re: #310 Obdicut

I’m not sure why you can’t understand the question. Let’s try it again.

Marjoriemoon wrote that she considered all Muslims living in the territories to be guilty of supporting terror. A position with which I strongly disagree, and have argued with her about.

You changed that to accuse her— and Ludwig— of saying that all Palestinians were guilty of terrorism. A false accusation.

Why did you do that?

I understand that you changed it. You don’t need you to remind me that you were talking about collective guilt. What I’m asking about is why you changed their actual charge of collective guilt in support of terrorism, to the charge of collective guilt in terrorism itself.

That is what I would like answered.

Can you try?

Fine. Take out the one post in which I said that. Does that change the facts any? I don’t think so.

Both of them support collective punishment of the Palestinian people.