Comment

WaPo: How a Detainee Became an Asset

167
Mostly sane, most of the time.8/30/2009 10:17:14 am PDT

re: #156 SixDegrees

I’m reminded of the scene from A Man For All Seasons in which Thomas More is arguing with the particularly vicious witch-hunting prosecutor. A servant of the king and a hungry and ambitious man.

And More says to this man, “You’d break the law to punish the devil, wouldn’t you?”

And the prosecutor, the witch-hunter, says, “Break it?” he said, “I’d cut down, I’d cut down every law in England if I could do that, if I could capture him!”

“Yes you would, wouldn’t you? And then when you would have cornered the devil and the devil would turn around to meet you, where would you run for protection? All the laws of England having been cut down and flattened? Who would protect you then?”

Wise words.

Leaving the question: Was it against the law? If they had sought and received permission from higher levels of the government, was it legal? What does our law allow?