re: #247 Walter L. Newton

Because, Catholics as individuals are as monolithic as any other group and your broad-assed brush is bigoted. In your second paragraph you claim it’s not morally acceptable to judge Jews as a group, yet that’s exactly what you do in your closing statement “Why should my ‘brotherly love’ go to Catholics?”

My arguments were:

1-It’s not morally acceptable to judge anyone by some statistical traits of a group.
2. Even if it was, there’s no reason to favor the group which I “belong to” - Catholics - as the group that I’d support in detriment of other groups.