re: #422 sattv4u2

You compared her situation, twice, to someone lying

Is there another word for claiming you’re something you’re not?

then say that you can’t formulate conclusions about her case unless you know motive.
No, I can’t formulate much about her character until her motives are known

Terrible Example,, , but one non the less

Guy has a gun to my sons head. Says he’ll shoot unless I tell the guy that my son is really his.

I Lie
My motive was clear
My character stays intact

Just to recap.

You say she’s lying, and then go on to say that you won’t judge her for lying unless you know her motive, and also say that in other situations where someone lied, motive is irrelevant to formulating a judgement.

You, repeatedly, completely ignore the argument I make to just repeat the argument you’re making without dealing with my point.

OK. I give up.