re: #308 Obdicut

Try answering the question.

Marjoriemoon wrote that she considered all Muslims living in the territories to be guilty of supporting terror. A position with which I strongly disagree, and have argued with her about.

You changed that to accuse her— and Ludwig— of saying that all Palestinians were guilty of terrorism. A false accusation.

Why did you do that?

As to that post that you quoted, I was talking about both of them were in favor of the idea of collective guilt of an entire population for the terroristic crimes of a minority, and the collective punishment of that population.

When you discuss forced deportation of millions (as LudwigVanQuixote did in this thread), the vast majority of whom committed NO crime, well, yes, I do think that that proves my assertion. As for marjoriemoon, she tried to pass of the guilt of a few on all of Palestine. (See #144).