re: #178 jimbouie

Oops:

From: Phil Jones
To: “Michael E. Mann”
Subject: Re: have you seen this?
Date: Wed Mar 31 09:09:04 2004

Mike,
(snip)
Recently rejected two papers (one for JGR and for GRL) from people saying CRU has it
wrong over Siberia. Went to town in both reviews, hopefully successfully. If either
appears
I will be very surprised, but you never know with GRL.
Cheers
Phil

Right, because you know, maybe part of his work as a reviewer is to make sure that bad papers are rejected.

So let me explain something. If he went to town in his review, that means he found a lot of errors, so many that he wrote a very lengthy rejection about everything that was wrong the paper.