These people try to sound smart but they are just ignorant of the source material of which they claim to be defenders:

Tolkien’s world is very explicitly creationist. There is no Darwinian evolution in Arda.

You apparently believe Aulë only made dwarves with a particular shade of skin, and that Eru supported that (by giving them souls.)

But that is just you projecting your desires.

— freetoken fights fecking fascists (@freetoken) August 7, 2022