Comment

Godwins of the Day: Jan, 17, 2013

141
jaunte1/17/2013 7:07:51 pm PST
“…there are other curious aspects to the Nazi-gun-registration argument. In the first place, the argument is of an odd form for the NRA and pro-gun proponents. After all, the NRA stands for the proposition that “it’s not guns that kill people, it’s people who kill people.” The central idea here is that instrumentalities—in this case handguns—are just that: instrumentalities. They are not to be blamed for what people do wrongly with them. If you follow the logic of that argument, then you would expect a member of the NRA to respond in the same manner when confronted with the Nazi-gun-registration argument: “It’s not gun registration that produces gun confiscation and genocide, it’s people who do.”
—Bernard Harcourt

law.uchicago.edu