re: #561 brookly red

well I guess then we would first have to waterboard anyone caught to find out if they are in the top 50, no?

Thereby hangs the shit cleaver. If you had a son in the military, and he was captured in, oh, say, Afghanistan, what would constitute torture to you? How would you like him to be treated? What would you accept as “enhanced interrogation” if the insurgents were interested in force structure, chains of command, and planned actions?