-♻RetweetVentura County Star Caught Using MSM Comment Deletion Trick
Tue, Dec 11, 2007 at 12:59:58 pm PST
It’s a thoroughly evil trick: you post a comment at a mainstream media site that criticizes them, or goes against their prevailing biases, and the administrator deletes your comment. But they delete it in a sneaky way; when you visit the page and are logged in to your account, you still see your comment, but everyone else sees either nothing or a message that the comment was deleted.
It’s Orwellian, in a convoluted Boolean kind of way. They make you think everyone else is simply ignoring what you wrote. And they also insulate themselves from criticism by making you, the commenter, believe your comment was never deleted at all. They turn you into an un-person at their web site, unknowingly posting meaningless comments into a heedless void.
I almost admire the tactic for its sheer deviousness.
The latest paper to be caught using it is the Ventura County Star: JunkYardBlog: Ventura County Star is Pretty Much Busted.
Also see:
SF Chronicle’s Sneaky Comment Deletion Trick - Update: ThinkProgress is Doing It Too
Sneaky Comment Trick Proof of Concept
Sneaky Comment Trick Now Disabled
SF Chronicle Admits Sneaky Comment Deletion Trick
UPDATE at 12/11/07 1:06:56 pm:
LGF reader “winslow” puts this sneaky trick into song:
To the tune of She’s Not There
(With apologies to The Zombies)It’s Not There!
Well, no one told me my comment
Had been removed.
I had no clue that my comment
Was quickly disapproved.Though it’s too late to read my comment,
I’ll never know; I’m unaware.
Please don’t bother trying to find it;
It’s not there!Well, let me tell you ’bout the post I wrote,
My point of view, writ so eloquent and fair.
My facts were cold and hard, my logic clear and tight,
But it’s not there!Well, no one told me my comment
Had lost its soul.
I had no clue that my comment
Went down the mem’ry hole.Though no one else can see my comment,
It’s plain to me; at it I stare.
But don’t bother trying to find it;
It’s not there!Well, let me tell you ’bout the post I wrote;
My reasoned prose, ’twas so elegant and rare.
My words impeccable! My thoughts invincible!
But it’s not there!



