re: #538 Learned Mother of Zion

At this link he says quite clearly

הרב קרים מבהיר: וודאי שאונס אסור בכל מצב

“Rabbi Karim clarifies: Rape is forbidden under all circumstances.”

Yes, but this link was put up yesterday, while that rabbi’s answer was there for many years. So I think the critic should not be blamed for the rabbi’s fault. As you said, the rabbi should have explained why these rules are not applicable, and he did no such thing.