The degree of specificity and detail in Robertson’s little fantasy scenario indicates he’s spent a frightening amount of time thinking about this.

“If it happened to them,” Robertson continued, “they probably would say, ‘something about this just ain’t right.”

Atheists would say that if it happened to anybody, not just them. Seriously, he’s projecting his own appalling callousness towards “the other” onto atheists. I’ve seriously never seen an atheist game out hypothetical fantasy rape / murder / decapitation / castration scenarios, or harm of any kind towards religious folk in order to castigate their beliefs.