Comment

Herman Cain: The Taliban Are Taking Over Libya

99
(I Stand By What I Said Whatever It Was)11/18/2011 3:56:01 pm PST

re: #93 Sergey Romanov

Something like that, but even that is not absolute. Given the objective vagueness of the term, we can have a situation where some people think that a person belongs to the group and some don’t - and they all are correct, just from their perspectives.

Depends on what “correct” means. I am more talking validity than correctness. Under any liberal sense of law, self-identification absolutely does trump all. I believe in today’s EU, you could literally declare yourself to belong to whatever ethnicity you wanted to and then claim whatever benefits etc. applied in certain places.