re: #362 Cato the Elder

That is a textbook case of allowing your enemies to define terms.

I am a proud anti-Jihadist who thinks Spencer has done immeasurable harm to the cause. Just as I’m a Catholic who believes Holocaust-denying bishops have no place in the Church. But I will not stop calling myself a Catholic because of them.

Not the best analogy— as you yourself know membership in the Catholic Church isn’t predicated upon or constituted by one’s belief that a certain bishop should be a bishop or not, but on other factors entirely.