Comment

Sheer Fun: Bob Schneider on eTown: "The Stars Over Your House"

228
The Very Reverend Battleaxe of Knowledge5/06/2018 4:40:03 am PDT

re: #226 Anymouse šŸŒ¹

Apparently theyā€™re not going to prevent it. (Iā€™m not sure how you could anyway: For example a nuclear blastā€™s damage is caused by the shock wave, which wouldnā€™t happen in space. Suggestions have been made about throwing repeated inert objects at one point on an asteroid to deflect itā€™s orbit, but that would take a lot of missiles and has never been tested.)

It depends on how much warning you have. The preferred method would be to rendezvous with a spacecraft whose gravitational effect would very gradually change the orbit of the object.

Blowing it to smithereens with a nuclear device, like the public seems to want, would be worse than useless, causing many catastrophic impacts instead of just one.

Detonating a nuclear device at just the right distance would cause a thin surface layer to vaporize, creating a thrust that would accelerate the object enough to deflect its orbit, given enough lead time. Youā€™d have to know whether it was a consolidated object or just a loose pile of gravel for that to work.

We have no launch vehicles suitable for any of these missions, and despite a lot of talk, thereā€™s been precisely zero action on developing anyā€”unless the Big Fucking Rocket turns out to be a real thingā€¦.