LGF

more options

  

Advertisement

Hamas Planning to Storm Gaza Border?

Sun, Feb 24, 2008 at 10:57:54 am PST

There are signs that Hamas may be preparing to attempt a “human wave” attack on the border between Gaza and Israel, similar to their successful storming of the Egyptian border wall: Israel prepares for mass protests at Gaza border.

And they’re releasing children from school so they can be on the front line.

JERUSALEM, Feb 24 (Reuters) - Israel has put paramilitary police on standby and boosted surveillance along the Gaza border in case Palestinians try to break through into Israel as they did in Egypt last month, security sources said on Sunday.

A pro-Hamas group said it would hold a peaceful protest on Monday in which it estimated that 40,000 to 50,000 women and children would form a “human chain” stretching the length of the Gaza Strip. Organisers said they had no intention of breaching the border.

A spokeswoman for the Israeli Defence Forces said: “The IDF is preparing based on reports from the Palestinian media.” She declined to elaborate.

Israel became increasingly concerned after Hamas Islamists blew open Gaza’s southern Rafah border wall with Egypt last month, and Hamas officials raised the possibility of similar breaches along the border with Israel. ...

The head of the Popular Anti-Siege Committee protest organisers, Jamal al-Khudary, said: “We do not have intentions of approaching the fence, either in the north or the south. We hope all the participants will abide by the instructions and we will try to prevent any violations.”

Organisers said Hamas-controlled schools across Gaza would get time off to allow students to take part in the protest.

An Israeli security source said the army was preparing for “all scenarios”.

“Obviously, if gunmen start shooting at the fence we will have to respond in kind and we are absolutely unwilling to countenance a situation where the fence is breached like it was at Rafah,” the source said.

Advertisement

374 comments

  • Comments are open and unmoderated, and do not necessarily reflect the views of Little Green Footballs.
  • Obscene, abusive, silly, or annoying remarks may be deleted, but the fact that particular comments remain on the site in no way constitutes an endorsement of their views by Little Green Footballs.
  • Posts that contain phone numbers, street addresses, email addresses or other personal information will also be deleted, as will posts that consist only of a variation on the word, "First!"
  • Comments that advocate violence will be cause for immediate banning with no appeal.
  • Disagreement and debate are welcome, but insults and abuse are not, and may cause your account to be blocked.
  • REMEMBER: posting comments at LGF is a privilege, not a right. Abuse that privilege, and your account will be blocked.

Hide comments | Jump to bottom

1 jaunte  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 10:59:23am

"40,000 to 50,000 women and children would form a “human chain” stretching the length of the Gaza Strip."

That may be a record-setting number of human shields.

2 Sharmuta  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:00:34am
Organisers said Hamas-controlled schools across Gaza would get time off to allow students to take part in the protest.

Considering the type of education we've seen coming out of their schools, I'd say this was less time off than it is a field trip.

3 Gordon Marock  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:01:54am

/ The children of Gaza are merely trying to build bridges toward peace.

4 lawhawk  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:02:08am

This is something that Israel has been worried about since the moment Hamas stormed the Egyptian border with Gaza and invaded that country. Israel's security is entrusted to those defending its border with Gaza, and they take that responsibility more seriously than the Egyptians did to theirs - with predictable consequences.

That isn't to say that Hamas couldn't try to overwhelm the Israelis with sheer numbers of unarmed women and children to storm the border, but they'd have to get through the defenses first - and that was accomplished along the Egyptian border by first undermining the fence and torching it, followed by blowing up sections.

5 Pass The Moonbaticide  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:03:46am

But the Egyptians wouldn't shoot to kill .
Israel , do us all a favour ...

6 cookielady  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:03:56am
A pro-Hamas group said it would hold a peaceful protest on Monday in which it estimated that 40,000 to 50,000 women and children would form a “human chain” human shield stretching the length of the Gaza Strip.

Had to correct that.

7 Iron Fist  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:04:18am

Ma Duce. M-2 heavy machine gun.

Rake the crowds until they go away.

There is no reason that Hamas should be successful at storming the border. None whatsoever.

8 abolitionist  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:05:15am

re: #3 Gordon Marock

/ The children of Gaza are merely trying to build bridges toward peace.

...like an army of ants build bridges across a small stream of water.

9 Killgore Trout  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:06:27am

I dinged the Debka version of this story earlier but it seems other sources are reporting the same thing now.

10 karmic_inquisitor  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:06:32am

To any Reuters personnel who may see this item -

Please accept my protest of the obvious bias in the piece. It is very one sided and unbalanced.

To wit:

The head of the Popular Anti-Siege Committee protest organisers, Jamal al-Khudary, said: “We do not have intentions of approaching the fence, either in the north or the south. We hope all the participants will abide by the instructions and we will try to prevent any violations.”

So where is the quote from the Unpopular Anti-Siege Committee?

11 Dianna  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:06:58am

re: #7 Iron Fist

They're herding kids ahead of them, which makes that impossible.

The disgusting thing is, this blatant piece of atrocity staging will be treated as an "over-reaction" by the Israelis.

12 LeftJustAintRight  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:07:06am

re: #1 jaunte

I will take bets the Islamicnuts will be standing behind the women and children launching rockets and throwing grenades with their human shields getting killed.
And Israel will be the barbarians for killing the women and children while defending themselves.
AP Headline
IDF killing women and children for no reason !

13 justnobody  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:07:19am

Just put mine fields on the border between Israel and Gaza and problem solved.

14 karmic_inquisitor  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:07:37am

re: #7 Iron Fist

Ma Duce. M-2 heavy machine gun.

Rake the crowds until they go away.

There is no reason that Hamas should be successful at storming the border. None whatsoever.

Can't used the M2 on personnel. But you can use it on their equipment.

Aim for their Official Hamas Headbands.

15 Airedale  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:08:08am

I think I saw this story at Debka earlier.......

16 Sharmuta  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:08:19am

re: #11 Dianna

The disgusting thing is, this blatant piece of atrocity staging will be treated as an "over-reaction" by the Israelis.

Which is exactly why hamas is doing it.

17 Cognito  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:08:21am

Hey Charles,

That's one big ol' ugly protest, sounds like. What are the signs they're preparing to attack, though?

I'm not saying it won't happen -- a breach is likely, I'd say -- but I'm just curious if there are concrete plans of an attack.

18 Dianna  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:08:26am

re: #13 justnobody

They'll give the kids copies of the koran and march them over the minefield. It's happened before.

19 Killgore Trout  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:08:32am

re: #11 Dianna

Tear gas, rubber bullets, etc will handle the problem nicely.

20 LeftJustAintRight  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:09:28am

re: #18 Dianna

They'll give the kids copies of the koran and march them over the minefield. It's happened before.


And what are the kids gonna do with all those virgins?

21 Dianna  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:09:52am

re: #16 Sharmuta

Yes.

But even the bloody Europeans should eventually figure out how this is being done. Though it may require many, many women and children shot in the back by Hamas to bring it to their attention.

22 Jack Reacher  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:10:18am
...we are absolutely unwilling to countenance a situation where the fence is breached like it was at Rafah...

The leaders of Hamasistan have been warned, and if blood flows it will be on their hands. It's sickening to think so many Legacy Media ™ outlets and LLLs will blame the Israelis when the Paleos use children as shields.

23 Dianna  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:10:35am

re: #19 Killgore Trout

We can hope.

Bean-bags, btw, work better than rubber bullets - which can put out an eye.

24 Dianna  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:11:19am

re: #20 LeftJustAintRight

Think of it this way: the virgins will be glad of the rest.

25 Nevergiveup  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:11:25am

re: #22 Jack Reacher

...we are absolutely unwilling to countenance a situation where the fence is breached like it was at Rafah...

The leaders of Hamasistan have been warned, and if blood flows it will be on their hands. It's sickening to think so many Legacy Media ™ outlets and LLLs will blame the Israelis when the Paleos use children as shields.

The stories are already written. All they are going to have to do is fill in the dates.

26 Jack Reacher  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:11:32am

re: #20 LeftJustAintRight

re: #18 Dianna

They'll give the kids copies of the koran and march them over the minefield. It's happened before.


And what are the kids gonna do with all those virgins?

No, no, you've got it wrong; the kids are the virgins (For future splodeydopes).

27 BulgarWheat  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:12:05am

re: #23 Dianna

You said "Hope"
Drink!

28 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:12:07am

Hmmm Israel should line up their military on the border and do what the Egyptians claimed they were going to do, shoot to kill anyone who attempted to cross the border.

29 Killgore Trout  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:12:17am

re: #17 Cognito
Carl has some links from reliable sources.....
IDF bracing for breach of Gaza 'fence'

30 mbruce  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:12:53am

They are going to play right into the moonbat rage when they force their own children to die for what essentially is a publicity stunt calculated for world outrage. Although I do pity the little ones caught up in this insanity that is the Pali/Islam marketing machine, we will be directly up against this kind of depravity soon enough. God Bless the IDF and what they are about to face.

31 ornery elephant  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:13:01am

Why don't the Israelis just erect huge posters/billboards of Rosie O'Donnell in a bikini? That outta repel any mass of people.

On second thought, that might just clear Gaza entirely. Hmm.....:thinking:.....

32 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:13:35am

re: #19 Killgore Trout

re: #11 Dianna

Tear gas, rubber bullets, etc will handle the problem nicely.

Napalm would work so much better...

33 LeftJustAintRight  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:13:44am

re: #26 Jack Reacher

re: #20 LeftJustAintRight

re: #18 Dianna

They'll give the kids copies of the koran and march them over the minefield. It's happened before.


And what are the kids gonna do with all those virgins?

No, no, you've got it wrong; the kids are the virgins (For future splodeydopes).
Why don't those Berkly nuts go stand in for the kids
I would admire them for that

34 Jack Reacher  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:14:06am

re: #31 ornery elephant

Why don't the Israelis just erect huge posters/billboards of Rosie O'Donnell in a bikini? That outta repel any mass of people.

On second thought, that might just clear Gaza entirely. Hmm.....:thinking:.....

Not gonna happen. Contrary to MSM reporting, the Israelis will not commit war crimes.

35 solomonpanting  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:14:11am
Organisers said Hamas-controlled schools across Gaza would get time off to allow students to take part in the protest.

Their version of "take your child to work" day.

36 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:14:21am
37 LoFlyer  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:14:23am

This looks like another no-win scenario for Israel. It will take massive amounts of tear gas and rubber bullets to knock down an assault like the Pali's are contemplating. I pray the Palis, or Hamas think about the results of such an assault. On second thought, I am sure the Hamas has thought everything through very carefully, and considering the Hamas's attitude towards propaganda and death of "innocent civilians" in their war against Israel, its a done deal. Even if Israel use the same tactics the US uses in Iraq, taking military casualties to minimize civilian casualties, Reuters and the western MSM will take Israel to the cleaners for any civilian casualties incurred in the assault. Even if Israel kills no one, you can almost be assured that the Pali's will kill a few civi's just to add to the "drama" of the event, and western media will broadcast every allegation by the Hamas as gospel, whilst doubting anything the Israelis report. I really detest western journalism, it is an occupation of liars and hypocrites.

38 Nevergiveup  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:14:29am

re: #28 doriangrey

Hmmm Israel should line up their military on the border and do what the Egyptians claimed they were going to do, shoot to kill anyone who attempted to cross the border.

I think they will use smoke, water cannons, rubber bullets, and other less lethal methods and control the situation just fine. You will notice I said LESS LETHAL, since any mass movement of indisciplined peoples is inherently dangerous.

39 Daisy  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:14:43am

"40,000 to 50,000 women and children would form a “human chain” stretching the length of the Gaza Strip."

Could Islamists possibly be more cowardly?

40 Dianna  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:14:46am

re: #27 BulgarWheat

A sip of coffee will suffice, won't it? It's a stimulant, after all!

41 ornery elephant  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:14:48am

re: #34 Jack Reacher

re: #31 ornery elephant


Why don't the Israelis just erect huge posters/billboards of Rosie O'Donnell in a bikini? That outta repel any mass of people.

On second thought, that might just clear Gaza entirely. Hmm.....:thinking:.....


Not gonna happen. Contrary to MSM reporting, the Israelis will not commit war crimes.

hahaha Jack! Touche' !

42 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:14:52am

re: #31 ornery elephant

Why don't the Israelis just erect huge posters/billboards of Rosie O'Donnell in a bikini? That outta repel any mass of people.

On second thought, that might just clear Gaza entirely. Hmm.....:thinking:.....

Damn OE you might have just solved the Palestinian problem...Now if anyone in Israel had the balls to do it...

43 justnobody  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:14:52am

This is not really a "peace protest". These are simply human shields for terrorists who will try to kidnap Israeli citizens and for potential suicide bombers.

44 Roger  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:15:09am

re: #26 Jack Reacher

The kids are 90 feet tall; and have translucent alabaster skin/muscles so that you can see their skeletons moving? All identical per islamist's choice after death?

45 Adrenalyn  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:15:38am

no, tear gas and bullets will not suffice
when this human wave comes in from the West/Gaza
the Hezbollassholes will start attacking from the north
just when the IDF is bogged down on the Gaza border
then Syria and Iran will join in

this could be something big

Israle may not only have to shoot the kids/women in Gaza
but send a nuclear message to Damascus and/or Tehran

46 BulgarWheat  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:15:51am

re: #40 Dianna

What ever works best.

47 Daisy  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:16:04am

re: #35 solomonpanting

Organisers said Hamas-controlled schools across Gaza would get time off to allow students to take part in the protest.
Their version of "take your child to work" day.

I laughed and then wanted to cry. Really.

48 Gharqad  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:16:22am

re: #23 Dianna

Bean-bags, btw, work better than rubber bullets - which can put out an eye.

They really need this.

49 Dianna  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:16:49am

re: #32 doriangrey

On children? And women with no choice?

I don't think so.

And remember: Napalm sticks to kids is not a motivational phrase.

50 Daisy  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:18:01am

I wonder if the Jew Eating Rabbit will show up to entertain the troops .. uh .. I mean kids.

51 Roger  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:18:04am

The evil in the world via islam hasn't had its blood-lust slaked enough of late.

52 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:18:05am

re: #45 Adrenalyn

no, tear gas and bullets will not suffice
when this human wave comes in from the West/Gaza
the Hezbollassholes will start attacking from the north
just when the IDF is bogged down on the Gaza border
then Syria and Iran will join in

this could be something big

Israle may not only have to shoot the kids/women in Gaza
but send a nuclear message to Damascus and/or Tehran

Crap you could very well be right... There have been indications that Syria has been planning a military assault against Israel every since Israel took out their clandestine nuclear weapons facility last year...

53 Stonemason  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:18:09am

Threads such as this seem to bring out the kill 'em all attitudes that make lurking tough somedays.

y'all might want to tone it down a little

54 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:18:34am

If Hamas is going to breach the border, at least they're prepared to be gentlemanly about it -- women and children first.

/s

55 Shaky Louie  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:19:20am

re: #6 cookielady

A pro-Hamas group said it would hold a peaceful protest on Monday in which it estimated that 40,000 to 50,000 women and children would form a “human chain” human shield stretching the length of the Gaza Strip.

Had to correct that.


This is getting sickening. This pro-hamas group plans a peaceful protest by using unarmed women and children as a human chain, rather - shield? And then, when the brave leaders (otherwise known as the "steering committe") ,in back of the line force them forward, what then?
Yes, I know. Blame will then fall on Israel for the slaughter of peaceful civilians.
Israel, you're damned if you do, and damned if you don't.

56 Stonemason  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:19:49am

re: #53 Stonemason

Threads such as this seem to bring out the kill 'em all attitudes that make lurking tough somedays.

y'all those so inclined might want to tone it down a little

57 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:19:59am

re: #53 Stonemason

Threads such as this seem to bring out the kill 'em all attitudes that make lurking tough somedays.

y'all might want to tone it down a little

Point well taken.

58 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:20:10am

re: #49 Dianna

re: #32 doriangrey

On children? And women with no choice?

I don't think so.

And remember: Napalm sticks to kids is not a motivational phrase.

Doesn't have to be on them, just as a barrier between them and the border. Napalm burns for quite a while, all Israel needs to do is napalm their side of the border, the Pali hordes are not charging through the flames.

59 Iron Fist  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:20:34am

re: #11 Dianna,

We have to harden our hearts. The enemy is willing to cause any level of atrocity.

We have to be willing to meet them with it. Certainly, we should kill the leaders first, wherever we can.

I have always advocated the extermination of Hamas. All of them. They are slime who would march children into M-2 fire.

Kill all of them, and we don't have to worry about what we would do about a human wave headed by children.

60 lookingup  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:21:59am

What would Israel do now if they hadn't built that wall that every lib complained was awful toward the palis. Good thing they did build it.
What mischief would they do if they do storm through? Every muslim country supports the palis making trouble but won't give them one acre of the damn desert they own. They don't want'em either.

61 Dar ul Harb  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:22:04am

re: #52 doriangrey

re: #45 Adrenalyn

no, tear gas and bullets will not suffice
when this human wave comes in from the West/Gaza
the Hezbollassholes will start attacking from the north
just when the IDF is bogged down on the Gaza border
then Syria and Iran will join in

this could be something big

Israle may not only have to shoot the kids/women in Gaza
but send a nuclear message to Damascus and/or Tehran

Crap you could very well be right... There have been indications that Syria has been planning a military assault against Israel every since Israel took out their clandestine nuclear weapons facility last year...

If this breach actually occurs, you bet it'll be a diversion for the actual Hizballah attack.

62 solomonpanting  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:22:13am

re: #47 Daisy

re: #35 solomonpanting


Organisers said Hamas-controlled schools across Gaza would get time off to allow students to take part in the protest.
Their version of "take your child to work" day.

I laughed and then wanted to cry. Really.

Beyond sad, huh?

63 MJ  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:22:23am

"the Popular Anti-Siege Committee"

Also called the Rachel Corrie birgade.

64 ornery elephant  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:22:23am

I think I have the answer to this. When the hundreds of thousands are massed at the border fence, pushing at the wall...the Israelis bomb out some abandoned 1992 Dodge Aspen some tenth of a mile BEHIND the massed palis. This will instigate the inevitable scream of "Allahu AckbarCarSwarm" and the thousands will immediately turn and sprint back to the burning vehicle abandoning all plans for any push into Israel.

65 Iron Fist  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:23:02am

re: #39 Daisy,

No. Muslim "men" are ALL cowards. It is simply part of being a Mohammedan. You follow your "Prophet" who was the Supreme Coward.

In addition to being a pedophile, although those are perhaps synonymous.

66 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:23:29am

re: #56 Stonemason

re: #53 Stonemason

Threads such as this seem to bring out the kill 'em all attitudes that make lurking tough somedays.

y'all those so inclined might want to tone it down a little

Should the Israeli's also tone down their concern regarding an emanate invasion by Palestinians lead by women and children while armed and murderous terrorists calmly carry their bombs and guns in the midst of the human shield?

67 Kosh's Shadow  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:23:34am

Fill a ditch with pig carcasses. Build a fence just towards the Israeli side, and cover it with lard.

68 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:23:35am
69 lookingup  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:23:52am

Car swarm lol

70 Roger  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:24:17am

re: #64 ornery elephant

I take it some 1992 Dodge Aspen gave you headaches and sapped your cash...

71 LoFlyer  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:25:01am

re: #45 Adrenalyn

no, tear gas and bullets will not suffice
when this human wave comes in from the West/Gaza
the Hezbollassholes will start attacking from the north
just when the IDF is bogged down on the Gaza border
then Syria and Iran will join in

this could be something big

Israle may not only have to shoot the kids/women in Gaza
but send a nuclear message to Damascus and/or Tehran

I think you are over reacting with nuclear weapons. A cluster bomb will annihilate all life with a quarter mile. And the Israelis know how to use them. I believe this is going to be more of a rubber bullet, water cannon, tear gas response. I understand there are some new acoustic weapons that would be effective in repelling this type of assault. The Israeli military has never been afraid to "think outside the box" and apply innovative responses to attacks.

72 Kosh's Shadow  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:25:18am

re: #68 buzzsawmonkey

Again: a minefield along the Gaza border--except at the checkpoints--will solve this problem.

The advantage of a minefield is that it endangers nobody unless they themselves decide to enter it.

Fortify the checkpoints and mine the rest. Problem over.

They'll do like the Iranians did in the Iran-Iraq war, and send the children through the minefields. No one criticized Iran or Iraq for that, but they'll still criticize Israel.

73 BulgarWheat  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:25:41am

re: #67 Kosh's Shadow

Now, there's a thought.

74 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:25:55am

re: #70 Roger

re: #64 ornery elephant

I take it some 1992 Dodge Aspen gave you headaches and sapped your cash...

Must have, he sure dont like 1992 Dodge Aspens, to quote Steve Martin from the Jerk...He hates 1992 Dodge Aspens....OK sort of quote...

75 Stonemason  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:26:24am

re: #66 doriangrey

Israels reaction to anything Hamas does is up to Israel, calling for teh death of people on a blog is wrong, especially the innocents that will be in the line of fire

sorry, just my opinion and I will wait for the next thread.

76 Iron Fist  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:27:05am

re: #68 buzzsawmonkey,

Works for me. Perhaps a tripple layer minefield. Non-leathal at the outside, frag in the middle, and gas on the innermost side.

A real deterrant.

77 nyc redneck  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:27:20am

israel is must have the will to survive and do what it takes to insure that. otherwise, bad people who have bad plans for them will decide their future.

78 hhc 2-2 scr  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:27:27am

This is one of the biggest fundamental differences between them and us.
We would never allow our children to be put in such danger.
Where are the human rights activist now?
Oh wait, now I remember they're busy writing up the U.S for our racist treatment of Middle Easterners. It's put your child in danger day in palestine and thats a-okay in their book.

79 Killgore Trout  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:27:36am

The Palestinians would love nothing more that to martyr 1000's of women and children. The Israelis won't give them the satisfaction. It's not going to happen.

80 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:27:48am

re: #73 BulgarWheat

re: #67 Kosh's Shadow

Now, there's a thought.

Except the Jew's are almost as troubled by pork as the Muslims. So who exactly would do the work and where would the pork come from?

81 Daisy  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:28:06am

re: #56 Stonemason

re: #53 Stonemason

Threads such as this seem to bring out the kill 'em all attitudes that make lurking tough somedays.

y'all those so inclined might want to tone it down a little

And there is always the 'click the football'/ notify Charles option to employ towards those who choose not to practice reasonable impulse control.

82 snowcrash  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:28:15am

It seems only America and Israel ever have to consider world opinion when defending themselves.

83 mbruce  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:28:55am

At this point, might as well get PETA totally pissed off and into the fray.
Shooting live pigs from cannons into the crowd would do that and be effective in so many other ways.
Just trying to think outside of the box.

84 MJ  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:29:50am

I don't think Olmert will be able to make it in person if Hamas carries through with this. He'll be in Japan with the major American supporter of Hamas -Condi Rice:

"Prime Minister Ehud Olmert and US Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice will hold a surprise meeting during their two respective state visits to Japan next week, it was announced Friday, even though Rice is scheduled to travel to Israel the following week.

Government official estimated that the meeting, arranged at Rice's request, would focus on the crisis in the Gaza Strip and that the secretary of state would express her concern over the humanitarian situation in the territory."

[Link: www.jpost.com...]

It's expected Rice will demand that Israel move forward with "peace" talks with the Palestinians.

85 Dianna  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:30:00am

re: #79 Killgore Trout

The Palestinians would love nothing more that to martyr 1000's of women and children. The Israelis won't give them the satisfaction. It's not going to happen.

If anything does, I really fear it will be Hamas shooting their civilians in the back. And then the stringers will report that it was done by the Israelis.

Think the ambulance caper.

86 BulgarWheat  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:30:05am

re: #80 doriangrey

I'm Christian, and I love pork. I'll volunteer. Bet there's a ton of Lizards here that would be willing to help too.

Lizards, doing jobs that Israeli's aren't willing to do...........

/utmost sarcasm tag

87 Daisy  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:30:33am

re: #62 solomonpanting

"Beyond sad, huh?"

Yes, it's a deliberately planned tragedy - in other words, an atrocity.

88 Iron Fist  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:30:40am

re: #79 Killgore Trout,

Which is why I advocate killing Hamas. All of them.

It doesn't make sense to say "This guy is a lower level Hamas Terrorist, so we won't kill him."

89 Confuzed  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:30:58am

Non-lethal alternatives may be appropriate.
Free-roaming black dogs.
Bacon bits fired from cannons.
Porn dropped from planes.

90 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:31:10am
91 BulgarWheat  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:31:21am

The French had the Maginot line. Gaza can have the Pork Lard Line

92 Nevergiveup  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:31:27am

re: #80 doriangrey

re: #73 BulgarWheat

re: #67 Kosh's Shadow

Now, there's a thought.

Except the Jew's are almost as troubled by pork as the Muslims. So who exactly would do the work and where would the pork come from?

Well if you haven't been in Israel lately, there is quite a bit of " white meat( white meat = pork) "available to secular Israelis than you would ever imagine!

93 Killgore Trout  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:32:05am

re: #86 BulgarWheat

Shabbos goy!

94 BulgarWheat  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:32:41am

re: #93 Killgore Trout

yeah, can't escape the goyism.

95 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:33:32am

re: #75 Stonemason

re: #66 doriangrey

Israels reaction to anything Hamas does is up to Israel, calling for teh death of people on a blog is wrong, especially the innocents that will be in the line of fire

sorry, just my opinion and I will wait for the next thread.

Except that we all know that no matter what Israel does they will be crucified in the MSM. I suppose had blogs existed in 1939 and you read post where people were calling for the death of Hitler and the Nazi's you would also be offended. You need to understand something here. There are NO INNOCENT Palestinians. Even their children are willing subjects in this. They are indoctrinated from birth that to kill Israels and Jews is to please Allah.

96 justnobody  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:33:34am

Gaza is foreign territory, which is actually at war with Israel. Anyone who tries to cross the border from Gaza should be shot. Why endenger Israeli lives in the name of the enemy's supposed human rights?

97 MJ  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:33:50am

re: #90 buzzsawmonkey

"...However, the up-close view of Hamassholes driving children into a minefield may just possibly wake some people up to just what Hamas actually is."


Not a chance that would happen.

98 opinionated  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:34:06am

I'm certain if the Leftists at the New York Times weren't too busy fantasizing about John McCain's imagined sex life, they would have time to find the answer to a question that puzzles the hell out of me.

On one side is Israel, with Jews who Hamas/"Palestinians" want to slaughter and eat. On the other side are their supporters and brethren, the Egyptians.

If the Jews close one door because they really don't want to be on the Hamas menu, why is it considered a siege when the other door leads to fellow Arabs- who love them and support them in every which way and should be happy to provide them with all their needs- even if only to prove that they not like those evil Zionists.

99 Adrenalyn  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:34:43am

re: #52 doriangrey

re: #45 Adrenalyn


no, tear gas and bullets will not suffice
when this human wave comes in from the West/Gaza
the Hezbollassholes will start attacking from the north
just when the IDF is bogged down on the Gaza border
then Syria and Iran will join in

this could be something big

Israle may not only have to shoot the kids/women in Gaza
but send a nuclear message to Damascus and/or Tehran


Crap you could very well be right... There have been indications that Syria has been planning a military assault against Israel every since Israel took out their clandestine nuclear weapons facility last year...

that and stay off Europe bound/origin airplanes
eventually they're going to pull something off
if not now, look just before or after the November elections in the US

100 lawhawk  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:34:56am

re: #85 Dianna

re: #79 Killgore Trout

The Palestinians would love nothing more that to martyr 1000's of women and children. The Israelis won't give them the satisfaction. It's not going to happen.

If anything does, I really fear it will be Hamas shooting their civilians in the back. And then the stringers will report that it was done by the Israelis.

Think the ambulance caper.

I'm thinking al Dura.

101 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:35:17am

re: #92 Nevergiveup

re: #80 doriangrey

re: #73 BulgarWheat

re: #67 Kosh's Shadow

Now, there's a thought.

Except the Jew's are almost as troubled by pork as the Muslims. So who exactly would do the work and where would the pork come from?

Well if you haven't been in Israel lately, there is quite a bit of " white meat( white meat = pork) "available to secular Israelis than you would ever imagine!

I am surprised....

102 lawhawk  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:36:11am

re: #98 opinionated

Because you've entered that strange place where logic and reasoning do not apply.

You cannot adjust the horizontal or the vertical.

You have entered.... Israeli double standard time (tm all rights reserved Meryl yourish).

103 wild olive  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:36:18am

re: #86 BulgarWheat

re: #80 doriangrey

I'm Christian, and I love pork. I'll volunteer. Bet there's a ton of Lizards here that would be willing to help too.

Me too! Me too! Me too!

104 Dianna  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:36:23am

re: #95 doriangrey

I must disagree. Emphatically, even.

Children may be indoctrinated, but they remain innocent. There is a line, and it's a bad idea to cross it.

105 Gumby  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:37:07am

Doesn't have to be on them, just as a barrier between them and the border. Napalm burns for quite a while, all Israel needs to do is napalm their side of the border, the Pali hordes are not charging through the flames.

The women and children haven't been taught to jump through the rings of fire yet.

106 Shaky Louie  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:37:16am

re: #80 doriangrey

Except the Jew's are almost as troubled by pork as the Muslims. So who exactly would do the work and where would the pork come from?


The Jew is forbidden to eat pork, The muslim, IIRC, is forbidden to even touch it.

(And, if they needed someone to lock and load, I'd do it!)

Now, I'm going out to breakfast where, oddly enough, I'll be having...pork chops!

107 Dianna  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:37:18am

re: #100 lawhawk

Also an excellent example.

108 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:37:50am

re: #98 opinionated

the other door leads to fellow Arabs- who love them and support them in every which way and should be happy to provide them with all their needs

Was that intended as sarcasm?

109 Geepers  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:37:51am

MJ (#97),

re: #90 buzzsawmonkey

"...However, the up-close view of Hamassholes driving children into a minefield may just possibly wake some people up to just what Hamas actually is."
Not a chance that would happen.

Undoubtedly the headlines would read: Isreal Forces Hamas to Force Children into Minefield.

110 Gumby  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:41:12am

re: #80 doriangrey

re: #73 BulgarWheat


re: #67 Kosh's Shadow

Now, there's a thought.


Except the Jew's are almost as troubled by pork as the Muslims. So who exactly would do the work and where would the pork come from?

Send our illegal aliens there and have them lay down a line of tamales. That should take care of that.

111 MJ  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:42:41am

re: #109 Geepers

MJ (#97),

re: #90 buzzsawmonkey

"...However, the up-close view of Hamassholes driving children into a minefield may just possibly wake some people up to just what Hamas actually is."
Not a chance that would happen.

Undoubtedly the headlines would read: Isreal Forces Hamas to Force Children into Minefield.

Yup, exactly. Every ill in the entire Middle East, let alone with the Palestinians, is easily traced back to the "occupation".

112 LoFlyer  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:43:30am

re: #104 Dianna

re: #95 doriangrey

I must disagree. Emphatically, even.

Children may be indoctrinated, but they remain innocent. There is a line, and it's a bad idea to cross it.

Indoctinated children are the lifeblood of the Palestinians, while the children may be innocent in the fact they are unwillingly and unknowingly being indoctrinated. Once indoctrinated and old enough to kill, they become the enemy and innocence is just another empty word for public consumption.

113 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:43:57am

re: #104 Dianna

re: #95 doriangrey

I must disagree. Emphatically, even.

Children may be indoctrinated, but they remain innocent. There is a line, and it's a bad idea to cross it.

And you would be sadly and profoundly mistaken...

Oh and the second link translated into English...

Ten-year sister cuts back A ten-year one cut back its two years older sister erstochen in an Egyptian village and, because him its schoolmates had gehaenselt. How the Kairoer daily paper "Egyptian Gazette" reported on Friday, the other children had told him, his sister sleep with young men of the village. Rami, which up-played itself after the death of the father as a "man in the house", firstoh therefore its sister Samah in the sleep. In order to be safe that she was really dead, it separated it with a kitchen measurer the head. Subsequently, he washed the knife and put again to bed. The nut/mother found the corpse in the morning. Its sister "entehrt" the family, said the boy later with the verhoer. "I only did, what is correct."

114 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:44:35am

re: #110 Gumby

re: #80 doriangrey


re: #73 BulgarWheat

re: #67 Kosh's Shadow
Now, there's a thought.

Except the Jew's are almost as troubled by pork as the Muslims. So who exactly would do the work and where would the pork come from?

Send our illegal aliens there and have them lay down a line of tamales. That should take care of that.

How about loudspeakers lining the Israeli side, broadcasting Arkansas football fans callin' th' hogs?

115 opinionated  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:45:09am

re: #108 pre-Boomer Marine brat

re: #98 opinionated

the other door leads to fellow Arabs- who love them and support them in every which way and should be happy to provide them with all their needs
Was that intended as sarcasm?

I'll get back to you.

I need to consult Bush and Rice and Tony Blair- and so many others- who tell me that all the Arabs and Islamics hate us and all the problems in the Mideast are the result of the pain and anguish and sympathy the Arabs feel for how their beloved 'Palestinians' are treated by Israel.

116 mbruce  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:45:21am

re: #111 MJ

re: #109 Geepers

MJ (#97),

re: #90 buzzsawmonkey


"...However, the up-close view of Hamassholes driving children into a minefield may just possibly wake some people up to just what Hamas actually is."

Not a chance that would happen.


Undoubtedly the headlines would read: Isreal Forces Hamas to Force Children into Minefield.

Yup, exactly. Every ill in the entire Middle East, let alone with the Palestinians, is easily traced back to the "occupation".

AS the whole lefty world ignores the larger picture that we are ALL considered "occupiers "of dar Islam and the global caliphate by the loving peeps following the cowardly Koran to the letter.

117 lawhawk  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:45:35am

The Hamas/Islamist playbook operates as follows;

Use kids to prepare the battlespace. Whether it is agitprop like al Dura, or kids who are injured because they're sent out ahead of jihadis with guns to either play in the fields where kassams are launched or throw stones at Israelis as jihadis with guns lurk just behind, the Islamists see their children as nothing more than cannon fodder.

Women, elderly, and mentally deficient/ill are acceptable alternatives to children. Not nearly as good as children because children are seen as innocents, but Islamists will use women who are shaming their family/tribe by seen talking to men not related to them, or accused of adultery, etc., and told that the only way to reclaim honor is to die for the cause.

The possibility that Hamas will attempt to invade Israel takes all this in to account. Hamas will put women and children at the head of the line, knowing that Israelis are trained not to fire on women or children, even if there are terrorists in their midst. Israel's humanity and restraint will be taken advantage of by the Islamists. Again. And Again.

So, what is Israel to do. They will not open fire on the crowds or rake them. They will not mine or boobytrap the border (though the Hamas thugs may do that just to claim that Israel did so), because of the possibility of civilian injuries.

They could go after Hamas leadership, but Israel's own leadership is too concerned with making peace with Fatah thugs that they ignore the threats posed by making deals with terrorists generally.

Israel faces a no-win situation here, and it is due in part to Olmert's failures to secure Israel's borders, to stop the kassam attacks, and to maintain Israel's national security deterrent factors against jihadis.

118 gman  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:45:51am

Funds keep pouring money into this country and there is absolutely no accountability. The Pali's shut down the schools built with foreign aid money any time they want. Imagine if you made receiving aid money contingent upon certain criteria. What a mind- blowing concept. Imagine what would happen if aid money was withheld or at least decreased for each instance of financial impropriety.

119 MandyManners  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:46:44am

This is just incomprehensible. The Kid is outside running with his dog, shouting for no good reason other than joyful abandon. I cannot wrap my mind around a mother allowing her child to be used as the Jordyptians are planning to use those children.

Moloch must be smiling in anticipation.

120 chubby vegan  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:46:46am

Fence Swarm!

121 Gumby  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:47:04am

re: #114 pre-Boomer Marine brat

re: #110 Gumby


re: #80 doriangrey

re: #73 BulgarWheat

re: #67 Kosh's Shadow
Now, there's a thought.

Except the Jew's are almost as troubled by pork as the Muslims. So who exactly would do the work and where would the pork come from?

Send our illegal aliens there and have them lay down a line of tamales. That should take care of that.

How about loudspeakers lining the Israeli side, broadcasting Arkansas football fans callin' th' hogs?

SOOOOO EEEEEEEEEEE PIG PIG! (Hook'em Horns, btw)

122 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:47:42am
123 Nevergiveup  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:47:53am

The problem with all this, as usual, it boils down to perception. The general perception in the EU and even a growing perception in the US State Department ( I personally disavow all relations with that part of our Gov. )is that Israel has been to harsh with Gaza. It seems they all want Israel to back off, open up all the crossings, and just smile as the missiles rain down on their towns and kibbutzim. It tends to put Israel between a rock and a hard place, which wiser leaders then presently in power in Israel have found it hard to navigate.

124 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:48:25am

re: #115 opinionated

(-: NOWWW I get your drift!

The Arabs have used the "Palestinian" common people far worse than anyone else has, even the PA.

125 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:49:00am

re: #121 Gumby

Bear Down!

126 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:49:14am

re: #122 buzzsawmonkey

What some people say about Israel being blamed for minefield casualties is very likely true.

However, to the extent that a minefield would prevent the mass influx Hamas is planning, without endangering or traumatizing Israeli soldiers while at the same time reducing the hostile population works for me.

Would work for me as well, let the Palestinians kill themselves.

127 Kosh's Shadow  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:49:56am

re: #80 doriangrey

re: #73 BulgarWheat

re: #67 Kosh's Shadow

Now, there's a thought.

Except the Jew's are almost as troubled by pork as the Muslims. So who exactly would do the work and where would the pork come from?

Jews are forbidden from eating pork, and contact with pig carcasses does make one ritually impure (to offer sacrifices), but no one is ritually pure today anyway, and since there is no Temple, this isn't much of a problem.

128 Joshin  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:50:11am

A few dozen F16's doing fly by's at around 200' ought to send the Pali's running home.

129 Kosh's Shadow  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:51:30am

re: #90 buzzsawmonkey

re: #72 Kosh's Shadow

The Iran-Iraq war was "distant"; nobody in the West really gave much attention to "those countries" way back when.

Yes, Israel will be blamed, but Israel is always blamed. However, the up-close view of Hamassholes driving children into a minefield may just possibly wake some people up to just what Hamas actually is. More to the point, the Arabs who get to watch their children get blown to bits just over the next rise may lose a little of their support for Hamas.

Who's going to show those pictures on TV and newspapers? Maybe Fox, but certainly not the BBC, Al-Guardian, or the NY Slimes.

130 MJ  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:51:53am

re: #118 gman

"Funds keep pouring money into this country ..."


Never was an independent country called Palestine...

131 Dianna  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:52:22am

re: #112 LoFlyer

How about we wait until they actually commit a crime?

I'm really not patient with that line of thinking.

132 grumpy old codger  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:52:53am

Unfortunately, this will be a media disaster for Israel. for any other country, repulsion of this "invasion" by any means, including weapons fire, would be deemed appropriate. If the Israelis harm one child, the media will be up in arms about "war crimes", "excessive force", etc..
Despite this, I think that Israel should be prepared to use all, repeat all, necessary force to maintain their integrity. PS - Tell the IDF to switch to full automatic.

133 Iron Fist  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:53:35am

re: #117 lawhawk,

What you are really saying is that Israel will lose. Once Hamas successfully storms the border, it is all over with. The Jews migh as well flee to America, because at least we won't try to exterminate them.

And that is exactly what Hamas has in mind.

People cringe when I say exterminate Hamas, but all I am doing is echoing Hamas' rhetoric back at them.

Why has no one asked why I hate Hamas?

134 Cognito  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:53:54am

re: #29 Killgore Trout

re: #17 Cognito
Carl has some links from reliable sources.....
IDF bracing for breach of Gaza 'fence'

Interesting. I'm not quite seeing concrete plans of attack -- more the fear of attack -- but history gives us good reason not to expect Hamas to stage a peaceful hand-holding expression of discontent.

We'll see, I guess.

135 Adrenalyn  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:54:01am

re: #71 LoFlyer

re: #45 Adrenalyn


no, tear gas and bullets will not suffice
when this human wave comes in from the West/Gaza
the Hezbollassholes will start attacking from the north
just when the IDF is bogged down on the Gaza border
then Syria and Iran will join in

this could be something big

Israle may not only have to shoot the kids/women in Gaza
but send a nuclear message to Damascus and/or Tehran


I think you are over reacting with nuclear weapons. A cluster bomb will annihilate all life with a quarter mile. And the Israelis know how to use them. I believe this is going to be more of a rubber bullet, water cannon, tear gas response. I understand there are some new acoustic weapons that would be effective in repelling this type of assault. The Israeli military has never been afraid to "think outside the box" and apply innovative responses to attacks.

well, I am not so sure
Iran has said many times they will annihilate Israel when they have the capability and that beside that, just plain often state that Israel should be wiped out
but if the Gaza wave happens, and is a diversion for an assault from Hezbollah and/or other states
then Israel may have to resort to some drastic measures
and I don't think cluster bombs will suffice
if it were just the Gaza and Lobabomb borders
Hamas and Hezbollah, you could maintain control with conventional weapons but not with other forces entering the fight

136 Gumby  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:54:33am

re: #125 pre-Boomer Marine brat

re: #121 Gumby

Bear Down!

Who shot 'im?

137 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:54:58am

re: #131 Dianna

re: #112 LoFlyer

How about we wait until they actually commit a crime?

I'm really not patient with that line of thinking.


What do you mean wait until they have committed a crime? They have done nothing for the last 40 years but commit crime after crime. It's not a matter of if they are going to commit a crime only where and when.

138 Daisy  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:57:22am

re: #133 Iron Fist

re: #117 lawhawk,


"Why has no one asked why I hate Hamas?

"

Okay, why do you hate Hamass?

139 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:57:33am

re: #136 Gumby

re: #125 pre-Boomer Marine brat


re: #121 Gumby

Bear Down!


Who shot 'im?

It's cryptic. University of Arizona. (I'm a Lute Olson fan.)

140 Dirk Diggler  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:57:40am

Iron Fist,

People cringe when I say exterminate Hamas...

Not me. I applaud.

141 pat  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:58:26am

What? The Islamic model country is not Paradise?

142 Adrenalyn  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:58:46am

even if this is not a diversion for the all-out assault
you can bet it is at least a dry run for the eventual

143 Cognito  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:59:15am

re: #95 doriangrey

There are NO INNOCENT Palestinians. Even their children are willing subjects in this. They are indoctrinated from birth that to kill Israels and Jews is to please Allah.

So?

What are you advocating?

Take your time.

144 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:59:45am

re: #142 Adrenalyn

even if this is not a diversion for the all-out assault
you can bet it is at least a dry run for the eventual

Yup, pretty much a guarantee there...

145 cookielady  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:00:15pm

re: #75 Stonemason

re: #66 doriangrey

Israels reaction to anything Hamas does is up to Israel, calling for teh death of people on a blog is wrong, especially the innocents that will be in the line of fire

sorry, just my opinion and I will wait for the next thread.

I will call for the death of our enemies on blogs, on TV, on the radio, on the phone, and on my front lawn. All of our enemies. I want them all dead.

Too bad you have a problem with killing those that are out to kill you.

146 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:00:19pm
147 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:03:27pm

re: #143 Cognito

re: #95 doriangrey

There are NO INNOCENT Palestinians. Even their children are willing subjects in this. They are indoctrinated from birth that to kill Israels and Jews is to please Allah.

So?

What are you advocating?

Take your time.

I am not suggesting anything. I am making a solidly backed up statement. What are you suggesting. Until the Palestinians cease this behavior they all fully deserve whatever happens to them. Put a bomb on a five year old and send him near my family or friends and I'll shoot him dead on the spot, period.

148 attributor  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:03:28pm

But what is Israel to do in this situation?
What can Israel do to diminish the Hamas propaganda from this move?

149 Cognito  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:06:56pm

re: #147 doriangrey

re: #143 Cognito

re: #95 doriangrey

There are NO INNOCENT Palestinians. Even their children are willing subjects in this. They are indoctrinated from birth that to kill Israels and Jews is to please Allah.

So?

What are you advocating?

Take your time.

I am not suggesting anything. I am making a solidly backed up statement. What are you suggesting. Until the Palestinians cease this behavior they all fully deserve whatever happens to them. Put a bomb on a five year old and send him near my family or friends and I'll shoot him dead on the spot, period.

Well that's fine. What about the five-year-old without a bomb?

He's a Palestinian, as you said, also. What does he deserve?

150 Daisy  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:07:53pm

re: #119 MandyManners

This is just incomprehensible. The Kid is outside running with his dog, shouting for no good reason other than joyful abandon. I cannot wrap my mind around a mother allowing her child to be used as the Jordyptians are planning to use those children.

Moloch must be smiling in anticipation.

I know what you're saying. I wonder if comprehending the full extent of evil with our minds is even possible? Maybe it's more possible to accept the fact that human beings are fully capable of being caught in the grip of what they hate about themselves and therefore, cowardly project that self-hate onto others. We need to pay attention to the data (in this case, a willingness to murder one's own children in order to deny one's own failure to thrive) and act accordingly.

IMO, the Jews discovered a moral code like no other - which makes them targets of all peoples who would prefer to live by lower codes of behavior. Do you think this is a battle of good (or consciousness) vs (unconsciousness) evil or do you think that may be too simplistic?

151 cicero05  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:11:31pm

The always-objective L.A. Times has an article today telling how the Israelis killed some Arab "picnickers" in Gaza with a missile strike:

Three Palestinian men picnicking in a field in the northern Gaza Strip were killed Saturday by an Israeli tank missile, said a Palestinian official and relatives of the dead.

Three male "picknickers", ages 23, 25 and 26, just enjoying their tea together when those nasty Israelis ended the idyll with missiles. I guess all-male "picnics" are a palestinian pastime I hadn't heard much about. We all know how those muslims love their downtime.

But read further...

Khalil Zaaneen, a cousin of the student, said the field is part of his family's farm and is near sites used by militants to fire rockets and mortar shells across Israel's border, about 500 yards away. He said the family does not condone the rocket fire.

Ah! The "picnickers" happened to choose a picnic site that someone was using at that very moment to fire rockets into Israel. Bad luck that! Did the Times' editors ever stop to think that maybe reporter "Rushdi abu Alouf" was maybe, shading the story a bit?

This is a perfect example of the reason I canceled my subscription to the Times years ago. They peddle bullshit as news.

152 Ps2  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:12:33pm

israel's hope

[Link: www.stangoodenough.com...]

153 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:13:06pm

re: #149 Cognito

re: #147 doriangrey

re: #143 Cognito

re: #95 doriangrey

There are NO INNOCENT Palestinians. Even their children are willing subjects in this. They are indoctrinated from birth that to kill Israels and Jews is to please Allah.

So?

What are you advocating?

Take your time.

I am not suggesting anything. I am making a solidly backed up statement. What are you suggesting. Until the Palestinians cease this behavior they all fully deserve whatever happens to them. Put a bomb on a five year old and send him near my family or friends and I'll shoot him dead on the spot, period.

Well that's fine. What about the five-year-old without a bomb?

He's a Palestinian, as you said, also. What does he deserve?

He's a Palestinian, he's going to have a bomb. a Palestinian not brainwashed into wanting to kill Jews is like a democrat who wants America's to keep their money. It just isn't going to happen. Quit trying to play your pathetic moralist games with me. Their really is such a thing as evil, and little on this earth personifies it better than fanatical Muslims or Palestinians.

154 cookielady  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:13:20pm

re: #133 Iron Fist

Why has no one asked why I hate Hamas?



Most of us know why and concur heartily with your hatred.

155 Cognito  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:13:57pm

re: #153 doriangrey

He's a Palestinian, he's going to have a bomb.

Ah. I see we've moved from the realm of fact into the realm of fantasy.

No point in continuing.

156 Sunlight  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:14:02pm

The U.S. govt has spent mega$$ on this:
Active Denial - Wiki
Along with riot control tear gas, rubber bullets, etc., this situation could be a good proof-of-value for the Active Denial system. Deploy it in the south today; the Patriot system(s) deployed in the north creates a precedent for doing it.

157 Jauhara al Kafirah  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:17:59pm

re: #20 LeftJustAintRight

re: #18 Dianna

They'll give the kids copies of the koran and march them over the minefield. It's happened before.


And what are the kids gonna do with all those virgins?

They will get plastic keys, just as children were given during the Iraq/Iran wars. Also, remember, that's RAISINS.....72 RAISINS....kids just LOVE raisins.

158 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:20:40pm

re: #156 Sunlight

The U.S. govt has spent mega$$ on this:
Active Denial - Wiki
Along with riot control tear gas, rubber bullets, etc., this situation could be a good proof-of-value for the Active Denial system. Deploy it in the south today; the Patriot system(s) deployed in the north creates a precedent for doing it.

Any type of metallic foil will easily absorb and deflect the beam.

At last, a use for those tin-foil hats!

159 Killgore Trout  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:21:17pm

re: #149 Cognito

Disclaimer: I'm no no way defending dorian's position on this thread.

However, on a related topic; The Palestinians have really invented a new strategy. All through history leaders have surrendered when beaten. We had to nuke the Japanese twice but the leaders saw the witting on the wall and acted responsibly to protect their own citizens. The Palestinians have are trying to win by killing their own civilians. Even the Iraqi insurgency tried this tactic but the Iraqi citizens eventually got tired of it. The Palestinians have a seemingly endless capacity to suffer. As long as the citizens participate in this system, their own government will kill as many of them as possible. It's a fascinating process to watch.

160 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:21:22pm

re: #158 pre-Boomer Marine brat

PIMF -- the last sentence came from the Wiki article!

161 buzzsawmonkey[deleted]  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:21:51pm
162 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:23:57pm

re: #161 buzzsawmonkey

re: #157 Jauhara al Kafirah


Also, remember, that's RAISINS.....72 RAISINS....kids just LOVE raisins.

Martyrdom is the Muslim's raisin d'etre.

BARF!
(LOL)

163 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:24:10pm

re: #155 Cognito

re: #153 doriangrey

He's a Palestinian, he's going to have a bomb.

Ah. I see we've moved from the realm of fact into the realm of fantasy.

No point in continuing.

No, we moved into that realm the second you pulled the moralist redirection card of what about the five year old without a bomb. You have never had a valid point so there was no point in this conversation to start with, just you and your moral relativism bullshit.

164 eclectic infidel  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:24:23pm

re: #1 jaunte

"40,000 to 50,000 women and children would form a “human chain” stretching the length of the Gaza Strip."

That may be a record-setting number of human shields.

Indeed, and it's just what Hamas needs to make Israel look like the monster it accuses Israel of being should the IDF be forced into a confrontation with mere women & children.

165 Cognito  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:24:50pm

re: #159 Killgore Trout

re: #149 Cognito

Disclaimer: I'm no no way defending dorian's position on this thread.

However, on a related topic; The Palestinians have really invented a new strategy. All through history leaders have surrendered when beaten. We had to nuke the Japanese twice but the leaders saw the witting on the wall and acted responsibly to protect their own citizens. The Palestinians have are trying to win by killing their own civilians. Even the Iraqi insurgency tried this tactic but the Iraqi citizens eventually got tired of it. The Palestinians have a seemingly endless capacity to suffer. As long as the citizens participate in this system, their own government will kill as many of them as possible. It's a fascinating process to watch.

That's all true. And horrifying to watch.

166 Clio  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:25:05pm

re: #80 doriangrey

No, Jews are not comparable to Muslims on the subject of aversion to pigs.

In the laws on kosher food, the pig is only one of a number of animals that are not edible. That does not make it an object of superstition. The horse is also not edible, but there is no inhibition about riding a horse.

The reason that the pig has become particularly prominent as "not kosher" is that Judeophobes have historically tried to force Jews to eat pig meat as a way of renouncing their own lawa, or they have used refraining from pig-meat as a way of identifying Jews -- as done by the Spanish Inquisition.

Also, the pig is considered different from other domesticated animals in that it is of no use to mankind while it is alive. It does not give milk, eggs, wool, fleece, labor, or transportation. It is bred for no other purpose than to kill it, and that thought can cause some squeamishness about it.

167 Cognito  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:26:06pm

re: #163 doriangrey

I have to admit I'm curious how you're using the phrase "moral relativism." What two things am I relating, precisely?

168 Sunlight  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:26:13pm

re: #160 pre-Boomer Marine brat

re: #158 pre-Boomer Marine brat

PIMF -- the last sentence came from the Wiki article!

Even if... you think they have enough foil to cover lots of people head to toe?

169 eclectic infidel  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:26:44pm

re: #101 doriangrey

re: #92 Nevergiveup

re: #80 doriangrey

re: #73 BulgarWheat

re: #67 Kosh's Shadow

Now, there's a thought.

Except the Jew's are almost as troubled by pork as the Muslims. So who exactly would do the work and where would the pork come from?

Well if you haven't been in Israel lately, there is quite a bit of " white meat( white meat = pork) "available to secular Israelis than you would ever imagine!

I am surprised....

Friends who have spent time in Israel tell me that all one needs to do to acquire pork is to shop at a Christian market.

170 Cognito  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:28:08pm

re: #167 Cognito

re: #163 doriangrey

I have to admit I'm curious how you're using the phrase "moral relativism." What two things am I relating, precisely?

Actually, don't worry about it -- moving along.

- C

171 Iron Fist  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:30:45pm

re: #138 Daisy,

Because they are scum. Because they kill children and call it good. Because they teach children to hate, and call it good.

Because they want to destroy Israel. I doubt America is more than a cypher to them. They hate us, but the same way a man hates mosquitoes. We don't do anything to them really, we just are.

And I hate them for that, too. Every time they have "Death to America" get togethers, I want us to bomb them.

Good enough?

172 pre-Boomer Marine brat  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:32:56pm

re: #168 Sunlight

re: #160 pre-Boomer Marine brat


re: #158 pre-Boomer Marine brat

PIMF -- the last sentence came from the Wiki article!


Even if... you think they have enough foil to cover lots of people head to toe?

Oh, you're right. I was being cute with the tinfoil-hat reference.

173 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:36:58pm

re: #167 Cognito

re: #163 doriangrey

I have to admit I'm curious how you're using the phrase "moral relativism." What two things am I relating, precisely?

Oh please you are pathetic. Moral relativism isn't about comparing two moral situations, its a philosophy where morals are dictated by situations rather than absolutes. Teaching ones children that killing innocent people because Allah will be pleased is absolutly evil. When all polls ever taken show that 80 percent of Palestinians give active approval to efforts to commit genocide against Israel's Jews and the other 20 percent give passive support there is simply no possible way morally ethically or logically to suggest that any Palestinian is innocent of intent to to take action or support the killing of innocent Israeli citizens.

174 Cognito  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:39:54pm

re: #173 doriangrey

Teaching ones children that killing innocent people because Allah will be pleased is absolutly evil.

Of course it is. I haven't said otherwise, and never would.

But this makes the parents evil, not the children.

175 guftafs  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:41:40pm

What would a breach in the Gaza-Israel fence mean? Wouldn't it be sealed relatively quickly regardless?

176 Roger  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:46:17pm

re: #174 Cognito

It quickly makes the children evil. Doesn't take long.

177 Cognito  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:47:34pm

re: #176 Roger

re: #174 Cognito

It quickly makes the children evil. Doesn't take long.

No, it doesn't. Evil is a choice. Someone incapable of making his or her own choices, then, can't be evil.

They can be the puppets of evil parents, but no more.

178 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:47:41pm

re: #174 Cognito

re: #173 doriangrey

Teaching ones children that killing innocent people because Allah will be pleased is absolutly evil.

Of course it is. I haven't said otherwise, and never would.

But this makes the parents evil, not the children.

Wrong answer clyde, It makes everyone involved, children included evil. Thats the problem with evil, it contaminate everything it comes into contact with. Those children would have to be completely removed from any contact with their parent and their parents society, completely re-programmed and even then the rate of successfully de-programming them from the evil that has been inflicted on them would be pitifully low.

179 Daisy  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:47:53pm

re: #171 Iron Fist

re: #138 Daisy,

Because they are scum. Because they kill children and call it good. Because they teach children to hate, and call it good.

Because they want to destroy Israel. I doubt America is more than a cypher to them. They hate us, but the same way a man hates mosquitoes. We don't do anything to them really, we just are.

And I hate them for that, too. Every time they have "Death to America" get togethers, I want us to bomb them.

Good enough?

Yes. I understand completely.

180 Roger  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:48:43pm

re: #177 Cognito

How do you think they've kept this going for generations?

181 Jauhara al Kafirah  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:49:32pm

re: #161 buzzsawmonkey

Golden raisins are called Sultanas. Now I know why.

182 Palandine  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:49:34pm

re: #7 Iron Fist

Ma Duce. M-2 heavy machine gun.

Rake the crowds until they go away.

There is no reason that Hamas should be successful at storming the border. None whatsoever.

Snipers. I'd like to see the IDF taking out the adult men attacking one by one, each one's head disappearing in a red mist. The sensible women and children would get the hell out.

If the "Palestinians" are going to try to invade Israel, Israel must be able to respond.

183 Miss Molly  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:50:15pm

I was about to ask Iron Fist why he hated Hamas but the answer has been given and understood. Looks like there will have to be built a "no mans" zone to protect Israel on the Gaza boarder and to protect the Gaza children since the Muslims doen't seem to care all that much about protecting their own children.

184 kenprice  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:50:27pm

Riot control police have a lot of options available. Ordinary tear gas (CN) is the least of the worries the Pali's have. Next step up is "vomiting gas" (CS) and microwave pain projectors. Mix the CS and CN together and you get real interesting results. I don't care how determined the Pali's are, they're not going to withstand what Israel can throw at them. I don't think there are enough gas masks in Gaza to make a difference.

185 Occasional Reader  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:50:53pm

Every Palestinian child is born as innocent as any other child. Of course, their sick society gets to work on them pretty quickly (with genocidal anthropomorphic bees on TV, etc.).

186 Cognito  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:51:08pm

re: #180 Roger

re: #177 Cognito

How do you think they've kept this going for generations?

When the children become old enough to account for their own actions, they are choosing to become evil.

Their parents have left little room for diversion, at that point, but still everyone becomes accountable for his own actions when he is old enough to understand them.

187 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:51:48pm

re: #177 Cognito

re: #176 Roger

re: #174 Cognito

It quickly makes the children evil. Doesn't take long.

No, it doesn't. Evil is a choice. Someone incapable of making his or her own choices, then, can't be evil.

They can be the puppets of evil parents, but no more.

Again wrong answer clyde, once the programming as been started it feeds itself. One need look no further than the learned behaviors common to mankind to know this. Children of alcoholic have ten times the rate of alcoholism as those whose parents are not alcoholics, child of abusive parents have 10 times the rate of being abusive people as adults as those not raised by abusive parents, and it almost doesnt matter how young they are when they are separated from those parents.

188 Promethea  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:52:13pm

re: #77 nyc redneck

israel is must have the will to survive and do what it takes to insure that. otherwise, bad people who have bad plans for them will decide their future.

This is the crux of the problem. Being "Mr. Nice Guy" can sometimes lead to more trouble rather than less trouble.

189 Da_Beerfreak  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:53:17pm
re: #2 Sharmuta

Organisers said Hamas-controlled schools across Gaza would get time off to allow students to take part in the protest.

Considering the type of education we've seen coming out of their schools, I'd say this was less time off than it is a field trip.

With an opportunity to receive extra credit for becoming a Martyr.

190 Roger  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:53:41pm

re: #186 Cognito

That's if they have the conceptual minds like the West. Bu for some of them they can be over 30 and still don't understand the evil of their actions. They are a deceived people.

191 Palandine  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:53:56pm

re: #39 Daisy

"40,000 to 50,000 women and children would form a “human chain” stretching the length of the Gaza Strip."

Could Islamists possibly be more cowardly?

An doesn't it illustrate wonderfully that even the Islamists acknowledge the inherent righteousness of the Israelis? They KNOW the Israelis would never mow down women and children, which is why they are hiding behind them. Yet, all the while, the Islamists strive to kill Israeli women and children, rather than those who might fight back.

Strange how the world chooses not to see the obvious.

192 Occasional Reader  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:54:46pm

And the IDF will not, ever, open up on a line of schoolkids with M2's; ever. There has to be more creative thinking about this. The minefield idea is better; lay it, mark it clearly (like we do with ours in Korea), and then if Hamas shovels kids into it at gunpoint, even a creative Reuters cameraman will have trouble disguising who's responsible.

Another idea is for the IDF to disrupt the whole plan, by going on the offensive against Hamas targets beginning the day before the planned "protest". Make THEM hunker down.

193 Cognito  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:55:03pm

re: #190 Roger

re: #186 Cognito

That's if they have the conceptual minds like the West. Bu for some of them they can be over 30 and still don't understand the evil of their actions. They are a deceived people.

But then, we weren't talking about 30-year-olds.

194 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:55:24pm

re: #185 Occasional Reader

Every Palestinian child is born as innocent as any other child. Of course, their sick society gets to work on them pretty quickly (with genocidal anthropomorphic bees on TV, etc.).

They may be born innocent, but by the age of five that innocence is long gone. The Palestinians haven't managed to keep their homicidal hatred of Israel going for the last 60 years because they allow any of their children to not be indoctrinated or infected with their genocidal hatred.

195 cookielady  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:55:55pm

re: #166 Clio

Also, the pig is considered different from other domesticated animals in that it is of no use to mankind while it is alive. It does not give milk, eggs, wool, fleece, labor, or transportation.

Actually, pigs are the smartest and cleanest of domesticated animals, given the opportunity to be so. Unlike other livestock, they never 'go' where they eat. They are easily trained, and they can be used to pulls carts or find delicacies (truffles and mushrooms) with their excellent olfactory prowess; they have even been trained to sniff out drugs. Their problem is their physical deficiencies: they can't run fast or far, they can't jump worth a darn, and heat kills them too easily (the rolling in mud thing is to cool them and block biting bugs). We have bred most of their original ability to survive on their own out of them. Slow pigs with short legs are much easier to take care of, in other words.

And now, in these days of the Attack of Islam, pigs have come into their own as the most useful animal of all. Even their poo would be useful, if we had the sense to use it.

Thus endeth my defense of the Swine.

196 So?  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:56:39pm

Israel should herd in 1000s of pigs and spread them out along the border with tons of pig food.

197 Occasional Reader  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:57:19pm

re: #194 doriangrey

And so, just to be clear; are you arguing in favor of the IDF gunning down Palestinian 5 year-olds?

198 boazhorribilis  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:58:45pm

re: #169 eclectic infidel

re: #101 doriangrey


re: #92 Nevergiveup

re: #80 doriangrey

re: #73 BulgarWheat

re: #67 Kosh's Shadow

Now, there's a thought.


Except the Jew's are almost as troubled by pork as the Muslims. So who exactly would do the work and where would the pork come from?

Well if you haven't been in Israel lately, there is quite a bit of " white meat( white meat = pork) "available to secular Israelis than you would ever imagine!

I am surprised....

Friends who have spent time in Israel tell me that all one needs to do to acquire pork is to shop at a Christian market.

Or a non kosher Jewish shop.

199 Roger  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 12:59:08pm

re: #193 Cognito

We're talking about future 30 year olds and how they get there. It doesn't take long. Accountability starts a lot younger than a coddled West would think.

200 Shay4l  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:01:52pm

"And they’re releasing children from school so they can be on the front line."


Such despicable people! They'll have their cameras ready hoping and praying for dead children. They may even have to do it themselves....

201 Cognito  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:03:21pm

re: #199 Roger

re: #193 Cognito

We're talking about future 30 year olds and how they get there. It doesn't take long. Accountability starts a lot younger than a coddled West would think.

Perhaps. But I know children -- children -- are not accountable. In a land of loudly pretending victims, they are silently the real thing.

202 cookielady  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:03:46pm

re: #200 Shay4l

"And they’re releasing children from school so they can be on the front line."


Such despicable people! They'll have their cameras ready hoping and praying for dead children. They may even have to do it themselves....

Their children are a resource, cannon fodder, and p.r. material. That is all. They hope and pray that their children will be killed or will kill themselves in an attempt to kill Jews. That is their highest dream for the child they bore and held in their arms.

These are a demonic people.

203 cookielady  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:05:04pm

re: #201 Cognito

There are absolutes. There is right and wrong.

And

But I know children -- children -- are not accountable. In a land of loudly pretending victims, they are silently the real thing.

is absolutely right.

204 Roger  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:05:19pm

re: #201 Cognito

Your poetry lost me. Actually incomprehensible.

205 Occasional Reader  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:06:18pm

Cognito, I see you already covered the "what are you advocating" point. And apparently, all Palestinian children always have bombs with them. (So we're told by dorian.) So I withdraw my question in #197.

206 Cognito  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:06:46pm

re: #205 Occasional Reader

Cognito, I see you already covered the "what are you advocating" point. And apparently, all Palestinian children always have bombs with them. (So we're told by dorian.) So I withdraw my question in #197.

Yeah. It's been weird.

207 TimeQuake  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:08:37pm

They're teaching their children to hate and kill. We're emasculating our kids. How's that going to work out in a generation or two?

208 So?  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:09:39pm

I read somewhere that the US had developed a new "heat gun". It emits microwaves or something (don't remeber exactly) that's heats up the skin's temperature to intolerable levels. No human can withstand it for more than a few seconds. The US should lend this newly (?) developed crowd control weapon to Israel just for the occasion being planned by Hamas.

209 Occasional Reader  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:10:45pm

re: #207 TimeQuake

They're teaching their children to hate and kill. We're emasculating our kids. How's that going to work out in a generation or two?

Actually, I think our kids will do just fine. We have 20 year olds in Iraq and Afghanistan working wonders, who were "kids" just a few sort years ago. And I think their kids will either have to pull out of this death spiral (somehow), or self-destruct.

210 So?  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:10:45pm

By the way, it's non-lethal.

211 Occasional Reader  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:12:04pm

re: #208 So?

I read somewhere that the US had developed a new "heat gun". It emits microwaves or something (don't remeber exactly) that's heats up the skin's temperature to intolerable levels. No human can withstand it for more than a few seconds. The US should lend this newly (?) developed crowd control weapon to Israel just for the occasion being planned by Hamas.

Me, I think Israel should be prepared to display giant holographic images of Helen Thomas at the borderline. Geneva Conventions be damned.

212 guftafs  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:12:17pm

re: #197 Occasional Reader

re: #194 doriangrey

And so, just to be clear; are you arguing in favor of the IDF gunning down Palestinian 5 year-olds?

It's a long standing tactic of the "Palestinians" to use children as fighters.

In the 12 year civil war in Lebanon, Arafat recruited eleven year olds to become what was described by the press as RPG kids. An RPG (Rocket-Propelled Grenade) is a shoulder fired missile, used against ground vehicles. An RPG doesn't know that the finger on its trigger is just 11 years old. Their eyesight is young and clear; the weapon fires and people are killed. What a lesson for kids! Arafat's motive was that Israeli soldiers would hesitate to shoot kids. It worked. Many Israelis became victims as they did, indeed, hesitate in defending themselves against armed kids. ([Link: www.teachkidspeace.com...]

And this is how they behave today
[Link: www.pmw.org.il...] > PA Television . Video Library > Children are combatants in PA Ideology

213 cookielady  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:12:32pm

re: #207 TimeQuake

They're teaching their children to hate and kill. We're emasculating our kids. How's that going to work out in a generation or two?

I'm teaching my daughters to revere warriors and to be crack shots themselves. What are other Lizards doing to turn the tide? I'm interested in what we can do as a group of informed and determined people to disable the emasculators, if you know what I mean, to block the efficacy of what the socialist/liberal axis of evil has been attempting to complete before it is too late.

214 Occasional Reader  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:12:37pm

re: #209 Occasional Reader

"sort" = "short", gah

215 TimeQuake  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:13:52pm

re: #209 Occasional Reader

their kids will either have to pull out of this death spiral (somehow), or self-destruct.

I hope you are right.

216 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:15:07pm

re: #197 Occasional Reader

re: #194 doriangrey

And so, just to be clear; are you arguing in favor of the IDF gunning down Palestinian 5 year-olds?

I'm advocating that the IDF shoot anyone, five year olds included, that attempt to cross their border during this planned invasion. Being a human shield for homicidal psychopaths is every bit the act of evil that the homicidal psychopaths intend to perpetrate on Israel. If Hamas want to use the Palestinian women and children as human shields then the life's of those human shields was forfeited by those who made the decision to use them for their evil enterprise, and any deaths that occur as a result are solely the responsibility of those who planned and executed the event.


Does that make my position clear enough. Am I being a stubborn hard ass about this, you bet your ass I am. One of my childhood best friends dads was killed in Vietnam when a five year old walked up to him as he was passing out food and candy, the five year old had a hand grenade, the pin had already been pulled. My friends dad and two other US Marines died. For me this is cut and dried, nothing to debate, nothing to moralize, nothing to rationalize.

The second that that hand grenade was put into that kids hand he was dead. The same is true of any Palestinian kid used as a human shield, they are already dead the only question is how many others will they take with them. More importantly is the fact that this is exactly the question that those responsible are asking themselves. How many lives can we trade for each of these human shields.

It is the zenith, the absolute apogee of evil to employ tactics such as this, and the only thing worse is to allow such tactic to be used against yourself.

217 Occasional Reader  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:16:08pm

re: #212 guftafs

In the 12 year civil war in Lebanon, Arafat recruited eleven year olds to become what was described by the press as RPG kids.

And of course Hitler did the same thing in the closing days of the War, with Hilter Youth and the Panzerfaust (from which the Soviet RPG line is a direct descendant, if I'm not mistaken).

Nobody is arguing that you can't fire at children who are actually shooting at you. The question is, if they're "all evil", are you advocating targeting them even if they're playing hopscotch.

218 TimeQuake  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:17:24pm

re: #213 cookielady

I think that is wonderful (as I am a gun owner and practice as much as I can). But I believe you and others like you, are the exception to the rule. The public school system is making our kids weak and impotent. Especially boys. Girls, I shudder to think what they are doing to the girls.

This site changed my mind completely about feminism and I never even burned a bra but felt that the movement was a good idea. Now I don't think it worked out like it should have.

219 Cognito  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:17:28pm

re: #217 Occasional Reader

Exactly.

220 Occasional Reader  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:17:49pm

re: #213 cookielady

I'm teaching my daughters to revere warriors and to be crack shots themselves.

That's good, as long as you're also teaching them to be politically active... on behalf of freedom. Our society is indestructible, as long as we keep a robust sense of self. With that in place, it won't matter whether your daughters are crack shot or not!

221 Occasional Reader  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:19:01pm

re: #217 Occasional Reader

Hilter Youth... stupid, stupid fingers, I hates you, hates you

222 So?  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:19:39pm

Here it is...not ready till 2010? But we need it now!

223 Palandine  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:21:01pm

re: #195 cookielady

Also, they're tasty. :)

Although the feral hogs are tearing up some of the good hiking spots in Missouri--especially Bell Mountain.

However, it's open season on 'em--you can shoot any feral hog at any time.

Tasty, and target practice. ;)

224 Occasional Reader  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:22:07pm

re: #222 So?

Here it is...not ready till 2010? But we need it now!

I love it... it looks like a weapon from an old Godzilla movie! (They had military vehicles with these parabolic antennae that shot lighting bolts at the Big G... they only pissed him off, of course, but they looked cool)

225 guftafs  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:23:03pm

re: #217 Occasional Reader

re: #217 Occasional Reader

re: #212 guftafs

Nobody is arguing that you can't fire at children who are actually shooting at you. The question is, if they're "all evil", are you advocating targeting them even if they're playing hopscotch.

OK, I see what you mean. No, I think such indiscriminate killing would be pointless from any rational standpoint. What purpose would that serve?

226 Iron Fist  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:24:00pm

re: #217 Occasional Reader,

No one said anything about targeting them if they are playing hopscotch.

It is another thing entirely to allow a human wave attack to succeed because the front of the wave is made up of children.

If you allow it to succeed, then you have given your enemy an invincible method of attack.

You can't survive that.

227 Occasional Reader  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:24:11pm

re: #223 Palandine

Also, they're tasty. :)

Homer: Are you saying you're never going to eat any animal again? What about bacon?
Lisa: No.
Homer: Ham?
Lisa: No.
Homer: Pork chops?
Lisa: Dad, those all come from the same animal!
Homer: Heh heh heh. Ooh, yeah, right, Lisa. A wonderful, magical animal.

228 eastvillageinfidel  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:25:31pm

I would like to take this opportunity to point out an important difference between our culture and that of our enemy. We argue passionately about the almost unimaginable horror of possibly being in the position of having to kill children in combat. Our enemy plots with casual cunning how to make the most efficient use of their childrens death. Just an observation.

229 Dr. Shalit  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:26:32pm

Whatever happens, it WILL BE UGLY.
-S-

230 Occasional Reader  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:27:03pm

re: #226 Iron Fist

No one said anything about targeting them if they are playing hopscotch.

But the "they're all evil, even the toddlers" arguments (not you, others) head straight in that direction.

It is another thing entirely to allow a human wave attack to succeed because the front of the wave is made up of children.

And as I said above, I think Israel has other, better options for dealing with this.

231 Occasional Reader  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:28:39pm

re: #228 eastvillageinfidel

Our enemy plots with casual cunning how to make the most efficient use of their childrens death.

And of course they also indoctrinate their children into a death cult at an early age; and throw parties - literally - when they manage to murder Jewish children.

232 TimeQuake  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:29:14pm

re: #226 Iron Fist

And if it works, it will be all the rage with militant Jihad worldwide.

233 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:31:16pm

re: #226 Iron Fist

re: #217 Occasional Reader,

No one said anything about targeting them if they are playing hopscotch.

It is another thing entirely to allow a human wave attack to succeed because the front of the wave is made up of children.

If you allow it to succeed, then you have given your enemy an invincible method of attack.

You can't survive that.

Yup, same kind of bullshit Cognito tried throwing into his argument. It's a moral relativist bait and switch.

234 Occasional Reader  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:31:57pm

(In any event, I don't know if the Ma Deuce would be my first choice against a human wave attack... rate of fire is a little too low. Give me something in the 800 - 1200 rounds/min range.)

235 guftafs  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:32:34pm

re: #226 Iron Fist

I was just thinking about adding that. If Hamas goes through with what has been suggested here, then I'm all for that the IDF should target the masses of people allowing the incursion to proceed, including women and children. In a sane world that would be a sane choice. Maybe if Israel recorded in detail the whole unfolding of events and published it everywhere with their own explanations, so that the tactics of the Palestinians were clear for all to see people would understand why it would be necessary to mow them down.

/lost every shred of sympathy for the "Palestinians" when he saw them taking pleasure out of the mindless slaughter of Americans on 9/11

236 Cognito  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:32:57pm

re: #233 doriangrey

Honestly, having read this, and your most recent post on the next thread, I'm coming to realize you simply don't understand the arguments at hand.

So that's that, I suppose.

237 Occasional Reader  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:34:42pm

re: #233 doriangrey

re: #233 doriangrey

bait and switch

Please tell me what was the "bait and switch". Specifically. Thanks.

238 guftafs  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:36:55pm

re: #234 Occasional Reader

(In any event, I don't know if the Ma Deuce would be my first choice against a human wave attack... rate of fire is a little too low. Give me something in the 800 - 1200 rounds/min range.)

How about mortars?

239 So?  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:37:08pm

re: #232 TimeQuake

re: #226 Iron Fist

And if it works, it will be all the rage with militant Jihad worldwide.

If it works, the swarms will come from all over the mid-east to invade Israel. I have a feeling while this so called march is going on rockets will be flying into Sedrot and Hizbullah will launch from Lebanon.

And wouldn't breaching this wall be considered an in INVASION into a soverign state who has ever right to defend themselves with any means necessary.

Imagine 100,000 Kurds marching into Turkey...guess what the response of the Turkish government would be? But Israel always has to have its hands tied.

240 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:41:36pm

re: #230 Occasional Reader

re: #226 Iron Fist

But the "they're all evil, even the toddlers" arguments (not you, others) head straight in that direction.

.

Wrong, you cannot fight an enemy you refuse to acknowledge is your enemy. You cannot solve a problem you refuse to grasp as a problem. Since there is no intervening in the Palestinian indoctrination of their children anyone who fails to grasp the nature of the situation is a self deluded fool.

Their children are already corrupt and evil, because their is absolutly zero chance of halting the indoctrination and infection of them by the evil that corrupts their parents. Like the five year old Vietnamese child that killed my friends dad, their fate has already been decided AND THERE IS NO CHANGING IT. To pretend otherwise is to indulge in a fantasy that will get countless innocent people killed.

241 TimeQuake  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:42:25pm

re: #239 So?

Sovereignty only applies to Muslim nations these days. All other countries are up for grabs...including ours (USA).

242 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:42:34pm

re: #236 Cognito

re: #233 doriangrey

Honestly, having read this, and your most recent post on the next thread, I'm coming to realize you simply don't understand the arguments at hand.

So that's that, I suppose.

What ever you say KELLER...

243 Cognito  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:43:07pm

re: #240 doriangrey

re: #230 Occasional Reader

re: #226 Iron Fist

But the "they're all evil, even the toddlers" arguments (not you, others) head straight in that direction.

.


Their children are already corrupt and evil, because their is absolutly zero chance of halting the indoctrination and infection of them by the evil that corrupts their parents. Like the five year old Vietnamese child that killed my friends dad, their fate has already been decided AND THERE IS NO CHANGING IT. To pretend otherwise is to indulge in a fantasy that will get countless innocent people killed.

That's disgusting, and gives LGF a bad name.

Stop. Seriously.

244 Da_Beerfreak  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:45:49pm
re: #59 Iron Fist

re: #11 Dianna,

We have to harden our hearts. The enemy is willing to cause any level of atrocity.

We have to be willing to meet them with it. Certainly, we should kill the leaders first, wherever we can.

I have always advocated the extermination of Hamas. All of them. They are slime who would march children into M-2 fire.

Kill all of them, and we don't have to worry about what we would do about a human wave headed by children.

"War is cruelty. There's no use trying to reform it, the crueler it is the sooner it will be over."
-- William Tecumseh Sherman --

245 So?  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:45:55pm

I'll repeat this part of my last post:

Imagine 100,000 Kurds marching into Turkey...guess what the response of the Turkish government would be?

246 mean Gene  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:46:43pm

This puts another (yet another) nail in the coffin of the ''shiite won't work along with sunni'' garbage used to claim Saddam wouldn't help Osama.
Hamas and Iran, Syria and the lebanese land and hezb'allah, fatah in West Banok all will work together long enough to destroy Israel.
Only later will they turn on one another.
This is just round I-don't-know-what-round-it-is-anymore.
Round X.

247 Iron Fist  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:46:48pm

re: #234 Occasional Reader,

I'm looking at depth of penetration. An M-2 round isn't stopped by what it first hits.
Have you ever been to the Knob Creek machine gun shoot? The main firing line is pretty much all M-2s. It is incredibly devastating. Nothing will make it through that.

Nothing.

They could certainly be backed up with M-249's, M-60's, hell, for that matter M-19's (WP really sucks). The point is to stop the human wave. That means massive casualties.

There is simply no way around that. Cause the most casualties in the shortest amount of time, and you probably minimize the total number of casualties.

It is the horrible calculus of such an action.

248 Occasional Reader  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:47:17pm

re: #240 doriangrey

Wrong, you cannot fight an enemy you refuse to acknowledge is your enemy.

Interesting that you declare me "wrong", and then in the very same sentence reinforce the point I'm making.

You keep dodging the question. If you think all Palestinian children - even 5 year olds (your example, not mine) - are irredeemably "corrupt and evil", would you support the IDF targeting them, anywhere any time? Yes, or no?

249 Da_Beerfreak  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:48:23pm

Israel needs a W.T. Sherman.

250 alibey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:49:07pm

re: #14 karmic_inquisitor

re: #7 Iron Fist

Ma Duce. M-2 heavy machine gun.

Rake the crowds until they go away.

There is no reason that Hamas should be successful at storming the border. None whatsoever.

Can't used the M2 on personnel. But you can use it on their equipment.

Aim for their Official Hamas Headbands.

Actually, there is nothing against using the M2 against personnel. It is just one of those myths like not being able to shoot paratroopers out of the sky. I loved correcting the troopers from 82nd on that fact.

Straight Leg and proud of it.

251 guftafs  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:49:31pm

re: #243 Cognito


re: #240 doriangrey

re: #230 Occasional Reader

re: #226 Iron Fist

But the "they're all evil, even the toddlers" arguments (not you, others) head straight in that direction.

.


Their children are already corrupt and evil, because their is absolutly zero chance of halting the indoctrination and infection of them by the evil that corrupts their parents. Like the five year old Vietnamese child that killed my friends dad, their fate has already been decided AND THERE IS NO CHANGING IT. To pretend otherwise is to indulge in a fantasy that will get countless innocent people killed.

That's disgusting, and gives LGF a bad name.

Stop. Seriously.

It is disgusting but it is a fact that must be recognized that you cannot treat the children reared in murderous regimes such as the Nazi or "Palestinian" as normal children. They aren't. This doesn't mean you kill them indiscriminately, but you acknowledge that they will participate in the fighting and you treat them accordingly. War is not nice.

252 guftafs  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:51:15pm

re: #248 Occasional Reader

re: #240 doriangrey

Wrong, you cannot fight an enemy you refuse to acknowledge is your enemy.

Interesting that you declare me "wrong", and then in the very same sentence reinforce the point I'm making.

You keep dodging the question. If you think all Palestinian children - even 5 year olds (your example, not mine) - are irredeemably "corrupt and evil", would you support the IDF targeting them, anywhere any time? Yes, or no?

But that question isn't relevant, is it? Why do you need an answer to that question?

253 Occasional Reader  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:51:31pm

re: #247 Iron Fist

Have you ever been to the Knob Creek machine gun shoot?

No. [sulk] STOP TORMENTING ME!

I'm looking at depth of penetration. An M-2 round isn't stopped by what it first hits.

True, dat.

There is simply no way around that. Cause the most casualties in the shortest amount of time

... and the Hamas leadership will be high-fiving each other over their public relations victory. Like I said, I think Israel kind find more creative ways of dealing with this specific threat.

I do agree with you, however, on the "destroy Hamas" idea.

254 Iron Fist  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:53:59pm

re: #253 Occasional Reader,

Gotta run. I won't say it has been a fun afternoon (discussing how to massecre human wave attacks), but, well, you know what I mean.

:-)

255 Occasional Reader  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:54:11pm

re: #252 guftafs

But that question isn't relevant, is it?

doriangrey has made it relevant. He's the one pushing beyond the bounds of "is it moral to fire at children who are being used as combatants", and gone on to declare that all Pali children, all the time, are evil, enemies, always have a bomb, etc. I want to see if he really means it. I'm taking his argument to its logical conclusion.

256 Occasional Reader  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:55:24pm

re: #253 Occasional Reader

kind find

Can't blame that one on my fingers... "can" find

257 AuntAcid  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:55:34pm

For reasons I know not, other than a nice lunch and a glass of wine, this comes to mind.

From Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet, 1594:

JULIET:
'Tis but thy name that is my enemy;
Thou art thyself, though not a Montague.
What's Montague? it is nor hand, nor foot,
Nor arm, nor face, nor any other part
Belonging to a man. O, be some other name!
What's in a name? that which we call a rose
By any other name would smell as sweet;
So Romeo would, were he not Romeo call'd,
Retain that dear perfection which he owes
Without that title. Romeo, doff thy name,
And for that name which is no part of thee
Take all myself.

258 Dirk Diggler  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:57:07pm

So?

If it works, the swarms will come from all over the mid-east to invade Israel. I have a feeling while this so called march is going on rockets will be flying into Sedrot and Hizbullah will launch from Lebanon.

Yup. It's an invasion.

I am totally indifferent to the self-inflicted suffering of those "poor, dispossesed" Palestinians.

The whole lot of them.

Israel needs to defend itself even if it means "children" trying to storm border outposts are killed. If you don't like the fact that children have been put on the front lines of theis conflict, then (for once) place the blame at the feet of the corrupt and bloodthirsty Palestinian leadership.

259 mean Gene  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:57:07pm

The demographics of Gaza:
Population 1,482,405
0-14 years: 47.6% of the total poulation.
16 years is the median age of the whole population.
5.64 children born/woman.
What else can they do but send children.
It is all that they have.

Of Israel:
Population 6,426,679
0-14 years: 26.1%
15-64 years: 64.2% (many more adults)
Median age in Israel is 29.9 years.
2.38 children born/woman

260 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 1:57:43pm

re: #237 Occasional Reader

re: #233 doriangrey

re: #233 doriangrey

bait and switch

Please tell me what was the "bait and switch". Specifically. Thanks.

The interjection of hypothetical conditions wherein specific situations can be redirect to relative moralistic judgments. The specifics in this case being the inherent nature of Palestinian society.

The fact that it is not possible to intervene in Palestinian society and bring about any cessation of the vile homicidal indoctrination of their children, totally and completely negates any suggestion that those who will be indoctrinated into this evil are anything other than evil.

The introduction of the false dilemma pretext of an innocent child into a social structure where that child has absolutly no chance of retaining the innocent nature it was born with is the bate and switch.

The child is not innocent, because it has no chance to be innocent. It's future course has already been determined and sealed in stone as it were. Any allusion that the situation is in any way other than depicted serves only to buttress the morally relativistic bait and switch. It is not real, has no chance of ever being real and therefore serves only to provide an imaginary high ground for the morally relative argument.

261 Occasional Reader  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 2:01:13pm

re: #260 doriangrey

I asked you a question. Yes or no. Please answer.

(By the way, never use a long word when a diminutive one will do.)

262 FIVEOFNINE  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 2:02:25pm

dump pig dung, that would stop them

263 Cognito  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 2:04:19pm

re: #261 Occasional Reader

re: #260 doriangrey

I asked you a question. Yes or no. Please answer.

(By the way, never use a long word when a diminutive one will do.)

But when the indiminutive word extrapolates to the interjection of hypothetical cessation in the... fractal... intelligible... taco... aw, crap.

264 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 2:05:50pm

re: #252 guftafs

re: #248 Occasional Reader

re: #240 doriangrey

Wrong, you cannot fight an enemy you refuse to acknowledge is your enemy.

Interesting that you declare me "wrong", and then in the very same sentence reinforce the point I'm making.

You keep dodging the question. If you think all Palestinian children - even 5 year olds (your example, not mine) - are irredeemably "corrupt and evil", would you support the IDF targeting them, anywhere any time? Yes, or no?

But that question isn't relevant, is it? Why do you need an answer to that question?

He keeps trying to get an answer that makes him feel soft and cuddly and warn inside. I have not anywhere made any assertion advocating the indiscriminate wholesale slaughter of the Palestinian people. What I have asserted it the the notion of the possibility of innocent Palestinians possibly dying while other Palestinians attempt to kill innocent Israeli's is a notion that is logically morally and intellectually bankrupt.

265 Occasional Reader  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 2:10:43pm

re: #264 doriangrey

He keeps trying to get an answer that makes him feel soft and cuddly and warn inside.

Actually, I'm just trying to get a straight answer out of you, period.

But you make John Kerry look like Will Frickkin' Rogers in this regard.

So here's my third request on that question in #248. Yes, or no? (By the way, my answer is "no". Your turn.)

266 Geepers  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 2:11:34pm

I've always known Occasional Reader wants to be soft and cuddly and warn inside.

267 Occasional Reader  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 2:12:21pm

re: #266 Geepers

I've always known Occasional Reader wants to be soft and cuddly

OKAY OKAY I NEED TO GET THE GYM MORE, I GET IT!

268 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 2:14:05pm

re: #261 Occasional Reader

re: #260 doriangrey

I asked you a question. Yes or no. Please answer.

(By the way, never use a long word when a diminutive one will do.)

No, you never asked a question, you pretended to ask a question, while phrasing a metaphorical statement of moral and ethical superiority as a question. It was at best a rhetorical question where you presupposed what the answer would be before the answer was given and couched your question in such a manner as to lead to an intractable appearance propriety.

I have never made any statement advocating the indiscriminate killing of Palestinians. The fact that in the light of my failure to make any such advocacy you dare to suggest that I would through your implicit begging of the question speaks volumes regarding your ethics and morals. No, I am obviously not impressed with either you or cognito.

269 Occasional Reader  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 2:14:15pm

Headed out for a little while. I wonder if I'll get an answer. Stay tuned...

270 Cognito  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 2:15:17pm

re: #268 doriangrey

re: #261 Occasional Reader

re: #260 doriangrey

I asked you a question. Yes or no. Please answer.

(By the way, never use a long word when a diminutive one will do.)

No, you never asked a question, you pretended to ask a question, while phrasing a metaphorical statement of moral and ethical superiority as a question. It was at best a rhetorical question where you presupposed what the answer would be before the answer was given and couched your question in such a manner as to lead to an intractable appearance propriety.

I have never made any statement advocating the indiscriminate killing of Palestinians. The fact that in the light of my failure to make any such advocacy you dare to suggest that I would through your implicit begging of the question speaks volumes regarding your ethics and morals. No, I am obviously not impressed with either you or cognito.

So many syllables.

271 Occasional Reader  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 2:16:17pm

re: #268 doriangrey

couched your question in such a manner as to lead to an intractable appearance propriety

Please tell me this is deliberate self-parody.

272 Occasional Reader  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 2:17:28pm

re: #270 Cognito

So many syllables.

And so many rotating title nominees.

Okay, now I'm off.

273 guftafs  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 2:18:29pm

re: #264 doriangrey

He keeps trying to get an answer that makes him feel soft and cuddly and warn inside. I have not anywhere made any assertion advocating the indiscriminate wholesale slaughter of the Palestinian people. What I have asserted it the the notion of the possibility of innocent Palestinians possibly dying while other Palestinians attempt to kill innocent Israeli's is a notion that is logically morally and intellectually bankrupt.

Yes, I agree. Let us assume that truly innocent "Palestinian" children will get killed. Is that our fault? Who endangered them? Any accusations must be hurled at Hamas, the "Palestinian Authority" who made this possible, even want children to be killed for PR or religious purposes.

274 trace[deleted]  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 2:24:43pm
275 mojo jojo  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 2:24:57pm

Israel has banned the foreign press from the Gaza border on Monday so there is a high probability of shoot to kill orders being issued. Nobody can be allowed to get through.

276 cookielady  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 2:28:07pm

re: #220 Occasional Reader

re: #213 cookielady


I'm teaching my daughters to revere warriors and to be crack shots themselves.

That's good, as long as you're also teaching them to be politically active... on behalf of freedom. Our society is indestructible, as long as we keep a robust sense of self. With that in place, it won't matter whether your daughters are crack shot or not!

Believe me, they get more politics around here than they can stomach, at times. They will be very much a part of the political future of our country, if we have one.

277 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 2:39:15pm

re: #265 Occasional Reader

re: #264 doriangrey

He keeps trying to get an answer that makes him feel soft and cuddly and warn inside.

Actually, I'm just trying to get a straight answer out of you, period.

But you make John Kerry look like Will Frickkin' Rogers in this regard.


So here's my third request on that question in #248. Yes, or no? (By the way, my answer is "no". Your turn.)

I cannot believe that you are still trying to get an answer to a question as odious and foul as that. Why not just ask if I believe in killing people at random? Oh wait thats exactly what you did just ask. I find your question quite honestly bordering on nauseating. What kind of monster do you think I am.

I quite honestly find it humiliating and disgusting to answer such an vulgarly obscene question. And yes, that is exactly what that question is, what kind of sick and twisted mind could ever entertain the notion that anyone else would support genocide?

That is what the indiscriminate targeting of Palestinians would be. Regardless of how sick and evil their society is, and regardless of the degree or lack of culpability of it's individual citizens indiscriminate targeting of them would be an attempt at genocide.

They may not by any stretch of the imagination be innocent, and their society without question is both vile and evil, but what the average Palestinian is guilty of is not a crime worthy of a sentence of summary execution.

I think you are sick for even implying that I would or even could hold the view that such an outrageous and deplorable notion could be rationalized or justified.

278 wiley  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 2:40:51pm

This would be a good time to bomb the Pali infrastructure to rubble with lesser risk of human collateral damage. Make it so that they have only smoking debris to return to.

wiley

279 cookielady  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 2:41:16pm

In honor of today's discussion, I will be serving PORK CHOPS for tonight's meal.

You are all invited to dine, if you are so inclined.

You may even recline to dine, if you deign.

Words rock.

280 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 2:42:18pm

re: #271 Occasional Reader

re: #268 doriangrey

couched your question in such a manner as to lead to an intractable appearance propriety

Please tell me this is deliberate self-parody.

Please tell me your just trolling for the hell of it.

281 itellu3times  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 2:48:46pm

I suppose Israel will try clouds of tear gas, fire hoses, and whatnot, maybe some of those fancy new microwave "discomfort" guns, vats of Nickleodeon green slime, whatever.

But here's the question - say they get through, then what, where exactly do they want to go?

282 GATORBAIT  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 2:54:23pm

re: #79 Killgore Trout


Once again, the Arabs demonstrate the depth of their depravity. Of course, Hamas telling the world of their maneuver in advance, gives the humane and brilliant Israelis an opportunity to thwart this preposterous human wave assault with a degree of aplomb and creativity unlike anything the world has ever seen. May God bless them in this endeavor.

283 jenv  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 3:02:29pm

re: #197 Occasional Reader

re: #194 doriangrey

And so, just to be clear; are you arguing in favor of the IDF gunning down Palestinian 5 year-olds?


If said 5-year-olds are acting as shields for an attack on the border, yes, the IDF should shoot them.

284 Perplexed  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 3:39:55pm

Time to bring out the noise makers (directed sound weapons) and the flash heaters (millimeter microwave crowd dispersal devices). Hit the front lines with the noise makers and the back lines with the flash heaters. True it would stampede the goats, but you have to take the good with the bad. Also the rear guard would be a target rich environment.

285 mjazzguitar  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 3:45:29pm

Maybe tear gas would work.

286 Perplexed  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 3:48:16pm

re: #277 doriangrey

Why don't you google Three conjectures then get back with us. If islam doesn't change soon, we could be facing the prospect of having to do just that - kill people on a scale unheard of in all of history. Does that bring joy to my heart? No, not in the least bit. If it stops global aggression by the followers of the prophet for profit, then it might be required just for humanity to survive.

287 Palandine  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 3:49:25pm

It's too bad that Mythbusters proved that there's no such thing as a brown note.

That's a method of non-lethal crowd dispersion I could get behind.

/oh, wait...

288 Perplexed  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 3:50:12pm

re: #285 mjazzguitar

Maybe tear gas would work.

Yep, and the gazan thugs would say "the Jews gassed us and look at all of the people tear gas killed (ignoring the bullet and shrapnel wounds in the back of the victims).

289 Carolyn  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 3:51:56pm

It worked in Kosovo.
Secretary General of the OIC declares support to the Kosovo Independence:

...Secretary General of the Organization of the Islamic Conference Prof. Ekmeleddin Ihsanoglu made the following remark..."...a very important event took place yesterday. Kosovo has finally declared its independence after a long and determined struggle by its people. As we rejoice this happy result, we declare our solidarity with and support to our brothers and sisters there. The Islamic Umma wishes them success...There is no doubt that the independence of Kosovo will be an asset to the Muslim world and further enhance the joint Islamic action."

U.S. welcomes "Muslim state" in Kosovo:

“We think it is a very positive step that this state -- Muslim majority state -- has been created today,' [Undersecretary of State Nicholas] Burns said Monday... Creating a Muslim-majority state in a region that is the cradle of the Serbs' Orthodox Christian religion never was the driving force of US policy on Kosovo, [Council on Foreign Relatoins analyst Charles] Kupchan said in a telephone interview. “But it's a fringe benefit.

290 Carolyn  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 3:56:34pm

Palestinian Aide Suggests Kosovo a Model

"Kosovo is not better than Palestine," he added. "If the whole world, the United States, the European Union, the majority of its states, have embraced the independence of Kosovo, why shouldn't this happen with Palestine as well?"
291 REDSTATE  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 3:56:52pm

It's Sunday, and maybe it's having a GREAT sermon preached this morning. Maybe it was the fellowship. Or even the Bible study afterward. Maybe that's what has me in a different mode. (see www.lcms.org)

But there has GOT to be a better way. There has to be some solution that doesn't involve people killing each other. Doesn't there?

Are we actually anticipating a human wave, lead by women and children - and some of us are suggesting that they be slaughtered?

Is our hatred that intractable? Are we that far gone down the road of death?

I pray that we find that better way.

I pray that we - and they - have the ears to hear, and the strength to do His will, and that through Him, we find that better way

292 Perplexed  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 3:57:06pm

re: #289 Carolyn

Time to pull our troops out of Kosovo as they are an independant nation. Tell me again how many years Clinton said that we would be in Kosovo?

293 Shaky Louie  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 3:57:19pm

This is a moral dilemma for the IDF.
To shoot and kill innocent women and kids, or, let the wave of invaders cross the border.
There seems to be no satisfying resolution to this.
Defend your country or lose it. What to do?
Will the fear of being labeled as "no better than they"
paralyze the IDF?
Many here have said, "that would make us just as bad as they are".
War is ugly. As a rational human being, I hate war but, to win a war, one must become as ugly, as vicious as their opponent. That is a sad, yet inescapable fact of war. You may not like it, but there it is.
Let me make one thing clear, I am not advocating genocide. I am, however, advocating victory by any means possible. Yes, many innocents will die. But the bullshit will stop.

You may now proceed to flame me.

294 Perplexed  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 3:59:25pm

re: #291 REDSTATE

No, the use of civilians as a human shield violates the Geneva Convention for warfare and as such is a war crime, since those women and children are caught between two armed forces. Israel must survive.

295 Alas  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 3:59:32pm

The savages storming the gates. First, it's Israel. Then, it's the rest of the West. The West is not waking up fast enough.

296 Carolyn  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 4:01:07pm

re: #292 Perplexed

re: #289 Carolyn

Time to pull our troops out of Kosovo as they are an independant nation. Tell me again how many years Clinton said that we would be in Kosovo?

The second quote by Nicholas Burns is really jaw-dropping.
Why is screwing Christians around a "benefit"?

297 Perplexed  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 4:02:41pm

re: #293 Shaky Louie

Flame you? You've said nothing flame worthy and I agree. Use women and children as a weapon of war and they will be killed by the defenders. As repugnant as I find doing that very thing, it might come down to that.

Google Mark Twain War Prayer.

298 Perplexed  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 4:07:47pm

re: #296 Carolyn

The forces of darkness hate both the Jews and Christians and would do anything to undermine both.

299 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 4:08:30pm

re: #286 Perplexed

re: #277 doriangrey

Why don't you google Three conjectures then get back with us. If islam doesn't change soon, we could be facing the prospect of having to do just that - kill people on a scale unheard of in all of history. Does that bring joy to my heart? No, not in the least bit. If it stops global aggression by the followers of the prophet for profit, then it might be required just for humanity to survive.

What exactly do the Three conjectures have to do with anything I posted? Islam is not a race, it's a pseudo-religion masking a violent political ideology. Like yourself the thought of killing people on a scale unheard of in all of history brings an involuntary shudder down my spine. Never the less I am a lessor of two evils kind of guy. Such a conflict may well be unavoidable given the nature of Islam, however at the same time since Islam is not a ethnicity or race such a conflict would not be an intentional act of genocide.

Nor would such a conflict likely involve even a unintentional act of genocide, even though the scale of death would as you correctly point out be unprecedented in human history. To make matter worse such a conflict would be a choice of the lessor of two evils where even choosing the lessor of the evils would make the strongest among us weak in the knees.

300 Carolyn  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 4:09:43pm

re: #296 Carolyn

re: #292 Perplexed

re: #289 Carolyn

Time to pull our troops out of Kosovo as they are an independant nation. Tell me again how many years Clinton said that we would be in Kosovo?

The second quote by Nicholas Burns is really jaw-dropping.
Why is screwing Christians around a "benefit"?


Sorry, that was not Burns who said that bit of shiite, it was Council on Foreign Relations analyst Charles Kupchan.

301 Da_Beerfreak  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 4:10:24pm
re: #291 REDSTATE

It's Sunday, and maybe it's having a GREAT sermon preached this morning. Maybe it was the fellowship. Or even the Bible study afterward. Maybe that's what has me in a different mode. (see www.lcms.org)

But there has GOT to be a better way. There has to be some solution that doesn't involve people killing each other. Doesn't there?

Are we actually anticipating a human wave, lead by women and children - and some of us are suggesting that they be slaughtered?

Is our hatred that intractable? Are we that far gone down the road of death?

I pray that we find that better way.

I pray that we - and they - have the ears to hear, and the strength to do His will, and that through Him, we find that better way

I will risk repeating myself:
"War is cruelty. There's no use trying to reform it, the crueler it is the sooner it will be over."
-- William Tecumseh Sherman --

302 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 4:11:37pm

re: #291 REDSTATE

It's Sunday, and maybe it's having a GREAT sermon preached this morning. Maybe it was the fellowship. Or even the Bible study afterward. Maybe that's what has me in a different mode. (see www.lcms.org)

But there has GOT to be a better way. There has to be some solution that doesn't involve people killing each other. Doesn't there?

Are we actually anticipating a human wave, lead by women and children - and some of us are suggesting that they be slaughtered?

Is our hatred that intractable? Are we that far gone down the road of death?

I pray that we find that better way.

I pray that we - and they - have the ears to hear, and the strength to do His will, and that through Him, we find that better way

We cannot find that which they (the Palestinians) refuse to allow to be found.

303 Perplexed  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 4:15:03pm

re: #299 doriangrey

The Three Conjectures details US response to a nuke attack on US soil and what our response should be and the results of said response.

The following countries would get badly hurt

Egypt
Indonesia
Iran
Evil house of saud
Yemen
Lybia
Morocco
Syria

If only 25% of the people in those countries were killed in the conflaguration, you would see a fundamental shift of culture that they would never recover from.

304 Carolyn  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 4:23:18pm

I agree.
Remember the scene from Independence Day when the President asked the alien what we could do {to make peace}?
The alien said "die!"
That is the circumstance the Israelis are in.
The quran and ahadith is full of instructions to kill the Jews.
Bukhari has the tale of rocks crying out for moslems to come and kill the Jew hiding behind the rock.
Book 041, Number 6981:

Ibn 'Umar reported Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) as saying: You will fight against the Jews and you will kill them until even a stone would say: Come here, Muslim, there is a Jew (hiding himself behind me) ; kill him.

How can they make peace with that?

305 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 4:24:26pm

re: #303 Perplexed

re: #299 doriangrey

The Three Conjectures details US response to a nuke attack on US soil and what our response should be and the results of said response.

The following countries would get badly hurt

Egypt
Indonesia
Iran
Evil house of saud
Yemen
Lybia
Morocco
Syria

If only 25% of the people in those countries were killed in the conflaguration, you would see a fundamental shift of culture that they would never recover from.

I have read the Three Conjectures, just didn't see how it fit into anything I posted.

306 Perplexed  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 4:25:35pm

re: #305 doriangrey

The numbers of dead and dying.

307 Winston Y. Smith  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 4:29:24pm

Hamas plans to be successful in its endeavour, as they have been successfull in their egiptian border crossing. They are thinking two steps ahead while dummy israeli politicians care about protecting their current career objectives. This Hamas action could have been predicted years ago and the border successfully land mined. Then all willing shahids will happily go to haven/hell alone without taking innocent people with them while the rest of rioters seing the outcome will disregard promised hamas carrots and happyly go back home. Not a big deal. Done in plenty places around the world.

308 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 4:31:06pm

re: #306 Perplexed

re: #305 doriangrey

The numbers of dead and dying.

Ahhh, I get it, comparison to committing genocide against the Pali's...

309 buzzdroid  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 4:31:58pm

the three conjectures sounds plausible alright.
we had to do some god awful terrible things to the japanese to shake them out of their bushido kamizkaze death cult. i think folks nowadays forget all that. i wasn't easy defeating Japan.

310 Daisy  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 4:47:06pm

re: #191 Palandine

re: #39 Daisy

"40,000 to 50,000 women and children would form a “human chain” stretching the length of the Gaza Strip."

Could Islamists possibly be more cowardly?

And doesn't it illustrate wonderfully that even the Islamists acknowledge the inherent righteousness of the Israelis? They KNOW the Israelis would never mow down women and children, which is why they are hiding behind them. Yet, all the while, the Islamists strive to kill Israeli women and children, rather than those who might fight back.
Strange how the world chooses not to see the obvious.

It sure does. From that perspective, one can only wonder about the longing of the souls that comprise the human chain (so apt) as they look towards Israel - of the woman - for men who would not do this to them - and of the children, simply to be safe.

311 buzzdroid  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 4:47:18pm

and meanwhile , obama wants to withdraw all troops from iraq by 2009.

doesnt he realise just how DUMB that is. right now, no arab country would dare attack israel with several hundred thousand U.S.troops just over the border in iraq.

312 Iron Fist  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 4:50:15pm

re: #311 buzzdroid,

Obama doesn't strike me as dumb. More than a little naive, yes, dumb no.

Which means he knows exactly how bad a US withdrawal from Iraq would be right now. He just doesn't give a flying fuck.

It'lll be CHANGE.

313 Bard  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 4:50:25pm

I said it in the other thread, but I'll repeat it here: if the front lines are indeed filled with children, then it shouldn't take a lot of work to subdue them; they won't put up much of a fight. Let the rest have it. Then, the mercy of civilization will be seen by those with eyes, and if not, well, at least Hamas gets neither their sick propaganda fuel nor a successful incursion.

314 Dr. Shalit  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 4:52:38pm

re: #241 TimeQuake

re: #239 So?

Sovereignty only applies to Muslim nations these days. All other countries are up for grabs...including ours (USA).

Quake -

Understand this well. In the "Dar-al-Islam" there ARE no nations - only the ephemeral "ummah." Talk of "NATIONS" is sheer Taquiya.

-S-

315 Iron Fist  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 4:54:33pm

re: #313 Bard,

Children equipped with remote-detonated "suicide" belts? Don't think for a minute our enemies wouldn't do that.

They did so with Downs-Syndrome women in Iraq.

They'll tell the children it's a game. That is how utterly evil our enemies are.

That is why I advocate the extermination of Hamas. At least they won't do such things if they are dead.

316 WitchDoctor  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 4:55:16pm

It's been an interesting read, but frankly, I'll be more invovled in this discussion when something (I hope not) actually occurs. until then, this is just speculation and some of the wilder comments do not reflect all that well on the Lizard Army.

Let's see, it's about, what, +11 hours there? (from my PST zone) So if something's going to happen it'll actually be tonight...

317 Daisy  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 4:55:52pm

re: #312 Iron Fist

re: #311 buzzdroid,

Obama doesn't strike me as dumb. More than a little naive, yes, dumb no.

Which means he knows exactly how bad a US withdrawal from Iraq would be right now. He just doesn't give a flying fuck.

It'lll be CHANGE.

I'm afaid you're right. At best, I don't think B.O. gives a damn about Israel. And at worst, well, he's siding w/the rest of the ME.

318 Dr. Shalit  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 4:58:08pm

re: #312 Iron Fist

"I-F" -

If Sen. Obama tours the USA campaigning with Rep. John Conyers, as he did today, his fate of "Loserhood" is sealed. If all y'all have to tour with a Black, Urban Congressscritter at least pick a an articulate one like Little Jesse from Chicago or Payne from Newark, NJ.

-S-

319 buzzdroid  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 4:58:13pm

interesting aside - Olmert wont be in israel. Livni will be acting prime minister...
[Link: www.ynetnews.com...]

"Livni assumed Prime Minister Ehud Olmert's duties after the latter embarked for an official diplomatic visit to Japan."

320 Daisy  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 4:58:52pm

re: #315 Iron Fist

re: #313 Bard,

"That is why I advocate the extermination of Hamas. At least they won't do such things if they are dead.

"


You know, Iron Fist, I'd like to be able to discuss more w/you, because I think you probably care about justice and truth ... but when you advocate 'exterminating' human beings, well, I've gotta go.

321 Iron Fist  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 5:05:33pm

re: #320 Daisy,

Would you say the same if I exchanged the word "Nazis" for the word "Hamas"? I'm not talking about a "race" of people, I am talking about a very specific group of terrorists. Hamas is a political movement in the same manner that the Nazis were a political movement.

Were it up to me, we'd exterminate the Nazis from the face of the Earth. Likewise Hamas. And Hezbollah, and Islamic Jihad.

Guess what? They want to exterminate you and I. They don't make any bones about it. Convert, pay the Jizya, or die. That is the choice they would give you or I.

Why should I give them any other choices?

Hamas is a terrorist organization. We should be killing them where we find them until we run out of them to kill.

Why is it so bad to say that?

322 Dr. Shalit  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 5:05:50pm

re: #319 buzzdroid

Sounds kinda like Nancy Pelosi substituting for Harry Reid. Big Deal!

-S-

323 buzzdroid  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 5:06:14pm

[Link: www.haaretz.com...]

"The head of the Popular Committee Against the Siege of Gaza, an independent member of the Palestinian parliament, Jamal al-Hudari, who is close to Hamas, said that the chain will stretch to 40 kilometers in length, from Rafah in the south to the Erez crossing, and will include 40,000 children. "

thought occured to me - might the whole "protest" be a diversionary tactic - in that, while israeli manpower is concentrating on the southern areas where the [bigoted word]s will be concentrating, might Hamas themselves attack the northern border?

324 buzzdroid  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 5:07:44pm

re: #320 Daisy

jeez. we got a peacenik here folks - who thinks that Hamas just want to sing "kumbaya" with all of us... i'd bet Daisy is voting Obama in November.

325 buzzdroid  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 5:08:29pm

re: #322 Dr. Shalit

didnt realise it was THAT bad in israel. thats not good. not good at all...

326 Dr. Shalit  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 5:09:03pm

re: #321 Iron Fist

"I-F" -

Such things should never be "Spoken About." Beyond that, conclusions which must be drawn, shall be drawn.

-S-

327 Spiny Norman  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 5:09:07pm

Shorter doriangrey:

Nits make lice.

Lovely sentiment, but hardly a new one. Col. Chivington would be proud.

328 Dr. Shalit  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 5:13:25pm

re: #325 buzzdroid

"buzz" -

1. Yes it IS.

2. Both of them claim to have "BETAR" upbringings. Vladimir Jabotinsky must be doing a 7200 rpm Hard Disc Grave Spin at this news.

-S-

329 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 5:13:37pm

re: #327 Spiny Norman

Shorter doriangrey:

Nits make lice.

Lovely sentiment, but hardly a new one. Col. Chivington would be proud.

What are you referring to?

330 Maximu§  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 5:17:13pm

When is this supposed to go down?

331 Dr. Shalit  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 5:18:05pm

re: #330 Maximu§

"Max" -

SOON, VERY SOON!

-S-

332 darkster2400  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 5:24:06pm

does Israel have any AC-130s?

That would do the trick......

AC-130 versus the Terrorists

333 mefolkes  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 5:24:39pm

Just how unarmed would all those civilian shields be? They might have bomb belts, concealed guns, knives, box cutters, clubs or other weapons. They might pick up rocks on-site when they reach the Israeli soldiers hobbled by conscience. Even the best troopers are not trained or equipped for hand-to-hand combat with hordes of people. Once they are in the crowd, they are either dead or dragged off to be tortured at leisure by the terrorists. A human wave, even if it isn't peppered with fully-armed combatants, is a danger. When the Israeli front line collapses, either the IDF engages in massive cluster bomb and napalm attacks, or Israel ceases to exist. I'm a Christian who would volunteer to machine gun even a supposedly unarmed human wave assault on Israel.

334 darkster2400  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 5:25:21pm

Right on!

re: #321 Iron Fist

335 Spiny Norman  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 5:26:32pm

re: #329 doriangrey

re: #327 Spiny Norman


Shorter doriangrey:

Nits make lice.

Lovely sentiment, but hardly a new one. Col. Chivington would be proud.

What are you referring to?

Your insistance of Palestinian children being equally guilty and deserving of death. Because they're evil.

Col. John Chivington attacked an encampment of Cheyenne and Arapaho women and children who were supposedly under the protection of the US government. When someone asked if they were to kill everyone, even the children, he responded: "Kill and scalp them all, big and little; nits make lice."

You really ought to take your extermination fantasies somewhere else. You do realize you are using the exact same argument the Palestinian terrorists use for killing Israeli women and children, don't you?

336 jordash1212  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 5:26:33pm

re: #1 jaunte

"40,000 to 50,000 women and children would form a “human chain” stretching the length of the Gaza Strip."

That may be a record-setting number of human shields.

Somebody phone the Guiness Book of World Records.

337 Iron Fist  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 5:32:36pm

re: #335 Spiny Norman,

You do, I assume, see the difference between my advocation of the extermination of Hamas and the more general advocation of the extermination of the Palestinians. Hamas have made their choices.

They should live, or prefferably, die by them.

338 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 5:33:03pm

re: #335 Spiny Norman

re: #329 doriangrey

re: #327 Spiny Norman


Shorter doriangrey:Nits make lice.

Lovely sentiment, but hardly a new one. Col. Chivington would be proud.

What are you referring to?

Your insistance of Palestinian children being equally guilty and deserving of death. Because they're evil.

Col. John Chivington attacked an encampment of Cheyenne and Arapaho women and children who were supposedly under the protection of the US government. When someone asked if they were to kill everyone, even the children, he responded: "Kill and scalp them all, big and little; nits make lice."

You really ought to take your extermination fantasies somewhere else. You do realize you are using the exact same argument the Palestinian terrorists use for killing Israeli women and children, don't you?

Spiny, I usually try to be more civilized here, but you need to pull your fucking head out of your ass and read more of what I have posted.

339 Spiny Norman  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 5:38:00pm

re: #338 doriangrey

No, you pull your head out of your ass:

re: #194 doriangrey

They may be born innocent, but by the age of five that innocence is long gone. The Palestinians haven't managed to keep their homicidal hatred of Israel going for the last 60 years because they allow any of their children to not be indoctrinated or infected with their genocidal hatred.

5 year olds are legitimate targets? Are you fucking serious?

340 Spiny Norman  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 5:41:49pm

re: #178 doriangrey

re: #174 Cognito
re: #173 doriangrey
Teaching ones children that killing innocent people because Allah will be pleased is absolutly evil.
Of course it is. I haven't said otherwise, and never would.

But this makes the parents evil, not the children.

Wrong answer clyde, It makes everyone involved, children included evil. Thats the problem with evil, it contaminate everything it comes into contact with. Those children would have to be completely removed from any contact with their parent and their parents society, completely re-programmed and even then the rate of successfully de-programming them from the evil that has been inflicted on them would be pitifully low.

Unless you posted something else in this thread completely disavowing those statements, I stand by what I posted. You have lowered yourself to Hamas' level. Thank God the IDF is far more civilized than you.

341 Cognito  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 5:46:40pm

re: #340 Spiny Norman

Hey Spiny,

You've put together an excellent argument, but there's really no point. He or she really doesn't get it. Which is a shame, because this is the sort of thinking that drives people away from LGF.

- C

342 Daisy  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 5:52:32pm

re: #321 Iron Fist

re: #320 Daisy,

Would you say the same if I exchanged the word "Nazis" for the word "Hamas"? I'm not talking about a "race" of people, I am talking about a very specific group of terrorists. Hamas is a political movement in the same manner that the Nazis were a political movement.

Were it up to me, we'd exterminate the Nazis from the face of the Earth. Likewise Hamas. And Hezbollah, and Islamic Jihad.

Guess what? They want to exterminate you and I. They don't make any bones about it. Convert, pay the Jizya, or die. That is the choice they would give you or I.

Why should I give them any other choices?

Hamas is a terrorist organization. We should be killing them where we find them until we run out of them to kill.
Why is it so bad to say that?

You know, Iron Fist, I would say the same thing. And I'd say it because there is a difference in defeating an evil ideology and warring against and triumphing over those who would impose their evil rule over others and exterminating the people who carry the evil. I think you know, I share your thinking about Hamas, etc. and I have no difficulty identifying them as Fascists whose goal is to enact evil. They need to be conquered.

Why is it so bad to say that? Because evil cannot be "exterminated" - it needs to be dealt w/more realistically and more honestly than that - in order to combat evil and allow what's righteous to prevail, evil needs to be faced without resorting to evil oneself .. which is certainly what would happen if one planned to exterminate any people or group, no matter how threatening they are to our sense of well being and safety.

343 doriangrey[deleted]  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 5:52:58pm
344 doriangrey[deleted]  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 5:56:23pm
345 Daisy  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 5:56:31pm

re: #324 buzzdroid

re: #320 Daisy

jeez. we got a peacenik here folks - who thinks that Hamas just want to sing "kumbaya" with all of us... i'd bet Daisy is voting Obama in November.

Think before you write.

346 Iron Fist  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 6:02:29pm

re: #342 Daisy,

You know, Iron Fist, I would say the same thing. And I'd say it because there is a difference in defeating an evil ideology and warring against and triumphing over those who would impose their evil rule over others and exterminating the people who carry the evil.


It would surely be better to conqure the evil in their hearts. That is simply not a gift given to me.

I can put my boot on their neck, put the muzzle of my pistol against their temple, and pull the trigger. I can do that, and would do that given the oppertunity.

I'm not talking about the massacre of innocents (which Hamas may be trying to bring about). I am talking about the extermination of people who have chosen evil, although they may call it good.

I can do that, and live with myself at the end of the day. If I could stop their evil, and I did nothing, well, I don't know that I could live with that.

347 Iron Fist  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 6:09:47pm

re: #346 Iron Fist,

Addendum: It may do some good that Hamas learns that there are those in the West willing to talk in terms of exterminating them. This might make them more willing to back off of their exteremist views in the name of self-preservation. If my views help achieve that, and Hamas relents and moderates, then I will consider myself to have done good.

I don't really see that happening, though.

I want the IDF to know that there are those of us out here who want them to finish the job. If that lifts the spirit of one IDF trooper, then I will consider myself to have done good.

348 Daisy  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 6:25:49pm

re: #347 Iron Fist

re: #346 Iron Fist,

Addendum: It may do some good that Hamas learns that there are those in the West willing to talk in terms of exterminating them. This might make them more willing to back off of their exteremist views in the name of self-preservation. If my views help achieve that, and Hamas relents and moderates, then I will consider myself to have done good.

I don't really see that happening, though.

I want the IDF to know that there are those of us out here who want them to finish the job. If that lifts the spirit of one IDF trooper, then I will consider myself to have done good.

I appreciate your loyalty and your willingness to support our troops and Israel. I can also appreciate your frustration in light of all the effete political appeasement that's been going on. I also agree that it's highly unlikely for Hamas to become moderate (what would moderate even look like?!) They do need to be defeated - but let's leave enough living so they can warn their children to shape up and fly right! :) I wonder, have you been in the armed forces yourself?

349 Daisy  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 6:28:34pm

PS .. Iron Fist . . Re: "It would surely be better to conqure the evil in their hearts. That is simply not a gift given to me." Look deeper. You were not left out when that gift was being handed out. It's there.

350 Iron Fist  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 6:40:55pm

re: #348 Daisy,

I could go for a reverse-decimation-i.e. kill nine in ten of them, and hope that the survivors teach the horrors of our wrath, but there is nothing in Hamas' history that indicates that they would do so. The only hope I see for the Palestinians is the destruction in detail of Hamas.

Do you prefer that wording to extermination? They mean essentially the same thing. Destruction in detail is a more military terminology of what must happen.

Simply killing the leaders has been inadequate.

351 doriangrey  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 6:41:19pm

re: #349 Daisy

PS .. Iron Fist . . Re: "It would surely be better to conqure the evil in their hearts. That is simply not a gift given to me." Look deeper. You were not left out when that gift was being handed out. It's there.

No Daisy, Iron Fist is right we were not given that gift, and it is the mistaken belief that we can negotiate with evil that will result in the worst bloodshed this poor planet has ever seen. If the people like Iron fist who could take the steps required to eliminate the truly evil people from among the Palestinian were allowed to, then perhaps a remnant of the Palestinian people could be saved.

But sadly the people who could are like you, deceived into believing that they can negotiate with evil. It is this false belief like those held by cognito and Spiny Norman that evil has some boundary it wont cross that condemn the people enslaved by Islam to death and violence.

352 talon_262  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 6:50:18pm

re: #344 doriangrey

Dude, you can't be serious...saying in one comment that Palestinian children are as equally evil as the adults who corrupt them and fill them with hatred towards Jews and insinuating that they're always strapped with a bomb (and therefore fair game), while in other comments saying you're against indiscriminate killing.

Which is it, dear sir?

353 Iron Fist  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 7:10:00pm

re: #349 Daisy,

I can't exactly argue your point without getting nasty.

Try this as an alternative. It is how I feel as opposed to how I reason.

354 Daisy  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 7:10:23pm

#350 Iron Fist,

Somehow the quote function isn't functioning. As you know, I not only have a problem w/the term 'exterminate' but with its moral meaning and practical application. I'm glad there are warriors who are prepared to fight, kill and even die in combat. I'm more than glad; I'm grateful.

We didn't kill every single Nazi, did we? I don't think anyone would disagree that we triumphed over that particular manifestation of evil in that particular time, would they? The trouble w/'exterminating' evil is that it's unrealistic - and the intention of extermination can have the effect of causing us to enact evil.

I'm more moderate than that. I'm willing to believe that the struggle w/evil is a lifetime endeavor in much the same way that the protection of freedom (goodness) is a lifetime endeavor: both require honest and diligent vigilance and both battles are, in some sense, never done. Neither can be dealt with in one absolute moment and neither can be underestimated in importance or taken for granted in any way, shape or form. These sorts of battles require real spiritual fortitude - and it would be a serious error to confuse bravado w/fortitude.

#351 doriangrey,
You misunderstand me, I'm not into negotiating with evil. In fact, I believe extremism (in almost all instances) is a form of negotiating with evil. You seem like an extremist to me. Are you quite sure you're not, in fact, negotiating with evil yourself? Think about it.

355 Daisy  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 7:20:53pm

#353 Iron Fist,

I understand you feel passionately (and probably misunderstood too) and that can certainly have a way of putting you on the "outside". I don't intend to trifle with your feelings - that would be disrespectful. Just let me repeat. Keep looking inside. I think you'll find plenty of authentic bravery in there. Courage, after all, means to 'take heart' /we cannot afford to leave our hearts out of courage, otherwise, I think we're in as deep trouble as those we fight. Of course, all I can do is share my thoughts with you .. and I can also thank you for bringing things down a notch so that we could have what I consider a pretty darned good exchange. So, thank you.
I'm off now .. stay well.

356 guftafs  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 7:50:58pm

re: #342 Daisy

re: #321 Iron Fist

re: #320 Daisy,

Would you say the same if I exchanged the word "Nazis" for the word "Hamas"? I'm not talking about a "race" of people, I am talking about a very specific group of terrorists. Hamas is a political movement in the same manner that the Nazis were a political movement.

Were it up to me, we'd exterminate the Nazis from the face of the Earth. Likewise Hamas. And Hezbollah, and Islamic Jihad.

Guess what? They want to exterminate you and I. They don't make any bones about it. Convert, pay the Jizya, or die. That is the choice they would give you or I.

Why should I give them any other choices?

Hamas is a terrorist organization. We should be killing them where we find them until we run out of them to kill.
Why is it so bad to say that?


You know, Iron Fist, I would say the same thing. And I'd say it because there is a difference in defeating an evil ideology and warring against and triumphing over those who would impose their evil rule over others and exterminating the people who carry the evil. I think you know, I share your thinking about Hamas, etc. and I have no difficulty identifying them as Fascists whose goal is to enact evil. They need to be conquered.

Why is it so bad to say that? Because evil cannot be "exterminated" - it needs to be dealt w/more realistically and more honestly than that - in order to combat evil and allow what's righteous to prevail, evil needs to be faced without resorting to evil oneself .. which is certainly what would happen if one planned to exterminate any people or group, no matter how threatening they are to our sense of well being and safety.

Um, evil is not some mysterious force we cannot comprehend, although the results are at times very hard to accept. Evil is done by men, individual men, and if you remove enough evil men and dishearten the rest, you will have defeated evil, at least for that generation. I think the Israelis more or less exterminated PLO terrorism in Europe after the Munich olympic games atrocities. So, of course it can be done.

357 Cognito  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 8:24:48pm

re: #354 Daisy

Are you quite sure you're not, in fact, negotiating with evil yourself? Think about it.

Beautifully said.

358 webs87  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 9:15:43pm

I believe this situation could have been averted if Israel had acted differently when the Palis stormed Egypt. The IDF should have taken the opportunity to invade Gaza. With a quarter of the population gone (supposedly) and Hamas concentrating their efforts elsewhere, it might have been the best timing for Israel....But alas.

PS: I wish the best of luck to all Israeli soldiers and police officers, and the worst to hamas.

359 jenv  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 9:27:32pm

re: #290 Carolyn

Palestinian Aide Suggests Kosovo a Model

"Kosovo is not better than Palestine," he added. "If the whole world, the United States, the European Union, the majority of its states, have embraced the independence of Kosovo, why shouldn't this happen with Palestine as well?"


If Palestine wants independence, let them cut the power lines from Israel first. Fat chance of that happening.

360 jenv  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 9:43:04pm

re: #335 Spiny Norman

Your insistance of Palestinian children being equally guilty and deserving of death. Because they're evil.


How can a child raised in the cesspool of Palestine and taught in a Hamas-run school be anything other than evil? Haven't you seen the Hamas children's shows with kids advocating the murder of unbelievers? If you haven't, before writing another word on this subject you must see them. Several are here on LGF.


You do realize you are using the exact same argument the Palestinian terrorists use for killing Israeli women and children, don't you?


Actually, he isn't. He's advocating killing evildoers, Palestinians advocate killing Jews because they're Jews. The sex and age of said Jew is of no consequence to them. There is a huge difference between the two.

361 Iron Fist  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 10:32:40pm

re: #357 Cognito,

I don't think you, or Daisy, really grasp the evil that we are facing.

Imagine, if you will, the IDF soldier faced with little Johnny Jihadi equiped with a suicide vest. Kid is five years old.

This is evil. I think we can all agree on that.

Now imagine 500 little Johhnnys. It overwhelms what one IDF soldier can do.

This is what we are talking about. This is what Hamas wants to do.

To simply call it evil is to denigrate evil.

I have simply said go after the perpertrators, preferably before they actually perform such an evil act.

And you balk. Why? I do not know nor comprehend. Because the perpertrators might be reformed before the actually commit this evil? They have already committed other evils to hold them to account.

They are Hamas. They are terrorists.

Why wait for them to commit one more atrocity?

362 Da_Beerfreak  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 10:41:36pm

re: #361 Iron Fist

Some folks do not know how to fight, and others are afraid to.

363 Frank_Mtl  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:08:57pm

This is an AP headline for French Canadian consumption: "Israël appelle à une manifestation". Literally translated: "Israel calls for a demonstration".
Appears on a French Québécois site [Link: www.canoe.com...] to the attention of those who condemn Israel by reading headlines only. The article itself obviously refers to the demonstration called for by Hamas.

364 Frank_Mtl  Sun, Feb 24, 2008 11:22:50pm

The Yahoo title for the same article is: "Hamas appelle à une manifestation..." [Link: fr.news.yahoo.com...]

365 ashan  Mon, Feb 25, 2008 12:23:39am

One musn't forget the Palithug terrorists dressed in women's clothes who will hide among the human shields in an attempt to enter Israel. It's obvious that any Palithug penetration of the border will be used to massacre Israeli civilians.

I believe that this may be a prelude to a Hizbonazi attack on Israel's northern border. We may be seeing the beginning of the all-out war we have been fearing.

The IDF should wrest control of our incompetent and myopic government.

Anyway, I am glad we got our delivery of mineral water and have a tiny, but real shelter (as we live in Hadera, which suffered only one missile attack in the 2006 debacle, but which is nevertheless a target by longer range missiles because of its power station).

Scary.

366 pauldanish  Mon, Feb 25, 2008 12:28:48am

You know, if you let all those civilians come across and get a kilometer or two into Israel, it would be a great time to invade Gaza. A lot of the women and children would be out of the way.

367 deegee  Mon, Feb 25, 2008 2:45:29am

Apologies if someone else posted something similar.

Hamas (and regrettably the Olmert-Barak government) seem to have forgotten that mass-action is very much a double sided sword.

• Israel (or some private group) could arrange a mirror-image border crossing to recover the settlements so rashly abandoned in Gaza
• Israel (or some private group) could arrange a storming of the Temple Mount.
• Israel could make some symbolic attempts to stop them and then let them come! Where would they go? There isn't too many roads. Those who reach a town or a settlement would be arrested away from TV cameras. Most would wander around in Raul Eitan's memorable phrase "like cockroaches in a bottle".

368 miguelj  Mon, Feb 25, 2008 5:24:12am

I basicaly agree with deegee. If they "storm" into Israel like they "stormed" into Egypt, that means--what?--that they'll spend some money in Israel buying flour, sugar, livestock etc., and then go home. Sounds OK to me....

369 mean Gene  Mon, Feb 25, 2008 6:47:49am

Well, they didn't storm the border.
But the meida said, it was a ''peaceful'' demonstration.....except that as soon as it ended thousands of youngsters hurles rocks at the IDF.
Oh, only that.
Pics are good here:
[Link: www.reuters.com...]
Reuters knows which side will give them the coverage and so they never wonder why.
Idiots!

370 Daisy  Mon, Feb 25, 2008 6:52:30am

re: #357 Cognito

re: #354 Daisy

Are you quite sure you're not, in fact, negotiating with evil yourself? Think about it.
Beautifully said.

Thank you.

371 mean Gene  Mon, Feb 25, 2008 7:12:32am

I think the idea that over 10,000 Israeli's visited Sderot that same day was part of why nothing happened on the border.
Don't Israeli's still have the right to carry out in the open?

[Link: www.jpost.com...]

[Link: eye-on-the-world.blogspot.com...]

372 OCBill  Mon, Feb 25, 2008 7:12:59am

I will never understand how Israel can impose a blockade on a territory that shares a long border with Egypt. It's like blockading someone's front door when their house has several other doors.

373 ashan  Mon, Feb 25, 2008 7:28:23am

Anyone who says "Let them come across the border. What can they do?" doesn't understand the Paleos, particularly the Gazans, at all. These people are constantly being fed hateful propaganda against Israeli (read: Jews) through their media. The hate is quite explicit in the Koran. Vile spew is spread by imams in the moques. Little children are daily being fed violent death-cult hatred, lies and distortion of history in their schools and on the TV (witness the hateful Farfur and other repugnant characters). They are exposed to violence, blood and death on a regular basis.

Right now, any Gazan who wishes to cross the border for medical treatment (and goodness knows why we constantly extend our hand to those who would bite it) must have permission and documents. But if these people cross the border into Israel by force, there is no doubt that they will kill Israeli civilians. Terrorists disguised as women, children with knives or carrying a small bomb in a backpack, women concealing explosives in fake pregnancies are not at all rare - and they have killed and maimed Israelis.

Whatever the case, they won't be coming across to do their shopping - unless, of course, it's to loot Israeli homes.

374 Spiny Norman  Mon, Feb 25, 2008 11:47:09am

re: #372 OCBill

I will never understand how Israel can impose a blockade on a territory that shares a long border with Egypt. It's like blockading someone's front door when their house has several other doors.

It's the same as the US trade embargo with Cuba: despite the fact that virtually every other country in the world is free to trade with Fidel Raul Castro, they still blame the exteme poverty on a US "blockade".


This entry has been archived.
Comments are closed.

^ back to top ^

log in
Name:
Pass:

Register Forgot Your Password? My Account Re-send Confirmation (To log in, cookies must be enabled in your browser!)

► LGF Headlines

► Top 10 Comments

► Bottom Comments

► Recent Comments

► Tools/Info

► LGF Hits

► Slideshows

► Resources

► Never Forget

► Statistics

► Tag Cloud

► Contact

You must have Javascript enabled to use the contact form.
Your email:

Subject:

Message:


Messages may be published in our weblog, unless you request otherwise.
Tech Note:
Using the Contact Form

► News/Opinion

More Partners

Compare Electricity Prices in your area. Texas Electricity is deregulated; you have the right to choose Texas Electric Rates from among many Texas Electric Companies.

Why not?


Barnes & Noble Home