re: #740 WindUpBird

haha okay maybe it doesn’t SUCK, I’m being mean, but it sounds a bit one-dimensional compared to the tightly coiled rage that Waters brought to the band. I like Dave Gilmour a LOT, but I consider ML to be a Dave Gilmour record more than a Floyd record. It is a GREAT Dave Gilmour record. Sorrow is still one of my favorite songs of all time :D

I’m all conflicted, basically ^_^

I imagine they need to make some tunes that will sell to the masses. ML was probably that. Still a great tune, but one that would make the charts. (I’m assuming it did.)