re: #307 Charles Johnson

Excuse me?

He clearly wrote that it was one of those four women. That’s a direct quote from his post.

You are ignoring the whole context, which is that he identifies her as S.K. in every single other paragraph. He only mentions the four girls to exclude three of them. BuzzFeed confirmed that S.K. is indeed the one.

Chuck published an article in which he presented his “find” as a result of mere analysis/sleuthing, excluding three girls out of the group of four and positively identifying Josie as S.K. (but still leaving it in the realm of speculations).

BuzzFeed said that he correctly identified her.

Chuck saw the Buzzfeed piece and boasted about the confirmation, referring to his GotNews piece (which is also how we know it’s not any other of the four names, since that piece still identifies S.K. as Josie).

Nowhere does the argument about “how would Chuck know the name if he didn’t write the email” come in. There was only one name of the four that Chuck explicitly chose.