re: #333 Walter L. Newton

But look at my 330, and flesh this out for me if you have a better understanding than me. It seems all I am getting is “kill them all” but no one can tell me if that’s the way it should shake out.

I think we’re all looking at the same problem from different angles. To simplify, I see two scenarios: First scenario: a patrol is out and is fired upon from a building. Upon entering the building they find one adult male, but no weaponry. IMO no fault, no foul, but they take the adult in for questioning just to find out what he knows. Second scenario: same as the first, the only difference: upon entering the building, they find a male with a smoking AK-47 and the home-owners family held hostage and used as human shields. Question, adjudicate, eliminate.