re: #872 torrentprime

Result-based jurisprudence? Scalia wouldn’t approve…

You’ve completely skipped the “legal force” part of the opinion, which was of course the entire post I made in the first place, which is what you wanted backup on. Right now, you’ve fallen back from “what’s wrong with the opinion” to “well, you got what you wanted and we can ignore your post about the troubling dicta as long as we ignore the troubling dicta.” Tidy, but not dispositive.

again, i am not following you correctly.

are you referring to the specific point where he says “their argument has some force”?