Charles

This is your blog - so you are entitled to post what you want with your own comments. Some disagree with you.

1 At the start of this you said the CRU stuff was a hack, defintely not a leak. Do you now accept that it looks more like a leak ? Which in English law would be difficult to be proven as a crime)

2 You have been asked MANY times to comment on the Harry-file stuff. Which suggests that the whole coding of the data is a mess, that there were all sorts of unexplained “fudges” of the basic data. Have you ever responded to this ? I THINK NOT .

3 You predicted that the whole “Climategate” thing would be dead, press coverage was effectively finished. Do you agree you are wrong? Over here the story is on TV, radio, and the newspapers. And there is plenty of new stuff in the US press.

4 You have taken a strong - no TOTAL - view on the whole issue. You call anyone who is sceptical - unsure - a “denier”. Isn’t that a bit over the top ? Or - insulting ?