re: #15 Prononymous, rogue demon hunter

Speaking of critical thinking, you should know perfectly well that this is an argument from ignorance.

If we discount the first person account because of potential bias, then we don’t have any evidence to conclude who pushed the issue. It is no more reasonable to assume that one of the atheists “pissed somebody off deliberately” than it is to assume the nonprofit instigated it.

Rebuild the situation—Why would they show up unscheduled as a group? For that matter, why would they even indicate their belief system to the organizers, then make a public demonstration of counter-giving? It speaks to case-making. Obnoxious evangelical atheists should go to the same part of non-hell as obnoxious evangelical Christians.