathering a whole group of people based on the actions of one asshole teenager doesn't help the situation any, especially when we have absolutely no idea what the shooter's motivation was yet?

Yeah, they quoted some scuzzbag from CAIR, but they have a point: there's a whole lot of bigoted bullshit being posted in here lately.

In the meantime, it would be nice if Desert News would spend as much time digging into the reality of this event as they did worrying about what some jerks on a blog think. How many of us even live in Utah? Come on.

97 easy  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:06:22am
98 Atoz  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:06:29am

#28 Ned

I read in one of the stories that he attended a mosque in Salt Lake City. They gave an address on 7th East. I will go back and try and find story.


Interesting. That mosque is only a block from the mall he shot up.

99 mglazer  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:06:36am

These people are ignorant

They have chosen to ignore reality

They choose what to publish and allow others to read as truth

They are peddlers of lies

The media is the enemy

follow them at your own peril

100 uptight  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:06:42am

Also, just because LGF and its readers oppose the extreme lunatic left, that doesn't make them conservative (although some of us may be).

Opposing fascism is something that liberals should do (if they weren't too busy getting into bed with it).

101 Q-Burn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:07:39am

Isn't the Deseret News owned by the Mormons? Maybe these weird religions that start with "M" are all in cahoots...

102 Sponge  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:07:39am

As stated in a blog earlier today:

"Welcome to my world," said Ibrahim Hopper, communications director of the Council on American-Islamic Relations in Washington, D.C., about the angry e-mails. "I get tons of it every day."
On Wednesday, in response to a CAIR effort to find photos of American Muslims for a special project, the group received a phone call from someone asking sarcastically, "Do you want a picture of the guy in Salt Lake?"


ibrahim. Please allow me to explain something to you. Your a member of a group that touts that islham is not here to mingle with other religions, it's here to be the ONLY religion. That in itself is a declaration of jiha(m)d toward all religious belief other than your own in this country. You, your group and your religion REFUSES to denounce terrorism, your imams and leaders constantly preach about jiha(m)d and death to the west and yours is the DOMINANT RELIGION in suicide bombings, beheadings and warfare.

GEE! I WONDER why AMERICANS look at a muslham and wonder 'IS HE WEARING A BOMB under his coat?'

Its high time you pull your head out of your ASS and 1....tell the TRUTH about your religion and 2....become TOLLERANT of AMERICA for what IT STANDS for, or MOVE your sorry jiha(m)dist BUTT TO A nation that is ALREADY shri'lla law.

103 WriterMom  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:07:49am

#96 POTO

Consortium of Multicultural Groups

Feh. They lost me at "consortium". What a sniffy, stupid word for special interest victimization groups to whine about how mean people are.

104 Pawn of the Oppressor  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:08:02am

88 Cartman 2/15/2007 09:03AM PST

Personally, the jury is still out with regards to this scumbag's motivation. Yet, I guarantee you one given - this incident will be railroaded towards renewed liberal attacks on the 2nd Amendment. Count on it.

That ship has sailed. He used a shotgun, and it must not have had black plastic furniture, otherwise it would have been shown on a table at a press conference already. There's no grist for the "Assault weapons" or "high capacity handgun" mill.

Then again, Utah is relatively pro-firearms, so maybe the local PD wouldn't have felt the need to show off and demonize the gun.

105 Occasional Reader  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:08:02am
or certain that because Talovic is Muslim that he must be a terrorist.

Actually, for me, my first inkling that he just might be a terrorist was the whole "shooting random people at point-blank range with a 12-gauge" thing.

106 Ginn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:08:02am

85 dicentra

If he was waging jihad, he'd have at least popped off a good "Allahu akbar" at some point, but he didn't

I disagree. You are stereotyping what a Jihadi would or should be saying while shooting people.

You just made my point in my last post, 94.

107 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:08:07am

#85 dicentra

I am a long-time fan of LGF, but I think you guys have it wrong this time. The kid was probably a MINO, Muslim in name only, who was also disaffected and psychotic and trying to assimilate into a new culture (which is no piece of cake, BTW).

Who cares? That didn't stop the MSM from plastering all over the world that McVeigh was a Christian (even though he was an agnostic). The story isn't the shooter, the story isn't that he was muslim. The story is the corrupt dishonesty and incompitance (USSR my butt) of this media outlet, whether or not you consider them MSM.

108 Ward Cleaver  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:08:16am
Having lived under Soviet Union rules for decades, where religious freedom was not an option, a majority of these people”

Uh, hello, they were Warsaw Pact, but not Soviet Union.

109 Elric66  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:08:27am
#92 WriterMom 2/15/2007 09:05AM PST

#45 Elric66

If LGF is "ultra-conservative" what would they call Islam?

Duh-uh. What are ya, shtooopid?

"Islam-a RELIGION OF PEACE, with a TINY MINORITY of adherants, WHO DO NOT REPRESENT ISLAM, and who have HIJACKED ISLAM and given a very bad name to the majority of peaceful, loving, kumbaya-singing Muslims."


Good point. Bad Muslims hasve been highjacking Islam and giving Islam a bad name. I blame Mohammed because he started the highjacking of Islam. :-)

110 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:08:48am
#45 Elric66

If LGF is "ultra-conservative" what would they call Islam?

75 NoSubmission

Good Question.

Fascist comes to mind.

111 uptight  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:09:10am

#95 Shiplord Kirel

Ah, but the Iranians are poor desert people oppressed by the bushitler.

112 phoenixgirl  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:09:15am

remember in SF the muslim ran his car into a bunch of people?

113 WriterMom  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:09:39am

#105 O.R

'zactly

114 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:09:44am

#94 Ginn

If the killer in Salt Lake City had been Jewish, Evangelical, ect.. you can bet the headlines would something like this:

Jewish Man Goes On Rampage In Mall

Exactly. GMTA.

115 unreconstructed rebel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:09:47am

#100 uptight.

Opposing Supporting fascism is something that liberals should do.

Sorry to do that, but when a liberal crosses the socialist bridge, he becomes a fascist.

116 HeatherRadish  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:09:51am

#36 Iron Fist

It is interesting how wanting to win the WoT is now a conservative position.

It kind of always was. To conserve something is to attempt to prevent it from being destroyed. If you believe America and its attendant freedom is something worth keeping from being destroyed by Islamofascism (or any other form of fascism), that's a conservative idea.

117 Elric66  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:10:08am

#112 phoenixgirl 2/15/2007 09:09AM PST

remember in SF the muslim ran his car into a bunch of people?


Happened in NC also

118 jrdroll  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:10:08am

#85

If he was waging jihad, he'd have at least popped off a good "Allahu akbar" at some point, but he didn't.

He may have "Allahu akbarred"

119 amphibian  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:10:16am

#47 Ojoe:

"... or certain that because Talovic is Muslim that he must be a terrorist."

Well, he WAS a terrorist because he shot innocent people at random in a mall.

That makes him a murderer, not necessarily a terrorist. He might have gotten the idea to go shoot him some kaffirs by spending time on the wrong web sites, but I would guess that he was more Columbine or amok than regular jihadnik. If I were to learn that his mosque attendence was regular or went up recently, I would revise my opinion.

120 Carolyn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:10:16am
#85 dicentra

I am a long-time fan of LGF, but I think you guys have it wrong this time. The kid was probably a MINO, Muslim in name only, who was also disaffected and psychotic and trying to assimilate into a new culture (which is no piece of cake, BTW).

Let's face it, islam is a mental condition in itself.

121 Charles  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:10:28am

dicentra: please note -- I have not expressed any opinion on whether the attack was an act of jihad, personal or otherwise. I've raised the issue, with good reason. But I have deliberately refrained from expressing a conclusion, because we obviously do not know enough at this point to do that.

I have come to the conclusion, however, that the media are doing everything possible to hide connections to Islam in cases like this. It's an absolutely predictable pattern, and they do it every time.

122 Jeff MacMillan  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:10:56am

I love it. They say, "More secular than religious."

What the heck is that kind of speak? You are either 100% secular or you are simply not secular.

If they are suggesting here that he doesn't go to Mosques and therefore isn't religious enough to be deemed Islamo-Terror material, then I would like to know what MOSQUE have the Islamic Terrorists in Guantanomo Bay Cuba have gone to recently?

123 Occasional Reader  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:11:09am

#83 Kenneth:

Wrong: Yugoslavia was NOT part of the Soviet Union nor was it part of the Warsaw Pact.

Good catch.

124 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:11:12am

And if you really want to be sick read the rest of their coverage of this nutjob murderer:

By Ben Winslow
Desert Morning News
and Nedim Hasic
Slobodna Bosna

As a little boy in Bosnia-Herzegovina, Sulejman Talovic hid in fear from the Serb military forces who were slaughtering Muslim men and boys as war and genocide ravaged his country.

A world away, those who knew him say he was an "ordinary kid" with dreams of America, and they are unable to comprehend that he could have committed such a crime.

"I know all Talovic family," said Omer Johic, who was a neighbor of the Talovic family in the Bosnian village of Cerska, near Srebrenica. "Everybody are nice, quiet and fine people, and I just cannot believe that Sulejman has been able to kill those people."

'We are good people'

Omerovic said Talovic was not a terrorist.
"I want to make sure that people don't think about us that we are terrorists or something like that," she said. "We are good people, just like everybody, and we want to be nice to everybody."

Talovic's family wants to know where he got the guns, suggesting he did not have them at home.
"We want to know who signed for the guns and all the things that he had with him," Omerovic said. "We don't have any ideas how he get all that. We want to find who did that."

A child of war

The atrocities of war and "ethnic cleansing," and the pressures of daily life in a new country after he immigrated to the United States, could have created immense pressure on Talovic,

Hopes for a better life

But life here in Utah has been a struggle for the family.
"We came here to America to survive from war and to be good with every people," Omerovic said.

See? He was just a poor victim. And if we would have just been nicer to him he wouldn't have felt a need to go out and MURDERED a bunch of people.

Poor kid. Don't you feel sorry for him?

A child of violence: Talovic survived genocide

He survived genocide? WRONG. He's a MURDERER.

I swear touchy-feely do gooders like the Desert News and Ben Winslow who want to lie me into thinking this kid is the victim here really piss me off.

The man MURDERED five people Desert News, and you seem to care less about them. What a farking joke.

125 mglazer  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:11:25am

Journalists or purveyors of Lies and Islamists propaganda and false information

Head meet sand

no thanks

126 Abu Maven  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:11:41am

NY Times is fretting about the "anti-Bosnian backlash."

Anti-Bosnian Backlash Feared in Utah

By KIRK JOHNSON
Published: February 15, 2007
SALT LAKE CITY, Feb. 14 — Most of the thousands of Bosnians living in the Salt Lake City area are refugees of war, and all of them are toughened by the experience of making new lives in a new country.

[Link: www.nytimes.com...]

Those dangerous Mormons...

127 Beagle  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:11:58am

We're going to have to get used to being slaughtered in droves by Muslims. It's a small price to pay in order to support the fantasy all religions and cultures are the same.

/At least I'm joking when I say it.

009.005
YUSUFALI: But when the forbidden months are past, then fight and slay the Pagans wherever ye find them, an seize them, beleaguer them, and lie in wait for them in every stratagem (of war); but if they repent, and establish regular prayers and practise regular charity, then open the way for them: for Allah is Oft-forgiving, Most Merciful.


Sounds like one of them opened the damn book again!

128 TalkinKamel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:12:06am

#92 WriterMom

ROFL! That's great!

{WriterMom}

(At this point, it's usually obligatory to mention Moslem unhappiness over the Crusades, and the modern day state of Israel. Also, the noble Saladin, who was extremely noble, and Andalusia---ever heard of Andalusia? It was a really, really swell place! And Moslems invented soap and algebra.)

129 j-damn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:12:20am
“Having lived under Soviet Union rules for decades, where religious freedom was not an option, a majority of these people” are not practicing Muslims, he added.

Tim McVeigh wasn't a "practicing" Christian either, but that doesn't stop leftists from throwing his name in your face if you discuss the preponderence of Mohammedans among the rank of terrorists.

130 SlothB77  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:12:22am
There is no record that Talovic attended any of the mosques in the Salt Lake area, according to both Tarek Mosseir, a spokesman for the Islamic Society of Greater Salt Lake, or Bobby Ravish of Muslim Forum. Mosseir noted that many Bosnian Muslims are more secular than religious.

careful now, you don't want to motivate someone to dig into that one, Deseret. You may be scared what they might find. Things you are unwilling to report.

131 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:12:31am
132 JammieWearingFool  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:12:55am

First they came for Rush Limbaugh and he only increased in popularity.

Then they came for Fox News, now the No. 1 television news outlet in the nation.

Now they've come for LGF, which will only further increase this audience and decrease theirs.

If these twits did any basic research, they're realize hundreds of blogs reported basically the same information as LGF; yet they single out only a few, knowing the power you have.

133 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:13:38am

#116 HeatherRadish

It is interesting how wanting to win the WoT is now a conservative position.

It kind of always was. To conserve something is to attempt to prevent it from being destroyed. If you believe America and its attendant freedom is something worth keeping from being destroyed by Islamofascism (or any other form of fascism), that's a conservative idea.

Therefore, the opposite of conservative is nihilist. The Nazis were NOT conservative.

134 mglazer  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:14:13am

If the person ahd any religios affiliationa t all it woudl have been noted especailyl one of the hated religions

i.e. judeo-christian

But one of the loved ones i.e feared i.e. terrorism works
that is hidden

A better question is why?

Why would a 'journalist' hide known information?

The root cause of terrorism is its success

This is one of the successes of islamic terrorism

Getting American's so fearfull of being honest and listing facts

Terrorism works - we see the effects everyday

135 "Oh no...Sand People!"  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:14:21am

“Having lived under Soviet Union rules for decades, where religious freedom was not an option, a majority of these people” are not practicing Muslims...

I spent two years in Bulgaria, and from approximately 1380 A.D. - 1908 A.D. (500+ years) the Bulgars and Slavs were under what they call "Tyrskoto Robstvo"...The Turkish Yoke (Ottoman Empire).

During that time Christian Churches were turned into execution chambers. Just visit a small village, Batak. In Batak more than 2000 Christians were forced into a church by the muslims and locked in it. You can still see the 2 foot high blood ring on the church walls. People dug 4 feet with nothing but BARE HANDS, and various items that could be found in the church, through solid stone and rock trying to reach water. Cannibalism ensued and the skeletons are still there. The church there is now a museum/memorial.

The muslims did their best to force the bulgar/slavs to convert to Islam by holding knives under the chins of the people. So if they didn't deny the Christian belief the knife would then be shoved up into the head. The Christians adapted accordingly and the practice still stands today, that in order to survive, they would move their head from left to right and not up and down to say 'yes'. So when the knife was under there chin and they were asked, "Are you a christian?" They would turn the head left and right. The muslims felt it meant no, yet the christians knew it was 'yes'. They still nod that way. Nodding the head up and down means 'No', left to right, right to left means 'yes'. It took me a while to get used to it.

You can't tell me that about 50 years of communism is going to have the ability to wipe out 500 years of Ottoman Empire reign?
You can take Israel out of Egypt...but it's a lot harder to take the Egypt out of Israel...(Old Testament Metaphor).

Now Bulgaria is 13% Muslim...Bosnia is ALOT HIGHER in the percentages.

136 TalkinKamel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:14:32am

#126 Abu Maven

There will be no backlash. There wasn't one after 9/11, and there won't be one now.

This constant talk about "backlash" and "Islamophobia" is a slander against the American people, who are depicted as bloodthristy brutes, eager to attack minorities----whcih is the Marxist/Gramscian vision fo them, to be sure. (Hey, Babba, we need you here!)

137 Just_A_Grunt  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:14:45am
There is no record that Talovic attended any of the mosques in the Salt Lake area, according to both Tarek Mosseir, a spokesman for the Islamic Society of Greater Salt Lake, or Bobby Ravish of Muslim Forum


Are they trying to say that only muslims who go to a mosque are prone to acts of violence? If that is what they are inferring isn't this good enough reason to close them down? I would think that a devout Muslim who attended mosque regularly would be overwhelmed by feelings of good will since it a RoP&reg.
Why did they feel it necessary to point out that he hadn't attended any mosque?

138 NoSubmission  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:14:59am

124 Geepers

A child of war
The atrocities of war and "ethnic cleansing," and the pressures of daily life in a new country after he immigrated to the United States, could have created immense pressure on Talovic,


Sounds like the press would like to let him go free. Maybe he just needs a hug and some nice warm cocoa.

139 JammieWearingFool  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:15:11am

MSM perspective: Seven years after Columbine, we're still hearing about it.

Three days after this, nary a blip on the national radar.

Selective reporting to fit an agenda.

140 Carolyn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:15:27am

Did you see this comment at the video site?
I can not believe it.

Once again cops in America killing people. You give cops in America the SLIGHTEST reason and they will unload 90 rounds of .40 cal in you from 6 different directions. Its funny because you would think a few slugs to the chest/leg/arm areas would be enough to bring a person down and then see if they want to fight or give up, but no they gotta unload on you until you are a leaking pile of meat. This is sickening man, im tired of seeing cops abuse their power. They have a tough and dangerous job, but they never aim to wound they ALWAYS aim at the head and they always shoot way more shots than are necessary. The judge and jury should make the decision on if the kid loses his life or not; not some cop with a .40 cal. Their job description is PROTECT AND SERVE, not "shoot people that have guns". Clear the area of civilians (protect) and call in the negotiatiors and follow their instructions (serve), stop trying to be Chuck Norris with a pistol just because you can.
Posted 2 hours ago by "WhyFightForFossilFuels?"
141 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:15:32am
142 Occasional Reader  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:15:37am

#124 Geepers:

As a little boy in Bosnia-Herzegovina, Sulejman Talovic hid in fear from the Serb military forces who were slaughtering Muslim men and boys as war and genocide ravaged his country.

Well, I guess the intrepid Mr. Winslow's reporting helps explain why Elie Wiesel and Primo Levi perpetrated all those spree killings in the 1950s and 60s.

What?! They didn't?!

143 RedPepper  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:15:54am

dicentra #85: Yes, the fact that Talovic was a Muslim does not necessarily prove that was his motive to commit these murders.

However. It is still a load of PC bull-bleep to deliberately suppress that fact lest the toothless moron rubes get the "wrong idea" !

144 deadbackpacker  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:15:59am

ABC

Americans Broadcasting for the Caliphate

145 WriterMom  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:16:29am

#124 Geepers
#126 Abu Maven

PUKE. That didn't take long. SPIN, MY PRETTY LITTLE LIBERAL JOURNALISTS, SPIN!

This will continue ad nauseum with several themes:

-even if shooter was a jihadi, not all Muslims are jihadis
-Muslims had many bad things happen to them, so we must understand that sometimes Muslims might do bad things
-nothing anyway could be as bad as the JOOOOOOOOOS

146 Ginn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:16:42am

124 Geepers

Such solace to the victim's family that the person who murdered those they loved in cold blood had such a good reason to kill them.

////

147 doppelganglander  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:17:02am

Maybe the kid was a jihadi wannabe, maybe he was just a nut, but we have a right to know as much as can be known, and the so-called journalists are not doing their job. Are they afraid of what they might find out? They all fancy themselves brave, speaking-truth-to-power types, but they're going to be the first ones to stick their asses in the air five times a day to save their skins.

148 StinkHammer  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:17:04am

OT

If THIS doesn't make a patriotic American proud, then I'd suggest you aren't one.

/Bravo, Bert Brady

149 formercorpsman  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:17:19am

This sets the perfect contrast to how modern liberalism affects cognition.

They are disgusted to think out there exists a group thought that automatically becomes suspicious in light of events such as this. In there terms, bigoted.

Realize the credibility of a similar thought process, however, when the shoe is on the other foot.

Roth said she

sees the potential for escalation of the harassment

and is working to start discussions among refugees and the mainstream community to foster increased understanding.

Amazing.

150 Shiplord Kirel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:17:19am

Our attacks on Serbia and Serbian affiliated forces may go down in history as the worst injustice and crime ever committed by this country. Ironically, it is the only recent military action that had any substantial support from the left.

How bad were guys like Milosevic, in reality? How much do we really know about his crimes, and how much was driven by the pro-Muslim agenda of the media-industrial complex? The mass graves of Muslim victims in Kosovo, for example, have yet to be found; but hundreds of churches have been burned.

151 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:17:41am

#136 TalkinKamel

This constant talk about "backlash" and "Islamophobia" is a slander against the American people

Absolutely.

152 DavidJSchwartz  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:18:11am
There is no record that Talovic attended any of the mosques in the Salt Lake area, according to both Tarek Mosseir, a spokesman for the Islamic Society of Greater Salt Lake, or Bobby Ravish of Muslim Forum. Mosseir noted that many Bosnian Muslims are more secular than religious.

Dear Elaine Jarvik and Deborah Bulkeley:

I am terribly sorry you received "angry" emails. On the other hand, my heart goes out to the innocent victims in Salt Lake City butchered and murdered at the hands of the criminal mass murderer for no reason.

I would like to point out a few points for you to ponder and consider:

1) We do not see any evidence to the contrary that the teenager didn't attend any Mosque or obtain any terrorist-Jihadi brainwashing or pulled Islamic snuff porn off the Internet;

2) The spokesperson for the Islamic Society of SLC, gave us no reason or reasons why a Bosnian Muslim would kill 3 innocents for no reason;

3) We are suspect in America of the pervasive media attempts at both whitewashing and covering up crimes by U.S. Muslim Nationals and/or citizens by always saying or implying that it was done as a "lone" criminal act;

4) It is stupefying to read anything or go anywhere without the Arab or Muslims living here to remind us, the American citizens, how and what we are doing around the world makes us hated or that our political echelon is ignorant;

5) Your pernicious malady of ignoring how the Islamic community in the U.S., led in no small part by CAIR, is undermining our War on Terror and spreading virulent hatred of Jews and Christians, in many ways and by many means;

In any case, it is our First Amendment right to discuss on-going events that concern us all, and to cast aspersions on news forums like LGF, shows us one thing, that your focus to try and drive a wedge between what is reality and your alternate version of reality is duplicitous and delicious to observe your "newspaper" misconstrue how we witness horrific crimes that you would like us all to just "ignore."

BTW, don't you have a Anna Nicole Smith story to pursue?

Sincerely,

David J. Schwartz

153 TalkinKamel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:18:25am

#135 Oh no. . . . Sand People

Oh, come ON! How can you say such terrible things? Islam is a religion of PEACE! It's just been hijacked by a SMALL MINORITY of radicals, but, really, most or them are PEACEFUL, and sing "Kumbaya" all the time! And Saladin was really noble, did you know that? And Andalusia was really a swell place. They had Algebra. And soap.

/Seriously, you're right. Also, take a look at Will Durant's description of Moslem atrocities in India, in "Our Oriental Heritage".

154 mglazer  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:18:34am

#85 dicentra

Have what wrong? What does LGF have wrong exactly? expound please

The media lied, hid an important fact about a mass murderer, for no other reason but fear of muslim terrorists

Why did they hide this known fact from the public?

Why did they lie?

Who are they to tell us what we need to know?

You report, we decide.

They felt it wasnt part of the story? why is that? isn't islamic terrorism all over the world?

The irrational fear of muslims is by the media

they are islamaphobes they hide from reality irrationally

Terrorism works on silencing the news reporters - making them into liars, untrustworthy

155 j-damn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:18:49am
#94 Ginn

If the killer in Salt Lake City had been Jewish, Evangelical, ect.. you can bet the headlines would something like this:

Jewish Man AIPAC member/noted Elder of Zion, Goes On Rampage In Mall

Fixed that for you.

156 Elric66  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:19:17am
#141 Sharmuta 2/15/2007 09:15AM PST

117 Elric66

Jihad Minneapolis
Jihad San Fran
Jihad Seattle
Jihad UNC


It will get worse as time goes on.

157 Sponge  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:19:24am

Hmmmm......

ter·ror·ist /ˈtɛrərɪst/ Pronunciation Key - Show Spelled Pronunciation[ter-er-ist] Pronunciation Key - Show IPA Pronunciation
–noun 1. a person, usually a member of a group, who uses or advocates terrorism.
2. a person who terrorizes or frightens others.
3. (formerly) a member of a political group in Russia aiming at the demoralization of the government by terror.
4. an agent or partisan of the revolutionary tribunal during the Reign of Terror in France.
–adjective 5. of, pertaining to, or characteristic of terrorism or terrorists: terrorist tactics.

If he wasn't a 'terrorist' as the story says, than I guess the people in the mall who WEREN'T dead, weren't scared.

158 Ned the Red  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:19:43am

This is interesting [Link: www.sltrib.com...]

In about the middle of the story it says suspicious folks were hanging out at mosque. The story was written Jan 20, 2007. Also a problem about funds from Saudi Arabia.
I couldn't find where I read it, but I know I read a story saying the killer attended this very mosque.

159 Cartman  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:19:48am

#104 Pawn

Then again, Utah is relatively pro-firearms, so maybe the local PD wouldn't have felt the need to show off and demonize the gun.

I'm just saying (regardless of the weapon type) that we gun owners who follow the law to the letter will somehow be demonized, once again.

160 Poitiers-Lepanto  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:19:52am

.

I have come to the conclusion, however, that the media are doing everything possible to hide connections to Islam in cases like this. It’s an absolutely predictable pattern, and they do it every time.

It's the i word ! ! !

161 TalkinKamel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:20:37am

#140 Carolyn

I was afraid of this.

I hope it's not going to happen---but I'm afraid they're going to go after the heroic cop, who faced down the killer.

162 mglazer  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:20:41am

The Media does NOT have the RIGHT to LIE to the American People

PERIOD

"for our own good"

That sort of paternalism belongs in a facist country

I know msm liberals long for facism ..

163 Pawn of the Oppressor  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:21:07am

Did anybody catch this? Check out the bolded part:

There is no record that Talovic attended any of the mosques in the Salt Lake area, according to both Tarek Mosseir, a spokesman for the Islamic Society of Greater Salt Lake, or Bobby Ravish of Muslim Forum. Mosseir noted that many Bosnian Muslims are more secular than religious.

“Having lived under Soviet Union rules for decades, where religious freedom was not an option, a majority of these people” are not practicing Muslims, he added. “What I hear is that he came a couple of times at most, to Eid prayers, but I can’t confirm that he came.”

Now what's happening with this quote here? Is the "not practicing Muslims" phrase the words of the spokesman, or the reporter's interpretation?

Everything I've read about Balkan Muslims says they're generally not as crazy as their desert counterparts - they drink, they smoke, they don't put their women in sacks, and I've read in many different places (even in articles about the revival of the modern Jihad movement in the Balkans) that they roundly rejected the Al Queda tentacles that wormed their way into Bosnia in the 90's. They're as close to the hypothetical "Europeanised Muslims" as you're likely to find. So there are some interesting questions to take away from that quote:

1. Is the spokesman for Islamic whatever calling Bosnian Muslims apostates because they're not Islamic enough?

2. Or did the spokesman say something else entirely, and the reporter tweaked the quote to whitewash the degree of the immigrant community's Islamic-ness? Because as written, the quote implies that Bosnians aren't, you know, religious. At all.

Everybody's got an agenda... Sheesh.

164 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:21:15am

#124 Geepers

See? He was just a poor victim. And if we would have just been nicer to him he wouldn't have felt a need to go out and MURDERED a bunch of people.

I know that these leftard journalists find facts to be really, really annoying, but the US was fighting against the SERB CHRISTIANS on the side of the BOSNIAN MUSLIMS. Fat lot of good that did......

165 Elric66  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:21:16am

EGYPT: STUDENTS SUGGEST RENAMING VALENTINES DAY 'PROPHET MOHAMMED'S DAY'

Cairo, 14 Feb. (AKI) - A group of Muslim students and activists has suggested that Saint Valentine's Day - the traditional celebration of love in Western countries - should be renamed "The Prophet Mohammed's Day," daily al-Watan reports. In recent years Valentine's Day has gained growing popularity among the middle and upper classes in Egypt, but the Muslim students say they want to divest Valentines Day of its consumerist ethos and turn it into a "broader" vision of love for humankind.


[Link: www.adnki.com...]

Broader by renaming the holiday after a pedophile?

166 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:21:25am

dicentra (#85),

The kid was probably a MINO, Muslim in name only, who was also disaffected and psychotic and trying to assimilate into a new culture (which is no piece of cake, BTW). The neighborhood he lived in was none too wealthy, and he had loner tendencies.

Aaaaaww.

Poor guy. I feel so sorry for him.

And your concern for all the people he MURDERED is touching.

167 zombie  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:22:11am

Oh, like I'm really going to trust somewone who says this:

“Having lived under Soviet Union rules for decades, where religious freedom was not an option, a majority of these people” are not practicing Muslims, he added.

Say what? Yugoslavia was independent, and not part of the Warsaw Pact. No part of Yugoslavia ever lived under "Soviet Union rules." Tito opted out and staunchly rebuffed absorption into the Soviet sphere.

A real expert that guy, I tell ya.

168 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:22:21am

162 mglazer

I know msm liberals long for facism

It's why they are attracted to islam.

169 mglazer  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:22:47am

When a muslim shot and killed people at an El Al ticket counter at LAX after 9.11 why did the media/feds report within seconds it was not terror related?

How could they know that?

Paternalism

It is for their own good, not to worry their pretty little heads ..

Thanks

170 jimash  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:23:02am

"How are they idiots for pointing out the proven fact that people who come here from repressive, war-torn shitholes usually feel isolated and afraid of the police and the media?"


Because those factors do not lead to a mall-shooting rampage.

171 deadbackpacker  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:23:13am

#152 DavidJSchwartz

BTW, don't you have a Anna Nicole Smith story to pursue?

Man you got the MSM pegged!

172 HeatherRadish  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:23:21am

#165 Elric66

the Muslim students say they want to divest Valentines Day of its consumerist ethos and turn it into a "broader" vision of love for humankind.

Because Mohammed was all about love for humankind. Never slaughtered Jewish farmers or tortured old women poets or anything like that.

173 hous bin pharteen  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:23:49am

Well, since you reporters at the Deseret News seem to read this site, let me hit you with a clue bat.

We are not interested in proving that this guy is a Muslim terrorist. We are interested in the truth. What we expect it the news media and the authorities to report the truth. If this guy was mad because of something that happened in his life and just went nuts, then fine. Report it. But I also expect if this guy went on his own personal Jihad against the infidel then I expect it to be reported as well.

WE are interested in the facts and the truth.
Can you say the same thing when you withhold facts?

174 Alouette  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:23:58am

#124 Geepers

As a little boy in Bosnia-Herzegovina, Sulejman Talovic hid in fear from the Serb military forces who were slaughtering Muslim men and boys as war and genocide ravaged his country.

So effing what?

Did an Auschwitz survivor go on a shooting rampage in the 1950's?

Did a Cuban Castro refugee go on a shooting rampage in the 1960's?

Did a Cambodian Pol Pot refugee go on a shooting rampage in the 1980's?

Did a Rwandan refugee go on a shooting rampage in the 1990's?

What does that have to do with the f&&king price of rice in China?

175 Buck  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:24:12am

Email sent to the writers of the article:

Are you aware that Bosnia was part of Yugoslavia, not the Soviet Union?

Religion certainly was not repressed the same way. This fact should have been mentioned, if you were to insist on the quote.

It is nice (and professional) that you sought comment from both Tarek Mosseir, and Bobby Ravish. I wonder if you also tried to get comments from any of the editors of the websites you trashed. I can't help but notice that you don't mention not being able to get in touch with anyone at these so called "ultra conservative" site.

Can you explain to me why?

176 wvobiwan  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:24:16am

The Deseret obviously has no clue about the dangers of Islam. As many here have posted, Sudden Jihad Syndrome is not a myth, or even a rare phenomenon anymore. If there's even a chance that SJS is involved here WE AMERICANS DEMAND TO KNOW THAT.

Who is Deseret to say that this pyschotic killer's Islamic religion had nothing to do with this mass murder? Give us the facts Deseret, as diplomatically as you like. But know that omission is LYING, not reporting. Is Deseret prepared to be lumped in with the NY Slimes? They are well on their way...

177 TalkinKamel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:24:49am

Anyway, this poor, disaffected youth was probably just upset about the Crusades. And the manifold atrocities of Baldwin IV, the nefarious leper king (who fought against Saladin, who was really noble, did you know that?) And Israel's unjust occupation of Utah. And capitalist shopping malls. And Serbian atrocities against Bosnians, even though he wasn't there when they occurred. And Irag.

(Did I miss any of the usual talking points, WriterMom?)

P.S. By the way, have I mentioned Andalusia? There was a golden age of tolerance there, and Islam invented soap! It was a really swell place!

178 Fjordman  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:25:07am

Cultural Marxism

In 1919, Georg Lukacs became Deputy Commissar for Culture in the short-lived Bolshevik Bela Kun regime in Hungary. He immediately set plans in motion to de-Christianize Hungary. Reasoning that if Christian sexual ethics could be undermined among children, then both the hated patriarchal family and the Church would be dealt a crippling blow. Lukacs launched a radical sex education program in the schools. Sex lectures were organized and literature handed out which graphically instructed youth in free love (promiscuity) and sexual intercourse while simultaneously encouraging them to deride and reject Christian moral ethics, monogamy, and parental and church authority. All of this was accompanied by a reign of cultural terror perpetrated against parents, priests, and dissenters.

Hungary's youth, having been fed a steady diet of values-neutral (atheism) and radical sex education while simultaneously encouraged to rebel against all authority, easily turned into delinquents ranging from bullies and petty thieves to sex predators, murderers, and sociopaths.

179 Elric66  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:25:21am

#172 HeatherRadish 2/15/2007 09:23AM PST

#165 Elric66

the Muslim students say they want to divest Valentines Day of its consumerist ethos and turn it into a "broader" vision of love for humankind.
Because Mohammed was all about love for humankind. Never slaughtered Jewish farmers or tortured old women poets or anything like that.

Mo was all about the love. Love of killing and oppresing non Muslims.

180 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:25:32am

#167 zombie

Something tells me that that Einstein doesn't think that the USSR was such a bad place......

181 Occasional Reader  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:26:01am

#150 Kirel:

How bad were guys like Milosevic, in reality?

Quite.

The mass graves of Muslim victims in Kosovo, for example, have yet to be found

Wrong.

182 BeerDrinking_VictoryMonkey  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:26:42am

#9 Killgore


The video isn't graphic. This is what I hear at 1:03....
Voice #1: "Allahu Ackbar"
Voice #2: "This is the police, put the gun down"

I couldn't make out what was being said just before the police officer clearly said "put the gun down," but if you listen to it from the beginning, about 5-10 seconds in, I thought I heard an "Allahu Ackbar," though it was hard to tell. Bear in mind, I wasn't listening for any "A.A.'s" before 1:03 in.

183 mglazer  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:26:44am

Another Mass Murdering Muslim

Why does it matter that he was muslim?

Because since the RoP began with convert, die or dhimmi this has been going on all over the world, it has only gotten stronger while the w/rest has gotten weaker

No thanks to our leaders, media or otherwise

So their purposefull blindfolding of the citizenry is telling, expected and chilling

Terrorism works and we are bearing its fruits

184 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:27:05am

#169 mglazer

You're completely right. They see themselves as haveing a special annointed status in society. Egotistical sumbiches.

185 find your violent jihadi on ebay!  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:27:16am

# 85

I am a long-time fan of LGF, but I think you guys have it wrong this time. The kid was probably a MINO, Muslim in name only, who was also disaffected and psychotic and trying to assimilate into a new culture (which is no piece of cake, BTW). The neighborhood he lived in was none too wealthy, and he had loner tendencies. ..... Don't lose perspective, lizards. Don't earn the reputation the LLL continually tries to foist on you. Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar.

You are truly missing the point. All over the world - and, increasingly, within our own borders, Muslims are going on murderous killing sprees. Sometimes these are directly connected with Jihad, and sometimes they appear an increment more "random". But either way, something in Moslem culture is producing a kind of ongoing, grinding random violence that has come to our shores. Christians are not storming into shopping malls and shooting up strangers. Nor are Jews, Hindus, animists, or wiccans. This is a Moslem thing, and its frequency and dispersal across the globe is wildly picking up steam. For the media to refuse to cover this story, preferring over and over to call these random acts of random people, is a travesty and a grave disservice to the public. LGF and others like it are the ONLY places to go to get a taste of the truth.

Haven't you had enough with the 'crazed, loner, underemployed, angry person' excuse? Have you noticed that EVERY SINGLE ONE OF THEsE PEOPLE IS A VERY PISSED OFF MUSLIM, AND THEY"RE KILLING OUR CITIZENS?

186 hous bin pharteen  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:27:16am

#152 david...

Yeah, but if Anna Nicole was beheaded by a Jihadi it would not be news.

187 "Oh no...Sand People!"  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:27:19am

The Salt Lake Tribune has posted the reason it happened by being a mouthpiece for this crappy lib quote:

Antonella Packard, president of Honduras Maya de Utah, and Renetta Coppard, executive director of the Latin-American Chamber of Commerce, both asked for more assistance for refugees. They said better health care and other services would help prevent similar incidents and might have prevented past shootings.

uh...sure.

188 Just_A_Grunt  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:27:46am

But it is important to let you know that Mitt Romney is a Mormon because you know it could have an impact on whether or not you vote for him unlike Mr Ellison (MN-D) for whom his religion has no impact on whether you vote for him or not.
/MSM Pretzel Logic
//coming to a psychiatric disorders list near you

189 wanumba  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:27:55am
#85 dicentra
I am a long-time fan of LGF, but I think you guys have it wrong this time. The kid was probably a MINO, Muslim in name only, who was also disaffected and psychotic and trying to assimilate into a new culture (which is no piece of cake, BTW). The neighborhood he lived in was none too wealthy, and he had loner tendencies.


trying to assimilate into a new culture (which is no piece of cake, BTW). The neighborhood he lived in was none too wealthy,
Let's put a stake into this right now. This concept that assimulation is so tough it can drive someone to violence is phony. The entire United States was populated by immigrants who arrived with a hell of a lot less than this man had, and arrived here after weeks of lousy shipboard conditions, not stepping off a neat and tidy modern jet. They managed. They went into cruddy neighborhoods - worse than what can be found in Utah, that's a fact. They made something of themselves with less money, poor English, no health care, no social security no welfare and greeted by hostile people. They didn't go nuts and start murdering people.
I ought to institutionalize my kids right now if assimulation is so mind-wrenching. They've grown up in 6 different Third World countries. WHen we came back to the US to live, they had to assimulate, too. They don't know the TV shows, the actors, the slang, the "in" fashions, the this, the that. They spoke English, but had done all their schooling in another language, so it took them over a year to be able to read their school textbooks competently in English. They missed math problems because they knew the terms in the other language, but not in English. They are American and Americans don't understand them. How's that for feeling like a misfit? At least with a foreign accent, people assume you might not know something, but with our kids who have no accent, they're sometimes dismissed as strange or dumb. Despite all the drama, and frustration, not a one has the least inclination to pick up a gun and trot off to a mall and blow people away.
"Assimulation anxiety" is a bogus concoction of the Left. It's being used a lot - this isn't the first time I've seen the excuse used.

190 HeatherRadish  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:28:00am

#157 Sponge

BabbaZee's really the expert here, but the Leftist media doesn't ascribe to the "theory" that words have specific agreed-upon meanings.

/Was the shooter George Bush or Dick Cheney? Then he's not a terrorist.

191 Cognito  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:28:00am

51 tfk,


Its ok, Cognito in his new voice of reason will
make it clear, its just the cost of the plant and
equipment, the high cost of transporting the
rags once the lies are in ink, and of course the
30 little silver things that pay the lead liars aka
editors ect.

gag them all tie a knot
throw away the knot code

Etc., etc., etc...

I just believe that -- in most cases -- the more information we have, the better. Then we can use the information to make up our own minds. Which in this case means that the paper should have included description of the shooter as a Muslim -- as LGF did -- so that we can decide whether he's a terrorist.

In this particular case, I'm not quite convinced yet. I've not followed it turn-by-turn, but I've not seen anything that links this guy's religion to his homicidal act. That is, Muslims can be crazy in the ordinary way.

But the paper still owed us the information, because if no one ever notes details like the guy's belief in Islam -- then we'll never see patterns emerge.

192 Pawn of the Oppressor  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:28:08am

170 jimash

"How are they idiots for pointing out the proven fact that people who come here from repressive, war-torn shitholes usually feel isolated and afraid of the police and the media?"

Because those factors do not lead to a mall-shooting rampage.

The issue was the "community's" reluctance to talk to the police, if you'll read the article. Last I read, the family wasn't answering the phone and for whatever reason, we're still in the dark about a motive. Even CAIR is in on this already (Desert News must have a hotline to them!) but we hear nothing from the actual investigators? What the F is going on?

193 jrdroll  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:28:29am
194 Carolyn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:28:42am

#161
TalkinKamel

Once again cops in America killing people. You give cops in America the SLIGHTEST reason

The slightest reason?
5 dead people, one of them a 15 year old girl....
The slightest reason?

195 Killgore Trout  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:29:26am

#140 Carolyn
Thanks, I forgot to check the comments....

Once again, it is not a cops place in the chain of command to condemn and execute. It is their job to incapacitate and detain a suspect. If they cant do that they need to call in the negotiators. As you can see the cops in the video have no care in the world about the clearing the area of civilians, they just steam head first with weapons drawn ready to kill the guy if he doesnt immediateley give up.


LLLogic.

196 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:29:29am

#175 Buck

Email sent to the writers of the article:

Are you aware that Bosnia was part of Yugoslavia, not the Soviet Union?

That was cold.

197 ciaospirit  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:29:36am

#46 find your violent jihad

"Welcome to my world," said Ibrahim Hopper, communications director of the Council on American-Islamic Relations in Washington, D.C., about the angry e-mails.

Do they ever miss a chance to play the victim? Reality check, Dougie. You got emails. They got murdered.

198 jooly  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:29:39am

The article is listed in the paper under News instead of opinion. What crap!

199 formercorpsman  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:29:50am

Buck, real good words.

200 find your violent jihadi on ebay!  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:30:31am
They said better health care and other services would help prevent similar incidents and might have prevented past shootings.

So.......this act of terrorism happened because the kid didn't have good dental coverage?

The MSM is really reaching on this one.

Just for fun, they should try reporting the real story, just to see how it feels.

201 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:30:58am

191 Cognito

Care to comment on this genius' knowledge of history and geography, let alone commitment to quality?

202 Dianna  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:31:17am

#108 Ward Cleaver

Yugoslavia was the leader of the non-aligned nations. It was not a member of the Warsaw Pact.

and am I invisible or something? I pointed out the "Soviet Union rules" stupidity at #24 or #25.

203 Kenneth  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:31:55am

It is simply acknowleging facts that witnessing the brutality of the genocidal civil wars, such as those in Bosnia, Rwanda, Sudan, Cambodia & etc., can cause deep psychological scars on children. There is a well documented increased risk of mental illness, personality disorders and various forms of post traumatic shock. Sometimes the survivors of these horrible experiences will "snap" and go out and victimize others. This is not excusing the crime, nor the criminals. It's just a fact.

This case in Utah is likely just such an instance, and it may or may not have a further causal influence of jihadi Islam.

204 ggt  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:32:05am

Thank you Charles!

205 DavidJSchwartz  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:32:44am

#85 dicentra 2/15/2007 09:03AM PST


I don't know if it's a good idea to accuse the Deseret News of being deliberately obtuse ("ultraconservative" label notwithstanding). It's not what you'd call a bastion of MSM thought. It's owned by the LDS church and has traditionally been more conservative than its historic rival, The Salt Lake Tribune.

I am a long-time fan of LGF, but I think you guys have it wrong this time. The kid was probably a MINO, Muslim in name only, who was also disaffected and psychotic and trying to assimilate into a new culture (which is no piece of cake, BTW). The neighborhood he lived in was none too wealthy, and he had loner tendencies.

If he was waging jihad, he'd have at least popped off a good "Allahu akbar" at some point, but he didn't. It sounds more like your basic Columbine syndrome than jihad. This time, anyway. Don't lose perspective, lizards. Don't earn the reputation the LLL continually tries to foist on you. Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar.

If it looks like a terrorist, walks like a terrorist, kills innocent people like a terrorist, and the MSM covers it up with a story today showcasing and whitewashing the murderer instead of covering the stories about the VICTIMS of the PERPETRATOR, we are proud to be "losing our perspective."
[Link: www.deseretnews.com...]

With all due respect.

206 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:33:06am
207 Shiplord Kirel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:33:58am

#181 Occasional reader

These are scarcely authoritative or unbiased sources: A release from the Clinton spin machine during the period of the attack on Serbia, and an Amnesty International report that is ambiguous at best. (The latter admits, for example, that many victims were Serbs murdered by Muslims and that many of the deaths occurred after the NATO intervention).
A biased source's claim of 3700 dead from both sides is scarcely evidence of programmed genocide, which is the accusation.

208 Pawn of the Oppressor  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:34:23am

203 Kenneth

Shut up, man. You and your "humanity", what are you, some kind of Commie traitor? PUT EM ALL IN CAMPS!

/sad but true.

209 Kenneth  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:34:42am

#27 Dianna

Just so. Your post is prior to mine at #83.

And no, you are not invisible. I just got excited and jumped to comment with reading everything else.

210 SlothB77  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:35:52am
"Welcome to my world," said Ibrahim Hopper, communications director of the Council on American-Islamic Relations in Washington, D.C., about the angry e-mails. "I get tons of it every day."

FYI his name is HOOPER

Here at LGF, we at least spell your name right.

211 Jeff MacMillan  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:36:18am

"...have not expressed any opinion on whether the attack was an act of jihad, personal or otherwise....I have deliberately refrained from expressing a conclusion,"

BRAVO for LGF standing behind old traditional news media principles.

If only Deseret (degenerate) News in Utah would do the same by not prematurely concluding that the man's religion is not a motive, then we'd finally be given some real honest news for a change.

212 Axiom  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:37:40am

If you folks are writing to newspapers and you are sourcing your information to LGF, then I'd like to suggest that vitriol in your emails be left on your computer. Today's modern press is not as aware of Sudden Jihad Syndrome like LGF readers are aware to it. Note that. It's important for you to contextually make the case that Talovic's religious background may have played a role in his reported "random" shooting.

The letters are important because they introduce an angle of which the local press may not be aware. Proceed with caution and if you have questions about your email then post them here and they can be answered.

Unfortunately, when you give the press just one email that is hateful upon first glance, you give the press an excuse to frame their story that way.

213 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:38:04am

#202 Dianna

We're all invisible. You were the first to comment on that, followed by me, followed by Kennith, followed by Zombie (I hope I didn't miss anyone). That's a major screw-up to publish that, IMO.

214 THX-42  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:38:12am

You know, there was a time when "profiling" was considered to be good detective work. And there were (still are) specialists called "profilers" whose job it is to take seemingly inocuous, unrelated small facts and create a picture (profile) of the likely suspects of a crime. In many such cases, serial killers who would otherwise have continued their brutal crimes were captured and prevented from killing any more innocent victims.

But now profiling is itself about to become a PC crime (look it up, some congress critters are actually trying to come up with laws to prevent this). My, how "enlightened" we are about to become (enlightened, as in aerated by so many bullet holes that light will shine through us).

215 wildcat_clan  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:38:23am

#85: I understand what you are saying I too am trying to assimilate into another culture, Mexican. The only oddity here is I live in the US. I think you missed the point entirely, it wasn't that anyone stated he was an islamic terrorist, the crux of the article dealt with media declivity for convenient absence of details.

216 ggt  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:39:25am

#131 tfk

What is going on in Washington D.C. is a direct result of the fact Lt. Kerry and Jane Fonda etal were never punished for their true and real crimes.

/shiver, lurch, spew

217 bikermailman  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:39:29am

#92 WriterMom
I'm glad I read down before responding to
45 Elric66
If LGF is "ultra-conservative" what would they call Islam?
Was about to say the exact thing...lol

218 jimash  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:40:08am

#192 Pawn of the oppressor.

Maybe you're right, and I got the reference wrong.
I just looked at video interviews of his Father and cousin.
They want to know where he got the guns.
They didn't seeem all that shy.

219 ggt  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:40:21am

#131 tfk

not at you --sorry, not well presented.

Those two names invoke revulsion in me.

220 WriterMom  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:40:45am

#197 ciaospirit

Reality check, Dougie. You got emails. They got murdered.

Amen, sistah.

221 hous bin pharteen  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:40:47am

Does this kind of reporting also apply to Iraq?
Next time there is an IED or car bomb go off over there maybe the MSM should investigate it before proclaiming it as part of the NBC decleared civil war.
How do we know its not just some disgruntled Iraqi postal worker who is pissed off because he got fired.

222 ciaospirit  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:41:41am

#85 dicentra

If he was waging jihad, he'd have at least popped off a good "Allahu akbar" at some point, but he didn't.

How do you know that?!

223 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:42:20am

Cognito (#191),

But the paper still owed us the information, because if no one ever notes details like the guy's belief in Islam -- then we'll never see patterns emerge.

LOL!

But they're not intentionally biased.

224 ciaospirit  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:42:39am

I read a headline that six are now dead, but when I click on the link a story about bond issues comes up. Anyone have the latest?

225 Arbalest  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:43:47am

News reports indicate that the suspect was carrying a shotgun, a .38, and lots of ammunition.

If this was a response to Bosnia (10+ years ago, and he was a child at the time), where is his long troubled history of acting out?

How many people did he murder, and what were their crimes against him or his family?

As per the link provided by #9 (Kilgore Trout), the audio portion of the video indicates the suspect clearly shouted “Allahu Akbar”, and it is clearly audible over the other noise.

“Allahu Akbar” is, among other things, the Muslim war cry. It is not used by Christians, Hindus, Sikhs, Jains, Shintoists, Buddhists, various animist sects, atheists, agnostics, etc. Is it also not a secular war cry.

Sulejman Talovic’s equipment, actions, and his own recorded words clearly show that the fact he was a Muslim is of significant importance.


The article written by Elaine Jarvik and Deborah Bulkeley
is little more than propaganda; an attempt at a whitewash of the murders.

Their quotes of Tarek Nosseir, and Bobby Darvish are simply a distraction. Nosseir (?):"What I hear is that he came a couple of times at most, to Eid prayers, but I can't confirm that he came."

This is a throw-away response, a “who woulda thunk” excuse.

They portray Buba Roth, a spokeswoman for the Consortium of Multicultural Groups, as some sort of impartial expert.

They quote her and write: "People living here 10 or more years in America still don't even feel the freedom to communicate with the media," she said. "They are so afraid, and so isolated."

This is doubtfully true.

Jarvik and Bulkeley should be a bit more intellectually honest in their reporting.

226 Kenneth  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:44:27am

#214 THX-42

I think you are confusing two different definitions of the term "profiling". The pc caterwalling is about "racial profiling" which is when border guards spot people who look like they might be Muslim (which is not a race) and then subject them to increased scrutiny. Forensic "profiling" is about building a dossier on the likely identity of a suspect in a crime by collecting personality driven clues. That practice is not the subject of pc caterwalling.

227 Sgt.Slappy  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:44:58am

#96 Pawn...

we have absolutely no idea what the shooter's motivation was yet?

Gee, I guess you're right. There's no possible merit to the suspicion of a connection with being muslim, and yet another murderous rampage.

Just like no connection between the dead lambs and the coyote with the full belly and blood on his fur.

Right.

Got it.

Thanks.

228 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:45:34am

#222 ciaospirit

How do you know that?!

You've put your finger right on the problem. We know that we can't trust the media, so we don't know for certain what didn't happen. He very well could have yelled out "allah ackbar", and we'd never know. Don't be surprised if some more facts that have been heretofore censored come out in the blogosphere in the next week or two.

229 find your violent jihadi on ebay!  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:46:01am

The media is not going to "get it" until the next 9/11-class attack. Maybe not even then. We may as well hunker down for the looooooong term fight with the mainstream media to portray Islamic violence honestly. Today's media is a collection of idealistic people who believe, at the core, that all the world's problems are our fault and that the only solution is to rectify our wrongs through cash payments, ideological submission, one-way "dialog" to understand their complaints, and destriction or just atrophying of our cultural heritage.

230 cry of defiance and not of fear  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:46:29am

A great many people who come out of this murderer's part of the world are psychotic and this mental state is due to several factors in the history of the area, the religious creeds and the deprivations in civilised foundations of life experienced by all the peoples of that benighted land mass.

Both MSM and the blogosphere are shadow-boxing in one aspect which it is essential to dismantle: the silence over Muhammad and his central role in islam. We are forever going to be saying to ourselves and as many as we can reach with our knowledge that this man's example and teachings are behind humanity's on-going problems with islam and moslems, and the MSM, by never mentioning a peep about him, is boxing itself into a corner. The public, meanwhile, can see that it's not a ROP but the demonic aspect is not defined clearly. I've said before, we need all forms of communication on our side. As many as possible need to get onto other blogsites, write to newspapers, their columnists and reporters, feed people the info. I do see changes happening in reporting islam in Brit papers, for example. Until Muhammad is exposed, we are going to see these desperate attempts to keep a lid on the issue in MSM with the result of a disconnected and frustrated greater public. If we can get the full truth out, it removes the underpinnings of silence and protection of the forces seeking to spread islam.

231 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:46:36am

Axiom (#212),

Unfortunately, when you give the press just one email that is hateful upon first glance, you give the press an excuse to frame their story that way.

Oh please Axiom. The press has never needed an "excuse" to shove their bias down our throats.

232 Buck  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:46:53am

#196 Earth2moonbat
#199 formercorpsman

I got a response:

On 2/15/07, Elaine Jarvik wrote:
You're right, we should have contacted someone from one of those sites. Elaine
233 kateca  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:48:28am

So, let me see if I have this straight: You can't be a terrorist unless you attend Mosque regularly? Is that an admission by MSM that Mosque attendance breeds terrorism?

Can we shut down the damned Mosque's yet?

234 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:49:33am

211 Jeff MacMillan

BRAVO for LGF standing behind old traditional news media principles.

If only Deseret (degenerate) News in Utah would do the same by not prematurely concluding that the man's religion is not a motive, then we'd finally be given some real honest news for a change.

The problem is any news outlet withholding facts from their audience. It then ceases to be news, and becomes propaganda.

235 zombie  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:50:42am
#202 Dianna
#108 Ward Cleaver

Yugoslavia was the leader of the non-aligned nations. It was not a member of the Warsaw Pact.

and am I invisible or something? I pointed out the "Soviet Union rules" stupidity at #24 or #25.

#213 Earth2moonbat
We're all invisible. You were the first to comment on that, followed by me, followed by Kennith, followed by Zombie (I hope I didn't miss anyone).

Dianna and Earth2moonbat: you've not invisible to me! I just hadn't read the thread yet. I saw the historical boo-boo, posted a quick note about it, and later went back and skimmmed the thread and noticed others had pointed out the same thing.

It's a pretty common occurence that the same fact gets pointed out repeatedly by post-and-run commenters (like me sometimes).

236 zombie  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:51:26am

you've = you're

PIMF

237 Charles  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:51:50am

I listened to the audio on that video at LiveLeak, by the way, and I do not hear "Allahu Akbar." The only audible voices seem to be the cops'.

238 Taqiyyotomist  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:52:27am

#212 Axiom

Good advice. They need to be walked through the facts, step by step, and "led" to the truth sometimes. Simply e-mailing them with a nasty response that assumes they know what we know and are just ignoring it (well, it may be the case for some of the writers, but not most), is counterproductive. E-mailing them with "kill all the camel-jockeys" or insane rambling is not going to help LGF or any of us. Quite the opposite.

None of us should be in a cussing rage at this point in history, despite the tactics of our Blogospheric opposition, who see reason and order as anathema to their cause. Not venting of 'Feelings'. I feel like cussing a lot in forums. I feel like hurling abusive epithets at my usually quite aggravating debate opponents. It never helps.

Calm, measured, tactical responses are in order, despite what you feel.

-Taq

239 Axiom  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:52:28am

kilgore trout: I cannot make out "allahu akbar" at 1:03 into the liveleak video.

240 randman  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:52:40am

"“Having lived under Soviet Union rules for decades"

Uhhhhhhh....Yugoslavia was officially a part of the non-aligned movement and not the Soviet Bloc. Tito played both sides against each other.

241 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:53:47am

#9 Killgore Trout

I think that's "Ogden police", but you really can't be sure. I don't think that would stand up in court. I don't know how possible that is to clean up, either.

242 "Oh no...Sand People!"  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:55:34am

#237 Charles:

I concur.

I can hear the beginning of an utterance at 1:03 on the audio, but it is mixed with the police. I can't tell what was said.

243 Axiom  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:55:47am

#238 Taqiyyotomist

I'm glad someone is getting it. The media must be viewed as a wild beast that you can tame over time. You can't just run up to it and start waving your arms around. Media management is a full time job for thousands of people everyday.

Look, I just read a comment here asking when we were "closing all the mosques". Put that in an email and the media will frame their story around that. The media is inflammatory. That's simple enough to grasp from watching one nightly newscast.

244 WriterMom  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:58:21am

#232 buck

Way to go.

245 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:58:31am

So let's see:

Elaine Jarvik and Deborah Bulkeley can't even get the basic facts straight. Re: The Soviet Union.

Elaine Jarvik and Deborah Bulkeley can't even spell Doug Hooper's name correctly.

Elaine Jarvik and Deborah Bulkeley admit that they don't follow fundamental journalistic practices. Re: contacting Charles before they smear him.

Yet, they expect us to lap up their opinions as gospel.

Brilliantly ignorant.

246 Ojoe  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:58:32am

119 amphibian

I am sure that those killed and those near them, felt terror.

You would have too. Heart racing. Adrenalin.

He.

Was.

A.

Terrorist.


Wake up !

247 doppelganglander  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:58:42am

It isn't just the MSM ignoring the elephant in the room:

Meanwhile, the FBI said Wednesday it has no reason to believe the shooting spree that killed five people in a shopping mall was an act of Islamic terrorism, leaving a young Bosnian immigrant's motives a mystery.

"It's just unexplainable," FBI agent Patrick Kiernan said. "He was just walking around and shooting everybody he saw."

And this gem:

Talovic was only 4 when he and his mother fled their village of Talovici on foot after Serbian forces overran it in 1993, people close to the family told The Associated Press.

He lived as a refugee in Bosnia from 1993 to 1998, when his family moved to the United States, they said.

During that period, he spent some time in Srebrenica, the northeastern enclave where up to 8,000 Muslim men and boys were slaughtered in 1995 by Serb forces.

Talovic left Srebrenica two years before the massacre, but acquaintances suggested it may have left an indelible mark on the quiet little boy they knew.

"That's why I'm convinced the war did this in Utah," said Murat Avdic, a friend of the family. "There cannot be any other reason."

Yep, a massacre that happened two years AFTER he left the area as a small child, that's what did it!

248 Carolyn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:59:42am
#234 Sharmuta
The problem is any news outlet withholding facts from their audience. It then ceases to be news, and becomes propaganda.

Exactly. What is the criteria for withholding facts? Can we trust anything the news says?
/pandora's box, media
//do you understand yet?

249 Kenneth  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:59:57am

#9 Killgore Trout 2/15/2007 08:41AM PST

Repost from the dead thread:
Dramatic Home Video Shows Utah Mall Rampage

The video isn't graphic. This is what I hear at 1:03....
Voice #1: "Allahu Ackbar"
Voice #2: "This is the police, put the gun down"

Can anyone clean up that audio?

I watched the video & I did not hear anything that sounded like "Allahu Ackbar."

250 zombie  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:00:57am
#9 Killgore Trout
Dramatic Home Video Shows Utah Mall Rampage

The video isn't graphic. This is what I hear at 1:03....
Voice #1: "Allahu Ackbar"
Voice #2: "This is the police, put the gun down"

Can anyone clean up that audio?

Killgore (and everyone):

I've listened to the tape very carefully. No one is shouting "Allahu Ackbar!" There is only one voice in that audio segment, and I can say with near certainty that it says this (exactly):

Voice #1: "Drop the gun! Salt Lake Police! Put down the gun now!"

I'd be the first to jump on this if there was anything to it, but no: Talovic is not audible in this video. Just the cop.

Listen again and you'll hear what I mean.

251 Taqiyyotomist  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:01:39am

It would be nice if someone here knew how to clean up audio clips, and somehow remove all that reverb. I'm sure it can be done.

#231 Geepers

I understand what you're saying, but at the same time, we don't need to be giving them better ammunition, which they will use to tar the entire LGF community and beyond.

252 Killgore Trout  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:01:45am

#237 Charles
I tried different EQ settings and a few filters but couldn't find anything to make to audio more intelligible. It's tough to even tell different voice apart. Unfortunately the video doesn't really shed any light on the situation.

253 THX-42  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:03:25am

#226 Kenneth

I think you are confusing two different definitions of the term "profiling".


On the contrary, I'm drawing the parallel. Both forensic profiling and the pejoratively-termed "racial profiling" use the same principle: is there a pattern here that would allow us to select a subset of the total population for closer scrutiny, so we are not wasting our resources looking through the entire general population?

My very point is that the PC crowd is intimidating us AND our law enforcement officials from using legitimate means to protect ourselves from certain violence-prone subsets of our population.

254 Killgore Trout  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:03:57am

#251 Taqiyyotomist
I'm pretty good at cleaning up audio and I had no luck. There's no real way to take out the reverb once it's on the recording.

255 zombie  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:04:01am
#237 Charles
I listened to the audio on that video at LiveLeak, by the way, and I do not hear "Allahu Akbar." The only audible voices seem to be the cops'.

See my comment #250 above for an exact transcription of what is actually said. If you listen again while reading the words, it'll be clear to you.

256 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:04:30am

doppelganglander (#247),

Yep, a massacre that happened two years AFTER he left the area as a small child, that's what did it!

The media will be making excuses for this MURDERER 'till the cows come home.

Any excuse, no matter how absurd will be trotted out to deflect attention away from this guy intentionally MURDERING five people.

257 bill-tb  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:05:13am

If he wasn't a Muslim, if it weren't Jihad, the gun control parade would already be marching in WDC. Draw your own conclusions. What is not said is more important than what is said when dealing with MSM stories.

258 SENATOR  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:05:47am

One thing that's unique about this story, however, is that they are acknowledging the fact that people believe there might be a jihadi connection. Most papers and news outlets gloss over this completely.

259 JustMyView  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:06:11am

#43 kateca

Reminds me of twenty years ago when the MSM couldn't bring themselves to mention a person's race if that person was black: "Suspect is described as a 6' tall male, black hair and brown eyes." Maybe throw in a clue like "suspect has an afro".

This is baloney. Media outlets generally have specific policies re what they say in identifying people, and they explicitly do mention race when it is relevant to the story. In stories about crime, the perpetrator's race is mentioned if he or she is still at large and knowledge of race might help a member of the public identify the person.

260 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:06:55am
261 jrdroll  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:07:39am

It would be nice to know what the cameraman heard.

262 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:08:28am

248 Carolyn

What is the criteria for withholding facts? Can we trust anything the news says?
/pandora's box, media
//do you understand yet?

Clearly, they don't understand. So they attack Charles. Nevermind that this is about the audience being informed with facts and drawing their own conclusions.

263 formercorpsman  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:09:41am

Buck, good work.

Interesting to see if they have credibility to contact Charles, asking for a statement.

It is absolutely mind blowing how quickly their words can be assessed.

The same amount of time they can put out their article regarding this situation, and attempting to make their own point, this site has the ability to counter on a substantive basis.

They know this, a caveat for print journalism. Trump hands now reduced to pairs, requiring countenance for discernment.

I see your Soviet religious oppression, and raise you a Warsaw Pact.

264 km  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:09:51am

85 dicentra

If he was waging jihad, he'd have at least popped off a good "Allahu akbar" at some point, but he didn't

On the above video @ 1:38 I hear three shouts of Allah Akbar.

This reeks of jihad.

265 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:10:16am
266 Pawn of the Oppressor  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:10:17am

227 Sgt.Slappy

#96 Pawn...

we have absolutely no idea what the shooter's motivation was yet?

Gee, I guess you're right. There's no possible merit to the suspicion of a connection with being muslim, and yet another murderous rampage.

Just like no connection between the dead lambs and the coyote with the full belly and blood on his fur.

Right.

Got it.

Thanks.

No fatwa note or final video. Acted alone. No witnesses heard "Allahu Akhbar", which any Jihadi worth his six dozen virgins would have been yelling. No apparent attempt to attack Jewish or specifically Christian targets. Family has no freaking idea why he went off the deep end. Not seen at local mosques. Recent photo shows no beard. Described as "socially isolated". No word yet about internet sites on his computer, beheading videos on DVD, or any other Jihad strangeness.

Aside from his name being Suleiman, there's no indication that this is SJS. Believe it or not, it's actually possible that "Muslim" does not automagically equal "Murderer". I'm not ready to instantly assume the worst on near-zero evidence. The only indicator of Jihad so far is the name he was born with.

267 Killgore Trout  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:11:33am

#250 zombie
After a few more listenings I think you nailed it. It does sound like that segment is one voice and not two.

268 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:11:53am

#266 Pawn of the Oppressor

No fatwa note or final video.

Sez the media. I'm not willing to accept their word as proof of a negative yet.

269 Carolyn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:12:08am

# 264 km
It does sound like it. But I am not 100% sure.

270 Axiom  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:12:40am

#264 km

Ok, I listened at 1:38. I still don't hear anything resembling "allahu akbar".

271 doppelganglander  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:13:15am

#259 JustMyView: I don't know where you live, but in Atlanta, the TV and radio news rarely, if ever, mentions the person's race in the description of a perp at large, unless it's a white guy in a pick-up truck who's been trying to snatch little girls from the bus stop. The only major outlet I know of that routinely includes race in a description is America's Most Wanted.

272 J.D.  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:13:27am

It isn't the true story unless it is the entire story as it is known thus far.
Simple.

273 Pawn of the Oppressor  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:14:06am

264 km

On the above video @ 1:38 I hear three shouts of Allah Akbar.

To me that's somebody with a south/western accent saying "Come on back" or "Come on out". Probably a cop shouting to another cop, because you can hear the response, "Where's he at?".

274 Killgore Trout  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:16:14am

#264 km
I found that interesting too but I think it's a cop telling the rest of the officers to "come up, come up, come up." A few seconds later the same voice says "Come on up, come on up" as a few more officers advance past the camera.

275 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:16:20am

#259 JustMyView

Please 'splain to me why the Duke lacrosse case was all over the media for the better part of a year, and then this case is limited to the blogosphere. If you limited your scope to the MSM, you's never know that a second Duke rape case happened. Suppose the fact that the rapist is black and the victim is white might have something to do with that?

276 WriterMom  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:16:43am

Actually, the Toronto Star has a policy of NOT mentioning the skin colour of assailants in their reporting-even when the police press releases clearly state the person's skin colour and description in order to better identify them.

About two years ago, there was a murder in a bingo parlour. The suspects were described as two women, with dark hair and medium builds-they were seen fleeing the scene. The ony thing is that the police added the detail that they were black women. The Star took that out-and actually published a few paragraphs by their ombudsman justifying their decision to alter the police alert.

277 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:16:51am

Taqiyyotomist (#251),

Reread your nickname.

Then ask yourself if there might not be some, let's say, "less than honest" people writing the Deseret News, after say, an Action Alert by CAIR, that might possibly, just possible misrepresent themselves to make "ultraconservative" websites look bad.

And what do you want to bet that Elaine Jarvik and Deborah Bulkeley read those and say: See. PROOF! that that "ultraconservative" website is just a bunch of racist haters.

Then ask yourself why they couldn't be bothered to actually email Charles?

Could it possibly be that they'd already decided what LGF "is" and they have already have judged us and condemned us out of hand?

Nah.

They're unbiased "professionals" only reporting the facts.

278 Carolyn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:16:58am

It would be nice if we could hear from an eye-witness.

279 Orbit Rain  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:17:57am

...If you like getting just part of the news, keep subscribing to the Deseret News...people around the country are doing it...go ahead keep feeding the machine that obfuscates the truth...

go ahead...keep feeding those flames

280 Axiom  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:19:14am

You folks need to read the Wikipedia discussion about Talovic's Muslim background.

[Link: en.wikipedia.org...]

Excerpt Quote: "Written by Al-Hakaymah, the "Guide for Individual Jihad" suggests ways to kill the enemy when one is fighting alone. The recommended methods include stabbing, feeding overdoses of cocaine or heroin, injecting air via needles, assassination with guns, burning down homes, putting poisonous snakes in cars, tampering with car brakes, planting explosives in vehicles, running over people, and luring people and then killing them." [Link: www.worldtribune.com...]

VP1974 14:14, 15 February 2007 (UTC)VP1974

Al-Hakayamah's religious instructions were written by a holy man and should be understood in the context of sacred Islamic teachings. To construe them in any other way is an affront to the exalted and devout imam.Lestrade 16:39, 15 February 2007 (UTC)Maghmuod Hesayn

The author of this book explains ways an individual can kill someone and the response from another Wiki user is that the author should be viewed from a religious context?

This is insanity. The author is writing about ways to kill people. This is religious speech now?

281 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:19:42am

272 J.D.

It isn't the true story unless it is the entire story as it is known thus far.
Simple.

It is simple. So simple it's crazy. So crazy it just might work! The solution for the msm's dwindling audience is simple: Report the facts.

282 friarstale  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:19:48am

well, I sure hope the police and/or the FBI is searching his home for clues
any suicide note?
and I still wonder where he got the guns and ammo
you usually hear a lot more from the anti-gun crowd when things like this happen
but they're handcuffed when it may fly in the face of the multicultural mindset

who paid for the guns and ammo?
[Link: cruxy.com...]

283 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:20:42am

I don't know if that's "allah ackbar" at 1:38. but it does sound like "allah" something. Again, it's probably impossible to clean up. It could be Arabic, or it could be Bosnian.

284 Buck  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:20:44am

#266 Pawn of the Oppressor

No one thinks "Muslim" automagically (sp) equal "Murderer".

Nice straw man.

What we think, and are making clear (over and over) that it is wrong to ignore SJS as a possiblity.

To describe the killer, and ignore his background is a lie by ommission.

Blogs will FACT CHECK, and the MSM will attack BLOGS for it.

285 Pawn of the Oppressor  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:20:51am

278 Carolyn

It would be nice if we could hear from an eye-witness.

It always takes a couple of days to get any real meat about what happened. The first day you're always going to get the scare quotes.

"He showed no emotion! Like a robot!"
"Blood everywhere!"
"I was so scared!" (the media loves this one, they suckle the Teat of Fear like mama's milk)

Usually it takes another two days before corroborated descriptions start appearing. I did see one eyewitness account of this guy saying "Die motherfcker!" to somebody he shot, though.

286 Wanderer  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:21:32am

The solution is clear. The lamestream media have an agenda designed and carried out to destro our country and so do I . I haven't purchased a newspaper since the LA Slimes did the their Thursday before the recall election drive by on Ahnold.
To my list will be added a non-purchase/use policy for every major television network, magazine, book published by, or cable services owned and controlled by the corporate giants who control the so called mainstream media.

287 Taqiyyotomist  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:21:58am

Did a search on techniques for removing reverb.

1. Deverberator effect in Postfish.

"The Postfish is a digital audio post-processing, restoration,
filtering and mixdown tool....The Postfish is a stream filter; feed it audio from a list of files or input stream, and it renders audio to standard out, as well as optionally providing a configurable audio playback monitor via a sound device. If the input audio is being taken from files, Postfish also provides simple forward/back/cue seeking and A-B looping control."

From the FAQ. Looks like quite a tool.
Advice at a Cakewalk forum.
And some highly technical advice here.
And one more, from recording.org.

And there are probably some $1500+ forensics programs out there.

288 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:22:34am
289 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:22:51am

#280 Axiom

Wikipedia is not a place to get facts on controversial subjects.

290 TalkinKamel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:23:02am

#194 Carolyn

You must understand--for this sort of pinhead, the cops are always evil oppressors of the poor underclass. The 15 year old girl, and the other victims, don't matter. Their killer does, and they see his as the real victim. Therefore, no act, no matter how violent, is ever seen as necessitating any action by the cops.

Deep down, they probably wish there were no cops at all. The law is always oppressive, and supports the rich against the poor, etc. and so forth!

(Babba, we really do need you here!)

291 JustMyView  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:23:46am

#31 budfox

If the shooter was a Christian or a Jew, how fast would either word be placed in every headline or byline around the country?

What are you smokin'? Can you honestly say that you have ever seen such a headline? Here are a few hideous crimes that have occurred in the area where I live in the recent past.
- psychiatrist beaten to death by a deranged patient
- two police officers shot in station parking lot by deranged patient, who then shot himself
- middle-class guy shot while on an evening walk in a nice neighborhood
- young couple killed while leaving nightclub/getting into car

Know how many of them mentioned anything about the killers' religion or lack of it? NONE

292 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:25:28am

doppelganglander (#271),

JustMyView comes here to change the subject.

She'll never talk about this MURDERER or the article pertaining to it.

But steer you into some crap argument about reporting standards or the history of Halloween.

293 Axiom  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:26:07am

#289 Earth2moonbat

Clearly. However, it is still interesting to see the rebuttals when Wiki users refer to Jihad books, materials, and guides. This one says books that tell you how to kill people is "religious speech".

It's asinine, but it's Wikipedia. This is exactly what would happen if you let anyone edit the Encyclopedia Britannica.

294 Lateral  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:26:10am

Um, just in case you may be confused:

The deseret news IS MSM;
Meaning: muslim sympathic mormons.

Go to Utah, look about at the nice fancy mormon only communites, with locked gates. The newly settled muslims, and mexicans are loved by the mormons. Someon has to maintain thier lawns, man the food joints and all the other menial labor jobs and services that the mormons feel are beneath them. Not much in the way of outside the church ownership either. A lot of the places those poor malignined victim muslims and mexicans work at are owned by said locked gate community mormons.
Not much more than a cult in itself, the mormons. I refused them as a religion.
Magical golden plates my shiny metal ass!

Yes I would be considered an apostate of the mormon cult. Yes, I used cult! Women are not property or bound by duty to produce babies! (and yes, I do have children, but by mutual choice of my wife and myself, not because some damned religious propogation propoganda!) And poeple outside the cult are not to be shunned, charged more money than a 'brother' or cheated or shunned or otherwise treated with predjudice for the advancement of the cult offices.

295 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:28:12am

#280 Axiom

His gender may be relevant if his high testosterone level influenced his behavior.

This is downright disguisting. Straight from womyn's studies 101. He did it because of his gonads. I hate moonbats. I wish they'd all die. Now.

296 easy  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:28:58am

JustMyView

Media outlets generally have specific policies re what they say in identifying people, and they explicitly do mention race when it is relevant to the story.


Generally, specifically and explictly are not the same, and no, not all do always.

Just paying attention.

297 Taqiyyotomist  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:29:14am

Geepers,
Then I guess I'm gonna whip off a quick "Let's throw all the Muslims on boxcars and ship them off to camps! From all of us here at Charles Johnson's LGF, a hearty Kill 'em All!"

After all, what further harm could be done?

298 Murqtaad  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:29:19am
"Welcome to my world," said Ibrahim Hooper

Soon Dougie, you'll here that from the beast with the 7 heads. Say hello for me.

299 TMF  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:29:26am
Having lived under Soviet Union rules for decades, where religious freedom was not an option, a majority of these people” are not practicing Muslims

If the kid is 18, then he

didnt

live under Soviet rule, you sanctimonious ignorant tool

300 Carolyn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:29:42am

#290 TalkinKamel & Pawn of the Oppressor
Make you kinda wonder if witnesses are instructed to keep their mouths shut too.

301 Pawn of the Oppressor  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:30:11am

#284 Buck

No one thinks "Muslim" automagically (sp) equal "Murderer".

No? That's not the impression I get from quite a few posts here. Pinning this down as definite SJS because the kid was named "Suleiman" is about as bad as Kos Kiddies blaming everything on Bush by reflex. It's an indicator, nothing more, and only one indicator at that. I'm not really happy reading garbage here about kicking out all immigrants or writing off every Bosnian in UT, as I've seen in the last two days, because of one punkass kid with a gun. Especially when it provides fodder for knee-jerk copy-spewers at local newspapers to play High & Mighty again with the facts, giving them an excuse to justify their self-appointed positions as Reality Editors and purveyors of Truth & Justice For Dummies.

Don't give them the excuse, and don't excuse people who give them the excuse either. I know LGF is a place to blow off steam and goof around, and we pride ourselves in not taking ourselves as seriously as the raving HuffDUKosians, but I'm a bit weary of knee-jerk genocidal BS in the comments here. It gets old. We're better than that.

302 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:30:43am

#259 JustMyView

Still waiting for an explaination......

303 jimash  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:32:22am

0On the above video @ 1:38 I hear three shouts of Allah Akbar.

1:34 has an example, he says it all as one sylable, with the emphasis on "akh" which stands out.

304 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:32:26am

buzzsawmonkey (#288),

Well stated.

So they intentionally don't want to find out the truth.

Not exactly what "journalism" is all about is it?

305 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:32:30am

288 buzzsawmonkey-


The hardest thing for many people here to realize is that, indeed, many of the people in the media indeed are not intentionally biased--if by "intent" you mean that they consciously, with malice aforethought, slant what they say and write.

From Elaine Jarvik and Deborah Bulkeley:


The online stories, as well as Tuesday’s and Wednesday’s stories in the Deseret Morning News, have resulted in a barrage of vitriolic e-mails to the News from people either angry at the paper for not mentioning the religion of shooter Sulejman Talovic in Wednesday’s Web edition, or certain that because Talovic is Muslim that he must be a terrorist.

They admit to it.

306 Michael Levy  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:34:03am

How often does Deseret News use the term "ultraliberal"?

I'm guessing it's about as often as they... uh... do something... that they don't do very often.

307 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:36:15am
308 Cartman  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:36:20am

#293 Axiom

It's asinine, but it's Wikipedia. This is exactly what would happen if you let anyone edit the Encyclopedia Britannica.

But they have! Encyclopedic works are now filled with revisionist historical views, presented as fact.

309 GoatGuy  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:36:52am

Charles...

You're right of course. But you know, in "marketing the news", the general plan is to outline as much as necessary, leaving off those aspects that people can infer - giving them something to talk about (their conclusions). Just like a beautiful woman is made much more beautiful - and able to walk around in public - by wearing revealing, but "not too revealing" clothes. Same with the news. Dress it up by occluding the potent portent of Islamic-ness and the like. All news is apparantly so dressed.

GoatGuy

310 TalkinKamel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:37:00am

#300 Carolyn

I have wondered that sometimes.

311 Charles  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:38:10am

Pawn: I'm going to back you up on one point. I am also getting very irritated by the "round 'em all up and put 'em in camps or deport 'em" talk.

Face facts. This is never going to happen, and the only thing you achieve by calling for it over and over is to make yourself -- and LGF by association -- look like ranting extremists.

I try to keep discussions as open as possible, but I'm thinking seriously of simply deleting any such comments that I see from now on.

312 Kenneth  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:38:18am

#253 THX-42

OK, I see what you mean. And you make a good point about the parallel.

313 TalkinKamel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:39:15am

#292 Geepers

Hey, what about the history of Halloween? Isn't it simply fascinating?

And nobody's mentioned Andalusia during the last five minutes or so, and I hear it what really swell!

/Seriously, yes, that's exactly the kind of thing JustMyView does.

314 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:39:55am

Taqiyyotomist (#297),

Then I guess I'm gonna whip off a quick "Let's throw all the Muslims on boxcars and ship them off to camps! From all of us here at Charles Johnson's LGF, a hearty Kill 'em All!"

After all, what further harm could be done?

Are you intentionally missing the point?

The MSM doesn't need any emails whatsoever, good or bad, to push their agenda.

Send 'em any email you want. Or not. It won't change their excuse making for muslims or their tarring of "ultraconservative" websites like the one you're posting on.

315 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:39:59am

Regarding shouts of "allah ackbar":

That should be in the police report, if the cops recognized what he was saying. That should be publicly available. I don't think it's legal for them to ammend a police report, and I think they're subject to FOIA requests, so that should come out in the next few days. If the cops didn't recognize what was being said, it's unlikely that any civilian witnesses would, either.

There was also a report of a koran at the scene. This, too, will be in the police report if true. So it's best to give this 100 hours, and chill with the speculation. It should all become public knowledge by next week. Some blogger will request the report, and publish it.

I think trying to infer anything from that audio is just looking foolish.

316 ciaospirit  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:40:38am

#259 JustMyView

In stories about crime, the perpetrator's race is mentioned if he or she is still at large and knowledge of race might help a member of the public identify the person.

Wish it were so. In central Ohio news, I've seen them go out of their way to the point of rediculous to avoid mentioning race.

317 uptight  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:40:40am

#115 unreconstructed rebel

when a liberal crosses the socialist bridge, he becomes a fascist

Is there a bridge? I just thought is was a road that lead from moderate - to liberal - to socialist - to fascist.

The road goes the other way too, mind you. Moderate - to conservative - to far right - to fascist.

Whilst Liberals and Conservatives couldn't be more different, the extremes tend to blur. This allows Stormfronters to turn up in support of Sheehan. This allows the far left to march in tacit support of Islamofascism.

It is not insignificant that "Nazism" is a shortened term for "National Socialism".

On the less extreme side of things, Liberals do make a lot of noise about how "caring" and "humanitarian" they are. They claim to be the ones leading the fight against poverty, racism, sexism, homophobia and fascism.

They claim that it is the conservatives who have racist, sexist, homophobic and fascist tendencies.

The facts suggest otherwise.

Conservatives may not make a big show of their commitment towards humanitarian and egalitarian causes, but whereas liberal politics effectively maintain the status quo, conservative policies actually provide opportunities for change.

A liberal would see a starving junky begging in the street. He would borrow $10 and give it to the junky as proof that he "cares". The junky of course will just spend it on junk and carry on begging.

A conservative will encourage and help the junky to clean up his act and get a job. A liberal would claim this lacks compassion, but it is the only path that actually helps the junky.

Liberal "compassion" is just for show purposes. It is there to demonstrate how "wonderful" they are, but when push comes to shove, they will more readily team up with psychopathic, homophobic, misogynist theocrats and fascists.

Conservatives just get on with the job of protecting freedom and creating opportunities for us to better ourselves.

318 WriterMom  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:42:37am

#290 TalkinKamel

I'm not BabbaZee, but can I help?

LOL!

319 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:43:04am

Pawn of the Oppressor (#301),

because of one punkass kid with a gun.

You forgot the part about him MURDERING five people.

Funny that.

320 doppelganglander  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:43:53am

#292 Geepers: I know, but that's a particular pet peeve of mine, and I think it is tangentially related to the topic at hand. I should have known better.

321 Axiom  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:43:59am

Charles: I think a little pushback from you is will probably have the same effect. Warnings, cautions: these can be very helpful at communicating the displeasure with comments along the line you mentioned.

LGF users should also push back against that kind of commentary. We know inflammatory comments when we see them. It's only right that those commenters are rebutted by other LGF users.

322 Michael Levy  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:44:12am

Let's say for purposes of argument that this guy had a legitimate mental breakdown that doctors would recognize, and he's not a perfectly healthy fellow overcome by desire to commit Jihad.

That still doesn't defeat the "sudden Jihad syndrome" hypothesis.

Crazy people react in ways they've been taught. This Muslim, like every Muslim in this country, has been exposed to the idea that individual Muslims can flip out and commit acts of mass murder. So instead of blowing his head off like a Christian or an atheist, he takes a trip to the mall and tries to kill as many people as possible.

Just like the "jeep jihadi" and San Francisco rampage Muslims learned how to flip out like Muslims. Like how the Arab boy Bishop (actual family name: Bishara) learned to fly a plane into a building. Just like that creep who shot up LAX learned how to flip out like A Muslim. Like the Arab Marc LePine learned to hate and kill women.

Just like the non-Muslim school shooters of the past decade learned to go on rampages from our sensationalist media. The idea to commit mass murder doesn't just spring forth out of nowhere in most people who flip out, it's learned from our culture.

The blame for this lies squarely with the Muslims who glorify these sorts of attacks, such as Palestinian terror attacks in Israel. That's where this Muslim learned how to flip out like a Muslim.

That's why it's important to condemn Palestinian terror, and to demand that Muslims in America condemn Palestinian terror (and Hezbollah, and the Iraqi insurgents who blow up marketplaces, etc.).

But the weak, complaint, cowardly media like Deseret News refuse to ask the difficult questions once, let alone asking them repeatedly until they get an answer. Shame on Deseret news.

323 J.D.  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:44:23am

#311 Charles

I try to keep discussions as open as possible, but I'm thinking seriously of simply deleting any such comments from now on.


Hear hear!
And don't feel the least bit bad about doing it.

324 ciaospirit  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:44:25am

#266 Pawn of the Oppressor

No witnesses heard "Allahu Akhbar",

Early on, however, someone posted that there was a witness on CNN (I believe) that said the shooter was holding a Koran. Future segments were minus this guy for whatever reason. Was the guy mistaken, censored, what? We don't know.

325 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:44:40am

#309 GoatGuy

'Scuse me. The news is supposed to be about the facts, not art. If leaving facts out makes it juicy because that leaves something to the imagination, that's a bad thing, not a good thing. Or do you like the Arab media?

326 Ojoe  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:45:14am

311 Charles

If, God forbid, the Islamic extremists set off a nuke in a city in the USA it will look like we were stupid not to have taken some measures sooner.

I will be quiet for now but I think some thoughts more as time goes on and events unfold.

327 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:46:05am

318 WriterMom

I don't know. How's your Gramscian?

328 jimash  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:47:09am

at 2:04 you can hear him repeat it after an extended fusillade.

1:34 and 2:04 are the same voice saying, not shouting allahhuakhbar.

329 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:47:17am
330 WriterMom  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:48:12am

I would say this crime is definitely terrorism-random, mass murder of innocent civilians. Whether it was terror in the name of jihad still remains to be seen.

331 Cartman  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:48:14am

#311 Charles

I try to keep discussions as open as possible, but I'm thinking seriously of simply deleting any such comments from now on.

Bravo. As a relatively regular reader, I find some of the more outlandish comments embarrasing, at the very least. To be fair and balanced though, the vast majority of Lizards appear to be intelligent and well thought out in their opinions. Just my humble two cents...

332 jrdroll  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:48:19am
333 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:48:26am

#324 ciaospirit

See #315. Some blogger in the SLC area needs to make a FOIA request for the police reports. I'm sure it's already been done.

334 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:48:53am
335 Carolyn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:50:24am

From Hugh Fitzgerald

The absurdity of those who claim that on the one hand the murders in Salt Lake City are "unexplainable" but who apparently refuse to consider the one thing about the murderer that is certain -- that he was a Muslim, that is the adherent of a belief-system that, according to its canonical texts, the Qur'an and Hadith and Sira (which offers the model of Muhamamd, uswa hasana, al-insan al-kamil), inculcates in Muslims the idea that Believers and Infidels are in a permanent state of war, if not always of actual warfare (there is a difference).

In postings yesterday about this event, I noted that it is not a question of "Jihad" in the sense in which some people take that word. It is not, that is, that this or that Muslim, angry about the world, has necessarily to have a particular goal in mind: to destroy Israel, to seize Kashmir and then much of the rest of India, to drive the Buddhists out of southern Thailand, to kill all the black African Christians, and indeed non-Arab black African Muslims, in Sudan, or to snatch part of historic Serbia from the Serbs. It need not reach that level of consciousness.

What happens, or can happen, and what has been happening, is this: a Muslim who has suffered any kind of personal setbacks or mental disarray will always be able to blame Infidels, and will take out his fury, his rage, on Infidels -- any Infidels will do.

That, I suggest, is what happened in this case. One would like to know more. One would like to know what was at his house, what he read, what he looked at on-line, whom he talked to about his fury over either the situation in the Balkans, or in Iraq, or here in the United States.

I have little doubt that fair-minded investigators instead of throwing up one's hands and sputtering, as FBI agent Kiernan did, that "it is unexplainable" -- will be able to reconstruct the mind of someone whose chief, and overwhelming identifying characteristic, the molder of his thoughts and attitudes and above all, his resentments and his murderous hatreds --was Islam, Islam, Islam.
Posted by: Hugh

336 Beagle  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:50:55am

Yes, just another Muslim who suddenly up and decided to murder as many kuffar as possible. There's no pattern of behavior to notice. The Qur'an is just like the Bible when it comes to the treatment of other religions.

The FBI would like to announce that tommorow's mass shooting and mysterious explosions have nothing to do with Islam or terrorism. Whatever you do, don't associate Islam with Iran, Saudi Arabia, or Pakistan, where they practice the real thing.

And on that whimper of pitiful stupidity, western civilization allowed itself to be destroyed.

337 WriterMom  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:51:16am

#329 buzzsawmonkey

While these particular authors might not have been intentionally leaving out the Muslim bit-there is certainly no shortage of journalists who are leaving out the information because of their leftist, anti-Western convictions. Not all of the omissions are innocent. I would say that some are a result of a direct wish to apologize for Islamic terror.

338 FredWM  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:51:46am

It's all very simple. The MSM exists in order to educate and direct the unwashed masses to a higher level of existence. If any one fact would lead the masses in the wrong direction, it is their duty to obscure it. Therefore, acts of terrorism might make people think GWB is correct about something. As that conclusion is obviously in error, anything leading the uneducated in that direction is best left unmentioned.

339 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:53:08am

Axiom (#321),

LGF users should also push back against that kind of commentary.

I used to, always. Spoke out against bigel's endless genocidal screeds. Spoke out against American Infidel's endless deport them all screeds.

About all it got me was labeled an "ankle-biter", and worse.

So I just scroll over 'em anymore.

340 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:55:44am

#337 WriterMom

In this case, I think Buzzsaw's right. There's no need for them to go out on a limb and defend jihad, when they can pretend that this wasn't jihad. But if it were undeniable that this was jihad, I think you're right; they'd be making up excuses for why it was an excusable, if not legitimate thing to do.

341 Sam I Am  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:56:38am
Having lived under Soviet Union rules for decades

What idiots.

Bosnia was part of Yugoslavia and not part of the Soviet Union.

Yes, Tito was a communist/dictator but not like Stalin or the Soviets.

The people there had more freedoms than those under the Soviets (but that is not saying much...)

Also, the Bosnian muslims have always been pretty much secular (at least until the 1990s when they were becoming radicalized) but this was after Tito's death and the breakup of Yugoslavia into its various ethnic parts -- Serbia, Croatia, Bosnia, Kosovo, Slovenia, etc.

Another example of the media not having their facts straight.

342 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:56:59am

The issue here is not the drawing of conclusions, but a media outlet's deliberate omission of facts.

Charles, Elaine Jarvik and Deborah Bulkeley can draw all the conclusions they want. So long as I have been supplied with the facts, I can form my own conclusion(s), while taking someone else's conclusion(s) into account.

When facts are omitted, the intent of the media outlet has changed from that of informing the public to misleading the public.

343 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:57:25am

339 Geepers

So what? So you get labeled an "ankle biter". Big deal. I'm an ankle biter, too. A proud ankle biter.

344 republic  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:58:13am
And Elaine Jarvik and Deborah Bulkeley explicitly blame LGF for angry emails the paper has received, rather than examine their policy of hiding information from the public. They really don’t like it when their politically correct coverups are exposed.

That is spot on Charles.

They leave out relevant facts to the story, with pre-meditation of their leftist agenda, and then scream "V I C T I M" when anyone even mentions this.

The msm suffers from "truthophobia".

They are "truthophobians"!

345 torontoguy  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:58:33am

#276 WriterMom,

Actually, the Toronto Star has a policy of NOT mentioning the skin colour of assailants in their reporting-even when the police press releases clearly state the person's skin colour and description in order to better identify them.

CityPulse News once beeped out the word 'black' when spoken by a police officer reporting on a crime.

346 bigdicksplace  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:01:51am

Charles, screw them.
You have a hell of a lot more readers than they do.

347 Fenway_Nation  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:02:35am

If the shooter was a Mormon, we'd have the MSM insinuating 27/7 that Mitt Romney himself sold him the shotgun and shells.

A co-worker brought up the shooting yesterday and said something about 'Crazy Mormons'. When I corrected him and said 'Bosnian Muslim', he didn't seem very surprised.

348 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:03:56am

#329 buzzsawmonkey

This is why I think the confusion of the USSR with Yugoslavia is significant. If they really had a culture of quality, and cared about getting things right, they wouldn't have made a bonehead mistake like that. And if they had a culture of quality, they also wouldn't let their biases enter the picture.

As I've been preaching, at the root of bias is the media's "whatever" attitude toward quality. That's what opens the door to political bias. If they really has a commitment to quality, their personal biases would be irrelevent. The dominance of left-leaning culture is a necessary but not sufficent condition for a biased product. The other necessary condition is an attitude that it doesn't matter if they put out a quality product. That's the part that's going to be their downfall.

349 Fenway_Nation  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:04:01am

*24/7

PIMF

(altho if there were 27 hours in a day, I'm sure the MSM would do that as well).

350 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:07:16am

329 buzzsawmonkey

but it was not intentional because the biases which informed the writers were, to them, as self-evident as the fact that the sun comes up in the morning.

So because they have a bias they don't see that they have a bias, and this excuses them from omitting facts from news stories?

351 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:08:00am

Look at the latest Deseret News article:

Investigation ongoing despite shooter's death

Despite the fact the gunman in Monday's mass murder at Trolley Square shopping mall is dead, police remain hard at work trying to piece together more information about the crime and the motive behind it.

Geez, the cops viciously gunned down this poor innocent immigrant, can't we move on? Really, there's nothing to see here, nothing. Stop digging. We're just gonna whitewash it anyway.

352 snowtravel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:09:23am

Deseret News got this one right. The whole point of the post was, indeed, that the shooter at Trolley Square was Muslim. We all know how important that is here on LGF. Pretending otherwise now isn't just disingenuous, it's a howler.

Equally ridiculous is the implication that Deseret is part of some MSM effort at “hiding information from the public.” These are local writers for a local paper, n'est-ce pas?

FYI, the constituency that Deseret serves is more than a bit conservative. In fact, it’s hard to imagine anyplace more fervently, flag-wavingly patriotic than Utah. (Ever heard of the Mormans, lizards?) Deseret is no more plausibly part of the left than it is the MSM. Tired and stupid dichotomies aren't helpful, but even if they were LGF is fighting its own here.

So let's review: The Trolley Square shooter was a Muslim. No need to back away from it: Muslim, muslim, muslim. LGF scooped the world.

Great job. Enjoy.

353 TalkinKamel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:09:24am

#318 WriterMom

Sure, any time!

:>)

354 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:10:55am
355 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:11:47am
356 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:11:53am

#352 snowtravel

It would help if you actually contributed something to the discussion.

357 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:12:36am
358 JustMyView  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:13:27am

#91 Elric

Perhaps the Deseret News can answer that since Im sure they are lurking. Excuse me Deseret News. Could you please answer the question? :-)

They might be happy to answer, but, unlike the Deseret News, which accepts comments from anyone who has a keyboard, they would be unable to respond unless they are already registered.

359 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:15:58am

354 buzzsawmonkey

It would be an easier thing if more of them were in fact conscious of the biases they mistake for eternal, unchallengeable verities.

As I said in 248, that would happen if they were real professionals. The fact that they don't recognize the difference between facts and assumptions is a symptom of their big problem, which is an industry culture of arrogance. They're about where the US auto industry was in the '70s wrt quality. Scratch that. They're a lot worse. Probably hopeless.

360 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:16:18am

snowtravel (#352),

So let's review: The Trolley Square shooter was a Muslim.

"Shooter" What a nice bland unassuming and non-judgmental word.

All feel good and happy.

Too bad about the shot huh? They probably had it coming, eh?

361 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:16:42am

358 JustMyView

They might be happy to answer, but, unlike the Deseret News, which accepts comments from anyone who has a keyboard, they would be unable to respond unless they are already registered.

They could use the contact form on the left sidebar. I'm sure Charles would share.

362 WriterMom  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:16:45am

#354 buzzsawmonkey

Yes-we definitely agree. Most journalists think they are being completely "objective", and that they have no bias. They are just reporting. There are different degrees to which this idiotic self-assessment endanger the public. As Bernard Goldberg pointed out in "Bias", journalism is a field that attracts liberals, but these people often don't even classify themselves as 'liberals'-their bias is so deeply ingrained it's almost unconscious. They think that everyone else in the world has bias-but that they are immune. Then there are others that are willfully promoting the anti-Jewish, anti-Western, pro-Palestinian agenda.

363 Alouette  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:19:10am

#203 Kenneth

Sometimes the survivors of these horrible experiences will "snap" and go out and victimize others. This is not excusing the crime, nor the criminals. It's just a fact.

Bullshit. When did an Auschwitz survivor ever go postal?

364 snowtravel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:20:57am

#356 Earth2moonbat 2/15/2007 11:11AM PST

It would help if you actually contributed something to the discussion.

Mea culpa. I wrote my post when there were like, 30 comments maybe. Realized an hour later that I hadn't pressed "post" and then did so without thinking. Sorry.

Anyway, I was referring to this statement, which everyone here ignores: “[T]he story of Monday’s shooting rampage at Trolley Square has been reduced to one fact: ‘Salt Lake City Killer Was a Muslim.’[A ridiculous, patently untrue assertion that shows their agenda. —ed.]”

365 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:20:57am

buzzsawmonkey-

"To crooked eyes the truth might wear a wry face." Gandalf

366 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:23:28am
367 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:24:36am

JustMyView (#358),

Yeah, because we all know just who fucking difficult it is to type "charles@littlegreenfootballs.com" into an email address field. Apparently for intrepid journalists only seeking the truth, this is just too high a hurdle to clear.

Do you really expect anyone to buy your bullshit excuses?

368 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:28:36am
369 Dar ul Harb  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:28:42am

#264, km

On the above video @ 1:38 I hear three shouts of Allah Akbar.

Sounds like it to me.

The police at about 1:05 identify themselves and order the suspect to drop the gun.

Then you hear shots.

The police repeat the order.

Then the three "Allahu Ackbars".

Another shot.

Then the police, or someone shouts "there he is!"

370 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:28:46am

JustMyView (#358)

Still waiting......

371 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:29:07am
372 formercorpsman  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:29:46am
So let's review: The Trolley Square shooter was a Muslim. No need to back away from it: Muslim, muslim, muslim. LGF scooped the world.

Great job. Enjoy.


I know, your just as concerned about right wingers as you are about the possibility of islamic violence.

It is your type that has me more concerned, and seriously thinking about utilizing my Second Amendment Rights, than the thought of lone muslim going on a shooting spree in a mall.

It is your ilk who are so quick to label someone who votes for a different political party in a free country, with Nazi, without recognizing the same threat stemming from what is discussed on this board each day.

No you fear me, who pays their taxes, employs other Americans, and is very concerned about the global threat, and what will be left for my children, and what we have wasted in the aftermath of those who gave their lives in defending our freedom.

You are a twit. Go back to your chicken wire experiments.

373 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:31:18am

taxfreekiller (#366),

#203

carefull I may go Rambo on you......

I very much doubt that Kenneth is any too concerned with you going "Rambo" on him, when you can't even refer to him by name.

374 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:31:53am

#363 Alouette

I agree. People go postal when there's a crowd of fans cheering them on to go postal.

375 JustMyView  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:32:58am

#94 Ginn

How lucky for the Islamists that if someone does a single terrorist attack here in the US as long as they aren't dressed in camouflage and wearing a ski mask while chanting Arabic then the MSM will not include the info that this mass murderer, for no apparent reason, killed a bunch of people, happened to also be a Muslim.

Perhaps the absence of the reference to his religion has something to do w/ your phrase "happened to be." That is, it was a correlate, not a cause. Let's just say, for instance, that he owned a motorcycle (a potential Hell's Angel) and was a vegan (a potential animal rights nutcase). Should those facts be in the story too? How about in the headline? On Page 1? Above the fold?


If the killer in Salt Lake City had been Jewish, Evangelical, ect.. you can bet the headlines would something like this:

Jewish Man Goes On Rampage In Mall

Again, baloney. No serious newspaper would ever print such a headline. Do you even believe this yourself? Have you ever seen a headline describing a murder that specified the killer's race or religion when that information was not obviously and directly relevant to the crime?

Quickly now. What was the religion of the man who shot the children in the Amish schoolhouse? What? You don't know? Guess he must have been Muslim since that information was obviously suppressed.

376 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:35:07am

#375 JustMyView

You're either being dishonest or stupid. Which one is it?

377 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:35:39am
378 mglazer  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:36:57am

More on the Media and Police Blackout of the latest Muslim Mass Murderer

[Link: www.debbieschlussel.com...]

Our protectors aren't protecting us

I feel safer

379 mglazer  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:37:49am

#375 JustMyView

Yes, they do that all the time

just search news headlines

380 DWalla  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:39:13am

I live here in Salt Lake City... and I can tell you the media has definitely gone out of their way to slap down any question as to whether he was a jihadi or not. Personally I'm open to the answer whichever way it falls. If he was a jihadi... then let's deal with it in the correct manner. If he's not a jihadi... then fine... it's a random act of violence or spurred on by other motives. But to instantly slap down the possibility without any facts smacks of serious media bias and political correctness. Asking if he is a jihadi is DEFINITELY a valid question.

381 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:39:38am
382 mglazer  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:41:11am

Terrorism Works

It has instilled fear in Americans

in their newspapers, police, even citizenry

too afraid to ask simple question to save their own hides

383 JustMyView  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:42:03am

#185 violent jihadi

Christians are not storming into shopping malls and shooting up strangers.

Of course, they are. It happened just a few months ago in a shopping mall not too far from where I live. If all the murder and mayhem committed by Muslims in the United States were eliminated entirely and there was never another crime committed by a Muslim, I daresay the effect on the crime rate would not be detectable.

384 DWalla  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:42:51am

By the way... the area where the 18 year old lived is a horrible place. Riddled with crime.

385 amphibian  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:43:23am

#246 Ojoe:

He.

Was.

A.

Terrorist.


Wake up !

Ojoe, no need to shout. I'm not standing behind the guy, just giving an opinion that he did not seem to be connected to anything wider, or to political terrorism, except maybe for reading some web sites about the joys of jihad and deciding that he needed to get him some virgins, asap.

I'm awake, don't worry. But I will decide whether this was a freelance job, the fruit of hints dropped at the mosque or online, or something organized, after I get some more details. (Probably not from the Deseret News, though.)

386 Dar ul Harb  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:43:35am

Anyone who knows police jargon?

Right before the "Allahuackbars" at 1:38, I hear something like "O.T. O.T." at 1:37. It seems like the police yelling to each other, or one officer warning the others about the tactical situation.

Is this jargon, or one of the officers' initials?

387 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:43:50am

#368 buzzsawmonkey

They are acting according to a series of prejudices of which they are largely unconscious. Making them aware of their prejudices is confrontational enough without tarring them with a malicious intent that most simply do not have.

I think you're right, but I say again, until you instill some discipline into their industrial culture, there's no way to get them to give a crap. They won't question their assumptions and prejudices, because there's no motivation to. I don't think it's going to happen. I think what is going to happen is the media will become fragmented into niche markets of biased news for their respective markets. We're headed there right now; two halves of a country listening to two completely different sets of facts.

388 Daisy  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:44:25am

One good thing about Salt Lake City is that deniers of reality have really easy access to tons of sand to bury their stupefied heads in.

389 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:44:50am

368 buzzsawmonkey

They are acting according to a series of prejudices of which they are largely unconscious. Making them aware of their prejudices is confrontational enough without tarring them with a malicious intent that most simply do not have.

I understand your point, and agree to an extent. However, there has been an ongoing effort to expose media bias for a number of years now. This effort has been successful thanks in large part to the very blog we post on now, as well as countless other blogs and media personalities. This effort is clearly affecting the msm's bottom line. The media is waking up too slowlyto this problem, if they are waking up at all. I await the day the nyt goes out of business, it shouldn't be long.

390 DWalla  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:45:14am

"Of course, they are. It happened just a few months ago in a shopping mall not too far from where I live. If all the murder and mayhem committed by Muslims in the United States were eliminated entirely and there was never another crime committed by a Muslim, I daresay the effect on the crime rate would not be detectable."

The difference here is this.... religion is the motive for slaying when it comes to the jihadis. They feel it is their religious obligation to carry out such acts of violence against the innocent. The other cases you are referring too are primarily random acts of violence.

391 J.D.  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:45:25am

So according to Encyclopedia Brittanica, the Taliban is ultraconservative... [Link: www.britannica.com...]

392 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:46:14am

#383 JustMyView

Of course, they are. It happened just a few months ago in a shopping mall not too far from where I live.

Show me the evidence that it was a Christian.

393 jimash  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:46:47am

Is this jargon, or one of the officers' initials?

Dar, the cop ois yelling OPD... Ogden Police Department.

394 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:46:56am

JustMyView (#375),

Fuck you for even attempting to conflate the two.

“The Amish have been reaching out to the family of the gunman, Charles Carl Roberts IV, 32, who committed suicide during the attack. Dwight Lefever, a Roberts family spokesman, said an Amish neighbor comforted the Roberts family hours after the shooting and extended forgiveness to them… Staring down the barrel of Charles Carl Roberts' gun, 13-year-old Marian Fisher and her 11-year-old sister, Barbie, bravely pleaded with the madman to shoot them and spare the eight other girls he was holding hostage. "Marian said, 'Shoot me first,' and Barbie said, 'Shoot me second,' " said midwife Rita Rhoads, who had helped deliver several of the victims. "They were really trying to save the younger girls. It is a real reflection of their faith’… At the behest of Amish leaders, a fund has also been set up for the killer's widow and three children.”
395 DWalla  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:46:59am

The one cop was yelling "OPD! OPD!" for Ogden Police Department.... he didn't wawnt to get shot in a friendly-fire situation.

396 JustMyView  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:47:04am

#379 mglazer


Yes, they do that all the time

just search news headlines

I read news headlines all the time, and I've never seen such a headline. You'll have to convince me. If you can find five headlines published over the past ten years in which the religion of someone who committed a major crime in the United States was printed in the headline of the initial article regarding that crime I will send a check for $100 to your favorite Republican presidential candidate.

397 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:48:31am

#391 J.D.

The USSR used to be routinely destribed as "conservative" and even "ultraconservative" by the media.

398 jrdroll  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:49:29am
two halves of a country listening to two completely different sets of facts.

I disagree. We have the left trying to impose their myths on us. Global warming, minimum wage, public schools etc. are issues for the left that are destroyed by the facts.

399 Daisy  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:49:51am

"There is no record that Talovic attended any of the mosques in the Salt Lake area,"

Or, it's not been made available/has been hidden (what! crazy imams lie!) .. or .. it was in area other than Salt Lake City .. or .. he took his mind-meals at Islamoncrack etc.

400 mglazer  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:51:08am

#383 JustMyView

Earth 2 moonbat , hello, anyone home in there , hello mcfly...

how can you be on lgf and that dense?

[Link: www.thereligionofpeace.com...]

Weekly Jihad Report
(2/03 - 2/09) Jihad Attacks: 62

Dead Bodies: 529

Critically Injured: 717

[Link: www.terrorismawareness.org...]

401 Murqtaad  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:51:15am

I'm just happy it wasn't a fundemental Christian who did the shootings. God knows how much more of a threat they are to America than muslims. There would have been scores of dead. Plus a few abortion clinics would have been blown up while a pre-school was on a field trip there.

/y'all know

402 JustMyView  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:52:20am

#271 doppelganglander

#259 JustMyView: I don't know where you live, but in Atlanta, the TV and radio news rarely, if ever, mentions the person's race in the description of a perp at large, unless it's a white guy in a pick-up truck who's been trying to snatch little girls from the bus stop. The only major outlet I know of that routinely includes race in a description is America's Most Wanted.

I'll be persuaded of that when you tell me who you've called at three radio stations and three TV stations to find out what their policies are on this issue.

403 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:52:33am

#398 jrdroll

Let me clarify by putting quotes around the word "facts". Make sense now?

404 mglazer  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:53:20am

#383 JustMyView

Get a clue douche

[Link: jihadwatch.org...]

[Link: www.danielpipes.org...]

405 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:53:42am

387 Earth2moonbat

They won't question their assumptions and prejudices, because there's no motivation to.

See my 389. Eventually, they will have to. $$$

406 Murqtaad  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:53:45am

JMV,

Christians are not storming into shopping malls and shooting up strangers.

Of course, they are. It happened just a few months ago in a shopping mall not too far from where I live. If all the murder and mayhem committed by Muslims in the United States were eliminated entirely and there was never another crime committed by a Muslim, I daresay the effect on the crime rate would not be detectable.

Link, please?

407 Murqtaad  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:56:21am

394 Geepers,

THANK YOU. Somebody needed to say that.

408 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:56:57am

Earth2moonbat (#392),

She isn't going to show you shit.

She's here to piss on the graves of the murdered so she can feel good about herself standing up the "Reich wingers" because she's too big a coward to ever condemn a muslim for any reason whatsoever.

You know, cuz, they're just poor oppressed brown people that can't possibly be held accountable for their actions. It's the ultimate bigotry, and she's so blinkered by her own self-righteousness that she probably doesn't even know she's doing it.

Hey JustMyView, are you a journalist?

409 ggt  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:58:19am

clean-up in aisle #297

410 Murqtaad  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:59:40am

JMV 396,

I read news headlines all the time

We can tell. That's as far as you read, no doubt. I have friends like you, they vote democrat cause the headlines tell them to, then they argue with me, 5 or 6 on 1, and call me brainwashed. Heh. Ironic, no?

411 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 9:59:41am

#405 Sharmuta

I don't think it's going to happen. I think they're going to shrink, and blame it on other factors than their own poor quality. I don't think the investors are going to demand change, because they would have done so already. Eventually, they'll reach an equilibrium where they'll be selling to the lefty market exclusively. Other papers selling to the sane market will expand to fill the void. They just haven't hit bottom yet.

412 Dar ul Harb  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:02:11am

#393,


Dar, the cop ois yelling OPD... Ogden Police Department.

Thanks.

So what I have is...

1:03 "Drop the gun! Ogden Police! Put down the gun now!"

1:08 A shot.

1:12 Another shot.

1:28 Two shots, closely spaced.

1:38 "Police!"
1:37 "O.P.D.! O.P.D.!"
1:38 "Allahuackbar! Allahhuackbar!"

1:40 Another shot. Possibly another "Allahuackbar!".

1:43 "There he is!"

413 J.D.  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:03:08am
414 Murqtaad  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:03:40am

ggt 409,

I may be wrong (it's happened once or twice before), but I think 297 forgot the sarc tag.

415 Murqtaad  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:05:04am

Dar,

I can't stream during peak hours at work, but is it a definite that the killer was saying allahu akbar?

416 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:05:47am

411 Earth2moonbat

I think they're going to shrink, and blame it on other factors than their own poor quality.

I think that's a given. lol

417 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:06:22am

#413 J.D.

Then he and Bush and Sharon should get along just fine!

418 Carolyn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:07:13am

snowtravel (#352)
This crime does not stand alone. There are how many instances of "sudden jihad syndrome" now?

419 Dar ul Harb  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:07:15am

1:33 "Put down the gun." (said quietly)

420 Mormon Doc  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:08:23am

If anyone is up for organizing a demonstration against the DesNews in Salt Lake I am certainly up for attending. I'll bring my three oldest sons as well.

421 ggt  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:08:56am

#414 murqtaad

ggt 409,

I may be wrong (it's happened once or twice before), but I think 297 forgot the sarc tag.

Perhaps, I am sensitive to calls for murder. IMHO--Sarcastic or not, I don't like seeing in on LGF.

Too easy to be taken out of context by those who are constantly berating Charles and LGF. We aren't in each other's living rooms, talking privately. The whole world can read what we write here. Sarcasm isn't always understood when written.

422 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:09:32am

#415 Murqtaad

I couldn't hear it. I don't know if it can be enhanced, but I think it takes some imagination to hear that in the raw audio. I'm not saying that that's wrong, I'm just saying that it's pretty badly garbled. You can barely make out the cops' words.

423 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:10:06am

Murqtaad (#407),

I have no patience for people who try to justify murderers by saying "well somebody else murdered someone too, so what?"

She will never condemn this guy. Even as simply a MURDERER, because he's muslim.

424 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:11:48am

418 Carolyn

There are how many instances of "sudden jihad syndrome" now?

I posted a short list at #141 above.

425 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:12:21am

#423 Geepers

I think you're right. If this was a bombing of an abortion clinic, there would be outrage that could be heard around the world.

426 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:13:21am

Hmmmm.......interesting hypothetical: What if a muslim bombs an abortion clinic? What's a moonbat to do?

427 jimash  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:13:32am

I have my computer hooked up to a mixing board and studio monitors.
You really need to make it so loud that the gunshots are painful. cut 100hz and below, boost 2.5k a bit.
He's not screaming.
it is some bad mall sound. but he repeats it in the same tone of voice several times.
Notably for me at 1:38 and 2:04.

428 Dar ul Harb  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:15:07am

#415, Murqtaad

I can't stream during peak hours at work, but is it a definite that the killer was saying allahu akbar?

Not definite, but it sure sounds like it to me.

Said quickly as though it is all one word. "Allahuackbar!"

I'm trying to make a transcript so that others can identify what segment of the video we're talking about here.

It'd be useful to have someone who's used to Arabic listen. I'm certainly no expert, but it sounds like other recordings of the phrase that I've heard before.

Admittedly difficult to identify the individual speakers, though.

429 Highrise  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:15:57am

Charles wrote:

Please note — I have not expressed any opinion on whether the mall attack was an act of jihad, personal or otherwise. I’ve raised the issue, with good reason. But I have deliberately refrained from expressing a conclusion, because we obviously do not know enough at this point to do that.

I believe the same thing. I think questioning is what you are SUPPOSE to do when a crime happens. Questioning would be to a minimum if you could trust the MSM to report the conclusion..but when they leave out vital pieces of info...kinda hard to do that. Oh, but they can sure question and even reinforce the fact that Bush carried out the 9/11 attacks. /BOGGLE

430 Carolyn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:16:13am
383 JustMyView 2/15/2007 11:42AM PST

#185 violent jihadi

Christians are not storming into shopping malls and shooting up strangers.

Of course, they are.

Did the perp shout Jesus is the only way right before he shot people? Of course not!
Not everyone that is not Jewish (or Hindu or...) is a Christian.

431 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:18:18am

#427 jimash

Somebody with a serious DSP system needs to filter that. You're not only doing it the hard way, you're doing it in a way that others can't repeat. A very narrow notch filter can seperate the shooter's voice from the cops. Whether it can overcome the bad acoustics, I don't know.

Or you can wait for a blogger to do a FOIA request from the cops, and get the police report.

432 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:19:18am
433 Dar ul Harb  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:20:58am

#427, jimash

It's true, you have to turn the sound up loud enough that the gunshots are painfully loud (as they would be if you were on scene). I'm using earbuds, but I do have a very high speed connection at the moment...

I'll listen at 2:04, as you suggest.

434 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:21:46am

J.D. (#413),

I'm really kinda surprised Elaine Jarvik and Deborah Bulkeley didn't try to get cute and label us Überconservatives.

435 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:24:12am

430 Carolyn

Not everyone that is not Jewish (or Hindu or...) is a Christian.

Precisely. Why- they might even be an atheist. The possibilities are endless.

436 Highrise  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:25:15am

58 Ward Cleaver 2/15/2007 08:56AM PST

Who'd have ever thought Salt Lake would go dhimmi?

Cult basics have already been laid down there. The mindset has been there for decades. Just pick your religion poison.

437 jimash  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:25:39am

Make that 1:34

1:27 "there he goes"
Shots
1:30 "one down in ?
1:34"allahuackbar" "Police" "OPD OPD"
1:40 "Come on BAck"
Then the police get it together.
2:00 bunch of shots (5) "Are you ok ?"
2:04 "allhuackbar" x2
PA noise
"I'm Good"
"Yeah"

438 Ojoe  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:26:03am

385 amphibian

Well functionally he was a terrorist.

And we should thank God that he didn't go to a school where there would be less chance that someone with a pistol could have stopped him early or we would have had something like Beslan here in the USA.

Thanx for debating

439 TalkinKamel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:27:42am

#351 Geepers

I know what you mean. Myself, I certainly hope they would still be investigating the crime, whether the murderer's still alive or not! This is not something that should just be brushed away with, "Oh well, he's dead, no point in pursuing this any further!" As I recall, investigations re Columbine went on for weeks afterwards.

Maybe he did it for Islam; maybe he was just nuts. Somebody sold him a gun. Somebody may have taught him how to shoot it. There's a lot going on here and, yes, the authorities should continue investigating, and not just let it drop because they're afraid of what might they might find.

#382 JustMyView

Please provide a link or reference for the Christian gunman you say shot up a mall.

440 scattershot  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:27:48am

Aren't we glad he was not a Viet Nam Veteran ?

#432: You make good sense.

441 Highrise  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:28:28am

45 Elric66 2/15/2007 08:52AM PST

If LGF is "ultra-conservative" what would they call Islam?

For some reason their mind just can't *go there*. After talking to some of these nuts, they refuse to reason. I often wonder how they feed themselves.

442 crash_test_dhimmi  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:28:58am

What I sent them:

Whenever the media ignores the 800 pound gorilla in the room, there will always be an army of Captain Obvious' screaming about the gorilla. This is the essence of the "Blog" movement. If the Media actually did its job, to present all facts, views, angles and stories related to national events, (IE Journalism), then the army of bloggers would go back to their day jobs and other nefarious hobbies. Every article that ignores the gorilla, make excuses for the gorilla, or calling the gorilla a "good boy", only adds to the ranks of the bloggers, and detracts from your readerships.

Vitriolic e-mails zero in on 'Gorilla'

When you claim that the motive is yet unknown, and go to great lengths to ignore possible religious motivations, (or as some news outlets went ahead and called the shooter "Solomon" in place of "Sulejman" as if the shooter were a confused Rabbi), your reporting becomes suspect.

"It is a certain fact that not all Muslims are terrorists, but it is equally certain, and exceptionally painful, that almost all terrorists are Muslims... What an abominable 'achievement.' Does all this tell us anything about ourselves, our societies, and our culture?''- Abdel Rahman al-Rashed, the general manager of Al-Arabiya

[Link: www.csmonitor.com...]

443 doppelganglander  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:29:45am

#402 JustMyView: Why on God's earth would I waste my time doing that?

444 Partisan  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:29:49am

The msm is more interested in telling us what/how to think than providing information to allow an informed public to make decisions. The msm is so leftists and anti American that they are terrified of an awake and engaged public. When the public awakes, todays crop of self selected elites will be swept aside. And this time rational, aware, awake citizens will have the Internet and BLOGs to help them remember how earth-shakingly WRONG the left and msm were about Islam and Socialism and Science.

I just can't take reading this shit anymore on a daily basis. I'm waiting for the next great explosion and then hopefully some of the misguided among us will see.

Until then, back to cleaning my guns.

445 formercorpsman  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:30:07am

snowtravel, if my reponse to your post was in error because of a forgotten quote function, and was the words of another, my apology.

446 Dar ul Harb  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:31:39am

Sounds like a police negotiator at 1:57:

"You are a [unintelligible], why would you do something..."

2:00 A fusillade of shots (four, possibly five)

2:04 I don't hear anything that sounds like "Allahuackbar" here, though someone is saying something as the shot echoes die away. All I can make out is a syllable, sounds like "hit".

447 Highrise  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:31:46am

#88 Cartman 2/15/2007 09:03AM PST

Personally, the jury is still out with regards to this scumbag's motivation.

To a reasonable person, you are entirely correct. I hold the same view as you.

What irks me is that the MSM has already reported it wasn't a motivation within 24 hours. THAT seems a tad too fast. Either put up or shut up with the proof it wasn't..or say the investigation is still ongoing. Either way, their reporting sucks if it isn't asking the same questions as most of it's readers.

448 Paul  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:34:06am

The PC madness of the MSM is not confined to a Muslim youth shooting up a mall.

This week in Racine, Wisconsin, a six year old boy was sexually assaulted in his school's washroom. Based on the reports of eyewitnesses, the assailant was described by the police as to his approximate age, height, his closely cropped goatee and the color of his clothing; he was further described as a "Hispanic or light skinned African-American".

Out local super-PC newspaper, The Milwaukee Journal, in its report of the crime included the police description but omitted the ethnicity and race of the attacker. They subsequently defended the omission on the basis that the attacker's ethnicity and/or race could not be firmly established and was not relevant.

449 TalkinKamel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:34:40am

JustMyView

Carolyn in Post #430 brings up some more good points; did this Christian you're referring to shout something like, "BLOOD FOR JESUS!" when he opened fire? Did he even attend a particular church?

Futhermore, there doesn't seem to be anything like "Sudden Crusader Syndrome" corresponding to the "Sudden Jihadi syndrome"; Christians, as Christians, just don't seem to be losing it the way Moslems, as Moslems, seem to.

450 Sgt.Slappy  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:35:23am

Pawn,

As Buck says in post #284...

What we think, and are making clear (over and over) that it is wrong to ignore SJS as a possiblity.

Perhaps it is a speculative leap to say that this particular shooting was a SJS situation, a small leap at best. Compared to some of the deliberate, calculated, foot-stamping denials: "It's not jihad, I tell you, it's not!" - from most our media, and even law enforcement... with any situation involing a muslim and acts of murder... my bias (...and I will admit I am biased.) inclines toward suspecting Jihad when muslim is involved in a senseless act of violence.

...islam's religious text has made it abundantly clear that all devout followers should either kill or enslave me. Is it wrong to be wary of one's enemies?

451 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:35:39am

#437 jimash

You really can't distinguish that, but I will say that it has that singy chanty quality to it that they use when they say that. It wasn't spoken or shouted; it was chanted.

452 jimash  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:36:39am

Earth 2 moonbat.
I just tried to download it and load it into final cut or soundtrack but I can't wangle it.
The QT download had no sound.

453 3 wood  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:37:00am

#408 Geepers

She isn't going to show you shit.

She's here to piss on the graves of the murdered so she can feel good about herself standing up the "Reich wingers" because she's too big a coward to ever condemn a muslim for any reason whatsoever.


That is JMV in a nutshell, Geepers.

454 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:38:32am

#439 TalkinKamel

Please provide a link or reference for the Christian gunman you say shot up a mall.

That one doesn't answer hard questions.

/Still waiting for an answer to #275.........

455 snowtravel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:41:05am

#372 formercorpsman

I know, your just as concerned about right wingers as you are about the possibility of islamic violence.

Not at all, debate is good if it's civil . . .

It is your type that has me more concerned, and seriously thinking about utilizing my Second Amendment Rights, than the thought of lone muslim going on a shooting spree in a mall.

. . . and refrains from veiled threats of violence . . .

It is your ilk who are so quick to label someone who votes for a different political party in a free country, with Nazi, without recognizing the same threat stemming from what is discussed on this board each day.

. . . and doesn’t bang away at straw men . . .

No you fear me, who pays their taxes, employs other Americans, and is very concerned about the global threat, and what will be left for my children, and what we have wasted in the aftermath of those who gave their lives in defending our freedom.

. . . or stray too far off topic . . .

You are a twit. Go back to your chicken wire experiments.

. . . or engage in hilarious ad hominem attacks that destroy your credibility as a serious thinker.

456 TalkinKamel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:41:44am

#447 Highrise

That's my point exactly. It is too early, at this point, to dismiss ANY motive for this crime.

To my knowledge, they haven't completely searched this kid's home yet; they haven't gone through his computer, checked his cell phone, interviewed all his family, friends, enemies, what have you, and they're still sifting through the witnesses' stories. All that can honestly be said at this point is, "INVESTIGATION IS CONTINUING." Anything else is just speculation.

Yet, already we're being assured that terrorism had nothing to do with it, and the press is pushing the story that he snapped because of Serb atrocities in his homeland (a rather dubious proposition, considering how young he was when he left the place.) In short, the MSM is telling us so desperately not to worry, and nothing's going on, we can't help but be suspicious.

457 TalkinKamel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:44:02am

JustMyView

Earth2Moonbat and I are still waiting.

458 jimash  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:44:37am

#451
Earth2Moonbat

So you do hear it.
I can make it out pretty good. But that really doesn't mean it's there. I accept that. Maybe later I can figger out how to get it n here and really notch and limit and gate the crap out of it.

459 jingoisticirredentist  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:46:06am

I just found a home video of the Mall shooting in SLC, about halfway through you can hear what sounds lik Allah Ackbar! then A lot of shooting. Can anyone analize the recording and tell if thats what is really being said? Also someone is saying at Jihad watch that he had a Koran in his ammo bag and that he shaved his junk prior to the shooting. If this stuff is confirmed there is a MAJOR MSM coverup going on here!

460 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:47:22am

TalkinKamel (#439), Earth2moonbat (#454),

Pretty amazing isn't it?

She can remember that there hasn't been more the five headlines in the last ten years that mention the perpetrators religion, yet can't seem to find a link to the recent Christian killer at a mall near her.

461 TalkinKamel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:48:26am

Also, if Post Traumatic Stress were as severe, and prevalent as people say it is, we'd have had hundreds shootings in Southern California when countless Cambodian refugees and Vietnamese refugees suddenly snapped, and started blasting away at their neighbors.

But we haven't.

462 TalkinKamel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:50:18am

#460 Geepers

Yes, I know---absolutely astonishfying.

(JMV, we're still waiting.)

463 WriterMom  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:50:36am

Geepers, TalkinKamel

I just did a search for Christian+mall+shooting, and about 43 pages of links came up. Most deal with the recent Utah shooting of Christians by a Muslim in a mall. Or that if the shooter was Christian in the mall there would be a lot more media attention.

Don't hold yer breath for JMV to cough up her links.

464 WriterMom  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:51:34am

TalkinKamel. It's like totally ridonculous, man.

465 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:51:47am

#461 TalkinKamel

Right. Alouette called BS on PTS, and I second it. People chose to go nuts.

466 Yank in the EU  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:52:04am
(JMV, we're still waiting.)

Oh, been there, done that.

467 biff  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:52:10am

Why doesn't the MSM take what al-qaeda says seriously? Here is a quote from a September, 2002 USA Today article titled "Al-Qaeda fragmented, smaller, but still deadly":

"We are proving the kuffar (infidels) in Washington wrong," says Jamal Waheeb, 32, a Saudi refugee official in Quetta who Pakistani officials suspect is an al-Qaeda operative. "They said al-Qaeda would be finished. But we are emerging stronger and will hit America's shopping malls, stadiums and kindergartens. This is our promise."


Read the whole thing and ask yourself why millions of American adults cannot connect the dots?

468 Murqtaad  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:52:44am

At any moment JMV should be providing links to the christians who are always walking into malls and shooting them up. She should have no problem backing up her earlier claim with a link since it happened right down the street from her.

/HEAVY

469 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:54:12am

jingoisticirredentist (#459),

We've been discussing that since 450 posts before yours. ;-)

It seems up in the air at this point.

You think one of the intrepid journalist will ask that question of:

• Sgt. Andy Oblad, a patrol sergeant and 10-year veteran of the force.

• Sgt. Josh Scharman, a gang unit/SWAT sergeant who has also spent a decade with the Salt Lake City Police Department.

• Detective Dustin Marshall, a gang detective and member of the SWAT unit who has been a 9-year veteran of the force.

• Detective Brett Olsen, a gang unit detective and 6-year veteran who also serves on the SWAT team.

Good job sirs, you most certainly saved lives with your quick and decisive response.

471 Dar ul Harb  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:55:36am

#459,

Welcome, moby!

472 Murqtaad  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:57:26am

Writermom 463,

Well that right there proves it to headline readers like JMV. See? Christian. Mall. Shooters. It's all right there in the headlines, man!

/And this global warming is making a virtual summertime paradise for those of us lucky enough to live in the sub-tropical NorthEast.

473 J.D.  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 10:57:28am

#434 Geepers
Salafis/Wahhabis are ultraconservative.

I'm beginning to be more perturbed by the inference...

474 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:00:22am

432 buzzsawmonkey

If we are to get back to "We, the people of the United States" we have to take care of business ourselves. Our elected officials--and our media--have to be constantly reminded of who they are serving--or claiming to serve. We have to take the energy generated here and direct it at the people we have placed in power to serve us.

I agree completely.

475 WriterMom  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:01:34am

#472 Murq

No consolation to those whose loved ones were murdered, but thank goodness the murderer was killed before he could kill even more people. And I know "Just My View" denies it, but it sounds so much like View From Ireland it is freaky.

476 Sprite  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:02:24am

#378 mglazer

From your link to debbieschlussel.com/the Salt Lake Tribune piece:

Salt Lake City police spokeswoman Robin Snyder said Wednesday that police have not discerned a motive or found anything resembling a suicide note. With the permission of Talovic's parents, detectives searched their home but did not take any computers or video games, she said.

I have written to Detective Snyder to ask if this is true and if so, why not. If I get an answer I'll let you know. And if there were no computers or games, why did she not say so?

The Trib article also indicated:

Although he quit school at 16, Sulejman Talovic often attended Friday prayers at the Al-Noor mosque on 700 East in Salt Lake City, said Salih Omerovic, Ajka's cousin.
Salih Omerovic said the young man stopped coming to the prayers in December, when he landed a full-time job at Aramark Uniform Services in South Salt Lake. He said Sulejman Talovic's father had pressured his son to get a job to help out with the family's living expenses.

Link

477 J.D.  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:02:25am

Is this better, worse, or about the same as "ultraconservative"?
Deseret News gets a taste of the right-wing hate machine

478 WriterMom  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:03:03am

What are the linguistic odds of two people with CREEPILY SIMILAR "VIEWS" choosing two supposedly completely separate nics for two supposedly completely separate people that have the word "VIEW" in them?

480 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:06:52am

J.D. (#391),

So according to Encyclopedia Brittanica, the Taliban is ultraconservative...

J.D. (#473),

Salafis/Wahhabis are ultraconservative.

Damn.

Well we all know the right-wingers are way worse than them.

The next article by Elaine Jarvik and Deborah Bulkeley will probably just label us Nazis and be done with it.

481 Sgt.Slappy  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:08:17am
#459 jingoisticirredentist 2/15/2007 12:46PM PST

Can anyone analize the recording and tell if thats what is really being said?

Analize the recording? LOL! ...cue porno music soundtrack!

I think you mean analyze.

482 Carolyn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:08:41am

Sharmuta and all,
Isn't it hilarious how the left claims the USA is not a Christian nation, but when something happens, it is assumed the perp is a Christian? Heh heh®

483 Murqtaad  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:08:52am

WriterMom,

The view is obviously obstructed. And self admittedly a headline reader. Sums it up. She's a deep thinker. Those headlines are never biased and break down a 1,000 word article/story in 6 or 7 words.

484 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:10:12am

#478 WriterMom

If Charles gets curious enough, he can trace the IP (if we know for a fact that VFI was in fact in Ireland). I don't think that troll is worth the effort. Trolls are for spanking.

485 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:12:13am

#479 J.D.

You're on a roll......

486 Carolyn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:15:19am

#471 Dar ul Harb
It is posted at JW, but without links.

487 Dar ul Harb  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:15:23am

One hopes that, if this incident was Sudden Jihadi Syndrome, that fact won't be suppressed, at whatever level...

(Analyzing the audio will be one thing that helps make sure that doesn't happen.)

488 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:16:17am

J.D. (#477),

From your first link:

Kudos to the D-News for turning over this rock and reporting on the crap they found under it.

Um, they didn't turn over anything and they surly didn't report on what they "found".

I doubt very seriously if they even stopped by for more time than to check to see if it was an actual post here.

Charles, do you have any hits for LGF from Deseret News before they printed this "story"

489 biff  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:19:13am

#476 Sprite 2/15/2007 01:02PM PST
#378 mglazer

Because the FBI has his computers! You have to read between the lines:

detectives searched their home but did not take any computers or video games, she said.
...
And if there were no computers or games, why did she not say so?

490 Carolyn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:28:53am
491 Highrise  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:29:36am

311 Charles 2/15/2007 10:38AM PST

Pawn: I'm going to back you up on one point. I am also getting very irritated by the "round 'em all up and put 'em in camps or deport 'em" talk.

Face facts. This is never going to happen, and the only thing you achieve by calling for it over and over is to make yourself -- and LGF by association -- look like ranting extremists.

I try to keep discussions as open as possible, but I'm thinking seriously of simply deleting any such comments that I see from now on.

Charles,

Do what you need to do. In the end it's your rep and your blog. I would think from the people who participate here, they would support you too.

I don't know much about software at all, but I'm wondering if there is a way to put a script in that allows the user to ignore certain users. I know sometimes it is too much work to maintain special scripts so thought I'd just toss it out there.

492 ovoid  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:29:44am
"There is no record that Talovic attended any of the mosques in the Salt Lake area, according to both Tarek Mosseir, a spokesman for the Islamic Society of Greater Salt Lake, or Bobby Ravish of Muslim Forum. Mosseir noted that many Bosnian Muslims are more secular than religious."

What is being implied here by the paper and the Muslim spokesmen is that someone who had attended an area mosque would be more likely to be motivated to kill for jihad than an area Muslim who hadn't. What's wrong with this picture?

493 biff  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:30:17am

Chicago mall jihadist: "the time for jihad is now"

How can the MSM be suppressing logical thought on such a massive scale?

494 J.D.  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:31:05am

#485 E2m
Done!

#488 Geepers
Amazin', ain't it?

495 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:37:20am

2007 Season for Nonviolence

Jan 27, 2007

by Elaine Jarvik

A lifetime of nonviolence would be preferable. But for now the idea is to at least have a short season each year -- 64 days in which we can think about, as Charlene Telford-Tims says, "how powerful nonviolence can be as a solution."

The 2007 Gandhi King Season for Nonviolence officially begins Tuesday with a multifaith event at the Center for Spiritual Living in Midvale. It ends April 4. In between there will be workshops, a youth songwriting contest and a "connections path walk" between downtown places of worship.

Isn't that special?

Gosh Elaine, no condemnation for Sulejmen fucking up your pretty little Season for Nonviolence?

Or is that why you're trying to bury it as "oppressed victim" story?

496 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:38:38am

And while moonbat defends the MSM's selective reporting of the facts as simple discression, said moonbat also defends the NYT publishing classified info because of the public's "right to know". Which is it? Doe the public have a right to know, or don't we?

497 Sprite  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:38:51am

#489 biff,

Makes sense to me ;). Shhh. It's a secret. I guess I got stuck in that 'po side of town' , disaffected loner, victim refugee stuff. Heh.

498 wanumba  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:39:42am

JustMyView is often "right" in the excruciatingly narrow band in which she operates to fog up the thread. To spot a person's religion in a headline is undoubtably rare - but not from fairness, rather that Christian as a word takes up too much headline space, and it's really even too overt. It's the article that adds the essentials: Senator X, blah blah fundamentalist positions, blah blah CHristian blah blah , rigid blah blah, unyielding blah blah blah convictions blah blah harsh blah blah divisive blah blah alienate blah blah.
This JMV comment is rich, too

Christians are not storming into shopping malls and shooting up strangers.
Of course, they are.


Of course, they are? As if it was tea time? What a breezy tone to lay guilt for murder! Christians do not shoot up malls. Sorry-O. You know them by their fruits. Shooting up the mall violates all the commandments. If one carries out premeditated murder,then how can they possibily be genuine practitioners of a religion that condemns murder? Answer, they can't be. Simple. You can call yourself a turnip, but that doesn't make it the truth.
I could call JMV a few lurid names, too, but a shill is correct. It is always curious to note which subjects are deemed necessary to be spun.

499 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:40:54am

#495 Geepers

The implication being that for the other 301 days out of the year, it's ok to kick the crap out of your neighbor? This stuff is just so freeking sappy!

500 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:41:16am

500

501 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:41:52am

Sorry, devil made me do it.

502 JustMyView  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:43:30am

#275 E2m

Please 'splain to me why the Duke lacrosse case was all over the media for the better part of a year, and then this case is limited to the blogosphere. If you limited your scope to the MSM, you's never know that a second Duke rape case happened. Suppose the fact that the rapist is black and the victim is white might have something to do with that?


I absolutely agree that it was the white perp/black victim issue that made the Duke case so intriguing to the cable news networks.

I disagree, however, that one would never have heard about the Utah shootings w/o reading LGF, another blog, or even an online source. It was, quite obviously, in the Utah papers, and it also appeared on at least two network news shows last night and it was in the NY Times and the WaPo.

I'd say that's a fair amount of coverage. If the story sinks faster than the Duke story, it'll be at least partly because there's no one around to prosecute.

503 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:47:39am

#502 JustMyView

The question had nothing to do with the Utah shooting. The question had to do with the rape that the MSM didn't report. You completely ignored that.

Sorry, you're not that slick.

504 wanumba  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:51:24am

It's going to be inconclusive to discern the vaguer parts of the audio from the video download. But, the FBI has that magnificent crime lab plus start of the art audio. They certainly will have the original video to work with. The problem is, the FBI seems to have some internal pressures that makes it so the public is not as sure as they'd like to be that the FBI can be trusted with such material. We can hope, though. All we want is a fair and thorough investigation. Just be straight.

505 Tasty Beverage  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:51:48am

#492 ovoid

What is being implied here by the paper and the Muslim spokesmen is that someone who had attended an area mosque would be more likely to be motivated to kill for jihad than an area Muslim who hadn't. What's wrong with this picture?

Actually what the spokesliar is doing is trying to imply that Talovic was not religious, and hence islam could not be a motivation for what he did. Saying there's "no record" is a weaselly way to assert/lie that he was not religious. Of course there won't be a "record" of his going to any mosque unless they require attendees to sign in/swipe a membership card at the door.

However, if you read the article linked at #476 you'll see that his cousin claims Talovic "often attended" mosque until December 2006.

506 Murqtaad  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:56:30am

JMV,

Wanna provide that link to the Christians shootin' up the mall down the street from your house? We've been askin' for a few hours. You've had plenty of time to find it.

507 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 11:57:11am

Earth2moonbat (#499),

I just really don't (can't?) understand people like Elaine Jarvik who have so little compassion for the murdered and work so hard to excuse the murderer.

Yet, she can condemn LGF and all of us out of hand, right out of the gate? A strange inconsistency there.

508 Sam I Am  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:01:13pm

Wow.

JMV finally showed up, but still hasn't answered the question(s) that TalkinKamel and Earth2moonbat etal asked.

509 wanumba  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:02:15pm
#502 JustMyView
I'd say that's a fair amount of coverage. If the story sinks faster than the Duke story, it'll be at least partly because there's no one around to prosecute

.
What's the legal age in Utah to purchase firearms and ammunition? Is it 18?
If it is legal in the state, if a man of 18 has at least 4 arrests for offenses, what are his chances for purchasing the weapons he had in his possession?
Inquiring minds may discover that there's is someone around to prosecute after all. Licensed, law-abiding gun dealers doesn't come to mind, not with all the twitchy prosecutors out there just waiting for them to screw up. On the other hand ...criminal elements, straw purchasers, enablers, conspirators ...

510 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:02:59pm

#504 wanumba

I don't know that that's going to matter. The cops know what they heard, and I'm sure that went in the report, before the PC enforcers got to them. I don't think they can just scrub a police report like that. that's evidence tampering. It's going to come out. We don't need the tape. But it may take a FOIA request to get them to come clean.

511 JustMyView  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:04:18pm

#394 Geepers

Fuck you for even attempting to conflate the two.

You are out of line.

All we know about this situation so far is that an 18-year-old guy, who happens to be a Muslim, went into a shopping mall and shot a bunch of people for reasons that only he understands. Horrible.

In the Amish incident, a somewhat older guy walked into a school and shot several young children for reasons only he understood.

How are these incidents so terribly different?

512 Murqtaad  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:04:20pm

Geeps,

I think it's cause we fuck Elaine Jarvik's utopian ideology up with a heavy dose of the truth.

It aint the victims fault, and the perp deserves no sympathy and no time trying to be understood.

513 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:04:33pm

#509 wanumba

/Speculation mode on.

He stole the freeking firearms.

/Speculation mode off.

514 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:07:06pm
Inside the mall, chaos erupted.

"I saw a guy run in the hallway in front of our store, and he stopped, kind of ran back. People were yelling and screaming, and I heard glass break," said Marie Smith, who is a clerk at Bath and Body Works on the first level.

Shaking, she described watching a girl die in front of her.

"He turned and there was a girl standing in front of our store. He shot her. I saw him shoot her," she said, her voice trembling. "She's dead."

And JustMyView won't condemn this man.
She's even more despicable than I had first thought.

Quinn, whose maiden name is Antrobus, moved to Utah in 2002 to work at the Olympics.

Her family hopes people will remember how special she was.

"I always said I had four spots in my heart, one for each daughter," Ken Antrobus, Quinn's father said. "I didn't want to play favorites and had one spot for my wife. Now, one spot has been ripped out of my chest and it hurts so badly. I hope no parent ever has to go through this again."

Rest in peace Vanessa Quinn.

515 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:07:20pm

#511 JustMyView

How are these incidents so terribly different?


Because one's part of a pattern, and the other isn't?

516 raven1  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:12:17pm

just my view
As a long time reader of LGF, I must say, any time I see your nic, I know it is going to be some really dumb shit you are posting. You are consistent.

517 wanumba  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:13:49pm

#513 E2Mb
Could be the case. That's what a proper investigation is supposed to discover. If he had previous run-ins with the law, then he was not a "good boy," unlike the rumored assertations of the alleged family.

Saying he did it for jihad is not more reliable than saying he didn't do it for jihad with the information we have available. However, slapping people down simply for noticing the warning signs is just suspicious.

518 jimash  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:14:20pm

One's part of a pattern and the other isn't.
No question mark needed.

Geepers brings home another point.
Even though we know all kinds of details about NAtalie, Lacey , and Anna, the victims in this case as in Seattle ancd the SUV case and the El AL shooting seem to be below notice.

519 Murqtaad  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:15:12pm

Asshat,

All we know about this situation so far is that an 18-year-old guy, who happens to be a Muslim, went into a shopping mall and shot a bunch of people for reasons that only he understands. Horrible.

In the Amish incident, a somewhat older guy walked into a school and shot several young children for reasons only he understood.

How are these incidents so terribly different?

One did it for jihad, the other was mentally ill and liked to rape little girls. The guy who shot up the mall didn't happen to be a muslim, that was the whole friggin reason why he did it. Now, where are the links to the christian ghuy shootng up your local mall?

520 raven1  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:16:08pm

just my view
I suspect your view is up your ass.

521 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:16:34pm
522 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:17:27pm

JustMyView (#511),

You are out of line.

Am I?

Trying to change the subject isn't going to work with me. Sorry.

Your pitiful attempts at moral equivalency just illustrate your true nature.

Why are you are so unwilling to ever condemn a muslim for their actions?

523 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:17:41pm

518 jimash

Geepers brings home another point.
Even though we know all kinds of details about NAtalie, Lacey , and Anna, the victims in this case as in Seattle ancd the SUV case and the El AL shooting seem to be below notice.

Most victims of jihad are. How about those kidnapped Israeli soldiers?

524 jimash  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:19:12pm

3 more people that it might be "upsetting" to spend a minute on for Wolf Blitzer.

525 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:19:16pm

#517 wanumba

Right. 4 arrests in 2 years means either he's a really "bad" boy, or a really stupid boy, or some combination therof. But it pretty much rules "good boy" out.

526 wanumba  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:21:45pm

#510 E2Mb
That's a good reminder. Trained officers of the law were the ones who cornered him - just them and him. They are trained to pay attention to these things - untrained people often can't recall what was said - it was over pretty quick - and there were multiple officers backing each other up. They will provide a strong confirmation of anything that is pulled from the tape audio.

One only wishes that the police at Columbine had been so pro-active, instead of locking down the killers inside with the victims. I have heard that there have been changes in police procedure to avoid that sort of thing. If this is the proof, it's encouraging.

527 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:22:28pm
528 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:24:24pm
529 Q-Burn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:24:39pm

Well, everything is obvious to me. This is an MSM (MormonS & Muslims) conspiracy. There are only two weird religions that start with "M" and have millions of followers in the U.S. And the Deseret News is the only daily newspaper in America owned by the Mormon church.

I rest my case.

530 JustMyView  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:25:22pm

#376 E2m

You're either being dishonest or stupid. Which one is it?

Neither. I was being sarcastic. Like Pawn and snowtravel and perhaps others whose posts I skipped over, I think the speculation about this killer's motivation is wwaaaaaaay out in front of the available facts.

People do horrible things for lots of different reasons. Sometimes it's religious/political zealotry; sometimes it's mental illness; sometimes it's money.

The idea that the reporters who wrote the first stories about this incident hid or suppressed information about his religion simply doesn't wash. Absent evidence of relevance, it's irrelevant. If it becomes relevant, it should be reported and, obviously, it has been.

531 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:27:02pm

Murqtaad (#512),

It aint the victims fault, and the perp deserves no sympathy and no time trying to be understood.

Absolutely.

The Elaine Jarvik's will tell you just how wrong violence is, then turn around and make every possible excuse for this POS murdering people.

Then like you said, get mad at, not the people who run around making their "grievances" felt by killing people, but us for pointing that out.

How's that go? Ignorance is bliss.

Elaine must be one happy camper.

Want to guess how many of the victims funeral's she'll cover?

Or if she does, that the whole story will be about how evil we all are for being so intolerant?

532 wanumba  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:28:16pm

Just out of curiosity. One or two posters have said that they've been inside that mall - and described it well. Anyone know if there is a military recruitment office in there?
:I

533 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:28:27pm

#530 JustMyView

Do you believe in the MSM meme of "the public's right to know" when it applies to classified war plans? Ok, now how about as it applies to mass murders?

534 raven1  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:29:34pm

#530-jmv
I suppose it was irrelevant when the jets crashed into the WTC that ROP'ers were doing the piloting?

535 Daisy  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:30:04pm

Anyone else recall this guy - or this incident?

October, 2001, Croatian Man Who Slashed Bus Driver's Throat Was Muslim/Croat Army Veteran


"... After attacking the driver (my note .. with a box cutter) , Igric crashed the bus killing himself and five other passengers."

He also was not a terrorist. And there was a just about complete news black out concerning this horrific event.

[Link: www.usvetdsp.com...]

536 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:31:32pm

#531 Geepers

One of these days Elaine may very well get mugged and raped. Then her thinking may change. But she may still not get it; she may very well blame it on the patriarchy.

That's the funny thing about the delusionally ideological. They can always expand their fantasy to explain all observables.

537 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:33:21pm

530 JustMyView

Absent evidence of relevance, it's irrelevant.

And who decides what information is relevant or irrelevant? The facts are the facts, and should be reported as such.

538 SlothB77  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:33:28pm

justmyview has made this thread very entertaining.

i suggest you watch the movie ARLINGTON ROAD, with Jeff Bridges.

that movie was made in response to the Oklahoma City bombings and singles out small government conservatives as terrorists. Surprisingly, the same Hollywood has yet to make a movie about muslims in the same light. (aside from 24, with guys like joel surnow.)

Arlington Road

539 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:34:18pm

#534 raven1

Come to think of it, the MSM wasn't too comfortable about using the "m" word on 9/11, either. I seem to recall them rattling off Arabic names, and not saying diddly about what religion they were, and even speculating crackpot theories about it being a navagational computer failure.

540 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:35:34pm
541 jimash  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:35:49pm

I've seen Arlington Road and it's chilling.
But I didn't get that they were small gov. conservatives.
I thought theyy were left over Red Brigade Faction, SDS,
anarchist type radicals.
or maybe commies.

542 Murqtaad  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:36:12pm

JustMyView,

Link to Christian rampage at your mall?

/34th request

543 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:38:27pm
544 JustMyView  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:39:22pm

#292 Geepers

JustMyView comes here to change the subject.

She'll never talk about this MURDERER or the article pertaining to it.

But steer you into some crap argument about reporting standards or the history of Halloween.

No, not to change the subject. I do like a good argument, though, and LGF almost always provides one. I rarely stop in w/o finding people making assertions that are demonstrably incorrect or based on, shall we say, limited evidence---the flap over the religion of the killer in the Utah shooting being a prime example.

Certainly, Muslims commit crimes, as do people of pretty much every other demographic group--different religions, races, ethnicities, whatever. What's important is to know whether the crimes Muslims (or the members of any other religious group) commit are a function of their religion, whether Muslims (or the members of other religious groups commit particular kinds of crimes, and crime rates are linked to being a Muslim (or a member of any other religious group).

We certainly know that acts of political terrorism are linked to Islam, but, in this country,we haven't seen any evidence that Muslims are planning small-scale assaults on civilian targets of the sort that occurred in Utah. We do, however, know that people of all races and religion are susceptible mental illness and that people who are socially marginalized, frustrated, and unable to solve their problems in other ways sometimes turn to violence.

Absent other evidence, I'd say that tossing fuel on the anti-Muslim fire is unwarranted. That's way I stick around. Because I think that, every now and then, somebody should point out how little evidence there is for some of the wild-ass claims that are made here.

545 funky chicken  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:39:24pm

322 Michael Levy Excellent comment, thanks.

546 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:40:10pm
547 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:40:31pm

JustMyView (#530),

Just how many times are you going to just skip over what you said in #383

Christians are not storming into shopping malls and shooting up strangers.


Of course, they are. It happened just a few months ago in a shopping mall not too far from where I live.

You said it unequivocally, back it up.

548 raven1  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:40:42pm

E2M
Unfortunately, the MSM is in bed with the jihadis.

549 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:41:32pm

#543 taxfreekiller

JMV goes where Cognito's too smart to tread......

550 raven1  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:43:06pm

#544-jmv
OK, If you say so. Muslims are not killing people all over the world.

551 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:44:29pm
552 funky chicken  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:45:31pm

Damn. I wish I'd had the type of family that would have told me I was a "good" kid if I only had two misdemeanor convictions a year, or as in this case, 4 misdemeanor convictions in the 2 years I had lived somewhere.

Well, maybe not. My family held me accountable for my actions.

Just My View is completely delusional and probably is "View from Ireland" from way back. JMV, the MSM STILL doesn't report on suspect's race if the suspect is black. Do you remember the DC snipers? They were angry white men in a work van until the very end. Whoops!

553 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:45:36pm

530 JustMyView

Absent evidence of relevance, it's irrelevant.

Information is knowledge, knowledge is power.

When public information is deemed irrelevant, the knowledge imparted is incomplete, and power is nonexistent.

It is the dumbing down of the American public. Too bad for the msm the American public isn't taking it lying down.

554 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:46:36pm

#551 taxfreekiller

Adjusted View

That should win some sort of award for insight.

555 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:46:43pm

JustMyView (#544),

I rarely stop in w/o finding people making assertions that are demonstrably incorrect or based on, shall we say, limited evidence

Oh that's rich.

Christian mall killer in the last couple of months link please. For like the twentieth time.

And don't think I don't continue to notice your complete lack of compassion for those murdered in Utah. Or you inability to condemn the man who murdered them.

556 funky chicken  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:48:38pm

535 Daisy Yep. I've got a nice list of other SJS cases too. One was a guy in a VA nursing home. One a guy who went and shot a Jew in a movie theater in Baltimore. One who tried to bring his shotgun in to the airport in New Orleans (duh). The El Al counter. A guy in Denver who shot folks at his work for "disprespecting" islam. just off the top of my head you know.

557 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:49:39pm

544 JustMyView

Certainly, Muslims commit crimes, as do people of pretty much every other demographic group--different religions, races, ethnicities, whatever. What's important is to know whether the crimes Muslims (or the members of any other religious group) commit are a function of their religion, whether Muslims (or the members of other religious groups commit particular kinds of crimes, and crime rates are linked to being a Muslim (or a member of any other religious group).

It's hard to know what religion when the newspaper won't tell you.

And that's the point.

558 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:50:23pm
559 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:50:54pm

#552 funky chicken

Another more esoteric example; the fight at Guilford college is being depected in the media as a bunch of white football players commiting a hate crime against 3 innocent Palestinian exchange students (who btw, started the fight). The only problem is that 2 of the football players are as black as charcoal. They never mentioned that.

560 Murqtaad  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:52:23pm

JMV,

You win the award for "Most Intellectually Dishonest Poster". Congrats.

And this gem....

we haven't seen any evidence that Muslims are planning small-scale assaults on civilian targets

....is the cherry on top. Seas of David (Miami freak terror group), Seattle, LAX, Chicago mall, Portland 7, North Va Paintball "club".

Now, can we have the god damned link to this Christian who shot up the mall?

561 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:52:31pm

#555 Geepers

And don't think I don't continue to notice your complete lack of compassion for those murdered in Utah. Or you inability to condemn the man who murdered them.

I'm noticing that, too. I think this is someone who agrees with killing kufr.

562 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:55:14pm

560 Murqtaad

Now, can we have the god damned link to this Christian who shot up the mall?

The link must have been deemed irrelevant.

563 JustMyView  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:56:25pm

#542 Murqtaad

Link to Christian rampage at your mall?

/34th request

Sorry to make you wait. Sometimes, I have to do other things.

I was mistaken. It was a stabbing, not a shooting.

Antoinette C. Starks left the Maryland Correctional Institution for Women in Jessup about 2:30 Tuesday afternoon after serving 16 months for malicious destruction of property.

The next night -- less than 28 hours after being freed -- she was back in police custody after more than 25 witnesses told investigators that Starks, wielding four large butcher knives, chased several women at a Nordstrom store in a Montgomery County shopping center, stabbing two of them, police said.

Seems like there was also something about a shooting in or near a Baltimore mall, but I couldn't find the right link. Maybe Cattt knows. While looking, I came across a story about a grandfather in Phoenix who shot his two female grandchildren and one of their friends. Wonder if he was a Muslim too.

564 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:56:28pm
565 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:57:41pm
566 Murqtaad  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:58:02pm

Sharmuta,

Apparently. Either that or JMV is fulla shit and obfuscating every chance she gets. Typical left wing debate tactics.

567 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 12:59:52pm

#563 JustMyView

The word "Christian" does not appear anywhere in that article. And yes, I checked all three pages.

568 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:00:43pm
569 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:01:37pm

563 JustMyView

Looks like Antoinette C. Starks was an anti-semite, but nowhere in the story do I see a confirmation that this woman was a Christian. Are you assuming, because she has a european name, that this woman is Christian?

570 Murqtaad  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:01:43pm

JMV,

Sorry to make you wait. Sometimes, I have to do other things.

Yeah, whats 5 hours? Who's counting?

Um, Not a mention of her being a Christian. Nice try.

Somebody stabbed someone somewhere, so we can't judge a jihadist. What utter crap-think. Yer a fool, and we are all collectively dumber for conversing with you.

I'm done. This thing is worthless.

571 J.D.  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:02:18pm
572 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:04:04pm

Earth2moonbat (#561),

I think this is someone who agrees with killing kufr.

Yeah. It would certainly explain a lot wouldn't it?

Wanna bet she don't deny it?

573 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:06:58pm

#572 Geepers

Wanna bet she don't deny it?

That does seem to be their weakness. They can obfuscate, they can feign indignation, they flip out and start calling names, but they can't seem to criticize jihad.

574 funky chicken  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:08:39pm

559 E2M That story is really, really funny actually. I think the palis thought the Duke rape case had softened up the NC populace so they were ready to rage for the poor palis.

The tendency for these folks to overreach and terribly misjudge the public mood here may save us all.

575 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:08:55pm

I guess Antoinette C. Starks religion was deemed irrelevant.

The evidence of relevance was absent.

576 Carolyn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:10:26pm

A person is not a Christian by default. It takes a statement of faith -"You must be born again" and living your life as a Christian.
/"God ain't got no grandkids"

577 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:13:43pm

#574 funky chicken

In some ways it's funny, and in some ways it isn't. The way the MSM and certain college officials have handled it is deplorable. However, 2 of the Palis are now at risk of deportation. When that finally happens, I'll agree that it's funny.

578 DANEgerus  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:14:50pm

Have they complained that everyone labels Mitt Romney "that Mormon"?

579 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:19:27pm

JustMyViw (#563),

Um, your memory seems to be more than a little bit faulty:

Christians are not storming into shopping malls and shooting up strangers.

Of course, they are. It happened just a few months ago in a shopping mall not too far from where I live.

From your link:

Friday, May 27, 2005;

So other than the fact that; she wasn't Christian, didn't shoot anyone, it happened two years ago and no one was killed, you were exactly right.

And I should ever take you at your word again, why?

580 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:20:27pm

J.D. (#571),

Link Goddess.

Well, no mention of him being Christian, and that was two years ago too.

581 Murqtaad  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:21:22pm

Geeps 579,

ZING!

582 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:23:48pm

Muqtaard (#560),

You win the award for "Most Intellectually Dishonest Poster". Congrats.

I'll second that.

583 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:25:51pm

579 Geepers

So other than the fact that; she wasn't Christian, didn't shoot anyone, it happened two years ago and no one was killed, you were exactly right.

Can't JustMyView say the evidence of relevance is absent or something?

(It ain't easy getting your ass fact checked.)

584 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:26:03pm

JMV illustrates the difference between articulate and intelligent.

585 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:28:48pm

#583 Sharmuta

Or evidence of relevence is relevence of evidence, or absense of relivence is relevent if if you're absent, or absence of mind is relevent if you're a troll, or something like that......

586 JustMyView  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:32:15pm

#569 Sharmuta

Looks like Antoinette C. Starks was an anti-semite, but nowhere in the story do I see a confirmation that this woman was a Christian. Are you assuming, because she has a european name, that this woman is Christian?

Ms. Starks is African American. Operating purely on the basis of statistical probabilities, I'm going w/ the idea that she was at some point in what appears to be a pretty sad life, connected w/ people who were, however loosely, Christian.

Note that this photo comes from a blog written by someone whose views many here will find appealing. I don't think either her race or her religiion were mentioned in the news story. Because she was already in custody, information about her race wasn't needed to inform readers about the suspect, and info about her religion didn't seem to be relevant to the crime.

It's true that Ms. Starks didn't kill anyone, but that appears to have been a happy accident. The people she stabbed were certainly injured.

587 Carolyn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:36:41pm
statistical probabilities

Ommm, profiling.

588 J.D.  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:38:53pm

#580 Geepers
I don't believe there was a Christian rampage at a mall in the Baltimore Area.
But it sounded "good" to JMV when he/she said it, I'm quite sure. Maybe I'm wrong...

If you go back a little further, there were the Beltway Snipers.

589 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:41:06pm

586 JustMyView

I'm going w/ the idea that she was at some point in what appears to be a pretty sad life, connected w/ people who were, however loosely, Christian.

That's a pretty bold jump- she was at some point, however loosely, connected to Christians so I'll call her a Christian to defend a muslim.

How do you know the religion of this woman? She could be a Christian, atheist, or even a muslim. But I guess the newspaper you linked to didn't feel that information was relevant. It's too bad they did- it's made you look like a fool.

590 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:41:22pm

This has gotten to the point of ridiculousness.

591 m  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:41:34pm

JMView From Ireland

While looking, I came across a story about a grandfather in Phoenix who shot his two female grandchildren and one of their friends. Wonder if he was a Muslim too.

Did he do it because they were caught talking to a non-muslim male? Or did they show some ankle or something? If so- prolly.

/come on- you guys are the ones that always want to know WHY they did it.

592 Highrise  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:43:17pm

516 raven1 2/15/2007 02:12PM PST

just my view
As a long time reader of LGF, I must say, any time I see your nic, I know it is going to be some really dumb shit you are posting. You are consistent.

jmv just got added to the list of *scroll by's*.

It's one thing to have a different view, it's another to act trollish in nature.

Back up your stuff or don't bog the blog down.

593 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:46:38pm

Let's use JMV's logic: Since muslims believe that all people are born muslim, then absent any information to the contrary, the default assumption should be that anyone mentioned in the press is muslim. Makes about as much sense as presuming Christianity until proven otherwise.

594 JustMyView  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:47:52pm

#390 Dwalla

The difference here is this.... religion is the motive for slaying when it comes to the jihadis. They feel it is their religious obligation to carry out such acts of violence against the innocent. The other cases you are referring too are primarily random acts of violence.

Yes, either random or motivated by something other than political ideology or religious conviction.

But the point is that Muslims also commit crimes for reasons that have nothing to do with religious obligations to terrorize the innocent. I guess I'd prefer to start w/ the assumption that Muslims are prey to the ordinary range of human weakness--mental illness, jealousy, greed, rage--than to start w/ the assumption that all negative acts committed by Muslims are a form of terrorism. I understand, of course, that the Utah incident may have been an act of terrorism. I just don't think we know that yet, and, like I said, I prefer to start my information processing from a different place.

595 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:49:44pm

593 Earth2moonbat

Let's use JMV's logic: Since muslims believe that all people are born muslim, then absent any information to the contrary, the default assumption should be that anyone mentioned in the press is muslim.

Unless the evidence of relevance is absent- then we just won't say at all.

596 funky chicken  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:50:02pm

Bwaaahaaa

Nope, never heard of a black muslim nope, not here.

Especially one who converted in prison, but kept their anglo sounding name.

/Richard Reid?

good heavens, they just don't get much dumber than JMV, eh?

597 Daisy  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:50:08pm

#556 funky,

Thanks for the reminders. I don't ever want to forget. The headline I printed was not from the MSM .. it was from a US vet's site. I've not found one MSM article stating the truth of the matter. Not one .. and this was a murderer who used a box cutter on the bus driver's neck in early October of 2001 .. and murdered 5 others (and himself) as well.

The NY Times made the murderer, Damir Igric, out to be some kind of Croatian war hero. No surprise there .. only for those who think it's worth paying $ to read the NY Times vomit: [Link: select.nytimes.com...] res=F30A11FD3C580C768CDDA90994D9404482&n=Top%2 fReference%2fTimes%20Topics%2fSubjects%2fA%2fAccid ents%20and%20Safety

598 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:51:14pm

Earth2moonbat (#590),

This has gotten to the point of ridiculousness.

Agreed.

And she's a bald faced liar.

And apparently has no problem whatsoever with kufr's being murdered.

I'm getting the distinct feeling this one believes in a book that says:

Muslims are harsh against the unbelievers, merciful to one another. - 48:25

599 Q-Burn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:51:54pm

I'm old enough to remember Charles Whitman. He was a Christian and an Eagle Scout. Nobody but him was blamed when he went on his murderous spree. But that was over 40 years ago. Times have changed.

600 Odinist  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:52:02pm

586 JustMyView

I'm going w/ the idea that she was at some point in what appears to be a pretty sad life, connected w/ people who were, however loosely, Christian.

That's got to be the worst argument I've ever heard. If that's all it takes to be a Christian, I guess that would make me Christian too, eh?

/please

601 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:52:04pm

594 JustMyView

I prefer to start my information processing from a different place.

We've noticed.

602 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:53:09pm

594 JustMyView

But the point is that Muslims also commit crimes for reasons that have nothing to do with religious obligations to terrorize the innocent.

Not anywhere near as much as the do here. That was on of the few good things about Saudi. You could leave your keys in the ignition of an unlocked car, and fnd it still sitting there the next day. Something about the threat of cutting your hand off does tend to cut down on petty crime. So no, as a general rule, if they're going to do something attrocious, they're going to do something holy and attrocious.

603 wanumba  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:53:56pm
JustMyView (#544),
I rarely stop in w/o finding people making assertions that are demonstrably incorrect or based on, shall we say, limited evidence
#586 JustMyView
Operating purely on the basis of statistical probabilities, I'm going w/ the idea that she was at some point in what appears to be a pretty sad life, connected w/ people who were, however loosely, Christian.

Condemned with her own words.

604 jrdroll  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:56:57pm

#594 jmv

But the point is that Muslims also commit crimes for reasons that have nothing to do with religious obligations to terrorize the innocent.

Cite one?

605 Killgore Trout  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:58:27pm

I was wondering where everyone was today. What's going on down here?

606 Daisy  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 1:59:48pm

I'm pretty sure I've read Just My Views posts in that rag, The Guardian. Given the style etc. there's a strong likelihood it's the same JMV - in which case, JMV's a disgruntled Pakistani Muslim who is equally angry at the general indigenous population of Great Briton (and the rest of the free world) as he is w/LGF.

For me "JMV" is a signal to "skip the post and move on to whichever one has nothing to do with his post". Of course, I learned the hard way - I tried to reason w/JMV. Good grief, but it's just not worth the effort.

607 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:00:29pm

#605 Killgore Trout

Just a good, old-fashioned butt kicking.

608 funky chicken  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:00:53pm

577 E2M The behavior of college administrators has me seriously reconsidering the value of a college education for my smart, athletic, white children. Why the hell would I spend huge amounts of money to put my kids at risk of railroading by their own college admin?

Bill Bennett is getting ready to launch a home school college program. I used his elementary curriculum (www.k12.com) and was extrememly impressed. The only reason I'm not still homeschooling is that the kids and I couldn't work together.....I'm not cut out to be an elementary school teacher full time. But the K12 curriculum is outstanding. The couple of months I taught them at home (before returning them to private school lest we come to blows) still pay off for them a couple of years later, especially in grammar.

My kids may just work part time and do their college at home with Dr. Bennett.

I wonder how many other parents are thinking the same thing?

609 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:02:20pm

605 Killgore Trout

I was wondering where everyone was today. What's going on down here?

JustMyView would tell you "absent the evidence of relevance, it's irrelevant" what we are doing down here.

610 funky chicken  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:02:57pm

604 jrdoll honor killings? You know, the motivation is to restore the family's honor, not terrorize the innocent.

611 reader  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:05:03pm

From Michael Savage's show tonight:

Savage reports of an email he was just from someone in Salt Lake City who has a relative who is a substitute teacher in the high school that this Muslim killer attended, Horizonte High School. This teacher witnessed this guy regularly researching weapons online, through the school's computers, where students are given password accounts for access. He writes that this teacher called the FBI to report this and was told by the FBI that they are "not interested" in pursuing this. Savage can't confirm the the truth of this email, except to say that it is "news".

612 Highrise  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:06:08pm

606 Daisy 2/15/2007 03:59PM PST


I'm pretty sure I've read Just My Views posts in that rag, The Guardian. Given the style etc. there's a strong likelihood it's the same JMV - in which case, JMV's a disgruntled Pakistani Muslim who is equally angry at the general indigenous population of Great Briton (and the rest of the free world) as he is w/LGF.

Interesting.

I think it's good some people (who are better than I at calling someone to the carpet when their argument is factless and moronic) are challenging justmyview. I just get bored easy with these types.

613 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:06:31pm

Killgore Trout (#605),

Well for the last few hours we've been trying to get JustMyView to say killing kufr's isn't OK.

Hasn't happened yet.

It's getting kind of humerus at this point.

Sort of akin to asking Nihad Awad if hezballah is a terrorist organization.

614 wanumba  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:06:40pm
#608 funkychicken
I wonder how many other parents are thinking the same thing?


Sigh. Every day. WHen I'm not thinking how to get the "defund the state universities" drive going.

615 tokyobk  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:09:20pm

The fact that they led with this Bosnian victim story is proof that it is relavent.

A-holes, liars and slanderers.

616 Highrise  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:10:32pm

611 reader

It really irks me that they are closing their options out so fast. Savage's report isn't the only one..the MSM is reporting that his muslim background has nothing to do with this either. That is just flat too. Yet all the reports state they don't have *any idea* why this guy went off his rocker.

When islam is being touted as this religion of peace, it cuts off people who don't know better or have the time to follow through that the koran teaches death and that uhh..just *may* have some influence or lay some foundation? Doesn't necessarily have to be an out and out Jihadi form. This to me is just logic and the question should exist until it's ruled out by them FINDING the reason..which they have not found yet.

I, for one, call bullshit on the MSM. Someone knows why he went ape...they just need to keep digging and not close off anything. Someone somewhere..knows.

617 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:10:34pm

613 Geepers

Well for the last few hours we've been trying to get JustMyView to say killing kufr's isn't OK.

Hasn't happened yet.


I think we were "lucky" to get JustMyView's link on the "rampaging Chriatian shooting up a mall".

618 Dr. Stu  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:12:44pm

I hear
"OPD, OPD", Then what sounds like a young Arabic voice saying something that resembles "Allahu Akbar" 2 times, and the third time is interrupted by a gunshot.

It's pretty echoey though, so at this point it's like interpreting those EVPs from Coast to Coast AM. I doubt that given the circumstances any of the witnesses had the presence of mind to note exactly what the gunmen was saying in the middle of a gun fight.

619 Highrise  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:12:57pm
Savage's report isn't the only one

Referring to his reporting that the person said the FBI didn't want to pursue the lead.

620 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:15:47pm

#616 Highrise

What irks me is the way the FBI will issue a statement that it doesn't appear to be terrorism before they even got anyone on the scene. I'm not exactly sure what's happening, whether the FBI is stating that it's not terrorism, or whether they're stating that they don't know, and the MSM reports it as not terrorism, but either way, they are making an affirmative statement before it's possible to legitimately make an affirmative statement.

621 RayH  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:15:57pm

I don't know if the guy who shot up the mall was a jihadi or not. But I have worked with 1 bosnian muslim. And all he really gave a damn about was hitting on certain women in the company and getting laid.

622 mich-again  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:18:18pm
"Welcome to my world," said Ibrahim Hooper, communications director of the Council on American-Islamic Relations in Washington, D.C., about the angry e-mails. "I get tons of it every day."

I only get about 10 ounds of e-mail a day. I can't imagine what its like getting a ton every day.

623 Q-Burn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:19:15pm

Whatever happened to personal responsibility, the bedrock of conservatism? A Muslim shot five people. Millions of other Muslims in this country went about their business peacably. So who is to blame, the religion or the individual? Just sayin'.

624 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:22:39pm

Daisy (#606),

Thanks for the heads up.

JustMyView, is this you:

justmyview

its stupid and counter-productive to play minority groups, jews, muslims, blacks etc against one another.

the fact is powerful people can say what they want about anyone and still prosper.

the powerful people who opposed desgregation remained senators long after Brown v Board of Education.

many european politicans have abused islam and remained in power - an italian minister called muslims one billion rats and stayed in power. golda meir referred to palestinians as cockroaches. ahmedinijad denied the holocaust. and so on. all these people remained in power after making these comments.

the question is not whether mel gibson should get an oscar. the question is whether right minded people should watch his films.

i wouldn't (and i am muslim).

i think the film the pasion of the christ is actually more anti-semitic than what gibson said to the traffic policeman.

interestingly an extremely and crudely racist film lost in translation wowed the critics with relatively little criticism - still didn't get the oscar though.

625 m  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:23:27pm

#623 Q-Burn
Depends. Did he do it to get into allah's whorehouse? Or did The Gap overcharge him?

626 Odinist  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:23:31pm

#620 Earth2moonbat

I think it's a cover up- same with most of the other attacks on crowds by Muslims since 9/11. Seems like the Feds think that if no one talks about a religious motivation behind these crimes, domestic terrorism will somehow go away...

627 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:24:54pm

623 Q-Burn

So who is to blame, the religion or the individual?

The problem is when the individual uses their religion as an excuse or justification for their actions.

628 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:26:15pm

Q-Burn (#623),

So who is to blame, the religion or the individual?

Because it couldn't possibly be both right?

Just sayin'.

629 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:26:42pm

626 Odinist

What I was getting at was I'm not sure if that's the feds who are rushing to affirm a negative, or if that's the media. I can believe either, but I can more easily believe the media.

630 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:28:35pm
interestingly an extremely and crudely racist film lost in translation wowed the critics with relatively little criticism - still didn't get the oscar though.

Lost in Translation is racist?!

631 Daisy  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:29:07pm

#612 Highrise,

"I think it's good some people (who are better than I at calling someone to the carpet when their argument is factless and moronic) are challenging justmyview. I just get bored easy with these types."

You and me both. And I think you're correct in your assessment of those better at 'carpet calling' :) - after all, jmv does keep coming back - he must be attracted, albeit unconsciously, to reason.

632 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:29:25pm

#624 Geepers

the powerful people who opposed desgregation remained senators long after Brown v Board of Education.

Can't argue with that. One from West Virginia is still there. Another one from Tennesee is running around the world right now promoting a concert tour.

633 cbinflux  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:29:26pm
the story of Monday’s shooting rampage at Trolley Square has been reduced to one fact: “Salt Lake City Killer Was a Muslim.”

/Jealousy from over-sexed and under-wifed Mormons, pure and simple.

634 Odinist  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:29:48pm

#623 Q-Burn

Ordinarily, I would agree with you, however there seems to be more and more of these kinds of attacks in recent years...

Are all of them terrorist related? Probably not. Are some of them terrorist related? I'd bet yes...

/I'm still waiting on the facts in this particular case- cell phone records, computer logs, etc.

635 Q-Burn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:30:54pm

#625

I don't pretend to know his motives but he is still personally respnsible. Not allah or the Gap.

636 cbinflux  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:31:52pm

e2m

Are you sure about the second one? Perhaps his father, but..?

637 missouri boy  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:32:08pm

iSLAm does not allow personal responsibility--- one must only obey the prophet .

638 Taqiyyotomist  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:32:09pm

#409 ggt

Sarcasm. I was making a point that apparantly missed it's mark. I am not opposed to the deletion of those types of remarks, I was arguing against those types of remarks in my #238, and was responding with absurdity in my #297 in response to the great* Geepers' post #277.

I should have noted all that in my post, admittedly, but I just read it again, and it seems pretty clear to me, even out of the context of that little debate, that it is sarcasm.

Sometimes on LGF the side-conversations can be numerous and it is sometimes hard to keep track of all of them at once when you're reading the thread. Sometimes people, myself included, scroll way way down into the 200s in order to just read the more current posts, and end up missing some conversations woven into the thread. So I understand how you could have missed that one, in a thread with more than 400 replies.
-Taq

*I mean that.

639 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:34:15pm

637 missouri boy 2/15/2007 04:32PM PST

iSLAm does not allow personal responsibility

That's true. Nothing happens without the will of allah, Inshallah.

640 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:35:53pm

636 cbinflux

Details.......

If you believe in anthropogenic global warming, you can believe that a Gore is a Gore.

641 Odinist  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:36:56pm

#629 Earth2moonbat

What I was getting at was I'm not sure if that's the feds who are rushing to affirm a negative, or if that's the media. I can believe either, but I can more easily believe the media.

True, but, I'd still have to lay equal odds on the feds... After all, they never seem to go back on their initial assessment...

642 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:38:01pm

missouri boy (#637),

There ya go.

Inshallah.

I like saying that when ever there's a "work accident".

643 Q-Burn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:38:07pm

#628 Geepers

Yes, both could be correct. Are you drinking yet?

644 formercorpsman  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:38:30pm
#372 formercorpsman

I know, your just as concerned about right wingers as you are about the possibility of islamic violence.

Not at all, debate is good if it's civil . . .

It is your type that has me more concerned, and seriously thinking about utilizing my Second Amendment Rights, than the thought of lone muslim going on a shooting spree in a mall.

. . . and refrains from veiled threats of violence . . .

It is your ilk who are so quick to label someone who votes for a different political party in a free country, with Nazi, without recognizing the same threat stemming from what is discussed on this board each day.

. . . and doesn’t bang away at straw men . . .

No you fear me, who pays their taxes, employs other Americans, and is very concerned about the global threat, and what will be left for my children, and what we have wasted in the aftermath of those who gave their lives in defending our freedom.

. . . or stray too far off topic . . .

You are a twit. Go back to your chicken wire experiments.

. . . or engage in hilarious ad hominem attacks that destroy your credibility as a serious thinker.


Well snowtravel, sorry for the delay in response. I am man enough to admit up front, I do sometimes respond with knee jerk reaction.

I'll spare the tit for tat, because truly, it is easy to see we would agree on very little. If you are worried about veiled violence, don't be. My opining about the second amendment has to do with the fact I don't own a firearm, and the reason I would consider changing has more to do with whom I feel my are a threat to my life, and my family's lives. It is my constitutional right. Furthermore, I would not know you, if I tripped over you, nor would you, tripping over me. I digress, feel whatever you want, I know Cameron is still concerned rape will become legal in the wake of Bush winning in 2004, just don't worry about me.

And Elaine Jarvik and Deborah Bulkeley explicitly blame LGF for angry emails the paper has received, rather than examine their policy of hiding information from the public.

I think the record shows, the direction of this blog took a turn post 911. Coming here, I know the nuance.

645 wanumba  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:38:51pm
#623 Q-Burn
Whatever happened to personal responsibility, the bedrock of conservatism? A Muslim shot five people. Millions of other Muslims in this country went about their business peacably. So who is to blame, the religion or the individual? Just sayin'.


Depends on what cultural perspective you have. If I were to say, not all Muslims are terrorists because I happen to know a lot of Muslims (and I do) in my perspective, I would be correct. In the Wahhabist perspective, those Muslims who do not act aggressively and violently in jihad, mass or minor scale, aren't Muslims. They are considered apostates. They are also considered to be requiring of correction and the Wahhabists feel perfectly justified in trying to cow them or sneak around and indoctrinate their children out from under them. The Muslims I know do not consider themselves apostates. So, who gets to set the terms of debate? The violent, nasty Wahhabists, the Mafia-like Muslim Brotherhood or the mainstream laid back bunch? It would be better for everyone if the mainstream laidbacks were the ones who should set the standards, not the hateful Wahhabists and their ilk.
If a Muslim, an immigrant, is at a mall shooting perfect strangers, harmless civliians, I naturally wouldn't lump him into the mainstream laidback mass of Muslims, would you ? and it seems prudent at the least to find out more about who he was. It is essential to determine whether he acted alone or not - because people's lives will depend on it.

646 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:39:36pm

#639 Sharmuta

Nothing happens without the will of allah, Inshallah.

So the absence of evidence of relivence is irrelivent, because evidence is irrelivent, because nothing happens without the will of allah, there everything that happens is just evidence of the will of allah.

I got it.

647 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:40:08pm

642 Geepers

Inshallah.

I like saying that when ever there's a "work accident".

I like you. Thanks for the laughs today.

648 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:40:30pm

Taqiyyotomist (#638),

Thanks buddy. I try.

Can I buy you a beer?

649 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:40:55pm

JMV is gone. I think Babba's right. Stan hates to be mocked.

650 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:43:13pm

646 Earth2moonbat

So the absence of evidence of relivence is irrelivent, because evidence is irrelivent, because nothing happens without the will of allah, there everything that happens is just evidence of the will of allah.

Throw in a couple "Inshallahs" and you're good to go.

651 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:44:26pm

Q-Burn (#643),

Huh?

Where ya been?

That was like six hours ago. ;-)

652 Highrise  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:46:37pm

623 Q-Burn 2/15/2007 04:19PM PST

Whatever happened to personal responsibility, the bedrock of conservatism? A Muslim shot five people. Millions of other Muslims in this country went about their business peacably. So who is to blame, the religion or the individual? Just sayin'.


This would not even be an issue for 97% on here (if I had to guestimate) IF the media and fbi hadn't already put out there that his muslim faith had nothing to do with it before 24 hours was even up. Try that in conjunction with being also told by both that they DO NOT KNOW the reason. IT seems to me one would be smart then to say that *this is still under investigation*. They do that in most all other cases lately, not sure why this one would be any different.

The koran's violent teaching can't be denied yet it is *swept* under the rug because people are afraid of it not being PC to call a spade a spade.

Questions need to be asked...tis all and that is what I'm mainly seeing in this thread. The trust just isn't there for the average person that they will be told the truth when a newstory starts out this way given the msm trackrecord.

653 mich-again  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:48:04pm

Irony alert. I pulled this from the State Department web page about refugee programs in the USA.

The Department of State strives to ensure that refugees who are accepted for admission to the United States are prepared for the significant life changes they will experience through resettlement by providing cultural orientation programs prior to departure for the United States. It is critical that refugees arrive with a realistic view of what their new lives will be like, what services are available to them, and what their responsibilities will be. Every refugee family receives Welcome to the United States, a resettlement guidebook developed with input from refugee resettlement workers, resettled refugees, and state government officials. Welcome to the United States is produced in ten languages: English, French, Spanish, Russian, Serbo-Croatian, Arabic, Somali, Vietnamese, Amharic, and Farsi.

Apparently their responsibilities don't include learning the language.

654 Athos  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:54:27pm

#620 E2M

What irks me is the way the FBI will issue a statement that it doesn't appear to be terrorism before they even got anyone on the scene. I'm not exactly sure what's happening, whether the FBI is stating that it's not terrorism, or whether they're stating that they don't know, and the MSM reports it as not terrorism, but either way, they are making an affirmative statement before it's possible to legitimately make an affirmative statement.

This current event just reinforces that this has to be SOP for the FBI and other elements in DHS. Several years ago, an Egyptian national shot up the Bradley Terminal El-Al ticket counter at LAX killing 2. For over a year, the FBI insisted that the effort was entirely unrelated to terrorism - despite the connections to radical islamic groups, despite his words before and at the scene - until they finally relented to the evidence, and quietly admitted that yes, the shooting was an act of terrorism.

I don't know if it's the internal conflict between multi-culturalists and conservatives inside these agencies - or the fear and backlash that results from the MSM and CAIR partnering in their blame and deflection efforts - but one would think that the default position should be to assume terrorism until all evidence points otherwise as opposed to the opposite. That would seem to be the more prudent approach to public safety.

655 jrdroll  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:56:42pm

Why do Muslim refugees go to America? Saudi has Sharia!
Maybe to kill us.

656 Taqiyyotomist  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 2:59:55pm

Geepers,
A Leinenkugel's in one of those fancy new Sam Adams glasses, if you would! :)

657 TalkinKamel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 3:01:58pm

#586 JustMyView

That was pretty lame, even for you.

Sorry, a hypothetical vague connection with "people who were, however loosely, Christian" doesn't automatically make one a Christian. (And you don't even have proof of any such connection). Christianity isn't like the measles; you don't catch it merely by hanging around those who have it.

Over the years, I've had some connections with people who considered themselves Wiccans. I'm not one myself, however. Just knowing someone from a certain religion doesn't automatically make you a member of that religion---really, JMV, you've got to do better than that. Did this woman shout out, "GOD WILLS IT! JESUS HATES INFIDELS!" during her attacks? Is there such as thing among Christians as "Sudden Crusader Syndrome?" No, didn't think so.

658 TalkinKamel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 3:13:57pm

WriterMom

Ridonculous? Posilutely and absatively, it most certainamently is!

#509 Wanumba

Yes, these are all good questions, which, I'm afraid, aren't going to be addressed in the rush to keep this story politically correct. Can one legally sell firearms to an 18 year old in Utah? Where did he get the money, both for the gun and all the ammo he had? What if said 18 year old had 4 misdemeanors on his record? And, if it isn't legal, who got the weapons for him? Some posters on different blogs have stated that he seems to have known how to use the weapon pretty well; where did he learn to shoot? Who taught him?

There should be some real investigating going on here, and it shouldn't just be dropped because oh, he was just a crazy kid who snapped, or, oh, it was just an ordinary crime! Whether it was terrorism or not, it needs to be looked into.

And consider this; maybe the kid himself was crazy, suicidal and just generally messed up---but, if he had help, what were this "helper's" motives? Is there somebody out there trying to push jihad by preying on unstable, unhappy Moslem teenagers?

Shouldn't this be looked into?

659 Earth2moonbat  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 3:21:59pm

#658 TalkinKamel

Ridonculous?

Howard Dean?

660 wanumba  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 3:22:35pm
#658 TalkinK
Is there somebody out there trying to push jihad by preying on unstable, unhappy Moslem teenagers

?
You said it. That's documented that unstable, unhappy Moslem teenagers are the radicals #1 targetted group, followed by boys who are orphaned or separated from their families out of war zones or civil strife. They hand in unstable zones and know how to spot the lost kids and round them up. They use as bait the initial help of giving them shelter and food, then they replace the boys' parents with themselves and indoctrinate them into violent jihad teachings. Modus operandi.

661 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 3:25:33pm

Taqiyyotomist (#656),

Can do.

And who couldn't respect a brewery that serves up Big Butt Doppelbock?

662 m  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 3:26:40pm

#635 Q-Burn

I don't pretend to know his motives but he is still personally respnsible. Not allah or the Gap.

Duh. I wasn't saying he held no responsibility for his actions. Just the motive makes the difference on whether religion was a factor. But you knew that.

If religion keeps telling you to kill, kill, kill!... and you actually kill - are you saying the religion had nothing to do with it?

663 Momzilla  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 3:28:35pm

I lived in Salt Lake for three long years:

1. I wouldn't wrap fish in the Desert News.

2. From our experience as an "outsider" living in Utah, I marvel that this doesn't happen MORE often. Even Mormons moving to the area from elsewhere have trouble adjusting to the Stepford-like culture. A kid already traumatized by life in a war zone, plus being Muslim, plus normal teenaged reaction to being relocated from his friends and familiar environment, , plus being relocated to Utah specifically is a recipe for one suicidal kid.

664 m  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 3:29:11pm

m-

If religion keeps telling you to kill, kill, kill!... and you actually kill (because that holey book tells you to kill, kill, kill) - are you saying the religion had nothing to do with it?

There- fixed before you started wiggling.

665 wanumba  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 3:32:19pm

TalkinKamel
Yeh. ABout those firearms. It'll take a little bit, but there are websites that list the state laws. JustMyView of course was trying to push the concept that an investigation is surperfluous, on the grounds that the shooter is dead. Just reassuring other readers who didn't think that was correct. JMV is either completely ignorant of the law or of course was purposely fogging. I'm sure you know what I think the answer is to that. :)

666 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 3:36:48pm

Hey m!

667 RayH  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 3:38:17pm

#661 Geepers

Now that beer looks damn good.
And the Creamy Dark also.
I'd say you've got good taste in beer.

668 justamomof4  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 3:40:25pm
#5 Heather Radish
There is no record that Talovic attended any of the mosques in the Salt Lake area,

So? You can be radicalized outside of mosques.

Indeed.

I looked into the local mosques online and found that this website, a collective for the various mosques offers video programs such as this one

Sunni-Shia Dialogue Featuring Dr. Muzzamil Siddiqi (Sunni) & Imam Al-Qazwini (Shia) 3/12/06 Dr. Muzzamil Siddiqi, Religious Director of The Islamic Society of Orange County, meets with Imam Al-Qazwini, the founding Imam of The Islamic Educational Center of Orange County along with a mixed council of Sunni and Shia leaders in California to discuss unity and cooperation between Sunnis and Shias in a time when Muslims are facing increased internal and external threats. You can listen to this dialogue with quicktime:

Sunni-Shia Dialogue (Part 1)

Sunni-Shia Dialogue (Part 2)

Now why, you might ask, would that be of interest?

Dr. Muzzamil Siddiqi helped convert Al Qaeda operative Adam Gadahn

Now I'm not saying that the shooter, Sulejman Talovic was a disciple.

You are correct, and The Muslim Forum of Utah offers all avenues - online - easily accessible to all.

669 justamomof4  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 3:46:20pm
#620 E2M

What irks me is the way the FBI will issue a statement that it doesn't appear to be terrorism before they even got anyone on the scene. I'm not exactly sure what's happening, whether the FBI is stating that it's not terrorism, or whether they're stating that they don't know, and the MSM reports it as not terrorism, but either way, they are making an affirmative statement before it's possible to legitimately make an affirmative statement.

Recall Atlas' piece last week:


"Public information officers or spokesman for law enforcement agencies are purposely downplaying and in some cases lying outright to the public about arrests of Muslims in the US," so said one Federal law enforcement official.
670 Q-Burn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 3:47:32pm

#662 m

If religion keeps telling you to kill, kill, kill!... and you actually kill - are you saying the religion had nothing to do with it?

#662 m

I'm not an expert on any religion. I know that one killed and millions didn't. On this day.

671 AirForceWife  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 4:00:10pm

#608

I wonder how many other parents are thinking the same thing?

I can't tell you how many times my husband and I have talked about this very thing. While we appreciate the value of a college education and both made it through colleges where the college Republicans were a very lonely group, we can't stand the thought of those liberal professors getting to our kids. Fortunately, my two boys seem to be natural born right wingers. They drive their liberal teachers nuts.

It's too early to tell with my daughter. I pray she didn't inherit any of her hippie grandmother's DNA who uses my husband's (her son's) participation in this war to further her own anti-war activism. She has no regard for the fact that he believes in what he is doing. It's all about her and what she wants for him. She has given him grief since the day he told her he was joining and I almost kicked her out of our house the day she told him that this war was all about our oil interests. It took me a week to get her stinky hippie smell out of my couch. I'm getting leather before she comes back.

672 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 4:01:57pm
673 m  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 4:06:44pm

Hey Geepers!

#670 Q-Burn ~ yeah. I happen to be one of the "they aren't all terrorist" people. But your argument that religion can not have anything to do with it is wrong in my opinion. That doesn't absolve the perp from their responsibility either.

It most certainly COULD have been a factor. I just thank G-d there are bunches of bad muslims that don't want to kill for the cause of allan.

674 Q-Burn  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 4:14:55pm

#671 Airforcewife

I am in an Air Force family. At the risk of sounding like a hippie, please love your daughter unconditionally. Things will work out, if not this year.

675 Geepers  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 4:17:51pm

RayH (#667)

Thanks. It does sound good. Started drinking beer when I was 15, in Austria so I have always had a preference for "heavy" beers.

But thank Taqiyyotomist for the heads up.

676 TalkinKamel  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 4:20:52pm

#654 Earth2moonbat

Howard Dean? Never, a thousand times never, I say!

I got "ridonkulous" from from the highly un-ridonkulous WriterMom!

#660 Wanumba

Yes, I'd known about Islamofacists recruiting orphaned boys, and unhappy teenagers, and how many Palestinian suicide bombers turn out to have personal problems, or severe illnesses. It's a method that's worked in other places, so why wouldn't they try it here?

Look at all those Palestinians "doctors" who are so ubiquitous in terrorist groups, and who so often claim to be working with children. (What are they working on?) I'm not saying that's what happened here---but, given the times we live in, and the dangers we face, shouldn't we at least check it out? Not only for the sake of any would-be victims, but for the Moslem kids themselves?

And no, JMV doesn't know the law; just because the killer's dead doesn't mean the investigation comes to a halt---by no means!

Whatever the answers are, I hope those in charge keep digging.

When I get a chance, I'll try researching some of those Utah gun laws.

{Wanumba}

677 Sharmuta  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 4:26:23pm

673 m

I just thank G-d there are bunches of bad muslims that don't want to kill for the cause of allan.

So am I, Inshallah. No one should ever kill for the cause of allan, Inshallah.

678 RayH  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 4:41:02pm

Geepers, and Taqiyyotomist thanks for the link.
I prefer dark beers, stouts and porters. The best.


RayH (#667)

Thanks. It does sound good. Started drinking beer when I was 15, in Austria so I have always had a preference for "heavy" beers.

But thank Taqiyyotomist for the heads up.

679 AirForceWife  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 5:01:33pm

#674 Q-Burn 2/15/2007 06:14PM PST

#671 Airforcewife

I am in an Air Force family. At the risk of sounding like a hippie, please love your daughter unconditionally. Things will work out, if not this year.

I think you may have misunderstood my post. It's my MIL that I can't stand. I will always love my kids unconditionally but if one of them ever turns out like their grandmother...I'll talk to them until they have come to their senses. My Daughter is only 6 so I have no idea what her politics will be as an adult.

680 pst314  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 5:05:54pm

Ultraconservative?

Well let's see, just what topics does Charles post on? Islamic extremism, terrorism, the war, and everything related to them. Not much of anything on big vs. small government, the Federalists vs. the Anti-Federalists, the merits or demerits of various welfare programs, affirmative action, gay rights, gay marriage, abortion, evolution vs. creationism, second amendment issues, progressive taxes vs. flat taxes, tax cuts vs. tax increases, etc, etc, etc. Maybe Jarvik and Bulkeley did spent hours and hours sleuthing out clues to Charles' opinions on these issues, but more likely they just did what so many mainstream journalists do and took one deviation from liberal orthodoxy as proof of extreme right-wing ideology. Which, to use a classic leftist term, makes Charles a right-deviationist. :-)

681 AirForceWife  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 5:17:03pm

#663 Momzilla,

plus being relocated to Utah specifically is a recipe for one suicidal kid.

You've got to be kidding me. This is so completely opposite of my experiences here. While I would never want to live in SLC (where it's as crime infested as any big city) outside of SLC is a whole other world and one I love. I don't believe what the LDS religion teaches but the Mormons have made Utah a GREAT place to raise my kids. Maybe that makes me a real prude or some kind of Stepford wife or something but I love the culture here. Parents are involved in their kids. They are some of the most patriotic people I've ever known. I wish to God that more places were as wholesome as Utah is. It's refreshing. Like I tell my kids....."be rebels. Don't pierce your face or wear shags or mohawks or have your pants hanging off your butt....please be rebels". My kids haven't had adjustment problems because they aren't Mormons. They have friends and play sports like any other kid. They are nice people and about the most law-abiding on the planet. Can get pretty aggressive when it comes to sports though. Especially youth soccer........My Gawd! I was also a bit shocked when my husband played some church basketball and he said that our Mormon neighbors were dropping the "F" word left and right. Anyways........I would live with these people for the rest of my life if I could.

682 AirForceWife  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 5:25:05pm

#676

I thought he used a shotgun? Kids as young as 14 can buy shotguns. At 12, they can hunt with a parent. We also take our 12 year old to the range and at 12 he can take a safety course but we've pretty much taught him everything.

683 EE  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 5:50:36pm

We live in a time when there are some Muslims who go on a terrorist rampage for jihad reasons, so when a Muslim goes on a murderous rampage, the question should naturally come up as to whether this is another jihad rampage. Maybe yes, maybe no, but it is a legitimate question.

But the tactics of the media in withholding the information about the perpetrator being a Muslim is an effort to lie to the public by omission. Instead of presenting the facts, and letting the facts determine what conclusion should be reached concerning motive, by omitting the information that the homicidal rampager was a Muslim they are taking one possible motive off the table, to prevent any serious consideration of it.

This is like cooking the books, and it is dishonest.

If a pharmaceutical company were to know that people died after taking their drug, and if they were to withhold that information because they had the theory that it had nothing to do with their drug, they would rightly be accused of cooking the books, and of withholding information that might possibly be important.

In this case, the media have taken on themselves to decide that the perp's being a Muslim had nothing to do with the rampage. But instead of presenting all of the information, including the information that the perp was a Muslim, and also whatever information might be relevant to whether jihad was a motive, they just decided to withhold the information completely. They are cooking the books, and it is dishonest of them to do that.

But most outrageous of all is the effort of Deseret News to attack those who bring out a possibly important fact that was hidden -- apparently deliberately hidden it seems from the attacks -- by attributing bad motives and libeling the whistleblowers who have uncovered the malfeasance in hiding a possibly important fact.

It's bad enough that they suppress a possibly important fact that might relate to motive. But it is shameful that they resort to libelous ad hominem attacks on whistleblowers who point out the fact that they suppressed. The attacks also show that the hiding of the fact that the perp was a Muslim was deliberate, because they identify facts with political labels, according to what cause the facts support. If the facts are inconvenient truths, then they are spiked, they are not revealed.

684 EE  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 5:56:53pm

To use the phrase made famous by Al Gore, in a different matter, the fact that a perpetrator who goes on a murderous rampage is a Muslim is regarded by the media as an inconvenient truth. So they suppress it.

685 TGregg  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:32:27pm

What does one expect from an ultra-radical-way-off-the-deep-end-mega-extreme-lu natic-fringe-whacko-insane-nutcase-moonbat publication other than lies about the USA and the patriots that love this country? People don't subcribe to that rag to read anything else.

686 J'accuzzi  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 6:49:01pm

It seems obvious that the Deseret News team has some difficulty keeping Bosnia and Chechnya sorted out correctly in their little world. Or if not, perhaps the perp had some connections to the Chechen "trainers" who "helped out" in former Yugoslavia from time to time.

687 mjazzguitar  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 7:49:33pm

The kid who flew the plane into a building (was it Fla.?) was a pali, there was a quran in the plane, and notice the msm seemed to downplay that guy on top of the Empire State Building who was pali also.

688 mjazzguitar  Thu, Feb 15, 2007 8:14:28pm

#314 Geepers 2/15/2007 10:39AM PST


Taqiyyotomist (#297),
Then I guess I'm gonna whip off a quick "Let's throw all the Muslims on boxcars and ship them off to camps! From all of us here at Charles Johnson's LGF, a hearty Kill 'em All!"

After all, what further harm could be done?

Are you intentionally missing the point?

I didn't see a connection either. And when people just use a name and no # that means you have to scroll back and if you're lucky you'll see what they were referring to.

689 TalkinKamel  Fri, Feb 16, 2007 6:07:38am

My apologies if anybody else has posted this, but Debbie Schlussel, and Jihad Watch, talk about this case this morning. And what they have to say is quite troubling. [Link: www.debbieschlussel.com...]

690 mrsmomomoto  Fri, Feb 16, 2007 3:39:17pm

JMV wrote:

"but, in this country,we haven't seen any evidence that Muslims are planning small-scale assaults on civilian targets of the sort that occurred in Utah"

There have been a number of incidents in which a single Muslim has driven a car into pedestrians, or the like. There is also extremist Islamic literature targeting individual Muslims, encouraging them to do individual acts of jihad such as running people over, or shooting them.

Go look at Spencer's site, he has the documentation.

None of this is to say that Islam was this guy's motivation. It is to say that that motivation shouln't be ruled out; it is realistic, there is evidence to suggest that it is a realisticly possible motivation. This information means that the FBI might find clues as to his motivation on that computer of his they didn't bother to take a look at. It isn't racism or Islamophobia to point this out; it is simply concern for the facts.

You are as biased as the worst on this website, and the impact of your bias is just as negative. You don't hold murderers accountable, and you aren't honest about investigating their motivation. The effect is reduced deterent to murder, and diminished capacity to confront the underlying problems of murder, should that be possible. That means increased liklihood of murder and, should SJS be a real phenomenon, that means increased chance of a major backlash.


This entry has been archived.
Comments are closed.

^ back to top ^

log in
Name:
Pass:

Register Forgot Your Password? My Account Re-send Confirmation (To log in, cookies must be enabled in your browser!)

► LGF Headlines

► Top 10 Comments

► Bottom Comments

► Recent Comments

► Tools/Info

► LGF Hits

► Slideshows

► Resources

► Never Forget

► Statistics

► Tag Cloud

► Contact

You must have Javascript enabled to use the contact form.
Your email:

Subject:

Message:


Messages may be published in our weblog, unless you request otherwise.
Tech Note:
Using the Contact Form

► News/Opinion


More Partners

Compare Electricity Prices in your area. Texas Electricity is deregulated; you have the right to choose Texas Electric Rates from among many Texas Electric Companies.

Skiing through the revolving door of life.

Fast & Free Delivery 160x600
Save $5 off $50 at Kmart with code KMART5OFF50
Finish Line- $10 off $60- 728 x 90