LGF

-RetweetFact or Fiction at The New Republic?

Fri, Jul 20, 2007 at 8:59:21 am PDT

Recently, The New Republic published an extremely far-fetched article titled “Shock Troops,” with disgusting tales of brutality and heartless behavior by US troops, purported to be written by a soldier serving in Iraq. Michael Goldfarb at the Weekly Standard is skeptical (to say the least), and asked for feedback from milbloggers: New Republic: Fact or Fiction?

The New Republic has some explaining to do.

Advertisement

314 comments

  • Comments are open and unmoderated, and do not necessarily reflect the views of Little Green Footballs.
  • Obscene, abusive, silly, or annoying remarks may be deleted, but the fact that particular comments remain on the site in no way constitutes an endorsement of their views by Little Green Footballs.
  • Posts that contain phone numbers, street addresses, email addresses or other personal information will also be deleted, as will posts that consist only of a variation on the word, "First!"
  • Comments that advocate violence will be cause for immediate banning with no appeal.
  • Disagreement and debate are welcome, but insults and abuse are not, and may cause your account to be blocked.
  • REMEMBER: posting comments at LGF is a privilege, not a right. Abuse that privilege, and your account will be blocked.

Hide comments | Jump to bottom

1 JammieWearingFool  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:00:53am

Is Stephen Glass back on the payroll?

2 Beagle  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:01:46am

Another Jesse? They want to believe so much!

3 Tuna  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:03:15am

Ever seen the movie "Shattered Glass"? About Stephen Glass at the TNR? Is it possible this is happening again?

-The Tuna

4 jamgarr  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:04:20am

Can't wait to see how this plays out.

5 Drained Brain  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:05:33am

But "We Support The Troops."

6 lawhawk  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:06:33am

This has been making the rounds for a couple of days. Some of the stuff sounds truly far fetched - like how any soldiers would make cracks about another person horribly disfigured by an IED (not clear whether it's a soldier or a contractor they're talking about - and if you're in the military, wouldn't that be abundantly clear not to mention that such injuries would likely result in an honorary discharge?) or that some driver would purposefully target dogs on the street and run them over - and the dogs would willingly stay put while all this happens?

These stories don't have to be true. They don't even have to interview people and get the story straight. They epitomize what the writers think the situation is in Iraq. If I were someone investigating this matter, I'd be demanding to see all manner of phone records, emails, notes and other communications to verify these events took place.

The whole thing reeks of being invented from the mind of an anti-war writer who couldn't be bothered by facts.

7 Terp Mole  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:06:49am

Here's the invite;

Does anyone who has served at FOB Falcon remember hearing about or seeing the humiliation of this woman? Do they know her name and how we might get in contact with her to confirm the author's account of the events that day?

Is anyone familiar with a combat outpost a few miles south of the Baghdad airport where a mass grave of Iraqi children was discovered? What about the other parts of the story? And does anyone else know of Bradleys careening wildly through the streets of Baghdad?

Please email any information, thoughts, and suggestions for further lines of inquiry to THE WORLDWIDE STANDARD at wws@weeklystandard.com. Click here for updates at THE WORLDWIDE STANDARD.

8 DaMishMan  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:08:03am

Must be a slow news day. If nothing happens that reflects badly on the United States...make it up! And what better way then to go after the troops on the ground. They can't respond immediately in kind.

Rise, Lizard Nation! Don't let the trolls smear our sons and daughters!

9 EtNorskTroll  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:08:29am

Has anyone here been to Iraq?

Anyone served in the Military under such conditions?

Would it make you want to do such terrible things?

Can anyone here stand in judgment of these troops if (!) they did do these things?

I know that I couldn't...

~Norsk Troll

10 mickthemick  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:09:38am

Fake atrocities are a trick of the left going back to the Vietnam War days. Many of these claims were/are made by men who (1) never were in the places they claim to have witnessed atrocities or (2) were never in the military, period.

The left compares Iraq to Vietnam regularly. The only similarities in the conflicts are in the tactics and propaganda of the left.

11 Spiny Norman  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:12:07am

re: #6 lawhawk

These stories don't have to be true. They don't even have to interview people and get the story straight. They epitomize what the writers think the situation is in Iraq...

The whole thing reeks of being invented from the mind of an anti-war writer who couldn't be bothered by facts.

It's all about the Truthiness!

12 NJDhockeyfan  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:12:10am

I saw that yesterday. Made me want to throw up. I would bet this is fiction and the author just hates our military.

13 Sharmuta  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:12:15am

Either the New Republic is completely incapable of vetting a story (which I've heard from a reliable source is possible) or there is no horror story "perpetrated" by American troops they are not willing to believe (never mind the true horror stories perpetrated by our enemies).

If it's the former- shame on them. If it's the latter- shame on them.

14 cbinflux  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:12:23am

Note: Two articles posted yesterday pointed out that journalists can and do tell truths as they see them,; their under no obligation to tell THE truth.

15 'Nam Grunt  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:13:14am

In a word, HOGWASH!...or someone is smoking too much crack!

16 Milk Toast Intolerant  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:13:21am

Here we go again. It doesn't matter if it's true or not. Just write it and spread it throughout the internet. Many are willing to listen, because if it's on the internet, it must be true. Our troops are constantly being smeared by these "dissenting" types.

17 lawhawk  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:17:06am

Malkin and she, among others, makes the Winter Soldier comparison.

18 Terp Mole  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:17:42am

Hugh Hewitt: The Hysterics of the Anti-War Fringe

Today's wacademia specimen;

Perpetuating grassroots extremism
By Dylan Miracle
20 easy  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:18:34am

Summer Soldiers. Stories heard and embelished x 10.

These are just stupid.

21 MandyManners  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:18:44am

re: #14 cbinflux

Note: Two articles posted yesterday pointed out that journalists can and do tell truths as they see them,; their under no obligation to tell THE truth.

This is not in the tradition of real journalism. Instead, it's the bastard child known as advocacy journalism.

22 galloping granny  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:18:48am

Anybody considered 'Jon Cary" as the author of this abomination? This isn't a scrap different than what he pulled during the Vietnam War.

23 Dave the.....  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:19:32am

I was reading a couple of threads yesterday on this a couple of blogs. The commentaters included Iraq veterans or contractors.

Reminded me a lot of the thread the day the Rather/TANG docs were exposed as fakes. The posters on these blogs explained why what was said in the New Republic was probably impossible.

When you have 1000s of experts reviewing something, it's easy to spot false items. Events that could not have occured. People that probably don't exist. etc.

24 MandyManners  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:19:37am

re: #21 MandyManners

Or, better known as "fiction."

25 jamil hussein  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:19:37am

Kinda reminds me of the work of some other Iraqi fiction writer whose name escapes me.

26 Beagle  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:20:07am

It sure reads like another Jesse MacBeth. It's that alternate parallel universe the Left likes to document when they don't have anything to say about actual facts on the ground. It's so common now I think we should call them Kerry Stories or something. Lying about the troops launched Kerry's career and made him internationally famous. It's become a career track.

27 YourTaxDollarsAtWork  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:20:33am

Jump over to BLACKFIVE. Uncle J has addresses this travesty there as well. I know a service member or two, and with the exception of the random douche bag who would quickly be regulated on, NO ONE FROM ANY BRANCH would behave the way this evil mother f^cker suggests. These John "The-Military-is-Stupid" Kerry-esq lies are almost certainly the spawn of some basement dwelling leftist pond scum who seeks to please his deranged Blame-America-First masters. I'd stake a pay check that the author of these articles this chronic Michale Moore masturbater has never served a day in the military. Or had a girlfriend for that matter.

Sorry for the ranting, but I haven't had my coffee yet.

28 brent  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:21:06am

Hugh Hewitt's had this up for a day, and it's been debunked on a couple pretty good points. Besides hitting the emotional heartstrings of dogs and disfigured women, there are problems like:

It's impossible to see close to the outside of a Bradley, especially with the periscope. No one calls it the chow hall, not since say the 70s. It's highly unlikely that stories like the skull on the head would not have been leaked and or investigated.

Etc etc etc.

Jesse, that you son? You out in EERak again? Smokin' KeeeRack again?

But, they do of course support our military. Or, the seal just broke and the flood of baby killer stories is coming again.

29 cbinflux  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:21:20am

re: #21 MandyManners

re: #14 cbinflux


Note: Two articles posted yesterday pointed out that journalists can and do tell truths as they see them,; their under no obligation to tell THE truth.

This is not in the tradition of real journalism. Instead, it's the bastard child known as advocacy journalism.

The former is all but extinct; welcome to the New World Order.

30 SlartyBartfast  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:21:28am

My ol' buddy Dar ul Harb and I were hoping this one would get its own thread. (Thanks, Charles.)

I'm sure there was a previous LGF post showing a Jihadist (or a Kos Kid...I get them confused) advising like-minded folk to post fictitious crap like this. Maybe a little LGF Search is in order...

31 Dave the.....  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:21:45am

MSM is back to what I saw in the 1980's with stories on Vietnam vets. They are either victims or villians.

32 cookielady  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:22:00am

What? You mean some (lefty) journalist is making up lies and smearing our valiant troops in the field? Why, why... that's impossible! Journalists don't do that, they are objective observers and reporters of facts. They verify everything told them before publication or airing; they would never report something false just because it promoted their personal worldview!

/must I?

33 MIchael in MI  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:22:32am

From the Weekly Standard link I posted above:

I served 4 years in the Army, including service in Desert Storm, and was in a Bradley Fighting Vehicle battalion, the 1/9 Cav Regiment out of Ft. Hood.

As with most things written by the the traitorous media, the Shock Troop story is a collection of lies, complied by sissy leftist who don't even do enough research to make their lies believable. Sort of like the story of flushing a Koran down a toilet.

I've been in the drivers seat of a Bradley, and as Stuart Koehl says, you have terrible visibility on the right hand side. The engine is over there, and it's like trying to put a Ford Excursion in a parking space for a compact car.

The closest you can see on the right side is probably 15 feet away, and that would be with the seat all the way up, and the hatch fully opened back. No trooper is going to ride down a road in Iraq sitting that high, he'd be a sitting duck for a sniper. They either roll with the hatch fully shut, looking through the periscopes for visibility (think driving a sub down the street), or at most, with the hatch at half-cock, where you look though a slit (think sitting in a trash can with the lid on your head).

You're not going to be able to see a dog over there, so that's one lie.

Another lie is running things over with the Bradley. Take a look at the front it. The first thing that sticks out is the tracks, which are also the most vulnerable part of it. If you went around running into buildings or concrete barriers with your Bradley, you'd throw a track, and after your BC (Bradley commander) put his boot up your ass for being a dumb-ass, you'd spend the rest of your tour demoted down to sitting in the dreaded side turret jump seat between the driver and the rest of the crew, breathing diesels fumes, mixed in with BO and MRE gas from the dismount team.

Other lies - how does a dog sit in the road and get run over by an armored vehicle? How many dogs have you ever seen run over like this? Dogs aren't dumb, they get out of the way of a 23 ton armoured vehicle. The Bradley is not a Formula 1 race car either - the usual rolling speed is about 20-30 MPH. The article makes it sound like the BFV (Bradley Fighting Vehicle) is some sort of Klingon warship with a clocking device and a sound silencer, capbale of sneaking up on sleeping dogs and running them over before they can get up and move the 2 feet they'd have to get out of the way.

Then there's the story of a dog getting run over, with the two sections twitching around. Notice how it's written for shock value, with some lie about the head just staying there. The tracks of a Bradley are pretty wide - it's not a tire, it's a track. That would have to be one damn big stray dog to be cut in two by a Bradley, and still have identifiable parts on either side. Besides, how did he know what happended after he had run it over? Did he stop, get out of his vehicle, and walk over to it to take a look? You don't have real view mirror on a BFV.

Ian Kress
US Army, 1989-1993
MOS 11H (Infantry - Anti-Armor)
1/9th Cav Regiment, 1st Cav Division, Ft Hood.

34 Prince of Dorkness  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:22:43am

I'm sure John F. Kerry will be testifying to TNR's "truthiness". He served in Viet Nam and is very familiar with atrocities, ya know

35 SusanL  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:22:46am

As the daughter and granddaughter of soldiers, I call BS. Only in the fevered dreams of the left do our men and women of the military behave this way.

Good Lord, if you can't find something horrid to say, I guess you should just make it up.

Susan

36 FLBuckeye  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:22:53am

I call BULLSHIT!
[Link: www.americanthinker.com...]
this link shows some striking similarities to a nutroot ex soldier

37 Ben Hur  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:23:18am

THere'll be a slew of movies produced with this kind of lying BS.

SOrt of like Kerry's congressional testimony.

All Vietnam movies following that BS showed our soldiers as psychopaths.

38 Osama Bin Porkchop  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:23:32am

OT...Rocket launcher found near Newark Airport...


[Link: wcbstv.com...]

39 experiencedtraveller  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:24:16am

re: #1 JammieWearingFool

Is Stephen Glass back on the payroll?

Maybe they brought Ruth Shalit back?

40 Ben Hur  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:24:20am

re: #34 Prince of Dorkness

GMTA

41 Dave the.....  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:24:41am

Wow, you'd think I troops were acting in a way reminiscent of Jenjis Khan.

42 cookielady  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:25:11am

re: #26 Beagle

It sure reads like another Jesse MacBeth. It's that alternate parallel universe the Left likes to document when they don't have anything to say about actual facts on the ground. It's so common now I think we should call them Kerry Stories or something. Lying about the troops launched Kerry's career and made him internationally famous. It's become a career track.


No, they are officially, as of this moment, named

Kerrytales

43 MandyManners  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:25:12am

re: #29 cbinflux

I useta' wonder what went wrong but, thank's to BabbaZee's raising awareness about Gramsci, I know what happened.

44 cod_is_great  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:25:44am

re: #38 Osama Bin Porkchop

Good link.

Though, I'm sure we'll find that it was just some innocent non-Muslim leaving it on the roof of his car and driving away by accident. I did that with a bucket of KFC once.

45 Ben Hur  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:25:57am

Strange that our troops only commit atrocities while republicans are in office, yet die more when dems are.

46 JammieWearingFool  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:26:11am

Rocket launcher found in Jersey City

Planted by Republicans to whip up fear over the John Doe legislation.

47 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:26:57am
48 mrsoc  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:27:06am

re: #10 mickthemick

Fake atrocities are a trick of the left going back to the Vietnam War days. Many of these claims were/are made by men who (1) never were in the places they claim to have witnessed atrocities or (2) were never in the military, period.

The left compares Iraq to Vietnam regularly. The only similarities in the conflicts are in the tactics and propaganda of the left.

Wait, didn't I hear this sort of thing from John Kerry? He had a magic hat in a place we hadn't been yet and they were murdering, terrorizing men women and children in the dark of night and...Oh yeah, he also had a piece of rice in his ass.
And not for nuthin',

Stephen Glass


They don't learn fast over there, do they?
Some may call it treason.

49 MandyManners  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:27:32am

re: #42 cookielady

Kerrytales!

I like it! No. I love it!

50 pat  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:27:48am

More. I just happened to be on topic when Charles put up the subject.
[Link: www.mudvillegazette.com...]

OK, let's call it bullshit. Does anyone really think after Abu Grhab some idiot is going to wear a skull around all day? Or laugh at an American IED victim?

52 cbinflux  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:28:08am

OT
Philly Imam to enter prison Aug. 13

/Will he comply, or will he boogie in a burqa?

53 YourTaxDollarsAtWork  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:28:16am

re: #38 Osama Bin Porkchop

Whoa. Maybe I'm still not awake yet, but did you notice the woman' name?

54 SlartyBartfast  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:28:57am

Ahhh...I found it: LGF, Mon, Mar 19, 2007 at 9:59:04 am PST.


Influencing the Views of the Weak-Minded American
Here’s an eye-opener.

We all know they’re doing it, but this post on a jihadi web site explicitly instructs the Islamic warriors on how to manipulate “weak-minded Americans” and foster anti-war sentiment, by using popular web forums (I’m looking at you, Daily Kos) and video sharing sites like YouTube and LiveLeak to spread propaganda and disinformation.

And, the phrase that pays...


“Invent Stories About American Soldiers You Have [Allegedly] Personally Known”
55 humanity  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:28:58am

Ehmm...

Its Execution time

56 'Nam Grunt  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:29:01am

An NCO would bring anyone up on charges utilizing the UCMJ if this happened, end of story. I'm speaking of ANY war we have fought!

57 Ben Hur  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:29:06am

re: #50 pat

More. I just happened to be on topic when Charles put up the subject.
[Link: www.mudvillegazette.com...]

OK, let's call it bullshit. Does anyone really think after Abu Grhab some idiot is going to wear a skull around all day? Or laugh at an American IED victim?


Stealing scenes from Apocalypse Now.

When they reach the bridge.

The Black soldier who fires the mortar at the guy on the loudspeaker.

58 Spiny Norman  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:29:24am

re: #26 Beagle

It sure reads like another Jesse MacBeth. It's that alternate parallel universe the Left likes to document when they don't have anything to say about actual facts on the ground. It's so common now I think we should call them Kerry Stories or something. ..

Kerry Stories.

I like it!

59 cookielady  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:30:25am

Mandy likes it! I'm so honored!

:-D

So, can we make up our own Kerrytales now? And whenever someone lies about the troops, can we call it a Kerrytale? Can we, can we, huh?

Puhleeeaaassseee?

60 experiencedtraveller  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:31:51am

All this talk of summer and winter soldiers reminds me of a time when this term described a much more sanguinary situation.

Please support the Thomas Paine Memorial in Fort Lee NJ.

61 Spiny Norman  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:32:22am

Kerrytales is even better!

Excellent, cookielady!

62 Ed Mahmoud's Sock Puppet  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:32:47am

Now banned lizard Rayra, at GCP, discussed how difficult it would be for a Bradley driver to target dogs this way.

This is Jon Carry style 'Jenjis Khan' style baby-killing porn for the LLL

63 YourTaxDollarsAtWork  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:32:48am

re: #57 Ben Hur

Or from 'Dead Presidents' when he carries the head around for a week.

And I think the Apocalypse Now scene was an M-79.

64 cookielady  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:33:08am

We could tuck the KosKids in every night with a Kerrytale...

aawww, how sweet!

65 MandyManners  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:33:14am

#53 YourTaxDollarsAtWork 7/20/2007 9:28:16 am PDT reply quote

re: #38 Osama Bin Porkchop

Whoa. Maybe I'm still not awake yet, but did you notice the woman' name?

Niranjana Besai.

Is that a Muslim's name?

66 TrueKatipunero  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:33:19am

Worked before with John F***ing Kerry. Why should in not work now?

67 Kostya Lotz  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:33:39am

Dean Barnett, subbed for Hugh Hewitt last night and spent the entire show on this story. Turns out part of these "Karbala Tales" may have originated from articles in Der Spiegel from 2004, involving German troop misbehavior. I smell some stinky schnitzel.

68 Paul  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:33:48am

This is war porn for consumption by the moonbats, I'm sure they'll believe it without reservation at Kos and the DU. It reminds me of John Kerry and the Winter Soldier lies.

69 Dianna  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:34:14am

According to what Goldfarb posted this morning at the Weekly Standard's website, New Republic still hasn't responded. Certainly, there's nothing on New Republic's blogs (though I haven't checked this morning, yet).

Oh, it's probably not Stephen Glass himself, but it's his behavioral twin!

70 grumpy old codger  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:34:16am

The original story sounds and reads like another "Gee, we hate the country and the war, so let's write up a story that just shows how evil and mean we can imagine these guys to be, so that people will start believing us because we've made up stuff that makes the soldiers out to be worse than the Nazis, because, even though the story isn't true, we have to do something" BS.

The criticisms offered on the Standard regarding the dining room facilities, the turn radius, etc., combined with my own experiences at FOBs convince me that this is just another "Gee...something" story. A fabrication with a political goal.

71 galloping granny  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:34:18am

re: #28 brent

Hugh Hewitt's had this up for a day, and it's been debunked on a couple pretty good points. Besides hitting the emotional heartstrings of dogs and disfigured women, there are problems like:

I have to tell you, I was an Army wife for a good long time. Never, anywhere, have I seen women treated with as much respect - no matter their age or appearance - than on a military base. Any military base. BTW, the same applies to dogs.

72 Ben Hur  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:34:53am

re: #51 bosforus

the story's getting eaten alive over at The New Republic, just read the comments. it doesn't look like anyone has ever believed the story.

SOme don't beleive it, yet they think it's to make the New Republic look bad, not the US military and the soldiers.

Their priorities are STILL upsidedown.

73 galloping granny  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:35:55am

re: #62 Ed Mahmoud's Sock Puppet

Now banned lizard Rayra, at GCP, discussed how difficult it would be for a Bradley driver to target dogs this way.

This is Jon Carry style 'Jenjis Khan' style baby-killing porn for the LLL

Not to mention, unless things have changed greatly damage done to the Bradley due to misuse of government property while running over dogs as sport would come directly out of the driver's pocket, just like knocking down trees does in Germany.

74 Sponge  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:35:57am

scott thomas is obviously a member of nancy pelosi's staff...

75 Killgore Trout  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:36:05am

Video: O’Reilly on JetKosBlue Update: Kos crows?

But go to the YearlyKos convention website, and you’ll note the JetBlue logo is still there, on the home page. And I’ve confirmed that yes, indeed, JetBlue isn’t going anywhere. They don’t plan on caving to pressure from the neanderthals at Fox News.

You'll notice the logo is now removed. As I suspect earlier; Jetblue didn't insist their logo stay up, Kos just refused to take it down. He probably received a nice Cease and Desist order from Jet Blue's lawyers.

76 Dianna  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:36:09am

Do you think they'll claim it's satire, and we're all too thick to get it?

In my case, that might be true, but not most of the rest of you.

77 pat  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:36:20am

#67 Kostya Lotz
As I remember it the articles in Der Spiegel were also falsified.

78 YourTaxDollarsAtWork  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:36:23am

re: #65 MandyManners

Don't know... can't commit to a yes or no decision, but it just struck me as odd.

79 NJDhockeyfan  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:36:49am

re: #38 Osama Bin Porkchop

OT...Rocket launcher found near Newark Airport...


[Link: wcbstv.com...]


Sources tell CBS 2 HD that it’s the kind of missile launcher that can take down an aircraft and that the area where the launcher was discovered is in or very near a flight path for Newark Liberty International Airport.

My mom lives near there.

80 Dave the.....  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:38:36am
Worked before with John F***ing Kerry. Why should in not work now?

Ahhh, until, oh let's say 1991 or so with Rush, 2000 and later with blogs, Fox News, etc. but before that, there was no alternative to your evening news, big city daily, and Time/newsweek.

The fake Dan Rather docs still wouldn't be exposed if things hadn't changed.

81 Cognito  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:38:45am

I think the writer probably heard stories like these from soldiers -- guys tell tall tales during downtime -- and instead of doing the honorable thing and checking them, TNR's writer forsook any responsibility whatsoever, and simply published it. Or, even more outrageously, maybe the guy just made up the whole ball of dung himself.

Glad the Weekly Standard and the blogs are onto it.

82 Sharmuta  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:38:47am

re: #24 MandyManners

re: #21 MandyManners

Or, better known as "fiction."

Also known as "propaganda".

83 MandyManners  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:38:49am

78 YourTaxDollarsAtWork

Well, she immediately called police.

84 mattm  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:39:44am

I doubt dogs will just stand there while a big truck comes at them. I would bet that dogs can move quicker than a Bradley.

85 Throbert McGee  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:39:53am

Oh, ARRGH.

I've been working at The New Republic since May -- on the business/ad side, I wish to stress, not in the editorial department. Nonetheless, I have to sit in on the weekly editorial meetings, and there was not a word uttered about this during yesterday's meeting, so I guess they weren't aware of the growing blowback yet.

86 TalkinKamel  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:40:14am

thank heaven---in this age of the Blogsphere, such lies aren't going to go unchallenged, and they can actually be disproved, rather than simply being dished out---and never disputed---by NBC, CBS, ABC, Life Magazine and Walter Cronkite ("The Most Trusted Man in America"---heh!)

These tales themselves just don't sound credible: as some commenters on the Blackfive website point out, a woman that severely burned would probably have been airlifted out---and, even if she stayed, It's highly doubtful that she'd have been allowed to eat out with the general public, badly injured as she was. And you'll note the writer doesn't give her name, or her rank, or anything; she's just some anonymous woman in a tan uniform. You really have to doubt a story with such vague details. As for the poor run over doggies. . . why would soldiers on a mission, in enemy territory, take the time and effort to kill random dogs? (Even if they were just sadistic brutes, which I really don't think they are.) I mean, even a sadistic brute could probably figure out that such behavior was dangerous, and likely to get him killed.

It's part urban legend, part "Winter Soldier/American Soldiers are Sadists!" agitprop.

87 MandyManners  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:40:32am

re: #82 Sharmuta

The best propaganda has a kernel of truth. This doesn't at all.

88 pat  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:40:48am

Missile Launcher story does not say if the launcher was used. Since it looked like a tube, I am assuming Russian type. But it might have taken it's shot already!

89 TalkinKamel  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:41:14am

#81 cognito

Trust me, he made the whole mess of BS up himself.

90 YourTaxDollarsAtWork  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:41:42am

re: #83 MandyManners

Good point. I'm going to be anxious to see how this develops, whether is some kind of bizzare frame up, or someone trying to take out a plane and finding out their equipment was bad, or whatever.

91 Dave the.....  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:41:55am

As someone said yesterday, the stories have meaness to puppies, disfigured women, dead children, etc.

All that's missing is a contribution to global warming. Maybe he left his Bradly vehicle idling and contributed to climate change.

92 Kaymad  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:42:04am

My husband and I were talking about this. He is at Camp Phoenix near Taji, About the disfigured woman in the chow hall, he said, and I quote: "but i really don't think a military member sitting in a chow hall would say such a thing because if he said it loud enough for others to hear, someone would have yanked his ass out of the chow hall."

About the skull---basically what others have said. An NCO or officer would have put his ass on the 5th floor of a psych hospital back in the states.

About the dogs: Number one, these aren't house pets we're talking about. Arabs don't keep dogs as pets. Often times they carry bombs, they also hide bombs in corpses. They use to shoot dogs because they carry diseases, rabies and sometimes bombs and they didn't want them near their camp, because at that time they had hardly any protection around them. He said now you see very few stray dogs.

93 Sharmuta  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:42:19am

re: #87 MandyManners

re: #82 Sharmuta

The best propaganda has a kernel of truth. This doesn't at all.

But these are neo-leftists. It feels true.

/AKA- Fake but accurate

94 Sharmuta  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:42:38am

re: #81 Cognito

I had a feeling we'd see you today.

95 YourTaxDollarsAtWork  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:43:17am

re: #85 Throbert McGee

Can you provide us a location or point of contact for the author/editor? You know, so I can show my 'support'.

96 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:43:25am
97 FrogMarch  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:44:10am

Smells like bullshit to me.

The left-wingers are tying to set up a Vietnam style loss in Iraq. When our Military become easy to vilify -- that opens doors for democrats.

98 bosforus  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:44:15am

re: #70 grumpy old codger

it reads like an over the top comic book, like dick tracy.

I saw her nearly every time I went to dinner in the chow hall at my base in Iraq. She wore an unrecognizable tan uniform, so I couldn't really tell whether she was a soldier or a civilian contractor. The thing that stood out about her...

it's so poorly written i almost want to believe it was written by a soldier and not some wannabe journalist, not that i think soldiers are bad writers ;)

99 grumpy old codger  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:44:18am

One of my battalion's patrols was hit by an IED that severely wounded the BSM and the turret gunner. The others in the vehicle were also injured but not as badly. Immediately after this event, the rest of the patrol found four Iraqis who tested positive for explosives. Additionally, they found part of the detonation device in the trash barrel where the four were arrested. Despite the fact that these four had just injured (not killed, but they didn't know that yet, due to fast action by the medic and the heli team) five of their fellow soldiers, the patrol handcuffed them and brought them to my aid station. It was my job to examine the detainees medically and, if necessary, to order photographs of any injuries. The men were not harmed by my soldiers during or after the arrest. Despite injuring our fellow GIs, the detainees were treated (in reality - no uniforms, etc.) much better than they deserved under the GC.

100 Dustyvet  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:44:39am

More Fake Veterans
Democrats keep putting forward fake veterans.

There was Micah Wright.

There was Jessie MacBeth--the army ranger who wasn't. Ironically, what tripped up MacBeth is what trips up lots of fake veterans--mistakes in wearing their uniforms.

Now Clare McCaskill seems to have been taken in by another lefty-fraud.

Josh Lansdale has done a lot talking this past year about his time in Iraq. And... Not a word of it is true!
Besides the articles written about Josh describing his days in Iraq, in September, Josh made a commercial for democrat Claire McCaskill against the Missouri Veteran's Administration and and Senator Jim Talent (Ad Here). Josh blamed Senator Talent for waits he endured at a VA Hospital. When asked, however, to justify those claims with appointment records, Josh became indignant and disappeared. Now, Josh is filming more angry veteran commercials, this time for votevets.org, a democratic anti-Iraq War organization headed by Wesley Clark. The ads are airing throughout the country in an effort to take down Republicans.


The publicity has drawn out the guys in his unit who wonder what the hell he's talking about...

When they aren't impersonating vets or embellishing their war records (a remarkable number of Democrat elected officials have embellished their war records and like the pederasts in the party, have no problem getting reelected), they're denigrating vets as losers, bullies, torturers and murderers

If you want to know why John Kerry's comments resonated to strongly--this is why.

[Link: www.uncorrelated.com...]

101 Cognito  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:45:01am

re: #94 Sharmuta

re: #81 Cognito

I had a feeling we'd see you today.

Not a tough prediction, that. I'm here most every day.

102 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:45:06am
103 Ben Hur  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:45:09am

re: #73 galloping granny

re: #62 Ed Mahmoud's Sock Puppet


Now banned lizard Rayra, at GCP, discussed how difficult it would be for a Bradley driver to target dogs this way.

This is Jon Carry style 'Jenjis Khan' style baby-killing porn for the LLL


Not to mention, unless things have changed greatly damage done to the Bradley due to misuse of government property while running over dogs as sport would come directly out of the driver's pocket, just like knocking down trees does in Germany.


Also, let's not forget - let's NOT forget, Dude - that keeping wildlife, an amphibious rodent, for uh, domestic, you know, within the city - that aint legal either.

Walter Sobchak

104 galloping granny  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:45:34am

re: #81 Cognito

I think the writer probably heard stories like these from soldiers -- guys tell tall tales during downtime -- and instead of doing the honorable thing and checking them, TNR's writer forsook any responsibility whatsoever, and simply published it. Or, even more outrageously, maybe the guy just made up the whole ball of dung himself.

Glad the Weekly Standard and the blogs are onto it.

Cognito, you are full of crap on this one. I spent every single night of my life for several years with a houseful of soldiers enjoying a little "down time" - tank unit, BTW - and never once heard tales like this. Descriptions of stage acts down in Frankfurt, comparisons of gun size, that kind of thing but never ONCE BS stories about running over dogs and never ONCE crap about how some poor SOB (male or female) looked after an injury.

105 Ed Mahmoud's Sock Puppet  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:46:24am

re: #85 Throbert McGee

Oh, ARRGH.

I've been working at The New Republic since May -- on the business/ad side, I wish to stress, not in the editorial department. Nonetheless, I have to sit in on the weekly editorial meetings, and there was not a word uttered about this during yesterday's meeting, so I guess they weren't aware of the growing blowback yet.


I'd be careful if I were you, mentioning place of work. I have a funny feeling someone seeing "Throbert McGee" could probably guess who you really are.

Are you as heart-broken as I am that LGF doesn't allow gaudily ostentatious weather updates anymore?

106 Ben Hur  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:46:51am

Cognito does have one point.

Reporters report what rumours they hear within the safety of their hotel.

107 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:46:55am
108 Dustyvet  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:46:58am

re: #100 Dustyvet

More Fake Veterans
Democrats keep putting forward fake veterans.

There was Micah Wright.

There was Jessie MacBeth--the army ranger who wasn't. Ironically, what tripped up MacBeth is what trips up lots of fake veterans--mistakes in wearing their uniforms.

Now Clare McCaskill seems to have been taken in by another lefty-fraud.

Josh Lansdale has done a lot talking this past year about his time in Iraq. And... Not a word of it is true!
Besides the articles written about Josh describing his days in Iraq, in September, Josh made a commercial for democrat Claire McCaskill against the Missouri Veteran's Administration and and Senator Jim Talent (Ad Here). Josh blamed Senator Talent for waits he endured at a VA Hospital. When asked, however, to justify those claims with appointment records, Josh became indignant and disappeared. Now, Josh is filming more angry veteran commercials, this time for votevets.org, a democratic anti-Iraq War organization headed by Wesley Clark. The ads are airing throughout the country in an effort to take down Republicans.


The publicity has drawn out the guys in his unit who wonder what the hell he's talking about...

When they aren't impersonating vets or embellishing their war records (a remarkable number of Democrat elected officials have embellished their war records and like the pederasts in the party, have no problem getting reelected), they're denigrating vets as losers, bullies, torturers and murderers

If you want to know why John Kerry's comments resonated to strongly--this is why.

[Link: www.uncorrelated.com...]

[Link: en.wikipedia.org...]

109 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:48:00am
110 anotherindyfilmguy  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:48:12am

I think this transcends fiction and goes straight to sedition/treason etc...

111 Cognito  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:48:30am

re: #104 galloping granny

re: #81 Cognito

I think the writer probably heard stories like these from soldiers -- guys tell tall tales during downtime -- and instead of doing the honorable thing and checking them, TNR's writer forsook any responsibility whatsoever, and simply published it. Or, even more outrageously, maybe the guy just made up the whole ball of dung himself.

Glad the Weekly Standard and the blogs are onto it.

Cognito, you are full of crap on this one. I spent every single night of my life for several years with a houseful of soldiers enjoying a little "down time" - tank unit, BTW - and never once heard tales like this. Descriptions of stage acts down in Frankfurt, comparisons of gun size, that kind of thing but never ONCE BS stories about running over dogs and never ONCE crap about how some poor SOB (male or female) looked after an injury.

Hey, it's no big deal -- guys do tell tall tales. I had a soldier tell me on an airplane two days ago that his branch forced a soldier to inhale a big pile of marijuana so they could test limits.

True? I can't say it's impossible. But it does sound like a tall tale, and the guy got a laugh out of telling it.

112 TalkinKamel  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:49:20am

#104 Galloping Granny

Heh, heh, heh. . . oh yes, soldiers just love to spend their time making up stories about how they go around killing poor lil' doggies, laughing at the wounded and wearing kids' schools---yeah. Right.

Ignore Cognito. He's a shill for the media, and, since Charles is running an article critical of the media, he's here to derail the thread.

113 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:49:32am
114 FrogMarch  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:49:47am

Remember folks: Precious left-wing progressives do not have to answer tough questions.

They are above criticism.
They are above the law.
They are allowed to lie.
They are allowed to propagandize.

115 Ed Mahmoud's Sock Puppet  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:49:48am

I've never been in a Army chow hall or mess tent or whatever they call them.


But my Dad, now deceased, told me stories about "SOS" from his days in the Army Air Force in WW2, and well, I have tried two different varieties of that back when I worked for Presidetn Reagan, one with creamed beef, another with beef in a thin tomato based sauce, and while I prefered the creamed beef, I didn't think either style was bad.

116 SlartyBartfast  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:50:07am

Regarding NJ Rocket Launcher...

I've been expecting this at Detroit Metro (DTW) for awhile.

/just sayin'

117 Dustyvet  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:50:16am

re: #108 Dustyvet

re: #100 Dustyvet


More Fake Veterans
Democrats keep putting forward fake veterans.

There was Micah Wright.

There was Jessie MacBeth--the army ranger who wasn't. Ironically, what tripped up MacBeth is what trips up lots of fake veterans--mistakes in wearing their uniforms.

Now Clare McCaskill seems to have been taken in by another lefty-fraud.

Josh Lansdale has done a lot talking this past year about his time in Iraq. And... Not a word of it is true!
Besides the articles written about Josh describing his days in Iraq, in September, Josh made a commercial for democrat Claire McCaskill against the Missouri Veteran's Administration and and Senator Jim Talent (Ad Here). Josh blamed Senator Talent for waits he endured at a VA Hospital. When asked, however, to justify those claims with appointment records, Josh became indignant and disappeared. Now, Josh is filming more angry veteran commercials, this time for votevets.org, a democratic anti-Iraq War organization headed by Wesley Clark. The ads are airing throughout the country in an effort to take down Republicans.


The publicity has drawn out the guys in his unit who wonder what the hell he's talking about...

When they aren't impersonating vets or embellishing their war records (a remarkable number of Democrat elected officials have embellished their war records and like the pederasts in the party, have no problem getting reelected), they're denigrating vets as losers, bullies, torturers and murderers

If you want to know why John Kerry's comments resonated to strongly--this is why.

[Link: www.uncorrelated.com...]


[Link: en.wikipedia.org...]

On Friday, May 18 2007, a criminal complaint was unsealed in the United States District Court in Seattle, Washington, charging Macbeth with one count of using or possessing a forged or altered military discharge certificate and one count of making false statements in seeking benefits from the Veterans Administration.[32] The complaint alleged that Macbeth posed as an Iraq war veteran and illicitly collected more than $10,400 in benefits.

On June 7, 2007, Macbeth pleaded guilty to one count of making false statements to the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs. He will be sentenced on September 21.[33]

118 MandyManners  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:50:19am

#90 YourTaxDollarsAtWork

Maybe a dry run to see how the authorities would react?

119 anotherindyfilmguy  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:50:24am

Kerry came out and said their was no bloodbath after the Vietnam War the other day... So when does he get at least unelected? What? He won't? Oh-I forgot that he's big Dem money and will only leave office as a corpse...

120 Police Commissioner Hakim H Hussein  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:50:49am

Hey, don't be so hard on THE NEW REPUBLIC. For a formerly occasionally interesting magazine now being edited by snotty 14-year-olds, it's doing a great job!

121 BabbaZee  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:50:50am

Men who have to kill for the sake of your continued living don't EVER tell asinine bullshit stories like these.
Trust me on that.

This is a Winter Soldier Redux agenda driven bullshitathon and it's right out of the commie playbook.

122 mrsoc  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:51:00am

re: #75 Killgore Trout

My word-their advertisers are like a list of the Enemies of America League. Teachers Union and all. Oy

123 Ed Mahmoud's Sock Puppet  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:51:10am

re: #115 Ed Mahmoud's Sock Puppet

I've never been in a Army chow hall or mess tent or whatever they call them.


But my Dad, now deceased, told me stories about "SOS" from his days in the Army Air Force in WW2, and well, I have tried two different varieties of that back when I worked for Presidetn Reagan, one with creamed beef, another with beef in a thin tomato based sauce, and while I prefered the creamed beef, I didn't think either style was bad.


SOS stands for "beef on toast", and is a popular breakfast item for government employees, in case you were wondering.

124 MandyManners  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:51:12am

#93 Sharmuta

HA! Thanks for the grim smile this morning.

125 TalkinKamel  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:51:14am

#94 Sharmuta

LOL! I was just about to do the Cognito Countdown, when, lo and behold, up he pops! What a shock! I'm shocked---SHOCKED, I tell you! (Heh, heh, heh.)

126 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:51:35am
127 pat  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:52:06am

To defend Cognito a bit, I have heard soldiers tell civies bullshit stories, but they were always the guys outside of the combat. On the other hand, this is not retold tales. This appears to be a moonbat's delusion of how all American soldiers are baby killers. Just like Kerry, who once got famous by lying, has now convinced himself that he actually was a soldier instead of a pretty boy who heard that 3 purples got you a ticket home.

128 Ed Mahmoud's Sock Puppet  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:52:31am

Newark was home to the Santa Claus sheikh, the spiritual leader of the people that killed Rabbi Kahane, killed a yeshiva student in a drive by shooting, and, oh yeah, bombed the WTC in 1993.

129 Cognito  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:52:39am

re: #112 TalkinKamel

#104 Galloping Granny

Heh, heh, heh. . . oh yes, soldiers just love to spend their time making up stories about how they go around killing poor lil' doggies, laughing at the wounded and wearing kids' schools---yeah. Right.

Ignore Cognito. He's a shill for the media, and, since Charles is running an article critical of the media, he's here to derail the thread.

Relax. I said the writer probably heard some stories and didn't bother to check them out -- or worse, he made them up from whole cloth. The small stuff could easily have originated from rumors. Not a crazy notion.

And I'm not shilling for anybody. Noticed I said TNR looks stupid here. And notice that the Weekly Standard is... drum roll... part of the media.

Don't try to twist what I've said.

130 BabbaZee  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:53:08am

yawn

131 TalkinKamel  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:53:46am

Should have said Kids' skulls, not schools, in my earlier post.

The point being that an American soldier parading around with a child's skull on his head (would it even fit?) is pretty unbelievable.

(Hey, even when the Kamel spells wrong, her heart's in the right place!)

132 Cognito  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:54:01am

re: #125 TalkinKamel

#94 Sharmuta

LOL! I was just about to do the Cognito Countdown, when, lo and behold, up he pops! What a shock! I'm shocked---SHOCKED, I tell you! (Heh, heh, heh.)

How impressive of you. Seeing how I show up pretty much daily.

133 Ed Mahmoud's Sock Puppet  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:54:15am

In boot camp, although I didn't really believe it too much, rumor went around about a square needle shot into the left testicle.

Never happened.


I did get a smallpox vaccination, but possibly because I had been vaccinated as a child, I got barely a blister. That was 25 years ago, I'm not sure how much immunity I would have left.

134 YourTaxDollarsAtWork  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:54:17am

re: #111 Cognito

I had a soldier tell me on an airplane two days ago that his branch forced a soldier to inhale a big pile of marijuana so they could test limits.

Still calling bullsh!t. Weed inhalation is a hell of a lot different than mocking an IED victim.

135 TalkinKamel  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:54:21am

#130 BabbaZee

(Double Yawn)

How's it goin' Babba?

136 Kostya Lotz  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:54:53am

re: #77 pat

Sooo, it's an Ouroboros. It gets a little deeper in the context of "the world".

137 Ed Mahmoud's Sock Puppet  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:55:13am

Cognito is a let less hysterical than Gordon is/was. I haven't seen a "shame on you, Charles" post from him yet.


That is a compliment, sort of.

138 galloping granny  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:55:43am

re: #133 Ed Mahmoud's Sock Puppet

In boot camp, although I didn't really believe it too much, rumor went around about a square needle shot into the left testicle.

Never happened.


I did get a smallpox vaccination, but possibly because I had been vaccinated as a child, I got barely a blister. That was 25 years ago, I'm not sure how much immunity I would have left.

About all of it. Unfortunately for humankind, any female that is still immune to smallpox is probably too old to bear children.

139 YourTaxDollarsAtWork  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:56:09am

re: #118 MandyManners

You think maybe flying imams style?

I'm still banking on someone trying to shoot down a plane and finding out it was dud.

140 BabbaZee  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:56:10am

re: #135 TalkinKamel

It goes. I try to keep up.
;~}

141 Cognito  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:56:23am

re: #134 YourTaxDollarsAtWork

re: #111 Cognito

I had a soldier tell me on an airplane two days ago that his branch forced a soldier to inhale a big pile of marijuana so they could test limits.
Still calling bullsh!t. Weed inhalation is a hell of a lot different than mocking an IED victim.

Nope. I find that part just as shocking as you do. I suspect the writer made it up totally, although I don't know just yet. No one does. Should be interesting to see the whole thing play out.

The writer's only redemption will be if he produces names of the soldiers he spoke with, and tapes of them talking.

142 jamil hussein  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:56:48am

re: #132 Cognito

How impressive of you. Seeing how I show up pretty much daily.

Impressive? Want to try a better word Mr. MSM. Prescient, maybe? Perceptive, perhaps?

143 TalkinKamel  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:57:09am

Uh-uh, I saw this coming---I thought, "cognito's gonna try and derail the thread by turning it into an argument over whether or not soldiers tell tall tales"---which my magical 8-ball subsequently confirmed. And, lo and behold, that's precisely what he's saying!

Next, he's going to complain that we're twisting what he's saying. Then his feeling are going to be hurt. Then, he's going to resort to snark.

144 pat  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:57:11am

Ed, Cog has earned a shame on you post from Charles. LOL

145 Cognito  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:57:12am

re: #142 jamil hussein

re: #132 Cognito


How impressive of you. Seeing how I show up pretty much daily.

Impressive? Want to try a better word Mr. MSM. Prescient, maybe? Perceptive, perhaps?

Huh. Impressive.

146 Just_A_Grunt  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:57:14am

The real story, for me in all of this, is how willing so many people are to believe this type of BS. For 90% of the people the closet they have come to actually experiencing anything remotely associated with the military is through the movies. When your points of reference are "Platoon", "Stripes", and "Apopcalypse Now" it is no wonder.
Whether it is Jeff Englehart with his wild stories of chemical weapons in Fallujah or Jesse MacBeth PX Ranger extraordinare, they are simply too many people with too little knowledge who just lap this stuff. It will find its' way into a speech on the floor of Congress and from then on it is fact.

147 Ben Hur  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:58:03am

The only time I've Israeli soldiers BS is when they want to get laid by American Jewish tourists.

"I'm heading up north to Lebanon on Sunday for 3 weeks, and might not come back. Will you spend my last night with me?"

And

"I can't tell you what I do in the army."

Guys who usually say this kind of shit are army chefs who do one week on, one week off, and get home by 12pm in the afternoon.

The special forces guys I know don't shvitz.

148 cookielady  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:58:23am

re: #138 galloping granny


Unfortunately for humankind, any female that is still immune to smallpox is probably too old to bear children.

There was a movie called 'Children of Men' which posed the problem of sudden mass infertility of women... gruesome.

149 amrilusaguy  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:58:26am

Hmmm

Isnt the new republic an easy way to get you rnew fiction stories out there so you can be published?

150 Ed Mahmoud's Sock Puppet  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:58:40am

Tropical Depression Cosme has finally reached the warmer water South of Hawaii, and should become a storm again shortly.


But no parties for Hawaii, it misses too far South, just wind gusts to 30 knots in passing squalls and locally heavy rain.

151 Cognito  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:58:42am

re: #143 TalkinKamel

Uh-uh, I saw this coming---I thought, "cognito's gonna try and derail the thread by turning it into an argument over whether or not soldiers tell tall tales"---which my magical 8-ball subsequently confirmed. And, lo and behold, that's precisely what he's saying!

Next, he's going to complain that we're twisting what he's saying. Then his feeling are going to be hurt. Then, he's going to resort to snark.

I'm sure you'll remember this little bit from my original post:

Or, even more outrageously, maybe the guy just made up the whole ball of dung himself.

Glad the Weekly Standard and the blogs are onto it.

152 Dar ul Harb  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:58:57am

re: #62 Ed Mahmoud's Sock Puppet


This is Jon Carry style 'Jenjis Khan' style baby-killing porn for the LLL

Winter Soldier all the way.

(and thanks Charles!)

153 Ben Hur  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:59:30am

Do you think he did it to make The New Republic look bad?

Or the soldiers?

154 BabbaZee  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:59:33am

re: #146 Just_A_Grunt

you are so right

155 JammieWearingFool  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:59:57am

re: #128 Ed Mahmoud's Sock Puppet

Newark was home to the Santa Claus sheikh, the spiritual leader of
the people that killed Rabbi Kahane, killed a yeshiva student in a
drive by shooting, and, oh yeah, bombed the WTC in 1993.


Omar Abdel Rahman

Lynne Stewart was his lawyer.

156 Cognito  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:00:11am

re: #146 Just_A_Grunt

The real story, for me in all of this, is how willing so many people are to believe this type of BS. For 90% of the people the closet they have come to actually experiencing anything remotely associated with the military is through the movies. When your points of reference are "Platoon", "Stripes", and "Apopcalypse Now" it is no wonder.
Whether it is Jeff Englehart with his wild stories of chemical weapons in Fallujah or Jesse MacBeth PX Ranger extraordinare, they are simply too many people with too little knowledge who just lap this stuff. It will find its' way into a speech on the floor of Congress and from then on it is fact.

I hope not. I hope people see though it.

157 GregInSeattle  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:00:27am

I can't wait for Iowahawk's parody of this insane leftwing smear on the troops.

158 Ojoe  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:00:33am

www.blackfive.net

This site will set it straight.

159 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:01:25am
160 cookielady  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:01:29am

re: #156 Cognito

I think a lot of them will see through this Kerrytale, as the folks here do. Others will believe what they want to believe, and will swallow the swill whole, and wholeheartedly. That's life and that's people, sadly.

161 Ed Mahmoud's Sock Puppet  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:01:44am

Well, with Baby #4 due on Halloween, if my wife became infertile, assuming the rest of the equipment still worked, I could probably handle it.


For that matter, if I catch the mumps now (how long does the vaccine last?) it wouldn't be a tragedy. Unless I developed complications and went blind, or deaf, or died.

Then I guess catching the mumps would be a tragedy.

162 MoonbatBane  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:02:04am

Went over to the swamps (KOs and DU), and didn't see a thing about this, either the original story or the mass fisking of it. Apparently, even the scum sucking moonbats over there weren't dumb enough to swallow this garbage...

163 Cognito  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:03:05am

re: #160 cookielady

re: #156 Cognito

I think a lot of them will see through this Kerrytale, as the folks here do. Others will believe what they want to believe, and will swallow the swill whole, and wholeheartedly. That's life and that's people, sadly.

That's what ticks me off about what those morons did at Abu Ghraib. It confirmed some people's worst suspicions about the military, and gives them license to believe whatever tale wafts up next.

164 vxbush  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:03:14am

re: #162 MoonbatBane

Went over to the swamps (KOs and DU), and didn't see a thing about this, either the original story or the mass fisking of it. Apparently, even the scum sucking moonbats over there weren't dumb enough to swallow this garbage...

Maybe not, but I can just see the MSM salivating at the chance to make the troops look bad, even if it's a lie. They never have to print retractions, you see.

165 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:03:37am
166 pat  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:03:57am

I don't listen to talk radio much, used to like Ingrahm but she is no longer here. But this is damn funny. Fellow named Boortz;
[Link: www.wnd.com...]

167 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:03:58am
168 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:04:16am
169 NJDhockeyfan  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:04:20am

OT:

Michael Moore vs. CNN

Let's be blunt: Michael Moore is one ungrateful leftist hack. CNN had showered him with three hours and 10 minutes of face time (repeats included) on "Larry King Live" and "The Situation Room," helping him sell his latest socialist film, "Sicko." That kind of attention would make a conservative drool. But when CNN aired a "fact check" piece on his documentary, adding a fraction of balance, he declared jihad, promising in a letter to be CNN's "worst nightmare."

170 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:04:28am
171 vxbush  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:04:43am

re: #164 vxbush

Maybe not, but I can just see the MSM salivating at the chance to make the troops look bad, even if it's a lie. They never have to print retractions, you see.

Clarification: the main three news broadcasters don't do retractions. The papers might, but they are often buried deep in the bush...

172 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:04:51am
173 pat  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:05:00am

Kerrytale. Love that. Can hardly wait till someone uses it in a debate.

174 JammieWearingFool  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:05:20am
175 tfc3rid  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:05:41am

Breaking Fox News Alert Email...

REPORT: FEDS INVESTIGATING ROCKET LAUNCHER FOUND AT A HOME NEAR FLIGHT PATH FOR NEW JERSEY'S NEWARK AIRPORT

176 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:05:59am
177 YourTaxDollarsAtWork  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:06:00am

re: #174 JammieWearingFool

YYYEEESSS!

178 Just_A_Grunt  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:06:12am

re: #166 pat

I don't listen to talk radio much, used to like Ingrahm but she is no longer here. But this is damn funny. Fellow named Boortz;
[Link: www.wnd.com...]

You have never heard of Neal "Fair Tax" Boortz? You don't know what you are missing. Go to his web site and read his comencment address and you will see why he never gets invited to give one.

179 Cognito  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:06:52am

I think the most damning thing about the story, for me, is that the guy was unwilling to write it under his real name. The only purpose there, that I can find, is to shield himself from the inevitable criticism.

Why? If he believes in the story, he should stand by it.

180 EC Marm  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:07:08am

re: #46 JammieWearingFool

Rocket launcher found in Jersey City
Planted by Republicans to whip up fear over the John Doe legislation.

Interesting, I think Cherry Hill and Pennsauken are the current epicenter of the Jersey Jihad. Speaking of the John Doe letdown, got a new "Blinking" Nancy Pelosi.

181 Cicero05  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:07:53am

What? No babies on pitchforks?

The New Republic is off its game.

182 Dar ul Harb  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:08:23am

The biggest thing that stinks to me about the Bradley dog grinder story (as a civilian) is that the guy would be exposing his buddies to increased risk from IEDs.

We might as well link to Kerry's "Winter Soldier" testimony.

Anyone got that link handy?

183 bosforus  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:08:26am

re: #156 Cognito

most of the anti-war lies that i've seen end up withering away. these war 'horror stories' rarely amount to anything.

184 GregInSeattle  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:08:32am

re: #175 tfc3rid

Good thing Jihadis are STUPID:

Federal investigators are examining what appears to be a military rocket launcher found Friday morning on the front lawn of a Jersey City home that sits directly in the flight path of busy Newark Liberty International Airport, CBS2 News reported.

185 EC Marm  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:08:49am

re: #178 Just_A_Grunt
Wasn't he the guy that wanted to label the homeless as "urban outdoorsmen?"

186 Wishing  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:08:58am

Truth is established by at LEAST two witnesses..not one jerk, sitting in his loft in Boston getting his jollies by writing ever more gruesome tales about OUR boys who are risking their lives daily for our safety.
Cowards on two fronts: TNR and their fake-named source.

187 realwest  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:08:59am

NO - I'm sorry y'all but I can't sit by and watch our troops be slandered like this the way we were slandered about our activities in Vietnam.
Unless New Republic comes up with this "soldier's" name, rank, service number, and unit currently attached to, I call absolute BULLSHIT on this story.
No name or other information I've requested then as far as I'm concerned it's nothing but a lie. And New Republic should be ashamed of itself, especially if they can't come up with the name, etc. I've asked for and damned if they have it and won't provide it.
John Kerry, under oath, in front of the US Senate told them lies about our behavior in Vietnam - I was there and never witnessed anything like what he was talking about on the scale he was professing to be true.
The Senate subcommittee gave Kerry a pass because of his medals - never pressed him for any serious details nor asked him why, as an officer, he violated his sworn duty to report these atrocities when he saw/became aware of them.
This is just another Kerry tall tale. And New Republic published it simply to hurt our troops.
Shame on them.

188 JammieWearingFool  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:09:27am

re: #180 EC Marm

re: #46 JammieWearingFool


Rocket launcher found in Jersey City
Planted by Republicans to whip up fear over the John Doe legislation.


Interesting, I think Cherry Hill and Pennsauken are the current
epicenter of the Jersey Jihad. Speaking of the John Doe letdown, got a
new "Blinking" Nancy Pelosi.

Most disturbing...

189 Sihlus  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:10:28am

re: #71 galloping granny

I have to tell you, I was an Army wife for a good long time. Never, anywhere, have I seen women treated with as much respect - no matter their age or appearance - than on a military base. Any military base. BTW, the same applies to dogs.

I hope you're not equating the two.

/Just kidding... Ow!

190 Cognito  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:10:50am

re: #183 bosforus

re: #156 Cognito

most of the anti-war lies that i've seen end up withering away. these war 'horror stories' rarely amount to anything.

The problem will come, as Just A Grunt noted, if the anti-war factions in Congress hold up this story as evidence of their suspicions. Merely holding it aloft on the congressional floor, for many people, will give it a patina of authenticity.

Although, after the breadth and depth of skepticism about this story, even Ted Kennedy might think twice before embracing it...

191 realwest  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:11:43am

re: #85 Throbert McGee
Hey, good to see you again! Can we assume that you'll make them aware of the blowback on this story?

192 NJDhockeyfan  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:12:04am

This could get interesting:

NBA IN A 'FIX'

July 20, 2007 -- THE FBI is investigating an NBA referee who allegedly was betting on basketball games - including ones he was officiating during the past two seasons - as part of an organized-crime probe in the Big Apple, The Post has learned.

The investigation, which began more than a year ago, is zeroing in on blockbuster allegations that the referee was making calls that affected the point spread to guarantee that he -- and the hoods who had their hooks in him -- cashed in on large bets.

A law enforcement official told the AP on the condition of anonymity that the referee was aware of the investigation and was planning to surrender next week.

The official said the bets involved thousands of dollars and were made on games during the 2005-2006 and the 2006-2007 seasons.

The NBA issued a brief statement: "We have been asked by the FBI, with whom we are working closely, not to comment on this matter at this time."

Federal agents are set to arrest the referee and a cadre of mobsters and their associates who lined their pockets, sources said.

"These are dangerous people [the referee] was involved with," a source said.

One source close to the probe counted the number of games on which the ref and his wiseguy buddies scored windfalls in the "double digits."

NBA Commissioner David Stern is aware of the investigation and has a report about the referee on his desk, another source said.

The official, whose name was withheld, allegedly wagered on games during the 2005-06 and 2006-07 NBA seasons.

James Margolin, an FBI spokesman, declined comment on the latest black eye for professional sports.

The sources indicated the referee apparently had a gambling problem, slipped into debt and fell prey to mob thugs.

"That's how he got himself into this predicament" by wagering with mob-connected bookies, one source said.

193 Just_A_Grunt  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:12:09am

re: #185 EC Marm

That's him

194 Cognito  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:12:42am

re: #191 realwest

re: #85 Throbert McGee
Hey, good to see you again! Can we assume that you'll make them aware of the blowback on this story?

Ha. They know. Their biggest competitor -- the Weekly Standard -- is leading the charge.

195 YourTaxDollarsAtWork  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:12:51am

re: #190 Cognito

If it's read into the congressional record, it must be true... Right?

196 eschew_obfuscation  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:13:02am
76 Dianna 7/20/2007 9:36:09 am PDT reply quote

Do you think they'll claim it's satire, and we're all too thick to get it?

In my case, that might be true, but not most of the rest of you.

They might well claim it's satire AFTER enough people raise a stink about it.

That's just the way the left floats ideas it knows won't be popular, but that it holds to be 'truth'.

It's just a variation on 'The Big Lie'...float it often enough and an increasing number of people will believe it, but if it makes the left look 'unhinged'...it's just satire...they didn't really mean it...calm down...you're exagerating.

197 Cognito  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:13:07am

re: #195 YourTaxDollarsAtWork

re: #190 Cognito

If it's read into the congressional record, it must be true... Right?

Right.

198 cookielady  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:13:14am

re: #190 Cognito

Although, after the breadth and depth of skepticism about this story, even Ted Kennedy might think twice before embracing it...

That will likely depend on how much Scotch has gone under the bridge...

199 Just_A_Grunt  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:14:02am

re: #190 Cognito

Although, after the breadth and depth of skepticism about this story, even Ted Kennedy might think twice before embracing it..

Can't say the same for Durbin or Murtha.

200 tfc3rid  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:14:15am

re: #192 NJDhockeyfan

Joey Crawford?

201 Ringo the Gringo  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:14:19am

OT - Malaysia bans mainstream media from reporting on Islamic state debate

KUALA LUMPUR, Malaysia: Malaysia's government has banned the mainstream media from reporting on the highly sensitive issue of whether the country is an Islamic state, an official said Friday.

Deputy Prime Minister Najib Razak sparked a storm last week when he declared that mostly Muslim Malaysia was not secular but an Islamic state that protects the religious rights of minority groups.

Government leaders, opposition parties, lawyers and activists condemned Najib's comment, saying Malaysia was set up as a secular state by the country's first leaders after independence from Britain in 1957.

The Internal Security Ministry issued a directive to all mainstream media to stop reporting on the issue, said a ministry official, who asked not to be named because of the sensitive nature of the issue.

"We want to stop this issue being aggravated into becoming a public debate as this will create tension," he told The Associated Press. "This is a very sensitive issue... As far as possible, we want to prevent (any racial) tension."

The official said the media are allowed to publish comments by Najib and Prime Minister Abdullah Ahmad Badawi but statements from anyone else should be disregarded.

"This debate will be never ending," he said, adding the ban was "for the sake of peace and harmony."

Any media outlet that violated the ban could be suspended, he warned.

202 YourTaxDollarsAtWork  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:14:50am

re: #198 cookielady

Ahh. Ted Kennedy and bridges. It's almost too easy...

203 pat  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:15:05am

#178 Just_A_Grunt
done

204 Spiny Norman  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:15:31am

re: #85 Throbert McGee

Oh, ARRGH.

I've been working at The New Republic since May -- on the business/ad side, I wish to stress, not in the editorial department. Nonetheless, I have to sit in on the weekly editorial meetings, and there was not a word uttered about this during yesterday's meeting, so I guess they weren't aware of the growing blowback yet.

Hey! Well now... you will keep us updated, won't you?

;^)

205 MarkTheGreat  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:15:31am

How much you want to be that this gets defended as another case of "fake but accurate".

After all even if this particular report turns out to be false, everybody knows that soldiers are viscious killers and would act like this if given the chance.

At least that's how our moral superious in the MSM view things.

206 tfc3rid  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:15:32am

Cognito...

Question for you.. Off topic a bit...

What's your take on the 'death' of the John Doe legislation?

207 ferris  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:16:47am

The God damn left in this country is so eager to defame the military they are willing to sell what little credibility they have to do it.

It just shows how out of touch they are with the military that this passes the smell test for them. Even if you allow that there are bad apples in every bunch, the idea that this is acceptable to a small number of troops is so far fetched as to be rediculous. And that's a key factor in these stories smear jobs...lots of soldiers saw and participated in each of them (all the better to tar the largest number of soldiers possible).

I admit I have never served and don't know a ton of military people but is it even remotely possible that no leaders stepped in let lone peers? The ones I have known (senior NCO and officer types) would have put their boot so far up this guys ass if they had seen any of this their foot would be sticking out of his mouth. One jackass? Sure, maybe. Dozens as this guy implies...nope, not in our military.

I really miss sedition laws.

208 RedPepper  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:16:50am

This is wildly OT, I know, but I thought some here might enjoy reading a comment John Podhoretz made on NR's The Corner today.

What Has Gone Wrong With This Country?

A Louisiana politician consorts with a hooker and we're all supposed to be outraged and call for his resignation? I am sorry, but this just goes too far. We're talking about Louisiana, for God's sake. A governor of Lousiana basically lived with a stripper in the governor's mansion a few decades ago! We're conservatives here. What about tradition?!?

209 Wishing  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:17:01am

re: #206 tfc3rid

Cognito...

Question for you.. Off topic a bit...

What's your take on the 'death' of the John Doe legislation?

lol..troublemaker lolol

210 Endangered in MASS  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:17:13am

Is Kerry an editor there?

211 bosforus  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:17:58am

re: #188 JammieWearingFool

Jersey City Police removed the launcher, and the incident is now being investigated by the Joint Terrorism Task Force and The Federal Bureau of Investigation.

can I sue the Joint Terrorism Task Force for wasting my tax money on investigating this case based solely on the suspicion of terrorism? i mean, come on, that rocket launcher could belong to my native american 80 year old neighbor

212 nyexpat  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:18:07am

re: #202 YourTaxDollarsAtWork

re: #198 cookielady

Ahh. Ted Kennedy and bridges. It's almost too easy...

Jeez, drown one secretary, and they haunt you for the rest of your life.

213 Cognito  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:18:21am

re: #206 tfc3rid

Cognito...

Question for you.. Off topic a bit...

What's your take on the 'death' of the John Doe legislation?

Hey, tfc3rid, somebody asked me that earlier. I said:


I'm still sorting through the details of it, but it seems to me that this opens up the possibility for CAIR and its counterparts to bully citizens into silence. Speak up at the airport? -- whammo. You risk lifelong poverty.

On the other hand, we already have laws addressing libel and slander. They'll probably suffice to keep CAIR, etc at bay. If you alert authorities to suspicious behavior and you're not maliciously trying to assassinate someone's character, you're standing on legal bedrock.

Just curious -- why do you ask?

214 Aladin Sane  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:18:41am

re: #205 MarkTheGreat

How much you want to be that this gets defended as another case of "fake but accurate".

I think you just nailed it.

215 Aladin Sane  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:22:07am

re: #213 Cognito

If you alert authorities to suspicious behavior and you're not maliciously trying to assassinate someone's character, you're standing on legal bedrock.

True, but it won't stop CAIR from threatening legal harrassment of people who do alert authorities.

216 tfc3rid  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:22:14am

re: #213 Cognito

Just wanted to see what your take on it was... I for one, am always curious and interested in what your take is... No other reason.

217 BabbaZee  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:22:38am

Big Lie is a propaganda technique, defined by Adolf Hitler in his 1925 autobiography Mein Kampf as a lie so "colossal" that no one would believe that someone "could have the impudence to distort the truth so infamously"

218 Dianna  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:22:54am

re: #147 Ben Hur

Reminding me distinctly of the Irish guys at the bars in San Francisco in the 80's, who would imply all sorts of activities and connections in order to get laid by the little American college girls.

It's nice to know that human nature is the same all over.

219 RJ_in_Reno  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:22:58am

Did you all here that Darth Vader...Um Dick Cheney will be acting Pres tomorrow while GW undergoes a colonoscopy? I can’t wait for the moonbats reaction.

220 Sharmuta  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:22:59am

re: #181 Cicero05

What? No babies on pitchforks?

The New Republic is off its game.

Isn't it interesting we hear about this from the msm, but not a peep about Baquba where we do have some facts.

221 Dianna  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:23:26am

re: #196 eschew_obfuscation

That's kind of what I thought.

222 BabbaZee  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:24:32am
223 grumpy old codger  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:24:33am

What's the difference between a fairy tale and a military exaggeration of fact?

The Fairy tale starts "Once upon a time..." and the military starts with "This is no BS..."

Com'n Ed tell'em what SOS really stands for! It's disgusting and thank God the new mess halls (now known as DFACs) offer a lot more choices.

Is it OK to for us to call all fairy tales kerrytales or should that be saved for these over-the-top war stories?

224 realwest  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:24:35am

re: #199 Just_A_Grunt
Indeed, John Fucking Murtha will read this into the Congressional Record first chance he gets.
Can't expect anything better from an Ex-Marine.

225 YourTaxDollarsAtWork  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:24:58am

re: #212 nyexpat

To paraphrase some old Dennis Miller:

"If teddy is such a ladies man, then why does it take him 9 hours to open a woman's door?"

and

"The Kennedy's might as well just name their next child 'Alleged'"

226 tfc3rid  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:25:27am

re: #219 RJ_in_Reno

That attack on Iran will begin 15 minutes into the Cheney Presidency...

/moonbat mode off...

Eh, no big deal...

227 BabbaZee  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:25:29am
228 Paul  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:26:08am

Where have we heard stories like this before? How about from a young Navy veteran testifying before Congress in 1971 where he stated that American soldiers:

...personally raped, cut off ears, cut off heads, taped wires from portable telephones to human genitals and turned up the power, cut off limbs, blown up bodies, randomly shot at civilians, razed villages in a fashion reminiscent of Genghis Khan, shot cattle and dogs for fun, poisoned food stocks, and generally ravaged the countryside of South Vietnam.

We all know who that veteran is.

229 Dianna  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:26:12am

re: #161 Ed Mahmoud's Sock Puppet

I got the mumps at the age of 28. I was vaccinated in 3rd grade, like everyone else; so that immunity can wear off.

It was embarassing.

230 BabbaZee  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:26:14am
231 RedPepper  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:26:19am

re: #217 BabbaZee

Why, Babba! You sound like you're criticizing here! You are talking about the foundational principal of the Moonbat Media™.

232 YourTaxDollarsAtWork  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:26:20am

re: #226 tfc3rid

We can only hope...

233 BabbaZee  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:26:52am
234 reloadingisnotahobby  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:27:06am

re: #225 YourTaxDollarsAtWork
Gotta love Dennis...
Those are excellent...Most acurate too!

235 BabbaZee  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:27:56am

re: #231 RedPepper

I am the Big Lie's sworn enemy.

236 Clubbeaux  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:28:28am

Sad to see, they were one of the few respectable liberal news outlets left.

237 MrC_5150  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:28:59am

Well, there is this video of US Troops taunting some Iraqi kids:

Got Water?

239 BabbaZee  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:30:31am
240 reloadingisnotahobby  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:31:18am

re: #237 MrC_5150Damn! Iwanted the little Olympiad to get it!

241 BabbaZee  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:31:42am
242 RedPepper  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:32:20am

re: #235 BabbaZee

Sigh. You just won't behave, will you ...

Here Babba. This one's for you.

“Let them call me rebel, and welcome; I feel no concern from it. For I should suffer the misery of devils, were I to make a whore of my soul.” -- Thomas Paine

243 galloping granny  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:33:37am

re: #213 Cognito

re: #206 tfc3rid

Cognito...

Question for you.. Off topic a bit...

What's your take on the 'death' of the John Doe legislation?

Hey, tfc3rid, somebody asked me that earlier. I said:



I'm still sorting through the details of it, but it seems to me that this opens up the possibility for CAIR and its counterparts to bully citizens into silence. Speak up at the airport? -- whammo. You risk lifelong poverty.On the other hand, we already have laws addressing libel and slander. They'll probably suffice to keep CAIR, etc at bay. If you alert authorities to suspicious behavior and you're not maliciously trying to assassinate someone's character, you're standing on legal bedrock.

Just curious -- why do you ask?

I see just one little thing wrong with that Cognito. It costs big bucks to defend yourself against a libel or slander suit. Most people don't have the skills to defend themselves and lawyers don't work for free.

I can tell you right now that if we did not have a Good Samaritan law on the books absolving medical people (and others) from any harm due to trying to render assistance at an accident scene our roads would be littered with dead. Nobody would risk their medical license.

And nobody is going to risk their house either. People just won't fly -

244 BabbaZee  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:34:27am

The Arafat I Knew
He hasn't changed since his days as a KGB-backed terrorist.
by ION MIHAI PACEPA


The point of all this stuff I am posting is tha this shit does not happen organically, even if useful idiots are the apparent perps. Actually it is optimal if they are idiots as far as the pamphlet makers are concerned.

In the case of Kerry believe me he was and is fully conscious of what he did and continues to do.

245 BabbaZee  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:34:42am

re: #242 RedPepper

AMEN!

246 NomadOfNorad  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:35:23am

OT:

To crosspost what I just said in the discussion about the removal of the John Doe protection amendment:

Well, Limbaugh's substitute teacher today has stated that there's still time to save the John Doe provision. The House and Senate must now get together, since one group's version of the bill still has the provision, and they must hash out a bill both sides can vote for.

If we bombard them with calls, faxes, emails, and visits telling them that this John Doe protection matter MUST stay in the bill, it might have a positive effect on this matter.

247 NY Nana  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:36:08am

‘Operation Ithaca’ Surprises, Pummels, al Qaeda Forces

Find that in the MSM..

Hat tip: YozhikVTumane

248 realwest  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:36:36am

re: #237 MrC_5150 Yup, that sure was an atrocity, wasn't it? Surprised the vehicle didn't back up and run the kid over.
What was your point (assuming you had one) in posting that?

249 realwest  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:39:15am

re: #247 NY Nana Thanks for posting that.

250 Cognito  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:42:00am

re: #243 galloping granny

And nobody is going to risk their house either. People just won't fly -

Let's hope not -- that's the best way to get something done in a free market. Vote with your wallet.

Unless there's a big example held up -- maybe the flying Imams, but likely something even more blatant -- people won't even be aware. They'll just keep flying as usual.

251 Cognito  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:45:49am

re: #237 MrC_5150

Well, there is this video of US Troops taunting some Iraqi kids:

Got Water?

Well. That's pretty depressing. Really disgusting. I'm ashamed of those soldiers.

252 mrsoc  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:47:35am

re: #161 Ed Mahmoud's Sock Puppet

Well, with Baby #4 due on Halloween, if my wife became infertile, assuming the rest of the equipment still worked, I could probably handle it.


For that matter, if I catch the mumps now (how long does the vaccine last?) it wouldn't be a tragedy. Unless I developed complications and went blind, or deaf, or died.

Then I guess catching the mumps would be a tragedy.

If you were born before 1957 you are considered immune by CDC.
The other criteria are as follows:
# They have documentation of receipt of 1 dose of live mumps vaccine on or after 12 months of age; or
# They have documentation of physician-diagnosed mumps disease; or
# They have documentation of laboratory testing which indicates immunity
Also
about 1 out of every 4 teenage or adult males with mumps will have a painful swelling of the testicles for several days. This usually does not make a person sterile and unable to father children
Do not consider mumping to be a birth control method. :)

253 MrMom  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:51:44am

Ed M
I am CRUSHED about the limits on your font/color. I loved those updates.
Also, I received the shot in the left testicle with the square needle at boot. How'd you get out of it?

/

254 Rugby the Rat  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:52:06am

re: #204 Spiny Norman

Hey! Well now... you will keep us updated, won't you?

;^)

hi my name is RUGBY and i used to be a rat but now i am a GHOST of a dead rat (but plz dont worry i will not kill you like that drippy hair girl from "The Rinbg"! not all ghosts ar e evil)

here is a picture to prive that i am an actual rat?!

anyway throbert and i used to be roommates & although he is a homo he cooked very good food and was very knid to rats. SO! out of my extreem niceness, i have retruned from byond the grave to give Throbret my LFG log-in pswd so he wont get in trouble w/ the job. now i am going back to rat heaven to have SEX with lady rats (b/c i am not a homo).

kthxbye!

RUBGY

ps. plz dont write homo stuff about wieners under my name?!?
pps. charls i curse you for taking awya my red monospacE! it was prettier

255 MrMom  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:53:06am

Oh yeah...
Good afternoon Lizards!
'specially you Babba. Still love ya. Smoooch.

256 Hard Right  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:54:17am

Major, massive, BS. Saw the comments of soldiers in the know.

257 MKelly  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:58:23am

Maybe the dog part of the stories are about MVick.

Seriously, if true this would indicate not only a total breakdown in moral fabric of a group of young enlisted men, but also the break down of the chain of command. No sgt or Lt. would allow the antics these tails speak of.

Wearing a part of a skull on top of your head under a helmet, come on.

258 realwest  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 11:06:34am

re: #251 Cognito But it's a looong way from that to actual atrocities; as I asked above, I wonder why MrC_5150 posted that, especially on this thread.

259 Mostly Annoyed  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 11:06:44am

re: #14 cbinflux


Note: Two articles posted yesterday pointed out that journalists can and do tell truths as they see them,; their under no obligation to tell THE truth.


I really find it disgusting that they claim to be "unbiased" in their reporting and to only report the truth when they also state that it is their "obligation as human beings" do do anything they can to get us out of any war and get Bush out of office.

They talk about all the lies the Bush administration has used to to get us into the war, and refuse to report on the evidense that most of those "lies" have been proven to be true. Of course they are obligated to lie in order to further their political agenda. Where are the morals they claim to have? Who is teaching them to be good honest reporters? Those unbiased teachers who are hired to teach how to lie and cheat in order to further their agenda.

When you ask teachers why they work for such low pay, the always say they enjoy molding the future generations... They should be teaching not molding, but you may notice the majority of university teachers lean far to the left. They are willing to sacrifice their present for a future of their making. Sounds a lot like the radical islamists, they are just willing to go a little further. However, if they don't see things going their way, they will take more and more lessons from radical inslam to further their agenda at any cost.

I was subjected to radical left wing teachers when I was at university, but I learned to agree with them untill the class was over so I could pass the course and forget 90% after that. There are good teachers, but a majority were pushing their political agenda. It made me sick that I was paying good money for someone to try to brainwash me and not to educate me. This was 20 years ago, and it's worse today.

They should not be allowed to put our children through this crap

260 Cognito  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 11:10:00am

re: #258 realwest

re: #251 Cognito But it's a looong way from that to actual atrocities; as I asked above, I wonder why MrC_5150 posted that, especially on this thread.

I assume he posted it because of the thread subject -- the veracity of stories about cruelty by soldiers.

Like I said, I'm ashamed of the guys in that video. But I don't think they're representative. When you deploy enough men, you're bound to find a few bad ones in there somewhere.

261 BabbaZee  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 11:12:48am

re: #255 MrMom

MWAH

Gotta go!

be well Lizardim

262 Old Tanker  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 11:14:56am

Check out the various milblogs that have already been mentioned, they're shredding this story.

As a former NCO and combat veteran the whole thing doesn't past the smell test. These things couldn't happen without an NCO or an officer seeing it and it would have been stomped on, immediately.

263 Rugby the Rat  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 11:16:36am
re: #191 realwest

re: #85 Throbert McGee
Hey, good to see you again! Can we assume that you'll make them aware of the blowback on this story?

Ha. They know. Their biggest competitor -- the Weekly Standard -- is leading the charge.

Now that I'm cleverly disguised as a ghostly rodent, I can say that there is some irony on the business side, because TNR has been trying to develop some co-branded stuff with The Weekly Standard (the idea being to sell a 2-for-1 "balanced package" deal to advertisers who otherwise might not run ads in either publication because they wish to remain politically neutral).

Also, there's a staff party tonight -- I wonder if this will be a topic of conversation.

I just watched Shattered Glass a few days ago -- looking for pro-TNR dialogue to use in a multimedia presentation! (There's actually a good line where Chloe Sevigny says "You write for The New FUCKING Republic!") Anyway, after watching the movie, I went and looked up some of the Stephen Glass pieces in the hardbound back issues from 1998 -- one of them described a "right-wing strategist" who was trying to start a rumor that Bill Clinton was a FTM lesbian transsexual...

264 Dustyvet  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 11:22:06am

re: #115 Ed Mahmoud's Sock Puppet

I've never been in a Army chow hall or mess tent or whatever they call them.


But my Dad, now deceased, told me stories about "SOS" from his days in the Army Air Force in WW2, and well, I have tried two different varieties of that back when I worked for Presidetn Reagan, one with creamed beef, another with beef in a thin tomato based sauce, and while I prefered the creamed beef, I didn't think either style was bad.

We call them Mess Halls...:)

Dustyvet
United Sates Army Veteran
Vietnam 1967-68
Desert Shield/Desert Storm 1991

ARMY CREAMED CHIPPED BEEF...:p IN THE WORDS OF BILL THE CAT ACKFTT! SOS!:p
C-RATION HAM AND EGGS CHOPPED, ONLY FOOD I HAVE EVER SEEN THAT'S OD GREEN WHEN YOU OPEN THE CAN...:p

265 Hard Right  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 11:28:13am

re: #257 MKelly

Maybe the dog part of the stories are about MVick.

Seriously, if true this would indicate not only a total breakdown in moral fabric of a group of young enlisted men, but also the break down of the chain of command. No sgt or Lt. would allow the antics these tails speak of.

Wearing a part of a skull on top of your head under a helmet, come on.

A couple soldiers who had been at that very "chow hall" had never seen such a woman. Plus it was stated that there was almost always an officer in earshot due to it's size. Not to mention, would you as a soldier make fun of someone who might be an officer?

Here's the link.
[Link: www.weeklystandard.com...]

266 lawhawk  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 11:31:47am

CY weighs in on this situation and asks some pointed questions of TNR. I doubt that they'll have satisfactory answers. Linky.

267 Ed Mahmoud's Sock Puppet  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 11:36:21am

Hey, Lawhawk only mentioned Lynn Stewart in the Santa Claus Sheikh trial:


Defendants: Sheik Omar Abdel Rahman, El Sayyid Nosair, Ibrahim El-Gabrowny, Victor Alvarez, Amir Abdelgani, Fadil Abdelghani, Tarig Elhassan, Ramzi Ahmed Yousef, Rodney Hampton-El, Fares Khallafalla, and Mohammed Saleh
Crimes Charged: All defendants: Seditious conspiracy; Nosair: Murder and assault; individual charges included solicitation and conspiracy to commit assassination or bombings, violations of the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations (RICO) Act, and weapons charges
Chief Defense Lawyers: Lynne F. Stewart, John Jacobs, Ramsey Clark, and Anthony Ricco

I guess one should expect Clark to be defending the people that assassinated Jews and tried to blow up the WTC.

268 TalkinKamel  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 11:38:21am

#248 realwest

He posted it to try and get us to believe that American soldiers commit atrocities on a regular basis, so we should just shut up and listen to the New Republic, and believe whatever it tells us.

Ignore him/it.

#254 Rugyby the Rat

{Rugby!}

269 Rugby the Rat  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 11:38:25am

Incidentally, I just want to underscore that I have no involvement with editorial decisions whatsoever -- although right now, for my employer's sake, I sure wish I'd seen this "Baghdad Diarist" piece before they ran it. (I've never served, but as a grown-up military brat, I sure would've been skeptical of the story.)

270 cbinflux  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 11:46:52am

re: #79 NJDhockeyfan

Memphis PD found one of those under a bridge here. Said that they were throwaway launchers, No Big Deal...

271 hippieforlife  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 11:50:34am

re: #75 Killgore Trout

Boy, Kos's diary on the Jet Blue back down is the best laugh I have had in a long time! O'Reilly's point about DKos was the hate language there.
One of the first comments is "f*ck JetBlue".

They are just so predictable. Not to mention totally blind to any fault on their part.

272 Old Tanker  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 11:50:37am

re: #264 Dustyvet

They were mess halls when I was in and mess tents when I was in Desert Storm/Sheild. Now they all call them DFAC's (pronounced Deefac)

273 witwwats  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 11:53:28am

Final Word: Didn't happen.

These idiots would have you believe that this happened, unchallenged, in a public area. That thinking is predicated on the fallacy that soldiers "revert" (?) "devolve"(?) or some other such idiocy, into feral creatures with no morals. That can happen, but not for everyone, all at the same time. If such an incident happened in MY presence or, for that matter, in the presence of 90% of the G.I. s I served with, the culprits would be missing a few teeth and a large portion of their dignity.

The New Republic printed an unsupportable Fairy Tale, slandered our military, and pocketed the profit, period.

274 Cognito  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 11:54:01am

re: #272 Old Tanker

re: #264 Dustyvet

They were mess halls when I was in and mess tents when I was in Desert Storm/Sheild. Now they all call them DFAC's (pronounced Deefac)

Ha. The military never met an acronym it didn't like...

275 Hard Right  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 11:54:51am

re: #237 MrC_5150

Well, there is this video of US Troops taunting some Iraqi kids:

Got Water?

Yeah, that is absolute proof that the lies, er, claims are true. Idiot.

276 TalkinKamel  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 11:57:37am

#275 Hard Right

Yes, it's proof, absolute proof that the lies---uh, claims, are true! Because a few American soldiers acting badly (not even committing real atrocities) is proof---PROOF, I tell you, that everything anybody says bad about them is true! so just shut up and believe the media already!

/Sarc. off.

277 Cognito  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 11:59:00am

re: #276 TalkinKamel

#275 Hard Right

Yes, it's proof, absolute proof that the lies---uh, claims, are true! Because a few American soldiers acting badly (not even committing real atrocities) is proof---PROOF, I tell you, that everything anybody says bad about them is true! so just shut up and believe the media already!

/Sarc. off.

Ah, don't forget it's a member the media -- the Weekly Standard -- who is kicking TNR hardest for this crap.

278 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 12:03:43pm
279 Old Tanker  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 12:11:58pm

re: #274 Cognito

How true, how true,

you got your DFAC's, your Tangos, your Charlie Foxtrots, FOB's, alpha-alpha's, pick up some Class1, class2, and don't forget the Class 6!

280 Cognito  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 12:13:42pm

re: #278 taxfreekiller

within words, meaning.

"When "YOU", deploy men, some of them are going to be bad"
From the mind of an elite, who knows he will not be, nor has
ever been "deployed", its the "those people" thinking.

so, when the judgment comes for the lies and fraud of the msm
could be the judgment will be for the bad and the enablers too

Within words, a total lack of meaning.

The second-person 'you' is commonly accepted in modern language as the general pronoun 'one.'

And if you were anything resembling an honest commentator, you would have noticed I wrote:


Like I said, I'm ashamed of the guys in that video. But I don't think they're representative. When you deploy enough men, you're bound to find a few bad ones in there somewhere.

I wrote "I" because I'm an American.

281 Cognito  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 12:15:16pm

re: #279 Old Tanker

re: #274 Cognito

How true, how true,

you got your DFAC's, your Tangos, your Charlie Foxtrots, FOB's, alpha-alpha's, pick up some Class1, class2, and don't forget the Class 6!

Ha, that's right. So I guess it's SNAFU.

282 opnion  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 12:30:14pm

You have to understand that the Left misses Viet Nam.
Some of the comparisons are tortured logic.
THey really want to demonize the troops just as Kerry and Jane Fonda did just to name a couple, cheered on by the MSM of the time.
THe elite convgentiona lwisdom at that time was that the troops were either baby killers or victims.
When you hear one say "I support the troops but..."
I believe the appropriate rsponse is"No you don't.Why pretend?"
Thats when they scream "Don't question my patriatism!"

283 Arbalest  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 12:44:09pm

How long is the customary waiting period for proof / explanations / spin from mighty journalists?

Is Monday, 23 July 2007, 11:45AM, a reasonable time limit?

It will be interesting to see if any of the editors at The New Republic are “let go”, or otherwise leave (but with very good and convincing reasons) due to the “Shock Troops” piece.

Free “Scott Thomas”.

284 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 12:46:01pm
285 kcladderman  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 12:46:22pm

#133
Ah yes i remember the square needle story from Great Lakes.
Just one of many mess deck rumors.

286 CDRSalamander  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 12:49:15pm

Fiction. Here, and here is all you need to know.

287 Ed Mahmoud's Sock Puppet  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 12:58:56pm

re: #285 kcladderman

#133
Ah yes i remember the square needle story from Great Lakes.
Just one of many mess deck rumors.


Are you with the KCMO FD?


Just guessing, based on the nic.

288 Old Tanker  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 1:01:57pm

CDRSalamander, good to see you. I had read the pieces by Greyhawk already. I thought about the "story tellers" I knew from my experience with Desert Storm/Shield but then this guy even blows some of the "lingo" which makes me even more leary...

289 kcladderman  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 1:08:24pm

Ed
Yes I am . Rescue 9

290 Hard Right  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 1:15:09pm

re: #282 opnion

You have to understand that the Left misses Viet Nam.
Some of the comparisons are tortured logic.
THey really want to demonize the troops just as Kerry and Jane Fonda did just to name a couple, cheered on by the MSM of the time.
THe elite convgentiona lwisdom at that time was that the troops were either baby killers or victims.
When you hear one say "I support the troops but..."
I believe the appropriate rsponse is"No you don't.Why pretend?"
Thats when they scream "Don't question my patriatism!"

Earler today I saw where Kerry tried to deny reality yet again.

"There was not a massive bloodbath in Vietnam. There were reeducation camps, and they weren't pretty and, you know, nobody, you know, likes that kind of outcome... "

"The Navy itself has said that every single one of the medals that I was awarded I deserved and they were appropriately awarded to me, and I'm proud of what I accomplished there personally as a warrior on behalf of my country. And it is a shameful tactic that Republicans see fit to attack the personal record of those who serve our country. Moreover, none of those wounds were self-inflicted, and I resent and will forever resent the implication by anybody that that was, uh, er, uh the fact. There were soldiers on my body, sailors on my boat. Every one of my crew has certified that what happened, happened, uh, and it was thoroughly vetted. So enough of this Republican smear tactic. With respect to, uh, uh, the visits, uh, to the Vietcong, uh, please, ma'am, I fought against the, uh, uh, communists in Vietnam -- and when I came back, after having seen the lies that our government told, uh, I stood up and told the truth about that war."

291 NomadOfNorad  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 1:16:56pm

re: #100 Dustyvet

I think these fake soldiers should have articles on them at MediaMythBusters, describing all the background of them, the lies they've told, and why they shouldn't be taken seriously.

292 hippieforlife  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 1:18:52pm

If these people would just read a daily newspaper they would find out that there are more criminals living next door than there are soldiers committing terrible crimes.

Daily we see stories about missing women, college coeds, children being sexually attacked and murdered.

This story is just that, a story; or, as another here noted "Kerrytales".
This story also serves no purpose other than propaganda. Pitiful.

293 Beagle  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 1:51:29pm

What's weird is how completely fake it all sounds unless you grew up believing the phony accuastions which came out of Winter Soldier. "Thomas" hits all the standard themes. The writing is just like Jesse MacBeth. He was well on to a career doing interviews with college radio, progressives, and so on. Oops, he was a total fraud.

294 Dar ul Harb  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 1:55:54pm

re: #266 lawhawk

Loved this comment at Confederate Yankee:

Tehran - Mr. Owens;

As you know I am a very, very busy man, but I manage to cover a lot of territory in Iraq. I can assure you that the incidents reported in TNR are, absolutely, categorically, 100% the truth. How, you may ask, do I know this. I was an eyewitness for each of the incidents described. Surely my word is good enough to vouch for the accuracy of the statements.

If you need any more information, please contact me through the Associated Press. They are the only ones who know how to get in touch with me.
Posted by: Jamil Hussein at July 20, 2007 10:46 AM

295 Dar ul Harb  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 2:13:09pm

This comment at Hot Air was pretty good, too:


I’d like to join the loud and thunderous calls of bullshit. This is pure lefty warporn. Liberals “support the troops” so much that they make up stories like this to smear them. How do you have somebody in a DFAC [Dining FACility] in a uniform that you can’t even identify as civilian or military? Probably because she’s a member of the armed forces of Madeupistan.

ReubenJCogburn on July 18, 2007 at 11:29 PM

296 NomadOfNorad  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 2:29:51pm

re: #295 Dar ul Harb

Hehe! Good one! :-D

297 itellu3times  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 4:16:16pm

re: #219 RJ_in_Reno

Did you all here that Darth Vader...Um Dick Cheney will be acting Pres tomorrow while GW undergoes a colonoscopy? I can’t wait for the moonbats reaction.

What is the proper mode of celebration, shotgun a lawyer?

298 kevinmumaw  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 4:45:33pm
Someone reached down and picked a shell casing up off the ground. It was 9mm with a square back. Everything suddenly became clear. The only shell casings that look like that belong to Glocks. And the only people who use Glocks are the Iraqi police.

This is an excerpt from "Scott Thomas." It is complete BS to anyone who even has a passing familiarity with 9mm ammo. The Glock 17 fires the same kind of 9mm ammo as the M9 Beretta, the same as my HK USP 9mm, the same as my buddy's Springfield XD 9mm, etc, etc. I have 9mm Luger hollow points for self-defense, 9mm parabellum for target shooting (its cheaper.) What is happening to this generation of journalists? Why do they feel the need to lie if they are so sure they are right? Rhetorical question, but still...

299 Cognito  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 5:24:37pm

re: #298 kevinmumaw

What's weird is that the guy who wrote that is, apparently, a soldier.

300 MrC_5150  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 5:38:22pm

re: #260 Cognito

re: #258 realwest

re: #251 Cognito But it's a looong way from that to actual atrocities; as I asked above, I wonder why MrC_5150 posted that, especially on this thread.

I assume he posted it because of the thread subject -- the veracity of stories about cruelty by soldiers.

Like I said, I'm ashamed of the guys in that video. But I don't think they're representative. When you deploy enough men, you're bound to find a few bad ones in there somewhere.

I should have added a sarcasm tag. Didn't mean to raise a fuss over what I considered the worst you'll probably find in the military. Just an occasional jerk here and there and that's about it. I'm sure these couple guys were just trying to lighten things up a little bit.

301 Perplexed  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 5:52:00pm
The article makes it sound like the BFV (Bradley Fighting Vehicle) is some sort of Klingon warship with a clocking device and a sound silencer, capbale of sneaking up on sleeping dogs and running them over before they can get up and move the 2 feet they'd have to get out of the way.

Shhh, you're giving away our best secrets. All of our troops now have complete invisibility capabilities. The USAF now flies a stealthy Bird of Prey, with complete cloaking/transporter/photon torpedoes/phaser/disrupter technologies.

/tongue in cheek.

302 mean Gene  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 6:31:24pm

The New Republic editor writes:


Several conservative blogs have raised questions about the Diarist "Shock Troops," written by a soldier in Iraq using the pseudonym Scott Thomas. Whenever anybody levels serious accusations against a piece published in our magazine, we take those charges seriously. Indeed, we're in the process of investigating them. I've spoken extensively with the author of the piece and have communicated with other soldiers who witnessed the events described in the diarist. Thus far, these conversations have done nothing to undermine--and much to corroborate--the author's descriptions. I will let you know more after we complete our investigation.

--Franklin Foer
[Link: www.tnr.com...]

This ought to be interesting.

303 kevinmumaw  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 6:32:12pm

Apparently a solodierre: #299 Cognito

re: #298 kevinmumaw

What's weird is that the guy who wrote that is, apparently, a soldier.

Here is something that has been bothering me...why would a "solider" such as Scott Thomas who embraces every personality trait so despised by the left, why would he be submitting stories to a liberal magazine such as The New Republic? Presumeably, "Scott Thomas" is not the kind of guy that gets junk mail from the DNC and Shamnesty International, yet he sees fit to submit his war stories to The New Republic? Just a tad bit convenient, no?

304 taxfreekiller[deleted]  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 8:03:59pm
305 Cognito  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 8:43:06pm

re: #304 taxfreekiller

Bad habit of late, flip channels trying to find reality, landed on the low worm Bill Moyers, none of them lower than that, lied for pay for LBJ the worlds worst liar, the king kong of liars, then he spends the rest of his life retelling the same on dead on arrival lies and now he digs deep into his self loathing caused by working for the evil LBJ and launches into full amnesty mode thinking that will end freedom and justice faster and bring the commie world to him before father time does what must be done.

Then it came, could be Cognito is a producer of the Bill Moyers show, or should he prove to be even more deceitful Bill Moyers is Congnito.

just thinking of low things, and its late and the msm and their enablers make my ass want a dip of snuff

I cannot tell you how amazing I find it that you, while flipping channels on your television late at night, are thinking of me. It's so bizarre that it's actually likable.

And yes. I am Bill Moyers.

306 whiskey rebel  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 9:02:16pm

A guy puts a child's skull on his head like a crown and it's a "perfect fit"? He would have to have a head the size of a grapefruit. The entire article smacks of leftist fantasy. If any of TNR's editors had any military experience, which I highly doubt, he would have flagged it as Glassery by the second paragraph.

307 Rugby the Rat  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:04:54pm

re: #302 mean Gene

The New Republic editor writes:

Several conservative blogs have raised questions about the Diarist "Shock Troops"...

--Franklin Foer
[Link: www.tnr.com...]

This ought to be interesting.

WELL, I just got back from a party at Mr. Foer's house (saying goodbye to Senior Editor Ryan Lizza, who's gotten snatched up by the New Yorker), and his off-the-record, private spin was exactly the same as the public statement: it's "conservative blogs" that are raising questions about the story. It was really painful because it was just not my position to say, "actually, Frank, you're wrong -- there are military people arguing credibly that 'Scott Thomas' is unacquainted with how military culture actually works."

Sigh.

308 Cognito  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:22:37pm

re: #307 Rugby the Rat

Be careful. I'm on your side of things, maybe even more than you know. But you're walking a bit of a line, reporting from within someone's home --- maybe things aren't as sensitive, so to speak, on the ad side, but you still might not want to be identified.

309 siiras  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:37:50pm

The real story in Iraq will never be told by the MSM and that is the exemplary behavior of 99.9% of the young American men and women serving under circumstances that no soldier has had to serve under before: attempting to MINIMIZE civilian casualties increasing the risk to themselves.

There should be an end run around the MSM - the army should allow/encourage blogging from every unit with rotating bloggers describing their typical day including ENEMY atrocities. The cumulative picture would be far more accurate than the BS we're being fed. Stateside, the military blogs should be disseminated by true supporters of the military to all friends and family, especially the moonbats.

There are two fronts in this war and the homefront is being lost because of thousands of homegrown Tokyo Roses calling themselves journalists instead of propagandists who are setting out to recreate the Vietnam travesty demonizing the troops and demoralizing citizens.

Secondly, inundate the MSM with letters of complaint about the shoddy one-sided reporting and where possible, cancel subscriptions. Make it hurt.

310 Rugby the Rat  Fri, Jul 20, 2007 10:41:26pm

re: #306 whiskey rebel

A guy puts a child's skull on his head like a crown and it's a "perfect fit"? He would have to have a head the size of a grapefruit. The entire article smacks of leftist fantasy. If any of TNR's editors had any military experience, which I highly doubt, he would have flagged it as Glassery by the second paragraph.

The example I really wanted to put to Frank Foer, but didn't, was:

Suppose someone had submitted a report about a meeting of the gay-advocacy group Human Rights Campaign that included the line, "So there I was, stuffing a gerbil up someone's ass..." Wouldn't that have triggered the skeptic-o-meters of the TNR editors? Well, the Scott Thomas story merits similar skepticism.

311 SeanGleeson  Sat, Jul 21, 2007 12:54:39am

Hold everything! It turns out the TNR piece by Scott Thomas has been corroborated, on the Jukt Micronics website!

312 Captain Hate  Sat, Jul 21, 2007 6:38:41am

Marty Peretz is a good guy but the New Republic needs a thorough fumigation as much as the CIA. Starting with Foer.

313 TalkinKamel  Sat, Jul 21, 2007 7:45:50am

#303 kevinmumaw

Unless, and until, TNR sees fit to actually name this guy, or corroborate his story with indepdent evidence, or to give us something other than anonymous stories from anonymous people, we don't know that this guy is really a soldier; he could be anybody, including the fiment of somebody's imagination.

314 whiskey rebel  Sat, Jul 21, 2007 2:58:19pm

re: #311 SeanGleeson

Hold everything! It turns out the TNR piece by Scott Thomas has been corroborated, on the Jukt Micronics website!

From the hilarious link page: "The mass grave of children's bones was wrongly identified as "a Saddam-era dumping ground of some sort." It was in reality a reliquary of the ancient Ninevites, who grew to giant proportions, so large that a child's skull would fit over a grown man's head."

Well, that explains everything. And it's quite an important find. We need to send a crack archaeological team over there immediately. Glass can head it up and Jessie Macbeth and Micah Wright can provide security, in case descendants of those gigantors are still hanging around.


This entry has been archived.
Comments are closed.

^ back to top ^

log in
Name:
Pass:

Register Forgot Your Password? My Account Re-send Confirmation (To log in, cookies must be enabled in your browser!)

► LGF Headlines

  • Loading...

► Top 10 Comments

  • Loading...

► Bottom Comments

  • Loading...

► Recent Comments

  • Loading...

► Tools/Info

► LGF Hits

► Slideshows

► Resources

► Never Forget

► Statistics

► Tag Cloud

► Contact

You must have Javascript enabled to use the contact form.
Your email:

Subject:

Message:


Messages may be published in our weblog, unless you request otherwise.
Tech Note:
Using the Contact Form

► News/Opinion

  • Loading...

More Partners

Compare Electricity Prices in your area. Texas Electricity is deregulated; you have the right to choose Texas Electric Rates from among many Texas Electric Companies.

I think we're overloading Ajax.

Follow Lizardoid on Twitter

 Frank says:

If your children ever find out how lame you really are, they're gonna murder you in your sleep...